civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 20, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 20, 20212h 56m

Mr. Chairman, interpreter speaking, may I interpret it?

Similar wording

interpreter proceed interpreting the previous statement or should i uh ignore

Similar wording

you can you can pass along the statement sure that is no opposition mr snow okay thank you

Similar wording

thank you el señor sloan folks representando a la señora maria quiñones sanchez juramente

Similar wording

y afirma que ha de decir la verdad, representa el apoyo recibido de parte de la RCO y declara

Similar wording

que no hay ninguna oposición. Gracias. Thank you, Your Honor.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Fulks. Is there anyone else with their hand raised that would like to

Similar wording

speak on this case? No more hands, Chair. Okay, no more hands. Any questions from the board?

Similar wording

no no all righty planning commission

Similar wording

apologies it took me a minute to get it going uh members of the board uh mason

Similar wording

office representing the planning commission uh the properties uh zone for single family

Similar wording

residential is indicated that use of the comprehensive plan there is no unique

Similar wording

physical condition that would prevent this slot from being used however given the historic use

Similar wording

of the property and the non-opposition of neighbors and the district council office

Similar wording

planning has no objection to the granting of the variance by the time thank you calendar number

Similar wording

mmi-2021-00 oh strike that that was the previous case strike that

Similar wording

Calendar number MI-2020-000-658-715 West Lycoming Street.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Have a great afternoon.

Similar wording

Aprobado la dirección 715 West Lycoming Street

Similar wording

in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

Similar wording

Hemos terminado con su caso.

Similar wording

Que tenga linda tarde.

Similar wording

Gracias.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

A million thanks.

Similar wording

Forever grateful for everything.

Similar wording

No problem.

Similar wording

Have a great afternoon.

Similar wording

okay moving on interpreter speaking would interpreter be excused at this time or is

Similar wording

there any other case that you would require my assistance sir i believe you can be excused thank

Similar wording

you very much for your service thank you very much interpreter disconnecting have a good afternoon

Similar wording

Take care.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

I believe we're down to one last case.

Similar wording

This is calendar number MI-2021-0015773519 Hamilton Street.

Similar wording

This is a case we were talking about earlier with Mr. Orphanides, Mr. Bonnie.

Similar wording

I could let Mr. Orfinetes and Mr. Bonney know.

Similar wording

Maybe they'll have good news, Sharon.

Similar wording

That would be great.

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

This is Paul Bonney.

Similar wording

I think I'm still-

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Paul.

Similar wording

Could you give your state your name and address for the record, please?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Paul Bonney, 325 Chestnut Street, Suite 1109.

Similar wording

And I'm the attorney for Pound Village Civic Association, the appellant in this matter.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yeah, this is an appeal against L&I.

Similar wording

So I don't think there's a risk.

Similar wording

Yeah, okay.

Similar wording

my mistake. Okay. But Mr. Chairman, we're, you know, I think we're minutes away to having a

Similar wording

deal here. We're down to the logistics. I wish you had a 3.30 list that you could put us on.

Similar wording

Well, let me ask you this. If we gave you 10 minutes, is that enough time?

Similar wording

Is Mr. Orfanides here? Because he's the one that's doing the logistics.

Similar wording

uh it's actually trying to um facilitate some sort of online zoom notary notary where i guess

Similar wording

he's actually trying to

Similar wording

everyone shows their driver's license and then the notary somehow electronically notarizes things

Similar wording

um if i might this is leonard reuter for the city uh as it turns out it probably would have

Similar wording

worked if we did go earlier uh notwithstanding that we wanted to give time for them to work

Similar wording

out an agreement because my conflict with the board apparently not really a conflict because

Similar wording

they're only on the third case of their list so and i'm like 24th on that list so uh that being

Similar wording

said if the issue is literally just uh confirming that the parties agree to whatever has been

Similar wording

written couldn't you just put it on the record of this hearing i mean it seems to me we're already

Similar wording

on zoom this is already recorded it's a public record uh you can't make unsworn falsifications

Similar wording

to authorities i mean it's just a suggestion i don't have a you know a pony in this race

Similar wording

uh as far as the settlement goes uh at least i hope i don't because david how many minutes

Similar wording

that we need. I just texted my clients right now. I'm waiting to hear back. But I mean,

Similar wording

the documents are being circulated for electronic execution and notarization right now. But

Similar wording

I can't leave this today with this matter, this case not resolved. So I don't know if there's a

Similar wording

question. Do me a favor, just state your name and your address for the record. Certainly. David

