civus
Hearing audio

ZBA Hearing - March 17, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Mar 17, 20261h 54m

i'm going to stop sharing my screen so i can just open up our exhibits to look at the refusals

Similar wording

chair i have a hand up from taylor de la pena oh she she's also a pathway so she may she could

Similar wording

also be promoted and can answer this question i think what happened is that um this is um what

Similar wording

was shown um earlier and there's been some tweaks as i mentioned on the proviso plan so i think

Similar wording

uh taylor could address those and she's there let's bring her up thank you

Similar wording

i saw her

Similar wording

but now she she was promoted briefly and now i don't see her

Similar wording

looks like there may be someone else under taylor's name this that's been promoted

Similar wording

sure yeah i i think maybe it's one of those situations where someone clicked on the zoom

Similar wording

like if whoever okay so whoever it is let's identify them okay i'm not i'm just not seeing

Similar wording

her name showing as a it's there the person under taylor de la pena can you please unmute

Similar wording

and identify yourself we can see you we can't hear you because you're muted this is dennis

Similar wording

kurek oh there thank you sir could you please state your name and spell it for the stenographer

Similar wording

uh it's dennis d-e-n-n-i-s kurek k-u-r-e-k right do you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth nothing but the truth i do all right so council we have three different projects we're

Similar wording

voting on could you just break down the three projects and tell us what we have okay thank

Similar wording

you i apologize for the the confusion dennis if you could just based on the updated plans that

Similar wording

we've already provided if you could just state the number of units on each site address yeah thank

Similar wording

you for 1409 to 11 is seven dwelling units well let me ask you do you have the plans there could

Similar wording

you just put the plans up and then it'll be easier for you to talk about it right yeah I can share my

Similar wording

screen why don't you do that back again I mean I don't know if these are yeah so that's that look

Similar wording

right dennis yes i see seven dwelling units yeah yes so 1409 to 11 has seven dwelling units okay

Similar wording

and 16 this is the next one that happens that is just just for so we understand better sure

Similar wording

say they have six could you just show us it what it looks like a little bit

Similar wording

i mean let we can at least see it i can um go to this sorry

Similar wording

i mean let we can at least say it i can um go to this sorry um this image

Similar wording

um there we go

Similar wording

this is the 1409 to 1411 north 17 right and this has six or seven residential units say that again

Similar wording

six or seven seven um that's what the refusal says okay yeah and then um 14 but for you but but

Similar wording

david let's figure this out i mean you at least got to show the plans you see what i'm saying

Similar wording

you've got seven units i mean are there six on one four two and just show the plans right

Similar wording

yes i mean we at least i mean look i'm not we're not going to get microscopes with this but we just

Similar wording

want to at least see what oh no problem i um let me let me grab those from i think they're in the

Similar wording

exhibit pack in the meantime uh fawn if you have those handy ipotes that weren't in this um we had

Similar wording

the elevations but give me a second to look at the um exhibit packet and and if you could promote

Similar wording

fun uh wong who's the architect uh they're being promoted to the endless thank you

Similar wording

do you have the floor plans available to to review

Similar wording

yes okay are you able to share your screen hold hold hold hold could you please state

Similar wording

your name and spell for the stenographer my name is fine wong uh f-a-n w-a-n-g do you

Similar wording

swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth I do please proceed

Similar wording

counsel thank you fun are you able to share your screen with the floor plans for the three properties

Similar wording

yes give me one minute

Similar wording

thank you I apologize for the delay

Similar wording

so let me share

Similar wording

So we're at 1409 right now.

Similar wording

Can you see?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

So this is the floor plan of 1409 and 1411.

Similar wording

Total units is seven units.

Similar wording

we have uh flats over flat um we have

Similar wording

two apartments on the first floor um let me know if you need me to go into them

Similar wording

could you could you just orient the board um where the entrance is please

Similar wording

actually could you just stop zooming in and zooming out if it's just like in one place

Similar wording

it to be easier to read yes okay thank you so just why don't you zoom all the way out so it's

Similar wording

we're able to see everything yeah thank you and then give a high level overview of where the

Similar wording

entrance is and then yeah thank you yeah this door location if you can see where my hand is

Similar wording

that's the main entrance into the building we have a central corridor and stairway

Similar wording

On the first floor, there are two units, three bedroom accessible units, as well as

Similar wording

a one bedroom accessible units. They each have their own individual entrances.

Similar wording

When you go up the stairs, we have two additional units on the second floor.

Similar wording

Just zoom in slightly. There are two bedroom apartments with kitchens, bathrooms, individual amenities for each apartment.

