civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 14, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 14, 20202h 14m

well you know what it's it's very upsetting because this is the second time something like

Similar wording

well you know what it's it's very upsetting because this is the

Similar wording

this has happened where oops i forgot and that's not lost to me mr chairman it just isn't so but

Similar wording

i'll be here next week if i could interject it could have been a mistake on the zoning board's

Similar wording

part i'll take that and we're going to go as it was scheduled with the notice to the attorney

Similar wording

I apologize for any inconsistencies or inconveniences.

Similar wording

Thank you, Tanya.

Similar wording

Yes, certainly this is not a situation where we forgot the hearing date.

Similar wording

And the reason for our objection and our request to move this to next week

Similar wording

is specifically so that everyone who has received notice of this

Similar wording

can participate in next week's meeting.

Similar wording

Okay, Tanya, if you could please send to the RCO the notices.

Similar wording

I would appreciate it.

Similar wording

So that's not how we operate.

Similar wording

If you wish to put in a parent statement,

Similar wording

you can put an appearance statement with the phone number the chair called out in the beginning

Similar wording

and then all appearances will be recorded and we'll send it to those who put an appearance

Similar wording

statement no i i meant may perhaps we're talking about two different things um and if i'm confused

Similar wording

i apologize but no i would like to see a copy of what claire uh harrison harvey received that says

Similar wording

the date is the 21st, and I would like to have confirmation that we will be heard on the 21st.

Similar wording

So everybody from the RCO who has made the time to take off from work and other activities can

Similar wording

once again do so. I mean, time is money. We're all volunteers. I realize that members of the ZBA are

Similar wording

also, you know, kind of giving the time, but we need to have some guarantee that we are going to

Similar wording

be heard on the 21st the 10 o'clock session the two o'clock session whatever whatever it is and

Similar wording

I would like to have you can email me Suzanne I can also email you the notices received I believe

Similar wording

I included that in my last email to you earlier this week but I'm happy to resend that to you

Similar wording

and I want but I want it's I want something from Tanya that tells me we are going to be heard on

Similar wording

the 21st and which session I want some level of confirmation of that so Suzanne yes what you can

Similar wording

do is email me your requests the chair runs the meeting if he states at this moment he will allow

Similar wording

your testimony then he will allow your testimony so please email me your direct concerns and i'll

Similar wording

take care of them but thank you i apologize for all the inconveniences look we just everybody's

Similar wording

apologizing we're going to be doing this for a long time today and god knows how long and we all

Similar wording

understand. It is unprecedented times. It's not an excuse. It's a reality. So we do appreciate

Similar wording

everyone's patience. We will get these hearings done. We've been trying the board with the help

Similar wording

of staff for three months to try to get these hearings up and running. And we're finally here

Similar wording

today. And again, we knew we were going to have some bumps in the road, if you will.

Similar wording

We're going to do our best to get this straightened out. And Suzanne, we appreciate you and

Similar wording

the other neighbors for taking the time to be with us today but thank you these are things that

Similar wording

are sometimes are beyond our control and thank you stephanie how about you're welcome thank you

Similar wording

very much how about the postings on the property can we get new updated postings so that people

Similar wording

know that it's scheduled for next week as well the postings do indicate that the meeting is next

Similar wording

week on the 21st that was the reason for our objection yeah i actually i actually read the

Similar wording

poster when I was on my way to Dr. Volpe's

Similar wording

office across the street, but I didn't remember

Similar wording

the date on it, so

Similar wording

if it's the 21st, we don't need

Similar wording

to repost.

Similar wording

As long as it's still, if you check it out,

Similar wording

John, if we're wrong, call us

Similar wording

back and let us know, but I think it does say

Similar wording

the 21st. Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

All right, thank you again.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and congratulations

Similar wording

on the birth of your granddaughter.

Similar wording

Thank you, you just made my day.

Similar wording

Who I've only seen

Similar wording

twice in a month.

Similar wording

Well, thanks to COVID-19.

