civus
Hearing audio

ZBA Hearing - March 4, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Mar 4, 20268h 6m

per amended refusal dated 2-25-26.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Diane Wayne, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

So we're going to go to our first case, which is number 15.

Similar wording

MI-2025-005-540-311 South 60th Street.

Similar wording

John Carr and Lakeisha Brandy-Carr are the listed tenants and applicants.

Similar wording

I'm great.

Similar wording

John Carr will be promoted to penalize.

Similar wording

He is here.

Similar wording

Good morning, sir.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

John Carr, J-O-H-N-C-A-R-R.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I swear.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

This application is for use as a personal services, body art service in an existing attack structure.

Similar wording

no sign on this permit whereas the proposed use personal services body art services requires a

Similar wording

special exception approval in the cmx2 zoning district there's a letter of non-opposition

Similar wording

from the third ward executive committee and there's also a request for a proviso from

Similar wording

for hours of operation our vice chair has a few questions for you sir yes good morning have you

Similar wording

submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing yes okay and do you

Similar wording

waive the reading of the referral and stipulate to its accuracy uh yes okay all right thank you

Similar wording

you can proceed with your case okay um yes um as far as my case i'm opening i want to open a tattoo

Similar wording

parlor i've been a tattoo artist in the city of philadelphia for the last 16 years professionally

Similar wording

I apprenticed

Similar wording

and got my license the correct

Similar wording

way through the city from the RIP

Similar wording

and

Similar wording

now I'm going to be

Similar wording

a father of five. I have five girls

Similar wording

and I'm just trying to start

Similar wording

and provide something for my own

Similar wording

You're trying to

Similar wording

make us warmed up

Similar wording

right away, right?

Similar wording

I have two girls so I don't

Similar wording

know about five.

Similar wording

God bless you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

well that's the case and i mean i've been doing it the right way the whole time and i feel like

Similar wording

it's time for ours to have a little something and i'm just trying to could you turn your or

Similar wording

he's going to turn on for you your case okay your exhibits right yes i believe i am appearance i'm

Similar wording

here it's coming up

Similar wording

okay now we have all of your paperwork yes so what what I would recommend you start with photos

Similar wording

okay now we have all of your paperwork

Similar wording

and maybe drawings you have of your property okay okay um these are the external photos of the

Similar wording

building I don't know this is the external photo of the building on the corner just the front view

Similar wording

as the notice

Similar wording

displayed here.

Similar wording

Same closer front view.

Similar wording

This is

Similar wording

the corner view

Similar wording

of the property.

Similar wording

this is how long have you been in the building i've had the building since uh september okay

Similar wording

and this is the inside of the property open layout

Similar wording

first floor only yes okay that that's the walk in the door

Similar wording

you're all the way to the back this is the back room storage

Similar wording

the restroom

Similar wording

and that's it that's the whole building or my whole space of it

Similar wording

okay um do you work there alone currently yeah okay all right all right so it's just one part

Similar wording

that building there is that what i'm saying yes right and that address is 311 right and 309 is

Similar wording

next door correct okay all right questions from the board yes what's your plan for any bio materials

Similar wording

that you're going to have on site um there is a bio hazardous pickup that comes around and picks

Similar wording

up the biohazardous material that gets stored once a year okay and then you're storing it inside is

Similar wording

going to be in the back room or there's a uh what they're considered bio containers you just drop a

Similar wording

needle you drop your needle drops just like in the hospital the red containers the needle bins

Similar wording

that's the only bottle has everything we use is um single use only it's no extra materials

Similar wording

there's no liquid waste anything like that it's just the needle drop and then they come and pick

Similar wording

those up regularly okay and then do you right now it looks like an open space are you going to have

Similar wording

any uh separation yes there is uh separation dividers um pretty much folding dividers clean

Similar wording

wipeable uh surfaces that you can be opened up placed out to give good separation and can be

Similar wording

cleaned properly okay other questions and you said you're working alone for now planning to have

Similar wording

other people there yes i do have plan on having other artists but right now the first step is to

Similar wording

get open before i can hire anybody okay and then uh in the windows there what is what is that that

Similar wording

you have uh well i just put uh some better drapery up because next door when i purchased the place

Similar wording

it had that like like like next door had that brown on the windows and it just didn't look

Similar wording

too tasteful so i just wanted to decorate it up a little bit wow okay so you may want to check into

Similar wording

to whether that's considered a sign.

