civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - February 10, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Feb 10, 20218h 33m

Share screen.

Similar wording

Is there?

Similar wording

When you hover your mouse along the way, do you see the green button that says share screen?

Similar wording

Yep, okay, green, share screen.

Similar wording

and if you click that

Similar wording

we haven't difficult to

Similar wording

okay we're going to have to

Similar wording

continue this to another date we have a date

Similar wording

Tanya or Yvette March 3rd

Similar wording

3.30. March 3rd. Okay. MI 2020-002-454. 441 East Mentor Street is continued to March the 3rd at 3.30 p.m.

Similar wording

Ms. Iona, you need to have someone with you who could work your computer so we can see the exhibits, okay?

Similar wording

Ms. Iona, you need to have someone with you who could work your...

Similar wording

And, Chair, if I could mention something as well?

Similar wording

Be my guest.

Similar wording

Luz, please be mindful that you shouldn't, before March 3rd, submit your exhibit package with everything to the ZBA box as well as to the attorney, Sharon Saleta.

Similar wording

you will get new posters to put up you have to put them up please be mindful you must adhere

Similar wording

to the information in the posters okay if you have any questions you can send an email to the

Similar wording

rco box and we'll help you excuse me this is sharon i have one more question can you confirm

Similar wording

that you are the property owner no your property owner is next to me

Similar wording

I have a property owners next to him. Jacqueline Torres is the

Similar wording

Jacqueline Torres is the property owner is that correct? Yes. Yeah. So she hasn't spoken at all

Similar wording

yet. Who who is Luz? What does Luz have to do with the property? I'm making the application.

Similar wording

you know what no no no okay all right so when we come back on the third the property owner

Similar wording

will make the presentation unless she decides to uh retain an attorney if she doesn't have a lawyer

Similar wording

the property owner is the one person who will need to testify okay all right okay thank you

Similar wording

Thank you. Calendar number 0718-6066 Vine Street. There are no exhibits, and this was previously listed twice.

Similar wording

Is there anyone here for 6066 Vine Street?

Similar wording

I don't see any hands at this time, Chair.

Similar wording

Thank you. MI2020-000718-6066 Vine Street. My vote is to dismiss.

Similar wording

My vote is to dismiss.

Similar wording

Dismiss.

Similar wording

Dismiss.

Similar wording

Calendar number 0086-6606 Woodland Avenue.

Similar wording

Property owner is Karen Gleason.

Similar wording

She does not have a copy of the refusal.

Similar wording

Ms. Gleason, you can unmute yourself and speak.

Similar wording

Good evening, everyone.

Similar wording

I know everyone's tired.

Similar wording

Hi, please put your name and address on the record, please.

Similar wording

Karen Gleason, 806 Longhaker Boulevard, Yaden, PA, 19050.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I did.

Similar wording

And have you emailed the exhibit packet with proof of ownership, tax compliance, refusal,

Similar wording

plans and photos of the property five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

and have you met with the RCO and do you have a letter? Yes. You may proceed. I'm sorry to

Similar wording

interject again. Yvette, can you promote her as a panelist? She will be presenting.

Similar wording

Okay. I apologize for that. She's been promoted to panelist.

Similar wording

Okay, Karen, you may proceed.

Similar wording

Ms. Gleason?

Similar wording

Now she's muted.

Similar wording

It was going.

Similar wording

It was clocking and clocking and clocking.

Similar wording

I don't know what happened.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Okay, you may proceed.

Similar wording

Rejoining me.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I do have a copy of the refusal.

Similar wording

okay can you share your screen sure um now i don't know how to work this i i do apologize

Similar wording

it's okay i'm not i'm not familiar with any of this but i don't worry karen we'll work it through

Similar wording

for you so if you're looking at your computer or on the zoom do you see a green button that

Similar wording

says share screen yes i did click on it it didn't show up oh no so when you click that right then

Similar wording

you go to the actual file you want us to look at and click that. And it should share it. Okay.

Similar wording

There we go. It's coming up for us. Okay. Okay. I'm so, I'm trying to get through this really

Similar wording

quickly. Everyone, I know you're tired and I appreciate your time. So this is the refusal.

Similar wording

Can you see it? Yes. Yes. Okay. Do you want me to proceed or? Yes. Okay.

Similar wording

Yes. Okay. Um, I am, um, the owner of 6606 with an avenue. I purchased a property property back in 2000, February, 2003. I would like to, it's a three story building. Um, I would like to convert it from, it was used to be two apartments and four rooms.

Similar wording

I am the owner of 6606 Willanair.

Similar wording

I want to do three individual apartments for multifamily.

Similar wording

But I was told it's zone RSA 3, and I would like to get a zone RSA 5 for multifamily dwelling.

Similar wording

I'm not doing anything else to the structure, only the redoing the floor plan inside.

Similar wording

That's it.

Similar wording

Nothing else will be done to the building.

Similar wording

Do you have any photographs or exhibits?

