civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - December 11, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Dec 11, 20247h 26m

Devin Obduck is the attorney.

Similar wording

Letter of unanimous support from the 50th Ward Democratic Executive Committee.

Similar wording

Letter of unanimous support from the 50th Ward Democratic Executive Committee.

Similar wording

Counsel?

Similar wording

Thank you there, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

Your vote has been sworn, Counsel. Could you just state your name for the record, please?

Similar wording

Yes, Devin Uqda, D-E-V-I-N Uqda, U-Q-D-A-H.

Similar wording

Counsel, could you identify your client, the relationship to the property?

Similar wording

Yes, I have one of the owners on the call, Mr. Ronald Bridges.

Similar wording

Okay, our vice chair has a few questions for you.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Good evening, counsel. Do you agree to weigh the reason of the refusal or stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Have you e-mailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed to proceed with this case 5 days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Yes. Well, I uploaded some after getting feedback, what I was missing, but I can re-upload anything that's missing.

Similar wording

I believe we received everything, but please share your screen and proceed.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

can you see my screen it should be coming up any minute i see it's yet i see it now

Similar wording

weird

Similar wording

all right it's not scrolling down i share my screen every share one second i apologize

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

coming up now all right that's better okay uh so the address of this property is 1918

Similar wording

east washington lane philadelphia pa 19138 um it's a table of contents of all the information

Similar wording

i present in my presentation it's been uploaded to the website um so here we have a letter of

Similar wording

referral. The proposed use is eating and drinking establishment. It's going to be a takeout

Similar wording

restaurant. Requires exception approval for zoning board adjustments.

Similar wording

So here we just have some pictures of the surrounding area. So this property is on

Similar wording

Washington Lane between Thoron and Lodkin Pike. The entire block, as you will see,

Similar wording

is pretty much all commercial.

Similar wording

There's like, the property used to be a hair salon.

Similar wording

I think next to it is a salon, ice cream shops

Similar wording

and restaurants and delis

Similar wording

and across the streets like dollar stores

Similar wording

and doctor's offices.

Similar wording

So again, it's Washington Lane

Similar wording

between Thoron and Lampkin Pike.

Similar wording

As you can see, the property is currently CMX2.

Similar wording

All of the properties on the block

Similar wording

actually are also CMX2 as well.

Similar wording

So, this is the property right here.

Similar wording

This is 1918 East Washington Lane.

Similar wording

To the right of it, as I mentioned, is the ice cream shop.

Similar wording

I'm sorry. Yes, to the right of it is ice cream shop.

Similar wording

To the left of it is a breakfast restaurant.

Similar wording

Again, all of the other properties on the block are CMX2.

Similar wording

Most of them have some type of residential living on the second floor.

Similar wording

This is the back of the property.

Similar wording

This is a picture of the posting on a property.

Similar wording

Here are some internal pictures of the property.

Similar wording

So probably even cleaned out.

Similar wording

It's going to be a full rehab.

Similar wording

So this is just a picture of it cleaned out.

Similar wording

Pretty much got it.

Similar wording

The picture of the inside of the property.

Similar wording

Now the picture is lost.

Similar wording

This is the first floor.

Similar wording

So the picture of me,

Similar wording

the picture of me showing the posting would be on

Similar wording

the other side of these windows.

Similar wording

this is the first floor and then these steps over here to the left will go down to the basement

Similar wording

the steps here would also go up to the second floor

Similar wording

so standing in front of property across the street there is a

Similar wording

large parking lot a dollar store dialysis a daycare and a doctor's office

Similar wording

a daycare and a doctor's office

Similar wording

um so now just getting into the drawings um so the property now

Similar wording

is still maintaining the same height um it's two two levels it's by level um

Similar wording

there'll be a takeout restaurant on the first floor

Similar wording

um the second floor it would have will be residential um

Similar wording

so it's the first the first floor to see some expansion on the windows

Similar wording

uh two doors one to go upstairs one to go into like the restaurant area into the basement

Similar wording

is multiple pictures outside

Similar wording

so here we have what we're looking at the inside so this this would be the basement

Similar wording

um the basement would have storage toilet room hvac hookup um some prep area and then the first

Similar wording

floor this would be the door you walk into the first door down here this part is like a takeout

Similar wording

restaurant section so you would order pay for stuff here uh proposed kitchen freezer food prep

Similar wording

all on the first floor this would be the second floor so the second floor would be

Similar wording

uh a kitchen a living area it's uh set up it will be set up to have two bedrooms and uh two bathrooms

Similar wording

Again, more and more reference to the drawings.

Similar wording

This is the first floor,

Similar wording

like the first floor of the restaurant area.

Similar wording

So this would be the counters.

Similar wording

If you were coming in from the front,

Similar wording

this is the counter and then this back here would be the back part of

Similar wording

the restaurant where you propose food prep and storage.

Similar wording

Some notice to the RCO.

Similar wording

Proof of mailing.

Similar wording

We also did mailing and we also just knocked on all the neighbors on

Similar wording

the block that then just also notified them and dropped off the mailing list as well.

Similar wording

It's a deed to the property.

Similar wording

This is clear to show that there's no real estate taxes owed on a property.

Similar wording

Then this is the letter of support from the RCO.

