civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - April 9, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Apr 9, 20255h 27m

i've been before this board a couple of times before with this uh use that we are speaking

Similar wording

about this afternoon. Again, it's called Quick Lube. We specifically received a refusal from

Similar wording

LNI because the proposed use that we are seeking today, which is personal vehicle repair and

Similar wording

maintenance, is expressly prohibited in the CMX 2.5 commercial zoning district. Again, Quick Lube,

Similar wording

as I started to say, we've been here before for, I think this will be our third location. The first

Similar wording

location was up at 2250 Cotman Avenue. The second one was over at Bluegrass and Welsh Road up there

Similar wording

in the northeast. What we are seeking this afternoon is to do a two-bay, 1,342-square-foot

Similar wording

take-five oil change facility. Again, if the board wants to hear it, take-five is unique from

Similar wording

anything else that we have in this area. Individuals will drive their car to the location.

Similar wording

They never leave the car. They stay in the car the entire time, and they are only provided a few services.

Similar wording

This one in particular will provide oil changes, windshield wiper replacements, engine air and cabin air filter replacement,

Similar wording

pool exchange, rotate tires, and they will do state inspections.

Similar wording

There are over 800 take-five oil change facilities across the United States,

Similar wording

And the average service time is about 11.2 minutes with a high volume of about 10 cars being serviced an hour.

Similar wording

With regards to this site in particular, as you can see from the screen, we're doing some substantial improvements to this property.

Similar wording

First off, we'll talk about traffic flow.

Similar wording

There's currently curb cuts right here where you kind of see this lighter green.

Similar wording

Also here, what we are doing is we are going to be closing those curb cuts off.

Similar wording

we are going to be doing, you know, we will be replacing the handicap accessible sidewalks just

Similar wording

so that they are freshened up, if you will, adding landscaping around the property. And so now the

Similar wording

only ingress and egress for the property will be along North 5th Street up here. Again, closing it

Similar wording

off, this has been done in consultation with the streets department. Right now, this intersection

Similar wording

at North Lehigh and 5th Street, excuse me, it's close to that intersection where that curb cut

Similar wording

is now so closing that off will allow uh cars to to enter in a little bit more of a safer location

Similar wording

it's more centralized with regards to hours of operation it will be open seven days a week 7

Similar wording

a.m to 8 p.m with regards to delivery supplies all deliveries minus the oil will be delivered

Similar wording

by essentially a ups uh truck with regards to oil delivery itself it's no different than your home

Similar wording

oil service a truck will pull up usually about once a week depending on volume if it needs to

Similar wording

go in it might be two times a week they'll pull into one of the bays uh and the truck will just

Similar wording

unload the oil and then they'll leave all the used oil which was something that was a question

Similar wording

uh with regards to the rco is stored and also removed uh out one

Similar wording

with regards to the RCO is stored and also removed out once a week.

Similar wording

The whole site is designed in a way that the oil collection system consists, you know, nothing spills out, if you will.

Similar wording

And I have someone from operations who can go into greater detail if the board so chooses.

Similar wording

Again, with regards to the support of the community, one thing that Quick Lube does is they look for employment opportunities within the community.

Similar wording

And I know that's something that everybody always says when they come to these.

Similar wording

This is something that this company really prides itself on.

Similar wording

In addition to that, they also work with, as they've been doing with the prior other RCOs that I've mentioned, to look at second chance opportunities.

Similar wording

Individuals who need a second chance, that's one big thing that they do with their hiring.

Similar wording

And they don't just keep them at entry level.

Similar wording

Instead, they really do an internal promotion program.

Similar wording

Some of the managers that are currently working at Quick Loop started out as entry level from a second chance program

Similar wording

and are now not only just managers of those individual stores, but also regional managers.

Similar wording

They also do charity.

Similar wording

They normally do two charities a year, one's for the local children's hospital where they're located,

Similar wording

and the other one is for Folds of Honor, which is an organization that benefits families of fallen service members.

Similar wording

In coordination or a conversation with the RCO, they requested two charities in particular.

Similar wording

So those charities, just for the board's knowledge, will be St. Christopher's Hospitals for Children,

Similar wording

as well as the Veterans Multiservice Center.

Similar wording

We did meet with the RCO back in, I guess that would have been March, excuse me.

Similar wording

The RCO meeting was attended by 22 residents.

Similar wording

The vote was 22 to nothing to support among the residents, and then 5 to 0 in support from the board itself.

Similar wording

I do have a full presentation packet with regards to the zoning notice and all that, but I don't think, you know, nothing's been flagged.

Similar wording

So I have no other presentation that I can have.

Similar wording

Why don't you have your testimony adopted?

Similar wording

it. Perfect. We'll start off with Shannon.

Similar wording

Why could you please state your name

Similar wording

and spell for the stenographer and try to get close

Similar wording

and turn that off for us. Thank you.

Similar wording

Shannon Park. S-H-A-N-N-O-N

Similar wording

E-A-R-K. Do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do. Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Thank you. Shannon, you were present in the room when I gave

Similar wording

that testimony? Yes. Is everything accurate

Similar wording

to the best of your knowledge, information, belief?

Similar wording

Yes. And just for the record, so you can

Similar wording

state for the board what is your role here this afternoon i am the civil engineer and so you work

Similar wording

with you you're you're an employee of bowler yes and you were responsible for the designing of

Similar wording

these plans yes perfect um and you would adopt that testimony that i provided as your own i do

Similar wording

there any questions for the engineer questions from the board for the engineer i guess i have

Similar wording

a question about the number of parking spots the plan shows i think spaces for seven cars and i'm

Similar wording

wondering is that a breakdown between cars that are being serviced employees of the location and

Similar wording

patrons yeah um the as a letter mentioned that the you stay within your vehicle for the service

Similar wording

so um the parking is mainly intended for the employees mainly for the employees okay you'll

Similar wording

never leave your car there's you know the you they're not parking like they're not parking at

Similar wording

actually go into the retail. There's not even a retail. It's just a storage and a restroom for

Similar wording

the employees and then like a spot for them to, you know, have their lunch. Um, but you pull in

Similar wording

here, it's kind of like a drive-thru restaurant. You pull in, you don't leave your car, you get

Similar wording

your service and then you leave. Okay. Other questions?

Similar wording

Questions or comments from our attorney? No, Mr. Chair. Questions or comments from the virtual

Similar wording

audience i see no hands at the sound chair planning commission amy blood with the planning

Similar wording

commission the comprehensive plan recommends no change in zoning at this location from the

Similar wording

existing commercial mixed use cmx 2.5 the zoning designation supports walkable community commercial

Similar wording

corridors and the property sets an important intersection for the el centro de oro commercial

Similar wording

corridor on north 5th street the planning commission recommends the board deny the

Similar wording

requested variance for vehicle repair and maintenance

Similar wording

mi 2024 007 499 433 to 43 wesley high avenue i vote yes michael johns my vote is yes

Similar wording

cheryl gaston my vote is yes tenetta graham my vote is yes i win my vote is yes thank you

Similar wording

council thank you very much mr chair and members of the board sure mi 2024 007 535 1800 south 32nd

Similar wording

street brett feldman is the attorney hi council good afternoon

Similar wording

so council could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

try again yeah good

Similar wording

try again yeah good afternoon brett feldman 1835 market street philadelphia pennsylvania

Similar wording

19103 b-r-e-t-t feldman f-e-l-d-m-a-n right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth nothing but the truth i do could you identify your client the relationship to the property

Similar wording

Yes, I represent Attain ABA Autism Therapy. They are the equitable owner of this property,

Similar wording

which was formerly the PHA headquarters. Yes. Do you waive the reading of the refusal and do

Similar wording

you agree with its accuracy? I do. Okay. Why don't you start your presentation? Great.

Similar wording

I'm going to share my screen here.

Similar wording

There's a recommendation and support from the Tasker Morris

Similar wording

Neighborhood Association, by the way.

Similar wording

You're coming up, right?

Similar wording

Okay, great.

Similar wording

Great. Let me get right to it here. Again, Brett Feldman, I represent the applicant to attain ABA

Similar wording

therapy. We've passed up exhibits 1 through 14, which I'd ask to be incorporated into the record.

Similar wording

Okay. Mr. Chairman, as you said, we do have a letter of support from the Tasker Morris

Similar wording

Neighborhood Association. That came after multiple meetings. We've worked closely with the community

Similar wording

to obtain that letter of support.

Similar wording

I'm joined by Fernando Vinagre,

Similar wording

who is the Director of Compliance for ABA Therapy.

Similar wording

This application might look similar.

Similar wording

Mr. Vinagre and myself were here about a month ago

Similar wording

for the location at 5440 Lansdowne Avenue,

Similar wording

which was a Rite Aid that Attain was purchasing

Similar wording

and converting into an ABA autism center.

Similar wording

This is now for the former PHA headquarters building, which would be really kind of their showpiece, flagship.

Similar wording

That's the one faces the expressway.

Similar wording

Correct. Let me just show you the picture, and everyone will recognize it there.

Similar wording

That's the letter of support.

Similar wording

Here is the building, right on 76.

Similar wording

That's Vare Avenue right in the front and 76.

Similar wording

There are the ingress and egress points, as you'll hear, are right on Vare.

Similar wording

We're not changing the building.

Similar wording

We're not changing the envelope.

Similar wording

We're not changing the ingress, ingress points.

Similar wording

We're not changing the 69 existing parking spaces that you see right there.

Similar wording

That's from the, I guess you would call it the back.

Similar wording

This is the picture of the front.

Similar wording

For many years, it was operated as a PHA headquarters.

Similar wording

It has now been empty for some number of years. If you've driven past, I drive past almost very frequently. There was a massive for sale sign that was on the back of this property that is weathered. It's been up for years and years, as I understand from PHA and its brokers.

Similar wording

There was not a tremendous interest in this property, but I think those in the community are very excited and appreciative to now have this type of facility, an autism center in that neighborhood, which is one of the, as Fernando, as you'll identify, is one of the main areas of need in the city for autism treatment.

