Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA STATED MEETING Via Microsoft Teams Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Thursday, November 19, 2020 10:12 a.m. PRESENT: COUNCIL PRESIDENT DARRELL L. CLARKE COUNCILWOMAN CINDY BASS COUNCILWOMAN KENDRA BROOKS COUNCILMAN ALLAN DOMB COUNCILWOMAN JAMIE GAUTHIER COUNCILWOMAN KATHERINE GILMORE RICHARDSON COUNCILMAN DEREK S. GREEN COUNCILWOMAN HELEN GYM COUNCILMAN BOBBY HENON COUNCILMAN KENYATTA JOHNSON COUNCILMAN CURTIS JONES, JR. COUNCILMAN DAVID OH COUNCILMAN BRIAN J. O'NEILL COUNCILWOMAN CHERELLE L. PARKER COUNCILWOMAN MARIA D. QUINONES-SANCHEZ COUNCILMAN MARK SQUILLA COUNCILMAN ISAIAH THOMAS MICHAEL A. DECKER, CHIEF CLERK Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Good morning. We're going to get started. I understand the state law currently requires that the following announcement be made at the beginning of every remote Council session: Due to the current public health emergency, City Council is currently meeting remotely. We are using Microsoft Teams to make this remote meeting possible. Instructions for how the public may view the meeting and offer public comment are included in the Stated Meeting notice that was published in the Daily News, Inquirer, Legal Intelligencer prior to the meeting, and can also be found on PHLCouncil.com. I now note that the hour has come. The Clerk will please call the roll to take attendance, and members that are in attendance will please indicate that you are present when your name is called. Thank you very much. Mr. Decker. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Good morning, Mr. President, colleagues, and the viewing public. I am present.
Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues. I'm present.
Good morning, Council President and colleagues and the viewing public.
Good morning, Council President. Good Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 morning, colleagues. Happy to be here today.
Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues. And good morning, Philadelphia.
Good morning, Council President. Good morning, members of Council. And good morning to the viewing public.
Good morning, Council President, and good morning, colleagues.
Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues.
Good morning, Mr. President. Good morning, Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 morning, Philadelphia.
Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues.
Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Good morning, Council President and colleagues. Present.
Good morning. Good morning to you all. We have established a quorum. We will now come to order. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 great need, there will be no invocation today. We will, however, observe a very brief moment of silent prayer for our city, its leaders, and citizens during the current public health crisis. And I can't emphasize enough to everyone, please be safe. Please follow the safety guidelines that have been established. Let's have a brief moment of silence. (Moment of silence.)
Thank you very much. Our next order of business is the approval of the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, November 12th, 2020, and the Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, November 12th, 2020 be approved. (Duly seconded.)
Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 been moved and properly seconded that the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, November 12th, 2020 stand approved. All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and our Journal is approved. And our next order of business is requests for leaves of absence, and the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.
Thank you, Mr. President. On behalf of the members of Council, there are no requests for leaves of absence today.
The Chair thanks the Councilwoman. And our next order of business is communications. Mr. Decker, would you Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 from the Mayor and any other communications that you may have in your possession.
To the President and members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia, I am submitting herewith for the consideration of your honorable body an ordinance amending Section 12-701 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Bicycle Lanes," by authorizing the Department of Streets to designate a bicycle lane, in the southbound direction, on North 8th Street, from Vine Street to Race Street, and to remove a travel lane, in the southbound direction, on North 8th Street, from Vine Street to Race Street; and An ordinance authorizing the Procurement Commissioner to enter into agreements to purchase electricity, natural gas and motor fuel for use by the City in City facilities and vehicles, including agreements that obligate payment for delivery of such energy Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 supplies in future fiscal years; and An ordinance amending Chapter 19-1300 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Real Estate Taxes," by clarifying definitions to provide that new construction containing a certain combination of residential dwelling units with commercial or industrial units shall be deemed residential construction for purpose of the tax abatements available under that chapter; and An ordinance authorizing the Procurement Department, on behalf of the City, to enter into an amendment agreement with Axon Enterprises, Incorporated for purchase of tasers by the City, all under certain terms and conditions.
Thank you, Mr. Decker. Our next order of business is the introduction of bills and resolutions. By way of a reminder, we are asking that all resolutions, Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 including privileged resolutions, be placed on the Final Passage Calendar for the next session of Council, unless they are being referred to committee. In our current remote environment, this procedure will provide an appropriate opportunity for public comment. I want to thank you very much in advance for your anticipated cooperation. We'll do a little something different. The Clerk will please read the titles of the legislation that is being offered today by the members.
Councilwoman Parker offers three bills and two resolutions. On behalf of Council President Clarke, she offers an ordinance amending Chapter 19-1300 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Real Estate Taxes," by modifying the amount of certain tax abatements; and An ordinance authorizing the Procurement Commissioner to enter into agreements to purchase electricity, Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 natural gas and motor fuel for use by the City in City facilities and vehicles, including agreements that obligate payment for delivery of such energy supplies in future fiscal years; and An ordinance authorizing the Procurement Department, on behalf of the City, to enter into an amendment agreement with Axon Enterprises, Incorporated for purchase of tasers by the City. Also for Council President Clarke, a resolution recognizing and honoring the dedicated and loyal service of Marcel S. Pratt, Esquire. And on her own behalf, Councilwoman Parker offers a resolution authorizing the Committee on Commerce and Economic Development to hold hearings on the state of Philadelphia's neighborhood commercial corridors.
Mr. Decker, I just want to do something a little different, and I'll ask my Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 colleagues to please indulge me. I rarely ask for such indulgence. I would like to speak on a particular bill that was introduced on my behalf by Councilwoman Parker. So to keep along with the time-honored tradition of Council, I would have to, I guess, virtually step down as the Chair in order to give my comments. So I would ask Councilwoman Parker to virtually take the Chair for a moment so I may speak on this particular bill. Again, I ask my colleagues to please indulge me. I rarely do this. So I'll ask for your indulgence in terms of the time. Councilwoman Parker, can you please take the virtual Chair while I make these comments on the bill that I introduced.
Thank you, Mr. President. The Chair recognizes Councilmember Darrell Clarke from the Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 mighty Fifth Councilmanic District.
Wow. Folks, I just want to let you know, I didn't ask for such a very awesome introduction, but I thank you. Thank you so much, Councilwoman. So real quick, I'll try to be as quick as possible, but for me to do this, I've only done it a couple of times, but it is something that I am passionate about. Over the last couple of years, we in Council have been looking at issues as it relates to our neighborhoods and the continued changes in our neighborhoods, the continued concerns about gentrification, the continued concerns about lack of investment, the continued concerns about opportunity in our communities at-large. We have attempted to do something for the last couple years, as last year we actually introduced a construction tax that would in our minds Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 put a significant amount of stimulus -I'd like to call it what it is -- in our local economy, particularly as it relates to opportunities for neighborhoods. Unfortunately, last year we were not able to get that done, so as you all know, we introduced a construction tax bill again this year, and it is before us as soon as we determine to have a public hearing. Today, we introduced legislation that reduces the tax abatement on commercial tax abatement, and essentially it is a comparable number when you look at the dollar figure as to the one percent construction tax. It is an option based on multiple conversations that I've had with individuals, particularly individuals from the industry with respect to concerns about one thing or another. But I have to say that I'm very concerned about the level of conversation that we've had over the last couple of Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 months, and I know all of you have talked to a different person, and I want to say that I'm disappointed in the pushback in the need and the willingness to do something to make sure that our entire city benefits in a meaningful way to keep pace with the significant market-rate development that has been happening in our communities and the concerns about not only gentrification but the concerns about lack of opportunity. Those opportunities and those disparities have been magnified as a result of the pandemic and the recent unrest, and a lot of people have recognized it, things that a lot of us have known for a long, long time. I mean, this is not new. People have been challenged for a long, long time. And when you talk about those disparities, you talk about an increasing wealth gap. You talk about a decrease in lack of opportunities. As things become more challenged in the country, those opportunities become more challenging for Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 those that have not traditionally had those opportunities. So during these conversations in our attempts to stimulate our local economy -- because, frankly speaking, as much as we like to think that the federal administration, President-elect Biden and Mitch McConnell will hopefully hold hands and gleefully walk down the primrose path, the likelihood that that may or may not happen is very uncertain. So as that conversation happened, I want to start off by saying I really want to thank the BIA, the Building Industry Association, for their longstanding tradition of having a conversation and having significant input. I also want to thank Ryan Boyer. Ryan has stood out as a person that has been willing to have conversation, understand the need to invest in our communities broadly, and there was a couple of other individuals from the industries whose name I won't say at this Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 point. But during that conversation, there was a number of things that were said to me.
I'll just give you a couple, and I know we're in the middle of the session, so I will be as brief as I can, and I'm not going to say no matter how long it takes, as my mentor used to say. We talked about -- they talked about some say that we're picking on one particular industry, the development industry, and I'm like, well, you know, I hear what you say, but others might say, well, why does that particular industry get so much incentives over the course of the year? And I'll lay out some of those tax incentives and other opportunities that they've gotten over the years. And we understand the need to increase opportunity in development and real estate across the City, because it does stimulate a local market. Then some say the economic impact on that industry is devastating. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 I actually heard that yesterday on call, and I don't think people understand the devastation that has happened in these neighborhoods across the City of Philadelphia way, way before the pandemic, and it's much more devastating because you're starting at a much lower threshold. Then they talked about -- there was a conversation about looking at the jobs and the new development in these communities. It was such a great thing, but the simple reality is that a lot of these communities, the people in those communities aren't getting the jobs. The people in those communities are not getting an opportunity to live in the new developments, because they are way priced too high. So the benefit to those local people is just not there. So as we move ahead, let's talk about the industry. And I did not want to do this, as I indicated to the individuals that I know and have worked Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 with for a long, long time, but the fact of the matter is, this particular industry over the years has gotten significant and lucrative benefits. Keystone Opportunity Zones, and on the surface you say, well, that's a great thing, but there are limited requirements in those Keystone Opportunities, such as being able to require participation levels that all of us would like to see, to require certain things that small businesses would like to get as a result of that, the lack of flexibility, the ten-year tax abatement. Again, limited requirements as it relates to that. The state fashioned a bill, and we appreciated it because we asked for it, but the reality is is that there are limitations in terms of what we can require for a person or developer to take advantage of that ten-year tax abatement, such as participation, such as local hiring, and such as local purchasing. We can't require that. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 The most recent entity -- and, again, I pointed this out to the members from the industry that were continuing to push back on any opportunity for them to have skin in the game and to deal with these neighborhoods -- the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, very lucrative tax breaks for the real estate developers, and this is one that I didn't know the level of specificity as it relates to the incentives, so this is not my words. So in the contract to American homeowners and contracts, which actually all of you if you own a home, you've noticed that your exemptions have dwindled significantly, your ability to write off certain taxes. You may have seen in your paycheck in the Tax Act of 2017 that your taxes have gone up because of the category that you find yourselves in, but as a result, in an estimate issued by the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation, four new tax breaks will result in a stunning $66 billion windfall for Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 real estate developers.
These new tax breaks include $30 billion windfall for new passthrough in real estate dividend deductions, $16 billion windfall for real estate exemption for limitations on interest deduction, $22 billion windfall for real estate exemption from like-kind exchange repeal. This also includes the capital gains tax breaks for the developers who build in Opportunity Zones. And you'll see across the City buildings reaching up to the sky. They're in Opportunity Zones, where those zones get substantially reduced capital gains tax and eliminates them on any profit from the sale of property they own for ten years. I mean, this is some extremely lucrative tax breaks that this industry has gotten on top of what we've done on the local level. So my concern is when we ask for them to simply put a little bit of skin in the game to help us rebuild our Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 communities across the City -- and it's not just affordable housing, it's investment in neighborhoods, formerly choice investments, it's investment in the people, it's providing real jobs for real people in neighborhoods -- we're getting all this pushback. So, Madam Chair, I just want to say thank you all for your indulgence, because I don't do this, but I am very passionate about this issue, and I hope in speaking not only to you, colleagues, because you've been real good about understanding the need, but to the individuals who may be listening to this from the industry, that they need to step to the plate and be supportive of what we're trying to do, because this is a local stimulus. This is not a CARES Act where we have to beg the Senate and the House and the President to enact. This is something that we can do locally. So I ask all parties involved, all parties in impact, to be serious Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 about this, to step up to the plate, put some skin in the game, and allow us to borrow $400 million under the Neighborhood Preservation Initiative and get this movement in the City of Philadelphia. So, Madam Chair, thank you again. Sorry for taking so long, but I really needed to say this, and I promise I won't do it again during the course of the year.
Thank you, Councilmember Clarke. I am now stepping down off the rostrum. It will take me a few seconds. And, Mr. President -Councilman Clarke, I am now back in my seat.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Council Majority Leader Parker. Sorry about that, but I needed to say that, and I needed to say it in a meaningful way. Mr. Decker, can you please read Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 those again so I can make sure that I refer those bills and resolutions to the appropriate entity.
Yes, because I don't think I referred them to committee.
On behalf of Council President Clarke, Councilwoman Parker offers three bills, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 19-1300 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Real Estate Taxes,' by modifying the amount of certain tax abatements."
And an ordinance authorizing the Procurement Commissioner to enter into agreements to purchase electricity, natural gas and motor fuel for use by the City in City facilities and vehicles, including agreements that obligate payment for delivery of such Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 energy supplies in future fiscal years.
And an ordinance authorizing the Procurement Department, on behalf of the City, to enter into an amendment agreement with Axon Enterprises, Incorporated for purchase of tasers by the City.
And also on behalf of Council President Clarke, a resolution recognizing and honoring the dedicated and loyal service of Marcel S. Pratt, Esquire.
And on her own behalf, Councilwoman Parker offers a resolution authorizing the Committee on Commerce and Economic Development to hold hearings on the state of Philadelphia's neighborhood commercial corridors. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Councilwoman Gilmore Richardson offers a resolution declaring the intent to prioritize climate action and environmental justice in the ongoing COVID-19 recovery effort.
Councilman Jones offers five bills, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property, on behalf of the City, to acquire fee simple title, or a lesser interest in real estate, by purchase, dedication, donation, condemnation, agreement in lieu of condemnation, or otherwise, in parcels of land along the Schuylkill River and the Wissahickon Creek for public recreational purposes."
And an ordinance amending Bill No. 010267, entitled "An Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 ordinance establishing a no truck parking regulation on Lancaster Avenue, from Fifty-Second Street to Sixty-Third Street, both sides" to include and establish tow-away regulations for trucks on Lancaster Avenue, from Fifty-Second Street to Sixty-Third Street, both sides.
And an ordinance authorizing the installation of a traffic signal at the intersection of Upland Way and Berks Street.
And an ordinance establishing a no truck park regulation on Parkside Avenue, both sides, from 50th Street to Belmont Avenue, 50th Street, both sides, from Parkside Avenue to Jefferson Street, Jefferson Street, both sides, from 50th Street to its terminus and 49th Street, both sides, from Parkside Avenue to Jefferson Street. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
And an ordinance establishing a no truck park regulation on Henry Avenue, both sides, from Allegheny Avenue to Abbotsford Avenue.
Councilman Johnson offers one resolution authorizing the Committee on Education to hold hearings to examine options for expanding the pipeline of Black male teachers and staff in Philadelphia schools.
That will be on this week's Calendar. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Councilman Domb offers a resolution recognizing Thursday, November 19, 2020 as Children's Grief Awareness Day and honoring the work of Uplift Center for Grieving Children to meet the emotional needs of grieving children in the City of Philadelphia.
Mr. President, Councilman Domb has asked to be recognized on this resolution.
Oh, I'm sorry. The Chair recognizes Councilman Domb.
Thank you, Council President. I wanted to take a moment and first thank the co-sponsors of this resolution. I'd also like to briefly highlight just how important Children's Grief Awareness Day is and honor the work that Uplift is doing day in and day out for our children and families in Philadelphia that are Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 struggling right now and for the last 20 years. Grief and loss of life are two things that are unavoidable in this world, but generally we shield our children from it as much as we can until it actually happens. In Philadelphia and many places all over the country, our children are often suffering in silence, because grief is difficult for everyone, and perhaps the adults in their lives can't manage the grief themselves, so the children's emotional needs get left behind by mistake. In the wake of the loss of life, we forget our children haven't developed the right tools yet, those tools that they need to navigate the difficult feelings that come with grief and loss. So we see kids act out in all sorts of ways, some good and some not so good. Uplift Center for Grieving Children helps provide our children with Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 those emotional tools they need to process the feelings and develop positive ways they can communicate what's going on inside their young minds. In the City of Philadelphia, our children are seeing things others can't even imagine. They're experiencing loss of life due to COVID-19, losses from violence, and especially gun violence, loss of life from substance use disorder and overdoses, and a complete loss of normalcy in their everyday life right now. We have to ensure our kids, our children have the supports they need if we want them to be okay. So Uplift continues to work with our children and families through the Philly HopeLine and referrals from the School District, medical providers in our community members, and I hope everyone here today will join me in recognizing their commitment to our children and appreciate the important work Uplift does to take Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 care of the emotional needs of our young people. For those of you looking for more information on Uplift, you can visit their website, upliftphilly.org, or contact my office for more information. In recognition of Children's Grief Awareness Day, Uplift is hosting an event this evening, tonight, from 6:00 to 7:30 where they'll present a partial viewing of the WPSU, Penn State's public radio, documentary called Speaking Grief. They'll hold a live stream panel discussion thereafter via Facebook and Zoom. Thank you again for everyone's support today, and please, to anyone in the public who is listening or if you know somebody or if you know a child that needs help managing after a loss of a loved one, call our office at 215-686-3414. We'll help you find the resources that you need. This is an important matter. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Thank you very much, Council President.
Thank you, Councilman. That will be on next week's Calendar.
Councilman Domb also offers a resolution honoring and expressing gratitude to the University of Pennsylvania for pledging one hundred million dollars to the School District of Philadelphia over the next decade.
Thank you, Council President. This is a happier one. I want to thank the co-introducer, Councilmember Maria Quinones-Sanchez, who is our Chair of our Education Committee, and all the co-sponsors of this resolution today, Councilmembers Gilmore Richardson, Thomas, Green, Gauthier, and Squilla. As we recognize the University Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 of Pennsylvania for this incredible donation to help Philadelphia's public schools, we have to acknowledge President Amy Gutmann's ambition and determination to go above and beyond and to make Philadelphia a better place for our youth, families, educators, and everyone that is proud to call Philadelphia their home. The City and the School District have been deliberating for years on a financial strategy to address the serious infrastructure needs of our aging schools. Now we're presented with a possible sustainable solution over the next decade that will go a long way, not the full solution, it will go a long way to solving the environmental hazardous conditions inside many of our school buildings. Some of these facilities are more than 70 years old. These facilities are older than me. This is truly a commendable action and donation made by the University of Penn. In fact, it's Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 the single largest donation to the School District ever. It's another prime example, though, of how we will move our City forward through collaborative public-private partnerships, and we need to recognize the efforts that our leaders and our business and education sectors make to improve our city. In my opinion, we don't do enough to honor these individuals and institutions for their efforts to make Philadelphia a better place to live and work. I spoke with President Gutmann yesterday and personally thanked her on behalf of Council for her work and dedication to our schools, and she was actually elated to hear from us, and we have more to do to build more coalitions and partnerships at this time, and so by reaching out, we showed our sincere gratitude. We have so many anchor institutions in our city that are truly Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 unsung leaders that don't seek the public spotlight for doing everything they can to make Philadelphia a first-class city. They provide economic opportunities to many underserved neighborhoods and go above and beyond the call of their own mission to support communities across the entire City. Please always continue to keep our city in your minds and hearts. This is to all Philadelphia residents, businesses, and institutions. Constantly seek ways to help us and go beyond your own mission and put Philadelphia first. With Thanksgiving, Council President, right around the corner and on behalf of all of us in Council, I can't think of a better Thanksgiving present to be bestowed upon the School District than the University of Penn, President Amy Gutmann, Chairman of the Board David L. Cohen providing this tremendous gift of $100 million to the Philadelphia schools. Thank you on behalf of all of Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 us. We really appreciate it. Thank you, Council President.
Thank you, Councilman. Thank you much. That will be on next week's Calendar.
Councilwoman Gauthier offers one bill, entitled "An ordinance authorizing encroachments in the nature of structural artwork consisting of metal manhole covers and traffic signs located in the vicinity of 6200 Osage Avenue, and authorizing the City of Philadelphia to accept ownership of such encroachments.
Councilman Thomas offers, on behalf of Council President Clarke, a resolution honoring and congratulating Ed Hurtt for his work with youth in the community and for being awarded the 76ers Jr. NBA Coach of the Year Award. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
And on his own behalf, Councilman Thomas offers a resolution honoring and congratulating the Northeast High School Boys Soccer team, on their successful 2019-2020 season and overall 12-1 and 1 record in the Philadelphia Public League.
Councilman O'Neill offers one bill, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property, on behalf of the City, to enter into a sublease agreement with the Philadelphia Municipal Authority, for use by the City, of a portion of the premises located at 11311 Roosevelt Boulevard, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania."
Councilman Squilla offers one bill and one Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 resolution, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 12-701 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Bicycle Lanes,' by authorizing the Department of Streets to designate a bicycle lane, in the southbound direction, on North 8th Street, from Vine Street to Race Street, and to remove a travel lane, in the southbound direction, on North 8th Street, from Vine Street to Race Street."
And a resolution proclaiming November as Lung Cancer Awareness Month.
There are no other bills or resolutions being offered by the members, Mr. President.
Thank you very much, Mr. Decker. And our next order of business is reports from committee, and the Chair Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 a report from the Committee of the Whole.
Thank you, Mr. President. The Committee of the Whole reports out seven resolutions with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you. Mr. Decker, please read that report.
To the President and members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia, the Committee of the Whole, to which was referred Resolution No. 200132, entitled a "Resolution appointing Gosia Primavera to the Board of Directors for the Old City Special Services District"; and Resolution No. 200133, entitled a "Resolution appointing Valerie Lyons to the Board of Directors for the Old City Special Services District"; and Resolution No. 200134, entitled a "Resolution appointing Kathryn Bittner Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Directors for the Old City Special Services District"; and Resolution No. 200135, entitled a "Resolution appointing Jonathan Dubrow to the Board of Directors for the Old City Special Services District"; and Resolution No. 200271, entitled a "Resolution appointing Jack Soloff to the Board of Directors of the Center City District"; and Resolution No. 200272, entitled a "Resolution reappointing Randall Scott to the Board of Directors of the Center City District"; and Resolution No. 200567, entitled a "Resolution appointing Angela Val to the Board of Directors of the Center City District," respectfully reports it has considered the same and returns the attached resolutions to Council with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you, Mr. Decker. Resolutions No. 200132, 200133, 200134, 200135, 200271, Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 200272, and 200567 will be placed on our Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. The Chair now recognizes Councilman Johnson for a report from the Committee on Rules.
Thank you, Council President. The Committee on Rules reports out one bill with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you. Mr. Decker, would you please read that report.
The Committee on Rules, to which was referred Bill No. 200416, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Buckius Street (extended), the Delaware River, Orthodox Street (extended), and Richmond Street," respectfully reports it has considered and amended the same and Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 to Council with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Johnson.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution.
Move for the suspension. Councilman Johnson, I just need you to move for the rules of Council to be suspended.
I'm sorry, Council President. Council President, I move for the rules of Council to be suspended to permit first reading of this resolution at the first reading of Council.
