civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - February 10, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Feb 10, 20218h 33m

I'm sorry. What was that, Pauline?

Similar wording

Oh, I'm sorry. We're live now. I just went to 3-2-1. We're good.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

I think attendees are starting to come in.

Similar wording

Okay. We'll give you a few minutes, Yvette, and then you'll let us know when you're ready.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

reminder only promote those who are presenting open up audio for people who just need to speak

Similar wording

okay okay good morning tanya how are you good to hear your voice good morning fearless leader

Similar wording

oh god you must be talking to carol not me

Similar wording

we're ready to go chair thank you very much good morning again everyone my name is frank

Similar wording

de chico i'm the chair of the zoning board of adjustment i'll be participating in today's

Similar wording

hearing along with our vice chair miss carol denari board secretary confessor plaza and board

Similar wording

members Mr. Thomas Holloman and Mr. James Snell. Board Administrator Yvonne Benton and

Similar wording

Board Attorney Sharon Saleta are also in attendance. For those of you who haven't yet participated

Similar wording

in one of our virtual hearings, I'll go through some of the basics of what you can expect.

Similar wording

First we will be administering oaths to individual participants prior to their testimony. Second

Similar wording

we'd like to advise everyone that this proceeding is being recorded and that by participating you

Similar wording

acknowledge your agreement to be recorded and when this recording will be available to the

Similar wording

public on the web or otherwise third for anyone participating by phone if you wish to testify

Similar wording

you must raise your hand by hitting star nine and then star six to unmute yourself

Similar wording

I'll repeat for anyone participating by phone if you wish to testify you must raise your hand by

Similar wording

hitting star nine and then star six to unmute yourself finally to enter an appearance statement

Similar wording

call google 267-270-5548 and leave your email address and the address of the property at issue

Similar wording

I will repeat, to enter an appearance statement, call Google 267-270-5548 and leave your email address and the address of the property at issue.

Similar wording

And I would also like to remind everyone that please do not attempt to testify in the chat.

Similar wording

Any comments should be directed to our board administrator, Ms. Yvonne Benton.

Similar wording

uh with that i will read off a list of cases that have been uh requested to either be withdrawn or

Similar wording

continued uh after i get done reading we'll ask if anyone has any concern with the request for

Similar wording

continuance and then we will ask if there are any further requests sorry no

Similar wording

all right you you do that drink yeah mi 2020-002610

Similar wording

1254 sydney street is withdrawn number five on our list mi 2020-002439

Similar wording

2401 North 33rd Street is continued. Number seven on our list MI 2020-002-420

Similar wording

2549 North 32nd Street is continued. MI 2020-002-421-3110 West York Street is continued.

Similar wording

Number 11 on our list, MI 2020-000299-4363 Main Street is continued.

Similar wording

Number 15 on our list, MI 2020-000108-5000 North 12th Street is continued.

Similar wording

and I believe that is those are all the cases that we have asked that have been asked to be

Similar wording

continued or withdrawn. If anyone disagrees with any of those cases please raise your hand at this

Similar wording

time no hands at this time chair thank you we'll now entertain any other requests for continuance

Similar wording

Other requests for continuance or withdrawals, please raise your hand at this time.

Similar wording

or with continuances or withdrawals please

Similar wording

If you're requesting a continuance or withdrawal and has not been already read into the record,

Similar wording

please raise your hand at this time.

Similar wording

No hands at this time, Chair.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

okay i believe with that we can begin carol okay two on our list

Similar wording

uh do what about the uh oh the add-ons i'm sorry the add-ons okay the add-on calendar number

Similar wording

0296 810 north 12th street i didn't participate in the original hearing i will not be voting

Similar wording

on this consideration for a reconsideration issue.

Similar wording

Xin Jin is the applicant.

Similar wording

We are not, this is simply a vote on the request

Similar wording

to reconsider and rehear the case.

Similar wording

They won't be presenting argument.

Similar wording

Okay, my vote is yes to reconsider and rehear.

Similar wording

Yes, reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Yes, to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Yes, to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Okay, now with that, we can go to number two

Similar wording

on our regular list, Carol.

Similar wording

Okay, calendar number 0340, 1530 West Champlist.