Similar wording

along the spectrum disorder.

Similar wording

These are the pictures inside.

Similar wording

It is an office building.

Similar wording

That's kind of what you have on the multiple floors.

Similar wording

And one of the attractions of this is that

Similar wording

there was a variance issued for the office building.

Similar wording

And this use, which is both offices,

Similar wording

which is the existing use and also the group medical,

Similar wording

there is a lot of, you know,

Similar wording

there's work inside that has to be done,

Similar wording

But it's not the type of massive residential conversion that would cost, would be prohibitively expensive with all the new bathrooms and all the new infrastructure and life safety that you would see with the conversion.

Similar wording

And I think that was one of the main reasons why this wasn't developed.

Similar wording

So with that being said, I'm just going to, Fernando, you testified previously to the board, but I'm going to ask you again to go on the record.

Similar wording

Sir, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Fernando Vinagre, F-E-R-N-A-N-D-O, last name V-I-N-A-G-R-E.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And Mr. Vinagre, can you just provide your name and title and your area of responsibilities within ATTAIN?

Similar wording

And Mr. Vinagre, can you just provide your name and title and your area of responsibilities?

Similar wording

Yes, my name is Fernando Vinagre, and I serve as the Director of Compliance for ATTAIN ABA.

Similar wording

And can you provide the board with what is ATTAIN and what type of services does it provide?

Similar wording

Basically, it provides a variety of behavioral treatment services to the autism population and developmental and intellectual disabilities.

Similar wording

And you have locations throughout the country, but you also have locations in Philadelphia, correct?

Similar wording

That is correct.

Similar wording

And you have one existing location?

Similar wording

One existing location in Maniunk.

Similar wording

Okay. And we were here a month ago on the other proposed location that we're now moving ahead with.

Similar wording

So can you just provide a sense of what types of services we would provide at this type of center that we discuss with the community?

Similar wording

So basically, we specialize in Applied Behavior Analysis Services, which is the gold star evidence-based treatment for autism and intellectual disabilities.

Similar wording

So basically, what you would see at this center is a variety of assessments and evaluations that we would be conducting there,

Similar wording

which would be the first step in the process to kind of diagnosing what the various deficits are

Similar wording

for that individual. And then from there, the second phase of there would be that you would

Similar wording

see there is direct services. So once we have a full mapping of the assessment, via the assessment,

Similar wording

all the treatment needs, then we move into direct services. The children would come to the actual

Similar wording

center and would be undergoing direct services there as well. We also have ancillary services

Similar wording

that will be specializing there. So we'll be engaging in occupational therapy, speech and

Similar wording

language pathology, and physical therapy they'll be able to provide. Thank you, Mr. Vinagre. And

Similar wording

you see in front of you a kind of a day in the a typical type day um that um uh an individual

Similar wording

a youngster would would would experience at the center is this a good sense of what a day might

Similar wording

look like it is it is yeah um basically there's there's a series of a variety of classes that

Similar wording

we'll be um utilizing um children will be grouped into uh various groupings or classrooms based on

Similar wording

levels of need, levels of acuity, and treatment goals. So we'll be pairing a lot of the children

Similar wording

based on a lot of the treatment goals that they have. The day is basically broken up into two

Similar wording

halves, where you might have children that come during the morning time, basically 9 to 12,

Similar wording

another grouping that might come in the afternoon time from like 12 to 5, and then some of the

Similar wording

children that have larger needs would be there the full day. And I have some pictures in front

Similar wording

of you of what the types of classrooms and group therapy spaces look like. Is this a good and

Similar wording

accurate representation of what the type of classrooms that we'll have at the center?

Similar wording

I guess absolutely. These are some of the renderings that we're looking to design on the

Similar wording

inside. We call them classrooms, even though they're not academically based or won't have

Similar wording

teachers. We call them classrooms because of the learning focus that we have, and there will be

Similar wording

interventions and basically a lot of instructional play that is occurring that's all backed by the

Similar wording

treatment interventions that they're receiving. And this is one of the rooms? Yeah, so that's

Similar wording

an example of a vocational area that we would have. Occupational therapists would be utilizing

Similar wording

that area as well um for you know a variety of different interventions from gross to you know

Similar wording

um motor skill use and so forth and i know at one of the community meetings someone mentioned this

Similar wording

looks kind of like the police touch museum inside but there is a serious purpose to this correct

Similar wording

there is absolutely thank you okay um that's your presentation right that's as far as mr

Similar wording

of an algrace testimony um if there's questions that the board has questions on the board

Similar wording

no i i don't have a question i guess i just want to say i worked this was one of my projects when

Similar wording

we first did it at p michael i was just ready to say what a beautiful building by the way what a

Similar wording

wonderful building if if you live long enough they redo all your but i'm glad to see the adaptive

Similar wording

the reuse for this facility because I know it was a long time that PHA had been looking

Similar wording

to get somebody to come in and acquire that building once we sort of did the consolidation

Similar wording

of the apartments on Ridge Avenue, so it's great.

Similar wording

departments on ridge avenue so it's great i'll tell you that building always looked great when

Similar wording