civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 25, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 25, 20248h 45m

He is now speaking.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

Hello.

Similar wording

Hi, could you state your name and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

Yes, I am Otabek Mohamedo, O-T-A-B-E-K, my last name M-A-K-H-A-M-E-D-O-V.

Similar wording

Right, do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

What case are you involved with, sir?

Similar wording

11707 Stevens Road Philadelphia Pennsylvania 19116 okay are you are you prepared to go on today sir

Similar wording

yes okay so what tell me why your hands up I mean I'm going to call your case shortly okay

Similar wording

okay okay all right and when you when you when I call your case you're gonna have to come on the

Similar wording

screen right you're gonna have to go on video all right okay i'll call your case shortly

Similar wording

thank you okay any other requests for continuance

Similar wording

also also i have a case here mi 2024 002 747 3265 south 61st street devin logan is the applicant

Similar wording

and SRA Incorporated

Similar wording

is the listed owner.

Similar wording

No exhibits first listing.

Similar wording

Devin Logan, SRA Inc.

Similar wording

Devin Logan,

Similar wording

raise your hand.

Similar wording

Chair, I have a hand raised

Similar wording

with a phone number

Similar wording

1415-412-8255.

Similar wording

bring them on all right they're allowed to talk hi could you state your name please and spell for

Similar wording

the stenographer yeah jason meyers json m as in mary y ers i'm the one having issues rejoining

Similar wording

the zoom link i know i i i have to wait your case is going to be called next i have to handle this

Similar wording

particular case i have now okay so you're going to hear me call you in a little bit okay

Similar wording

Is there anyone here from 3265 South 61st Street?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

okay so there's i'm sorry chair we have a craig melodosian with their hand raised

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

yeah well he would yeah and craig you've already been sworn so just state your name for the record

Similar wording

craig melodosian i just wanted to indicate to the board that

Similar wording

uh the rcos have had no contact from this applicant at this time

Similar wording

Okay. Councilperson Gauthier has sent a note saying the same thing.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

So, MI 2024-002-747-3265-61st Street. This is the first listing. This case will be continued. Mark must be heard. Thank you.

Similar wording

We're going to start with number four. MI2024-002-621-1428 Hope Street. Jason Myers is the listed owner. Mr. Myers.

Similar wording

Yes, good evening.

Similar wording

Good evening, Mr. Myers. Could you state your name and I'll swear you in?

Similar wording

Jason Myers. Can you spell it?

Similar wording

I think we're okay with that

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

The whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

Yes

Similar wording

Mr. Myers are you prepared to present your case

Similar wording

I am over the phone

Similar wording

Yeah I don't have my visuals

Similar wording

Because I can't get into the zoom

Similar wording

But my case is pretty straightforward in my opinion

Similar wording

Yeah but we'd have to see it

Similar wording

I can't hear your case without seeing your visuals

Similar wording

Yes Mr. Joe

Similar wording

I did try to

Similar wording

I did try to send Mr. Myers a direct panelist link for the Zoom.

Similar wording

Unfortunately, he was unable to open it.

Similar wording

Mr. Myers, we unfortunately have to have a hearing, and we have to be able to see your exhibits.

Similar wording

We cannot handle this over email.

Similar wording

So, unfortunately, we will need to reschedule your case.

Similar wording

The staff will work with you to get you.

Similar wording

I know the staff will work with you to get you back as soon as they can.

Similar wording

so just keep an eye on your email and the staff will be in touch with you and i'm sorry for the

Similar wording

inconvenience number four mi 2024 002 621 1428 hope street that case has been continued

Similar wording

okay we're gonna

Similar wording

i'm gonna start with one all right hillary

Similar wording

um hold on one second mr chair um if you could actually do number six next that is another

Similar wording

thank you mi 2024 002 798 11707 stephens road amas alaydon

Similar wording

there's a letter of support from somerton civic association

Similar wording

and a letter of non-opposition from council member o'neill

Similar wording

good evening could you state your name i think i already swore you in am i correct sir

Similar wording

yes yes all right could you uh share your go on your video and share your screen

Similar wording

is that mr meyers

Similar wording

it looks like Mr. Myers was able to get on Mr. Chair

Similar wording

Mr. Myers can we just come back to you in a second since we're already started on the next case

Similar wording

no problem thank you yeah he's

Similar wording

we cannot share the screen because somebody else in the screen

Similar wording

his screen is

Similar wording

already being shared right Hillary Mr. Myers no one is

Similar wording

sharing their screen right now

Similar wording

Yeah, we don't have the ability to share the screen with you guys.

Similar wording

You need to.

Similar wording

Where's our tech guy?

Similar wording

Yes, excuse me.

Similar wording

He's still in the attendees.

Similar wording

Let me.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Take him up.

Similar wording

Hold on one second.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

He'll be rejoining as a panel shortly.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

sir

Similar wording

uh this is my appeal for uh copy okay we see it yes not so refusal

Similar wording

keep moving that's your application for appeal we're good

Similar wording

Project Information Forum. Yeah.

Similar wording

project information forum yeah

Similar wording

Indeed. Indeed, yes.