Similar wording

Madam Vice Chair, does it say who the attorney is on that?

Similar wording

no it does not it looks like it might be a pro se

Similar wording

it is the property owner's names are

Similar wording

Andrew and Andrea Walker yes okay and we've also received a letter from or an email from Charles

Similar wording

Richardson on this which I will in a moment send to the board Andrew Walker you've been promoted

Similar wording

to panelists you may uh put your case forward now sure mr walker yes can you put your name

Similar wording

and address on the record please and spell your last name where you put that instead

Similar wording

mr walker can you hear me yes on the answer yes can you put your name and address on the record

Similar wording

please and spell your last name andrew walker andrew walker a-n-d-r-e my last name is w-a-l-k-e-r

Similar wording

first name she's just the last name okay excuse me before you begin um can i remind the board that

Similar wording

you did this morning receive i forwarded by email um the rco's letter on this matter with attachments

Similar wording

yes we did

Similar wording

sir do you swear or affirm to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

you may proceed

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

good morning mr chairman members of the board

Similar wording

My name is Andrea Walker.

Similar wording

Andrea needs to be sworn in as well.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Do you swear for him to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth, Mrs. Walker?

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

Thank you. You may proceed.

Similar wording

My name is Andrea Walker. This is my husband, Andrew Walker.

Similar wording

Sorry, I'm a little nervous, but please bear with me as I present our project.

Similar wording

In this project, we will show the following.

Similar wording

uh a refusal we're not seeing your screen ma'am you need okay share your screen with us please

Similar wording

share screen okay

Similar wording

it's in the uh i'm sorry ma'am do you see the share screen button along the bottom

Similar wording

yes ma'am okay great you click that it's in here um this one

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

it's a refusal letter are you seeing that

Similar wording

yes oh no i'm sorry we see no i think you need to open it

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

It is open. I opened it.

Similar wording

Just a minute.

Similar wording

Do you have more than one screen?

Similar wording

No, I only have one screen. I'm only on one laptop. No, I don't have more than one screen.

Similar wording

We see your Explorer window where you have a list of your files.

Similar wording

Oh, I need to take that off. Okay. All right. Give me one second. All right.

Similar wording

Share screen.

Similar wording

This one. Are you seeing it now?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you. So that's our refusal letter.

Similar wording

We also have a project information form.

Similar wording

am i going too fast no okay we have a deed for the property

Similar wording

this is the certificate of um tax clearance

Similar wording

and this is the uh plans for the property

Similar wording

i'm sorry madam chair um sharon did you look at the tax clearance

Similar wording

oh good it appears as though it's not the zoning board's tax clear

Similar wording

um i will look the property up now on the revenue site

Similar wording

thank you

Similar wording

should i continue

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

i'm sorry um i'm also this is the side picture

Similar wording

uh i'm gonna can you rotate yeah okay thank you

Similar wording

that's the side picture

Similar wording

this is also

Similar wording

uh these are the side pictures this is the side

Similar wording

These are the posted zone in picture.

Similar wording

These are the impacted neighbors.

Similar wording

These are the petitions.

Similar wording

It's going to be two copies.

Similar wording

This first copy wasn't showing too good.

Similar wording

so I redo it and put another and that's why we ended up with two copies in there.

Similar wording

Excuse me, this is Sharon Saleta. I checked and the property is tax compliant.

Similar wording

Thank you, Sharon.

Similar wording

You're welcome.

Similar wording

these are the list of contents and these are the um the other clearer copy of the um petitions

Similar wording

and the rc the rco did not have a regular meeting um they proposed some questions and answers

Similar wording

some questions and these are the answers that we provided could you rotate that yes sir

Similar wording

You can see a little bit.

Similar wording

You can see a little more.

Similar wording

More today.

Similar wording

And this proof of distribution.

Similar wording

and i'm early this morning received a letter from the rco stating that they did not

Similar wording

um approve of the project however there was no vote for that letter

Similar wording

and we do have member um impacted members i promise to come on here to

Similar wording

speak on our behalf and could you go back to the

Similar wording

did you go back to the uh beginning and uh i'd like to see the drawings the floor plans the plans

Similar wording

oh right here okay yeah should you rotate that yes sir

Similar wording

to the left uh is that first floor ground floor what is the you have to scroll up a little bit

Similar wording

I can't see, no the other way. Oh the other way, okay. Chain link fence, that's

Similar wording

third story not used, existing steel.

