civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 22, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 22, 20204h 57m

And you met all of the code requirements under the original application, the amended refusal for CDR and for the original RCO meetings, correct?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

And also, again, for the original ZBA meeting, which was to be held back on April 8th?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And did you also meet all of the code requirements for any notice to be served for this rescheduled hearing?

Similar wording

Yes, I did.

Similar wording

Thank you very much, Ms. Grooms.

Similar wording

Unless the board has any questions, I have nothing further for Ms. Grooms.

Similar wording

Does the board have any questions for Mr. Whalen at this time?

Similar wording

Seeing none.

Similar wording

With that, I would conclude my initial presentation just saying that I would only call any other witnesses, the same witnesses back in rebuttal if necessary.

Similar wording

and um you know again we're all kind of learning with regard to um you know this process uh mr

Similar wording

you know, this process. Mr. Orphanides was listed as an attorney in the beginning.

Similar wording

orphanetes was

Similar wording

I am the attorney for the owner and the applicant. I will let Mr. Orphanides speak for himself,

Similar wording

but I understand that he is appearing as the attorney for an opposition party today. So we

Similar wording

are not co-counsel, but rather in adversarial counsel, so to speak here. But I do understand

Similar wording

that there are other people to speak and support. So I will conclude at this time. Thank you very

Similar wording

much. Thank you. I would ask those who are waiting to testify. I would ask only those who are in

Similar wording

support to raise your hand at this time. We will get to those who are opposed once we complete

Similar wording

the testimony of those who are in favor. So if you're not in favor of this, please

Similar wording

remove your hand at this time we will get back to you and that way Tanya hopefully will be able to

Similar wording

get a summary from each person if you're in favor of this your name and address

Similar wording

identify yourself please and be as brief as you could we'd appreciate it thank you

Similar wording

Ivan, you have been unmuted and you are available to speak now.

Similar wording

Ivan Tancredi, you can unmute yourself to speak.

Similar wording

David Hall, you can unmute yourself and speak.

Similar wording

Oh, I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Can you hear me now?

Similar wording

Yeah, Mr. Tancredi.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Please identify yourself with a record.

Similar wording

Spell your name for the stenographer, please.

Similar wording

Ivan Tancredi.

Similar wording

I-V-A-N-T-A-N-C-R-E-D-I.

Similar wording

Mr. Tancredi, do you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

thank you please proceed my name is Ivan Tancredi I represent Washington Avenue

Similar wording

Property Owners Association I've been I owned 2100 Washington Avenue since the

Similar wording

early 80s on a personal note Washington Avenue needed this project it's about

Similar wording

time that this project is come to fruition representing Washington Avenue

Similar wording

Property Owners Association we're all in favor of the project as presented by the

Similar wording

lawyer and the architect. Thank you very much. Thank you for your patience. Thank

Similar wording

you.

Similar wording

Eric you have been allowed to speak if you wish to unmute you.

Similar wording

hi can you hear me

Similar wording

yes we can okay great name and address for the record spell your name for the stenographer

Similar wording

please sure my name is eric gertschberg that's e-r-i-c-g-e-r-c-h-b like boy e-r-g

Similar wording

my address is 2432 carpenter street philadelphia yes i'm sorry mr gertschberg do you swear and

Similar wording

a firm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I do, yes. Sorry I didn't

Similar wording

interrupt. Please proceed. Not a problem. So I just wanted to, you know, voice my support. I'm

Similar wording

a new resident of the neighborhood, and I've been in preparation coming to a lot of the community

Similar wording

meetings, because I know that this is a big draw for me personally, for wanting to be in this

Similar wording

neighborhood. And I just kind of wanted to, you know, see it through and make sure that it is

Similar wording

going to come to fruition and just very excited about it thank you and welcome to the neighborhood

Similar wording

thank you so much

Similar wording

steven you can unmute yourself and speak hi good uh good afternoon

Similar wording

this is uh steven zellinger i'm a resident at 2106 catherine street mr zellinger would please

Similar wording

spell your name for the stenographer sure steven s-t-e v as in victor e-n zellinger z as in zebra

Similar wording

e-l-i-n-g-e-r mr zellinger do you swear and affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and

Similar wording

nothing but the truth yes i do proceed yes i just wanted to voice my support for the project i'm a

Similar wording

15 16 year resident of the neighborhood and i think i've been waiting a long time for more

Similar wording

Um, and I think I've been waiting a long time for more development, um, and more things

Similar wording

development.

