civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 23, 2023

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 23, 20233h 12m

him to take just a couple minutes. Do we see his hand? Do you see him? Yes, he's available.

Similar wording

All right, thank you. Sir, could you state your name, please, and spell it for the court reporter?

Similar wording

Yes, hi. Can you guys see me and hear me?

Similar wording

We see your name, but we don't see you personally, but we hear you.

Similar wording

Maybe if I stop here. Let me see if I stop my share.

Similar wording

I don't think I'm sharing right now, actually.

Similar wording

Am I?

Similar wording

We see you now, sir.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Hi, could you state your name, please, and spell for the court reporter?

Similar wording

Yes, my name is Roland Cassis, 818 North 4th Street, Philadelphia, PA, 19123.

Similar wording

Could you spell your name, please, for the court reporter?

Similar wording

R-O-L-A-N-D, Roland, last name's Cassis, K-A-S-S-I-S.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Russell. Roland, as you know, we had a hearing originally scheduled on this reconsideration in

Similar wording

March, but we requested a continuance. Could you let us know, let the board know why we requested

Similar wording

a continuance and what interactions you had with the community following this rescheduling and

Similar wording

continuance of that proceeding? Yes, absolutely. So I just want to introduce myself to the board

Similar wording

real quick. And I want to thank you for hearing this case for the third time. I'm a real estate

Similar wording

developer. I develop most of the corridors on Frankfurt and Front Street and Fishtown.

Similar wording

uh frankfurt hall la colombe soraya badia pizza talia two robbers there are a lot of apartments

Similar wording

Frankfurt Hall, La Colombe, Soraya, Bedilla, Pizza, Talia.

Similar wording

a lot of homes started developing homes in 2000 uh sold a lot of houses uh most of the houses we

Similar wording

sold the last cycle was not even listed that our buyers come to us to buy them without any listing

Similar wording

knowing what our product is and knowing our reputation so that's who i am as a developer

Similar wording

I decided to do this project on Burke Street with Zeros Construction that I met through the House of Hope, through the Earth's Foundation.

Similar wording

They were building this church and cafe for free.

Similar wording

I met them and I decided to invest money with them and build this project together.

Similar wording

And I was at every hearing, listening to all the communities and listening to all the meetings.

Similar wording

and the last meeting and the last letter that came back you know everybody was going down on

Similar wording

Zato's construction because they said they built this project on Montgomery Avenue that

Similar wording

backs up to Will Street so and that was the whole meeting these guys had a bad

Similar wording

a bad taste in their mouth from that project what I found out from Zato's afterward that actually

Similar wording

they took the project over when it was already on the roof they just finished it because another

Similar wording

contractor so the damage was done from someone else but regardless i asked councilman clark's

Similar wording

office and the neighborhood to allow me to go back to the neighbors and introduce myself

Similar wording

and really go over the letter of the letter that they sent to the board about all their concerns

Similar wording

And one of their concerns in the letter is Winga Safran's article about how these guys do their build out.

Similar wording

So I met last Friday at the community center.

Similar wording

And what I found out was that these poor people have been going through some horrifying times because of not because of the Montgomery at Zaid with this, but because of also his project called Rack Flats.

Similar wording

I believe David said it was the ice house.

Similar wording

Not the ice house.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

I missed it.

Similar wording

It was the rag glass.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

There's another project across the street.

Similar wording

It was by an NFL player that had these machines that were shaking the grounds.

Similar wording

So there's a lot of damages that were done.

Similar wording

And people went through nightmares there.

Similar wording

And I get it because I said to them from day one, you know, I'm the kind of developer that comes to the neighborhood and always get their approval.

Similar wording

I literally got the Fishtown's FNA's approval for every project I did on Frankfurt Avenue

Similar wording

because back then, all these projects were ICMX.

Similar wording

So I work with the neighbors.

Similar wording

I work with the neighborhood.

Similar wording

They know me very well.

Similar wording

So I said, guys, I am the one going to be building this project now.

Similar wording

I am a reputable developer.

Similar wording

You don't have to worry about it.

Similar wording

I gave them my cell phone number.

Similar wording

I understood their concern.

Similar wording

And really also one of their concern is our adjacent neighbor, Michelle, sweetheart.

Similar wording

She's great.

Similar wording

But she didn't want anything built right next to her property line.

Similar wording

That's why we flipped the house for the first time to go from her property line to allow her to have as much sun as possible.

Similar wording

So we flipped it that way.

Similar wording

And nobody wants to go on Will Street because they don't want construction to be on Will Street because that's their access.

Similar wording

If we dig the street up, it's not a street.

Similar wording

If we dig it up, then people can't have access to it.

Similar wording

So we came up with this concept and also the fire department.

Similar wording

Everybody said, where is this a fire?

