civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 26, 2023

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 26, 20235h 26m

him to have this as a single family property, considering that there's a property on the block

Similar wording

that hasn't even sold in five months. At this time, I would ask if my client would be allowed

Similar wording

to come on and adopt my testimony. Yes, absolutely. Mr. Watson. Mr. Watson, could you state your name

Similar wording

please and spell for the court stenographer? I don't have to speak. Can you hear me? Yes. Could

Similar wording

you state your name and spell for the court stenographer? Bryant Watson, B-R-Y-A-N-T,

Similar wording

Watson, W-A-T-S-O-N. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but

Similar wording

the truth? Yes. Proceed, counsel. Thank you. Mr. Watson, are you the owner of 1821 North

Similar wording

Metrona Street? Yes. And do you own another property on that block? Yes. And do you agree

Similar wording

with and adopt the presentation and testimony I gave here today? Yes, I do. Do you have any other

Similar wording

comments you would like to make to the board oh i don't thank you questions from the board

Similar wording

no chair

Similar wording

no mr chair thank you questions or comments in the virtual audience mr chair i have whitney

Similar wording

blake with their hand raised i have allowed them to speak hi could you state your name please

Similar wording

and spell for the court stenographer. Good morning. Can you hear me? I can. Okay. Good morning. My

Similar wording

name is Whitney Blake, spelled W-H-I-T-N-E-Y. Last name is B-L-A-K-E. What else do you need? Do you

Similar wording

swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Yes, sir. Are you a

Similar wording

neighbor? Yes, sir. Proceed. I live directly across the street from 1821 North Latrona Street.

Similar wording

I have been present to all previous meetings with the Strawberry Mansion Board, along with Lynn Nichols and Brian Watson.

Similar wording

In the first meeting, they did not provide the correct dimensions of the building they were going to build.

Similar wording

And in the second spirited meeting that she mentioned, there was a lot of callousness regarding our concerns about the congestion in our neighborhood, particularly from Ms. Nichols.

Similar wording

um in the uh document they stated that there will be no impact on the congestion in and around the

Similar wording

neighborhood that is entirely untrue um our neighborhood is already congested as is people

Similar wording

are parking on the sides of the street as we do not have access we do not have the room adding

Similar wording

additional families would cause a lot of congestion and i am just appalled at the callousness as to

Similar wording

how they're going about this. As many people on my block have expressed our concern on the

Similar wording

construction, its impact on the already limited parking that we have, as well as just the overall

Similar wording

negligence of the feelings of the people who have lived here. I have grown up on this block. I am in

Similar wording

my 30s. I grew up on my block. And just noticing just how all of this has transpired, even now,

Similar wording

it seems as though our concerns are not being addressed. We have asked several times about the

Similar wording

parking situation and how that is going to be addressed and the congestion, and we did not

Similar wording

receive an adequate response. So I am hoping that you guys reject their request and that they come

Similar wording

to our block with an adequate revision. Thank you. Chair, can I ask what her address is, please?

Similar wording

1818 North Nachona Street. I'm directly across the street. Chair, do you want me to respond now or

Similar wording

wait why don't we uh why don't we see who else is in the audience okay okay

Similar wording

Why don't we, why don't we see who else is in the audience. Okay. Okay. Other people in the

Similar wording

virtual audience? Yes, Tyrone Williams. I've allowed them to speak. Good morning, Mr. Williams.

Similar wording

Could you state your name, please, and spell for the court sonographer? Oh, good morning, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

My name is Reverend Tyrone Williams, first name T-Y-R-O-N-E, last name Williams, W-I-L-L-I-A-M-S.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do, sir.

Similar wording

And, Reverend, are you a neighbor?

Similar wording

I am the program manager for the Strawberry Mansion Community Development Corporation, which was the RCO day of the meetings.

Similar wording

All right, proceed.

Similar wording

As well as the chair of the meetings. So as it was forestated, the first meeting, they did not have the proper dimensions or wasn't prepared to present. So they did not. On June 22nd, they did present. Yes, that was a very spirited meeting.

Similar wording

Many of the residents at that time expressed their concern of congestion, their concern of just changing the block from a family-filled block, single families, to having a change.

Similar wording

It was a fair factor going on with the residents about what can happen in that block.

Similar wording

It's a lot that has been going on around that block,

Similar wording

surrounding that block.

Similar wording

So they are observing development happening around them.

Similar wording

And they gave a vote resounding overwhelmingly no,

Similar wording

because they say that this is the only way that they think they can speak up.

Similar wording

Other than that, they don't feel as though they have been being heard.

