civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 15, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 15, 20267h 10m

family attached to the council supported action under the district plan recommended rm1 zoning

Similar wording

the proposal would be permitted by right therefore the city planning commission recommends the board

Similar wording

grant the requested variance for multifamily household living use with a count of three

Similar wording

residential units. MI 2026 001 254 1109 North 42nd Street. I vote yes with proviso. Trash

Similar wording

stored inside. Also revised plans one page stamped by ZBA 71526. Michael Johns. My vote

Similar wording

is yes with proviso. Cheryl Gaston. My vote is yes with proviso. Tanetta Graham. My vote

Similar wording

is yes with provisos ryan mcadams my vote is yes with proviso i win my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

layla bb my vote is yes with proviso thank you thank you have a great night um

Similar wording

mi 2026 001 549 3900 west gerard avenue

Similar wording

So, so before I swear you in, uh, I don't know if you were here when I talked about

Similar wording

the timelines. Okay. So. We're scheduled right now that our last case is going to be at 7

Similar wording

30 to start. Okay. So what we're doing is we're giving everybody a half hour. Yeah.

Similar wording

Right? Now, you know, there's trees you have put here a lot of information. We don't want you to shortchange your client.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

If we get to the point we get much past a half hour, what I'm going to have to do is give you a resumptive here.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

We're going to get it done in half an hour.

Similar wording

Absolutely.

Similar wording

A lot of people have said that.

Similar wording

If I don't get it done in half an hour, I'm not going to make it out of here.

Similar wording

Right. Please state your name and spell for this amount for a council.

Similar wording

Yes. Good afternoon, members of the board. Brett Feldman, 1835 Market Street, D-R-E-T-T-F-E-L-D-M-A-N, with my co-counsel, Andrea Salomon.

Similar wording

Right. Why don't you state your name, too?

Similar wording

Andrea Salomon, A-N-D-R-E-A-S-A-L-O-M-O-N.

Similar wording

Do you both swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

We do.

Similar wording

And could you identify your client, their relationship to this property?

Similar wording

Sure. We represent PTTI.

Similar wording

sure uh we represent um ptti um the philadelphia technician training institute ptti and its ceo

Similar wording

and founder mr sherman mcleod okay my left all right we'll swear him in later okay vice chair

Similar wording

has a few questions for you good afternoon have you submitted your documents and exhibits five

Similar wording

days in advance of this hearing we have okay and you have several use refusals as well as owner

Similar wording

refusal so do you wait to read another refusal specifically to the accuracy yes yeah you only

Similar wording

got 30 minutes so say yes all right yes thank you show your screen and proceed with the case okay

Similar wording

great i can i can start yeah give us a general absolutely uh may i please the board again my name

Similar wording

is Brett Feldman, 1835 Market Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Along with my colleague, co-counsel

Similar wording

Andrea Salman, we are really proud today to be representing the Philadelphia Technician

Similar wording

Training Institute, PTTI, that is the zoning applicant. They're also the owner, equitable,

Similar wording

owner of nine properties that are at issue today that are on the 3900 block of Girard

Similar wording

Avenue in Cambridge Street. PTTI seeks use and dimensional variance relief to permit

Similar wording

the relocation of these nine lots to one lot for the construction and operation of a new

Similar wording

four-story post high school vocational technical training school that will also include

Similar wording

include on-site commissary and cafeteria for students perhaps the community as well as

Similar wording

accessory signs in an accessory surface parking lot PTTI has worked tirelessly to acquire these

Similar wording

nine properties six of them are owned by PTTI the other three we have went through closely with the

Similar wording

land bank and we've acquired three of those properties through that we we have almost acquired

Similar wording

now the three properties from the land bank we um were approved by the land bank board city council

Similar wording

and uh waiting on a closing subject to uh zoning relief um and again this is for the construction

Similar wording

of this of this school um you know for the record based on the unique characteristics of the property

Similar wording

and the substantial public benefits associated with the proposed development the requested

