civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - April 24, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Apr 24, 20246h 7m

Right. And the number of parking spaces you agree is seven, right?

Similar wording

We'll stipulate to that because that's what was...

Similar wording

And you also understand that many of the clients that you are hoping to get in your facility may have their own personal vehicles, right?

Similar wording

Objection. Our community benefits agreement already says we're not going to have... Cars won't be required.

Similar wording

and that's beyond the scope of yeah i do remember that testimony may say that darwin but the but

Similar wording

the licensing requirements of the state of pennsylvania don't allow you to take cars away

Similar wording

from from clients who are in halfway houses so then we have that so we have an issue with the

Similar wording

licensing well you have an issue this is not a zoning issue the zoning issue is how many how

Similar wording

how many parking spaces you need to run your facility.

Similar wording

Not whether or not the state is requiring us to have individuals with cars.

Similar wording

No, the state is not requiring you to have individuals with cars.

Similar wording

The state is prohibiting you from removing their cars.

Similar wording

Those were the words you used.

Similar wording

I think there's seven.

Similar wording

We know there's seven spots.

Similar wording

Steve, I understand what you're trying to make.

Similar wording

We got to move on with this.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Over an hour.

Similar wording

We're over an hour into this.

Similar wording

Got it.

Similar wording

But I will rest at this point.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So, Darwin, we're over an hour into this.

Similar wording

Do you want to go back and redirect with him?

Similar wording

Do you want to go back and redirect with him or?

Similar wording

Actually, because our intention is to rest it, rest our case.

Similar wording

I do want to bring on the I want to bring on Matt Sullivan.

Similar wording

How long and how long would how long would you need?

Similar wording

It's it's it's just it's I'm not even going to cross examine it, examine.

Similar wording

I mean, I'm not even going to do direct testimony.

Similar wording

Here's what we'll do.

Similar wording

You'll bring him on, do what you want to do, and then we're going to break for the night.

Similar wording

And we'll start with Steve with a cross of him.

Similar wording

The the the OK, if we can just pause for a second.

Similar wording

Yeah, if if because, again, we're we're concerned about our timing.

Similar wording

and we're looking at I just wanted Matt Sullivan to just speak in support of the of the program

Similar wording

I also wanted to have uh the applicant just to adopt the testimony and I also wanted to

Similar wording

have John Disley to speak on the CBA so and he has the right he's not called as a witness but

Similar wording

but he has a right to speak

Similar wording

because he is the RCO

Similar wording

I'm talking

Similar wording

timeline

Similar wording

what I would prefer you to do

Similar wording

if you want is bring on your next

Similar wording

witness you said it'll be

Similar wording

real short he's going to say whatever he's going to say

Similar wording

and then we're going to break

Similar wording

then can we bring

Similar wording

on John Disley

Similar wording

and then I'll just

Similar wording

speak

Similar wording

I'll just have Matt

Similar wording

and the applicant adopt testimony at the next session.

Similar wording

Okay, so you're going to bring on John Bisley.

Similar wording

How long do you think you need for him?

Similar wording

Just five minutes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I just want to establish the terms of the CBA

Similar wording

and the support that we received.

Similar wording

And then, Steve, we're not going to cross him today.

Similar wording

We'll start that the next time.

Similar wording

I understand. Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Mr. Disley

Similar wording

He was

Similar wording

Mr. Disley

Similar wording

Do we see his hand

Similar wording

He's been allowed to speak Mr. Chair

Similar wording

Okay Mr. Disley

Similar wording

Yes sir

Similar wording

I remember I already swore you once today

Similar wording

Okay, so just state your name for the record, sir.

Similar wording

John Disley, D-I-Z-Z-L-E-Y.

Similar wording

Mr. Bobe, proceed.

Similar wording

Mr. Disley, good to hear from you.

Similar wording

Are you familiar with my client?

Similar wording

I just met him a couple months ago, so I'm not familiar with him.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Oh, your client?