And that's Bill No. 200416, and I second your motion, Councilmember Johnson. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill No. 200416. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and the bill will be placed on our First Reading Calendar today. The Chair now recognizes Councilwoman Parker for a report from the Committee on Law and Government.
Thank you, Mr. President. The Committee on Law and Government reports out three bills with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Decker, please read the report.
The Committee on Law and Government, to which was referred Bill No. 200588, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 17 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Contracts and Procurement,' by amending Chapter 17-100, entitled 'Procurement Contracts,' to add disclosure requirements related to prior contracting experience and the demographic characteristics of employees and board members of contractors and subcontractors for City contracts for competitively bid goods"; and Bill No. 200589, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 17-100, entitled 'Procurement Contracts,' by adding requirements related to the provision of information regarding the demographic characteristics of the employees of, and the labor force used by, City contractors and subcontractors in the performance of work under certain Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 bid services"; and Bill No. 200590, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 17 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Contracts and Procurement,' by amending Chapter 17-100, entitled 'Procurement Contracts,' and Chapter 17-1400, entitled 'Non-Competitively Bid Contracts; Financial Assistance,' to add disclosure requirements related to prior contracting experience and the demographic characteristics of employees, other sources of labor, and board members of contractors and subcontractors for City contracts for public works, other competitively bid services, and professional services, and by adding reporting requirements," respectfully reports it has considered and amended the same and returns the attached bills to Council with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Councilwoman Parker.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill Nos. 200588, 200589, and 200590. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bills No. 200588, 200589, and 200590. All those in favor will indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and these bills will be placed on our First Reading Calendar today. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 concludes our reports from committee, and our next order of business is the consideration of the Calendar. I note that the bills just reported from committee with a suspension of the rules have been deemed to have had a first reading. These bills will be placed on our Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. As there are no additional bills on the First Reading Calendar, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker for a motion concerning the bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar today.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the following bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars. They are Nos. 200481, 200387, 200599, 200600, 200182, 200254, 200537, 200539, 200561, Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 200562, 200572, 200591, 200115, 200412, 200420, and 200421. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the bills just read by Councilwoman Parker. All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. The motion carries. And we will consider the Consent Agenda shortly. The Chair again recognizes Councilwoman Parker for the purpose of calling up bills and resolutions on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 2ND READING
Thank you, Mr. President. In addition to the bills being considered on the Consent Agenda, the following resolutions and bills are being called up from the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars today. They are Nos. 200491-A, 200629, 200631, 200632, 200633, 200634, 200637, 200638, 200640, 200093, 200162, 200353, 200544, 200574, and 200425. All other bills and resolutions are being held.
Thank you, Councilwoman. Before we proceed with the consideration of the public comment, I would like to take a brief five- to ten-minute recess to give our technology professionals some time to connect the speakers we have for today to the meeting. We will take a brief recess. (Short recess.)
Thank you very much, and again good Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 morning. So now that everyone is connected to the meeting and before considering the resolutions and bills we have before us today, we will consider public comment as follows: The public comment must concern matters on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar for possible action at a session of Council. A speaker on any of those matters must sign up in order to testify. You must call 215-686-3406 by 5:00 p.m. the day before the session to sign up for public comment. When you call, we will take your name, phone number, the number of the legislative item you are commenting on, and whether you are in support or against the legislation, and we will add you to the list. We will telephone each person on the list during the Council session and invite them to our remote meeting. Under ideal circumstances, they will each have three minutes to speak, Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 but because we have a significant amount of people today, we will have two minutes. In order to be fair to all those wishing to speak, I intend to hold faithfully to the established time limit. Once invited to the meeting and asked to begin your testimony, a timer will be started. We will monitor your remaining time throughout your testimony, and when there are 30 seconds remaining to your time, we will remind you of this. Once your allotted time has passed, you will be asked to conclude your remarks. Shortly thereafter you will be muted and disconnected from the remote meeting. I also reserve the right to limit the number of speakers where repetitious comments are being made on the same matter and to limit the scope of testimony to only certain items on the agenda during the emergency, which could affect callbacks for public comment at the meeting. So please be aware that the Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 public meeting is being recorded. Because the meeting is public, participants and viewers have no reasonable expectation of privacy. So by continuing to be in the meeting, you are consenting to being recorded. I will now ask the Chief Clerk to please read the name of our first speaker.
Mr. Decker, I guess we'll move on and maybe we can reconnect.
Good morning. Thank you. Thank you. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
Thank you very much. Thank you, Council President and members of City Council. My name is Kris Soffa and I'm a member of Toxic Free Philly. We have a quiet public health and environmental justice emergency here and we are sincerely grateful to the Health Committee Chairman Cindy Bass for her leadership as well as to the Health Committee members for your unanimous passage of this bill out of committee. You may know, Toxic Free Philly is a volunteer grassroots advocacy group and we volunteer hundreds of hours for Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 our park systems, our community, and the City, and we are speaking with you today with new information and a relatively easy way the City can pivot to keep us all safe, no matter what our zip code. And we represent a growing coalition of over 28 state, local, and national organizations as well as over 2,600 folks who signed our petition, and you've been provided with a hard copy of the Healthy Outdoor Public Spaces briefing book and over 800 pages of scientific peer-reviewed medical evidence of the dangers of toxic herbicides. So what does this bill (connection interrupted) weeds. It's not really about cash or how we spend it. It's about cancer. It's about public health and fixing environmental and racial injustice. We urge you to let the science drive the policy. It's a free country, and everyone is allowed to make a profit, but we respectfully ask you to choose people Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 over products, which we've been told are safe but now we know they are very dangerous, and we're reminded that they are legal but, sadly, we all know from experience that just because it's legal doesn't mean it's safe, and it's very hard to argue for using our taxpayer dollars to poison our land, our water, and all of us without our permission or knowledge. We see this bill providing the best possible outcome for everyone involved. Thank you.
Yes. Good morning, Doctor. Please state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
Hi. I'm Sarah Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Evans. I'm an Assistant Professor of Environmental Medicine and Public Health at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in New York City. As a public health professional with expertise in children's health and the environment, I, along with my colleagues, advocate against the use of synthetic pesticides in areas where children play, live, and learn, and we support the passage of Bill 200425. We're particularly concerned about the unique vulnerability of children for the health effects of pesticides. Children play close to the ground where pesticides settle. They put their hands in their mouths and breathe more rapidly than adults, increasing inhalational exposures. So it's not surprising that the CDC finds that children have higher levels of pesticides in their bodies than adults. Low levels of exposure that are experienced by the general public have been associated with Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 increased risk of birth defects, asthma, certain cancers, learning behavior problems, and autism. We're also greatly concerned about the impacts of pesticides on children in black communities, who are disproportionately impacted by both harmful exposures and chronic illnesses. The CDC again finds higher pesticide exposures in black and Hispanic individuals. We have several lines of evidence that show toxicity of common herbicides that are used for cosmetic purposes. Glyphosate, the active ingredient in Roundup, is a probable human carcinogen, with recent studies showing an up to 43 percent increase in non-Hodgkin lymphoma in glyphosate applicators. No studies have examined the effects of long-term exposures to glyphosate on children. Because many communities are replacing glyphosate with Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 other herbicides such as 2,4-D, a known neurotoxin and hormone disruptor, and greater than 95 percent of pesticide formulations consist of inert ingredients also classified as respiratory irritants, neurotoxins, and carcinogens, we recommend against the ban on -- we recommend against the use of all cosmetic herbicides in public places. Unfortunately, the common practice of allowing 24 or 72 hours to pass before allowing play on fields is not sufficiently protective. The half life of glyphosate is 47 days. However, some studies estimate it to be as long as 197 days. Likewise, for 2,4-D that half life is ten days in soil. Given the propensity of children to play in soil and the fact that pesticide half life is lengthened by temperature and weather conditions as well as soil and microbial content, it's difficult to accurately predict when safe play can resume. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Children's risk of pesticide exposure and associated harms could easily be mitigated by restricting the use of synthetic herbicides in favor of organic methods proven to be safe and effective. For this reason, we urge you to pass Bill 200425 to protect the health of your most vulnerable constituents. Thank you.
Star six to unmute yourself, Dr. Stern. I see you are on mute.
Yes. Good morning. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Yes. We can hear you. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
Thank you. Dr. Linda Stern. Good morning, President Clarke and members of City Council. Thank you for the opportunity to make public comment on a critical public health issue. My name is Dr. Linda Stern. I strongly support passage of Bill 200425. Medical scientific evidence of harm from herbicides is overwhelming. I know what herbicides can do. Most of my medical career was served at the Philadelphia Veterans Affairs Medical Center where I treated veterans exposed to Agent Orange. The United States government acknowledges 14 diseases that Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 were caused by this herbicide. Yet the Philadelphia Parks Department continues to spray 2,4-D, one of the two active ingredients in Agent Orange, for weed control where children play in parks, on grounds, on ball fields. Acute exposure to 2,4-D can cause coughing, vomiting, loss of muscle coordination, diarrhea, coma, and even death. Over time and at low levels it's been linked to Parkinson's disease, liver disease, reproductive abnormalities, and much more. I'm sorry. Can you folks hear me?
Oh, okay. Fine. Someone told me you could not. Okay. And as you heard, the Parks Department also sprays glyphosate. A 2019 study by the University of Washington showed that glyphosate increased the risk of non-Hodgen's Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 lymphoma by more than 40 percent. Philadelphia is the fourth worst city for asthma in the country. One in four children in West Philadelphia suffer from this disease. There are many causes, but herbicides are proven to be both the cause and a trigger for asthma. There are no established safe levels of herbicides. Health and harms have been demonstrated at very low levels, and they can even be passed to future generations. Golf courses use 47 times the amount of pesticides per acre than agricultural land. A mortality study of golf course operators found elevated levels of cancer, respiratory, and neurological diseases compared to the general public. Anyone on the golf course or nearby is at risk. Herbicides don't stay put. The risk of airborne pesticide particles and dust puts children at particular risk. You have the opportunity to pass legislation to ban the use of toxic Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 herbicides on our public lands. The citizens of Philadelphia deserve no less.
Thank you, Doctor. Thank you for your testimony.
The next speaker is Julie Snell, commenting on 200425. (No response.)
Star six to unmute yourself, Ms. Snell. I see you are still on mute. (No response.)
Okay. Yeah. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony, please.
Thank you. This is Julie Snell. I'm co-founder and principal of a landscape architecture firm in Philadelphia and co-owner and operator of a native plant nursery in Media, Pennsylvania. This bill is an opportunity to examine how we manage public land. This bill is an opportunity to take stock of current authorization and focus on restorative and sustainable practices. It's an opportunity to focus on education and transparency, an opportunity to focus on soil health, vegetation, and water management. Now more than ever, our public landscapes are vital to our health and well-being. Safe and healthy parks, playing fields, natural lands can have a Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 direct impact on the public health. I think we need to start from a premise of a precautionary principle to do no harm, meaning we should do everything we can to eliminate the use of synthetic herbicides and pesticides in our public land. Although I do understand that it's a tool in the toolbox thinking, this tool should not be used as a matter of convenience. The use of synthetic pesticides is more like a surgical instrument. The problem has become the overreliance on this method versus its use as a strategic and targeted means of control after other non-toxic methods have been exhausted. I do think this bill is necessary to shift the overall approach to land care. I also think it won't be successful without the support of PPR. I don't think rushing to add amendments to this bill now would be helpful. Instead, there should be a collaborative and Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 thoughtful process following the passage of this bill where PPR and other experts in the field, not pesticides lobbyists, can develop the new rules to implement land stewardship. I'll close by acknowledging that this effort will require increased funding. Caring for our parks, playing fields, and natural land is skilled work and it has value and it requires investment. Thank you very much.
Good morning. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Yeah, we can hear you.
Oh, wonderful. Thank you. Thank you for this opportunity. My name is Sarah Francis. I'm a resident of the Eighth District. I have worked professionally in the public health, environmental science, and policy fields. For 12 years I've helped manage public lands organically, first in Lower Merion and now here in the Wissahickon. Today I am going to share with you why we're compelled to work in advocacy on this issue. A couple years ago I was visiting Bartram's Garden. I happened upon the gardener spraying a few tendrils of poison. I engaged her and asked her what she was doing. She said she was spraying glyphosate. Even though I maintained a distance of 12 feet, I could still smell the chemical and expressed concern over her lack of protection. She was wearing gloves, but not any protective covering over her nose, mouth, Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 or eyes. I also expressed concern about a group of about a dozen schoolchildren who were currently visiting the garden. They were 20 yards away and downwind, and I could plainly see the toxic chemical spray drifting towards them. I asked the gardener why, instead of spraying them with a known carcinogen, we couldn't teach the children about poison ivy, how to identify it, how to avoid it, and why most people are allergic to it, and then just carefully pull it up, as I have done so many times on the properties that I have managed. She merely shrugged and said this is how they manage it. This is the level of nonchalance with which toxic pesticides are viewed and applied in the City. I testify that Bill No. 200425 will go a long way towards making Philadelphia public grounds safe and healthy, and I strongly urge you to pass it. I recognize that this is an Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 unprecedented time of overlapping crises and extraordinary amount of suffering, but every crisis represents an opportunity for much-needed reform and innovative problem-solving that addresses the root causes of problems, not just the symptoms. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Good morning. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony, please.
Hi. Thank you for your time today. My name is Ryan Dougherty and I'm a community organizer with The Black Institute, a racial justice action think tank based out of Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 New York City, here on behalf of our President, Ms. Bertha Lewis, who is originally from the City of Philadelphia, and we are here today to express our support for Bill No. 200425 and implore the City Council to unanimously pass the healthy outdoor public spaces bill as introduced. As a racial justice organization who has done the analytical research on the use of pesticides in public spaces, The Black Institute knows firsthand the harmful effects these chemicals have on communities of color, specifically children and families. While it is now irrefutable that these herbicides cause cancer and other deadly illnesses, we know statistically that black and brown communities are the ones who disproportionately suffer the most through a report we published entitled "Poison Parks." And whether the pesticide industry or the Parks Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Department decides to recognize it or not, every single time a chemical-based herbicide is sprayed in Philadelphia, environmental racism is being manifested in our communities. Supporting this bill will ensure that our kids are safe when we play in our parks. It will ensure that our drinking water is clean enough to drink, and it will create some semblance of transparency in an industry that has gone unchecked for far too long. We are obviously in a public health crisis compounded by the devastating effects of COVID-19, and now is the time to finally stand up for our black and brown brothers and sisters by banning the use of glyphosate and other toxic herbicides in Philadelphia. It is imperative that the City Council support Bill No. 200425 and commit to the transition towards unique land management in Philadelphia. You have a responsibility to your Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 constituents, and that includes standing up to large corporations for a healthier and toxic free Philly. Thank you for your time.
Yes. Good morning. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony, please.
Good morning, Council President and members, and thank you for the opportunity to testify. My name is Amy Sinden. I'm on the faculty at Temple Law where I teach and publish on environmental law. I'm here to assuage any concerns you might have about the legality of the proposed HOPS ordinance. It's legal. In fact, not only do you Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 have the power to adopt it under the Environmental Rights Amendment to the Pennsylvania Constitution, you have a duty to adopt it. As an exercise of Council's legislative power over municipal functions, your maintenance of City parks and property, this ordinance falls well within your broad police power authority under the Home Rule Charter to protect the health and safety of Philadelphia's citizens. I understand there's been some worry about the HOPS ordinance would be preempted by the Pennsylvania Pesticide Control Act. Those worries are unfounded. The state pesticide law preempts local laws that conflict with it, but there's no conflict here. The state Pesticide Act provides for the registration of pesticides sold in the state of the licensing of private businesses that apply them. The HOPS Act is about the City's maintenance of its Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 own property by its own personnel. It doesn't in any way regulate or restrict the activities of private parties. So that's the first thing. There's no conflict or overlap between the two. But the second is that even if the Pesticide Act did preempt the HOPS ordinance, it would be unconstitutional under Article I, Section 27 of the Pennsylvania Constitution, also known as the Environmental Rights Amendment. That amendment grants the citizens of Pennsylvania the right to clean air, pure water, and the preservation of the environment, and it imposes on all levels of Pennsylvania government, state and local, the fiduciary duties of the trustee to conserve and maintain our public natural resources for the benefit of all Pennsylvanians, including future generations. This is heavy stuff, but the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has not been shy about striking down state statutes Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 that conflict with it, and that includes state statutes that preempt municipalities from passing ordinances aimed at protecting the environment. In fact, the Supreme Court's 2013 decision in Robinson Township versus Commonwealth is particularly on point. In that case, the Supreme Court actually struck down Act 13 passed by the all-powerful natural gas lobby to promote fracking. The court said it was unconstitutional because it commanded municipalities to ignore their obligations under the Environmental Rights Amendment. So, first, there's no preemption because there's no conflict of overlap between the HOPS ordinance and the Pennsylvania Pesticide Act. Second, even if there were any preemptive effect of the state Pesticide Act, it would be unconstitutional. And, finally, under the Environmental Rights Amendment, you actually have an affirmative Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 constitutional duty to pass this ordinance in order to protect the citizens of Philadelphia from the toxic herbicides that are fouling our air and water and threatening the health of our children and grandchildren. Thank you.
Yes, we can hear you. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
Yes. My name is Arthur Frank. President Clarke and members of the City Council, I wish to speak on 200425 as well. By way of my background, I'm a Professor of Public Health and a Professor of Medicine at Drexel Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 University. I have a medical degree with training in internal medicine and occupational and environmental medicine and a Ph.D. degree in biomedical sciences. I've served as a director or a deputy director at two agricultural safety and health centers in this country studying pesticides, and this is an issue that affects communities. And I've served for more than 15 years on the Environmental Justice Advisory Board of the State of Pennsylvania, including about ten years as Chair. We need to recognize that pesticides and herbicides are designed to kill, and not only do they kill plants, but they have hazardous effects on humans. As you heard, glyphosate is a chemical that has been shown to cause cancer, and we need to be careful that this is in fact true in spite of data manipulation by those that market and sell this product, as we have seen over the years with other products like Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 cigarettes, lead paint, and other materials. With regard to 2,4-D, which is also used, that was a significant part of Agent Orange, which has been shown to cause birth defects and, as you've heard, has been a significant factor in the lives of many of our veterans. The City of Philadelphia needs to adopt this bill. It needs to find a safer way to protect our people and our parks. Thank you very much for allowing me to comment.
Yes, we can. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
All right. My name is -- thank you for allowing me to Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 comment on 425. My name is Mark Leibeirt. I'm the County Board Chair of Douglas County, Wisconsin. We manage 287,000 public acres, including parks, parks in the City of Superior as well, and we have had this ordinance in effect for 20 years. Don't be afraid of this ordinance. Your managers can manage their parks with this. In fact, you can challenge them to come up with unique opportunities on how they can actually do what the pesticides used to do. If we can do it on 287,000 acres, we have hundreds of miles of trails, boat launches, parks, day parks, overnight parks, city parks in the City of Superior, and we have been very successful at eliminating herbicides for over 20 years. Your managers will come up with opportunities, and when they're challenged, they will come to the plate and actually find good solutions to the Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 use or non-use of these herbicides and pesticides. Is there any questions that I could answer for you guys on the problems or anything that we've encountered? I'd be glad to give up my time to answer questions.
No. We're good. You go ahead and get your testimony. If there are questions, we'll reach out to you.
Sure. Okay. Well, again, I just want to take away any of the councilors' fears that this is not going to be able to be managed. We've managed it. We have -- we don't allow herbicides, pesticides anywhere on 287,000 acres. Utility right-of-ways, pipeline right-of-ways are all restricted to non-pesticide use for keeping their right-of-ways clear, and we have never been challenged in court. We have been successful in convincing all stakeholders that we're serious about this, and we Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 have been successful. I think that's probably all I can add to you, unless you guys got questions.
No. Thank you very much. We appreciate your testimony.
The next speaker is Michael Froehlich, commenting on 200544.
Good morning, Council President Clarke and City Council. My name is Michael Froehlich and I am the Managing Attorney of Community Legal Services' Homeownership and Consumer Rights Unit, and I am a resident of Councilmember Gauthier's Third District in beautiful West Philadelphia. I am speaking today in strong Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 support of Bill No. 200544, which would curb the most predatory and out-of-control tactic of residential property wholesalers. This is the industry responsible for those ubiquitous "we buy houses" signs that are illegally plastered all over our neighborhoods. Over the past few years, Community Legal Services has seen a sharp increase in the number of homeowners targeted by this industry coming to our office. This bill would include three important consumer protection safeguards. First, this bill would expand our existing do not solicit list, so homeowners could opt out of receiving these solicitations to sell their house. Wholesalers who continue to harass homeowners after being put on notice that a homeowner does not want to be contacted would then be subject to fines. Second, the bill would require wholesalers, like many other professionals operating in the City, to Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 be licensed and to follow a set of ethical guidelines. Third, wholesalers would be required to provide homeowners with a bill of rights and a three-day cooling off period before executing on any contract regarding their home. Many residential property wholesalers use predatory tactics and target our most vulnerable residents, including seniors, to profit from the equity those residents have built over the years. This industry is often most active in our City's rapidly gentrifying neighborhoods where longtime homeowners may not appreciate how much their home may be worth to out-of-town investors, and this bill will help preserve intergenerational wealth and close the racial wealth gap. I'd like to especially thank Councilmember Domb and his staff for championing this legislation. The bill is supported by not just CLS, but by the Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Philadelphia Association of Community Development Corporations, Strawberry Mansion CDC, Asociacion Puertorriquenos en Marcha, CEIBA, and many other community and neighborhood organizations. Finally, I'd like to express my personal appreciation for the Greater Philadelphia Association of Realtors, who not only have supported this legislation but have been a key ally in moving this forward from the very beginning. Thank you.
Yes, we can. Good morning. Just state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
Hello. My name is Daniel Trubman and I'm calling to testify today on Bill 200837 [sic], not Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 because I believe it inappropriate for the Council to establish an advisory board to study Philadelphia parking in streets or the underlying goal of improving the working missions and pay of employees of the parking industry. I'm testifying today because I believe that one policy proposal the bill explicitly instructs the advisory board to study, reduction of the City's parking tax, is misguided. In the year 2020, we must move beyond the idea that the latest well-paying jobs for working-class residents is to cut the taxes of environmentally disruptive industries. It hasn't worked in the past and it won't work tomorrow. Reducing the parking tax would hinder achieving many of the goals this city and indeed many Councilmembers claim to champion. A city that claims to care about addressing climate change and supporting a green new economy doesn't Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 prioritize making parking cheaper. A city that cares about addressing poor air quality and accompanying health problems doesn't further subsidize driving. A city that is striving to achieve Vision Zero where no family has to grieve the loss of a loved one in an automobile crash does not encourage yet more driving. And at a time when the City is facing years of austere budgets, it is especially unconscionable to consider reducing a progressive revenue source that brings in millions of dollars to the City each month. What service does the City envision should be cut even more in the near future for the benefit of drivers? Should more librarians be laid off, more School District employees? Does this Council envision the need for human services or homeless services will decrease in the coming years? And, finally, though likely most germanely, there is little or no Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 reason to believe any of the benefits of abuse in the City's parking tax will be passed along to the workers of the parking industry. Instead, we can be almost certain that all the benefits will be captured by drivers, parking lot and garage companies, and property owners. How could the City of Philadelphia justify, especially in the upcoming difficult years, prioritize giving money back to those who park in the City, many of them who aren't even residents of Philadelphia? How can the City justify giving back money to parking lot and garage companies, many of which aren't based in Philadelphia? And how could the City justify giving money back to landholders, many of whom are land speculators sitting on valuable land instead of building the housing, offices, and other buildings that would greatly benefit the City? Many Philadelphians are already struggling and indeed were already Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 struggling before the current crisis. It's unfathomable the City would prioritize the financial well-being of these moneyed interests. I urge this Council to strike the language instructing the advisory board to consider lowering the City's parking tax before passing this bill. It is incumbent upon the Council to improve the conditions of working-class Philadelphians, including those employed in the parking industry, and for that reason, I believe establishing this advisory board is a worthwhile endeavor, but reducing the City's parking tax is not the solution and it is a proposal that should be tabled. Thank you.