Similar wording

relief satisfies standards for both use and dimensional variances under the Philadelphia

Similar wording

zoning code. Turning to the exhibits, we've passed up exhibits 1 through 17, which I'd

Similar wording

asked be incorporated into the record. We're going to go through a lot of those, but just

Similar wording

briefly, we have a lot of information about PTTI, what services, what skills it provides,

Similar wording

what courses of education. We have property photos. We have really strong letters of support

Similar wording

from District Councilperson, Jimmy Gauthier, both at the land bank. So we had to go through

Similar wording

the whole land bank approval process. And now for this zoning approval process, we have a letter from Centennial Parkside, which was, I think, the RCO in the last case, a unanimous letter of support, very strong support language. And then we have letters of support from the state rep, the state senator, because we're in the process of obtaining state money for the construction of this many million dollar project.

Similar wording

and then the other standard other documents, refusals, zoning map, and I'll just get right to

Similar wording

those. With me today, Sherman McLeod, the founder and CEO of PTTI, and Robert Lynn, who is back there,

Similar wording

who is our project architect, and he was before the board, I think, about two and a half months

Similar wording

ago, but we'll have him come up shortly. With that being said, I would ask that Sherman be sworn in

Similar wording

so that he can briefly introduce himself, talk a little bit about PTTI, and why the need for this

Similar wording

second campus building. They already have a campus in 1900 West Gerard at the former Berean Institute

Similar wording

and this is this is the hopefully their new West Philadelphia second campus. Please state your

Similar wording

name and spell for this. Yes sir my name is Sherman McLeod and my first name is S-H-E-R-M-A-N

Similar wording

last name is M-C-L-E-O-D. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the

Similar wording

truth? Yes sir. Thank you please proceed. Absolutely Sherman I already introduced you as

Similar wording

founder and CEO of PTTI but I just wanted you to we'll talk about that but can you just first

Similar wording

discuss like your background where you're from where you got your education your work in the

Similar wording

private sector just so um the board can get a sense of you know who you are and how you came

Similar wording

to this moment sure I'm from North Philadelphia 24th and Lehigh and uh I'm sorry sir this is the

Similar wording

we have it pull the mic to you thank you right there yeah I'm Sherman McLeod from uh 24th and

Similar wording

Lehigh, born and raised there and grew up. My father was, he worked for the city too, by the

Similar wording

way. He was a sanitation worker. And long story short, got myself in a lot of trouble. My grandmother

Similar wording

got me out and I wind up graduating from Drexel University in 1982. So I've been around a little

Similar wording

bit. And from there, I went on to a fortune 10 companies, being able to develop systems and

Similar wording

processes and ultra high-speed equipment to be able to reduce operations down to the point where

Similar wording

to be able to reduce operations down to the point where it was like 70, 80% reduction in workforce.

Similar wording

But I know that the technicians were always the ones that were left to be able to service the process.

Similar wording

So I saw a great opportunity here in the city of Philadelphia to be able to do that.

Similar wording

And since that time, we've graduated over thousands of people that are really getting into jobs that are $35, $45 an hour in six months.

Similar wording

So that was my job to reverse engineer everything.

Similar wording

They didn't want to leave those companies.

Similar wording

I'll come back to it.

Similar wording

So as I mentioned, you opened PTTI at the former Berean Institute in 1901 West Girard?

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

And can you tell the board what PTTI is and what career training?

Similar wording

If you look on the slide here, we've got – this is your current campus in 1901 West Girard.

Similar wording

Can you just briefly describe that?

Similar wording

We just expanded the Berean Institute by 15,000 square feet.

Similar wording

That was the first thing that's ever happened on that campus since it was built.