Similar wording

Thanks to COVID-19.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Bye-bye, everyone.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Next case, calendar number 38727, 1520 North Hancock Street.

Similar wording

Is there anyone here on North Hancock Street?

Similar wording

The attorney is John Rooney.

Similar wording

Yes, I'm here.

Similar wording

Hello. Hello. Mr. Rooney, do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes, we do. Name an address for the record, please.

Similar wording

This is Attorney John Rooney on behalf of the building owner, Brian Reese. It's for 1520 Hancock Street.

Similar wording

And Mr. Reese should be on the line as well. Brian, are you there?

Similar wording

I guess we're not hearing him. Is he there as well. Hello, and I'm having some technical

Similar wording

I guess we're not hearing him is he there as well

Similar wording

difficulties. Can you hear me? There you go. Are you Brian? How about now? Yes. Okay. There we go.

Similar wording

name and address on the record

Similar wording

Brian

Similar wording

Brian Reese

Similar wording

322 West Thompson Street

Similar wording

Philadelphia Pennsylvania

Similar wording

19122

Similar wording

Brian spelled B-R-Y-A-N

Similar wording

R-E-E-S-E

Similar wording

I'm going to ask

Similar wording

both you gentlemen

Similar wording

you swear for them to tell the truth

Similar wording

the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Carol?

Similar wording

They have to now present their case.

Similar wording

Did you ask about they stipulate?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Yes, they stipulate.

Similar wording

And Mr. Reese will be presenting as the building owner.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Please proceed, Mr. Reese.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

This is for reallocation of lot lines between two parcels of property located at 1520 North

Similar wording

Hancock Street, 1522 North Hancock Street.

Similar wording

It's approximately 1225 by 40 long.

Similar wording

There wasn't a great...

Similar wording

We lost you, Mr. Reese.

Similar wording

It was an agreement between myself and the property next door for the purchase of this

Similar wording

sliver of land.

Similar wording

Now we're just attempting to reallocate the lot lines and make it official.

Similar wording

Have you met with the RCO?

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

We got their approval.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

just wanted to question chair do we have supporting documentation

Similar wording

frankie on me on me yourself do we have on uh documentation we do supporting this application

Similar wording

we do yes we do okay is there anyone else here who wishes to testify on this matter

Similar wording

see none uh any questions from the board planning commission chairman and members of the board this

Similar wording

property is indicated for residential use on the comprehensive plan we have no objection to the

Similar wording

lot line adjustment thank you calendar number 38727 1520 hancock street my vote is yes

Similar wording

my vote is yes my vote is yes my vote is yes good luck thank you thank you thank you thank you

Similar wording

all thank you very much have a great day you too next case is calendar number 38163

Similar wording

2009 abigail street the attorney is richard slaven are you here

Similar wording

no actually the attorney is um claire harrison gussie o'neill

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

why do i have richard slavin is that was on the original i believe they changed attorneys

Similar wording

yes that was the original applicant

Similar wording

is gussie o'neill here

Similar wording

anyone here from Claire Harris on this case

Similar wording

Darren did you get correspondence from them because we have not had a change in attorney

Similar wording

if that's not done on record we cannot notify the change

Similar wording

Gussie is here she was in contact with me and she submitted all of the documents

Similar wording

I'm looking at the refusal sheet that I got and it does say

Similar wording

Claire Harris, Gussie O'Neill.

Similar wording

We're on the calendar, I'm sorry, the list.

Similar wording

Hi.

Similar wording

I'm promoting you as panelists.

Similar wording

Hello.

Similar wording

Actually, I think that Herc Grigos may be presenting.

Similar wording

Is that the case, Gussie?

Similar wording

Yes, Herc is going to be presenting.

Similar wording

And he should be on the line.

Similar wording

Gregos are you on the line I just promoted you as panelists

Similar wording

I just promoted you as panelist.

Similar wording

Hercules, are you there?

Similar wording

There he goes.

Similar wording

He's on.

Similar wording

I'm here.

Similar wording

Everyone see me and hear me.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Raising hands and texting frantically.

Similar wording

My apologies.