The final speaker today is Queen Judith Robinson, commenting on 200544. QUEEN ROBINSON: Good morning. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020
Good morning. Just state your name for the record. QUEEN ROBINSON: Queen Judith Robinson here speaking on Bill No. 200504 [sic]. I'm a longtime -- I'm a licensed real estate broker. That comes with years of experience, a real estate license, exams, et cetera. It's truly unfortunate that you would try in this bill to elevate wholesalers who come with bandit signs and all kinds of unethical behavior, you would try to elevate them to the level of a professional real estate broker. Where is the Real Estate Commission on this? Where are our trade organizations? You, without asking for any education, no examination and no guidelines, are trying to now elevate some wholesalers, some of them who aren't real estate professionals, to the same level of someone who has to go before the Real Estate Commission with regulations Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 and guidelines. The wholesalers, I can be quite frank with you, are eating our lunch. So I'm trying to figure out how they are legalized with a disclosure statement which doesn't protect the consumer from their unethical behaviors because you still are putting a document, a document in front of -- a legal binding document in front of a homeowner, a property owner who is not aware of what is in front of them. We as brokers have obligation and long term. These folks don't have obligation to negotiate those equity that they're taking out of the people's property. This bill is a dog whistle. I now see -- when you talk about discrimination, I know we're talking about black people catching hell, and I now see Bounce TV has more advertisement of equity investors coming after the black market. So I say, who did you talk to Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 before you convened this bill? Non-professionals along with Community Legal Services. Shame, shame, shame on you. This bill needs to help people, but it doesn't. It tries to elevate paper pushers, and I think the Real Estate Commission should weigh in on this bill before it goes forward. You all usually vote 17 to zero as you do, but I'm going to say as a long-term professional, please listen up. Let's do something that's really going to help the black community, the gentrifying black community, taking their equity from them, using unscrupulous practices. This is a dog whistle, because all of the sudden on Bounce TV they bouncing with that ad over and over again, continuing to heighten people who are unqualified to sell their property without proper information. That's what the problem is here. Now you're going to tell the wholesaler, the paper pusher, with no education, that they can run in front of Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 people now with a $200 fee, and then you charge the Managing Director? Don't they have enough to do to enforce this law here about non-solicitation? You already have non-solicitation laws not being followed. Not being followed. This is a sham here, and you need to be more respectful of people who really are practicing professionals. With that, I'll put a pin in it and respectfully request that you table this and not move forward, because it's not helping the consumer. I'm out here in the venues and I think it's the Wild Wild West, with ignorance on all parts. Have a great day.
There are no other speakers on the public comment list, Mr. President.
Thank you very much, Mr. Decker. We will now consider today's Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 I would ask Mr. Decker to please read the titles of all the bills on the Consent Agenda. After each title is read, any member may object to the inclusion of the bill on the Consent Agenda. Upon such an objection and without debate, the bill will immediately be removed from the Consent Agenda and placed on our regular Final Passage Calendar. Mr. Decker, will you please now read the titles of the bills on the Consent Agenda.
Bill No. 200481, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the Churchview Commons Condominium Association to own and maintain street lighting encroachments along the One Hundred Block of Church Street"; and Bill No. 200387, entitled "An ordinance amending The Philadelphia Code to add a new Section, entitled 'Good Parking Jobs for Philadelphia Review Committee,' to provide for the creation Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 body to consider the quality of jobs and opportunities for workers in the parking industry and the potential to make adjustments to the Parking Tax, including with respect to the goal of reducing the parking tax to seventeen percent by July 1, 2022"; and Bill No. 200599, entitled "An ordinance constituting the Twenty-Fifth Supplemental Ordinance to the Restated General Water and Wastewater Revenue Bond Ordinance of 1989, as supplemented; authorizing the Bond Committee to issue and sell one or more series or subseries of tax-exempt or taxable water and wastewater revenue bonds and revenue refunding bonds, some or all of which may be used for the implementation of a revolving commercial paper program for the System"; and Bill No. 200600, entitled "An ordinance constituting the Twenty-Fourth Supplemental Ordinance to the Restated General Water and Wastewater Revenue Bond Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 1989, as supplemented; authorizing the Bond Committee to issue and sell one or more series or subseries of tax-exempt or taxable water and wastewater revenue bonds and revenue refunding bonds"; and Bill No. 200182, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 12-3000 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Use Of An Automated Red Light Enforcement System To Prevent Red Light Violations,' by authorizing the installation of red light enforcement systems at the intersection of 52nd and Lancaster Avenue"; and Bill No. 200254, entitled "An ordinance establishing a no truck parking regulation on both sides of Milnor Street, from Bleigh Avenue to New State Road"; and Bill No. 200537, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 2 of an Ordinance (Bill No. 180560) approved July 10, 2018, entitled 'An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 portion of City Plan No. 250 by striking from the City Plan and vacating the legally open portion of Montour Street from Adams Avenue to Foulkrod Street,' by extending the period for compliance with the terms and conditions stated therein"; and Bill No. 200539, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 299 by striking from the City Plan Parker Avenue from a point approximately one-hundred fifty-six feet southwest of Matthias Street to its terminus southwestwardly therefrom"; and Bill No. 200561, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 12-3000 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Use Of An Automated Red Light Enforcement System To Prevent Red Light Violations,' by authorizing the installation of red light enforcement systems at the intersection of 31st and Spring Garden Street"; and Bill No. 200562, entitled "An Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Roy, doing business as John Bartram Association, to own and maintain an existing metal bench on the southeast corner at the intersection of South 54th Street and Lindbergh Boulevard"; and Bill No. 200572, entitled "An ordinance establishing a no truck parking regulation on both sides of East Godfrey Avenue from Tabor Avenue to Whitaker Avenue"; and Bill No. 200591, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 9-212 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Newsstands,' by expanding the allowable items newsstands can sell and offer"; and Bill No.
200115, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 10-602 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Smoking,' to prohibit establishments that are excepted from the indoor smoking prohibition from permitting minors to enter, and to require health informational signs; and amending Section 10-614, entitled Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 'Electronic Smoking Devices,' to prohibit establishments that are exempted from the indoor e-cigarette use prohibition from permitting minors to enter, and to require health informational signs"; and Bill No. 200412, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 10-2200 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Hate Crimes,' to provide for penalties for criminal conduct involving misuse of the 911 emergency response system motivated by hatred toward certain characteristics of other persons"; and Bill No. 200420, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 9-800 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Landlord and Tenant,' to address matters related to the landlord and tenant relationship during the novel coronavirus of 2019 pandemic, including providing for the temporary waiver of certain fees"; and Bill No. "
Thank you, Mr. Decker. These bills having been read on two different days, the question for each bill now is shall the bill pass finally. The Clerk shall call the roll, and upon being called, each Councilmember shall vote aye on each of the bills, nay on each of the bills or indicate those bills for which the member is voting aye and those bills for which the member is voting nay. Mr. Decker, please call the roll.
Mr. President, I vote aye on all bills, except No. 200387, on which I've been advised by Ethics to abstain.
Aye on all bills. A majority of all members having voted in the affirmative for each of the bills, the bills on the Consent Agenda are passed. We will now consider the bills and resolutions on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar. Mr. Decker, would you please read the title of Resolution No. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING 200491-A.
A resolution calling on the Kenney administration to develop a plan to be more inclusive of City Council when creating and implementing emergency public safety measures and restrictions.
Thank you very much, Council President. This is a resolution requesting that the Administration develop a plan that is more inclusive of City Council. I do cite that there was a decision in federal court that states that the executive must enact laws in conjunction with the Legislature. That decision has been stayed. It's been appealed, and the decision is stayed pending appeal in the Third Circuit. However, the principle is there that while laws can be made that people don't like, there is a system of checks Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING and balances in our democracy to ensure that there isn't just simply one branch of government doing things that affect people adversely, maybe for their own benefit, that hasn't been vetted through its system of checks and balances. When COVID-19 first broke out, we had emergency measures. We granted emergency -- we didn't grant. We accepted -- we did actually grant emergency powers through resolution. There's a requirement under that code section that these emergency powers be renewed through Council. However, the Law Department tells me that the Administration is going through the Health Code and through the State Health Code, and that's fine. The issue that I have is that during this time, we have gotten past the idea of opening up the Liacouras Center, the Convention Center, and we are well into the issues of COVID-19. We have a better understanding of what it is, and Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING that should inform us. We recently were notified that the Administration was going to brief us on Saturday at 12 o'clock about an announcement it was going to make on Monday for restrictions that were going to take effect on Friday. I had a prior commitment. And, by the way, I already read what the restrictions were, because apparently that was already given to the news and publicized, and I understand that the Administration met with business leaders on a Thursday. And as a Councilmember that represents people in this city, the first opportunity I had to actually weigh in on what I did not know was going to be restrictions taking place on Friday was Saturday at 12 o'clock. I'm asking the Administration to be more inclusive. I will say that I understand that the Health Department, the Health Commissioner is citing a CDC study that says people who tested positive for COVID-19 were twice as Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING likely to have eaten at a restaurant. They are not saying that people who have contracted COVID-19 in Philadelphia were twice as likely to have eaten at a restaurant. They're just saying that -I'm sorry; that did, they did eat at a restaurant. I don't know that there's any data or evidence that people contracted COVID actually ate at a restaurant, but, okay, if we say it's twice as likely, people who have contracted it nationally were twice as likely to have eaten at a restaurant, the same CDC study says if they went to a gym, they're 500 times less likely to get COVID-19 than the average person, 500 times less likely, and that there's no correlation to going to church, to shop, any of those things to an increased risk of COVID-19, yet that's also part of the restrictions. I would like to know, and I don't know, and I think the issue is, is it proper, is it a process of democracy Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING that we have a chance on behalf of the citizens of this city to inquire. In a city where over 50 percent of the people who have died from COVID-19 are African American and they only make up 40 percent of the City, they are dying at a rate 30 percent higher than the Caucasian population. Is it because they go to the gym 30 percent more, eat at restaurants 30 percent more? Like what is -- I am not saying we shouldn't do public safety restrictions.
I'm saying this body should inquire to ensure that the answers are provided to us based on science and data that what we're implementing is correct. What I wonder is this: Does poverty, unemployment, isolation, lack of exercise, an inability to pay rent, loss of business, inability to feed your family, does that contribute? Does that correlate to an increased risk of COVID-19? Because it certainly correlates to an increased risk of health Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING problems, drug addiction, depression, mental health issues. I don't have the answers to those questions, and simply coming out with a list of things not to do that have been done without a vetting of this body is of great concern to me. I am introducing a resolution and requesting that the Administration develop a plan that is more inclusive of this body. I will finally say that I am not clear -- I live 15 minutes from Delaware County, as I often say. I've discovered restaurants and bars in Delaware County while Philadelphia was closed. If I go to a restaurant in Delaware County and sit down and have dinner with my family and come back to Philadelphia, I've still been exposed. The thing about our city is, we are a city and county surrounded by other cities and counties, and I'd like to know the science but, more importantly, I'd Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING like to know that the democratic process is being met in actuality and hopefully voluntarily by the Administration. Thank you very much.
Yeah. Hold on one second, please. I think Councilwoman Gym would like to speak on this resolution.
My point of information, Councilmember Oh, who are the parties to the lawsuit you referred to in your resolution?
I don't know who the parties are. I have the case. I read the case, but I'd have to look at the case again. I believe that the Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING lawsuit was brought by the Republican Legislature. I'm not exactly sure. I think so. And I believe the appeal was brought by the Attorney General of Pennsylvania, and it is, to my knowledge, pending in the Third Circuit, which a stay was granted which allows the Governor to enforce his restrictions until a decision is made by the Third Circuit.
Just a follow-up, Councilmember Oh, you stated in your resolution, and I think you quoted in the resolution, passages from the decision, and you stated that you read the decision, but are not familiar with the parties of the case?
Yeah. Well, let me say this: I've read different portions of the case and I did not look at who the parties were.
I don't think Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING that I did.
Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gym.
Thank you very much, Council President. I just wanted to put on the record that I will be voting no on this resolution. The main body of this resolution references or are rooted in a ruling that should have nothing to do with the title of it. Two-thirds of the resolution, six out of the nine paragraphs, are rooted in a ruling out of the Western District Court that was stayed two weeks later by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals. The Third Circuit, which reinstated Governor Wolf's COVID executive orders, did so on October 1st. I understand my colleague's Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING frustrations with the Mayor's Office about not being fully apprised of important issues, and to be clear, these are frustrations that I can also share, but I cannot support a resolution that uses that frustration as a pretext to advance the flawed and failed logic of a two-week-old ruling that has no level of standing, nor do I endorse irresponsible lawsuits which endanger our city and state and are perpetuated by GOP legislators who have frequently and routinely flaunted COVID rules. In doing so, we are feeding into the hysteria that has resulted in extremist actions, including kidnapping plots, armed demonstrations outside of state capitals or in certain places around the country, and this idea that we should simply upend science and health because we just think we ought to. So, Council President, I appreciate the fact that you have worked hard to get us improved and necessary Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING dialogue between Councilmembers and this Administration, and those should continue, and we should send a clear message individually or in further dialogue and meeting, but this is a place for dialogue. It is not in flawed resolutions that advance other types of ideas, and that is why I will be voting no. Thank you.
Thank you, Councilwoman. I believe Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.
Thank you, Council President. I talked to the sponsor and shared similar concerns as expressed by Councilmember Gym. And I know we do symbolic resolutions all the time, some that I agree with totally, some that I don't, but I also agree with Councilmember Gym that the republicans at the state have been irresponsible, and I'm very concerned about this messaging Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING being tied in to the irresponsibility of our President and our lack for national standards. And we've worked too hard in this body and through your efforts, Council President Clarke, to mask up and send a narrative that's collective and around the items that we agree, and I just think the reference to, again, that lawsuit doesn't really speak to the spirit of this. And I want to ask the bill sponsor to write a resolution that speaks to that clarity. We're going to be in a COVID world for the next 18 months, and if he has some direct suggestions about how we better communicate through a work group, through a process with the Administration around decisions. I don't think that the Health Department should have full discretion. While I respect science, I also understand that how we operationalize directives are important, and as a District Councilmember who has to communicate directly with residents Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING and businesses every day, I want clarity, but I want consistency for them also. So to the bill sponsor, I'm happy to support something that speaks to that and that helps us get through the next 18 months or 24 months as a vaccine comes in, but I don't want to be part of any of the rhetoric that sacrifices people's lives for the economic well-being. And, again, that's not what he's doing, but that is the spirit of some of the other initiatives that we've seen in this city and in the state, but I thank the bill sponsor and agree with him about better communication. Thank you, Mr. President.
Thank you. Councilman Green is next. Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez, I just want to -- I know I'm not supposed to weigh in. I just want to get a little clarity on your request for Councilmember Oh. Was your request specific in nature Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING in terms of possibly holding the bill and doing a bill that's more -
Specific to more focused on a work group, communication recommendations for the Administration and this COVID world that we're operating. That's what I'm requesting of him. I know he introduced this in September. He's held it and didn't want the messaging to get conflicted with the elections and all the partisanship that existed. I just agree with him too much on the communication piece and I don't want that to get lost in this. Thank you.
Thank you. I just wanted a little clarity. Councilman Green, I believe you wanted to...
Yeah. I'll defer to the sponsor if he'd like to respond to Councilmember Maria Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Quinones-Sanchez.
Yes. Yes. Thank you very much. It's not my intention to politicize especially in a partisan way. I did cite the case because it is a case. A decision is a decision, and although the decision has been stayed pending a decision of the Third Circuit, it is a decision. However, I do not have a problem rewriting the resolution, which I think the main point is that I would hope, and quite frankly I would hope voluntarily, that the Administration without a resolution would invite a dialogue with Council and create a process of inclusion. I think the other thing, and I'll just be frank, is, I am drafting an amendment to the City Code, and I was doing the resolution as a way of not having to go through an amendment to the Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING City Code and the state law, where I do believe that that is ultimately what needs to happen. But the resolution I can rewrite in a way that I think since we are a body and we try to, to the best that -- I certainly agree that I would like my colleagues to be comfortable that they can support a resolution requesting an inclusive process in these restrictions and other things that we may agree or disagree, but I think that process is important. So I will hold this resolution and perhaps there will be a double AA later. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Councilman. I wish the General Assembly can take note of how we had this bipartisan breakout right in the middle of our Council session. So thank you for that, and I'm sure all the members would like to weigh in on the subsequent resolution. Thank you. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Thank you all. Next up, Mr. Decker, can you please read the title of 200 -
Excuse me, Mr. President. Councilmember Bass has written in the Chat that she's interested in commenting.
Oh, I'm sorry. It just popped up. I'm a little delayed here. Councilwoman Bass, did you want to comment on it?
Well, you know what, just to be brief, I just really wanted to thank the Councilman. I wanted to echo my concerns as well, but also recognizing that as a member of Council, people expect us to have information before it's out in the press, and so that caused a lot of problems I think for a lot of us, so I certainly Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING understand the sentiment of what Councilman Oh is trying to do. But I think that his willingness to work with his colleagues really just says something about his character in a very, very positive way, and wanted to thank him for being so willing to work with his colleagues. Thank you, Mr. President.
Thank you, Councilman and Councilwoman. I know we've all had our moments when we're a little concerned about the timing of the information flow, but we will hopefully get that corrected very soon. Mr. Decker, again read the title of 200629.
A resolution recognizing November 8 through November 14, 2020 as National Apprenticeship Week Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING and honoring ApprenticeshipPHL and the District 1199c Training and Upgrading Fund for its continued commitment to providing job skills, training, and opportunity to all Philadelphians.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gilmore Richardson for a motion.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200631.
A resolution recognizing and honoring the Philadelphia City Commissioners and the hard-working members of their staff for their around the clock work during the 2020 General Election, and for ensuring that every vote cast in Philadelphia was counted.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Jones for a motion.
Thank you, Mr. President. With Philly pride, I move for the adoption of this resolution. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor indicate by saying aye. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200632.
A resolution honoring the life and legacy of Ronald R. Donatucci, Sr., a dedicated public servant and renowned political leader.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson for a motion on the resolution.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200633.
A resolution authorizing the Philadelphia Land Bank to dispose of 1615 North 6th Street located in the Seventh Councilmanic District.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez for a motion on the resolution.
It's Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200634.
A resolution honoring Kindred Arts and Little Giant Creative on the occasion of Monumental Tour's public art exhibit in the City of Philadelphia.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Brooks for a motion on the resolution.
Thank you, Council President. Before I move... Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Councilwoman, you're breaking up a little bit. Start again. You were breaking up.
Sorry. Thank you, Council President. Before I move for adoption, I just want to take a moment to recognize the vital work of Kindred Arts and Little Giant Creative in bringing socially engaged art to the people of Philadelphia through the Monumental Tour's public art exhibition, which has been taking place throughout October and November. At a time when our city is grappling with the vast inequity and systemic racism, the work of art that make up the Monumental Tour provides an Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING outlet for us to reflect on the struggles of the present moment and make sense of our past and imagine a better future. I know many of my colleagues have already seen examples of their work across the City, such as the 28 foot Afro pick designed by artist Hank Willis Thomas that was on display in West and North Philadelphia. I encourage the viewing public to engage with their groundbreaking work this month, and I want to thank Marsha Reid, Director of Kindred Arts, and Tayyib Smith, Co-Founder of Little Giant Creative, for their important contribution to Philadelphia art and culture. And with that, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor say aye. (Aye.) Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200637.
A resolution proclaiming November 15 through 22, 2020 as National Hunger and Homelessness Awareness Week in Philadelphia and honoring organizations, advocates, and City workers for their work supporting Philadelphia's most vulnerable.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gauthier for a motion.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200638.
A resolution honoring and congratulating the Franklin Towne Charter Girls Soccer team, on their successful 2019-2020 season and overall 16-0 and 1 record in the Philadelphia Public League.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Thomas for a motion on the resolution. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200640.
A resolution calling on the United States House of Representatives and United States Senate to hold hearings on voter suppression and voter intimidation during the 2020 United States presidential election. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass for a motion on that resolution.
Thank you, Mr. President. I just wanted to say before I call to move for the adoption that once again we saw this week, even though the election was 16 days ago on November 3rd, that in Wayne County, Michigan, which is primarily Detroit, we saw that there was an attempt to just wholesale discount or remove votes and not have been counted by a district -- or by a county that is 80 percent African American. And so we call on the United States Congress to do something, not just to hold hearings, but to actually do something about this problem which persists, which I've said before is a cancer on our democracy. With all of that being said, I want to move for the adoption of this Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING resolution. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Thank you very much. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Bill No. 200093.
An ordinance establishing parking regulations in the vicinity of: North 3rd Street and Fairmount Avenue; Wildey Street and Marlborough Street; George Street and North 2nd Street; Salmon Street and Columbia Avenue; Montgomery Avenue and Wildey Street; Orianna Street and George Street. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that Bill No. 200093 be withdrawn. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that Bill No. 200093 be withdrawn. All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. The motion carries. Bill No. 200093 has been withdrawn. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Bill No. 200162.
An ordinance Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING amending Section 12-701 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Designation of Bicycle Lanes," to authorize a buffered bicycle lane on Spruce Street, from 2nd Street to 22nd Street and on Pine Street, from Front Street to 18th Street.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla for an amendment to Bill No. 200162.
Thank you, Mr. President. I would like to offer an amendment to Bill No. 200162. A copy of the amendment has been circulated to all members of Council. I move for the adoption of the amendment. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. All in favor of the motion will signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Those opposed? (No response.)
The ayes have it. Bill No. 200162 has been amended, and Bill No. 200162, as amended, will be placed on the Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Bill No. 200353.
An ordinance amending Section 17-109 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Local Bidding Preferences," to amend reporting requirements to require the establishment of local business usage goals and reporting on reaching such goals as a way to assist community businesses recover from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Thank you. This bill having been read on two different days, the question now is shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, call the roll. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Councilman Jones. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. The ayes are 17; the nays are zero. A majority of all members having voted in the affirmative, the bill Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING passes. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Bill No. 200544.
An ordinance amending Title 9 of The Philadelphia Code by adding a new Chapter, entitled "Residential Property Wholesalers," to regulate the solicitation of purchases of real property and require certain disclosures by property purchasers to homeowners, and amending Chapter 9-1100 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Fair Practices Ordinance: Protections Against Unlawful Discrimination," to provide protections to homeowners from solicitation and related problems. Council President, Councilman Domb would like to be recognized before the vote on this.
