civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 15, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 15, 20267h 10m

We are really excited to move forward in changing this nailery with your help to an event space, a venue for the community.

Similar wording

So the photograph there that says nails, that's the front of the property as it exists today?

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

So tell us a little bit about what it was and this.

Similar wording

It was a knellerie for many years.

Similar wording

The owners were ready to retire and didn't want to pass the business on.

Similar wording

The children were uninterested in taking on the family business, so they wanted to sell.

Similar wording

And it was the perfect location for what I was trying to do.

Similar wording

Okay, so tell us a little bit about your familiarity with this neighborhood.

Similar wording

So I grew up in this neighborhood, actually a few blocks, 54th and Whitland, which is a couple blocks over from Chester Avenue.

Similar wording

We grew up in this community, and the community, honestly, in my personal opinion, is in need of an event space.

Similar wording

It's in need of a facility that can host a bunch of gatherings of different sorts, from school gatherings.

Similar wording

a bunch of gatherings of different sorts from school gatherings, partnering with the local

Similar wording

schools for coat drives, back to school, book bag giveaways, things of that nature. We also would

Similar wording

like to do more things even with our older senior citizens, have like bingo nights and just a lot

Similar wording

of things not just for parties but community events um weddings funeral repass uh community

Similar wording

gatherings um possibly even rco gatherings anything you know like police uh retirement

Similar wording

parties whatever the neighborhood needs i feel as though this um venue adventure would be

Similar wording

a special place to gather all right let's go to the next slide april please

Similar wording

so what is this is the first floor as it exists now um yes this is actually the back of the

Similar wording

property looking from like the yard to the front uh what you see right there is more so like a

Similar wording

kitchen area and then the pink i'm not sure if you guys can see it it's like pink walls

Similar wording

that's like a hallway um and it's on the right it's a door that leads to the basement and then

Similar wording

through the next door would be the actual like nailery. All right and the next picture is still

Similar wording

on the first floor? Yes this is the this is the hallway. This is how it exists now? Yes this is

Similar wording

how it is now. And I see a picture of the lavatory or the toilet area? Yes that's once you walk

Similar wording

through to your left. All right let's go to the next picture. That again is what the existing

Similar wording

nailery looks like this is what the nailery looks like today um and that's a view looking out to the

Similar wording

street and back back the street yes okay and now let's go to the next slide quickly please um so

Similar wording

this is the back of the property um the previous owners had put up some i guess kind of like

Similar wording

makeshift uh securities so that no one could kind of like get in they have the bob wire it's a gate

Similar wording

behind that silver padding, if you will. But we plan to secure the property a little bit better

Similar wording

than that. All right. Let's go to the second floor. April, thank you. All right. So this is

Similar wording

the second floor as it exists now today. This is the second floor as it exists. This is one of the

Similar wording

rooms on the second floor. And I think we can all agree to this in need of some remodeling,

Similar wording

tender loving care all right this is also on the first floor second second floor i apologize um

Similar wording

yeah this is the second floor and beyond that those three when the two windows and the door

Similar wording

is actually um outside patio okay yeah and then the next floor is also on the second floor front

Similar wording

is that the front yes that's the front and that where the green is that would be the very rear

Similar wording

rear row. Okay. Then there's a third floor to this building? It's a third floor that's

Similar wording

equally needing some attention. Okay. The third floor is not as big as the first and second floor.

Similar wording

It's like cut off. Okay. Yeah. And then the basement? The basement is the full length of the

Similar wording

extension of the building. All right. And those are the two pictures of the basement. And then

Similar wording

you have a picture of the roof um yes um after i purchased the property i immediately had a roof

Similar wording

put on and um just so no further damage water damage would be getting done to the property

Similar wording

what did you pay for this property uh it was 112 000 after all the extra things it was 118 okay

Similar wording

so these are the last pictures of the roof now yes the next slide we have is your vision okay

Similar wording

Okay. Tell us what it is that you intend to do with this property.

Similar wording

So I really don't want to make a bunch of structural, like a bunch of changes. We would like to remove the walls downstairs just to make it an open space because, well, as many of us know, when you go to a venue is, you know, like open space.

Similar wording

There will be like a kitchen area in the back where the previous kitchen is just updated.

Similar wording

We will have a handicap, a better handicap accessible bathroom and another bathroom.

Similar wording

So two bathrooms on the first floor. We would also like to have two bathrooms, possibly on the second floor.

Similar wording

All right. So is so this next slide is the second floor?

Similar wording

Yeah. Okay.

Similar wording

Okay. And then the next slide after that, is this the third floor?

Similar wording

The third floor, yes. We are just basically going to just update it and kind of keep it

Similar wording

in like the apartment state.

Similar wording

All right. So you're just going to basically open it up so that you can accommodate.

