civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 29, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 29, 20265h 47m

was the visibility from the deck they're actually more concerned about someone

Similar wording

climbing onto that deck and causing problems so they asked that to be

Similar wording

removed the there were other safety issues on the block unrelated to my

Similar wording

client's property going back a few years so a lot of the discussion went into do

Similar wording

you have lighting on there what and he does and he does have security camera as

Similar wording

well so the committee members and the neighbors are very happy to hear about

Similar wording

that primarily we are asking for dimensional variances here for various items that's uh

Similar wording

pretty much the uh refusal items that you see uh with the deck being one of the things that we're

Similar wording

not looking for however that that basically changes our 100 coverage uh to basically a

Similar wording

smaller overall coverage because once the deck's removed the rear yard is still shorter than what

Similar wording

code permits with the uh with the property being the way it is uh with the access to the rear

Similar wording

alleyway being available and it's it's going to be maintained again as a two-story single family

Similar wording

dwelling we had no other objections from the neighbors and once again the rear does match

Similar wording

the neighbor's depth which has a similar depth rear yard my client should be here to verify the

Similar wording

testimony uh we were told to estimate to be heard around 12 30. uh i did ask him to still log in

Similar wording

in advance so i'm not sure if he's on at this moment that's i missed amir simpson yes amir

Similar wording

simpson yes before your client comes on are you saying the whole deck goes yes the whole deck

Similar wording

would be removed. Okay. Sir? Amir, if you're on, please unmute. Hi, sir. Could you please

Similar wording

state your name as spelled for the sonographer? Amir Simpson, first name A-A-M-I-R, last name

Similar wording

simpson simpson do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes counsel thank you amir um did you hear my testimony before the board and also see the

Similar wording

presentation on your screen yes can you verify what i have represented to the zoning board to

Similar wording

be true and correct and adopted as your own testimony yes can you confirm that the deck

Similar wording

will be removed if uh the board permits this to move forward as proposed yes thank you

Similar wording

questions from the board uh yeah there are a number of uh guess concerns one do you own the

Similar wording

property adjacent to you directly adjacent to you so no so for that property i paid a property tax

Similar wording

the owner abandoned the property when they knocked down the building so i've been practicing

Similar wording

I believe adverse possession. So I've been paying the property taxes and everything for the last,

Similar wording

I want to say about 10 years. And I own four other lots after that. So it's the one that's

Similar wording

after that so it's the one that's directly next to me and i own four directly after that so the

Similar wording

directly next to me and I own four.

Similar wording

one directly next to you you don't know that's the one that you're looking to to get adverse

Similar wording

possession for and i believe that's 20 years right um so i think for residential i believe

Similar wording

it's a little bit less is it less okay yeah um because you know i look at your plan and you've

Similar wording

got these windows on the property line which you can't have um so lni is going to make you take

Similar wording

them out right because you can't have windows on your property line um if you don't own the

Similar wording

property next to you um that would need to be some sort of lot consolidation right so that that's

Similar wording

going to be problematic and you put a lot of work into this i can see um the other thing is the

Similar wording

enclosed porch i don't doesn't that have to go separately as a separate approval it is uh part

Similar wording

of the front setback refusal is what the enclosed porch uh triggered uh on the um on the uh refusal

Similar wording

side okay because the adjacent house doesn't have the porch okay enclosed it does have a

Similar wording

The porch is not enclosed. So that is the front. Right? Yeah.

Similar wording

Um, okay. And then you did the extension on the back.

Similar wording

Correct. All right. Yes.

Similar wording

All right. So, those are my comments.

Similar wording

The questions questions from our attorney.

Similar wording

Yes. I just wanted to clarify. You've indicated that you're removing the deck. I realize that. Did you submit plans to L&I, like revised plans to L&I, that showed the absence of the deck in the rear?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

In fact, I believe our plans here does not show a deck, right? That plan that is before the board today also has the deck already removed on the plan.

Similar wording

Okay, because that would be this area will be covered by the deck. Is that correct?