Similar wording

I thought you were talking about the Pools and Calci.

Similar wording

Your client?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And at the time, is it safe to say that the applicant, my client, sat down with the RCO and negotiated a full-blown, fully executed community benefits agreement, correct?

Similar wording

Right now, Mr. Chairman, it would be disrespectful on my part to keep adding on what the CBA has before it, including the RCO support, the CBA, which was the third edition of it, and as of last week, our letter of why we did it.

Similar wording

I just think I would better serve this body, this distinguished party, and everybody on, if I just continue to ask questions, answer questions on a zoning issue, and the reason Dickinson Square West Civic Association supported this project.

Similar wording

Well, let's start with that question.

Similar wording

You're Mr. Bove's witness, sir.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

So let me just ask you that question.

Similar wording

Why did Dickinson Square support this application?

Similar wording

Well, not being extreme experts on the disease of drug addiction, we just felt that it was a transforming opportunity for our community and our city in this fight against drug addiction.

Similar wording

In that regard, we called upon all of our various alliances, including all the bordering RCOs, the registered state representative for this area, the state representative senator, and the office of city council.

Similar wording

And might I add, this is the third redemption of our CBA based on the office of city council

Similar wording

needing to have two more things added to it.

Similar wording

And not to disrespect anybody on this call, but the variance was for six spaces.

Similar wording

And not to disrespect anybody on this call, but the variance was for six spaces.

Similar wording

So I'm not understanding the seven, maybe I'm not counting, but just for the record.

Similar wording

So we used all these alliances in our decision to support this project.

Similar wording

that's what it what would you if anything uh say to the board about about the opposition

Similar wording

mr chairman and the members of the board respectfully i'm not going to get into that

Similar wording

type of character assassination i can just say that every everything that mr masters has done

Similar wording

including these unidentified and weak to be named people, was I don't know them.

Similar wording

And Mr. Masters' last email to me was not in opposition, but in effect, which I have in my possession,

Similar wording

he just wanted control of the CBA.

Similar wording

So what I would say to the board, that's all I would say.

Similar wording

Okay, no other questions.

Similar wording

um we are uh mr masters we're gonna break for the night okay uh we there we will continue um

Similar wording

we will work to see when we get this back in here i do appreciate both of you uh trying to work

Similar wording

together um and um thank you very much yes sir thank you mr disley i got to see i hear you twice

Similar wording

today, sir. Yeah, I'm trying to

Similar wording

do what's right, you know. All right, thank

Similar wording

you, Mr. Disley.

Similar wording

Thank you. Excuse me, Mr. Chair,

Similar wording

just one brief

Similar wording

housekeeping note. I don't

Similar wording

have on our records that we received a letter

Similar wording

from Dickinson Square. We

Similar wording

have a copy of the CBA, but

Similar wording

if there was a letter explaining their position...

Similar wording

You said nobody received a letter of rationale

Similar wording

that I was forced to do next week

Similar wording

by the Spirit? I can send that right now.

Similar wording

That would be fantastic.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Disley.

Similar wording

Mr. Disley, thank you very much.

Similar wording

Thank you. I'm sitting there to you right now.

Similar wording

Is there anybody in the virtual audience from the 330 list who has cases not been called?

Similar wording

I do not see any further hands, Mr. Disley.

Similar wording

Thank you, everyone. Thank you, everyone, for staying a little later.

Similar wording

And we did get a lot accomplished today, and I appreciate what everybody did.

Similar wording

and LeBaron as usual

Similar wording

we see you an awful lot LeBaron

Similar wording

I appreciate it

Similar wording

thank you very much LeBaron

Similar wording

of course

Similar wording

great job Bill

Similar wording

see you later thanks Tom

Similar wording

great job Bill

Similar wording

great job everyone

Similar wording

good evening everyone

Similar wording

good night all

Similar wording

good night everybody

Similar wording

You

Similar wording