Similar wording

all right so you're just going to basically open it up so that you can accommodate a larger crowd

Similar wording

yes for for for small for bigger gathering yes all right then the next slides are what what are

Similar wording

those what are these slides those are basically the same slides from different angles um i'm not

Similar wording

sure if they want to press the the play and see how we visualize it i don't think that'll work

Similar wording

Try to get closer to the mic when you're speaking.

Similar wording

Okay, so we have a press and play that will not operate how it, explain what you had.

Similar wording

Well, we had a press and play presentation that would have given you a better look at

Similar wording

the design moving forward, what we really wanted it to kind of look like.

Similar wording

But we're unable to do that right now.

Similar wording

So that's what we envision with your approval that this venue is going to look like.

Similar wording

Do you have a contractor for this work?

Similar wording

What is his name?

Similar wording

Jefferson Guzman is the contractor.

Similar wording

We've worked with him in the past.

Similar wording

He's licensed and insured in Philadelphia, PA.

Similar wording

And he does, you know, like amazing work.

Similar wording

So prior to today, did you meet with the RCO group?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Tell us about that.

Similar wording

I was present for that a couple of weeks ago.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

So on June the 24th, we had our RCO meeting, and they actually were very interested and very, what can I say?

Similar wording

They were on board.

Similar wording

They saw the vision.

Similar wording

They agreed with the vision, and they both, Mr. Roth and Mr. Kevin both agreed that the neighborhood would be, would benefit from opening up a community venue.

Similar wording

And those documents have been submitted to the board?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And we submitted deeds, and we submitted other photographs, yes?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Was there a fire alarm issue early on when you purchased this property?

Similar wording

Yeah, so the previous owners, they did not have the proper fire alarm registration.

Similar wording

They had a system installed, but it wasn't registered correctly.

Similar wording

So I definitely, one of the first things that I did was I got the contractors in there and the inspectors to come and do the box, register the box with license and inspection.

Similar wording

So and we've submitted all those documents. Yes. You've also submitted the deed to the property. Yes. With that and also your real estate tax certification. Yes. Yes.

Similar wording

Board members. Did I see drawings there? Could you go back to them? Can you go back to the drawings, April?

Similar wording

You might want to. Yeah. So you're going to use all three floors for this and the basement.

Similar wording

So the basement is just going to stay a basement. Right. I would like to change the first and the second floor.

Similar wording

The third floor is going to stay as it is like an apartment.

Similar wording

As an apartment. That's going to be an apartment.

Similar wording

the third floor is it's yeah it's uh like two rooms up there and i guess it was a bathroom

Similar wording

not not nobody's going to rent it yeah no no nobody's going to rent it it's just hold on

Similar wording

hold on a minute hold on a minute but council that's not on what you've asked for you've asked

Similar wording

for uh uh an event assembly facility to do that in an existing structure so you want a special

Similar wording

exception you didn't mention anything about an apartment no nothing it's not an important it's

Similar wording

three floors um marina misspoke it was it was previously it was a house and that's where

Similar wording

she misspoke it's not going to be an apartment nobody's going to live there

Similar wording

okay just so we're clear everything is going to be uh

Similar wording

yeah first second and third floor are you going to have things on all three floors or just no

Similar wording

limited to first and second the first and second that's it the third floor

Similar wording

what is the third floor going to be the third floor will probably be for storage

Similar wording

well then it's part of it so okay so it's going to be the whole building correct yes

Similar wording

but no but no parties or nothing nothing for the hill nothing for the public yeah it's still

Similar wording

related to the use that you're uh asking for with regard as a part right yep yes right yes

Similar wording

all right um anything else in your presentation no

Similar wording

All right. Anything else in your presentation? No, sir.

Similar wording

Questions from the board. Okay. So what kind of events are you planning to have here?

Similar wording

What kind of events? Go through it. So it's going to vary. We're going to offer anywhere from birthday parties, school back to school events.

Similar wording

We are hoping to partner up with the neighborhood schools, excuse me, pardon me, for like coat drives, back to school nights, you know, book bag giveaways, things like that, church functions, funerals, weddings, anything that people need to, you know, like gather, even if we wanted to host like Pilates classes.

Similar wording

It's a lot of people that are looking for spaces in that community to hold, you know, like things for the neighborhood and just don't have it in there.

Similar wording

They don't have it around the neighborhood.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Have you ever done this before?

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Have I ever done this before?

Similar wording

Not personally.

Similar wording

I have worked alongside people in the venue business, but I have never owned my home.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Do you plan on using the rear yard for it as event space, for outdoor event space?

Similar wording

No. Just for, not for event space, no.

Similar wording

Okay. And what hours, what are your hours going to be on a daily or, you know?

