civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 21, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 21, 20242h 44m

things i just got done testifying that there might be problems with these things i looked at

Similar wording

what what does the community do when those things are not being when there's a problem with those

Similar wording

things and that's where i got to the uh uh the section of the document where it talks about how

Similar wording

do you uh arbitration and things like that so that right well the zero tolerance policy let's

Similar wording

look at that directly um does the zero talents policy refer at all to behavior of the of the

Similar wording

residents of negative behavior towards the neighbors no but it but it talks about trying

Similar wording

to i think what you're you were trying to talk about here is that uh if residents do something

Similar wording

and are you going to do something about it?

Similar wording

You know, that's the...

Similar wording

Well, the zero tolerance policy here

Similar wording

just refers to zero tolerance for drug use

Similar wording

and alcohol use among the residents.

Similar wording

I think he's trying to lead him.

Similar wording

He asked, he answered the question,

Similar wording

even raised in his statement, I quote,

Similar wording

he says that zero tolerance policy is a good thing.

Similar wording

So now I sense that Steve...

Similar wording

We don't, we don't,

Similar wording

we're not seeing the zero tolerance policy

Similar wording

is not a good thing.

Similar wording

So Steve, Steve, listen.

Similar wording

Listen, try not to lead him. Let him testify to his own knowledge and what he's concerned with.

Similar wording

Is there anything in this community benefits agreement that would allow for a speedy resolution of issues that typically might come up between residents of a treatment facility and the surrounding neighbors?

Similar wording

Again, that's speculating, you know, no, I'm asking for provisions in the in the community benefits agreement that deal with speedy resolution of problems.

Similar wording

So I thought that he testified before he was more concerned about, in my mind, how do you execute?

Similar wording

He testified before he was more concerned about, in my mind, how do you execute this? Are there problems on how to execute this community benefits agreement? And I think he's shaking his head. And I would leave it at that. Look, here's the benefits agreement. Here's the issues I think will be hard to execute. And I think that's where he was trying to say.

Similar wording

Okay, I do want to just clarify, if I can, Mr. Chair, that is one of your concerns, Mr. Harrell, around the speediness of the resolution of these problems?

Similar wording

Yes, and also how they would know, for example, the zero tolerance.

Similar wording

How would they know that that zero tolerance policy was not being enforced?

Similar wording

You know, so my assumption would be that there would be an incident.

Similar wording

And if there's an incident, how do you deal with that quickly and effectively?

Similar wording

Is that a better way to...

Similar wording

Well, yeah, because the cure period, if we look here,

Similar wording

if there's an allegation of a breach of the agreement by the developer,

Similar wording

there is a cure period of 60 days to cure it,

Similar wording

and then they can extend it for another 60 days

Similar wording

with written notice to the association saying why they want to extend it.

Similar wording

So we're talking 120 days to address something, which, I mean, Mr. Harrell, in the facilities that you have that are close to families and other houses, is it unusual or somewhat, it just happens some of the time that there are encounters between residents and community members where people get some kind of feelings of upset or concern?

Similar wording

usually uh people uh hear rumors about things so you have to have a rumor control so you have to

Similar wording

have immediate response uh to to those kinds of things and in other times they may think that

Similar wording

something that happened in the neighborhood was done by one of your clients when it was somebody's

Similar wording

son down the street so you have to deal with them right away and if you let them go

Similar wording

from some period of time uh and you get into a legalistic if you don't try to resolve those

Similar wording

problems uh you end up uh with with the dissatisfied people in the neighborhood which

Similar wording

is an impact on the program you have to have a good relationship with that community regardless

Similar wording

you know regardless and what we usually do is we bring people in that have had where we have

Similar wording

locations and have them speak to the community and resolve and talk about how do we resolve

Similar wording

how to how have these issues been resolved with us and then that becomes the degree that we agree

Similar wording

to do that i give community members my the leader of that organization my my business my personal

Similar wording

they didn't have to go through 12 levels of people to get to me i mean if they had to but

Similar wording

But the process is not legalistic.

Similar wording

Mr. Masters, I don't want to brush your case here, but how much longer do you think you need for this witness?

Similar wording

I think that was the end of my direct examination.

Similar wording

So we are doing good timing.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Darwin Cross.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Mr. Carl.

Similar wording

How many community benefits agreements that you personally executed?