Similar wording

Signs have a broad definition.

Similar wording

So putting something on the windows

Similar wording

like that may trigger

Similar wording

a need to get some kind of sign approval.

Similar wording

Yes, I did ask my local neighborhood about it,

Similar wording

neighborhood board about it,

Similar wording

and they said that was acceptable.

Similar wording

Yeah, but it's not your local,

Similar wording

the local area folk it is whether LNI considers it yes a sign and you may need some kind of

Similar wording

additional approvals for that if you were just going to like some kind of just like blinds or

Similar wording

something or some kind of other kind of covering for the window it wouldn't be an issue but you

Similar wording

I would suggest that you check about whether what you have there is something that is accepted

Similar wording

and or whether you're going to need additional approvals to have that.

Similar wording

Yes, I will do that.

Similar wording

I have a quick question.

Similar wording

So I just want to, can you confirm, because I have different times that they are asking for the provisos.

Similar wording

So are you okay with the hours of operation from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And six days a week?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Questions from our attorney?

Similar wording

um just to clarify on that the six days a week would that be monday through saturday correct

Similar wording

Just to clarify on that, the six days a week, would that be Monday through Saturday?

Similar wording

okay okay so just as so we that and you said you're you're just leasing the first floor

Similar wording

correct correct all right thank you questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

i see no hands at this time chair planning position um yes i'm reading the excuse me i'll

Similar wording

be reading the recommendation of the planning commission into the record the comprehensive

Similar wording

plan recommends a change in zoning at this location from cmx2 to cmx1 commercial mixed use

Similar wording

the appellant has shown that the proposed body art services will have no detrimental impact beyond

Similar wording

what might be expected the city planning commission recommends that the board grant the proposed

Similar wording

special exception. MI 2025-005-540-311 South, 66th Street, I vote yes with proviso. First floor

Similar wording

only, hours 11A to 9P, Monday to Saturday. Michael Johns, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes with proviso. Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes with proviso. Taya Wayne, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

thank you and and and by the way thank you for coming in and we hope you do really well because

Similar wording

it cost you a lot of money with five girls i'm just telling you i i i know what two was like okay

Similar wording

thank you all right see you all right numbers 16 mi 2025 005 546 1809 73rd avenue sheree reed is

Similar wording

is the uh appellant applicant

Similar wording

Sheree Reed will be joining us as a panelist.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

We already swore you in.

Similar wording

Am I right?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

all right so just for the record state your name my name is sheree reed all right and and and before

Similar wording

we start uh our attorney has uh just a question or so about your your assignment what is this right

Similar wording

so so i just just wanted to clarify miss reed so you had did you prepare the flyer that you

Similar wording

provided to us about the excuse me the rco meeting and the zba hearing is that something that you

Similar wording

prepared yourself actually it was not that was something that the rco actually sent over to me

Similar wording

i had it printed and mailed it out to uh my neighbors okay all right and thank you for that

Similar wording

and um i just wanted to let you know as well um so we just received them this morning we did receive

Similar wording

letters of opposition from the 10th ward rco as well as council member phillips office

Similar wording

If you do not have copies of those, I can send them to you.

Similar wording

I do not have copies.

Similar wording

Okay, I will send them to you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay, so before we start, this application is for use as group living in an existing

Similar wording

attack structure, whereas the proposed use, group living, requires a special exception

Similar wording

approval in the RSA 5 zoning district.