Similar wording

to do along Washington Avenue.

Similar wording

I think having, you know, a full block retail on the first floor would open up a lot of

Similar wording

options.

Similar wording

I think, you know, a lot of people in the neighborhood regularly say that they have

Similar wording

to walk too far to, uh, some of the things that they want to do and have to go to Ritten

Similar wording

House Square to do things.

Similar wording

We just like to have more, more, uh, shopping and dining options along there.

Similar wording

And I think this would add to Washington Avenue development and the plan that we're trying to seek with is more retail and pedestrian friendly things to do along there.

Similar wording

So it's not just a highway with with cars blasting through the through the area.

Similar wording

So I'm in full support of the project.

Similar wording

What a true urban experience.

Similar wording

OK, thank you. Appreciate your time.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Murray Spencer you're allowed to speak now

Similar wording

Hi Murray Spencer from SOSNA SOSNA Zoning Board SOSNA Zoning Committee

Similar wording

Murray would you please spell your name for the record

Similar wording

M-U-R-R-A-Y Murray Spencer S-P-E-N-C-E-R

Similar wording

Mr. Spencer, you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

So on behalf of SOSNA, we enthusiastically support this project.

Similar wording

We like the process that it took to get to this project, this building, the architecture.

Similar wording

We like all of it.

Similar wording

We especially like the underground parking.

Similar wording

As someone said earlier, we've learned from the things that we don't like about Lincoln Square.

Similar wording

They've all been incorporated into this project. We like the fact that there's a

Similar wording

community benefits agreement that includes affordable housing.

Similar wording

And on behalf of the SOSNA, again, board, the zoning committee, the architecture review committee,

Similar wording

And most of all of the community, there's probably a little opposition, I'm not sure who that might be, but the majority of the community is in support of this project.

Similar wording

Thank you, sir. Appreciate your time.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Brian Lawson, you can unmute yourself and speak.

Similar wording

hi my name is brian lawson um i live at 1026 south 22nd street and the spelling the name is

Similar wording

b-r-i-a-n-l-a-w-s-o-n and i want to mr lawson you swear and affirm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth and nothing but the truth i do thank you i just want to say as someone who is directly

Similar wording

across the streets from this project um for over the last two years uh the ocf teams have been

Similar wording

meeting with the near neighbors both on kimball and league street and 20 along 22nd street um

Similar wording

even to the extent of you know we have a couple facebook pages that we have built set up to be

Similar wording

able to get direct messages to ocf and their teams regarding any issues we're having with the

Similar wording

projects and just the amount of time they've spent with those of us that are really directly

Similar wording

impacted initially by the construction phase of this project and also looking forward to what

Similar wording

it's going to be. I just want to say they've done an exceptional job of being available

Similar wording

and very responsive and again I'm in full support of this project. Thank you Mr. Lawson for your

Similar wording

time and your comments. Thank you. Loretta, you can unmute yourself and speak.

Similar wording

Hello, I'm Loretta Tague. That's spelled L-O-R-E-T-T-A-T-A-G-U-E.

Similar wording

Ms. Tague, do you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Would you give us your address, please?

Similar wording

Yes, I live at 2127 Oakford Street, so basically the same block, several blocks south of Washington.

Similar wording

And I, yes, sorry, did you have another, I think I interrupted you.

Similar wording

No, no, I'm saying thank you.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

And I just wanted to say that I've lived in the neighborhood for 14 years.

Similar wording

um up to um about five years ago I lived north of Washington and now I'm south of Washington and I

Similar wording

walk a lot across Washington Avenue and have been delighted for example by seeing some development

Similar wording

that includes the OCAF office and especially the new um brewery that I can't remember its name

Similar wording

brewery that I can't remember its name right now, but it's always delightful to see, you know,

Similar wording

right now, but it's always delightful to see, you know, sort of pedestrian activity.

Similar wording

sort of pedestrian activity around there. And I look forward to having a nice supermarket like

Similar wording

Aldi and nice walking distance and making it all just a lot more pedestrian friendly and

Similar wording

more neighborhood-y. Thank you very much. Appreciate your time. Thank you. You're welcome.

Similar wording

Jennifer, you can unmute yourself and speak at this time. Hello, can you hear me?