Similar wording

and we're just the the clients that we serve as a new city there we're just bursting at the seams

Similar wording

so we anticipated that that would happen we're pretty much the only one standing in the city

Similar wording

of philadelphia from a non-profit private organization public private organization

Similar wording

it was a non-profit that is doing this in the city and so it's it's really important to be

Similar wording

able to expand the facility. And we look at being in the neighborhood because people don't have

Similar wording

transportation to go outside the city. And it's a friendly place where they can learn and grow and

Similar wording

then get into really large companies. And Sherman, again, these are the courses of study

Similar wording

post-high school that you offer. The largest welding facility on the entire East Coast right

Similar wording

here at 1901. And we have other piping systems, advanced manufacturing, which is heavy in my

Similar wording

background. And we have a program called Central Processing, where we teach people how to sterilize

Similar wording

products for the hospitals and clinics and other type of programs. HVAC is coming on stream in the

Similar wording

next few months, an electrician program as well. Great. And you have most of your students in

Similar wording

from philadelphia yes all of them 100 okay and how many students in a year approximately approximately

Similar wording

now 1500 students a year so we right now have over a thousand students in the school right now

Similar wording

great and um let me just go to the next slide just just wanted to show some of the the different

Similar wording

career opportunities coming out of ptti you can just like go through that quickly

Similar wording

Basically, this is inside of the 1901 West Girard campus?

Similar wording

Yes, it is.

Similar wording

Correct, these pictures?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Well, you see the welders on the top left.

Similar wording

Great.

Similar wording

And we developed some of our own advanced technologies to teach them in VR, as well as hands-on training.

Similar wording

So when they go out, we have over 60 people out there in the shipyard right now, making over $35 an hour.

Similar wording

So speaking of the shipyard, I just wanted to, many of us have heard, you know, all the exciting opportunities down at the shipyard and the Bellwether District, so some of those, we really hope, expanding employment opportunities.

Similar wording

Are PTI students there? Are they working? Are they being recruited? Are they part of those efforts that we hear about, including CNBC today?

Similar wording

Yes, they are. I mean, we have students deployed all over. That young lady right there, she works in construction, and she's doing great work out there.

Similar wording

We have people in the center, the bottom, working for SEPTA, all kind of the railways, everywhere.

Similar wording

We're kind of omnipotent at this point.

Similar wording

Great.

Similar wording

And while we're here today, and this is, I know you get emotional kind of when you see this picture, but this is the second, this is the 39th in Girard.

Similar wording

This is what we're here for today.

Similar wording

That's right.

Similar wording

Just briefly, why are we here as far as really the need for additional space?

Similar wording

Because we already run out of space.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

And we want to make sure we keep everybody safe and to be the demand is so strong for people in the inner city is our client that they're coming to us hand over fist.

Similar wording

And now we have students to we don't even have to advertise for students, students who are graduating and bringing other students to us, alumni.

Similar wording

Great. Great. Sure. I don't have any other questions. I don't know if the board does, but I just wanted to give a base for.

Similar wording

We can if we have to. Great. Great. You finish your presentation. Great. Thanks.

Similar wording

So turning to exhibits, too. So here is getting to the project itself. Here's the assemblage. This is at West Girard. This is 39th, Cambridge and Union Street. Nine properties. The ones in pink salmon are the land bank properties. The other six are the properties that PTTI has already acquired. Again, putting these together, nine properties into one.

Similar wording

Here's our site. It's the kind of upside down L with the blue cursor right there on Girard Avenue. Tremendous mass transit, SEPTA right there.

Similar wording

On Gerrard Avenue, tremendous mass transit, SEPTA right there.

Similar wording

We're really part of this kind of educational district.

Similar wording

If you look across the street, there's the School of the Future.

Similar wording

We've got the zoo to the right, all the parking here.

Similar wording

So their first campus is on Gerrard, so it's very close to go back and forth between the two campuses.

Similar wording

So in so many ways, this was really an ideal location for us.

Similar wording

Just moving on to, again, here's a little more context.