Similar wording

Yes, it was just a question because you indicated you were then removing the deck. So that's why.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from diverse audience?

Similar wording

Yes, Chair, I have a phone number ending in 3552.

Similar wording

Okay, they will be allowed to speak.

Similar wording

hello hi adrian hi how could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

yes adrian fernandez my life name is spelled f-e-r-n-a-n-d-e-z

Similar wording

truth and nothing but the truth adrian yes please proceed

Similar wording

okay um comfort rco is only um only support of the front enclosed porch if

Similar wording

the owner uh gets certificate of occupancy from lni the uh eight percent is no one around here has

Similar wording

eight percent back there and um the decks also we don't have decks or um the uh yards on that

Similar wording

block of race mark feel like that's a small block um the south facing wall is adjacent to 2911

Similar wording

north fronzo the owner and her mother have passed away and house was torn down after that so it is

Similar wording

part of their state and not owned by 2913 owner that wall has numerous windows that shouldn't be

Similar wording

there it has a door that shouldn't be there and it also has a deck built out my guess is about

Similar wording

um maybe 10 feet or maybe not maybe uh six feet it's built out six feet into um 2911 as a camp

Similar wording

reliever to the structure to the structural wall the south facing wall so all that has to be removed

Similar wording

um i forgot if there's a deck in the back or not but i think it was mentioned there was a deck in

Similar wording

the back that needs to be removed there's um this house was worked on at the opposition of neighbors

Similar wording

for a long time with complete disregard to what was happening to the what it caused in our

Similar wording

neighborhood that part of judson street it is the most dangerous in terms of if you hide you can't

Similar wording

see if visibility is hidden you can't see there was a murder in front of the tree which is about

Similar wording

2909 a murder of a man who was the son of one of the mayor's employees

Similar wording

a murder of a man who was the son of one of the mayor's employees and also on the corner more

Similar wording

recently the owner of that property was robbed because the owner of 2913 has built security

Similar wording

fences um there's no curb cut never has been it's all residential um he's built them on 29 11 2909

Similar wording

2907 2905 and he also it's 100 okay he cannot see through it so it makes a large area where

Similar wording

it's not visible and increases um you know crime dangers to the area um all that needs to be

Similar wording

removed because he does not own those properties continuously he does not own them um neighbors

Similar wording

want all that removed and to be restored to um either a fence you can see through that's lower

Similar wording

um or just you know open with like a wooden fence as a lot of the lots have so um

Similar wording

there's a lot of violations on 2913 i think there's 16 investigations and about 12 violations

Similar wording

the other properties that he built on without permits fencing security gates that you can

Similar wording

drive-through and keeping cars on those lots belong to other persons and um they are 2911

Similar wording

2913 2909 2907 and 2905 all all those structures that he built there need to be removed

Similar wording

we did inform the owner of 2913 that we would never approve a curb cut there because

Similar wording

we are within a thousand feet of a school and um children are always walking down that street

Similar wording

on school time even in summer because the school is open for camp it just makes it dangerous to

Similar wording

think that cars will drive down cambia and then make a right onto judson that's going to be a

Similar wording

problem for children on an ongoing basis because it is elementary school so there's really young

Similar wording

children walking over there and a lot of elder persons so in summary the porch on the front

Similar wording

if um he can get l and i approval for that because we don't know how sound the structure is and to

Similar wording

protects the neighbor that's connected and we're also asking that the if the

Similar wording

variance is granted there's just be for the porch no eight-foot wall and no deck

Similar wording

and also that there be a temporary variance granted for four years to give

Similar wording

the owner and us time for him to correct all the not unpermitted and not

Similar wording

implemented structures that he has built on 2913, 2911, 2909, 2907, 2905, which is really

Similar wording

egregious to do that to a community without going through LNI, which has been a whole

Similar wording

lot easier if he had just went through LNI because it guided him and given instructions

Similar wording

on how to properly build on properties that he was allowed to build on.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

thank you uh adrian um just just to be clear the other properties is basically the enclosure that