Similar wording

10 people in attendance we all had all the vote in support of it

Similar wording

and that concludes my presentation um i have the one of the owners on a call

Similar wording

possible could i have him uh could i recognize him uh ronald bridges

Similar wording

bridges has been allowed to speak

Similar wording

good evening sir could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

ronald bridges r-o-n-a-l-d b-r-i-d-g-e-s you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

nothing but the truth i affirm please proceed counsel uh mr bridges were you able to hear my

Similar wording

presentation yes sir um do you verify that it was true and accurate yes sir and um do you adopt my

Similar wording

statements yes sir um questions from the board yes i have one quick question i'm sorry um that the

Similar wording

is there a bathroom for the restaurant was that that the bathroom that was in the basement no so

Similar wording

that bathroom would be for staff right but is it one on the first floor as well yes one on the basement

Similar wording

On the first floor as well.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

There are no bathrooms shown on your plane.

Similar wording

On the first floor.

Similar wording

By mistake, there's not a bathroom because it's only takeout.

Similar wording

So they would just come in and not go past the counter.

Similar wording

So it's just a basement bathroom for the staff.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

That's what I thought I saw.

Similar wording

okay so uh what kind of food are we going to be serving here and is it the type that might

Similar wording

require some sort of venting so they are going to be installed in that hvac um system and the

Similar wording

property is which is here here on the left um i'm not sure if they've established the the menu for

Similar wording

the restaurant, I think that that may be open to the tenant who occupies the property.

Similar wording

Okay. But if it's, okay, depending on what kind of food you may be, if this is like

Similar wording

food that's going to require any kind of venting, have you, is there anything about that on these

Similar wording

plans um no so we don't have any vents here on this

Similar wording

um no so we don't have any vents here on this um if the if they do decide to do that i guess we

Similar wording

would have to pull the permits to do something like that well the the the your plan shows a

Similar wording

number of fixtures that will require venting yes or a fryer a grill a griller yeah and another

Similar wording

piece of equipment we require

Similar wording

planting and so

Similar wording

Can you hear me? This is

Similar wording

Ronald Bridges speaking

Similar wording

Go ahead Mr. Bridges. There is a hood

Similar wording

system in the plans

Similar wording

Okay yeah because you're required

Similar wording

to have an ANSOL system and a hood system

Similar wording

Yes sir we will have an ANSOL system

Similar wording

it's in the plans

Similar wording

I think what

Similar wording

Member

Similar wording

Assurel was

Similar wording

kind of alluding to is if you're

Similar wording

you've got you've got to have these have you have these fixtures that need to be vented

Similar wording

what's the plan to vent and my request is that it be vented through the roof and not out the side

Similar wording

that's what i would prefer as well um but i'm not seeing that on these plants and that's where

Similar wording

my concern is. Thank you.

Similar wording

Mr. Purchase,

Similar wording

can you answer that?

Similar wording

Yes, the hood is venting over all

Similar wording

of the cooking equipment.

Similar wording

The hood will be venting through the roof on the left-hand

Similar wording

side.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Where is this on this

Similar wording

plane here?

Similar wording

It's hard for me to

Similar wording

see.

Similar wording

But it will be

Similar wording

it's a little small i'm trying to

Similar wording

can you go to the elevation page sheet

Similar wording

okay so you shut the venting out the roof yep all right okay thank you

Similar wording

okay any other questions questions or comments from our attorney hillary oh i'm sorry i'm sorry

Similar wording

although you do show a secondary event it looks up here to be at the first at the first floor level

Similar wording

correct

Similar wording

so I think

Similar wording

maybe

Similar wording

that's an issue

Similar wording

particularly since you've got

Similar wording

a window if you look at this

Similar wording

elevation you've got a window that's

Similar wording

right here

Similar wording

right behind where that

Similar wording

vent is coming through the roof

Similar wording

so

Similar wording

the desire

Similar wording

would have that vent

Similar wording

above the second floor

Similar wording

roof

Similar wording

in my opinion

Similar wording

because you're going to have exhaust fumes

Similar wording

and if somebody opens the window there

Similar wording

it's going to blow right in their window.

Similar wording

Better if it's through the roof.

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Or above the roof, right?

Similar wording

Yeah, or above the roof, yes.

Similar wording

Somebody's putting in the exhaust fan

Similar wording

from another side of the building.

Similar wording

That's the intake fan

Similar wording

on a lower level.

Similar wording

okay so that's an intake i can't read on the elevation it's it's it's two fans the other

Similar wording

fan will be it's a different one fan is on a roof on a left hand side and you got you can't see that

Similar wording

i can't expand this i got it i mean if it was zoomed in i think we'd be able to read i think

Similar wording

we're all familiar with the system we just can't read the notes at the scale right

Similar wording

sorry i'm trying to just zoom in a little bit oh i see it says new intake fan okay so that's an

Similar wording

intake fan and then the exhaust uh fan roof is above the roof okay good all right okay okay all

Similar wording

right thank you yeah questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson um just a quick note

Similar wording

uh mr i don't believe the interior photos that you showed were sent to the board at least i

Similar wording

I couldn't find a record of them, so please upload those by the end of the day tomorrow

Similar wording

so that they can be included in the record for this case.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

No problem.

Similar wording

I think my only question is about egress from the basement.

Similar wording

Is there egress well in the basement or door access?

Similar wording

Yes, there's a door access in front of the building.

Similar wording

To the basement?

Similar wording