Similar wording

The School of the Future across the street, our site, zoo, other parking facilities,

Similar wording

76 um next slide and then here's that kind of at a ground level um these lots are currently vacant

Similar wording

i think almost all these lots have been vacant since 2007 um if you go back on google street view

Similar wording

um so it's it's it's been a long time coming uh and even in the city plan which i think

Similar wording

alan referred to before for project near here this is one of the um sites this this this area right

Similar wording

here for redevelopment because of the long-standing vacancy and non-use next next slide

Similar wording

and sherman's real proud of this uh when pgti took over uh acquired many of these properties

Similar wording

they went out there with their students and with the 12 tons of refuse taken off off these

Similar wording

yeah it was used this was it had been a dumping ground this had been construction equipment

Similar wording

people were left there and it's just immaculate right now we actually had our community meeting

Similar wording

on the site in a tent to kind of celebrate what's happened there. Next slide.

Similar wording

I'll go through these. These are our letters of support. This is from the district.

Similar wording

We have every letter of support. Don't do that. We have every letter of support.

Similar wording

I'll get right through it here. Land Bank, at the Land Bank, the council person,

Similar wording

Sentinel Parkside, unanimous. We have an MOU. And if you look at the language, it's just about

Similar wording

as this is dynamical continuing on state senators, state rep, other interested parties, exhibit

Similar wording

four. This is our refusal. We have refusals for, we have a split zone situation here.

Similar wording

That's really part of the challenge here. We have two different zoning districts. We

Similar wording

have an RSA five and a commercial. So the way city planning review this is we get the

Similar wording

most restrictive of the residential, we get the most restrictive of the commercial, which

Similar wording

limits on what you can what you can do here we have a height refusal which as you'll as you'll

Similar wording

hear um because of the school because of the high floor to ceiling height 16 feet because this type

Similar wording

of school is not a traditional classroom this is basically a training factory um that you know to

Similar wording

to have these skills to have you know learn how to you know yeah wait you know two of our members

Similar wording

training centers, right? One, the carpenters union and the steam fitters. So I think we understand

Similar wording

the little bit of what you're talking about. Let's move on. We've got it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Similar wording

Next. We've got and refusals for signage here. We have letters of approval from the Art

Similar wording

Commission in Tamron Park. This is the district CMX1, RSA5. This is the split zoning, which

Similar wording

really kind of creates part of the hardship here. Exhibit tab six. So with that, let me

Similar wording

Let me now introduce our project architect, trying to make sure I'm on time here.

Similar wording

I'd like to now ask that our architect, Robert Lynn, be sworn in.

Similar wording

Sure. Let's get him, Mike, in front of him.

Similar wording

Hi, sir. Speaking of Mike, please, could you please state your name as spelled for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Robert Lynn, L-I-N-N.

Similar wording

Right. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth? Counsel?

Similar wording

Yes. Bob, thanks for being here. What is your current employment?

Similar wording

I'm the principal of Lynn Architects. I think I bored you with my credentials last time. I'll do it quickly.

Similar wording

You didn't borrow us, but you went through them.

Similar wording

I went through them.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

44-year-old company I founded.

Similar wording

We're architects, civil engineers, code officials, and construction managers in Delaware County Media.

Similar wording

I'm registered in Pennsylvania and about 22 other states.

Similar wording

And I appreciate your service.

Similar wording

I'm 31 years on the Planning Commission in another province township in Delaware County.

Similar wording

I know what it's like to serve.

Similar wording

It's not appreciated often, but it's necessary.

Similar wording

It's very important.

Similar wording

And I'm also the zoning officer in three municipalities in Delaware County.

Similar wording

That's great.

Similar wording

and I've done four comprehensive projects.

Similar wording

Yeah, you have your CV at Exhibit 15,

Similar wording

you've worked in the city,

Similar wording

you were previously,

Similar wording

you've appeared in front of the Philadelphia Zoning Board

Similar wording

a couple of months ago, correct?

Similar wording

And multiple occasions before that, yes.

Similar wording

And at that time you were qualified as an expert

Similar wording

and I'd like to ask that Mr. Lin also be qualified

Similar wording

as an expert in architecture, zoning, land development.

Similar wording