Similar wording

you're taking issue with correct because there's a fencing around what you're saying i'm not i'm

Similar wording

not sure give addresses because he's built on five properties 11 13 13 which he owns he's built on

Similar wording

11 and he does not own 09 0705 so can you be specific when you ask me questions so the structure

Similar wording

your the structure you're referencing is basically a fence correct

Similar wording

l and i is calling that a security gate it is a drive-thru security gate that requires a um

Similar wording

you know a license for a um that is a um that is a separate that's a separate product property

Similar wording

that has separate uh ongoing uh matters with l and i uh with regard to this property okay let

Similar wording

let me finish i wasn't finished the those structures were built

Similar wording

who owns 2913 and this is why ellen i was called to the locations okay so he built

Similar wording

all of those structures and we have photographs proving that uh with his construction workers

Similar wording

and everything uh not not to cut you off ms agent uh said i'm here at the property if y'all want me

Similar wording

to like show y'all a video or anything because i don't know which structure you're wrong here's

Similar wording

here's structures are the security center listen to me listen to me everyone listen this is a

Similar wording

concentration on 29-13 and that's what the board's looking at and adrian i appreciate your testimony

Similar wording

but that's where we are right now 29-13 uh zen do you have anything more you want to say about 29-13

Similar wording

yes uh just that we would agree to remove the deck um it would be part of if that's any part

Similar wording

of the requirement that's been agreed to uh and and uh any other requirement the board may have

Similar wording

thank you i have one more question i'm looking at google is that extension i see an extension

Similar wording

on to 2913 is that an extension is that extension still there um when you're

Similar wording

is that an extension is that extension still there um when when you're talking about extension you

Similar wording

mean it looks like it appears to be a wooden second floor extension that's the deck that's

Similar wording

the deck well it's enclosed it's like a second floor edition uh no uh amir the in the rear there's

Similar wording

a the when you're talking about second floor there's an on the google maps is that the deck

Similar wording

that's kind of covering that rear open space as a cover is a second floor deck that extends on

Similar wording

to 29 whatever the property is next to it i guess that's the deck is on you talking about on 29 11

Similar wording

correct correct turns to the side of the building yes all that will be removed part of the deck

Similar wording

all right okay um planning commission

Similar wording

Jonathan Goins Planning Commission comprehensive plan recommends no change to the RSA 5 residential single family zoning at this location.

Similar wording

Work was done without the benefit of zoning permits, and the appellant has not shown that dimensional compliance would have caused a significant financial burden.

Similar wording

The city planning commission recommends the zoning board deny the dimensional variance. Thank you. Um, Council, uh, we want to hold this.

Similar wording

It's a lot to digest, and I don't want the whole board to get a feel on where we stand with this.

Similar wording

So we will vote on this next Wednesday at 9.30 a.m.

Similar wording

Can I speak just to respond to some of what Ms. Adrian?

Similar wording

I think there's enough response.

Similar wording

I think a lot of comments were made about other properties.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

has 2913 in front of him and that's what we're going to concentrate on what what's going to

Similar wording

happen at 2913 what we think is the right thing to do so next week we will go at 9 30 a.m do you

Similar wording

want that the date it's all sure sure it's going to be let me just make sure i'm right yeah august

Similar wording

5th august 5th okay into the right thank you everything's closed everything's closed thank you

Similar wording

Thank you. Mr. Nockamson, will you come up and finish?

Similar wording

So, if I remember correctly, we were in the

Similar wording

point of following up and you were trying to answer questions. So why don't you introduce

Similar wording

your clients first and I'll, Darnell? Darnell. Darnell, could you please state your name and

Similar wording

spell it for the stenographer? Darnell Hamilton. D-O-N-N-E-L-L. Right. All right. Last name?