Similar wording

Check to get off the clearance zoning board.

Similar wording

You're posting? Yeah. Posting sticker.

Similar wording

Notes from zoning applicants.

Similar wording

what's in civic association

Similar wording

tell us what tell us first of all what tell us what you're trying to do

Similar wording

why don't you do that first show us the pictures first and tell us what you're trying to do

Similar wording

excuse me i'm here i'm here just to help him with the english sir

Similar wording

well you can't we you can't do that he has to do it himself we had to know that beforehand sir

Similar wording

yes i i change it guys you want you you're so what you're trying to do is is to close your

Similar wording

garage up? Yes. And you're going to want to park your car outside instead of in the garage,

Similar wording

am I correct? Yes, outside. And tell me why are you closing your garage off?

Similar wording

My car is big and it's not fixed. You want to have, you're making your apartment bigger?

Similar wording

and I need a room

Similar wording

for my parents

Similar wording

making a room for your parents

Similar wording

in the garage

Similar wording

let me ask you how many other houses

Similar wording

on the block have done that

Similar wording

did you hear my question

Similar wording

yeah can you repeat

Similar wording

are there other houses on the block

Similar wording

who have closed their garage up yet you know how many uh i don't know

Similar wording

you went to the somerton civic association i correct yes let me ask you do you have a drawing

Similar wording

of what you're putting in the garage what what the room's going to look like are you putting

Similar wording

plumbing in there, bathroom? Tell me what you're doing there.

Similar wording

Just

Similar wording

Gibson board. I put

Similar wording

Gibson board. Putting the kitchen in there?

Similar wording

No. Does it sound like you said

Similar wording

drywall, gypsum board? Drywall. Oh, gypsum board. Okay.

Similar wording

And you're just having a room, right? I mean,

Similar wording

you're going to let your parents live in the garage?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And you went to the Somerton Civic Association

Similar wording

and voted 12, 4, and 10 against.

Similar wording

Am I correct?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Do you have anything else there to show us?

Similar wording

No, I don't know.

Similar wording

questions from the board yeah i don't know how we make a decision on without seeing plans for this

Similar wording

i mean to close it off a garage and making it a room i don't know and for your parents and

Similar wording

i can't you know what is their bathroom down there out what's that's you know big chips

Similar wording

that's an elevation and that's fine but we don't know what's happening on the inside i don't i

Similar wording

don't know how we make it there's nothing inside you already done that you've already done it yes

Similar wording

that's that there's there's no bathroom there's nothing else there but that

Similar wording

no

Similar wording

there's no other bathroom

Similar wording

or anything in the basement

Similar wording

yeah there is

Similar wording

one bathroom which is originally

Similar wording

in the basement

Similar wording

so there's a powder

Similar wording

what's the rest of the basement look like i mean i this is like the this is a duplex right

Similar wording

no so single home and but that there's nothing else on the first floor there the garage level

Similar wording

right yes what's what's there sir

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

What's what's there, sir?

Similar wording

He's telling you what is in the first.

Similar wording

Excuse me, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

I think that we may need to resume this matter with an interpreter.

Similar wording

I agree.

Similar wording

I agree.

Similar wording

Sir, what language do you need an interpreter for?

Similar wording

Uzbek language.

Similar wording

Uzbek?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So we're going to continue the case and get you an interpreter.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And have some plans we can look at.

Similar wording

I mean, I don't know how we feel.

Similar wording

There's a person there that can talk to them.

Similar wording

We've got to see what the rest of the downstairs looks like.

Similar wording

I mean, it's.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So MI 2024-002-798-11707, Stevens Road.

Similar wording

The case is continued.

Similar wording

and uh mr chair uh yes uh mr chair um just going back uh mr myers i'm sorry i misspoke

Similar wording

um because we already continued this case we have to wait wait to hear it again we will

Similar wording

mr myers we will put this on next week at 2 p.m okay uh all right i i'm sorry but because we

Similar wording

already continued it and people may have left, we can't bring it back. So we have to continue

Similar wording

until next week at 2 p.m. So you'll get some follow-up information from the staff. We do

Similar wording

apologize for the inconvenience and you will be able to get on the right Zoom at 2 o'clock next

Similar wording

week. All right. Thank you for your patience. Number one, MI 2023-006-254-648 North Udall

Similar wording

Street. Henry Clinton is the attorney. Chair, they will be coming back in as a panelist.

Similar wording

good evening mr chairman members of the board mr clinton you've already been sworn could you

Similar wording

just state your name for the record sure henry clinton c-l-i-n-t-o-n could you identify your

Similar wording

client relationship to the property sure jeffrey jones he's the principal of jones

Similar wording

these properties, and he is on the call

Similar wording

along with his wife.

Similar wording

You stipulate to the

Similar wording

reading of the refusal,

Similar wording

and you agree with the accuracy?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

And we have a letter of opposition

Similar wording

from HMC Squared,

Similar wording

and we have a petition

Similar wording

of support with 25 signatures

Similar wording

and eight letters of support

Similar wording

from neighbors.

Similar wording

Why don't you begin?

Similar wording