Similar wording

um with that the struggling action cdc has to uh offer non-support we saw really we did get the

Similar wording

letter in i got it to mr lee i hope he got it to you miss nipples uh i know it wasn't timely but we

Similar wording

did give a letter of opposition to this project and like i said the residents uh supports we

Similar wording

support the residents and so that's our position all right thank you reverend for your taking the

Similar wording

time to call. Is there anyone else in the virtual audience? Yes, Calvin Williams. I've allowed them

Similar wording

to speak, sir. Could you state your name, please, and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

Hello? Mr. Williams, please unmute yourself. Yes, can you hear me at all? Yes, we hear you. Could

Similar wording

you state your name please and spell for the courts yes calvin williams c-a-l-v-i-n-w-i-l-l-i-a-m-s

Similar wording

you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do are you a neighbor sir yes i am a neighbor an 1800 block of natrona street

Similar wording

i am along hello okay i along with my neighbors thank you for the opportunity

Similar wording

I, along with my neighbors, are part of three and four generations of single family home ownership on the block.

Similar wording

Our block is no longer than a football field with the church at one end of the block and the other end of the block from Burke Street is an apartment houses.

Similar wording

I think we have maybe 20 houses, maybe on the entire block.

Similar wording

And there's all single families.

Similar wording

The comps that the attorney presented, neither of those houses and none of those houses have variances for multiple family units.

Similar wording

Two of the properties are lots.

Similar wording

Mrs. Blake owns one of the lots, and she has never given any authority or saying that it was three units allowed on there.

Similar wording

We are not in the position right now.

Similar wording

We're small. We're family oriented. We do everything together.

Similar wording

And I've spoken to the board before that we're trying desperately to keep the continuity of our neighborhood with single family homeowners with four and five generations.

Similar wording

And that is my block. I just hope that the board will vote into in our favor.

Similar wording

We reject this project. Thank you so much for listening.

Similar wording

Thank you. Is there anyone else? Thank you, sir. Is there anyone else in the first?

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, can I ask what Mr. Williams' address is?

Similar wording

Mr. Williams, what's your address?

Similar wording

Hold on.

Similar wording

It's okay if you don't.

Similar wording

I think he said he lived on the block. I know. Okay. Okay. All right. Is there anyone else in

Similar wording

I think he said he lived on the block.

Similar wording

I know.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Is there anyone else?

Similar wording

the virtual audience? Yes. Bevan Journey with her hand raised. I have allowed him to speak.

Similar wording

Okay. I could just state your name as spelled, please, for the court stenographer.

Similar wording

Hi. Yes. My name is Bevan Journey, and it's B-E-V-I-N-J-O-U-R-N-E-Y.

Similar wording

You swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

I do. Do you live on the, do you live, are you a neighbor? I do. And I live at 1817 for Miss

Similar wording

Nichols. Okay. Um, so I moved in about, uh, four years ago, um, with, I live here with my nine

Similar wording

month old daughter and I just want to second what Mr. Williams was saying. Um, to me, this block is

Similar wording

very family oriented. It is my intention to raise my daughter here. Um, I really like the tradition

Similar wording

of multi-generation families on this home.

Similar wording

And that's my intention to stay here and do the same thing.

Similar wording

The block is very family oriented

Similar wording

and I would hope that any change in development

Similar wording

would support that.

Similar wording

And then I also just wanted to push back again

Similar wording

against that idea of not increasing traffic.

Similar wording

And I just wanna point out that another neighbor

Similar wording

who I actually think is on this call

Similar wording

started a petition to switch the block

Similar wording

to permit parking years ago

Similar wording

because we were already facing issues with traffic on this block.

Similar wording

So we have a long history before this property was sold

Similar wording

and development was changing of being concerned about parking.

Similar wording

And as far as I know, that change was granted by the city.

Similar wording

They're going to allow us to switch to permit parking

Similar wording

because the city did recognize that there's already problems

Similar wording

with parking availability on the street.

Similar wording

I think we're just waiting for the signage on that.

Similar wording

And then the other thing I just want to say is that I also work at the neighborhood catchment school around the block. And we definitely, you know, the enrollment there is low. I think we would be looking for families to come in. I know I own a single family house.

Similar wording

the people on the other side next to me um it's a young couple they bought a home so i do think

Similar wording

that there is interest from families to buy full homes um i i don't think that there would only be

Similar wording

interest in multi-family homes i think that people are interested in uh uh you know a one family home

Similar wording

so thank you i just i oppose this yeah okay sure thank you for taking the time to calls

Similar wording

Thank you. Jason, how many more hands do we have? Just two. The first is Beverly Wilson Stone. I've allowed them to speak. Okay. Good morning.

