civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 6, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 6, 20267h 28m

So we've been doing contract food services and catering, like you've mentioned, for close

Similar wording

to 40 years.

Similar wording

we're all wherever we go we we make sure that we're committed to the community and part of our

Similar wording

values and mission is to make sure we're empowering the community offering jobs and supporting

Similar wording

development so they can move on in helping to create the next generation of food entrepreneurs

Similar wording

so we would love to do that here in this community as well thank you and as i mentioned you're taking

Similar wording

both the lower level and the first floor correct of the building correct yes and just briefly the

Similar wording

lower level, which I've got the floor plan up here, this would be your commissary kitchen,

Similar wording

correct? Correct. And you would be providing, this is where you'd be making the food that

Similar wording

this is where you'd be making the food that would then continue to serve serve um serve the rest of

Similar wording

would then continue to serve the rest.

Similar wording

the business operations correct that's correct and then the first floor would be um uh in synergy

Similar wording

with the commissary kitchen below would be an event assembly location correct that's correct

Similar wording

and the idea would be to do life life cycle events there uh host host um non-profit events

Similar wording

weddings, other events, correct? That's correct. Okay, great. So that's the lower level. There's

Similar wording

trash storage down there, and that's where the kitchen is, and then there's a small mezzanine,

Similar wording

and then the main floor here is where you saw those pictures with the interior. That's where

Similar wording

the event space. Yes, yes. As far as occupancy, it's with tables. We understand it's around 130,

Similar wording

130, 140, with standing. With some tables, it's more like 170, 180, roughly. That's what

Similar wording

we've been told from the architects. We have building permits already for the commissary

Similar wording

kitchen and some of the preparations on this floor here. And then we are in discussions

Similar wording

with Temple, the hospital facility that's up there, regarding using one of their lots

Similar wording

for our valet operations.

Similar wording

We know...

Similar wording

Is that Einstein Hospital?

Similar wording

Episcopal, the old Episcopal?

Similar wording

Episcopal up there, yeah,

Similar wording

which is, I think, two blocks, Jacob, three blocks?

Similar wording

Yeah, one block.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

We know we're going to need valet for special events

Similar wording

on that first floor.

Similar wording

Our customers are going to demand it.

Similar wording

We talked to the community about that,

Similar wording

so the valet would be on there in the front

Similar wording

as well as delivery area.

Similar wording

And that's really, you know, kind of the...

Similar wording

The basement will handle all your operations.

Similar wording

The food will go from there to all your operations.

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

Yeah, and then just, these are the boards

Similar wording

I know that we have in the room here,

Similar wording

but just, again...

Similar wording

Is the second floor just a mezzanine looking down?

Similar wording

Yeah, there's a small, what, 200 square feet,

Similar wording

something like that?

Similar wording

Yeah, it was an office.

Similar wording

Yeah, it was an office right there.

Similar wording

But that's really, you know,

Similar wording

KIND OF THE OUTLINE OF WHAT WE'RE LOOKING TO DO. AGAIN, THIS HAS BEEN VETTED HEAVILY BY

Similar wording

HISTORIC COMMISSION, THE COMMUNITY. THERE'S BEEN ARTICLES IN THE PAPER. I'M JUST BRINGING UP

Similar wording

ONE OF THE ARTICLES. I THINK ONE OF THE ZONE BOI MEMBERS MIGHT EVEN BE QUOTED IN THAT ARTICLE.

Similar wording

WE'RE FINALLY REALLY PLEASED TO NOW BE HERE IN FRONT OF THE BOARD TO BRING THIS,

Similar wording

hopefully to to reality and to to get this going as soon as possible a question is from the board

Similar wording

okay um deliveries and then uh you're going to be sending this food out how is that gonna work

Similar wording

deliveries in terms of the raw materials to make the food and then um you know once you've made

Similar wording

the food uh you're going to have a distribution system or what are you going to use for that

Similar wording

so okay so for for uh to to actually service the second floor so we'll use the food i mean

Similar wording

we'll use the commissary kitchen um that's in the basement to serve the food upstairs um

Similar wording

if you and one of the drawings you'll see that there uh lifts that will allow you to you know

Similar wording

bring the food from in from downstairs upstairs but also to receive the raw materials you'll see

Similar wording

there's a delivery zone right there along uh kensington avenue there'll be a loading zone

Similar wording

if i'm correct and then we'll load in right there on harold street there's a ramp there right

Similar wording

yeah yes all right and for the uh cooking part of this the venting how is that going to be handled

Similar wording

will you repeat your question i'm sorry venting oh for the food preparation area it's through the

Similar wording

roof we we had we included that on the historic plans okay yeah and in terms of the designation

Similar wording

of this property is it locally designated i think it's individually i believe it's individually

Similar wording

designated historic yeah yes it is locally designated oh yes yes philadelphia historic yes

Similar wording

okay and then um we already we already had to go to we already appeared before the historic commission

Similar wording

to get the approvals um for this so is any of the interior designated at all just or is it just the

Similar wording

exterior just the exterior right yeah yeah okay yeah all right okay thank you all the questions