Thank you, Council President. I want to thank my colleagues who co-sponsored this Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING legislation with me, Councilmembers Kathy Gilmore Richardson, Councilmember Mark Squilla, Councilmember Maria Quinones-Sanchez, Councilmember Kenyatta Johnson, Councilmember Isaiah Thomas, Majority Leader Cherelle Parker, Councilmember Jamie Gauthier, Councilmember Kendra Brooks, and Councilmember Helen Gym, and I encourage all Councilmembers to support this important bill today. I also want to recognize Community Legal Services, CLS, and the Greater Philadelphia Association of Realtors, GPAR, for all their hard work and input to ensure we establish sound policy that protects our most vulnerable residents. Additionally, I want to give a special thanks and a shout-out to Rue Landau with the Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations and the Law Department for their hours of work and their valuable input. They did a great job. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING With the passage of this bill, Philadelphia will establish fair rules and expectations for wholesalers buying and selling homes in our communities. This legislation levels the playing field and ensures the good acting wholesalers continue their practices and we weed out the bad actors in the process. All of our homeowners deserve market value for their homes, and everyone deserves to work with the knowledge they need in order to make the right decision about their financial future. We've seen so many neighborhoods in Philadelphia fall victim over the years to these signs that say "cash for homes," "we buy your house now," and it's time for us to take steps that go beyond just placing penalties on those who litter our neighborhoods with these signs. This bill will ensure that these businesses are finally regulated in a manner we all deem reasonable and Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING responsible and inclusive of enforcement, especially if they try to pursue questionable activities that take advantage -- this is the biggest issue here -- of our city's most vulnerable people and communities. Again, I want to thank all my colleagues for their support on this legislation, and I look forward to the ongoing work ahead to educate homeowners of their rights. Thank you very much, Council President. Thank you.
Thank you, Councilman. This bill having been read on two different days, the question now is shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, call the roll.
Councilwoman Brooks. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Councilman O'Neill. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. The ayes are 17; the nays are zero. A majority of all members having voted in the affirmative, the bill passes. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Bill No. 200574.
An ordinance amending Title 9 of The Philadelphia Code Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING to address matters related to commercial leases and provide eviction and financial relief to restaurant businesses that operate on leased premises.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Henon for an amendment to Bill No. 200574.
Thank you, Mr. President. I'd like to offer an amendment to Bill No. 200574. A copy of the amendment has been circulated to all members of Council, and I move for the adoption of the amendment. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. All in favor of the motion will signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
The Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING the ayes have it, and Bill No. 200574 has been amended. Bill No. 200574, as amended, will be placed on the Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Bill No. 200425.
An ordinance amending Title 6 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Health Code," by creating a new Chapter 6-1300, entitled "Healthy Outdoor Public Spaces," to promote a healthy environment that protects the public from the risks of toxic herbicides by prohibiting their use on all city-owned or used public grounds including but not limited to parks, trails, recreation centers, and playgrounds; establishing reporting requirements; and establishing a private right of action.
Thank you. The Chair recognizes Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Councilwoman Bass for an amendment to Bill No. 200425.
Thank you, Mr. President. I really first want to thank all of the folks who called in today to testify on behalf of this bill. This is something that's really, really important to all of our citizens and to the health particularly of our children. So I would like to offer an amendment to Bill No. 200425, a copy of which has been circulated to all members of Council, and I move for the adoption of the amendment. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. All those in favor of the motion will signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and Bill No. 200425 has Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING been amended. Bill No. 200425, as amended, will be placed on our Final Passage Calendar. Councilman Thomas, we have an indication that you were interested in speaking on 200353?
I'm sorry. It was an accident, Council President. I apologize.
All right. No problem. I just want to make I'm -- stepping down off of that podium has kind of discombobulated me earlier. I'm sure I won't ever do that again.
No. That one was on me, Council President, not you. I apologize.
Okay. Thank you, Councilman. Mr. Decker, do you have any additional resolutions?
A resolution authorizing the Committee on Commerce and Economic Development to hold hearings on Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING the state of Philadelphia's neighborhood commercial corridors, introduced by Councilwoman Parker.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.
And a resolution authorizing the Committee on Education to hold hearings to examine options for expanding the pipeline of Black male Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 11/19/20 - STATED - 2ND READING teachers and staff in Philadelphia schools, introduced by Councilman Johnson.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.
There are no other resolutions on the Final Passage Calendar, Mr. President.
Thank you very much, Mr. Decker. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 for today. Prior to recognizing members regarding speeches, I will note for the record at this time that we will use the Chat feature available in Microsoft Teams to allow members to signify that they wish to be recognized. In order to comply with the Sunshine Act, the Chat feature must only be used for that purpose. With that said, are there any speeches on behalf of the minority? The Chair recognizes Councilman Oh.
Thank you very much, Council President. In kind of keeping in line with the previous conversation that we had, Councilmember Mark Squilla shared with me a letter that he was in possession of. It was from the Chicago Medical Society to the Mayor of Chicago asking that gyms be allowed to open an hour earlier, because many Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 needed to exercise, maintain their strength, relieve stress, and I thought that was interesting. I looked at the CDC recommendations, and that's where I saw that -- and it says here after nearly 50 million check-ins over a three-month period that the study relied on by the CDC found that gyms nationwide had robust COVID-19 safety measures in place and there is zero evidence that the positive cases, which were 0.0023 percent, originated in the gyms themselves. Okay. I just want to make sure I don't lose my WiFi there. I'm sorry. And what that astounding number means is that people who go to gyms are 500 times less likely to get COVID-19 than the national average. The evidence, or at least the information in the CDC study, would indicate that gyms and healthcare facilities should not be closed. There could be disagreement about that, but I would ask the Health Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Department the issue -- the restrictions have been issued. I understand it's the responsibility of the Health Commissioner. I would just ask that they look at kind of this information, zero evidence. There's no significant difference between those who tested positive versus negative when it came to shopping, gathering with fewer than ten people in a home, going to an office, going to a gym, going to a salon, using public transportation or attending religious gatherings, according to this study. If we're going to rely on this study, should we not rely on all of the study? Because I am concerned that when people lose their jobs, lose their healthcare, lose their ability to pay rent, lose their ability to feed their children, lose their ability to go out into the community, that they are being moved from one category of risk to an Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 risk. I think it is worth looking at, and I hope that we'll be able to do that cooperatively, because, again, and I'm quoting him often, my friend and colleague Councilmember Jones says none of us are as smart as all of us, and I really believe that's something we owe the public. Thank you very much, Council President.
Thank you, Councilman. Speeches on behalf of the majority? The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Maria Quinones-Sanchez.
Thank you, Council President. Again, I want to thank Councilman David Oh for honoring our request, the body's request, and working in a conciliatory way to get to a better place. As he says, we're much better when we're working together. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 you, Council President. I know you took yourself out of your norm in your discussion about why investment now is important and why we should be unapologetic about the types of investments that we need in our neighborhoods. I want to thank you, and I look forward to continuing that debate and that discussion about why now and why the urgency of this. Even before COVID, I've always acknowledged that I represented a challenging district. Many of you have heard me talk about this consistently, but I've always done it with the respect and honoring the resilience of the people that I represent, because it is not hopeless, and that's why people elect us and give us this voice and this space, because it is not hopeless. The folks in the community that I represent remind me every day why I'm so proud to have been raised in Philadelphia and proud to represent Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 to represent Norris Square, South Kensington where you and I border our lines. Housing and community development was the space that I was in even prior to coming to Council. I take this work extremely serious. Affordable accessible housing, corridors, and the role that they play in people's lives, public spaces even before Rebuild, our office had embarked on a ten-year plan for how open spaces and green spaces and parks give neighborhoods an opportunity to brand themselves and give communities places to gather in an intergenerational way, and I'm proud of all of this work and the legislative work that I've done around these things. Whether it's the inclusionary housing, mandatory inclusionary housing at 20 percent with the support of all my colleagues is now on the books, to the authoring of OOPA and TAP, I've been very, very clear that keeping people in their homes is the best Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 strategy, and this work does not happen by accident but by us providing clear leadership about what we'd like to see. And it's taken us a while in the Seventh Councilmanic District, working with our RCOs, we're 80 percent remapped, and moving people away from what they're against to what they're for is much, much harder. And it's not just about the legislation but the resources attached to it, so that it has impact and we're investing in people. So yesterday I proudly stood -and I want to thank you, Council President Clarke, because I know you do a lot of things behind the scenes and people don't know about it. Yesterday's announcement was 13 years of work, a seven-year conversation, and two years of planning to get the collaboration between HACE, APM, Esperanza, and Norris Square alliance in a collaborative effort to transfer over 240 PHA-owned parcels, vacant properties and land over to Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 we can create a comprehensive strategy for South Kensington. Neighbors in South Kensington -- and I know you hear this, Council President -- all they see is all the development going up, and even with all of these four organizations working together, we're not going to stem the kind of development that folks see. But I want to thank my partners for engaging in this journey, for not being territorial in this work when I ask everybody to roll up their sleeves, all hands on deck. I want to thank Kelvin Jeremiah and the PHA Board for working with us. This is the kind of things we need. It is very easy to tell people what they're against.
It is very hard to guide them in a direction and reminding people that we're on the same road, sometimes in different lanes, but all are committed to the neighborhood. That Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 work. And so I want to thank you, thank PHA, thank the partners, thank my Council colleagues who support me in this work that I have to do in the Seventh Councilmanic District. And I'll end, when the Seventh Councilmanic District is doing better, the entire city does better, and I understand that correlation, which is why I always intend to be a good ally to my colleagues and their work in their district and thank them when they are champions for the work that I need to do in mine. So thank you all very much.
Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Green.
Thank you, Council President. Let me begin by reminding everyone that we will be having a blood drive next week on the 24th from 9:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. It's a give back Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 is next week. I wish every one of my colleagues and all those listening in the City of Philadelphia a great Thanksgiving. For those who want to participate, please go to redcrossblood.org and use the sponsor code Green in order to sign up for the blood drive, and this will be at the Red Cross location 2221 Chestnut Street. That's 2221 Chestnut Street. And in the spirit of Thanksgiving, I'm very thankful for where we are as a city and as a state and a nation, because we've gone through such a challenging time period. I was -- earlier in this session as we were discussing Councilmember Oh's resolution, I was going to provide some additional commentary and I pulled back from doing that because I wanted to give him an opportunity to respond to Councilmember Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 a revision to the resolution, and the reason I raised the point of information I did, because in this current climate in our nation, words have very serious implications. We have a nation that's dealing with a pandemic that has brought significant loss of life to people around this nation, around this world. I know I've been very critical of the Administration in reference to issues and concerns in how we address small businesses and getting relief to small businesses, because this pandemic has been both a global health issue and also an economic crisis. But my concern in reference to words is that we are currently in a state of play in our nation where we have a number of people who don't believe a number of things, don't believe the outcome of our most recent election, don't believe that if there is a vaccine, whether they should or should not take Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 goes back to the words that have been used by various parties, individuals, not saying political parties per se, to push forward their own message. And so I say that the words have meaning. I'm glad that Councilmember Oh is going to revise the resolution, but I'm also concerned that people will take information and use it for their own goals. I listened to his statement, and I agree with the concerns of having a more inclusive decision-making process regarding these issues, but we've also seen significant death in our city, especially for people of color and more specifically African Americans who have been impacted by this pandemic. So I think that we need to be very careful with the words that we use, especially in this climate, and not allow various parties to take bits and pieces of information and continue to see Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 only in our local government but also government as a whole. Thank you, Council President.
Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.
Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. President, I too want to commend you for your work today in stepping down from the rostrum to speak about the importance of neighborhood development. Investing in our neighborhoods is essential for our city as we attempt to move forward and out of this global pandemic that we're in to ensure that Philadelphia is on sound economic footing. With that in mind, I am thinking about a quote that late President John F. Kennedy was often identified as stating when he said a rising tide lifts all boats. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 the City of Philadelphia who are listening right now, we know that you have contributed consistently to Philadelphia's tax base over the years before there was great and grand development to change neighborhoods in our city, and it is with that in mind that any community development that we do in the future, ordinary Philadelphians need to benefit from that in a very substantive way and they need to touch it and see it and feel it, Mr. President. They can't hear us say that we care about neighborhood and economic development and then they walk out of their houses and see commercial corridors that are run down, don't have enough money to buy a home because they need assistance with closing costs and down payment assistance, and don't let me think about, Mr. President, those Philadelphians who it seems are penalized from being able to participate in programs that the City currently offers, not because they are Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 make a nickel more than the income eligibility guidelines for those programs. So I want to commend you, Mr. President, on that, and I look forward to having that discussion in the near future. In addition to that, Mr. President, I want to keep JFK in mind, and many of us remember this quote. He said victory has a thousand fathers, but defeat is an orphan. Victory has a thousand fathers, but defeat is an orphan. Before Philadelphia's final votes could be tabulated, there were so many people who wrote stories talking about the decline of Philadelphia's turnout, that our participation did not have a significant impact on this election, and when we finally saw the final tabulations, we learned that Philadelphia voters -- and I don't care what party you were in -- 749,317 of us Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 I want to say to Layla Jones thank you for your article entitled "Philadelphia turnout for the 2020 election was the highest in 25 years," and that was published in Billy Penn, but when I read that 25 years, they said the highest turnout since 1984, for those of you who remember, and I guess this is etched in my mind because in '83 I stood in line with mommy and daddy in the 10th Ward, 2nd Division on 74th Avenue when the lines were wrapped around the building to vote for Wilson Goode for Mayor during those times. And as I listened to the folks attempt to constantly use divide-and-conquer methods, particularly within the black community, to talk about black women being here but black men have strayed and that the turnout was not as robust as people have thought it was, then, Mr. President, I looked, as I am doing right now, to the text message and e-mail Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Sabir sent out showing the total votes cast in Philadelphia by ward. I want to say this with this visual in mind: To all of the organizations who helped to encourage turnout, to all of the elected officials, because I heard some people talking about what a campaign did, what a campaign didn't do. I don't care if you're a ward leader or elected.
I saw all of my colleagues across the board trying to do their best to encourage people to just participate in the voting process, and I'm thinking about Councilman Kenyatta Johnson and work that I know he did that wasn't connected with any campaign in his area to encourage voter registration. I'm thinking about churches, synagogues, mosques, and temples who were encouraging people to get registered to participate in their democracy. The final group, Mr. President, who deserves all of the credit in the Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 world, because sometimes people want credit because they say they go into a community and they are the people who organize that community. I need to give a hearty thank you to residents in the City of Philadelphia who encouraged each other to vote. Committee people, yes, you did your job. Ward leaders, you did your job. Elected officials, you did your job. Organizations, thank you for your work. But for the people who weren't on social media, for the people who knocked doors on their block and they're not even a block captain, for all of those, some who said, Cherelle, I've never been involved in politics before but I feel compelled to work to try to protect our democracy right now, they rolled up their sleeves and they went to work in ways that we will never know because we didn't see them. I want to say a thank you to each and every one of you. When I look at these numbers, Philadelphia, you showed up and you Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 to African American women in this city, I want you to know that no one will be able to write you out of this story, that you played a significant role, and that you should be proud of it. Peace to everyone in PHL, and thank you for making your voices heard. Thank you, Mr. President.
Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gilmore Richardson.
Thank you so much, Mr. President. I just wanted to circle back to thank you, our Majority Leader Councilmember Parker, our Majority Whip Councilmember Jones, and all of the members of Philadelphia City Council, all of our colleagues who stayed on our marathon Committee of the Whole hearing yesterday, to the Administration, the Mayor's Office of Labor. We worked closely with Richie Lazer, Monica Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Marchetti-Brock, and Rachel, and the nearly 100 witnesses for our first public comment hearing prior to the Administration entering into contract negotiations with the Fraternal Order of Police. I'm looking forward to sending all the recommendations we heard to the Administration, along with all the written testimony, and I look forward to the feedback that we'll receive from the Administration on how the proposal changed as a result of the seven hours of feedback we heard. So I just wanted to thank you, our leadership team, and each and every person who testified for their participation yesterday. Thank you so much, Mr. President.
Thank you. Thank you so much, Councilwoman. Thank you for your continued good work. Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 are no other speeches on behalf of the majority and minority. So with that, I will recognize Councilman Jones for a motion to adjourn.
Thank you, Mr. President. And before I do, I want to say what I'm thankful for. I'm thankful for working with this body, a chorus of different types of voices that help the public and the City of Philadelphia, and I enjoyed this week just watching you work. And with that, Mr. President, I now want to make a motion to have Council stand adjourned until Thursday, December 3rd, 2020 at 10:00 a.m. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, December 3rd, 2020, 10:00 a.m. All in favor will indicate by Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 (Aye.)
The ayes have it. The motion carries. Thank you all very much. And, again, please be safe. Thank you. God bless you. ) Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 CERTIFICATE I HEREBY CERTIFY that the proceedings, evidence and objections are contained fully and accurately in the stenographic notes taken by me upon the foregoing matter, and that this is a true and correct transcript of same. MICHELE L. ) Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 A act 22:8,19 173:1 174:1 advertisem... m 1:7 24:20 32:21 adjustments 93:23 11:16 13:10 28:25 41:3 12:10 argue 58:8 161:25 76:17,21,24 97:5 advised 27:8 28:18 47:7,9,18 APM 159:22 armed 173:18,24 77:8 78:10 administra... 103:10 40:17 48:5,7 apologize 115:17 AA 121:16 78:19,22 18:8 106:4 advisory agreements 96:22 98:9 150:10,18 art 128:17 abatement 153:10 106:14 80:12 88:3 10:21,24 98:22 99:18 apparently 129:17,19 16:14,14 acting 143:7 107:17 88:10 91:7 12:25 13:4 100:14,19 108:11 129:24 21:15,22 action 28:7 108:4,13,20 91:15 97:2 26:21,24 100:25 appeal 130:17 abatements 36:24 53:9 111:10 advocacy 102:6 101:8,16,24 106:21 Arthur 79:12 11:11 12:22 72:25 112:4 116:3 56:24 70:14 agricultural 137:2 113:4 79:20 26:16 148:22 117:18 advocate 65:15 80:7 138:12 appealed article 77:10 Abbotsford actions 119:7 59:8 ahead 20:22 141:6,12 106:20 168:4 30:7 115:16 120:17 advocates 83:10 146:25 Appeals artist 130:8 ability 22:17 active 60:16 163:12 131:14 129:11 148:10 114:21 Arts 128:15 155:21,22 64:4 86:15 171:23 Affairs 63:22 144:11 amendment appears 129:16 155:23 activities 172:5,10,13 affect 54:23 aimed 78:5 11:15 13:9 173:2 130:14 able 16:7 77:4 144:4 adopt 76:2,5 107:4 air 77:14 27:8 76:3 applicators artwork 21:10 83:16 actors 143:9 81:11 affirmative 79:5 89:3 77:12,13 60:21 39:11 156:4 actuality adopted 78:25 airborne 78:15,24 applied 71:19 asked 21:18 166:23 112:3 124:18 105:18 65:22 120:23,25 apply 76:24 31:12 54:8 171:4 Acute 64:8 125:3,23 140:25 all-powerful 137:12,16 175:22 54:14 70:18 abnormalit... ad 94:19 126:8,25 146:20 78:10 137:17,19 appointing 71:7 64:13 Adams 99:5 127:10 affordable ALLAN 1:11 147:9,13,14 42:16,21,25 asking 11:25 absence 9:16 add 47:10 128:11 24:3 158:8 Allegheny 147:16 43:5,9,17 92:19 9:21 48:11 53:19 130:23 afraid 82:9 30:7 149:2,12,15 appreciate 108:20 abstain 68:23 84:4 131:7 132:4 African allergic 71:12 amendments 33:24 39:2 153:24 103:10 96:23 132:13 110:6 alliance 68:23 84:7 86:17 Asociacion abuse 90:3 addiction 133:8,17 134:17 159:23 American 115:24 87:4 accept 39:15 111:2 135:6,14 164:19 allotted 54:13 22:13 110:6 appreciated Assembly accepted adding 47:20 151:21 171:2 allow 25:3 134:18 21:18 121:20 107:11 48:19 141:7 152:20 Afro 130:7 83:17 153:8 171:3 appreciation assist 138:18 accessible addition 52:3 adoption agenda 50:1 164:23 Americans 87:8 assistance 158:9 167:9 45:10 50:21 51:1 allowable 164:19 Apprentice... 166:19,21 accident additional 124:13 51:9,19 100:16 amount 123:25 Assistance,' 150:9 159:3 50:12 125:19 52:5 54:22 allowed 12:21 16:2 Apprentice... 48:11 accompany... 150:22 126:21 96:1,2,4,7 57:24 26:15 54:2 124:2 Assistant 89:4 162:22 127:23 96:10,14 153:24 65:14 72:3 apprised 59:2 accurately Additionally 129:14 97:1 98:1 allowing Amy 36:5 115:3 associated 61:24 175:5 142:20 130:19 99:1 100:1 61:12,13 38:21 75:9 approach 59:25 62:3 achieve 89:6 address 131:23 101:1 102:1 81:15,25 75:19 68:20 Association achieving 36:13 133:4 134:9 103:1 104:1 allows 113:8 analytical appropriate 18:16 87:2 88:21 101:18 134:25 105:1,20 ally 87:11 73:11 12:7 26:4 87:9 96:18 acknowledge 102:2 147:2 137:19 Agent 63:24 161:12 anchor 37:24 approval 8:1 100:3 36:4 163:13 147:16 64:5 81:6 ambition and/or 8:16 142:15 acknowled... addresses 149:14 aging 36:14 36:5 175:24 approved assuage 157:13 72:6 151:9 152:9 ago 70:15 amend 44:18 Angela 43:17 8:23 9:5,14 75:22 acknowled... addressing adults 32:12 134:11 138:14 announcem... 98:23 asthma 60:2 63:25 88:24 89:3 59:19,23 agree 116:21 amended 2:5 108:6 approxima... 65:4,8 acknowled...