Similar wording

Do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Name and address, please.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, members of the board. Good morning. Hercules Griegos, 1835 Market Street,

Similar wording

Philadelphia, PA. Here representing CCD 105 LLC, owner of the property located at 2009 Abigail

Similar wording

Street. We're here today with an application for construction of nine single-family homes,

Similar wording

five of which have parking with rear-loaded garages and a shared driveway. Also here is

Similar wording

Tyler McNeil, owner and developer, and Gabriel Deck, the project architect.

Similar wording

This property is currently configured to six lots. It's approximately an 8,000 square foot

Similar wording

area that's a vacant parking lot. This is in the East Kensington section at Abigail and Coral

Similar wording

Street. It's directly adjacent to the former Harvest and Dairy building, which is being

Similar wording

which is being redeveloped, as you're aware. The site is owned RSA 5, and the plan has always been

Similar wording

to redesign this as a townhome project that fits into the RSA 5 parameters, but also allows the

Similar wording

project to fit into the context of the neighborhood. And just as the slides go through, this is the

Similar wording

photos and get a context of the surrounding area next slide you'll see

Similar wording

the Harbison Dairy building adjacent and then the adjacent townhomes and then we

Similar wording

if we get to the site plan I'll just lay it out for everyone this is great be

Similar wording

nine townhomes facing Abigail Street entered from a rear drive for parking

Similar wording

for five of the homes. Originally, the project was taken to the RCO and configured as a eight

Similar wording

project with front-loading garages. This was rejected by the community. My clients were able

Similar wording

to acquire an additional piece of property to reconfigure the project to a nine-home concept

Similar wording

with the rear drive and we're able to offer varying housing types various sizes. We returned

Similar wording

the project with the additional design back to the RCO where we received overwhelming support.

Similar wording

You'll see from the record there was a vote of 38 to 2 in support of the project

Similar wording

and that should be in your packet. Additionally we have a letter of support and non-opposition

Similar wording

from Councilman Squillow. As I said, the houses range in size. There's three different housing

Similar wording

types. The smaller houses are three-story homes. As you walk the way toward Abigail Street,

Similar wording

the houses are a little larger, four-story homes. We think the varying housing stop

Similar wording

are consistent with the context of the neighborhood. I'll quickly go through the refusal.

Similar wording

four of the lots are a smaller width or 14 foot wide lots and some of the lots are smaller in

Similar wording

size but ultimately you know nine houses on the 8,000 square foot lot we think is

Similar wording

appropriate for the context of East Kensington and if you look on the site plan you know directly

Similar wording

adjacent on Susquehanna there's a number of lots that are more narrow and equally narrow so we

Similar wording

think it fits into the context and I'll just say the architect Gabriel Deck is here to answer

Similar wording

questions as well as Tyler McNeil owner and developer and I'll ask Mr. McNeil if he heard

Similar wording

my testimony and to adopt it as his own and I'll turn it over to the board for any questions

Similar wording

could we the witness who just adopted your testimony could be sworn in yep i'm just about

Similar wording

to do that uh this is tyler mcneil can you hear me mr mcnail it's frank to chico do you swear

Similar wording

from the tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes i do and please spell

Similar wording

your name first and last name for the stenographer please tyler t-y-l-e-r mc-n-e-i-l uh business

Similar wording

address 2400 market street number 200 philadelphia pa 19103

Similar wording

thank you mr you've heard my testimony do you adopt it as your own i do

Similar wording

Mr. McNeil, you've heard my testimony. Do you adopt it as your own?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Do you have anyone else, Hercules?

Similar wording

I think that's it.

Similar wording

All right. Is there anyone else here? Anyone else here to wish to testify on this matter?

Similar wording

You were about to say something, Hercules?

Similar wording

No, I'm just here to answer any questions that the board may have.

Similar wording

Are there any questions from the board?

Similar wording

Nope.

Similar wording

Is this a revised plan?

Similar wording

We had a revised refusal, so we do not need, I don't believe we need a revised plan to provide

Similar wording