Similar wording

yes we can thank you my name is jennifer leupold that's l-e-u-p-o-l-d and my address is 1306

Similar wording

south woodstock street and miss leupold do you swear and affirm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth and nothing but the truth i do please proceed thank you thank you i was an 11-year

Similar wording

resident of Graduate Hospital including six years on the board of SOSNA I just

Similar wording

moved a few blocks south to 20th and Wharton in May so I have attended many

Similar wording

many many years worth of meetings on this project as both a resident of the

Similar wording

neighborhood as well as with the SOSNA board I am now walking across Washington

Similar wording

Avenue on a very regular basis to bring my son to school and daycare and as I

Similar wording

know many Point Breeze residents are with the Stanton catchment that now

Similar wording

extends past Washington Avenue. From a safety perspective I am ecstatic about

Similar wording

this new development that's been proposed and in terms of ease for

Similar wording

shopping and access to things that we need on a regular basis, the ability to walk instead of

Similar wording

drive is very huge for myself as well as my neighbors. So I just wanted to register my

Similar wording

wholehearted support. Well, thank you very much and thank you for spending the time with us. Thank

Similar wording

you heather you are allowed to speak at this time good hi um my name is heather davidson h-e-a-t-h-e-r

Similar wording

d-a-v-i-d-s-o-n and i live at 1026 south 22nd street so i am across the street from both of

Similar wording

Rory's developments.

Similar wording

Ms. Davidson, I'm sorry to interrupt.

Similar wording

Do you swear to the firm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

I live at 1026 at 22nd Street.

Similar wording

I live across the street from both 2101 and 2201.

Similar wording

I work from home currently, so there is noise.

Similar wording

But knowing what these developments are going to bring to the neighborhood, much as Ms.

Similar wording

loophole talked about for added availability of shopping for people who can't get to center city

Similar wording

or can't get out of the neighborhood through the aldi having a cbs even closer to people who are

Similar wording

at the south end of the graduate hospital neighborhood and the north end of point

Similar wording

breeze some of these things are incredibly important to neighbors of mine who are senior

Similar wording

who can't drive, as well as those of us who live in the neighborhood, knowing that we're

Similar wording

going to have a vibrant community of new people coming into the neighborhood to become participants

Similar wording

in the neighborhood is incredibly important to me.

Similar wording

I'm a former board member of Blocktoberfest who, one of our missions was to give back

Similar wording

to other nonprofits in the neighborhood.

Similar wording

So seeing what Ori is doing, our OCF is development is doing around building the breezeway for League Street and adding a park in there, as well as the public access to things and bringing more commercial to the corridor, having Dock Street, having small oven and porcos.

Similar wording

those have completely changed the number of people who are walking by my house on a daily basis and

Similar wording

the types of people who are walking by my house that is a vitally needed area for small business

Similar wording

to continue to expand to help grow the neighborhood and that's all I had to say

Similar wording

thank you very much do appreciate your time thank you David Hall do you wish to speak

Similar wording

Hello? Can you hear me? Yes, go ahead. Okay. David Hall, D-A-V-I-D-H-A-L-L, 2037 Kimball Street.

Similar wording

2037 Kimball Street.

Similar wording

Chair, could you unmute yourself, please?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Sorry.

Similar wording

Mr. Hall, do you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

As a near neighbor, I just want to, you know, voice my support for the project, and I feel that the design of the project is thoughtful and architecturally interesting.

Similar wording

I particularly appreciate the inclusion of the pedestrian walkway at League Street that can be used by neighborhood residents and the added greenery on the property.

Similar wording

I think that throughout the process, there's been a very open line of communication with the developer from near neighbors.

Similar wording

And I feel that he's valued the input of the neighbors and incorporated that into the design.

Similar wording

and like other neighbors have said, this project will really activate the corridor, make it more

Similar wording

vibrant, more walkable, safer, and add much needed commercial space in terms of CVS and grocery store

Similar wording

that is currently unavailable or further away from us. So I fully support this project. Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you, sir. Thank you for your time.

Similar wording

at this time that's all the hands that i have to

Similar wording

okay um i i think it's almost correct me if i'm wrong almost two hours since we had our last break

Similar wording

was that or was that was that about 10 or 4 or 10 or 5 so we're coming up on that and i think

Similar wording

the rest of the

Similar wording

witnesses will probably

Similar wording

going to be Mr. Orfanides. You're going to be

Similar wording

testifying, correct?

Similar wording

You're representing?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

I have my

Similar wording

client, and then I'm going to add some questions

Similar wording

of some of

Similar wording

Mr.

Similar wording

Whalen's witnesses.

Similar wording

So rather than break

Similar wording

when you begin your testimony

Similar wording

or break it up, why don't we take a five-minute

Similar wording