Similar wording

i don't know i don't have i don't have a number you know is it more than five i'm objecting that

Similar wording

there's no relevance here um oh he spoke about and you insisted that he

Similar wording

steve i think he can ask that question and i think i think mr hall has answered by saying

Similar wording

he didn't know yeah so usually uh in in in that regard there is it gets built right into the

Similar wording

zoning to be honest with you there the agreements were made at zoning hearings where we said this

Similar wording

is what we'll do and that's and so you go back to the zoning board and say these guys have violated

Similar wording

the zone i mean that's a better way to uh okay and and i appreciate that so you've seen zoning

Similar wording

granted with some sort of proviso that says that the community has a quicker turnaround time

Similar wording

well beyond dealing with issues well not just that but also i think there's uh some uh you know

Similar wording

sex offenders will they be allowed in the program what will what will you do with drug use some of

Similar wording

the things but but but let's just stick because i think opposing counsel was talking about the

Similar wording

provisions for enforcement so you and i heard you say that zoning that the zoning board would take

Similar wording

care of it. So I'm asking you, have you seen that zoning approvals will say, oh,

Similar wording

that zoning approvals will say oh enforcement has to be done this way yes okay i i'm objecting

Similar wording

enforcement has to be done?

Similar wording

because we're talking about many different zoning hearing boards under the the and and that's fine

Similar wording

he's trying to answer my question okay

Similar wording

mike yeah can you restate the question so i can yeah i heard you say that when i asked

Similar wording

how you said that zoning boards will take

Similar wording

care of those provisions that you spoke about

Similar wording

with our CBA. No, usually, usually these things

Similar wording

are discussed. And then I asked

Similar wording

is it that the zoning board will put this information

Similar wording

and make it part of their zoning approval? Have you seen that?

Similar wording

No. Sometimes yes, sometimes not.

Similar wording

Okay. So even though that's the zoning approvals, it's purely a land use issue. You're saying that they'll put in stuff about enforcement for CBA.

Similar wording

right so that's right and so i think your your council was ready to object because

Similar wording

a it it most likely applied to outside the city of philadelphia

Similar wording

um no i don't know about that i mean it was in the city i'd have to go yeah the city of

Similar wording

philadelphia is not always operated the zoning board you have today you know keep so uh okay

Similar wording

oh i don't know i'd have to go research that day okay all right well let me just tell you that

Similar wording

something like that that's made part of a zoning approval would not be enforceable so let me ask

Similar wording

you this you've been i'm objecting to you to you on putting legal statements on the record i i i'm

Similar wording

still on cross. From 1988 to 2020, you were president, president, executive director of

Similar wording

Condensia, correct? Yes. All right. How many facilities did you open in, 3.1 facilities did

Similar wording

you open in Delaware? None. None. How many facilities did you open in Delaware? Four.

Similar wording

four how many of them are open now two how many did you closed under your presidency

Similar wording

one two programs in the same building one building okay what that building no if the

Similar wording

plans to close it were there when i left but it didn't close till afterwards the new okay

Similar wording

closed so i did not close them okay i've not actually i've only closed uh

Similar wording

two or three programs in my whole history so okay so the programs that that the programs that did

Similar wording

close and eventually closed um and they weren't 3.1 what was their what happened to the real estate

Similar wording

i'm object and what what's the possible relevance to to this to to this application this is a land

Similar wording

use issue so i'm just curious as to why his programming it it's all linked together if you

Similar wording

can link our programming to our use of group living for a facility that has been group living

Similar wording

since 1950 i think i can have the right to ask him what happened to the property for a program

Similar wording

that he closed in dollar he's not he's not on trial here he's not an applicant so so so steve

Similar wording

listen i think he can answer that question if he knows i mean maybe they were rented properties i

Similar wording

don't know if he knows it's still there property is still there it's still was it rented it's it

Similar wording

was it's still owned by condense okay um why not unless they sold it last week you know so i don't

Similar wording

to my history and by the way that doesn't mean it won't reopen as something else

Similar wording

so you're absolutely right but you're not there right so when when did you open your first 3.1

Similar wording

facility when i'm asking when i i don't i'd have to go do a little research so

Similar wording

uh a long time ago so a long time ago okay um now just in terms of where

Similar wording

or Pennsylvania or Maryland or

Similar wording

where. All right, let's

Similar wording

just stick with Philadelphia.

Similar wording

We've opened, probably, I've opened

Similar wording

during my tenure, 90 programs.

Similar wording

3.1

Similar wording

programs. Of that,

Similar wording

Of that, four of those programs are in Philadelphia. There are 3.1 that I opened. Four of the programs in Philadelphia and probably 12 to 15 around the state.

Similar wording

four of those programs are in

Similar wording

Philadelphia, they're 3.1.

Similar wording

Okay. So you've only opened four 3.1 programs in the city of Philadelphia.