Similar wording

yes yep go ahead uh my question is about main

Similar wording

yes my question is about main entrance because i know you have two entrances to the facility

Similar wording

is the uh herald street or not herald street sorry is the kensington avenue entrance

Similar wording

going to be the main entrance for any guests that come for an event

Similar wording

it's the the huntington avenue side of the building the huntington avenue so the with the

Similar wording

stairwell right with it you can see there's a there's an ada ramp along that side okay excuse

Similar wording

me chairman i don't know what the gentleman just wanted oh i'm sorry could you please state your

Similar wording

name and spell it for the stenographer jacob roller get a little closer mr roller jacob roller

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth whole truth nothing but the truth i do please proceed

Similar wording

continue did did you have more questions specifically no i was just because i see this

Similar wording

but your drawing currently is cut off so i was trying to understand like there are patrons coming

Similar wording

in you've got i see the deliveries are on the herald streets are like at the corner on the

Similar wording

street side yeah you can see we have sort of a a stair and a ramp there okay i see that to be all

Similar wording

highlighted the different the different areas and then what's the plan for your employees because i

Similar wording

understand that when you have guests you're going to have valet but what is your plan for and how

Similar wording

many people do you anticipate are going to be at the facility like on a typical day so on a typical

Similar wording

day um we on a typical day like full-time employees will be anywhere from like 10 to 12 employees

Similar wording

and then because this is event driven you know we'll have a plan we we have a plan throughout

Similar wording

Strother Enterprises would rehire and recruit initially it would be for the community and

Similar wording

that would be the goal again they would be per diem employees like catering staff yeah and it

Similar wording

is the idea that you're only going to be catering for events that are held at this facility are you

Similar wording

going to be using this facility as a basis to do catering for other events outside of the facility

Similar wording

um it could be for both it could be for on-site and off-site catering so that's the way we would

Similar wording

look at it okay it's the idea really is to have this operating five or probably more than five

Similar wording

days a week yeah so that's what i was wondering so like if we like if it's fully staffed you've

Similar wording

got 12 people i think my question is given that there's no parking on site what's the plan for

Similar wording

the parking for the people that are here every day for the um community or for your employees

Similar wording

for the employees well they would either have to find uh parking i can't say that fully thought

Similar wording

through that yeah but either they would find parking most of our employees currently um they

Similar wording

commute to work um the disc or septa there are different ways to do it but we i can't i can't say

Similar wording

that i'm going that far with it um but it is so very close to public transportation that's what

Similar wording

we would encourage okay and where are the dumpsters or or what is the trash um removal plan

Similar wording

so right there to the left of the building you'll see that gated area there will be

Similar wording

uh trash receptacles and areas storage area um on the harold street side of the building

Similar wording

there's a there's a trash storage room in the basement and then the trash comes up there and

Similar wording

then it goes out oh yeah yeah it's going to be yeah there is if you look on the basement plan

Similar wording

there's a whole trash storage uh room that's been um approved out for for that right questions or

Similar wording

comments from our attorney no questions at this time questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

planning commission just afterwards just um adopt my testimony well sorry go ahead okay but

Similar wording

mitasha you you heard my testimony and was it true and accurate and do you adopt it as your own great

Similar wording

and then jacob

Similar wording

I also adopt your testimony, Brad, and I just wanted to point out, you know, since we are here for hardship, that, you know, this is a very unique building, very difficult to reuse, not easily adaptable into, you know, residential uses or other more conventional uses.

Similar wording

You know, this is a very special space, and, you know, to use it for events is something that has proven successful in past adaptive reuse situations here in Philadelphia.

Similar wording

And, you know, we would greatly appreciate the relief here.

Similar wording

And as you said, it's been empty now for decades.

Similar wording

35 years?

Similar wording

Plus, at least, yeah.

Similar wording

It was used as a bank from 1909 until sometime in the 80s or 90s, and it's been vacant ever since.

Similar wording

It has not shown to be possible to reuse it in other manners.

Similar wording

you know possible to reuse it in in other manners planning commission here i'm sorry

Similar wording

to interrupt this is ian haggarty we do appear to have two remote participants who have their hands

Similar wording

raised i'm going to promote elige crawley to panelists now all right

Similar wording

i could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

Hello. Hello. Can I be here? Okay. I most certainly could you please state your name and spell for my name is Laji Crowley. First name is L. A. G. E. last name is Crowley C. R. A. W. L. E. Y.

Similar wording

You swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth. Nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

Yes, I do. Are you a neighbor? Do you have an interest in this project? I am a neighbor and have interest in this project. Please proceed.