Similar wording

When we go up the third floor, the total stories are three. So we have three stories for this building.

Similar wording

Third floor, we have another three apartments, excuse me, two apartments, so we have a one-by-room

Similar wording

So we have a one-by-room apartments at the top through this door, and then we have another two bedrooms.

Similar wording

apartments

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, do you have any questions about this property, or should we show the floor plan for the next property?

Similar wording

Well, is there anybody had any quick questions about this?

Similar wording

Yeah, where's the seventh unit?

Similar wording

It looks like there's three units on the third floor.

Similar wording

It looks like there's three one-by-room units.

Similar wording

Sorry.

Similar wording

let me correct myself on the third floor there are three units what's in the basement there's

Similar wording

no basement all right it's on slab okay hit a rear yard sorry rear your rear yard rear yard

Similar wording

it's in the back of the building so let me go back to the floor the first floor we have a

Similar wording

access door facing the sidewalk on uh on the 17th street and through that

Similar wording

access corridor we can walk through the next to the building to the rear yard

Similar wording

so everybody has access to the rear yard correct thank you yeah it's and just if it's helped when

Similar wording

we when we're done showing these i do have a separate plan that shows the rear yard more

Similar wording

clearly it's it meets code all right can we move on to the second property yes so the next one

Similar wording

is 1441 to 43 north 17th street uh go ahead if you want to just walk through the board the

Similar wording

through the plans with the board as you did with the first one please

Similar wording

So 1441 to 1443, we have the similar layout. The main entrance is also through the main

Similar wording

entrance door along North 17th Street. You walk into a central hallway with the stairway

Similar wording

to the upper floors. On the first floor, we have all the accessible units for mobile disability

Similar wording

residents. This unit is three bedroom accessible units. So that's one unit and then at the

Similar wording

end of the corridor there's another one bedroom accessible units. When we walk up to the second

Similar wording

floor we have another two units. At the plan south we have two bedroom units with entrance here.

Similar wording

The other half of the floor we have another two bedroom units.

Similar wording

So that's a total of four units on the second and the first floor.

Similar wording

on the

Similar wording

on the third floor

Similar wording

is the same layout as the second floor

Similar wording

so we have another

Similar wording

two bedrooms

Similar wording

two bedrooms on the third floor

Similar wording

total six

Similar wording

units

Similar wording

on 1441

Similar wording

to 1443

Similar wording

just the correction

Similar wording

it looks like every unit that you said was two bedrooms

Similar wording

is three bedrooms

Similar wording

on both the second floor and the first floor so it does it looks like you've got a one bedroom

Similar wording

unit and a three bedroom unit on the first floor and then two three bedroom units on the second

Similar wording

floor and two three bedroom units on the third floor is that right okay we have two three bedrooms

Similar wording

on the second and the third floors and it looks like there's one three bedroom on the first floor

Similar wording

the excess correct all right so why don't we move the number three just for an overview

Similar wording

thank you the third property is 16 16 24 jefferson yeah 16 24 to 26 jefferson

Similar wording

so this is 16 24 to 16 26 jefferson street

Similar wording

Also a similar layout, we have the main entrance along Jefferson Street, going into a main corridor, also a central stairwell.

Similar wording

On the first floor, we have a two-bedroom apartment unit.

Similar wording

and on the upper portion of the first floor plan we have another two baron units. So total

Similar wording

we have another two-bedroom units.

Similar wording

So total, two two-bedroom units on the first floor.

Similar wording

On the second floor, when we go up the stairs,

Similar wording

we have two units.

Similar wording

The first unit is a two-bedroom apartment unit.

Similar wording

And then on the upper part of the floor plan,

Similar wording

we have another two-bedroom units.

Similar wording

On the third floor, we have three units, total of three units on the third floor.

Similar wording

We have a one-bedroom here, another one-bedroom in the middle.

Similar wording

Also the third one-bedroom is here, so total of three one-bedroom units on the third floor.

Similar wording

total seven units on the lot of 16 why don't we take questions from all for anybody have any

Similar wording

questions about the project a few questions um i think my first question is understanding that

Similar wording

the first floor at each of these is supposed to be fully accessible but it looks like

Similar wording

you've got just enough hallway to get a wheelchair through what's going to be the plan for

Similar wording

packages

Similar wording

for the entire building.

Similar wording

Well, I would just imagine

Similar wording

somebody, you know, I know what it was like in every

Similar wording

apartment building, even in my own house,

Similar wording

and you get a bunch of Amazon packages

Similar wording

and all of a sudden your accessible path is

Similar wording

blocked. What's going

Similar wording

to be the kind of management plan

Similar wording

for these units

Similar wording

in the public

Similar wording

space?