Similar wording

Orphanides, again, Orphanides and Toner, 2 Penn Center, 1500 John F. Kennedy Boulevard Suite,

Similar wording

800 philadelphia pennsylvania 19102 you you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing

Similar wording

but the truth i do okay great so again you know we are you know they're out being circulated

Similar wording

um right now for execution i can't i've just asked how long um can we put it on for tomorrow's um

Similar wording

list and then just you know

Similar wording

Mr. Bonney it could be added as

Similar wording

an add-on to tomorrow's list

Similar wording

if it is simply going to be

Similar wording

that the board will be accepting withdrawal

Similar wording

of the appeal

Similar wording

right that worked for me

Similar wording

what do you think Sharon

Similar wording

I mean I know Tanya's not

Similar wording

here right now you think we'd be able to get them

Similar wording

on early

Similar wording

we can't do another

Similar wording

hearing tomorrow but

Similar wording

if they're saying that we're only waiting, they're going to sign the papers and withdraw,

Similar wording

then you could announce that tomorrow morning. I'll put it on. Okay. Relatively simple procedure.

Similar wording

Okay. Leonard, can you do me a favor? Just state your name and address for the record,

Similar wording

and then you can. Sure. Leonard F. Reuter, R-E-U-T-E-R, Senior Attorney for the City of

Similar wording

philadelphia i'll also note for the record that my colleague james panko p-a-n-c-i-o is also

Similar wording

present um you you can make him a panelist uh but um i do want to say that if the hearing were to

Similar wording

proceed today that would be difficult at this point we have learned that one of the main city

Similar wording

witnesses has a hard stop at 3 30 anyway uh that would be mr ribikoski so i'm not sure we wouldn't

Similar wording

be able to conclude the hearing today anyway um if we went on with the with the with the other

Similar wording

witness or whoever you know mr messrs bonnie and orphanetes were planning on presenting um so just

Similar wording

as a practical matter it sounds like uh literally everything's done but the signatures so i'm not

Similar wording

no problem with just putting this on tomorrow's list

Similar wording

just to announce that there's been an agreement.

Similar wording

Is that a fair representation, guys?

Similar wording

I think it's to announce that the appeal's been withdrawn.

Similar wording

I think that's what's going to happen.

Similar wording

Unfortunately, I can't announce that just yet.

Similar wording

So if you told me, then we'll be good.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Thanks, Aaron.

Similar wording

Are we okay doing that?

Similar wording

Yes, that's fine.

Similar wording

If you could just confirm before the hearings start tomorrow morning

Similar wording

that you have reached an agreement

Similar wording

and um mr bonning you will be present to withdraw is that correct yes i mean or i could

Similar wording

send you a letter send everyone a letter tonight that would be fine too thank you all right thanks

Similar wording

everybody and that'll be announced see that was quick and painless right we'll see hopefully

Similar wording

that'll be announced at the 9 30 list yes at the start of the ninth degree list yeah yeah it's about

Similar wording

as few words as you're ever going to get out of me there you go that's a record and you didn't

Similar wording

have to dig into all my exhibits either so yeah it's a great day for you guys it's really i already

Similar wording

have oh sorry sharon i tried all right so we'll we'll uh take care of this matter tomorrow morning

Similar wording

all right so we'll we'll uh take care of this matter tomorrow morning we'll make they make the

Similar wording

we'll make they make the

Similar wording

announcement um so gentlemen that's it i believe uh yeah you guys are finished david thank you

Similar wording

great thank you thank you bye see you tomorrow and the city witnesses you can go obviously

Similar wording

sorry oh could we mr snell could we just ask if anyone is absolutely i'm just getting ready

Similar wording

to do that. Is there anyone else in the audience that needs to still make a comment on any of the

Similar wording

cases today, or do you have anything you'd like to say? Just raise your hand.

Similar wording

No hands at this time, Chair. Wow, no hands. Okay. Well, I guess that

Similar wording

that is

Similar wording

that's a wrap as we said

Similar wording

so good job

Similar wording

just want to say thanks

Similar wording

everybody did a great job and

Similar wording

you know boy that was a

Similar wording

nice treat with David and Paul

Similar wording

so we're going to stop

Similar wording

it now and go home so listen

Similar wording

thanks for everything guys

Similar wording

good night

Similar wording

everyone did a great job we'll see you tomorrow

Similar wording

good night

Similar wording

good night

Similar wording

See you later.

Similar wording