Similar wording

you know said you know how can people how can we you know how can we fix this we went to the

Similar wording

fire department the fire department told us actually by us making this alleyway there what

Similar wording

it is it allows them access with hoses to go if there's any fire in the back so if we go step by

Similar wording

step I literally eliminated every time that something came up it was a concern and I we fixed

Similar wording

it from uh if we look at the letter it said the construction now i'm doing the construction

Similar wording

that is gone there's nothing to worry about because of my reputation how i build things

Similar wording

two they're asking how much the price of the houses was the house is going to sell between

Similar wording

million two a million four the other developer afraid to tell them because they're worried about

Similar wording

taxes and stuff taxes i told the neighbor i said your taxes already got you know there's houses

Similar wording

selling over a million dollars in the neighborhood so the evaluation of the homes already there

Similar wording

nothing's going to change the other thing they were concerned about is the uh david can you

Similar wording

please remind me there are too concerned the fna had in that letter um yeah let me let me pull that

Similar wording

i'm just going to put the cars there was too many cars yes they were worried about people driving i

Similar wording

said these are people and i sold a lot of homes in this category i'm like these are professionals

Similar wording

with wife and husband and having a kid they're not having a party going in and out of there i

Similar wording

I mean, it's not, you know, they're not 12 cars going in and out.

Similar wording

going in and out. We made it a three-car parking because neighbors were concerned somebody visits

Similar wording

We made it a three-car parking because neighbors were concerned.

Similar wording

where they're going to park. So we made it as a three-car parking. The other concern, and I've

Similar wording

never had any buyers having more than two cars of all the 20-some years that I've been developing

Similar wording

homes and selling homes, you know, in Northern Liberty and Fishtown. And all our buyers are

Similar wording

professionals, doctors, you know, they are architects. They come in the morning and they

Similar wording

go to home at work sometimes they don't they don't have cars they'd rather be in the neighborhoods

Similar wording

some people work from home but to alleviate that we can make it a two-car parking I told them

Similar wording

and one of the other concerns showing hardship we just gave them the we show the uh the appraisal

Similar wording

that we just showed as far as the hardship but beside this concern you know I beside the concern

Similar wording

they had in the letter I mean I alleviated and I told them this all the concern the letters that

Similar wording

you had you know i addressed them we've addressed every single time the neighborhood needed something

Similar wording

we addressed it so if there's ever any hardship in any project that i've seen is this project

Similar wording

i mean we have to dig a 300 street feet alleyway it's not even a street for us to build on this

Similar wording

lot in the back so i thought it was a great solution for us to work with the neighbors

Similar wording

to allow her to have the sun for her pool and, you know, and not to do any damage to her yard

Similar wording

whatsoever. I actually, somebody at the last meeting, they've asked if I can put some trees

Similar wording

along the, her yard. I said, absolutely. And I could, we could do that. And Michelle was worried

Similar wording

that what if I disappear? I said, we can get a contract from a landscaper because that's going

Similar wording

going to cost money to fix it. I said, we can get a contract from a landscaper for 10 years and I

Similar wording

can pay that landscaper for 10 years up front. That way they can take care of trees. They don't

Similar wording

have to worry about the maintenance of the trees. So for me, I've been working with this neighborhood

Similar wording

for a long time. I live in the neighborhoods. I sleep in the neighborhood. People all have my

Similar wording

number. I'm a neighborhood guy and a developer from the neighborhood. So I wanted to, the reason

Similar wording

why I asked for that meeting to take place is to be able to meet with all the neighbors around

Similar wording

there. And we knew that they're not going to change the outcome of the letter or the outcome

Similar wording

of Constantine Clark's letter. But I wanted to meet them face to face and change the narratives

Similar wording

and let them know how we're proceeding. So, you know, these are homes that I've built for the

Similar wording

past 20 years in Northern Liberty and Fishtown, having a courtyard, a driveway like that.

Similar wording

everywhere in the neighborhood you see that it's a common thing you know to have so i am not asking

Similar wording

we are not asking for anything that is unreasonable haven't been done before we have we're building

Similar wording

homes that improve the area we you know we are helping with the fire we are not allowing we're

Similar wording

not going to be using that alleyway in the back to dig it and and bother anybody in their lifestyle

Similar wording

we're not putting basements either that's another thing we're not going to do we said no basement

Similar wording

so that way we're not digging basement to bother anybody and have big machinery reason they're

Similar wording

digging and moving things and moving dirt so that way we are also being you know uh aware of

Similar wording

the construction that happened before of what we're doing here not to let that happen and by

Similar wording

not doing the basement we did the house is bigger it's a big chance that we're taking but i feel

Similar wording

like the last meeting we had with the neighbors it was a great meeting uh you know they i felt

Similar wording

that they trusted me as a person and they understand where i'm coming from and they you