Similar wording

Ground floor, going through this.

Similar wording

what was this what was the what was this property used as in the past was it a restaurant

Similar wording

um sir i know it was a church sir but we bought it as is so i think there was trying

Similar wording

they have different um settings in there i know it was a church once and before the church it

Similar wording

was something else i know and the dining room and all the kitchen equipment was pre-existing

Similar wording

when you bought it as is yeah we bought it as equipment um some of them is hers but some was

Similar wording

there yeah the furniture is we we um just put our front the furniture is in there a quick question

Similar wording

do you propose entertainment no no sir thank you

Similar wording

any other questions from the board no no all right anyone else like to testify in this case

Similar wording

if so please raise your hand

Similar wording

we have charles richardson chair good morning mr richardson you can speak now

Similar wording

good morning mr chair members of the board

Similar wording

charles richardson from the office of councilwoman cindy bass room 312 city hall

Similar wording

Do Richardson, you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you, sir. Please proceed.

Similar wording

Councilwoman has opposition to this proposal.

Similar wording

RCO did send a letter this morning stating their opposition to the proposal.

Similar wording

They're citing the immediate neighbors, the residential nature of the block, the apartment facility right next door with special needs,

Similar wording

that there's not sufficient parking for the number of patrons that they probably would incur,

Similar wording

uh no accommodations for dumpster no access for trash pickup uh steps are hazardous and then they

Similar wording

also feel that the uh steps might end up being a place where people loiter

Similar wording

uh there's already a high crime in the area uh producing a threat to safe walkable access

Similar wording

And they also cite that there's more appropriate commercial corridor access about a block away.

Similar wording

So the Councilwoman is opposed based on the opposition of the RCO.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Anyone else like to testify in this case, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

Chair, we have a Dennis Lee.

Similar wording

Mr. Lee, you've been unmuted.

Similar wording

You can speak now.

Similar wording

Excuse me, this is Sharon Saleta.

Similar wording

I also noted that Sandra brought us from the RCO is present.

Similar wording

Mr. Lee, please identify yourself for the record, name and address.

Similar wording

I'm sorry, Mr. Chair, I raised my hand.

Similar wording

I'm sorry, Mr. Chair, I raised my hand inadvertently. I'm not testifying.

Similar wording

No problem.

Similar wording

Thank you. Anyone else would like to testify in this case, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

Chair, we have a Juanita Gatewood. Ms. Gatewood, you are muted. You can speak now.

Similar wording

Morning, Ms. Gatewood. Please identify yourself with a record name and address.

Similar wording

Spell your last name.

Similar wording

Good morning. Can I be heard? Can you hear me?

Similar wording

Yes. Good morning. My name is Juanita Gatewood. I'm the community representative for the 17th Ward 13th Division. My address is 1516 Roseland Street.

Similar wording

Ms. Gatewood, do you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes. Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Thank you. Please proceed.

Similar wording

Okay, as I stated, I'm the community representative for the 17th Ward 13th Division, which covers the zone in which this area is being held, this in question.

Similar wording

I am speaking on behalf of the numerous concerned neighbors who have contacted me, along with fellow neighbors for the 1500 block of Champlst and 1500 block of Roseland, where I reside.

Similar wording

We are opposed to this idea, a facility being open in such a congested area, residential area, which has already been noted for growing high crime area.

Similar wording

It's congested in reference to parking and it's a bus route as well.

Similar wording

and due to the pandemic curbside services would be hazardous for pickups you know what I'm saying

Similar wording

this adds to concern issues of laudering and as I previously stated we've had an uproar and

Similar wording

crime around it that's just something that we you know are trying to work on there are numerous

Similar wording

eateries already around the facility and the trash and the smell in the area in reference to trash

Similar wording

pickup collection or whatever it would be it would just be too congested and with all due respect to

Similar wording

Mr. and Mrs. Walker I haven't seen anything noted for questions concerning um the community I never

Similar wording