Similar wording

um so first off hello to everybody we've spoken at the neighbors meeting and got some information

Similar wording

on what was going on and as a homeowner and a property owner on harold street i'm excited for

Similar wording

the new life that this brings in and ideally it removes a lot of the drugs and prostitution in

Similar wording

the area i know that's bigger than just this location and more of a partnership with the city

Similar wording

but excited for that um i can't say i'm excited for this event space but as a resident i am

Similar wording

terrified of what the event space can do for the parking in the area um harold street is already a

Similar wording

one-way street supporting homes also we have maybe two or three new developing apartments in the area

Similar wording

uh i am aware that maybe permit parking may be permitted um that's not exactly something i'm

Similar wording

excited about uh i am aware that this location will be open as late as 12 p.m uh which i'm not

Similar wording

exactly excited about especially as a father of a three and a five year old that that can get

Similar wording

really dicey on a given day um so i am kind of apprehensive about my yes um again excited for

Similar wording

what is to come but i also still have a lot of worries that are unaddressed uh we have gone over

Similar wording

things like putting up the gate which has helped but has also shifted uh some of the people that

Similar wording

hang out there we have some pictures here in your slideshow that kind of demonstrates the activity

Similar wording

there. So I think that there is still more work to come before getting to this point that this is a

Similar wording

thriving wedding venue when you have drug activity and prostitution going on in the corner. So again,

Similar wording

the gates that have been put up have been helpful, but I feel like the property overall is going to

Similar wording

need a property manager, someone that can be consistently keeping up with this. And so that's

Similar wording

my number one concern also someone spoke on it earlier um and i think i'm forgetting my place

Similar wording

we spoke on parking and yeah i'll have to leave it at that because it's slipping me but just on

Similar wording

my concerns there as a resident on this location all right thank you much thank you for taking

Similar wording

time to call next hand please hi chair we have a hand up from britney sanchez they're being promoted

Similar wording

with the panel. Hi, can you hear me okay? Could you please state your name and spell for the

Similar wording

stenographer? Yes, my name is Brittany Sanchez. B-R-I-T-T-A-N-Y-S-A-N-C-H-E-Z. You swear

Similar wording

referring to tell the truth told truth nothing but the truth i do um are you a neighbor yes i lived

Similar wording

on harold street directly across from this building please proceed um i went to the community meeting

Similar wording

on in april and spoke with these lovely people here i think that natasha's idea is something

Similar wording

that can really change the community and would be great however i do have concerns um jacob roller

Similar wording

and Brett Feldman were specifically spoken to that the community support came with demonstration

Similar wording

from that last month of showing how much they cared about our community and the fact that

Similar wording

their building has been abandoned for so long and there's no one there taking care of it which has

Similar wording

led to this drug activity, prostitution, dealers, feces and urine all outside. They have shown none

Similar wording

of that. The pictures that they uploaded here of the fence being put up is only on the front

Similar wording

part of that building but i could go outside right now and show you what it currently looks like

Similar wording

um so what was posted here isn't accurate to what's actually happening outside why i think

Similar wording

a wedding venue would obviously make some type of change because this is something that you would

Similar wording

have to maintain 24 7 in order to have people who want to actually have their wedding here

Similar wording

i don't think that they held up their end of the bargain of showing that they were committed to

Similar wording

improving the environment to show the potential of this space and to continue to have community

Similar wording

um the potential of this space and to and to continue to have community support behind them

Similar wording

support.

Similar wording

thank you um mr film do you want to respond absolutely um we i think you saw the pictures of

Similar wording

we've spent and take all you can answer this more we've spent thousands of dollars on that fencing

Similar wording

and the maintenance of that fencing over the last month month and a half um you know to to do

Similar wording

everything we can do to try to secure that that building. I mean, and we were repeatedly in touch

Similar wording

with East Kensington Neighbors Association about what we were doing each step of the way over the

Similar wording

last month and a half. So it's been our intention to to resolve any concerns. Anything further on

Similar wording

that? I was just going to add, you know, parking. I think people have mentioned that is a concern

Similar wording

is why we've been, we have sort of a, you know, early confirmation from Temple University Episcopal

Similar wording

campus that they have excess capacity at their facility, which is, you know, as you guys can see

Similar wording

on the map is right there a block away. And so we do intend to utilize valet service between, you know,

Similar wording

I think most people coming to events there, if they're driving, they would take, they would take

Similar wording

use of that valet uh were also of course you know directly adjacent to the huntingdon station on on

Similar wording

the l uh as far as the fences we we heard that feedback from the community we went out and and

Similar wording

as brett said spent thousands of dollars to purchase and install fencing on on either side

Similar wording

of the building and uh you know the the greater conditions of of kensington avenue is is a much

Similar wording

greater problem uh than than you know just that that but we hope to be part of the solution

Similar wording

also i own this building for decades yeah all right thank you um planning commission

Similar wording

amy boyd with the planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends a changing

Similar wording

zoning at this location from the current cmx 2.5 commercial mix use to cmx3 the proposed used to

Similar wording

be allowed by special exception under the proposed zoning the appellant has demonstrated that the

Similar wording

proposed use will not cause detrimental impact beyond what would reasonably be expected the

Similar wording

planning commission recommends that the board grant their requested variance for event assembly

Similar wording

facility thank you um lynn um first floor in basement only there's a small portion on the

Similar wording

second floor that they're not using right okay thank you mi2025-007-849-1801 east huntington

Similar wording

street i vote yes with proviso first and basement floor only michael johns my vote is yes with

Similar wording

proviso great adaptive reuse for this building cheryl guest then my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Tywin, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording