civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 20, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 20, 20212h 56m

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you. You may proceed.

Similar wording

Just to piggyback off of what Ms. Garner said, I've never heard any noise from that shop over there.

Similar wording

There's never a problem with the cars on the street, if there are any cars on the street.

Similar wording

um and you can actually see my house in that picture as well um i've never had a problem

Similar wording

with parking no noise at all from the shop i didn't even know they were open until uh a couple

Similar wording

of days ago when i went to go get an oil change um but besides that it's no problems at all uh

Similar wording

from that shop over there i think they're doing a great job okay thank you chair uh we also have a

Similar wording

Pinkett?

Similar wording

Yes, I'm here.

Similar wording

Miss, could you state your name and your address for the record, please?

Similar wording

My name is Mimi Pinkett.

Similar wording

I live at 6001 North 17th Street, and I live in one of the apartments in the building.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You may proceed.

Similar wording

um i've been living in that apartment um for about two and a half years so i was there before

Similar wording

um they took over it's been nothing but a joy to have them in the neighborhood i know that

Similar wording

myself and my daughter have brought our cars there they have been nothing but respectful to

Similar wording

anybody i see them interact with in the community um the cars have not been a problem

Similar wording

um there has not been any noise sometimes i have to check to see if they're open and i too uh my

Similar wording

apartment is visible from the pictures so i'm really really close and it has been nothing but

Similar wording

a problem i think they've been great um really helpful and like everyone else said who lives

Similar wording

nearby um it's just been it's pretty quiet there you can't really even hear anything it's really

Similar wording

really clean. They've been great. Okay. Thank you. Thanks for your comments. No problem. Thank you.

Similar wording

Anyone else? Oh, go ahead. We have two more hands. A Galaxy Tab A.

Similar wording

you can unmute yourself hello good afternoon could you pre-state state your name and your

Similar wording

You can unmute yourself. Hello?

Similar wording

address for the record my name is daryl reddick i live at 1609 west negro which is like right

Similar wording

down the street from the shop okay and do you uh swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth and nothing but the truth yes okay thank you uh proceed um again um feedback off what

Similar wording

everybody else said them guys are amazing they're very clean they're neat uh they're very respectful

Similar wording

of the community anybody that need help they're willing to help um and um it's permanent that walk

Similar wording

a lot you know i do own a vehicle but even walking by there um i see them shoveling i don't have to

Similar wording

worry about walking in the street uh nothing like that it's always clean i'll listen to what y'all

Similar wording

say about professional trash removal um they do a very good job of disposing of parts and everything

Similar wording

like that um i have never witnessed anything and again the noise is it is a repair shop you know

Similar wording

i'm talking about prior to when before them when it was a transmission shop before them when it

Similar wording

was another mechanic shop and uh this is the neatest that i've seen it and i've been living

Similar wording

around here almost uh seven years now you know um and uh again you guys are amazing okay

Similar wording

thank you thanks for your comments you're welcome and i think we had one more hand up

Similar wording

yes logan

Similar wording

hello hello uh could you miss could you please state your name and address for the record

Similar wording

marcia logan m-a-r-c-i-a logan l-o-g-a-n 1506 west grange avenue okay and do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes i do sir great uh thank you uh

Similar wording

proceed. I don't know if this is appropriate or not, but I just wanted to let you know that the

Similar wording

comments have been wonderful, but we have to be mindful that that's not a new neighborhood.

Similar wording

There are people who have been in that neighborhood longer than I've been on the planet,

Similar wording

and these people, the elderly people who are not computer literate, they're not being represented

Similar wording

it by the Zoom meeting. I just want you to know there were people in opposition and it's not fair

Similar wording

to everybody that she's put on here or that have spoken have been young. I can tell by how they're

Similar wording

speaking and by what they're saying. That's a very old neighborhood and to not take

Similar wording

into consideration what they feel based on technology, this digital divide which keeps

Similar wording

their voices should be at least thought of and that's all I wanted to say thank you for your time

Similar wording

I believe I believe the councilwoman uh councilwoman bass held the community meeting

Similar wording

were were any of those neighbors at the meeting it was a zoom meeting okay they were able to uh

Similar wording

call in and we did have people that did call in okay and just to um just uh echo the comments

Similar wording

Ms. Logan, we also did add every proviso except one that the community asked for in order to be

Similar wording

considerate of some of the concerns around trash, hours of operation, entering and exiting the

Similar wording

premises, keeping vehicles on the premise, things of that nature in consideration for the community

