civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 17, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 17, 20256h 43m

see it but

Similar wording

no it's a regular

Similar wording

yeah so it's a regular well I mean there's a regular door

Similar wording

but then there's a bill code door

Similar wording

on top of it so you come up out

Similar wording

like you're coming out of a cellar

Similar wording

and then there's a metal door

Similar wording

that you have to open

Similar wording

that doesn't match

Similar wording

the picture of the front

Similar wording

It doesn't, that's why I'm asking.

Similar wording

Can you walk us through how this property was subdivided?

Similar wording

Was it like this when you purchased it?

Similar wording

When he purchased it at the beginning,

Similar wording

it was just like that, combined it into duplex.

Similar wording

That's why it was the purchasing.

Similar wording

And then it's like, they didn't have the knowledge

Similar wording

that it was a duplex.

Similar wording

So they purchased it as it is.

Similar wording

so when they're trying to get the

Similar wording

arenas insurance

Similar wording

we find out that was not legal

Similar wording

so that's why we went through the process

Similar wording

that part I understand

Similar wording

we're trying to understand how it's laid out

Similar wording

you don't have floor plans and the photos are confusing

Similar wording

so if you could

Similar wording

I'm trying to get you to verbally walk us through it

Similar wording

otherwise we're probably going to have to ask you to come back

Similar wording

so

Similar wording

can you just verbally

Similar wording

explain to us how this is

Similar wording

how the units are separated

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

You see this. We're looking at a photo now. There's three doors.

Similar wording

Do two of those doors go to the same unit?

Similar wording

So in other words, what she's asking, so you come up the steps, the main steps,

Similar wording

the door on the right takes you where to the second floor or to the first floor unit?

Similar wording

You come up the steps and you go to this first door on the right.

Similar wording

where do you go when you get in that's what she's asking is he still on the call I don't know if

Similar wording

he's still on the call I don't see is he still on the call my soul Rodriguez please raise your

Similar wording

virtual hand chair he's been unmuted and allowed to speak okay so did you I don't think he heard

Similar wording

anything that was said, I think I can repeat myself.

Similar wording

The muscle Rodriguez, please unmute yourself.

Similar wording

Yes. Can I have Lucas answer you there?

Similar wording

Because I have that connection.

Similar wording

Lucas Cassidy, he's right there.

Similar wording

Because I really have a bad connection, I keep going in and out.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

So the door on the right, what does that take you in?

Similar wording

towards the first floor and the door on the left is the second floor

Similar wording

the door on the left is the second floor okay hello can you hear me yes yeah okay go ahead

Similar wording

lucas okay who's lucas wait a minute wait a minute who's lucas i'm sorry go ahead no lucas

Similar wording

Lucas is the owner and Lucas is the owner and the muscle works with Lucas

Similar wording

together with this.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Lucas,

Similar wording

but Lucas,

Similar wording

I guess they,

Similar wording

wait a minute.

Similar wording

Germain,

Similar wording

Germain,

Similar wording

listen to me.

Similar wording

You,

Similar wording

you gave us the impression that Mr.

Similar wording

Rodriguez or he's an agent for Lucas.

Similar wording

Is that what you're saying?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

All right. So, Miss Lucas, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

So, Ms. Lucas, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Yes. My name is Lucas Caceres, L-U-C-A-S, Caceres, C-A-C-E-R-E-S.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

All right. We've been going through a lot with this.

Similar wording

Could you explain how the house is laid out and what's going on and tell us about the basement?

Similar wording

Yes. So so in the front, you see you have two doors. The right one goes into the first floor.

Similar wording

When you immediately enter that picture with the fire alarm system is on the first floor.

Similar wording

Right. Then you have the living room and kind of a little dining area with the island.

Similar wording

Then you have the kitchen and then the bedroom is behind that. And there's another door that goes to the back, the rear of the house.

Similar wording

on the left side is there is a door to the stairs to the second unit once you enter the unit you

Similar wording

kind of have the uh the kitchen area kitchen area living room then we have a bathroom on the other

Similar wording

side and then on the other side towards the uh front of the building is a bedroom so they're

Similar wording

both one bedroom um apartments and then the basement is you see the entrance there to go

Similar wording

down into the basement once you go into the basement we have some items stored there and

Similar wording

And then there's another door that goes out to the second storage part with the exit out to the rear of the apartment.

Similar wording

I mean, of the property.

Similar wording

So that's the picture that we saw, the Bilco door.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Questions for Mr.

Similar wording

Okay, so Mr. Caceres, I have a few questions.

Similar wording

You purchased this property in 2015?

Similar wording

Yeah, well, my father did.

Similar wording

I'm his son, but he doesn't speak any English, so I'm here basically speaking for him.

Similar wording

But yes, he purchased it from a sheriff's sale in 2015.

Similar wording

You know, listen, listen, listen, listen to me.

Similar wording

Jermaine, you know we need the owner to testify.

Similar wording

And what we need is the owner, and then we'll have an interpreter.

Similar wording

Nobody can interpret for anybody here.

Similar wording

Jermaine, you understand?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

I'm sorry, I wasn't aware.

Similar wording

no no and what's we we continue this for or we give it a resumptive hearing date

Similar wording

give me give me a date please

Similar wording

i've got three continuance dates

Similar wording

i don't i don't have it i don't it's your man you got to get you you got we'll order an interpreter

Similar wording

but we need somebody to make a presentation

Similar wording

and we wasted a lot of time

Similar wording

but the one person who really wasn't even connected

Similar wording

I don't know what that was all about

Similar wording

and then Lucas came on

Similar wording

Lucas was okay but you've got to be the owner

Similar wording

My apologies about that

Similar wording

That's okay, we'll figure it out

Similar wording

January 13th, what time?

Similar wording

9 30 a.m. a.m. January 13th thank you thank you is there anyone in the audience that their case

Similar wording

has not been called I see no hands share thanks everyone we've done a decent time but doesn't

Similar wording

look pretty out there I'll tell you that and Nathan thank you it'll it'll get better each

Similar wording

time you come

Similar wording