Similar wording

Yeah. And 10 to 12 3.5s, which is the same license.

Similar wording

Okay, but I'm just sticking with 3.1. Now, with the 3.1s, were they open simultaneously? Were they all operating concurrently?

Similar wording

They opened at different times.

Similar wording

at different times okay and

Similar wording

and since they opened at different times

Similar wording

talk to me about the location where where were they

Similar wording

i'm objecting to this i don't know he has actual experience and knowledge

Similar wording

as the executive director he already stated he opened four

Similar wording

So here's the issue. I think he can answer if he remembers where the three or four were. I don't see anything wrong with that.

Similar wording

So we've opened one in Kensington. We opened one in Broaden, Washington and South Philadelphia. We opened one in Germantown and Wayne Avenue. And we've opened the fourth one at DRC, which is in North Philadelphia.

Similar wording

Okay, so the one in South Philly, how many, did Cadenzia own the property?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

No, was that a lease?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

So did you have to get?

Similar wording

It's a federal government property.

Similar wording

It was a federal government property.

Similar wording

Did you, did, what were the uses as of right, or did you have to go before the zoning board?

Similar wording

No, we went through Anna Verna, who used to be the city council president.

Similar wording

We went through them.

Similar wording

There was not a zoning application that was there by right.

Similar wording

But we had to still make sure the community knew.

Similar wording

We had to make sure that the state city council member, council president, city, what do you call it, the state representative, we went to everybody.

Similar wording

The community was not, actually, it was a cinder block company that made cinder blocks next door to us.

Similar wording

it had been a motor pool for the united states uh government and it still is it's still owned

Similar wording

by the federal government okay so so he has to take care of the building too they've so great

Similar wording

so there was really you didn't have to do a community benefits agreement there no okay um

Similar wording

so well we had to we had to

Similar wording

do whatever Anna Werner wanted us to do you know what I mean so yeah and that we made commitments

Similar wording

to to her about what we would do and what we wouldn't do that we would be the whole the whole

Similar wording

the same thing we would have had same discussion with her as we would with his own board so but

Similar wording

So it was never, it was the, you never had to execute a document.

Similar wording

Exactly.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

The, the.

Similar wording

Facility.

Similar wording

Well, let me just ask you this.

Similar wording

What has been your relationship with ATM?

Similar wording

ATM.

Similar wording

And American treatment network.

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

so the only thing you know about them is what you

Similar wording

testify to that you just did a basic google search

Similar wording

no not a basic google search i went to their website i went to their licensing

Similar wording

i went to uh uh look them up and all you know i did a research on the background and also by what

Similar wording

they said they were you know so get now just getting back to the facility in south philly

Similar wording

real quick um did you the one that he opened or the one that he opened the one that he right

Similar wording

you know it's been open for a very long time so you know and that's great right because that's

Similar wording

why i want to focus on it because i think you have a lot of history with it you you you stated

Similar wording

that you worked with Anna Verna

Similar wording

and to make sure that the community was fine.

Similar wording

Was your staffing already put in place?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

What do you mean staffing?

Similar wording

The staff for the facility

Similar wording

was from other facilities

Similar wording

that had expertise

Similar wording

that could move there before we opened.

Similar wording

that could move there before we open it that's that's not what i'm asking i'm asking okay

Similar wording

That's not what I'm asking.

Similar wording

I'm asking that.

Similar wording

i'm asking that when you were in discussions with anna verna and it still wasn't you know

Similar wording

i presume the lease wasn't signed yet did you have staffing in place

Similar wording

we had a staffing plan of who we had a staffing plan yes great done similar work i mean and that's

Similar wording

And that's fine. But you had a plan, right? You didn't have people hired or anything like that.

Similar wording

I'm objecting that that's asked and answered.

Similar wording

Yeah. And I was trying to get him to complete his answer. So when it comes to the, oh, yeah, that's what I wanted to ask. How many residents were at that South Philly location?

Similar wording

25 25 now the what was the capacity um there was a first floor and a second floor we turned we

Similar wording

didn't we would use the uh first floor in the winter time for the city would uh asked us to

Similar wording

bring in home homeless women on the first floor of the building so we had separate entrances

Similar wording

but um that was it the capacity was was larger it might have been for 35 40 people okay and at

Similar wording

the winter time they you know during code blue you as a courtesy you would go to capacity okay

Similar wording

and and was anyone worried about the nature of the type of residence during code blue

Similar wording

was anna verna ever concerned about the the residents uh with the coat if no if she was

Similar wording

uh we would get a phone call and it would get i would get her did you put her on notice

Similar wording