Similar wording

Our vice chair has just a few questions, okay?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

good morning have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing

Similar wording

uh yes i had well yes i have submitted all requested documents however um i received

Similar wording

a notification that i needed to continue sending different documents so i um i eventually sent all

Similar wording

of them i'm not sure if it was within five days but i started sending them a couple weeks ago

Similar wording

okay thank you for that and then uh the chair read your referral um just so do you stipulate

Similar wording

to the accuracy of the referral and waive is further reading yes okay all right thank you

Similar wording

you can share your screen and proceed with your case

Similar wording

okay first I would like to give an open a statement if that's okay sure okay so

Similar wording

as you all know my name is Cherie Reed and I'm proposing a group home for up to

Similar wording

to six boys I am totally willing to reduce the number if necessary but as of

Similar wording

six boys. I am totally willing

Similar wording

now I'm proposing a group home for six boys I am a schoolteacher in the city of

Similar wording

Philadelphia I have worked in education since 2006 I have also directed the

Similar wording

education program a youth emergency shelter at 17th and Fairmount and I'm

Similar wording

also adopted my mother I was raised in North Philadelphia by my mother and my

Similar wording

father they were my birth mother was 17 when she gave birth to me my mom who

Similar wording

raised me. She took me in. She raised me from the time I was a baby and loved me. And I want to be

Similar wording

able to give that to other children. Working at the shelter, I worked at the shelter for five years

Similar wording

with displaced youth, homeless youth. And although I worked in the education program, I was involved

Similar wording

in other capacities of the shelter. While there, my partner and I, under the leadership of Gwendolyn

Similar wording

Bailey, who was the executive director at the time, we offered book clubs to our students.

Similar wording

We offered tutoring, homework assistance. We took them places such as Broadway to see Lion King on

Similar wording

Broadway, the African-American Museum of History and Arts in Washington, D.C., the Blacks and

Similar wording

Wax Museum in Baltimore, just to name a few things that we did with the youth at the shelter.

Similar wording

So I have a burning passion to take care of young boys.

Similar wording

I'm a mother of a daughter.

Similar wording

She's actually just turned 30 years old, so I don't have any sons, but I do have nephews that I'm very close with.

Similar wording

And in addition to that, working in the school system, Philadelphia school system, I, at times I am grieved by the condition in which some of our students live.

Similar wording

And I want to do my part to help these young men become productive citizens of society.

Similar wording

So it has been a desire of mine for years to open a group home.

Similar wording

and purchased this home in 2021 my goal was to live here for a year or two and

Similar wording

then convert it it did take a little longer than a year or two but I'm here

Similar wording

now okay so why don't one do you do this why don't you show us your what what the

Similar wording

place looks like what drawings would be and you know talk a little bit about why

Similar wording

this would be important for you to have here why this would be compliant to do

Similar wording

it okay okay yes all right so the first uh photo this is the photo of the second floor bathroom um

Similar wording

you might want to make that a little bit bigger if that's possible

Similar wording

i mean we see it but i just think it would be the easier but good book okay so proceed

Similar wording

okay there you go there you go yeah now you got it okay all right so this is the second floor

Similar wording

bathroom it was newly renovated as of five years ago so it's pretty much in

Similar wording

the same condition this is the this is the original picture obviously I've been

Similar wording

living here so I didn't want to show a picture of a lived-in bathroom but this

Similar wording

is the second-floor bathroom this is the basement which also has a full

Similar wording

bathroom the basement would also could also be a living space for two of two of

Similar wording

the older boys this is the exterior exterior of the home

Similar wording

This is the kitchen, I'm sorry, trying to zoom in.

Similar wording

This is the living room area, which would be a common space.

Similar wording

those those seem to be all of the pictures that i had all right so well let me ask you this how

Similar wording

many bedrooms do you have in the property i have three bedrooms three bedrooms two and a half

Similar wording

bathrooms. And you want, where would you be putting the six boys? So each bedroom can house

Similar wording

two young men, but then there's space in the basement. So depending on the ages of the young

Similar wording

men, the ages of the boys, we would determine how we would room them. So for example,

Similar wording

if we have a 16 and a 17-year-old, we would be more than likely to make their living space the

Similar wording