Similar wording

i do have some photographs now how do i get to them because i had them all up to make sure

Similar wording

this is the floor plan that i have um for the three apartments the first floor second floor

Similar wording

and third floor each one will be a two-bedroom apartment with um with a laundry room with

Similar wording

laundry facility. And I can give you some pictures. I did have all this. I had all this

Similar wording

ready and waiting as I sat there, waited. I'm sorry guys. I'm just waiting for the photo to

Similar wording

come up. This is the corner of across the street, the 66th street. This is just a photo to show you

Similar wording

that it is a commercial corridor it has commercial property is in the middle of a commercial

Similar wording

corridor here and I do have

Similar wording

okay I'm fumbling

Similar wording

here we go this is a picture of the property

Similar wording

The property right here where I'm showing you is the actual property.

Similar wording

On the side of it is a twin, attached twin.

Similar wording

And each one of these are multifamily use.

Similar wording

And on the side of the house, on the side, it's like a breezeway.

Similar wording

And then it's other, it's another structures like this.

Similar wording

It's six other structures going down in the same format.

Similar wording

And they're all multi-use.

Similar wording

This is the picture of the block where to show that is the commercial is commercial

Similar wording

at the bottom and apartments at the top.

Similar wording

And it's right here on the one with an avenue where it has the 11 trolley runs right past

Similar wording

the property and again as you can see it's all um commercial use with apartments or things like that

Similar wording

at the top any questions or should i tell you anything else or well currently it's a vacant

Similar wording

building yes it is and how long ago did you purchase this 2003 when i purchased a property

Similar wording

um i purchased it where i had the first floor was a room with a bathroom and a one-bedroom

Similar wording

apartment the second floor was three rooms in a bathroom and the third floor was a two-bedroom

Similar wording

apartment and it has been vacant now for approximately eight years

Similar wording

questions from the board no

Similar wording

no would anyone else like to testify in this case please raise your hand

Similar wording

Hello, Mr. Chair, we have Mr. Craig Melodosian here.

Similar wording

Yeah, I was waiting for that. Okay. Mr. Melodosian, please identify yourself with a record and

Similar wording

I'll swear you in.

Similar wording

Good evening, board.

Similar wording

Good evening, Board. Craig Melodosian, M-E-L-I-D-O-S-I-A-N.

Similar wording

Craig Melodosian, M-E-L-I-D.

Similar wording

Ward 40, Republican RCO, Coordinating RCO, P.O. Box 33355, Philadelphia, 9142.

Similar wording

You swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you. Please proceed.

Similar wording

I'm going to refer to my notes.

Similar wording

I'm tired at this point.

Similar wording

I don't know how you guys are doing it.

Similar wording

We do it for the money.

Similar wording

We do it for the money.

Similar wording

It's a big paying job.

Similar wording

Oh, I do it for the life.

Similar wording

It's a big thing.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

To summarize the letter of support that the Consortium of Southwest RCO sent in,

Similar wording

the application is for a three-family dwelling.

Similar wording

We support that.

Similar wording

We also support without the minimum accessory parking of three spaces.

Similar wording

The subject property is a semi-detached twin. As indicated before, it's RSA 3, sits on the 6700 block of Woodland, which is part of the Woodland Avenue Commercial Corridor.

Similar wording

The south block face, which it's situated upon, is 60% CMX2, 40% RSA3. Across the street, the north face is approximately 70% CMX2, 30% RM1, all with street-level retail commercial uses.

Similar wording

We believe the conversion of the vacant single-family dwelling is in the best interest of the vibrancy of the commercial corridor.

Similar wording

It will produce three new two-bedroom apartments, which are immediately accessible to the Scepter Route 11 trolley.

Similar wording

Additionally, the rehabilitation of the building should stabilize the usability of the eastern-attached twin.

Similar wording

Our experience during the year of 2020 on the same block with the demolition of 6614 Woodland Avenue is one that adversely has impacted the integrity of 6612 Woodland Avenue's western and northern elevations.

Similar wording

The implementation of the repurposing of the subject property would preclude a repeat of the problems at 6612 through 14 Woodland Avenue.

Similar wording

Further, the applicant is a graduate of the Jumpstart Southwest program conducted by the Southwest CDC to educate and encourage community members to develop real estate for their and our local community's betterment.

Similar wording

Thus, our support of the applicant is a further step towards realizing Jumpstart Southwest community beneficial goals.

Similar wording

A publicized community Zoom meeting was conducted on Monday of this week.

Similar wording

Three RCOs in attendance were supportive of it.

Similar wording

We had two people in opposition, individuals, simple as that.

Similar wording

We had two other individuals with no opposition.

Similar wording

We had one individual with support.

Similar wording

As indicated, the three participating RCOs are in support.

Similar wording

Thank you very much. Thank you. Anyone else to testify in this case? Please raise your hand.

Similar wording

No, the answer this time, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Thank you, Jason. Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Good evening. Ariel DiLiberto here from the City Planning Commission.

Similar wording

This property is in a residential single-family district. The property is on a commercial corridor

Similar wording

and along the trolley line. We have no opposition to the granting experience. MI 2020-000086

Similar wording

660 Woodland Avenue. My vote is yes. My vote is yes. My vote is yes. My vote is yes.

Similar wording

thank you i believe you're right concludes the 3 30 list

Similar wording

and this is the latest i've ever been here in four years oh you should have been here six years ago

Similar wording