Similar wording

So we have mailboxes

Similar wording

If I want you to answer that, and then I'll let Christine answer as well.

Similar wording

So go ahead, Ms. Wong.

Similar wording

We have mailboxes outside of the building.

Similar wording

That's for the USPS delivery, and there's a parcel box associated with the mailbox.

Similar wording

And if the mail delivery is through USPS, the parcel can be stored in the mailbox that's

Similar wording

outside.

Similar wording

I will let Christine speak.

Similar wording

I think there's a plan for a multi-family, I mean, multi-delivery carrier storage locker.

Similar wording

Christine?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Go ahead.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

There is.

Similar wording

We've had extensive conversations and we're looking, we haven't picked a model yet, but

Similar wording

we're going to, in front of the buildings, have the type that has an electronic code

Similar wording

lock for the residents where Amazon can put a package or UPS can put a package.

Similar wording

Our intention is not to have packages lying willy-nilly around the apartment units.

Similar wording

Okay, that's my first question. My second question is about trash storage. I know this

Similar wording

is the notated plan and there's lots of notes on it, but it didn't look like

Similar wording

there's a dedicated trash closet in any of the units. I saw a closet for almost

Similar wording

everything else and so just want to know what's going to be the like week to week before trash

Similar wording

pickup day storage or maintenance for trash on site so we did plan for trash uh at the back of

Similar wording

the building trying to find a better plan we you can see there's concrete pavement and there will

Similar wording

be trash container located at the rear yard of each building, the residents will drop

Similar wording

their trash at the container in the back, and the maintenance staff will be able to pull

Similar wording

the container to the front during the trash collection days for collection.

Similar wording

And then are tenants going to have access to both doors, the main door and I guess that

Similar wording

pathway door to the rear yard where the meters are everybody has access to both correct okay

Similar wording

other questions questions from our attorney um i just wanted to note that the the floor plans and

Similar wording

i'm not sure if this site plan that's being shown with the trash enclosure was submitted either so

Similar wording

if if you would like these included for the record um they would need to be submitted by

Similar wording

like close of business tomorrow since they weren't previously sent thank you questions or comments

Similar wording

from the virtual audience uh Mr. chair I'm I'm sorry to interrupt may I just briefly discuss

Similar wording

the variances at issue just for the record sure thank you I can go very quickly I appreciate it

Similar wording

um Ms. Wong if you could please stop sharing your screen I appreciate it thank you I just

Similar wording

thank you i just wanted to you know cover uh these are their parking variances at issue so i just

Similar wording

wanted to you know cover uh these are their parking variances at issue so I just wanted to

Similar wording

wanted to mention it um so as as previously discussed uh pathways uh heard feedback from

Similar wording

mention it.

Similar wording

the community about a desire for more multiple bedroom units which resulted in three of the

Similar wording

properties including these larger unit sizes including as you just saw two buildings with

Similar wording

seven units and one with six units they triggered with these larger units a technical requirement

Similar wording

for a small amount of vehicular parking connected with the location within the north central

Similar wording

philadelphia overlay district so two one and two parking spaces are technically required

Similar wording

and none are proposed due to the very small lots and row home design in the context of

Similar wording

existing buildings in the neighborhood and the designs obviously are meant to maximize the

Similar wording

amount of of livable space and avoid the creation of curb cuts which would also result in the loss

Similar wording

of on-street parking. The variance is very minor in the context of this affordable housing

Similar wording

development. Pathways does not anticipate that many residents will have cars. The area is well

Similar wording

served by public transit. I won't list all of the various regional rail and broad street line and

Similar wording

buses that serve the area. The properties are unique, narrow properties without adequate space

Similar wording

for curb cut, as I mentioned, and compliance with the code's parking requirements would, in this

Similar wording

case cause an unnecessary hardship. The proposed signage, sorry, the proposed variances represent

Similar wording

the least modification possible to the relevant code provisions. And this is, as you've seen, I

Similar wording

hope, a great project for the area that will provide a lot of needed affordable housing. So

Similar wording

and we appreciate all the support from the community and the council office. So I just

Similar wording

wanted to wrap that up and mention that. So thank you for your time. Thank you. So we're going to

Similar wording

vote these uh three of them separately so first one m oh i thought i did public testimony please

Similar wording

chair do not see any hands raised for the matter amy boy with the planning commission

Similar wording

this testimony will be for all three cases thank you the comprehensive plan recommends

Similar wording