131:10 169:20 139:6,7 41:18 44:3 120:4 11:18 12:22 82:12 74:3 132:16 Churchview 142:9 46:16 49:24 166:14 21:12 22:18 challenged chemicals 133:20 96:17 144:25 50:4,10,13 167:24 26:16 44:20 17:19,24 73:15 135:17 cigarettes 145:2 50:16 51:25 169:11 47:25 54:21 82:24 83:23 Cherelle 1:16 136:25 81:2 brothers 53:9 96:11 career 63:21 60:3 90:6 challenging 142:7 138:11 Cindy 1:10 74:18 105:23 careful 80:21 101:13,22 17:25 170:16 139:2,5,8 56:19 brought 138:8 148:5 164:22 102:6 157:14 Chestnut 139:10,13 circle 171:17 113:2,5 150:4 carefully 115:19 162:18 162:12,13 139:16,18 Circuit 163:8 152:23 71:13 141:10 champion Chicago 139:20,22 106:22 brown 73:20 153:2 cares 24:20 certainly 88:23 153:23,24 139:25 113:7,11 74:18 Calendars 89:3 110:24 championing Chief 1:20 140:3,5,8 114:21,22 Buckius 50:23 52:7 Caring 69:9 121:8 86:24 3:2,9,16,22 140:11,14 120:12 44:22 call 2:1,20 carries 51:18 122:25 champions 4:6,14,21 140:17,20 circulated budgets 3:1 4:1 5:1 136:21 CERTIFIC... 161:14 5:3,9,12,15 141:5 137:17 89:11 6:1 7:1 174:8 175:2 chance 110:2 5:23 6:5,11 144:21,24 147:14 buffered 16:3 20:2 case 78:8 certification change 88:24 6:14,17,24 145:3,5,8 149:13 137:5 34:22 36:9 112:23,24 175:21 166:7 7:7,14,20 145:11,13 circumstan... build 23:11 38:7 53:12 112:25 CERTIFY changed 10:5 12:15 145:15,17 53:24 37:20 53:15 113:18,21 175:3 172:14 26:5,10,19 145:20,22 cite 106:16 building 102:13,20 120:8,9 certifying changes 27:5,13,20 145:24 120:8 18:16 90:21 134:9,18 cases 154:13 175:25 15:16 28:4,11,24 146:3,6,9 cities 111:24 168:15 138:25 cash 57:18 cetera 92:10 changing 29:11,17 146:12,15 citing 108:23 buildings 144:20 143:18 Chair 8:18 44:19 30:4,10,18 146:24 citizens 8:6 23:13 36:21 callbacks cast 125:12 9:17,23 chapter 11:3 30:22 31:2 148:9 66:3 76:13 90:22 54:23 169:3 14:9,12,19 11:12 12:19 31:11 35:8 150:23 77:13 79:4 built 86:13 called 2:24 catching 14:24 24:9 26:13 47:9 39:8,19 151:22 110:3 149:9 business 8:16 34:13 52:6 93:21 25:8 31:15 47:18 48:7 40:4,13,24 152:21 city 1:2 2:9 9:15,24 102:14 category 35:15,20 48:9 98:9 41:14,19 child 34:20 8:5 10:6,23 11:22 37:8 149:6 22:21 41:25 44:5 99:18 101:8 42:12 44:16 children 31:6 10:23 11:15 41:24 50:3 calling 51:23 155:25 45:6 46:17 101:16,24 47:4 55:8 31:8,24 11:18 13:3 100:3 87:24 106:4 156:2 49:2 50:14 141:7,12 55:11,19 32:7,10,17 13:3,9,12 108:13 133:21 Caucasian 51:21 80:14 148:12 58:18 62:13 32:25,25 17:7 19:22 110:21 campaign 110:9 82:3 106:10 character 62:18 66:11 33:7,16,18 20:5 23:12 138:16 169:10,10 cause 64:9 114:8 124:9 123:6 66:14,18 33:24 59:10 24:2 25:6 businesses 169:18 65:8 73:18 125:15 characteris...
69:16 72:13 59:15,16,22 26:23,23 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 27:7,10 claim 88:22 83:9 84:6 159:16 105:5,9,13 67:10 color 73:15 95:21 28:14 31:8 claims 88:23 84:11,17 161:17 106:3 co-sponsored 164:18 122:16 33:6 36:11 clarifying 87:14,19 165:6 123:23 141:25 Columbia 172:4 37:5,9,25 11:6 91:20 92:2 171:11 125:6 co-sponsors 135:23 commentary 38:4,9,11 clarity 95:18,23 172:22 126:11 31:19 35:21 coma 64:10 162:23 39:15 40:16 117:13 102:8 173:20 127:13 Coach 39:24 combination commenting 40:19 42:13 118:2,24 103:11 174:4,7 128:14 coalition 57:7 11:8 53:17 55:12 42:18,22 119:20 105:14,15 classified 131:10 coalitions come 2:20 58:19 62:14 43:3,7,10 Clarke 1:10 106:9 112:8 61:6 132:16 37:20 7:25 32:20 66:12 69:17 43:15,18 2:2 3:7,14 112:16 clean 74:10 133:20 code 10:10 82:12,22,24 72:14 75:9 47:15,24 3:20 4:4,12 114:6 77:14 135:17 11:4 12:20 92:12 79:12 81:19 48:2,16 4:19,25 5:7 116:12 clear 83:22 136:25 26:14 41:4 111:20 84:14 87:17 56:13 57:3 5:18 6:3,9 117:6 111:14 138:11 47:8 48:6 114:4 91:24 57:5 59:5 6:22 7:5,12 118:18 115:4 116:4 139:2,5,8 57:6 96:22 comes 92:8 122:11 63:13 65:4 7:18,21,22 119:18 158:24 139:10,13 98:10 99:19 118:8 comments 71:20 73:2 8:14,25 9:9 120:3 159:4 139:16,18 100:15,20 comfortable 14:10,20 73:4,7 9:12,22 121:18 Clerk 1:20 139:20,22 101:9,17,25 121:9 54:19 74:21 76:8 11:20 12:18 122:4,12 2:20 3:2,9 139:25 107:13,18 coming 85:12 Commerce 79:21 81:10 13:14,23 123:11,15 3:16,22 4:6 140:3,5,8 107:19 89:23 93:23 13:19 27:23 82:6,18,18 14:25 15:3 124:7,16,22 4:14,21 5:3 140:11,14 120:23 111:5 158:7 150:24 84:17 85:25 25:14,18,20 124:25 5:9,12,15 140:17,20 121:2 137:3 commanded commercial 88:22,23 26:7,11,17 125:13,21 5:23 6:5,11 141:5 138:13 78:13 11:9 13:22 89:3,6,10 27:3,11,14 126:3,6,15 6:14,17,24 144:21,24 141:6,13 commend 16:14 27:25 89:15,16 27:18 28:2 126:23 7:7,14,20 145:3,5,8 146:25 165:12 97:20 147:2 90:9,13,15 28:9,22 127:5,8,17 10:5 12:12 145:11,13 148:11,11 167:5 151:3 90:18,23 29:9,15 127:25 12:15 26:5 145:15,17 162:10 commenda... 166:17 91:3 99:2,3 30:2,8,16 128:6,9,19 26:10,19 145:20,22 Cohen 38:23 36:24 Commission 99:11,12 30:20,24 129:2,6,9 27:5,13,20 145:24 collaboration comment 92:17,25 106:6,15 31:9,14 130:21 28:4,11,24 146:3,6,9 159:21 2:14 12:8 94:8 142:22 108:16 35:4,14 131:2,5,17 29:11,17 146:12,15 collaborative 52:16 53:1 Commissio... 110:3,4,7 39:4,17,21 131:25 30:4,10,18 146:24 37:5 68:25 53:6,7,14 10:20 12:24 111:22,23 40:2,11,22 132:8,11,22 30:22 31:2 148:9 159:23 54:1,23 26:20 28:13 115:11 41:12,17,22 133:6,12,15 31:11 35:8 150:23 colleague 55:1 56:1 40:15 118:14 42:8 43:23 134:2 135:4 39:8,19 151:22 156:7 57:1 58:1 108:23 120:23 44:12 45:4 135:9,12 40:4,13,24 152:21 colleague's 59:1 60:1 155:2,6 121:2 125:8 45:13 46:2 136:2,10,17 41:14,19 climate 28:7 114:25 61:1 62:1 169:2 128:17 46:11,14,24 136:20 42:12 44:16 88:24 163:5 colleagues 63:1,15 Commissio...
129:22 48:24 49:10 137:9,21,25 47:4 55:8 164:23 3:5,13,18 64:1 65:1 125:8 130:7 49:19,22 138:4,20 55:11,19 clock 125:10 4:2,10,24 66:1 67:1 commit 74:23 131:15 51:5,14,17 140:21,22 58:18 62:13 close 59:16 5:6,22 6:2,8 68:1 69:1 commitment 161:9 162:5 52:13,24 141:21 62:18 66:11 69:7 86:20 6:20 7:4,11 70:1 71:1 33:24 108:9 162:16 55:13,17,22 144:15 66:14,18 closed 111:18 14:2,14 72:1 73:1 124:4 164:17 56:3,7 146:16,17 69:16 72:13 154:24 24:13 59:8 74:1 75:1 committed 165:17 58:16,21 147:6,18,22 75:8 79:11 closely 121:9 123:5 76:1 77:1 160:25 166:2,8,24 62:11,15,22 147:25 81:18 84:13 171:25 123:9 130:5 78:1 79:1 committee 170:7 171:3 63:6,12 148:23 87:16 91:22 closing 141:25 80:1 81:1 12:5 13:19 171:20 64:17 66:4 149:17,21 95:20 96:15 166:20 144:9 81:15 82:1 22:23 26:9 173:12 66:8,20,23 149:24 102:13,22 CLS 86:25 158:22 82:2 83:1 26:18 27:4 city's 76:25 67:3 69:14 150:11,19 103:2,6,14 142:14 161:5,12 84:1 85:1 27:12,22 86:15 88:11 69:20,25 151:5,11,16 103:18,22 co-founder 162:4 86:1 87:1 28:23 29:10 90:3 91:8 72:11,17 151:19 103:25 67:8 130:15 169:13 88:1 89:1 29:16 30:3 91:16 144:6 75:6,12 152:5,11,15 104:4,7,11 co-introduc... 171:21 90:1 91:1 30:9,12,21 city-owned 79:9,15,20 152:18,24 104:14,17 35:18 collective 92:1 93:1 30:22 35:20 148:17 81:16,21 156:13 104:21,25 co-owner 117:7 94:1 95:1 39:18 40:23 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 41:13,25 compared 96:17 consist 61:5 contractors 110:17 42:8,13 123:11,15 42:3,5,14 65:18 conduct consistency 47:14,24 175:8 43:21,23 124:7,16,22 44:7,9,16 compelled 101:11 118:3 48:16 corrected 44:4,9,12 124:25 46:19,21 70:13 confirm consistently contracts 123:20 45:2,4,9,12 125:13,21 47:4 50:3,6 170:18 69:23 157:15 22:14 47:8 correlate 45:13,16,18 126:3,6,15 56:19,21,22 competitively conflict 76:19 166:5 47:15 48:2 110:23 45:18,19,22 126:20,23 97:14 98:3 47:16 48:2 76:20 77:6 consisting 48:6,10,17 correlates 46:2,5,11 127:5,8,17 150:24 48:18 78:2,17 39:12 Contracts,' 110:25 46:14,24 127:25 151:23 complete conflicted constantly 47:10,19 correlation 48:23,24 128:6,9,19 170:8 33:12 119:12 38:13 48:8 109:19 49:6,10,13 128:25 171:22 completes congratulat... 168:18 contribute 161:11 49:19,22 129:2,6,9 Committee,' 153:2 39:22 40:6 constituents 110:22 corridors 50:11,20 129:13 96:25 compliance 132:17 62:9 75:2 contributed 13:22 27:25 51:5,8,14 130:21 common 99:7 Congress constituting 166:4 151:3 158:9 51:17 52:13 131:2,5,17 60:14 61:11 comply 134:19 97:10,23 contribution 166:17 52:24 53:10 131:22,25 Commons 153:10 Congressio... Constitution 130:16 cosmetic 53:21 55:13 132:8,11,22 96:17 compounded 22:23 76:4 77:11 control 64:6 60:15 61:9 55:17,22 133:3,6,12 Commonw... 74:15 conjunction constitutio... 68:17 76:17 costs 166:20 56:3,7,12 133:15 78:7 comprehen... 106:18 79:2 175:24 coughing 56:13 58:16 134:2 135:4 communicate 160:3 connect construction convened 64:9 58:21 62:11 135:9,12 33:4 117:17 concern 52:19 11:7,10 94:2 Council 1:2 62:15,22 136:2,10,17 117:25 23:23 53:7 connected 15:25 16:8 convenience 1:10 2:2,7,9 63:6,13 136:20 communica... 70:23 71:2 53:3 169:18 16:17 68:12 3:7,12,14 64:17 66:4 137:9,18,21 118:16 111:8 connection consumer Convention 3:18,20,25 66:8,20,23 137:25 119:6,15 163:18 57:17 84:21 85:14 107:23 4:4,9,12,16 67:3 69:14 138:4,8,20 communica... concerned Consent 50:1 93:7 95:14 conversation 4:17,19,25 69:20,25 140:20,22 9:25 10:1,3 16:24 59:13 50:21 51:1 contact 34:7 16:24 18:13 5:5,7,17,18 72:11,17 141:18,21 communities 60:5 116:25 51:9,19 contacted 18:18,21 5:21 6:3,7,9 73:7 74:22 141:24 15:21 17:10 123:18 52:4 96:1,2 85:21 19:3 20:11 6:22 7:3,5 75:6,12,17 144:13,15 18:23 20:13 155:19 96:4,7,10 contained 153:20 7:10,12,18 79:9,15,21 146:15,17 20:15,16,17 164:10 96:14 97:1 175:5 159:20 7:20,22 81:16,21 147:6,15,18 24:2 38:8 concerning 98:1 99:1 containing conversatio...
8:14,25 9:9 83:9 84:6 147:22,25 60:7,25 50:15 100:1 101:1 11:7 16:18 18:4 9:12,20,22 84:11,17,18 148:6,23 73:15,21 concerns 102:1 103:1 content 61:23 convincing 10:6 11:20 87:14,19 149:14,17 74:6 80:10 15:17,19,20 104:1 105:1 continue 83:24 12:4,17 88:3 89:21 149:21,24 143:5 144:7 16:21 17:10 105:19 38:10 85:19 cooling 86:6 13:13,23 91:6,10,20 150:9,11,17 158:15 17:11 75:23 consenting 116:4 143:8 cooperation 14:8 15:3 92:2 95:18 150:19 community 116:18 55:7 164:25 12:10 15:14 25:20 95:23 102:8 151:5,11,16 33:21 39:23 122:20 conserve continued cooperatively 25:22 26:7 103:11 151:19 57:2 72:23 163:13 77:19 15:16,17,18 156:5 26:11,17 105:13,15 152:5,8,11 84:20 85:10 164:14 consider 15:20 124:4 coordination 27:3,11,14 106:6,9,12 152:15,18 87:2,6 94:3 conciliatory 50:21 51:9 172:25 64:10 27:18 28:2 106:15 152:24 94:14,15 156:23 51:19 53:5 continues copy 57:11 28:9,22 107:15 153:18 138:18 conclude 89:12 91:8 33:18 64:3 137:16 29:9,15 112:6,8,13 156:11,13 142:14 54:14 95:25 97:2 continuing 147:13 30:2,8,16 112:14,16 156:20 155:24 concludes 105:21 22:4 55:6 149:12 30:20,24 114:5,6,11 157:2 158:7 157:22 50:2 considerati... 94:19 157:9 corner 38:17 31:9,14,18 115:23 159:15 158:5 166:9 condemnat... 10:8 50:4 contract 100:5 35:2,4,14 116:12,17 160:7 161:5 168:20 28:17,18 52:16 72:10 22:13 86:8 coronavirus 35:17 37:17 117:6 161:17,22 170:4,5 conditions considered 172:5 101:20 38:16,18 118:18 165:5,6 companies 11:19 36:20 43:20 44:25 contracted 102:4 39:3,4,17 119:18 171:11,21 90:8,16 61:22 91:11 48:21 52:4 109:4,10,13 corporations 39:20 40:2 120:3,19 172:22 comparable 99:8 102:7 considering contracting 75:3 87:3 40:11,22 121:18,22 173:16,20 16:15 Condomini... 53:4 47:12 48:12 correct 41:12,17,22 122:4,12,22 173:22 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 174:4,7 139:24,25 councilors' 145:10,13 110:5,24 57:15 43:24 44:14 122:14 Council's 140:2,3,4,5 83:15 145:14 138:19 Daniel 87:17 47:2 55:23 deliberating 76:6 140:7,14,16 Councilwo... 146:3,5,6,8 154:11,19 87:24 95:24 96:3 36:12 Councilman 140:17,19 1:10,11,12 149:2,4 crash 89:9 Darrell 1:10 96:12 102:9 delivery 1:11,13,14 141:18,22 1:12,13,16 151:4,6,7 create 74:11 14:25 102:20 10:25 13:5 1:14,15,15 141:23 1:17 3:2,4,9 156:18,19 120:19 data 80:22 105:24 26:25 1:16,17,18 144:16 3:11,22,24 161:18 160:3 109:10 122:6 democracy 3:16,17 145:3,4,11 4:6,8,21,22 165:9,10 creating 110:16 123:21 107:2 4:14,15 5:3 145:12,15 6:17,19,24 171:12,14 106:6 David 1:15 125:4 126:9 109:25 5:4,9,12,15 145:16,17 7:2 9:17,18 171:15 148:11 38:22 127:11 134:23 5:16,19,20 145:19,20 9:23 12:15 172:24 creation 156:21 128:12 169:23 5:23,24 6:5 145:21,22 13:18 14:6 counted 96:25 day 31:5,22 131:8 170:19 6:6,11,14 145:23,24 14:11,18,22 125:12 Creative 31:23,24 132:14 democratic 7:7,9,14,16 146:2,9,11 15:7 25:13 134:16 128:16 34:9 46:6 133:18 112:2 7:19 8:19 146:12,14 26:6,11 counties 129:16 49:7,14 135:15 demographic 8:20 25:18 147:8,11 27:21 28:4 111:24 130:15 53:13 82:17 136:23 47:13,22 28:11 30:10 150:5,8,16 39:8 42:2,4 country credit 169:25 95:17 118:2 138:9,25 48:13 31:2,12,16 150:20 45:11,23 17:24 32:9 170:3 157:23 141:3 demonstrat... 31:17 35:5 152:3,6,7 46:18,20 57:23 65:4 Creek 28:21 days 61:15,17 144:20 65:11 35:8,15,16 153:15,17 49:3,4 80:8 115:19 Crimes,' 61:18 146:22 demonstrat... 39:5,19 156:14,21 50:14,18 county 82:3,4 101:10 102:11 148:7 115:18 40:5,13,24 161:19,21 51:10,22 111:15,17 criminal 134:11 150:21 Department 44:6,8 45:7 165:7 52:2,14 111:19,23 101:11 138:23 152:25 10:12 11:14 45:8,14,17 169:16 102:22,24 134:12,17 crises 72:2 144:18 declaring 13:8 27:6 103:6,7,12 173:5,7 103:2,4,14 couple 15:10 crisis 8:7 deadly 73:19 28:6 41:5 64:3 103:13,22 Councilma... 103:16,18 15:13,23 72:4 74:15 deal 22:6 decline 64:22 74:2 103:23 15:2 127:16 103:20,25 16:25 18:24 91:2 163:17 dealing 163:7 167:19 107:16 104:4,5,7,9 159:6 161:7 104:2,21,23 19:5 70:15 critical 63:15 death 64:11 decrease 108:22 104:11,12 161:8 104:25 course 19:16 163:11 164:17 17:22 89:23 117:20 104:14,15 Councilme...
105:3 25:11 65:16 Cross 162:12 debate 96:8 dedicated 142:23 104:17,19 14:25 25:14 112:10,12 65:20 culture 157:9 13:15 27:16 155:2 105:5,7,9 35:19 45:25 114:9,10 courses 65:13 130:17 decade 35:13 126:13 depression 105:11 84:22 86:23 116:13,14 court 77:24 curb 85:3 36:17 dedication 111:2 106:10,11 102:14 116:16 78:9,11 current 2:8 December 28:17 37:18 deputy 80:7 112:6,14,17 108:15 118:21 83:23 8:6 12:6 173:17,23 deduction DEREK 1:13 112:18,22 112:19 119:4 122:8 106:17 67:16 91:2 decides 74:2 23:7 deserve 66:3 113:12,19 113:13 122:15,17 114:19,21 163:5 decision 78:6 deductions 143:10 113:23,25 116:19,23 123:12,16 Court's 78:6 currently 2:4 106:16,19 23:5 deserves 114:3,7 117:24 124:10,12 covering 2:10 71:4 106:21 deem 143:25 143:11 118:20 118:24 127:20,22 70:25 163:19 113:10,16 deemed 169:25 119:21,23 119:25 128:22,24 covers 39:12 166:25 113:17 11:10 50:7 designate 120:4,5 122:9 129:3,5,8 COVID CURTIS 120:9,10,10 defeat 167:13 10:12 41:6 121:19 123:14 129:10,12 109:11 1:15 120:11,12 167:14 Designation 122:2,19 142:3,4,5,6 131:20,21 114:23 cut 88:16 143:13 defects 60:2 137:3 123:3,13,16 142:8,9,10 134:5,7 115:14 89:17 decision-m... 81:7 designations 125:15,17 153:20 139:2,4,5,7 117:14 Cuts 22:7 164:15 defer 119:24 44:20 126:17,19 156:7 139:10,12 119:7 decisions definitions designed 132:24 162:21,25 139:13,15 157:12 D 117:19 11:6 80:16 130:8 133:2 136:4 164:9 139:18,19 COVID-19 D 1:17 deck 160:16 degree 80:2,5 Despite 8:2 136:6 171:18,19 140:8,10,11 28:8 33:9 daddy 168:12 Decker 1:20 Delaware determinat... 137:11,14 Councilme... 140:13 74:16 107:8 Daily 2:16 2:25 9:25 44:22 36:5 139:8,9,16 35:22 88:22 144:21,23 107:24 dangerous 11:21 13:24 111:15,17 determine 139:17,20 116:2 142:2 144:24 108:25 58:4 25:25 30:17 111:19 16:10 139:21,22 142:11 145:2,5,7,8 109:4,17,21 dangers 41:23 42:10 delayed Detroit Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 134:13 direction dispose 58:9 89:14 125:20 education 56:17 173:13 devastating 10:14,16 127:15 Domb 1:11 126:22 30:12 35:20 101:12 ensure 33:15 19:25 20:7 41:7,10 disproporti... 3:16,17 127:24 37:8 67:18 106:7 107:9 74:8,9 74:16 160:22 60:8 73:22 31:2,12,16 130:20 92:20 94:25 107:10,12 107:2 devastation directives disruptive 31:17 35:8 131:24 151:23 107:14 110:14 20:4 117:23 88:17 35:15,16 133:5 135:3 educators emotional 142:17 develop 33:3 directly disruptor 86:23 103:6 136:9 36:8 31:7 32:14 143:23 69:5 106:5 117:25 61:3 103:7,13 137:20 effect 78:21 33:2 34:2 165:19 106:14 director 80:6 distance 139:8,9 147:17 82:7 108:8 emphasize ensures 111:11 80:7 95:3 70:21 141:19,22 149:16 effective 62:7 8:7 143:7 developed 130:13 district 15:2 141:23 151:10 effects 59:15 employed ensuring 32:18 Directors 33:20 35:12 145:3,4 152:10 60:23 73:14 91:12 125:11 developer 42:17,22 36:12 37:3 donation 173:19 74:16 80:18 employees enter 10:20 21:21 43:2,6,10 38:20 42:19 28:17 36:3 dust 65:23 effort 28:8 47:13,23 11:15 12:24 developers 43:14,18 42:23 43:3 36:24 37:2 duties 77:18 69:8 159:23 48:14 88:7 13:9 26:21 22:9 23:2 disagree 43:7,11,15 Donatucci duty 76:5 efforts 37:7 89:20 27:7 40:17 23:11 160:2 121:13 43:19 70:6 126:13 79:2 37:12 117:5 en 87:5 100:23 development disagreement 84:23 89:20 doors 170:14 dwelling 11:8 Eighth 70:6 enact 24:22 101:5 13:20 17:9 154:24 114:19 double dwindled elated 37:19 106:18 entering 19:12,21 disappointed 117:24 121:16 22:16 elect 157:19 encountered 172:5 20:12 27:23 17:4 124:3 Dougherty dying 110:7 elected 169:8 83:6 Enterprises 87:3 150:25 disclosure 127:16 72:14,15,21 169:12 encourage 11:16 13:10 158:6 160:8 47:11 48:11 134:16 72:23 E 170:10 89:9 130:10 27:9 160:11 93:6 157:14 Douglas 82:4 e-cigarette election 142:10 entire 17:6 165:15 disclosures 159:7 161:7 downwind 101:4 125:11 169:7,14,19 38:9 161:9 166:7,9,15 141:11 161:8,13 71:5 e-mail 168:25 133:25 encouraged entitled 10:10 developme... discombob... distrust dozen 71:3 earlier 134:11 170:7 11:5 12:20 20:19 150:14 165:2 Dr 58:19,20 150:14 163:23 encouraging 26:12,14 Devices,' disconnected divide-and-...
