civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 6, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 6, 20267h 28m

let me show you some interior shots why do that so the the inside of the property is a is a three

Similar wording

room this one is from the back toward the front of the property

Similar wording

um toward the front of the property

Similar wording

that one is

Similar wording

now that's a

Similar wording

shot of the rear exit

Similar wording

this would be the general area i've got a better shot i think here's a better shot

Similar wording

So this would be the main area where you would come in and as you can see in the architect plan, she's going to remove these little rooms and just make a general space where she'll have the three bays for the nails, manicures, pedicures solely.

Similar wording

No, no other spa services. And in the back, she's going to have a storage room.

Similar wording

Let me see if I can share pictures, a better picture of the front.

Similar wording

Maybe if I stop sharing.

Similar wording

And. This is a better picture of the entrance to this. Lower level, and there's no no interior access from her house to the lower area.

Similar wording

and that at one time was a doctor's office right and at one time it was a doctor's office okay

Similar wording

and i think those are all the pictures i put your put your plans back up okay question questions

Similar wording

from the board uh the court we're going to accept his testimony am i correct hillary yes we can yep

Similar wording

do you want to see the uh exhibits again no just the plans the plans just put the plan that's it

Similar wording

that's it okay questions from the board how did the rco meeting go uh we had full support of the

Similar wording

I believe, 26 people in the neighborhood.

Similar wording

I believe 16 were remote by phone or.

Similar wording

And it's community community on the rise.

Similar wording

What about your directly adjacent neighbors?

Similar wording

They fully support as well.

Similar wording

From what I.

Similar wording

You have letters or anything from them?

Similar wording

I don't have any letters from them.

Similar wording

But there's only one neighbor because it's an end unit on Levek.

Similar wording

Other questions?

Similar wording

What is happening in that rear room behind the, I guess those are for the pedicure chairs?

Similar wording

So the rear room would be a storage room for supplies, this area.

Similar wording

Okay, and is the only sink the one in the powder room?

Similar wording

And there's the sinks across the way, and there's a little, like, kind of reception area right here.

Similar wording

But as far as the only sink, there will be one bathroom.

Similar wording

I was less worried about the bathroom.

Similar wording

I just have never been to an old salon that didn't have a utility.

Similar wording

oh they'll be they'll be you know in the uh to the actual three bays they'll need to have uh

Similar wording

water like i've never seen a i've never seen a nailed seat have water access so i mean i've

Similar wording

seen the chairs right but not but like typically they need a utility sink to be able to like clean

Similar wording

and wash hands and deal with a lot of the products that they bring in and i'm just wondering is there

Similar wording

in the stories

Similar wording

va a tener necesita interpretación señor si va a tener usted algún fregadero para materiales

Similar wording

además del lavabo del baño en esta área de almacenaje

Similar wording

lavadero como de ropa

Similar wording

lavadero como de ropa el lavabo para limpiar cosas the sink to clean your

Similar wording

I do need one.

Similar wording

Necesito, por favor, señora, que me diga su nombre completo y me lo deletre.

Similar wording

Diana Francois Suero.

Similar wording

Diana Francois Suero.

Similar wording

Could you spell it please?

Similar wording

N, N, C de casa, C, O, E, I, S, S, S, U, E, R, O.

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

say yes okay could you we continue where we were her answers relative to the sinks

Similar wording

what's the answer me repite su respuesta señora

Similar wording

Could you repeat, please?

Similar wording

Yes, I have always been really careful with every tool and

Similar wording

utensil that i use all of the materials that i need to prevent any infection either bacteria

Similar wording

or whatever in my job i have been doing this for years and i know that cleaning it's essential for

Similar wording

the prevention of uh you know in the care of the health of every client i i also believe that the

Similar wording

rco i looked just in my file she commented that the utensils aren't necessarily um like washed

Similar wording

in a sink there's a uh desanitizer machine that she has where all the tools get put after each

Similar wording

client to be esteemed or cleaned I'm not I I have a note as that how she cleans

Similar wording

that the only like there's gonna be the like yes the sanitizer machine is in

Similar wording

most nail salons but there's usually other solutions that they're handling

Similar wording

right right she's only going to use the sink that's in the bathroom for the

Similar wording

operations el único lavabo que va usted a utilizar para la operación el único lavabo es el que esté

Similar wording

en el baño no no no aparte de del lavado del baño creo que necesito otro porque no puedo mezclar los

Similar wording

utensilios que uso para los clientes en el baño. So se necesita uno aparte. Aquí yo tengo videos

Similar wording

también de... So I know on top of the one that is in the bathroom, I think I need another one

Similar wording

because I cannot be mixing my tools with, you know, the things that are in the bathroom for

Similar wording

the clients. So I need one on top of that. And I have videos here. Yep, I think we're on the same

Similar wording

page. I hear what you're saying. It's just not on the plan. I don't see it on the plan.

Similar wording

I hear what she's saying. It's just not on the plan. It's I don't see on the plan either board member, but she intends to put, I guess, another sink for the mixing of the.

Similar wording

En el plan no se encuentra todavía puesto ese lavabo, entonces se necesita tener otro lavabo.

Similar wording

Other questions.

Similar wording

A ver, con otra pregunta.

Similar wording

But then when you do the manicuring, usually there's, you know, they ask you to wash your hands after they get done doing whatever they're doing to get your hands prepared for being painted.

Similar wording

So is she going to have a sink for that too?

Similar wording

si es lo mismo del lavabo porque yo sé que por ejemplo cuando uno va a hacerse las uñas de las

Similar wording

manos a uno se les pide después del manicure que no se lave las manos antes de que las pinten

Similar wording

exactamente entonces va a tener ese tipo de lavabo también porque yo sé que para los pedicures con

Similar wording

la silla que tiene su tina integrada eso es más que suficiente eso es una cosa pero para las manos

Similar wording

para lavar las manos antes de pintarlas va a tener un lavabo instalado para eso también

Similar wording

ese es el mismo que le estoy diciendo dar desde guanda

Similar wording

i was talking about all right questions questions from our attorney not at this time mr chair

Similar wording

questions or comments from the virtual audience or the current audience here yes sir we have a hand

Similar wording

up from slow folks they're being promoted the panel good morning mr folks yeah good morning

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Mr. Folks?

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

I can't start.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

I apologize.

Similar wording

I entered this check.

Similar wording

I entered everything by accident.

Similar wording

I should not be testifying at all.

Similar wording

I apologize.

Similar wording

You're not going to testify here?

Similar wording

no sir i apologize okay any other questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

no hands at this time chair planning commission morning chair members of the board michael gall

Similar wording

with the philadelphia city planning commission m-i-c-h-a-e-l-g-a-l-l you swear affirm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth so affirm chair um please proceed with your

Similar wording

testimony thank you the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the rsa 5 residential

Similar wording

single-family attached zoning at this location. The property has a documented history of legal

Similar wording

office use as a doctor's office, dating to at least 1952. This end-of-row building is already

Similar wording

physically configured for similar uses, like many similar properties on this part of the city,

Similar wording

and along Levick Street, which operates as a de facto arterial for bridge access and has a number

Similar wording

of similar commercial activities fronting it. Therefore, the City Planning Commission recommends

Similar wording

the board grant the requested variance for personal services use mi2025-006-998-6354

Similar wording

revere street i vote yes johns my vote is yes cheryl gaston my vote is yes tenetta graham my

Similar wording

vote is yes i am mcadams my vote is yes hi i win my vote is yes thank you interpreter thank you

Similar wording

counselor thank you you all have a good day all right you too

Similar wording

number six mi 2025 002 853636 kerper street

Similar wording

joan conley is the current owner

Similar wording

this application is for use as a two-story family household living whereas

Similar wording

the proposed use two-story household living is prohibited in the rsa3 zoning district

Similar wording

good morning hi could you please your joan could you please state your name and spell for the

Similar wording

stenographer. And just pulled a little closer to you too, if you don't mind.

Similar wording

And just hold a little closer to you, too, if you don't mind. Yep. Joan Connelly, C-O-N-N-O-L-L-Y. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth? I do, sir. Our vice chair has a few questions.

Similar wording

Good morning. How are you? Have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing? I have. And your refusal is

Similar wording

for

Similar wording

two-family household living

Similar wording

that's prohibited in an RSA 3

Similar wording

zoning district. Do you

Similar wording

attest to that refusal

Similar wording

and simply to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Alright. You are getting some

Similar wording

assistance, right? Yes. So we can begin

Similar wording

with your case.