Similar wording

concerns expressed at the meeting. So I just, I don't know if you were aware of that, but just

Similar wording

wanted to add that for the record out of 11 provisos um i guess we're you're agreeing to 10

Similar wording

of them yes chairman okay all right is there anyone else in the audience that wishes to uh

Similar wording

speak on this no hands okay uh does the board have any questions no no questions

Similar wording

okay all right uh planning commission hi members of the board uh mason austin representing the

Similar wording

planning commission property is indicated for multi-family residential in the comprehensive

Similar wording

plan and is owned for that use the district plan recommended reinforcing multi-family residential

Similar wording

at this location and directing commercial development to nearby commercial corridors

Similar wording

however given the historic use of the property and existing structure and the non-opposition

Similar wording

of neighbors and the district council office planning has no objection to the granting of

Similar wording

this variance with the request provisos okay uh and i'll go over these provisos these these 10

Similar wording

uh provisos excuse me chair um yes i did i did email a list of the provisos i tried to abbreviate

Similar wording

them but um they aren't much shorter oh did you just email them i did okay hold on one second

Similar wording

we like them short no I think I eliminated maybe five words but it's the best thing to do

Similar wording

okay all right you did shorten them up all right so uh it looks like one two three four five six

Similar wording

seven looks like uh council shortened them up to eight okay I mean but they're all included the

Similar wording

one you agreed to. All right, so I'll read off the eight provisos. Number one, vehicle repairs only.

Similar wording

Number two, all vehicles stored on premises and all work performed are to be done indoors.

Similar wording

Number three, no storage of tires. Number four, waste oil or fluids are to be stored inside

Similar wording

and picked up by licensed disposal service. Number five, hours of operation Monday through

Similar wording

Saturday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., closed on Sundays. Number six, no dogs on the lot after closing.

Similar wording

Number seven, commercial trash pickup. And number eight, no vehicular access from Champlos

Similar wording

except in an emergency. All right. Did we miss any there? I think that covers it all.

Similar wording

Yes, Chairman.

Similar wording

Okay. All right. So we're going to vote. So with those eight provisos, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

my vote is yes with proviso my vote is yes with with provisos and just for the record that was

Similar wording

for uh calendar number mi-2021-001242-6000 lime kiln pipe all right okay

Similar wording

Okay. Let's vote one more time, just so we're clear. That's a yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Tom?

Similar wording

Are you muted?

Similar wording

I'm muted.

Similar wording

Hey, Tom?

Similar wording

okay he was a yes we heard him he was he was a yes i just wanted to

Similar wording

get that address out there again so okay thank you

Similar wording

get that address out there again so okay thank you that case is done okay

Similar wording

Mr. Holliman if you could hear us you might want to leave and come back in

Similar wording

okay here we go we're going to move on to calendar number mi-2020-000658

Similar wording

715 West Lycoming

Similar wording

Street

Similar wording

anyone here for 715

Similar wording

West Lycoming Street

Similar wording

yes we also have

Similar wording

an interpreter for this case

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

we have a

Similar wording

letter of support from the RCO

Similar wording

as well

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

this. Mi nombre es Ester Salazar.

Similar wording

Should we wait a minute or two to get the interpreter?

Similar wording

Yes, they're coming in now as a panelist.

Similar wording

Okay, no problem.

Similar wording

interpreter if you can unmute yourself good afternoon panel and mr chairman my name is

Similar wording

certified spanish interpreter would you be able to spell your name for the stenographer

Similar wording

gladly first name d-a-m-a-r-i-s last name f as in frank i g-u-e-r-o-a

Similar wording

previously stated good afternoon my name is esther salazar interpreter will briefly request a second

Similar wording

to introduce herself to the client if i may okay thank you buenas tardes señora salazar mi nombre

Similar wording

es la marisa estaré sirviendo como interpretar español interpretaré todo lo que diga y lo

Similar wording

Muy buenas tardes. Mi nombre es Esther Salazar. En mi dirección, 178 West Thelma Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 191 40. Y bueno, yo soy la dueña de la casa 715 West Lycoming Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 191 40.

Similar wording

Gracias. Good afternoon. My name is Esther Salazar, 178 West Helma Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania,

Similar wording

19140. I am the owner of the property located at 715 West Lycoma Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania,

Similar wording

919140. And could you ask, I have a few questions here. Could you ask your client,

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Tengo varias preguntas para usted. Juramente ella firma que usted ha de decir la verdad,

Similar wording

solamente la verdad y nada más que la verdad. Sí, toda la verdad. Yes. All the truth.

Similar wording

and we'll be able to us wearing this um interpreter as well yes well we're going to do

Similar wording

that right now thank you uh interpreter um miss figure out uh could you uh you already stated

Similar wording

your name i'm not sure did you state your address for the record gladly sir because i have been

Similar wording

subcontracted subcontracted i will state that i have been rehired by globo language and um the

Similar wording

The requester may gladly request my address if they so choose to provide it because of bridging confidentiality is that I don't state it, but I am a local interpreter in Pennsylvania.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do, sir.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Interpreter has been signed in.

Similar wording

we're going to ask a couple more questions uh of your client uh do you agree to waive

Similar wording

the reading of the refusal and stipulate to attack your seat

Similar wording

Usted está de acuerdo con que nosotros obiemos y saltemos y no leamos todas las estipulaciones listadas con respecto a este caso?

Similar wording

Sí, estoy de acuerdo.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Excuse me, Chair.

Similar wording

This is the court reporter.

Similar wording

Was the owner of Ms. Salazar sworn in?

Similar wording

I, I believe that did I? Well, let me do it again. In case I didn't. Interpreter, I'm not sure. Did I swear in your client?

Similar wording

I believe.

Similar wording

Did I?

Similar wording

I do not recall. So, thanks, John. I appreciate that. Thank you. If you could, could you ask your client if she swears or affirms to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

yes i do swear to say the truth and only the truth okay great great uh another question

Similar wording

for your client also uh have you emailed an exhibit packet with the required documents

Similar wording

proof of ownership, proof of tax compliance, copy of the refusal or referral, and plans

Similar wording

and photos five days prior to this hearing.

Similar wording

usted es propietaria, todo lo que tenga que ver con los impuestos, copia de haber rehusado

Similar wording

y cualquier otro documento pertinente con cinco días de anticipación?

Similar wording

Sí, todo fue enviado, correcto.

Similar wording

A favor, please, ma'am.

Similar wording

Madam Interpreter, please ask a question.

Similar wording

Compartir la presentación del paquete en la computadora, por favor.

Similar wording

Kindly, Madam Interpreter, please request this favor on my part.

Similar wording

Please ask Ms. Marisa Cadillo to share screen on my favor.

Similar wording

Okay, in one minute, I got one more question for you,

Similar wording

and then we're done, and then we can proceed.

Similar wording

Claro, en un minuto, si me permite, tengo una pregunta más para usted, y de ahí proseguimos.

Similar wording

Está muy bien.

Similar wording

Okay, and the last question, have you met with the RCO, and do you have a letter?

Similar wording

Muy bien. La última pregunta, ¿se ha reunido con el equipo de la RCO, y tiene usted una carta?

Similar wording

Sí, sí me he reunido.

Similar wording

Yes, I have. I have met.

Similar wording

This is Sharon. I can confirm that we did receive a letter in support from the RCO.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

Sharon, can I confirm that we received a letter from the RCO team?

Similar wording

Okay, thank you very much. Now you can proceed.

Similar wording

Thank you very much. Now you can proceed.

Similar wording

Lo que me trae aquí es legalizar mi propiedad en la dirección 715 West Lycoming Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 191-40.

Similar wording

Gracias, señora. Un segundo para interpretar.

Similar wording

Interpreter reminds client to kindly pause to allow proper interpretation.

Similar wording

The purpose of my presence here is to be able to legalize the ownership of the property on 715 West Lycomen Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 19140.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay, gracias.

Similar wording

Ya está bien.

Similar wording

En duplex.

Similar wording

Cuando compré.

Similar wording

And Sharon, we do have a letter of support, correct?

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

Sharon, si tenemos una carta de apoyo, correcto?

Similar wording

Okay. Is there anyone else in the audience? Do they have their hand raised, would like to speak on this case?

Similar wording

Yes, no, folks.

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Mr. Folks, you can unmute yourself, wait to be sworn in.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Mr. Snell.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Mr. Fultz. Could you state your name and your address for the record, please?

Similar wording

Yes, sir. Sloan Fuchs, S-L-O-A-N-E-F-S and Fire O-L-K-S. Office of Councilmember Maria

Similar wording

Quinones Sanchez, Room 508, City Hall. And do you swear or affirm to tell the truth,

Similar wording

the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Yes, sir, I do. All righty. Please proceed.

Similar wording

Yes, the applicant, having met with the RCO and having received a letter of support, the council member offers no opposition to this variance request. Thank you.

Similar wording

thank you okay that was no opposition mr chairman interpreter speaking may

Similar wording

That was no opposition.

Similar wording