58:25 62:14 153:25 167:22 169:21 28:12,25 101:2 54:16 168:18 62:19,21 162:19 168:6 encroachm... 39:9 40:14 dialogue discount dividend 23:4 63:2,10,11 easily 62:4 elections 39:10,16 41:2,4 116:2,6,7 134:15 division 63:16 64:19 East 100:10 119:13 96:19 42:16,20,24 120:19 discovered 165:2 66:6 79:12 easy 57:5 electricity endanger 43:4,8,12 diarrhea 111:16 168:13 79:14,19 160:20 10:21 12:25 115:11 43:16 44:18 64:10 discretion Doctor 58:22 drafting eat 109:7 26:22 endeavor 47:6,8,10 died 110:5 117:21 66:9 120:22 110:10 Electronic 91:15 47:17,19 difference discriminat... document Drexel 79:25 eaten 109:2,5 101:2 endorse 48:4,6,8,9 155:10 93:20 93:9,9,10 drifting 71:7 109:14 elevate 92:12 115:10 73:23 96:16 different 141:15 documentary drink 74:11 eating 93:4 92:14,21 energy 10:25 96:21,23 12:12 13:25 discussing 34:13 drinking echo 122:20 94:6 13:5 27:2 97:9,22 17:3 102:11 162:20 dog 93:18 74:10 economic elevated enforce 95:4 98:8,10,16 113:20 discussion 94:17 drive 57:22 13:20 19:24 65:16 113:9 98:21,24 138:23 34:15 157:4 doing 31:23 161:24 27:23 38:5 eligibility enforcement 99:9,17,19 144:18 157:10 38:3 70:19 162:2,11 118:10 167:3 98:11,14 99:25 100:8 160:24 167:7 100:2 107:4 drivers 89:18 150:25 eliminate 99:20,23 100:13,15 173:11 disease 64:12 115:14 90:7 163:17 68:6 144:2 100:18,20 difficult 64:13 65:6 118:12 driving 89:5 165:20 eliminates engage 100:25 32:11,20 diseases 119:3 89:10 166:15 23:16 130:11 101:7,9,15 61:24 90:11 63:25 65:18 120:24 drug 111:2 economy eliminating engaged 101:17,23 dinner disorder 161:9 Dubrow 43:5 16:4 18:6 82:20 70:18 101:25 111:20 33:11 162:23 due 2:8 33:9 88:25 embarked 129:17 137:3 direct 68:2 disparities 168:24 Duly 8:24 Ed 39:22 158:12 engaging 138:13 117:16 17:13,21 dollar 16:16 49:9 51:4 educate emergency 160:13 141:7,13 175:24 display 130:9 dollars 35:12 124:15 144:11 2:9 54:22 enjoyed 148:11,12 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 entity 22:2 23:6,8 exempted 116:19 167:12,14 figure 16:16 five 28:12 four 22:24 26:4 26:14 28:16 101:3 expressing favor 9:6 93:5 five- 52:17 65:5 160:9 environment 92:8,9,16 exemption 35:10 46:8 49:16 filings 113:24 fixing 57:20 fourth 65:3 12:6 59:7 92:16,23,25 23:6,8 extended 51:11 62:5 final 12:3 flaunted fracking 77:16 78:5 94:7 exemptions 44:22,23 124:19 44:3 50:9 115:14 78:11 148:14 estimate 22:16 extending 125:24 50:16,23 flawed 115:8 Francis 69:17 environme... 22:22 61:16 exercise 76:6 99:6 127:2 128:3 51:24 52:7 116:7 69:18,23 28:7 36:19 et 92:10 110:20 extraordin... 130:24 53:8 91:22 flexibility 70:3,5 56:17 57:20 etched 154:3 72:3 132:5 133:9 96:11 21:14 frank 79:12 59:3 70:8 168:11 exhausted extremely 135:7 105:23 flow 123:19 79:14,19,20 74:5 75:21 ethical 86:3 68:18 23:19 158:8 136:14 138:7 148:4 focus 67:16 93:4 120:22 76:3 77:12 Ethics 103:10 exhibit extremist 137:22 150:3 67:18,19 Franklin 78:14,24 Evans 58:19 128:17 115:16 147:19 152:22 focused 119:5 132:17 80:4,12 58:20,25 exhibition eyes 71:2 149:18 167:16,23 folks 15:4 frankly 18:6 environme...
59:2 129:19 151:13 169:24 57:9 64:15 120:16 88:17 evening existed F 152:13 finally 74:17 93:15 149:6 Fraternal envision 34:10 119:14 F 165:23 173:25 78:23 87:7 157:22 172:6 89:17,21 event 34:10 existing Facebook favorable 89:24 160:11 free 56:14,23 equity 86:13 everybody 85:16 100:4 34:15 42:7 43:22 102:12 168:17 57:23 75:4 93:16,23 4:23 160:15 expand 85:15 facilities 44:11 45:3 111:13 follow 8:9 frequently 94:15 everyday expanding 10:23 13:3 46:23 48:23 138:24 86:2 115:13 especially 33:13 30:13 26:23 36:21 fears 83:15 143:24 follow-up Friday 108:8 33:10 86:22 everyone's 100:16 36:22 feature 153:7 144:19 113:13 108:19 89:12 90:10 34:17 151:25 154:23 153:11 167:22 followed 95:7 friend 156:6 120:7 144:3 eviction expect 122:22 facing 89:11 federal 18:7 financial 95:7 Froehlich 164:18,23 147:3 expectation fact 21:2 106:16 36:13 48:11 following 2:5 84:14,16,18 Esperanza evidence 55:5 36:25 61:20 fee 28:15 91:4 143:14 50:22 52:5 front 93:10 159:22 57:14 60:14 expectations 75:25 78:6 95:2 147:3 69:2 93:11,12 Esquire 63:18 143:4 80:22 82:11 feed 110:21 find 22:21 follows 53:6 94:25 137:7 13:16 27:17 109:10 experience 115:24 155:22 34:23 81:11 foot 130:7 frustration essential 154:12,20 47:12 48:13 factor 81:8 feedback 82:25 footing 115:7 165:16 155:8 175:4 58:6 92:9 faculty 75:19 172:12,15 finds 59:21 165:20 frustrations essentially exactly 113:3 experienced failed 115:8 feeding 60:10 force 47:23 115:2,5 16:15 examination 59:24 fair 54:4 115:15 fine 64:19 foregoing fuel 10:22 establish 29:6 92:20 experiencing 141:13 feel 166:13 107:19 175:7,21 13:2 26:22 88:3 142:17 examine 33:8 143:3 170:18 fines 85:22 forget 32:17 full 36:18 143:3 30:13 67:14 expertise Fairmount feelings 32:20 firm 67:10 formerly 117:20 established 151:24 59:6 135:20 33:3 first 31:19 24:4 fully 115:3 7:24 8:10 examined experts 69:3 faithfully fees 101:22 38:15 45:20 formulations 175:5 54:6 65:9 60:22 explicitly 54:6 feet 70:21 45:21 46:6 61:5 functions establishing example 37:4 88:9 fall 143:16 99:14 46:16 49:7 forward 37:5 76:8 29:2,18 examples exposed falls 76:9 fewer 155:12 49:14,24 87:12 94:9 Fund 124:4 30:5 91:14 130:6 63:23 familiar fiduciary 50:8,13 95:13 funding 69:9 98:17 100:9 exams 92:10 111:21 113:17 77:18 55:9 70:10 144:10 further 89:5 135:18 excepted exposure families field 69:4 77:5 78:16 157:9 164:5 116:5 148:20,21 100:21 59:24 62:3 31:25 33:19 143:6 85:15 107:8 165:17 future 11:2 establishm... exchange 64:8 36:8 73:16 fields 61:13 108:16 167:6 172:8 13:6 27:2 138:15 23:9 exposures family 89:7 64:7 67:25 149:5 172:3 172:11 65:12 77:21 establishm... Excuse 122:8 59:20 60:9 110:22 69:10 70:9 first-class fouling 79:5 89:18 130:4 100:21 executing 60:11,23 111:20 Fifth 15:2 38:4 Foulkrod 143:14 101:3 86:7 express 73:5 far 74:13 Fifty-Second firsthand 99:6 166:10 estate 11:5 executive 87:7 fashioned 29:4,7 73:14 found 2:18 167:8 12:20 19:22 106:17 expressed 21:17 fifty-six fiscal 11:2 65:16 22:9 23:2,4 114:23 70:22 71:2 fathers 99:14 13:6 27:2 154:10 G Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 gains 23:10 130:15 Godfrey gotten 19:19 161:20,21 159:22 110:25 142:10 23:16 gift 38:23 100:10 21:4 23:21 162:10 half 61:14,17 111:3 hell 93:21 game 22:6 Gilmore 1:12 goes 94:9 107:21 grief 31:4,22 61:21 115:21 Hello 56:2 23:25 25:3 4:7 28:5 164:2 government 32:4,11,13 hands 18:9 117:20 66:21,22,25 gap 17:22 35:22 going 2:3 46:19,22 32:20 34:9 59:18 148:11 75:10 87:23 86:21 103:19 19:8 33:4 47:5 63:25 34:13 160:16 149:10 129:5,8 garage 90:8 124:10 70:12 83:16 77:17 107:4 grieve 89:7 Hank 130:8 154:25 help 23:25 90:16 139:14 94:11,13,23 165:3,3 grieving 31:6 happen 18:12 155:2,5 34:21,23 garden 70:16 142:3 145:9 107:17 Governor 31:7 32:24 121:4 159:3 163:16 36:3 38:14 71:4 99:24 171:14 108:4,6,7 113:9 ground 59:17 happened healthcare 62:21 86:19 gardener Girls 132:18 108:18 114:22 groundbre...
18:14 20:4 154:2,23 94:5,14 70:17 71:8 give 14:10 109:19 GPAR 130:12 70:16 155:21 173:12 gas 10:22 19:5 52:18 117:14 142:16 grounds 64:7 happening healthier helped 70:9 13:2 26:22 83:7 142:20 155:13,14 grades 99:2 71:23 17:9 75:3 169:7 78:11 157:20 155:14,17 99:11 148:17 happens 32:8 healthy 57:11 helpful 68:24 gather 158:14,15 160:8,10 grand 166:7 group 56:24 happier 67:24 71:24 helping 95:14 158:16 161:25 162:22 grandchild... 71:3 117:17 35:17 73:8 148:12 helps 32:25 gathering 162:24 164:9 79:7 119:5 happy 4:2 148:14 118:6 155:12 170:5 golf 65:13,16 grant 107:10 169:24 118:5 hear 19:14 Henon 1:14 gatherings given 61:19 65:19 107:11 growing 57:7 harass 85:19 37:19 56:6 5:3,4 104:4 155:16 108:11 good 2:2 3:4 granted guess 14:8 hard 57:11 58:20 63:2 104:5 Gauthier giving 90:12 3:7,11,12 107:9 113:8 55:23 58:8 115:25 63:4,7 139:20,21 1:12 3:23 90:15,18 3:14,17,20 grants 77:13 168:10 117:4 64:15,18 145:15,16 3:24 35:23 glad 83:7 3:24,25 4:4 grappling guide 160:22 142:16 69:24 70:2 147:9,11 39:9 103:15 164:8 4:8,9,10,12 129:23 guidelines 160:21 72:16 75:11 Henry 30:6 103:16 gleefully 4:15,16,17 grassroots 8:9 86:3 hard-worki... 79:14,16 herbicide 131:20,21 18:10 4:19,22,23 56:24 92:21 93:2 125:8 81:20 87:18 64:2 74:4 139:11,12 global 163:16 4:25 5:4,5,7 grateful 167:3 harder 160:6 herbicides 142:8 145:6 165:18 5:16,18,20 56:18 gun 33:10 159:10 166:14 57:15 60:15 145:7 gloves 70:24 5:21,24,25 gratitude Gutmann harm 63:19 heard 20:2 61:2,10 Gauthier's glyphosate 6:2,3,6,7,9 35:10 37:23 37:15 38:22 68:5 64:21 80:19 62:5 63:19 84:22 60:16,20,24 6:19,22 7:2 great 8:2 Gutmann's harmful 60:9 81:7 157:15 63:20 65:7 general 59:25 60:25 61:15 7:5,9,12,16 20:13 21:7 36:5 73:14 169:9 171:9 65:10,21 65:19 97:12 64:22,24 7:18,22,23 95:17 111:8 guys 83:5 harms 62:3 172:9,15 66:2 68:7 97:25 113:5 70:20 74:19 24:14 32:22 142:25 84:4 65:10 hearing 73:18 74:20 121:20 80:19 32:23 52:25 162:5 166:6 gym 1:13 Hate 101:9 16:11 30:19 79:5 80:16 125:10 go 36:6,17,18 55:15,17,25 greater 61:4 4:21,22 hatred 30:23 82:20 83:2 generally 38:6,14 56:6,7 87:8 142:15 103:25 101:13 171:23 83:18 32:6 71:22 83:10 58:22 62:15 156:2 104:2 hazardous 172:4 148:15 generations 92:24 62:23 63:12 greatly 60:5 109:16 36:19 80:18 hearings herewith 65:12 77:22 110:10 69:18,20 90:22 110:10 health 2:9 8:7 13:20 27:24 10:7 gentrificati... 111:18 72:15,17 green 1:13 112:10,12 56:16,19,20 30:13 Hi 58:25 15:18 17:11 120:25 75:13,16 4:14,15 114:9,10 57:20 59:3 133:23 69:18 72:21 gentrifying 129:10 82:25 83:10 35:23 88:25 116:19,23 59:6,7,15 134:20 high 20:20 86:15 94:14 143:20 84:16 87:20 103:22,23 139:18,19 62:8 63:15 150:25 40:7 George 154:18 91:25 92:2 112:6,14,17 142:10 65:10 67:20 151:24 higher 59:22 135:21,24 155:23 96:23 143:7 112:18 145:13,14 67:23 68:2 hearts 38:11 60:10 110:8 germanely 162:8 170:3 161:12 113:12,23 155:14 70:8 74:15 hearty 170:6 highest 168:6 89:25 goal 88:5 172:25 114:3 gyms 153:24 76:12 79:6 heavy 77:23 168:9 getting 20:16 97:7 Goode 118:20 154:10,14 79:24 80:8 heighten highlight 20:18 24:8 goals 88:21 168:15 119:21,23 154:18,22 89:4 100:24 94:20 31:21 163:14 138:16,17 goods 47:16 139:16,17 101:6 held 52:12 hinder 88:21 Giant 128:15 164:12 GOP 115:12 145:11,12 H 107:18,18 119:11 hiring 21:24 129:16 God 174:10 Gosia 42:17 158:13 HACE 108:22,23 Helen 1:13 Hispanic Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 60:11 18:9 112:3 71:11 88:2 132:5 133:9 100:24 154:5 invocation hold 13:20 123:20 ignorance incentives 136:14 101:6 interests 91:5 8:3 18:9 27:23 hopeless 95:16 19:16,18 151:13 infrastruct... intergenera...
involved 30:12 34:14 157:19,21 ignore 78:13 22:12 154:22 36:14 86:20 24:24 58:14 54:5 112:9 HopeLine illegally 85:7 include 23:3 173:25 ingredient 158:16 170:17 121:14 33:19 illnesses 60:9 29:5 85:13 indicated 60:17 internal 80:3 involving 133:23 HOPS 75:24 73:19 included 2:14 20:24 ingredients interrupted 101:11 134:20 76:15,24 imagine 33:8 includes 23:9 indication 61:5 64:5 57:17 irrefutable 150:25 77:8 78:18 130:4 75:2 78:2 150:6 inhalational intersection 73:17 151:24 hormone immediately including individually 59:20 29:13 98:14 irresponsib... holding 119:2 61:3 96:9 10:24 12:2 116:5 Initiative 99:23 100:6 117:2 home 22:15 hosting 34:9 impact 19:25 13:4 26:24 individuals 25:5 intimidation irresponsible 36:10 76:11 hour 2:19 24:25 68:2 77:21 80:13 16:19,20 initiatives 133:24 115:10 86:8,17 153:25 159:13 82:5 86:12 18:24 20:25 118:13 INTRO 11:1 116:24 155:13 hours 56:25 167:21 91:12 97:6 24:16 37:11 injustice 12:1 13:1 irritants 61:6 166:19 61:12 impacted 101:21 60:12 164:4 57:21 14:1 15:1 Isaiah 1:18 homeless 142:24 60:8 164:20 102:5 indoor innovative 16:1 17:1 142:6 89:22 159:2 172:14 impacts 60:6 115:17 100:22 72:6 18:1 19:1 isolation Homelessn... house 24:22 imperative 148:18 101:4 input 18:19 20:1 21:1 110:19 131:12 85:18 74:21 inclusion indulge 14:2 142:17,25 22:1 23:1 issue 24:12 homeowner 133:21 implement 96:6 120:20 14:15 inquire 110:3 24:1 25:1 63:16 70:14 85:21 93:11 143:18 69:5 inclusionary indulgence 110:14 26:1 27:1 80:9 97:14 homeowners houses 85:7 implement... 158:20,21 14:3,16 Inquirer 2:16 28:1 29:1 98:3 107:20 22:13 85:11 166:16 97:19 inclusive 24:10 inside 33:5 30:1 31:1 109:24 85:17,20 housing 24:3 implementi... 106:5,15 industrial 36:20 32:1 33:1 144:5 155:3 86:5,16 90:21 158:5 106:7 108:21 11:9 installation 34:1 35:1 163:16 141:12,16 158:9,20,21 110:17 111:11 industries 29:12 98:13 36:1 37:1 issued 22:22 143:10 human 60:18 implications 121:11 18:25 88:17 99:22 38:1 39:1 155:4 144:11 89:21 163:6 144:2 industry Institute 40:1 issues 15:14 Homeowne... 142:23 implore 73:6 164:15 16:21 18:16 72:24 73:13 introduced 107:24 84:20 humans importance income 167:3 19:12,13,15 institutions 14:5,21 111:3 115:4 homes 143:5 80:19 165:14 Incorporated 19:25 20:23 37:12,25 15:24 16:8 163:13 143:11,18 hundred important 11:17 13:11 21:4 22:4 38:13 16:12 73:9 164:16 158:25 35:11 96:20 31:21 33:25 27:9 23:20 24:17 instructing 119:10 item 53:17 honor 31:23 hundreds 34:25 85:14 increase 73:25 74:12 91:7 151:3 152:3 items 54:21 37:11 56:25 82:16 115:4 19:20 60:19 85:6,12 Instructions introducing 100:16 honorable Hunger 117:23 85:11 86:14 88:7 2:12 111:9 117:8 10:8 131:12 121:14 increased 90:5 91:13 instructs introduction ivy 71:10 honoring Hunting 130:16 60:2 64:25 97:4 88:10 11:23 15:6 13:15 27:15 158:2 142:12 69:8 109:21 inequity instrument invest 18:22 J 31:5 35:9 Hurtt 39:22 149:9 157:5 110:23,25 129:23 68:14 investing J 1:16 39:21 40:6 hysteria importantly increasing inert 61:5 Intelligencer 159:13 Jack 43:9 124:2 125:7 115:15 111:25 17:21 59:19 inform 108:2 2:16 165:15 Jamie 1:12 126:12 imposes incredible information intend 54:5 investment 142:8 128:15 I 77:16 36:2 34:5,7 161:11 15:19 24:4 Jefferson 131:14 Icahn 59:4 improve 37:9 incumbent 47:21 57:4 intent 28:6 24:5 69:12 29:22,22,25 132:17 idea 88:14 91:10 91:10 94:22 112:7 intention 157:5 Jeremiah 156:21 107:22 improved indicate 2:22 112:15,19 120:7 investments 160:17 157:17 115:20 115:25 9:6 46:8 122:23 interest 23:7 24:5 157:7 JFK 167:10 hope 24:12 ideal 53:24 improving 49:17 51:11 123:19 28:16 investors job 124:5 33:22 ideas 116:9 88:6 102:16 154:21 interested 86:18 93:23 142:25 120:16,16 identified inability 124:19 155:7 163:4 122:11 invite 53:22 170:9,10,11 156:4 165:24 110:20,21 125:24 164:11,25 150:6 120:18 jobs 20:12,16 hopefully identify inappropri... 127:2 128:3 informatio...