Similar wording

Should I just address?

Similar wording

Okay. Yeah, why don't you start? Well, first

Similar wording

tell us what you're doing.

Similar wording

Well, the property is now zoned as single family, and I'd like to have it changed back to its original use as a duplex.

Similar wording

Okay. Is it currently set up as a duplex?

Similar wording

Yes, for electric, water, gas.

Similar wording

Sure. Why don't you start your test?

Similar wording

Okay. This property was built as a duplex with separate entrances and separate utilities, two electric meters, two gas meters, two breaker boxes,

Similar wording

and there are two hot water heaters and separate hookups in the basement for laundry.

Similar wording

My grandmother, Alvira Kramer, was the original owner.

Similar wording

She purchased it July 1959.

Similar wording

She always lived on the first floor and rented the second floor.

Similar wording

In 1998, my parents, Art and Peggy Kramer,

Similar wording

purchased the property from my grandmother and moved into the second floor

Similar wording

where they cared for my grandmother until she died in 2001.

Similar wording

Since 2001, the property has been occupied only by family.

Similar wording

In 2012, the property was changed from multifamily to single-family use, with a use permit issued on December 14, 2012.

Similar wording

Currently, I live on the first floor, and the second floor is used for family occasionally.

Similar wording

My father passed away August 26 last year.

Similar wording

i am now the owner of 636 purple street and made settlement on april 16th of 2026 i am asking to

Similar wording

change the property back to its original use as a duplex why don't you show us some photos

Similar wording

i believe the interior too yep they'll have it yeah they'll do it for you okay okay

Similar wording

okay that's going upstairs private access to the second floor right

Similar wording

first floor bathroom okay

Similar wording

uh the second floor kitchen okay

Similar wording

second floor bathroom okay

Similar wording

tell us about the rco

Similar wording

no it it's her property right right okay tell us about i did go to the rco meeting my sister did

Similar wording

okay could you thank you could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

donna kramer d-o-n-n-a last name kramer k-r-a-m-b-r do you swear or affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

told truth nothing but the truth i do please proceed uh so i went to the rco meeting um met

Similar wording

with them made my presentation and here's the letter um right that they approved they don't

Similar wording

have a problem with it all right all right okay questions from the board

Similar wording

questions or comments from our attorney not at this time mr chair actually sorry no one um

Similar wording

One thing I wanted to mention, so the property now is zoned RSA 3, which requires parking, and it looked like in the photos, there's parking to the side.

Similar wording

Yes, there's all street parking for 4 cars. Okay. It just wasn't mentioned on the refusal. I just wanted to note it for the record because it is a requirement. Thank you.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience to the current audience here?

Similar wording

No hands at this time, chair.

Similar wording

Planning Commission.

Similar wording

morning michael gall with the philadelphia city planning commission the comprehensive plan

Similar wording

recommends no change to the rsa3 residential single family attached zoning at this location

Similar wording

this property appears to have a history as a two dwelling unit building despite the issuance of

Similar wording

permit in 2012 for single family use therefore the philadelphia city planning commission recommends

Similar wording

the board grant the proposed use variance for two dwelling units thank you mi 2025 002 853 636

Similar wording

Kerper Street, I vote yes.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

tennetta graham my vote is yes ryan mcadams my vote is yes my vote is yes thank you thank you okay

Similar wording

Tynetta Graham, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Taya Wayne, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

number nine mi 2025 006 771 1121 walkin street this application is for the erection of a

Similar wording

a vertical addition to an existing attached building and includes roof deck and roof deck

Similar wording

access whereas the maximum occurred area for the RSA 5 zoning district is 75 percent

Similar wording

and 80 percent 84 percent is uh processed when when the maximum rear yard is nine feet and six

Similar wording

feet is proposed and where the where the stories above the second floor of the attached house

Similar wording

shall be set back

Similar wording

an additional eight feet

Similar wording

and this is zero.

Similar wording

Could the

Similar wording

Paul

Similar wording

Giselle

Similar wording

Craig

Similar wording

Craig

Similar wording

Craig

Similar wording

Yes, hi.

Similar wording

Sir, could you please state your name

Similar wording

and spell it for the stenographer?

Similar wording