Similar wording

h-a-m-i-o-t-o-n do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the

Similar wording

truth yes now counsel you remember some of the questions so why don't you kick it off yeah so i

Similar wording

made a few representations to the board that you did not hear i just want to make sure they're true

Similar wording

and accurate um you're going to have three staff members working eight hour shifts separately each

Similar wording

so it'll be 24 7 care yes uh your clientele will be highly functional autistic individuals

Similar wording

yes all right um while you're not administering uh medication uh you will uh

Similar wording

i guess allow them to have medication while in the premises yes and you did state something about

Similar wording

like a reminder system that you do have so can you explain that so so it's a medication reminder

Similar wording

that the residents uh the people will have based off their needs that they need to utilize their

Similar wording

medication that's what the medication reminder is it doesn't necessarily mean that we're

Similar wording

delivering it it's just that they have it on hand all right and then the individuals that will be

Similar wording

living there are through city and state government programs is that correct yes all right and then

Similar wording

your why don't you state your qualifications like certifications as such the board i'm a six-year

Similar wording

licensed practical nurse i have a wide expertise when it comes to people of disorder mental

Similar wording

disorder like schizophrenia autism etc uh in multiple different facilities okay and then

Similar wording

the individuals that would be working here and including yourself have to go through background

Similar wording

checks yes have to sign hipaa agreements yes medical screenings yes provide immunization

Similar wording

documentation yes have cpr certification yes first aid certification yes

Similar wording

have cpr certification yes first aid certification yes emergency response training

Similar wording

yes abuse neglect and reporting training yes training on de-escalation and behavioral training

Similar wording

yes all right um what what would be the age this was a question the board asked what would be the

Similar wording

age range of the individuals who would be living there the age range would on average be around 30

Similar wording

to 50 okay and they would have no physical limitations no and you expect that they would

Similar wording

the clientele that you're seeking you would expect they would be taking public transportation if

Similar wording

anything yes all right and then you would you know the people oh we talked about uh food service you

Similar wording

would have your staff cook food for these individuals yes all right and then you would also do

Similar wording

programming for these individuals as well yes can you tell the board some of the programming

Similar wording

you envision in the property well some of them will be like a programs where you know in field

Similar wording

trips like once a month we'll take them out to certain events like neighborhood or you know

Similar wording

certain events like you know the casino or movie night uh and uh day programs is basically um

Similar wording

Like, it's therapeutic things like, you know, events like stretching or, you know, getting them more independent with their livelihoods, because we are, it is a supportive system that we're trying to do.

Similar wording

We're, they're basically people that are like tenants, but, you know, we're just assisting them and we're just trying to improve their daily livelihood with these daily programs.

Similar wording

Right. And then there's state licensing requirements, such as a PA, PhD, OPD license as required, right?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And the state has regular property inspections as well, right?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

I think that's basically it that I presented last time. I don't know if I missed anything.

Similar wording

You want to talk a little bit too. Three bedrooms, four people? Tell me how you'll handle that.

Similar wording

The three bedrooms for four people maximum. So one will be a shared space. It will be the biggest room. Everything else will be private. It's above watching 20 square feet and that meets the requirements to have two people in there at the same time.

Similar wording

okay all right and then oh one other thing the board didn't mention that there was a lease that

Similar wording

was presented to them of one year but my understanding is that you agreed to a five-year

Similar wording

extension with the property owner who also happens to be your father right yes and then i can have

Similar wording

mr hamilton also verify to the board that they'll adopt your testimony and he'll adopt that portion

Similar wording

of the testimony that there would be a five-year lease starting the date of the hearing so that

Similar wording

board feels comfortable that it's now a one-year lease so for the term of it so and what and would

Similar wording

the uh applicant be uh if we so were inclined to approve a five-year temporary variance

Similar wording

state that again a five commensurate with your lease a five-year temporary

Similar wording

I have a question. So are these residents, are they mandated to participate in your programs

Similar wording

or are they, is it optional for them since you said it's supportive?

Similar wording

100% optional.

Similar wording

Optional, okay. And then the other question is, you said there will be 24-hour staff.

Similar wording

I know the drawing that you gave us wasn't, you know, to scale, but could you show us

Similar wording