109:9,23,24 90:19 170:9 levels 21:11 listen 94:12 18:17 25:8 1:12 111:24 landlord leadership 59:22,23 listened longtime magnified Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 17:14 27:16 154:11 messages missions 88:6 7:6,10,13 134:25 92:3 main 114:14 Marcha 87:5 media 67:12 10:2 mistake 7:17,19,23 136:7 narrative 120:15 Marchetti-... 170:13 messaging 32:15 7:23 53:2 137:18 117:7 maintain 172:2 medical 116:25 misuse 55:15,18,25 147:15 nation 162:17 77:19 96:18 Maria 1:17 33:21 57:14 119:12 101:11 56:6,8 149:14 163:5,7,10 100:4 154:3 35:19 63:18,21,22 met 108:13 Mitch 18:9 58:22 62:16 151:8 152:8 163:20 maintained 119:25 80:2 153:23 112:3 mitigated 62:23 63:12 165:17 national 57:8 70:21 142:4 154:2 metal 39:12 62:4 69:19,21 moved 9:2 117:3 maintenance 156:18 medicine 100:4 modifying 72:15,18 46:3 49:11 123:25 76:8,25 Mark 1:17 59:3,4 method 68:15 12:21 26:15 75:13,16 51:6 124:17 131:12 Maitreyi 81:19 82:2 79:25 80:3 methods 62:6 moment 8:4 84:16 87:20 125:22 154:20 100:2 142:3 80:4 68:17 8:11,13 91:25 92:3 126:24 nationally majority 153:21 meet 31:7 168:19 14:13 31:19 mortality 128:2 109:13 25:22 market 19:23 meeting 1:3 Michael 1:20 129:15 65:15 130:22 nationwide 105:17 80:23 93:24 2:10,12,13 84:14,18 130:3 mosques 132:2 133:7 154:10 140:24 143:10 2:15,17 MICHELE moments 169:21 135:5 native 67:11 142:7 market-rate 8:17,22 9:4 175:15 123:17 motion 45:25 136:11 natural 10:22 146:19 17:8 52:21 53:3 Michigan mommy 50:15 51:18 151:12 13:2 26:22 156:16 Marlborou... nearby 65:20 management 102:2 147:2 42:13 47:14 Milnor 98:18 89:15 motivated 78:4,13 nearly 154:7 67:21 74:24 Matthias 48:15 56:13 mind 165:21 130:12 101:12 MURPHY 172:3 managers 99:15 56:21 63:13 166:8 months 17:2 motor 10:22 175:15 necessary 82:10,22 Mayor 10:2 75:17 79:21 167:11 117:15 13:2 26:22 muscle 64:9 68:20 managing 153:23 105:17 168:11 118:7,7 Mount 59:4 mute 62:20 115:25 34:21 84:19 168:16 121:24 169:6 Montour mouth 70:25 66:16,19 need 8:2 17:5 95:3 Mayor's 125:9 minds 15:25 99:5 mouths 59:18 muted 54:15 18:22 19:20 mandatory 115:2 137:18 33:5 38:11 Monumental move 8:21 24:15,17 158:20 171:24 140:24 mine 161:15 128:16 20:22 37:4 N 32:19 33:2 manhole McConnell 146:19 minority 129:19,25 45:9,13,15 name 2:23 33:16 34:24 39:12 18:9 147:15 153:14 morning 2:3 45:19 49:5 18:25 53:16 37:6 45:15 manifested mean 17:18 149:13 173:4 3:5,8,12,13 50:19 55:23 55:9 56:9 68:3 80:15 74:5 23:19 58:7 153:4,8 minors 3:15,17,21 88:13 95:13 56:13 58:23 80:21 89:21 manipulation meaning 68:5 171:20 100:23 3:25 4:2,5,9 124:13 62:23 63:7 95:9 143:12 80:23 164:8 men 168:21 101:5 4:10,10,13 125:18 63:16 67:4 157:7 manner meaningful mental 111:3 minutes 4:16,17,18 126:20 69:21 70:5 160:20 143:25 17:7 25:24 mentor 19:9 53:25 54:4 4:20,23,23 127:22 72:18,22 161:15 Mansion 87:4 means 68:16 merely 71:16 111:14 5:2,5,6,8,17 128:25 75:13,19 164:21 Maps 44:19 154:18 Merion 70:11 misguided 5:19,21,22 129:14 79:16,19 166:11,12 marathon 175:23 message 88:12 5:25,25 6:2 130:18 81:22,25 166:19 171:22 measures 116:5 164:6 mission 38:8 6:4,6,7,10 131:22 82:2 84:18 170:5 Marcel 13:16 106:8 107:9 168:25 38:15 6:20,23 7:3 133:3 134:9 87:21,23 needed 25:10 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 25:23,24 Newsstands,' 123:24,24 offers 12:16 ongoing 28:8 152:16 166:10 overwhelm... 154:3 100:15 129:21 12:18 13:18 144:11 174:5 organic 62:6 63:19 needs 31:7 nickel 167:2 131:11 26:12 27:21 OOPA opt 85:17 organically owe 156:9 32:14 34:2 nine 114:18 134:12 28:5,12 158:23 option 16:18 70:10 owner 93:11 34:21 36:14 Non-Comp... number 30:11 31:3 open 99:4 options 30:13 organization owners 90:8 81:10,11 48:10 16:15 19:4 35:9 39:9 153:25 151:24 73:11 ownership 94:5 121:4 non-Hodge... 53:16,16 39:20 40:5 158:13 Orange 63:24 organizatio... m 53:13 93:16 non-pesticide numbers 85:13 115:2 operating 9:24 11:22 160:9 169:7 161:25 negotiations 83:21 170:24 155:13 85:25 119:8 14:9 41:24 170:11 174:13 172:6 Non-profes... nursery 158:12 operational... 50:3 53:11 organize pace 17:8 neighborho...
94:3 67:11 171:24 117:23 54:4 79:3 170:5 pages 57:13 13:21 25:5 non-profit offices 90:21 operator 143:13 organizer paint 81:2 27:25 87:6 160:2 O officials 67:11 153:9 72:23 pandemic 151:2 non-solicita... o'clock 108:5 169:8 operators 162:10 Orianna 17:15 20:7 160:25 95:5,6 108:19 170:10 65:16 172:6 135:24 101:21 165:15 non-toxic O'Neill 1:16 Oh 1:15 6:5,6 opinion 37:10 orders originally 102:5 166:15 68:17 6:12,15 31:14 64:19 opportunities 114:23 73:4 138:19 neighborho... non-use 83:2 40:14 70:3 104:14 16:5 17:13 ordinance originated 163:8,15 15:15,17 nonchalance 104:18,19 104:15 17:23,25 10:9,19 154:14 164:20 16:5 20:5 71:18 140:6,7 106:10,11 18:3 19:18 11:3,13 orphan 165:18 22:7 24:4,7 norm 157:4 145:25 112:19,22 21:9 38:5 12:18,23 167:13,15 panel 34:14 38:6 85:8 normalcy 146:2 113:13,19 82:13,23 13:7 26:13 Orthodox paper 94:6 86:16 33:13 object 96:6 113:25 97:3 26:19 27:5 44:23 94:24 97:20 143:16,21 Norris 158:3 objection 118:25 opportunity 28:12,24 Osage 39:14 paragraphs 157:8 159:22 96:8 120:4,5 12:8 15:20 29:2,11,17 ought 115:22 114:18 158:14 North 10:14 objections 122:2,12 17:12 19:21 30:4 39:10 out-of-cont... parcels 28:19 165:16 10:17 41:7 175:4 123:3,13 20:18 21:6 40:15 41:2 85:4 159:24 166:7 41:10 obligate 140:3,4 22:5 23:11 44:18 47:6 out-of-town park 29:18 Neighbors 127:15 10:24 13:4 145:22,23 23:14 63:14 47:18 48:5 86:18 30:5 57:2 160:5 130:10 26:25 153:16,17 65:24 67:13 75:24 76:9 outcome 90:12 158:2 neurological 135:19,22 obligation 156:21 67:15,18,19 76:15 77:9 58:13 Parker 1:16 65:18 Northeast 93:14,16 164:9 70:5 72:5 78:18 79:3 163:23 6:18,19 neurotoxin 40:7 obligations Oh's 162:21 75:18 82:7,10 outdoor 9:17,18 61:3 Nos 49:8 78:14 okay 33:17 108:16 96:16,22 57:12 73:8 12:16 13:18 neurotoxins 50:24 52:8 observe 8:4 56:4 63:2 124:6 97:10,11,13 148:13 14:6,12,18 61:7 nose 70:25 obviously 64:19,20 158:14 97:23,24 outlet 130:2 14:22 25:13 never 83:22 note 2:19 74:14 67:4 83:13 162:25 98:2,9,17 outside 25:22 26:12 170:17,21 50:5 121:20 occasion 84:9 109:12 opposed 9:10 98:22,23,24 115:18 27:21 42:2 new 11:7 153:5 128:16 114:3 46:12 49:20 99:10,18 overall 40:9 42:4 45:11 17:18 20:12 notes 175:6 occupational 150:20 51:15 100:2,9,14 68:20 45:23 46:18 20:18 22:24 notice 2:15 80:4 154:15 124:23 100:19 132:19 46:20 49:3 23:2,4 57:4 85:20 October old 36:22 126:4 127:6 101:8,16,24 overdoses 49:4 50:14 59:5 69:5 noticed 22:15 114:24 42:18,22 128:7 131:3 135:17 33:12 50:18 51:10 73:2 88:25 notified 129:21 43:2,6 132:9 136:25 overlap 77:6 51:22 52:2 96:23 98:19 108:3 offer 2:13 older 36:23 133:13 138:11 78:18 99:13 141:7 novel 101:20 100:17 Omar 169:2 135:10 141:5,14 overlapping 104:22,23 148:12 102:4 137:15 once 54:7,13 136:18 146:24 72:2 122:8 140:9 news 2:16 November 147:12 134:10 138:2 148:9 overnight 140:10 108:12 1:7 8:17,22 149:11 one-hundred 147:23 ordinances 82:17 142:7 146:4 newsstands 9:4 31:4 offered 12:14 99:14 149:22 78:4 overreliance 146:5 151:4 100:17 41:15 41:20 ones 73:21 151:17 ordinary 68:15 151:6,7 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 165:9,10 112:20,23 Peace 171:8 people's 68:13 69:4 146:25 115:19 174:10 171:18 113:18,22 peer-revie... D 80:5 167:24 106:5,14 78:8 99:13 96:24 97:4 160:12 pending 110:10,11 PHA 160:17 168:5 169:4 111:11 112:7,15,18 97:6,7 161:4 106:21 134:17 161:4 170:7,25 158:12 120:15 98:17 100:9 partnerships 113:7 154:13 PHA-owned 171:20 planning 163:4 135:18 37:6,21 120:11 158:21 159:24 173:13 159:21 pointed 22:3 Parkinson's parts 95:16 Penn 34:12 159:8 Philadelphia Philadelphi... plant 67:11 poison 58:9 64:12 party 167:25 36:25 38:21 performance 1:2,6 4:11 13:21 27:24 plants 80:17 70:18 71:10 parks 64:3,6 pass 61:13 168:7 47:25 6:2 10:7,10 36:3 76:12 plastered 73:24 64:21 67:24 62:8 65:25 Pennsylvania period 86:7 11:4 12:20 131:16 85:8 police 76:10 69:9 73:24 71:24 73:7 1:6 35:11 99:6 154:9 20:6 25:7 151:2 166:5 plate 24:18 172:7 73:25 74:9 79:2 102:12 36:2 40:21 162:18 26:14 30:15 167:16,19 25:2 82:24 policy 57:22 76:8 81:13 138:24 67:12 76:4 permission 31:8,25 Philadelphi...
play 59:10,16 70:8 88:9 82:5,6,11 144:19 76:16 77:11 58:10 32:8 33:6 90:24 91:12 61:13,20,25 142:18 82:17,17,18 passage 12:3 77:14,17,24 permit 45:20 35:13 36:7 124:6 64:6 74:9 political 82:18 44:3 50:10 78:19 80:13 46:5 49:7 36:9 37:13 166:10,22 158:10 126:14 148:18 50:16,23 113:6 49:13 50:20 38:4,12,15 Philly 33:19 163:20 164:5 158:14 51:24 52:7 Pennsylvan... 51:8 38:24 39:15 56:15,23 played 171:5 politicize Parkside 53:9 56:22 77:21 permitting 40:10,18,21 75:4 125:18 playgrounds 120:7 29:19,21,25 59:11 63:17 people 17:16 100:23 41:4 42:14 PHL 6:21 148:20 politics part 81:5 69:2 96:11 17:18 20:3 101:5 44:19 47:7 171:8 playing 67:25 170:17 109:22 105:23 20:15,17,21 perpetuated 48:6 63:22 PHLCounc... 69:9 143:6 poor 89:3 118:8 138:7 143:2 24:6,7 34:3 115:12 64:3 65:3,5 2:18 please 2:20 popped partial 34:11 148:5 150:4 54:3 57:25 persists 66:3 67:10 phone 53:16 2:22 8:8,9 122:13 participants 152:22 71:12 81:12 134:22 71:23 73:4 pick 130:8 10:2 12:12 population 55:4 passages 93:21 94:5 person 17:3 74:4,20,24 picking 19:11 14:2,15,19 110:9 participate 113:15 94:20 95:2 18:20 21:21 79:4 81:10 piece 119:15 25:25 34:18 portion 40:19 162:8 passed 54:13 95:9 106:24 53:21 84:24 87:2 pieces 164:24 38:10 42:10 99:2,4,11 166:24 65:12 78:10 107:5 109:18 87:9 88:4 pin 95:11 44:14 47:2 portions 169:15,22 90:4 105:20 108:15,24 172:18 90:10,14,17 Pine 137:7 54:25 55:9 113:21 participation passes 141:2 109:3,10,13 personal 87:8 96:22,24 pipeline 58:22 67:6 positive 33:3 21:10,23 146:21 110:5 personally 98:10 99:19 30:14 83:20 72:20 75:15 108:25 167:20 passing 78:4 122:22 37:16 100:15,20 151:25 94:12 96:3 123:7 172:19 91:9 129:18 personnel 101:9,17,25 pivot 57:5 96:12 154:12 particles passionate 144:7 77:2 109:4 place 36:7 102:20 155:11 65:22 15:12 24:12 154:18 persons 111:17,21 37:13 105:24 possession particular passthrough 155:13,20 101:14 125:7,12 108:18 112:9 122:7 10:4 153:22 14:4,13 23:4 157:17,19 pesticide 127:14 116:6 125:4 126:9 possible 2:12 19:12,15 path 18:11 158:25 60:10 61:4 128:18 129:20 127:11 15:9 36:16 21:3 65:23 pay 88:6 159:8,13,18 61:21 62:2 129:18 154:11 128:12 53:9 58:13 particularly 110:20 160:20,23 65:22 73:25 130:10,17 156:24 131:8 possibly 16:4,20 155:21 163:9,21 76:16,18,21 131:13 placed 12:3 132:14 119:2 59:13 78:8 paycheck 164:11,18 77:8 78:19 132:20 44:2 46:15 133:18 potential 149:10 22:19 167:18 78:21 137:3 49:24 50:9 135:15 97:5 168:19 payment 168:23 pesticides 138:13 96:10 138:7 136:23 poverty 171:2 10:25 13:5 169:9,14,22 59:9,16,17 141:6,13 148:4 150:3 138:9 141:3 110:19 parties 24:24 26:25 170:2,4,8 59:22 60:6 142:15,22 places 32:9 146:22 power 76:2,7 24:25 77:4 166:20 170:12,13 65:14 68:7 143:3,16 61:10 148:7 162:8 76:10 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 powers 6:7,9,20,22 84:11,17 149:5,17,21 108:8 153:4 47:10,19 152:12 76:21 107:12,14 7:3,5,10,12 87:14,19 149:24 158:7 172:4 48:8 properties 129:25 PPR 68:22 7:18,20,22 91:20 92:2 150:9,11,17 prioritize Procureme... 71:14 providing 69:3 8:14,21,25 95:18,22,23 150:19 28:6 89:2 47:9 48:7 159:25 24:6 38:23 practice 9:9,12,19 102:8 103:8 151:5,8,11 90:11 91:4 product property 58:12 61:12 9:22 10:5 103:11 151:16,19 privacy 55:5 80:24 23:17 28:14 101:21 practices 11:20 12:18 105:13,15 152:5,8,11 private 76:23 products 40:16 76:9 102:5 124:5 67:17 94:16 13:13,23 106:9,12 152:15,18 77:4 148:21 58:2 80:25 77:2 85:5 159:4 141:14 14:23 15:3 112:7,8,13 152:23,24 privileged professional 86:9 90:8 provision 143:8 24:22 25:17 112:15,16 153:18 12:2 48:19 59:6 93:11,18 47:21 practicing 25:20 26:7 114:5,6,11 156:12,13 probable 92:15 94:12 94:21 141:8 public 2:8,13 95:10 26:11,17 115:23 156:20 60:17 professiona... 141:10,11 2:14 3:6,19 Pratt 13:16 27:3,11,14 116:12,17 157:3 probably 70:7 proposal 88:9 4:18 8:6 27:17 27:18 28:2 117:3,6 159:16 84:3 professionals 91:17 12:8 16:11 prayer 8:5 28:9,22 118:17,18 160:7 problem 52:19 85:25 172:13 28:13,21 precaution...
29:9,15 119:18 161:17,22 68:14 94:22 92:23 95:10 proposed 34:12,19 68:4 30:2,8,16 120:3 165:5,6,11 120:14 154:2 75:24 36:3 38:2 predatory 30:19,20,23 121:18 165:11,23 134:21 Professor protect 62:8 40:10,16 85:3 86:10 30:24 31:9 122:4,9,12 166:13,22 150:12 59:2 79:24 76:11 79:3 48:17 52:16 predict 61:24 31:11,14,18 123:10,11 167:6,10 problem-so... 79:25 81:12 93:7 53:1,6,7,14 preempt 77:8 35:3,4,14 123:15 168:24 72:6 profit 23:17 170:19 54:1,23 78:3 35:17 36:4 124:7,13,16 169:24 problems 57:24 86:12 protecting 55:1,2,3 preempted 37:15 38:17 124:22,25 171:10,11 60:4 72:7 program 78:5 56:1,16 76:16 38:21 39:3 125:13,18 171:16 83:5 89:4 97:20 protection 57:1,12,19 preemption 39:4,17,20 125:21 172:21,22 111:2 programs 70:23 85:14 58:1 59:1,3 78:17 40:2,11,22 126:3,6,15 173:8,15,20 122:24 166:24 protections 59:5,25 preemptive 41:12,17,21 126:20,23 174:4,7 141:17 167:4 141:14,16 60:1 61:1 78:21 41:22 42:5 127:5,8,17 President-e... procedure progressive protective 61:10 62:1 preempts 42:8,12 127:25 18:8 12:7 89:13 61:14 70:25 63:1,14,15 76:19 43:23 44:9 128:6,9,19 presidential proceed prohibit protects 64:1 65:1 Preferences 44:12 45:4 128:25 133:25 52:15 56:10 100:21 142:18 65:19 66:1 138:14 45:9,13,18 129:2,6,9 press 122:23 58:23 62:24 101:2 148:14 66:2 67:1 premise 68:4 45:18 46:2 129:13 pretext 115:7 63:8 67:5 prohibiting proud 36:9 67:14,22 premises 46:11,14,21 130:21 Prevent 69:22 72:19 148:16 157:24,25 68:1,2,8 40:20 147:5 46:24 48:24 131:2,5,17 98:12 99:21 75:14 79:17 prohibition 158:2,17 69:1 70:1,7 present 1:9 49:5,10,19 131:22,25 prevention 81:23 87:21 100:22 171:7 70:10 71:1 2:23 3:6,13 49:22 50:19 132:8,11,22 159:2 proceedings 101:4 proudly 71:23 72:1 7:11,17 51:5,14,17 133:3,6,12 previous 175:4 promise 159:14 73:1,8,13 34:11 38:19 52:3,13,24 133:15 153:19 process 33:3 25:10 proven 62:6 74:1,14 130:3 55:13,17,22 134:2,8 priced 20:19 69:2 109:25 promote 65:7 75:1 76:1 presented 56:3,7,12 135:4,9,12 pride 125:18 112:2 78:11 provide 11:6 77:1,20 36:15 58:16,21 136:2,7,10 primarily 117:18 148:13 12:7 32:25 78:1 79:1 preservation 62:11,15,22 136:17,20 134:13 120:20 propensity 38:5 86:5 79:24 80:1 25:5 77:15 63:6,12 137:9,15,21 Primavera 121:11,14 61:19 96:25 81:1 82:1,5 preserve 64:17 66:4 137:25 42:17 143:9 proper 94:21 101:10 83:1 84:1 86:19 66:8,20,23 138:4,20 prime 37:3 164:15 109:25 141:15 85:1 86:1 President 67:3 69:14 140:20,22 primrose 169:15 properly 9:3 147:3 87:1 88:1 1:10 2:2 69:20,25 141:18,21 18:10 proclaiming 46:4 49:12 162:22 89:1 90:1 3:5,7,12,14 72:11,17 141:24 principal 41:15 51:7 126:24 provided 91:1 92:1 3:18,20,25 73:3 75:6 144:14,15 67:9 131:11 128:2 57:11 93:1 94:1 4:4,9,12,16 75:12,17 146:15,17 principle Procurement 130:22 110:15 95:1,21 4:19,25 5:5 79:9,15,20 147:6,12,18 68:4 106:23 10:20 11:14 132:3 133:7 providers 106:7 5:7,17,18 81:16,21 147:22,25 prior 2:17 12:24 13:8 135:5 33:21 110:13 5:21,25 6:3 83:9 84:6 148:23 47:11 48:12 26:20 27:6 151:12 provides 126:13 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 128:17 puts 65:23 Randall 118:1 119:1 52:22,23 172:9 47:5 112:20 rely 155:17 129:19 putting 93:9 43:13 120:1 121:1 recognition reconnect reflect 130:2 155:18 130:11 rapidly 59:19 122:1 123:1 34:8 55:24 reform 72:5 remaining 132:21 Q 86:15 124:1 125:1 recognize record 40:9 refunding 54:10,11 148:13,15 quality 89:4 rarely 14:3 126:1 127:1 35:25 37:7 56:9 58:23 97:18 98:7 remapped 148:17 97:3 14:15 128:1 129:1 71:25 74:2 62:24 63:8 regard 81:4 159:8 155:15 Queen 91:23 rate 110:8 130:1 131:1 80:15 67:5 69:22 regarding remarks 156:10 91:25 92:5 RCOs 159:7 132:1 133:1 129:15 72:19 75:14 47:21 86:8 54:14 158:11 92:5 reach 83:12 134:1 135:1 142:13 79:17 81:23 153:5 remember 172:3 question reaching 136:1 137:1 173:5 87:21 92:4 164:16 167:11 173:12 102:11 23:13 37:22 138:1 139:1 recognized 114:12 registered 168:10 175:16 138:23 138:17 140:1 141:1 17:16 31:13 132:20 169:22 remind 54:12 public-priv...