Similar wording

Well, we planned on having it open anywhere from like 8am to maybe having the last event be

Similar wording

like at 8 because each event might be between three and four hours. We wanted to open up early

Similar wording

like 8 because just say for instance if someone is having a funeral repass and normally the event

Similar wording

starts at 11 maybe like the viewing. So we would like to give the family or whoever has to set up

Similar wording

ample amount of time to set up before you know the services start. So I would say between like

Similar wording

eight and midnight all the questions uh yeah on your plan i say okay go ahead no good go ahead

Similar wording

all right so and then what about food and drink how is that going to work um so the food we have

Similar wording

we're going to have like a kitchenette area in the back for when you bring your food in you can

Similar wording

heated up and things like that. We will have like a small refrigerator, microwave, you know,

Similar wording

things like that. It's not going to be any cooking on the premises. Like, yeah, it's not going to be

Similar wording

any cooking allowed on the premises, but you are welcome to bring, you know, your food in and maybe

Similar wording

use the sternos to warm it up. We're not going to be having a bunch of alcohol and things like that.

Similar wording

it's more so water, beverage, juice, soda, depending on your event.

Similar wording

All right. And then my big question about these always is, are you going to have some way that

Similar wording

you have a source of water, like a basin, sink, something so that you can clean tables

Similar wording

or clean the floors? Do you have anything in this? Because I can't, this is so small, I can't tell.

Similar wording

Yes, absolutely. So in the kitchen area, it will be an adequate size basin for, you know,

Similar wording

like hygiene purposes. The basement will also have a wash and dryer and sink area.

Similar wording

And bathrooms, everybody will have, you know, adequate working sinks.

Similar wording

And how many bathrooms do you have?

Similar wording

Right now it's three. We're trying to have one or two.

Similar wording

We're trying to have at least four, two on the main level, one like a handicap, a bigger handicap accessible bathroom and another smaller bathroom.

Similar wording

And then one on the second floor and another one on the third floor.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you. You're welcome. Michael, you have a question?

Similar wording

No, actually, Cheryl talked about the things that I was going to bring up.

Similar wording

Any other questions? Go ahead. So for the first floor and the second floor, will that be used as an event space like for the same event?

Similar wording

They have access to both floors or are they able to be rented out for separate events?

Similar wording

um so i honestly i would like if you're having a bigger event then you will be offered the first

Similar wording

and the second floor if you're having a smaller event then you know you might just need the first

Similar wording

floor i really don't want to have two different events going on at one time i don't really want

Similar wording

events going on at one time i don't really want people walking through somebody else's event

Similar wording

people walking through somebody else's.

Similar wording

because the way the entry is if you had a separate event on the second floor you would have to work

Similar wording

walk through the first floor event so no if you're having a bigger party then yes you'll be able to

Similar wording

run out the first and the second floor for one event okay so it'll just be the first floor by

Similar wording

itself or the first and second floor, but not the second floor alone? Yes. Okay. And if I could just

Similar wording

jump in here, we also talked about that for security purposes as well. Sometimes two events

Similar wording

can be a problem. And Marina is very security conscious. She comes from a family that is

Similar wording

very security-concerned, and that was one of the topics of discussion with the RCO.

Similar wording

And so Marina is a very, very responsible young person who...

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So that's...

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Any other questions from the board?

Similar wording

Questions from our attorney?

Similar wording

None at this time, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

questions or comments from the virtual audience or people here i see no means at this time too

Similar wording

yes i'm going to step in for michael oh sure hi could you please just state your name and

Similar wording

spell it for the stenographer yes nina solomonic s-o-l-o-m-o-n-i-c do you swear or firm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth yes please proceed the comprehensive plan recommends

Similar wording

no change to the existing cmx2 commercial mixed use zoning at this location the property is

Similar wording

located on a commercial corridor there are no near residential neighbors abutting the property along

Similar wording

the commercial corridor but the rear of the property abuts a residential side street so

Similar wording

there is still potential for nuisance due to the event types allowed by assembly and event use

Similar wording

category therefore the city planning commission recommends the board grant the requested variants

Similar wording

for assembly and entertainment use, but with a recommended proviso for limited hours of operation.

Similar wording

DARYL FOX- We give it the hours. Do we want to do like we did the last time, 11?

Similar wording

DARYL FOX- I can't, I can't hear. We're trying to figure out what limited

Similar wording

hours means, okay? And what we're looking at is possibly everything has to be over by 11 o'clock.

Similar wording

DARYL FOX- That's fair.

Similar wording

Okay. All right. Well, thank you. MI 2026-002-006-5508 Chester Avenue. I vote yes with proviso. All events to be over by 11 p.m.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Iowan, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Layla Beebe, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel.

Similar wording

Okay, so we're going to go to number two and three and hear these both together.

Similar wording

So number two, MI 2024-007-462-6215 North 13th.

Similar wording

Number 3, MI 2024-007-465-6217-NOR13. Jermaine Harris is the attorney for both.

Similar wording

Jermaine Harris will be coming in as a panelist.

Similar wording