Similar wording

Morning. Hi, I think I've already sworn you in. Could you just please state your name for the record?

Similar wording

Beverly Wilson Stone. All right. And are you a neighbor? Yes. 1831.

Similar wording

Okay, proceed.

Similar wording

Yes, I just wanted to reiterate on what my fellow family neighbors were saying.

Similar wording

We have one side parking, that's first of all, that's evident.

Similar wording

You know, there's not much parking space available for us.

Similar wording

Older residents and our regular new residents that's already on the block to own homes.

Similar wording

we already have

Similar wording

two apartment buildings on this block

Similar wording

so

Similar wording

we're fighting

Similar wording

always for parking spaces that are

Similar wording

disabled

Similar wording

the elderly neighbors who still drive

Similar wording

it's going to be

Similar wording

a real inconvenience

Similar wording

like we said at the prior

Similar wording

meeting on June 22nd

Similar wording

we had a little discrepancy there

Similar wording

we had a little

Similar wording

a little rough communication.

Similar wording

I'm going to say it like that. But, you know,

Similar wording

I'm just hoping that, you know, we stay family oriented and the block will stay

Similar wording

where as far as families are in these homes that, you know,

Similar wording

getting the industrialized, we would like

Similar wording

to stay family oriented on this block.

Similar wording

All right. Thank you for taking the time to call us, and we appreciate your testimony.

Similar wording

And I am against the building of it.

Similar wording

I think I understand that. Jason, next hand.

Similar wording

Bryant Wilson. Nothing to speak.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I'm Bryant Watson.

Similar wording

Watson.

Similar wording

Could you state your name, please?

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, I believe this is Ms. Nichols' client.

Similar wording

I know, I know.

Similar wording

Yes, I was going to recall him, Chair.

Similar wording

uh chair if all right what why don't we do that now okay mr watson is there anything you'd like

Similar wording

All right, why don't we do that now?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

to say in response to the comments that you just heard from the members who've uh testified yes

Similar wording

can you hear me yes yes um the last meeting there was never a issue with parking about saying we

Similar wording

wouldn't try to uh fix the parking the issue with parking is not with not not concerned my concern

Similar wording

with me because there's only one side of parking on the street so if i have a fan one family or

Similar wording

two family that's that that's that's not nothing that i can fix if i put one family in there and

Similar wording

it's a five-bedroom house there's going to be two people or three people with cars regardless

Similar wording

the whole time like my family lit that's my family's house just interrupt you 1821 was your

Similar wording

family's house yes it's my family's house so the the parking was always an issue right there

Similar wording

there was always an issue in that neighborhood if there's only parking on one side of the street

Similar wording

so that's not that it's not like i said like i i didn't try to fix that concern is that there's

Similar wording

no way to fix that there's no parking on the street so most people that rent most young people

Similar wording

uh catch ubers anyway so that wouldn't have been an issue with me and and my property so there was

Similar wording

never like so when when they said it was testy and it was getting loud in the last meeting that

Similar wording

wasn't because of us because it was because of the uh someone talking loud it was it was never

Similar wording

me talking loud I was always respectful I was actually getting high on that on the last meeting

Similar wording

I never talked back to anyone I didn't raise my voice to anyone that was all the neighbors

Similar wording

getting tested with me and and and Miss Nichols I never said anything loud that was the neighbors

Similar wording

getting loud so we never had I never had an issue about parking I never said anything about that

Similar wording

is that it's parking it's only parking on one side of the street and that's most of the streets

Similar wording

in the neighborhood, unless you're on a big

Similar wording

street, whereas there's two sides of parking.

Similar wording

But on that street, there's only one side of parking.

Similar wording

And Mr. Watson, how long did your

Similar wording

family own that house?

Similar wording

They owned that house since the 50s.

Similar wording

So when Mr.

Similar wording

William?

Similar wording

Mr. Calvin, yes, when he says he'd been there

Similar wording

and his family, he just moved in that house

Similar wording

in the 90s. Like, my family remember

Similar wording

when he moved there. So for him to say that and say

Similar wording

it's family oriented, my family been there

Similar wording

longer.

Similar wording

My family owned that house in the 50s.

Similar wording

Did you obtain these signatures on the petition of support?

Similar wording

Yes, yes. And they all have addresses. Yes.

Similar wording

Now, there's addresses here on Montgomery Avenue.

Similar wording

Yes, right behind there. Exactly. I'm from that neighborhood. I'm 55. I've been around

Similar wording

the whole 55 years. I'm from there. So when they say I'm not from there and I'm coming

Similar wording

from somewhere else and family oriented that doesn't that doesn't relate to me i'm from there

Similar wording