144:18 read 10:2 142:1 143:1 141:19 153:6 registration 157:23 37:6 questionable 12:12 25:25 144:1 145:1 153:9 recorded 76:22 reminded publicized 144:4 26:6 42:10 146:1 147:1 recognizes 55:2,7 169:19 58:4 108:12 questions 44:15 47:2 148:1 149:1 8:18 9:17 recover regular 51:24 reminder publish 75:20 83:4,8,11 51:10 55:9 150:1 151:1 14:24 31:15 138:18 96:10 11:24 published 84:5 111:5 96:3,5,13 152:1 35:15 42:2 recovery 105:22 reminding 2:15 73:23 quick 15:8,9 102:10 real 11:5 44:5 45:6 28:8 regulate 77:3 160:22 168:7 quiet 56:16 105:25 12:20 15:8 46:17 49:2 recreation 141:9 161:23 Puertorriq... Quinones-S... 108:10 19:21 22:9 50:14 51:21 148:19 regulated remote 2:6 87:4 1:17 6:25 112:24 23:2,4,5,8 106:10 recreational 143:24 2:11 12:6 pull 71:13 35:19 105:2 113:17,20 24:6,7,14 114:8 124:9 28:21 regulation 53:22 54:16 pulled 162:23 116:15 113:23 26:14 28:16 125:15 red 98:11,12 29:3,18 remotely purchase 118:21 122:7 92:8,9,15 126:17 98:13 99:20 30:5 98:18 2:10 10:21 11:17 120:2 123:21 92:16,23,25 127:19 99:21,22 100:10 remove 10:15 12:25 13:11 127:20 125:4 126:9 94:7 141:10 128:21 162:11 regulations 41:9 134:15 26:21 27:9 140:12 127:11 reality 20:14 131:19 redcrossblo... 29:6 92:25 removed 96:9 28:16 142:5 146:7 128:12 21:19 132:24 162:9 135:18 renewed purchasers 156:18 131:8 really 18:15 134:4 136:4 reduced Reid 130:13 107:15 141:11 quite 93:3 132:14 25:10 39:2 137:11 23:15 reinstated renowned purchases 120:16 133:18 57:18 94:13 141:22 reduces 114:22 126:14 141:9 quorum 7:24 135:15 95:10 147:8 16:13 related 47:11 rent 110:20 purchasing quote 165:22 136:23 117:10 148:25 reducing 47:20 48:12 155:22 21:24 167:11 138:9,22 122:19 151:6 152:6 88:20 89:13 101:18 repayment pure 77:14 quoted 141:3 123:5 149:5 153:15 91:16 97:7 102:2 102:6 purpose 113:15 144:17 149:8,8 156:17 reduction 141:17 repeal 23:9 11:11 51:22 quoting 146:22 156:9 161:19 88:11 147:2 repetitious 153:12 156:6 148:7 168:8 Realtors 87:9 165:8 refer 26:3 relates 15:15 54:19 purposes reading 142:16 171:13 reference 16:4 21:16 replacing 28:21 60:16 R 45:20,21 reappointing recognizing 117:9 22:11 60:25 pursue 144:3 R 126:12 46:6,16 43:13 13:14 27:15 163:12,18 Relations report 42:3 push 22:5 Race 10:15 49:7,14,24 reason 62:7 31:3 33:23 references 142:23 42:11 44:6 164:5 10:18 41:8 50:8,9,13 90:2 91:14 122:21 114:14 relationship 44:15 46:18 pushback 41:11 50:16,22 163:3 123:24 referrals 101:19 47:3 73:23 17:4 24:8 Rachel 172:2 51:24 52:1 reasonable 125:7 153:4 33:20 102:3 reported 50:6 pusher 94:24 racial 57:21 52:7 53:8 55:5 143:25 recommend referred 12:5 relatively reporter pushers 94:7 72:24 73:10 105:23 rebuild 23:25 61:8,9 26:8,18 57:4 175:25 put 16:2 86:21 106:1 107:1 158:11 recommen... 27:4,12 relied 154:9 reporting 23:24 25:2 racism 74:5 108:1 109:1 receive 42:7 43:22 28:23 29:10 relief 147:4 48:20 38:15 59:17 129:24 110:1 111:1 172:12 44:11 45:3 29:16 30:3 163:14 138:14,17 65:21 85:20 radio 34:13 112:1 113:1 receiving 46:23 48:23 30:9 39:18 relieve 154:4 148:20 95:11 raised 157:24 114:1 115:1 85:17 recommen... 40:23 41:13 religious reports 41:1 114:12 163:3 116:1 117:1 recess 52:18 119:6 154:6 42:15 44:17 155:16 41:25 42:1 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 42:6 43:1 research 127:9,12,13 62:17 66:13 revenue risks 148:15 rushing 109:3,6 43:19 44:1 73:12 127:21 66:17 89:13 97:12 River 28:20 68:23 110:12,13 44:10,24 reserve 54:17 128:10,13 101:12 97:17,17,25 44:23 Ryan 18:19 124:19 45:1 46:1 resident 70:6 128:14,23 124:24 98:6,6 road 98:20 18:20 72:14 125:24 46:22 47:1 84:22 130:19,23 126:5 127:7 Review 96:24 160:23 72:22 127:2 128:4 48:1,21 residential 131:6,9,10 128:8 131:4 revise 164:9 Robinson 132:5 133:9 49:1 50:2 11:8,10 131:23 132:10 revision 78:7 91:23 S 136:14 represent 85:4 86:9 132:3,12,15 133:14 98:25 99:10 91:25 92:5 S 1:13 13:16 137:23 57:7 157:18 141:8 132:16,25 135:11 163:2 92:6 27:16 147:20 157:23,25 residents 133:4,8,16 136:19 revolving robust Sabir 169:2 149:19 158:2 38:12 86:11 133:19,20 138:3 97:20 154:10 sacrifices 151:14 Representa...
86:13 88:16 134:6 135:2 147:24 rewrite 121:6 168:22 118:9 164:4 174:2 133:22 90:14 135:6,13 149:23 rewriting role 158:10 sadly 58:5 says 108:24 represented 117:25 150:23 151:18 120:14 171:6 safe 8:8 57:6 109:15 157:13 142:19 151:9,20,22 152:17 rhetoric roll 2:1,21 58:3,7 123:5 154:7 represents 166:2 170:6 152:9,19 174:6 118:9 3:1 4:1 5:1 61:24 62:6 156:7,24 72:4 108:15 resilience 162:21 responsibili... rich 167:2 6:1 7:1 65:9 67:24 scenes 159:17 reproduction 157:17 163:3 74:25 155:5 Richardson 102:13,21 71:23 74:8 school 33:20 175:22 resolution 164:10 responsible 1:12 4:7,8 138:25 174:10 35:12 36:11 reproductive 13:14,18 resolutions 85:6 144:2 28:5 35:23 144:20 safeguards 36:20 37:2 64:13 27:15,22 11:24,25 Restated 103:19,20 160:15 85:14 38:20 40:7 Republican 28:5 30:11 12:2,17 97:11,24 124:10,12 rolled 170:20 safer 81:12 59:4 89:20 113:2 30:21 31:3 26:3 41:20 restaurant 139:14,15 Ronald safety 8:9 schoolchild... republicans 31:13,20 42:6 43:21 109:2,6,8 142:3 145:9 126:12 76:12 80:8 71:3 116:23 35:9,22 43:24 51:23 109:11,15 145:10 Roosevelt 106:7 schools 30:15 request 95:12 39:21 40:6 52:5,12 111:18 171:14,15 40:20 110:13 36:4,15 118:24,25 41:2,14 53:4 105:22 147:4 Richie 171:25 root 72:7 154:11 37:18 38:24 156:22,22 42:15,16,20 116:8,20 restaurants Richmond rooted sale 23:17 152:3 163:2 42:21,24,25 150:22 110:11 44:24 114:15,18 Salmon Schuylkill requesting 43:4,5,8,9 152:22 111:16 right 32:2,18 rostrum 135:22 28:20 106:13 43:12,13,16 resources restorative 33:13 38:17 25:16 salon 155:14 science 57:22 111:10 43:17 45:10 34:24 77:20 67:17 54:17 77:14 165:13 SANCHEZ 70:8 110:16 119:9 45:21 159:12 restrict 77:3 81:24 Roundup 7:2 105:3 111:25 121:10 105:25 respect 16:21 restricted 121:21 60:17 116:16 115:21 requests 9:16 106:3,13 97:6 117:21 83:20 143:13 routinely 119:4 117:21 9:20 107:12 157:16 restricting 148:22 115:14 127:22 sciences 80:6 require 21:10 111:9 respectful 62:4 150:12 Roy 100:2 140:13 scientific 21:12,21,25 112:11,21 95:9 restrictions 166:3 RPR-Notary 146:8 57:13 63:18 69:8 85:23 113:14,15 respectfully 106:8 108:7 168:25 175:16 156:19 scope 54:20 100:24 114:13,14 43:19 44:24 108:10,18 170:19 Rue 142:21 Sanchez's Scott 43:13 101:6 114:17 48:20 57:25 109:22 right-of-ways Rule 76:11 163:2 se 164:5 138:15 115:6 95:12 110:13 83:19,20,22 rules 44:7,10 Sarah 58:19 season 40:9 141:10 117:12 respiratory 113:9 rights 76:3 44:17 45:12 58:25 69:17 132:19 required 86:5 120:14,18 61:6 65:17 121:12 77:12 78:15 45:15,19 70:5 seat 25:19 requirement 120:24 respond 155:3 78:24 84:21 46:4 49:6 Saturday second 45:24 107:13 121:5,10,15 119:25 result 17:14 86:6 144:12 49:12 50:7 108:5,19 50:9,16,22 requirements 121:25 120:4 21:13 22:22 rising 165:25 50:20 51:7 saw 134:10 51:24 52:6 21:8,16 123:23 162:25 22:24 risk 60:2 62:2 69:5 115:14 134:14 53:8 77:7 47:11,20 124:14,18 response 172:14 64:25 65:20 143:3 154:7 78:20 85:23 48:12,20 125:2,5,6 5:11,14 resulted 65:22,23 ruling 114:15 167:22 105:22 138:15 125:19,23 6:13,16 115:16 109:21 114:19 169:12 112:9 148:21 126:7,10,11 9:11 46:13 resume 61:25 110:23,25 115:9 saying 9:6 seconded requires 2:5 126:18,21 49:21 51:16 returns 43:20 155:25 run 94:25 18:14 46:9 8:24 9:3 69:11 126:25 55:16,21 45:2 48:22 156:2 166:17 49:17 51:11 46:4 49:9 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 49:12 51:4 74:11 shame 94:4,4 153:8 66:24,25 99:15 161:1 162:1 115:10 51:7 124:15 Senate 24:21 94:4 signs 39:13 67:2,7,8 southwestw...
sustainable 19:10,10 160:20 60:1 61:1 166:1 167:1 68:16 studies 60:18 97:11,24 36:16 67:17 20:10 tells 107:16 62:1 63:1 168:1 169:1 strategy 60:22 61:16 supplement... symbolic 116:17 temperature 64:1 65:1 170:1 171:1 36:13 159:2 study 64:23 97:13 98:2 116:20 talking 93:21 61:22 66:1 67:1 172:1 173:1 160:3 65:15 88:4 supplies 11:2 symptoms 167:18 Temple 75:20 68:1 69:1 174:1,12 Strawberry 88:10 13:6 27:2 72:8 169:9 temples 70:1 71:1 statement 87:3 108:24 support synagogues tank 72:25 169:21 72:1 73:1 93:6 164:13 strayed 109:15 34:18 38:8 169:20 TAP 158:24 temporary 74:1 75:1 states 63:24 168:21 154:9,22 53:18 59:11 synthetic target 86:11 101:22 76:1 77:1 106:17 stream 34:14 155:17,18 63:17 68:22 59:9 62:5 targeted ten 23:18 78:1 79:1 133:21,22 street 10:14 155:19 73:6 74:22 68:7,12 68:16 85:12 61:18 80:14 80:1 81:1 133:25 10:15,15,17 studying 80:9 85:2 115:6 system 97:21 tasers 11:17 155:12 82:1 83:1 134:19 10:17,18 stuff 77:23 118:5 98:11 99:20 13:11 27:10 ten-minute 84:1 85:1 stating 29:4,5,8,8 stunning 121:10 101:12 tax 11:11 52:18 86:1 87:1 165:24 29:14,20,20 22:25 142:11 106:25 12:22 15:25 ten-year 88:1 89:1 statistically 29:22,22,23 subcontrac... 144:9 107:7 16:9,13,14 21:15,22 90:1 91:1 73:20 29:24,25 47:15,24 158:22 systemic 16:17 19:18 158:12 92:1 93:1 statutes 41:8,8,8,11 48:16 161:5 129:24 21:15,22 tenant 101:19 94:1 95:1 77:25 78:3 41:11,11 subject 85:22 supported systems 57:2 22:7,8,19 102:3 96:1 97:1 stay 65:21 44:22,23,24 sublease 86:25 87:10 98:14 99:23 22:24 23:2 Tenant,' 98:1 99:1,8 113:8 96:18,20 40:17 supporting 23:10,16,20 101:18 100:1 101:1 stayed 106:20 98:19 99:5 submitting 74:7 88:25 T 26:16 88:11 102:2 102:1 103:1 106:21 99:15,24 10:7 131:15 table 95:12 88:20 90:3 tendrils 104:1 105:1 114:20 100:6 subsequent supportive tabled 91:18 91:9,16 70:17 106:1 107:1 120:11 127:15 121:25 24:18 Tabor 100:11 97:6,7 term 93:15 108:1 109:1 171:21 135:19,20 subseries supports tabulated 166:5 terminus 110:1 111:1 stem 160:10 135:21,21 97:15 98:4 33:16 167:17 tax-exempt 29:23 99:16 112:1 113:1 stenographic 135:22,22 subsidize supposed tabulations 97:16 98:5 terms 11:18 113:13,16 175:6 135:24,24 89:5 118:22 167:23 taxable 97:16 14:16 21:20 114:1 115:1 step 14:9 135:25 substance suppression tactic 85:4 98:5 99:7 102:7 116:1 117:1 24:17 25:2 137:5,6,6,7 33:11 133:23 tactics 86:10 Taxation 119:2 118:1 119:1 stepping 137:7,8 substantially Supreme take 2:21 22:24 territorial 120:1 121:1 25:15 162:12,13 23:15 77:24 78:6 14:12,19 taxes 11:5 160:14 122:1 123:1 150:13 Street,' 99:6 substantive 78:9 21:21 25:16 12:21 22:18 tested 108:24 124:1 125:1 165:13 streets 10:12 166:12 sure 17:6 31:18 33:25 22:20 88:16 155:10 126:1 127:1 steps 143:19 41:6 88:5 successful 26:2 83:13 52:17,22 Taxes,' 26:15 testified 128:1 129:1 Stern 62:14 strength 40:8 68:22 113:3 53:15 67:15 taxpayer 172:18 130:1 131:1 62:19,21 154:4 82:20 83:24 121:23 83:14 108:8 58:8 testify 53:12 132:1 133:1 63:2,10,11 stress 154:4 84:2 132:19 150:15 121:20 Tayyib 71:21 75:18 134:1 135:1 63:16 64:19 strike 91:6 sudden 94:18 154:15 129:14 130:14 87:25 149:7 136:1 137:1 66:6 striking suffer 65:6 surface 21:7 143:19 teach 71:10 testifying 138:1 139:1 stewardship 77:25 99:3 73:22 surgical 144:4 158:7 75:20 88:8 140:1 141:1 69:6 99:12 suffering 68:13 163:25 teachers testimony 142:1 143:1 stimulate striving 89:6 32:10 72:3 surprising 164:11,24 30:14 152:2 54:8,10,21 144:1 145:1 18:5 19:23 strong 84:25 sufficiently 59:21 taken 159:5 team 40:8 56:10 58:17 146:1 147:1 stimulus 16:2 strongly 61:14 surrounded 175:6 132:18 58:24 62:12 148:1 149:1 24:20 63:17 71:24 suggestions 111:23 takes 19:9 172:17 62:25 63:9 150:1 151:1 stock 67:15 struck 78:9 117:16 suspended 161:2 Teams 1:6 66:10 67:6 152:1 153:1 stood 18:20 structural Sunshine 45:16,20 talk 17:20,21 2:11 153:7 69:15,22 154:1 155:1 159:14 39:11 153:10 46:5 49:6 17:22 20:22 technology 72:12,19 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 75:7,15 116:16 173:7,21 114:21,22 time-honor...
toolbox 68:10 87:24 73:7 79:10,18 118:15,17 174:9,10 120:12 14:7 tools 32:18 truck 29:2,18 unapologetic 81:17,23 118:19 thanked Thomas 1:18 timer 54:8 32:19 33:2 30:5 98:17 157:6 83:11 84:8 119:17,19 37:16 7:15,16 times 15:11 top 23:21 100:9 unavoidable 87:15,22 120:6 thankful 35:23 39:19 65:13 71:14 total 169:3 trucks 29:6 32:5 91:21 95:19 121:17,19 162:15 40:5 105:10 109:16,18 totally 116:21 true 80:22 uncertain 172:11 121:22,25 173:9,10 105:11 154:19 touch 166:12 175:7 18:12 text 168:25 122:2,5,19 thanks 9:23 130:9 168:16 Tour 129:25 truly 36:23 unchecked thank 2:24 123:7,10,12 142:21 132:25 timing Tour's 37:25 92:10 74:13 8:15,20 9:2 123:13,16 Thanksgivi... 133:2 123:18 128:17 trustee 77:19 unconscion... 9:18 11:21 124:8,12,17 38:16,19 140:18,19 title 28:15 129:19 try 15:8 89:12 12:9 14:22 125:14,17 162:2,2,6 142:6 47:7 48:5 tow-away 92:11,14 unconstitut... 15:6,6 125:22 162:15 146:13,14 96:5 105:25 29:6 121:7 144:3 77:9 78:12 18:15,19 126:16,19 therefrom 150:5,8,16 113:24 Towne 170:18 78:22 24:10 25:8 126:24 99:16 thought 114:16 132:18 trying 24:19 underlying 25:13,21,21 127:18 thing 16:22 154:4 122:7 Township 92:21 93:5 88:5 25:21 28:3 128:20,24 20:13 21:8 168:23 123:22 78:7 123:3 underserved 31:17,19 129:13 77:5 111:22 thoughtful 125:5 toxic 56:14 169:13 38:6 34:17 35:2 130:13,22 120:21 69:2 126:10 56:23 57:15 turnout understand 35:5,16,18 131:18,21 things 17:16 thousand 127:12 65:25 71:6 167:20 2:4 18:22 38:25 39:3 132:2,23 17:23 19:4 167:12,14 128:13 71:18 74:20 168:5,9,22 19:20 20:3 39:5,5 133:2 134:3 21:12 32:5 threatening 131:9 75:4 79:4 169:8 68:9 76:14 41:23 42:4 134:7 135:5 33:7 107:4 79:6 132:15 148:15 TV 93:22 108:12,22 42:9 43:24 135:14 109:20 three 12:16 133:19 toxicity 60:14 94:18 114:25 44:8,13 136:3,6,11 111:6 26:12 46:22 135:16 trade 92:17 Twenty-Fifth 117:22 45:5,8 46:3 137:10,14 121:12 53:25 85:13 136:24 tradition 97:10 123:2 155:4 46:20,25 137:22 158:19 three-day 138:10 14:7 18:17 Twenty-Fo... 161:10 48:25 49:4 138:21 159:17 86:6 141:4,6 traditionally 97:23 understand... 49:11 50:18 141:23,24 160:19 three-month 146:23,25 18:2 twice 108:25 24:15 51:6 52:2 144:8,13,14 163:22 154:8 148:8,10 traffic 29:12 109:5,12,14 107:25 52:14,25 144:16 think 18:7 threshold titles 12:13 39:13 two 12:16 unemploy... 55:14 56:8 147:7,11,19 20:3 26:8 20:9 96:3,13 trails 82:16 32:4 54:3 110:19 56:8,11,12 148:24 38:19 68:3 Thursday 1:7 today 4:3 8:3 148:19 64:4 77:6 unethical 58:15,17 149:4,6,18 68:19,21,23 8:17,22 9:4 9:21 12:14 training 80:3 80:7 102:11 92:13 93:8 62:10,12 150:20 72:25 84:3 31:3 108:14 16:12 33:22 124:3,5 114:20 unfathoma... 63:10,13 151:7 152:7 94:7 95:15 173:17,23 34:18 35:22 transcript 138:23 91:3 66:5,6,9,9 152:25 109:24 tide 165:25 46:16 49:25 175:8,22 144:18 unfortunate 67:7 69:13 153:17 112:10 tied 117:2 50:17 52:8 transfer 159:20 92:11 69:15 70:4 156:11,14 113:4,14,25 time 14:17 52:20 53:5 159:24 Two-thirds Unfortunat... 70:4 72:9 156:19,21 115:21 17:18,20 54:3 57:3 transition 114:17 16:6 61:11 72:12,21 157:2,8 117:9,19 21:2 37:21 70:12 72:22 74:23 two-week-old unfounded 75:5,7,17 159:15 120:15,21 52:19 54:6 73:5 84:25 transparency 115:9 76:18 79:8,10 160:12,16 121:6,13 54:10,12,13 87:25 88:8 67:19 74:12 types 116:8 unique 59:14 81:14,17,25 161:3,4,4,4 122:25 64:11 72:2 91:23 transportat...
157:6 74:23 82:12 84:7,9,12 161:13,16 123:4 156:3 72:9,22 142:12 155:15 173:11 Unit 84:21 86:22 87:13 161:18,21 164:21 74:3,17 149:7 153:3 travel 10:16 United 63:24 87:15 91:19 165:5,7,10 166:21 75:5 83:7 165:12 41:9 U 133:21,22 91:21 95:19 168:4 170:6 thinking 89:10 today's 95:25 treated 63:23 ubiquitous 133:24 95:24 102:9 170:11,23 68:10 107:21 told 58:2 tremendous 85:6 134:18 103:12,13 171:9,10,12 165:22 116:21 64:20 38:23 ultimately units 11:8,9 106:11 171:15,17 169:16,20 129:22 tomorrow tries 94:6 121:3 University 112:5,12 172:16,20 Third 84:23 143:19 88:19 trigger 65:8 unanimous 35:10,25 114:4,7,10 172:23,23 86:4 106:22 153:6 tonight 34:10 Trubman 56:21 36:25 38:21 116:11,13 172:24 113:7,10 162:18 tool 68:10,11 87:17,18,23 unanimously 64:23 80:2 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 Unlawful 159:25 visual 169:6 26:5 33:17 20:19 25:24 143:8 123:8 165:12 141:15 vacating 99:4 vital 67:23 35:18 69:23 29:13 36:17 weeds 57:17 willingness 169:17 unmute vaccine 118:7 129:15 83:14 85:21 36:18 57:5 week 123:25 17:5 123:4 170:12,18 55:20 62:19 163:24 voice 157:20 117:11 71:22 77:3 131:13 Willis 130:8 170:21 66:15,19 164:2 voices 171:9 118:2,3,8 79:23 81:12 134:10 Wilson 172:25 unprecede... Val 43:17 173:11 118:22,23 108:9 120:8 161:24 168:15 173:14 72:2 Valerie 42:21 voluntarily 119:11,16 120:24 162:3 windfall worked 20:25 unqualified valuable 112:4 122:15 121:6 123:7 173:13 22:25 23:3 70:7 88:18 94:20 90:20 120:17 129:14 138:17 week's 27:19 23:5,7 115:24 unrest 17:15 142:25 volunteer 130:13 156:23 28:3,10 Wisconsin 117:4 unscrupulo... value 69:11 56:24,25 134:25 158:17 30:25 31:10 82:4 171:24 94:16 143:10 vomiting 141:24 166:12 35:6 39:6 wish 79:21 workers 90:4 unsung 38:2 various 164:3 64:9 142:13,20 Wayne 40:3,12 121:19 97:4 131:15 upcoming 164:24 vote 94:10 144:8 149:5 134:12 41:18 153:9 162:3 working 88:6 90:11 vast 129:23 102:15 150:12 ways 32:22 weeks 114:20 wishing 54:5 156:23,25 upend 115:20 vegetation 103:8 154:15 33:4 38:14 weigh 94:8 Wissahickon 159:7 160:9 Upgrading 67:20 125:12 156:20 170:21 108:17 28:20 70:11 160:17 124:3 vehicles 141:20 157:2,8 we'll 12:11 118:23 withdrawn 173:10 Upland 29:13 10:23 13:3 168:2,15 159:15 34:23 55:23 121:24 136:8,13,22 working-cl... Uplift 31:6 26:24 170:8 160:12,16 83:11 156:4 well-being witnesses 88:15 91:11 31:23 32:24 venues 95:15 voted 105:18 161:3 162:7 172:12 67:24 91:4 172:3 works 48:17 33:17,25 versus 68:15 140:25 165:12 we're 2:3 118:11 Wolf's world 32:6 34:5,9 78:7 155:11 146:20 167:5,10 19:6,11 well-paying 114:23 117:15 upliftphilly... 0023 71:1 72:1 12 70:9,21 200093 52:10 52:8 106:2 101:20 141:1 142:1 76ers 39:24 154:13 73:1 74:1 108:5,19 135:16 200504 92:6 102:4 143:1 144:1 010267 28:25 75:1 76:1 12-1 40:9 136:8,12,22 200537 50:25 2019-2020 145:1 146:1 8 77:1 78:1 12-3000 98:9 200115 51:2 98:21 40:8 132:19 147:1 148:1 8 123:24 Stated Meeting November 19, 2020 134:17 159:7 57:13 168:11 8th 10:14,17 41:7,10 141:6 146:25 9-1100 141:12 9-212 100:14 9-800 101:16 101:24 9:00 161:25 101:12 61:4