Similar wording

know and i said to them i said you better have someone like me to build next to you then a lot

Similar wording

of you know developers that don't care and that is true that just put their gc out there and just

Similar wording

let let them build and they hide behind them i'm not that guy so that was the reason for the

Similar wording

continuance and you know i'm hoping that today we can get this to put this to bed and allow me to go

Similar wording

build these houses and make these neighbors happy roland the one other thing roland thank you very

Similar wording

much the one other thing i think that was in their letter was about the um the entrance for the the

Similar wording

corner building the building located at the corner that was the only other thing they noticed so the

Similar wording

original design had the building um the building right at burke street and had the entry all the

Similar wording

entrances are on the shared drive. And then so you made this change to bring the entrance so that

Similar wording

there was, you know, more traffic coming in and off directly off of Eastbrook Street. So I just,

Similar wording

that was the only other thing in the letter. But other than that, you addressed everything else.

Similar wording

That is correct. Thank you.

Similar wording

Questions from the board?

Similar wording

David do you have any other witnesses no that's that's it that's in terms of

Similar wording

okay thank you um questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you. Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

There's two hands up. A Mr. Martin and Kernan.

Similar wording

Okay. Whichever one.

Similar wording

Hello.

Similar wording

Hi. Good afternoon. Could you state your name, please, and spell for the court reporter?

Similar wording

Yes. It's Michelle Martin. M-I-C-H-E-L-E. Last name is Martin. M-A-R-T-I-N.

Similar wording

Do you swear to work firm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

And you are the neighbor, right?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

All right, proceed.

Similar wording

Good morning, everybody.

Similar wording

Just a little, I just want to backtrack real quick.

Similar wording

Historically, there were buildings in the rear.

Similar wording

They were slaughterhouses.

Similar wording

All the houses that built up to Burke Street, people got their mail from the people in the front of Burke Street.

Similar wording

That was part of our, it was part of our community.

Similar wording

I own that. I own 1334, 1332. I own the back. I own 15 feet into the peak alley as well as the people on Burke Street. But they were slaughterhouses. They weren't homes that actual people lived in.

Similar wording

And if there was any mail or anything, they couldn't be given to them from Wilts Street because it's not a street, not recognized by Philadelphia as a street.

Similar wording

We have to walk the mail back to them.

Similar wording

That's one thing I wanted to consider.

Similar wording

Second thing I wanted to consider, I thought about it the other day.

Similar wording

If we get 12 inches of snow up the side, that's 48 inches of snow in front of four units.

Similar wording

Where is 48 inches of snow going to go at the end of that?

Similar wording

But I also think this is going to be a deprimental, it's just going to be horrible for my property.

Similar wording

I have a beautiful front yard, hedges, rose bushes that are over 100 years old.

Similar wording

I have a pond with koi.

Similar wording

I have kids that stop and ask if we can take pictures in my yard for prom and other things.

Similar wording

Kids in the neighborhood.

Similar wording

I have a school a half a block away.

Similar wording

Penn Treaty.

Similar wording

I have another school the other side.

Similar wording

St. Laurentius.

Similar wording

These kids come by my property every day.

Similar wording

To have a driveway now slapped in the middle of a residential street again,

Similar wording

now that we have rag flats on two doors away from me,

Similar wording

now you're going to put this directly beside me.

Similar wording

I will have absolutely no privacy.

Similar wording

You have four houses with four rooftop decks.

Similar wording

You have four balconies.

Similar wording

Everybody's looking into my yard.

Similar wording

everybody every every single person will be looking into my property building a six-foot

Similar wording

fence is not going to solve the problem putting trees up like Rowan said I already deal with the

Similar wording

trees from rag flats they don't maintain their my husband is the guy that's out there with the pan

Similar wording

and the bucket sweeping the street every week cleaning up no other neighbors come out but we

Similar wording

do because we we were born and raised there for 56 years that's how we are we are very respectful

Similar wording

to our neighbors i am very respectful to everybody but this project is going to affect my yard affect

Similar wording

my beautiful garden affect my pool affect my pond they act like it's a big great thing to have

Similar wording

children playing in a driveway i was born and raised in fish town i hung i was born and raised

Similar wording

at the Fishtown Recreation Center, at the Swimmo, at the Parks, at Newt's, at Hetzel's, or in my own

Similar wording

backyard. I never at a point in time did my mom and dad allow me to play in a driveway. And I put

Similar wording

that to Rowan's attention too. Like, why do you think it's better to have a driveway than give

Similar wording

somebody a backyard? Do I want somebody building up against my property line and have my property

Similar wording

collapse like they did down the street? Absolutely not. But I certainly don't want four up the side

Similar wording

on a residential row home block that really doesn't conform with the block at all.

Similar wording

And it's just going to cause me a lot of hardship and the neighbors that surround it with the light, the air.

Similar wording