civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 17, 2023

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 17, 20237h 55m

Again, the board granted reconsideration on its own grounds primarily because, again, a determination was made that the neighbors and the community did not get an adequate chance to express their concerns.

Similar wording

As far as the incident that took place over Mother's Day, that was presented for the purpose of indicating that the neighbor's concerns about safety and nighttime activities at the location are founded.

Similar wording

And again, somebody could have gone back and, you know, if you want, you can keep the record open.

Similar wording

I can go back and get CAD reports for the neighborhood going back several years prior to the zoning board that could have been presented and that the neighbors didn't have an opportunity to present.

Similar wording

So, again, the incident, it's not a new thing.

Similar wording

As far as new evidence, and again, we don't believe that the zoning board is restricted to simply new or evidence that, you know, should have, I mean, courts remand cases all the time to take in new evidence.

Similar wording

So, and with respect to this, we don't believe that the board was made aware of the fact of the numbers of people on the petition in favor of the project being so far away.

Similar wording

And you can simply, we would simply ask the board to re-examine the petitions and you can take judicial notice of where the addresses are in relation to the subject property.

Similar wording

so and again we think that's that's fairly self-evident um but again and i i do want to

Similar wording

say in terms of things that the board can take judicial notice of what the permitted uses are

Similar wording

in cmx1 uh you can have adult care family child care group child care library religious assembly

Similar wording

safety services transit station building uh antennas you could have uh the board knows that

Similar wording

these are all the things that the applicant did not explore he mentioned a bodega okay they don't

Similar wording

want to have a bodega did they explore business and professional offices sole practitioner group

Similar wording

practitioner government office well that's not going to happen building supplies and equipment

Similar wording

consumer goods uh food beverage pet supplies all these things were ignored mr chair the zoning

Similar wording

to go the zoning board no they can't hear you again i'm sorry i was muted because i was speaking

Similar wording

over mr reuter and my apologies the zoning board knows the code there's absolutely zero new evidence

Similar wording

zero new testimony do you have anything new here there's nothing burn burn please

Similar wording

Leonard, do you have anything else?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Hillary, should we open up for public testimony?

Similar wording

I actually don't think that we need to at this point because we have taken particular.

Similar wording

Do we need the planning commission to make another comment?

Similar wording

We can ask the planning commission if they have another comment, but I think given that the scope of the hearing was limited to people who hadn't previously testified,

Similar wording

and we ask for lists in advance.

Similar wording

We do not need to take public testimony.

Similar wording

And I can just state again, as I did,

Similar wording

that the Planning Commission recommendation

Similar wording

hasn't changed.

Similar wording

There's nothing to add to that.

Similar wording

Again, no new testimony here today.

Similar wording

Okay. All right.

Similar wording

So obviously, we've heard a lot today.

Similar wording

So we're going to take this to executive session next week.

Similar wording

And Hillary, will you do this at the 2 o'clock meeting?

Similar wording

The add-on?

Similar wording

Yes, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

We'll do this 2 o'clock next Wednesday, and we'll vote in public, okay?

Similar wording

And thank both of you for your comments.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Is there anyone in the audience whose 330 case has not been called?

Similar wording

I see no handshake.

Similar wording

Thank you, everybody.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

We don't usually go this late, but I do appreciate everybody.

Similar wording

Thank you. I just appreciate everybody hanging around.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording