civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 8, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 8, 20258h 7m

First floor, one-bedroom apartment.

Similar wording

It's a 128-square-foot living room, 138-square-foot kitchen, a bathroom, and 107-square-foot bedroom.

Similar wording

Second floor, two-bedroom apartment, 141-square-foot primary bedroom, second bedroom, 84-square-feet, 96-square-foot kitchen, 73-square-foot living room, and a bathroom.

Similar wording

And per the requests of the RCO and just what my client was doing anyway, they're installing one-hour fire walls and ceilings as part of what they're doing, which will separate the units and hopefully ensure the safety of the residents and folks in the neighborhood.

Similar wording

We believe this is a reasonable project, not creating a new use and restoring and bringing into full compliance historical use on a blighted property.

Similar wording

We got the support of the RCO, and I'd like to call my client to adopt my testimony.

Similar wording

Nicole, if you're on the call, could you raise your hand?

Similar wording

Nicole has no problem.

Similar wording

Nicole, you're allowed to speak.

Similar wording

Good morning, Nicole.

Similar wording

Hello.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

Hi.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

My name is Nicole Ramirez.

Similar wording

spelled N-I-C-O-L-E-R-A-M-I-R-E-V.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth,

Similar wording

the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Police proceed counsel.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Nicole.

Similar wording

Did you hear my testimony just now

Similar wording

regarding your property on Bouvier Street?

Similar wording

Do you adopt it as your own?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

I have nothing further.

Similar wording

Questions from the board.

Similar wording

Comment.

Similar wording

Just a quick comment.

Similar wording

Can you go through a second?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

yes sir not not for not for nothing but the location of your um range is a fire hazard

Similar wording

right next to the window somebody puts curtains there they're going to go up in flames just so

Similar wording

you know but um okay so but so um so i'm not quite sure uh um board member gaskin will have some

Similar wording

comments

Similar wording

I think my only question is about the subdivision

Similar wording

so you bought it in this condition

Similar wording

yeah

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

I

Similar wording

have my pet peeve

Similar wording

my pet peeve is that

Similar wording

this idea

Similar wording

that you have to wander from

Similar wording

the bedroom

Similar wording

all the way through the kitchen

Similar wording

and all to get to a bathroom.

Similar wording

I just, I don't,

Similar wording

and bathroom, bedroom here,

Similar wording

living room, then bath,

Similar wording

and then the other way,

Similar wording

it's through the kitchen.

Similar wording

So, you know, three o'clock in the morning,

Similar wording

that's a little hard to deal with.

Similar wording

I just think that a better layout

Similar wording

would be um so that you don't have to do that um i'm sorry can you guys hear me yes we can yeah

Similar wording

okay yeah i'm sorry i'm a little confused um because you said you i don't you don't have to

Similar wording

go through anything all of the bedrooms or like the room have their own door so you don't have

Similar wording

to go through like the kitchen or the bathroom or like they all have their own doors if i'm

Similar wording

understanding what you were stating i believe i believe she's mentioning the first floor here

Similar wording

where it appears that you go through the kitchen to get through the to the bathroom from this

Similar wording

bedroom and the yes yeah in the back well okay i understand i thought you were referring to the

Similar wording

second um unit so for the the layout like um we purchased the property like with this layout we

Similar wording

didn't make like any changes. And then between I don't I think there's a picture that I took from

Similar wording

um and then between i don't i think there's a picture that i took from like standing in the

Similar wording

like

Similar wording

kitchen to the bedroom there's um that's this tell me tell me which way to go on these on

Similar wording

these pictures nicole if i'm going the right way or the wrong way maybe go um like yeah backwards

Similar wording

keep going because this is the second unit

Similar wording

all right now we're downstairs again okay so keep going

Similar wording

oh i'm sorry maybe go um your renovation photos okay other way yeah so because there's a picture

Similar wording

okay right it should be um the couple of next pictures so this is the kitchen i should be the

Similar wording

next one okay here yeah so I'm standing in the kitchen and right there's like a little like

Similar wording

hallway I don't know what you call that and then that's the the bedroom but I do understand what

Similar wording

you're saying but there is like a door so it like the bedroom isn't like directly in the kitchen but

Similar wording

I do understand um what what you mean by like having to walk through the kitchen to go to the

Similar wording

bathroom i'm not i'm not saying that the bathroom is in the kitchen what i'm saying is that when you

Similar wording

get up at three o'clock in the morning okay to go to the bathroom you got to wander through

Similar wording

the kitchen to get to oh okay i understand sorry i misunderstood what you were saying

Similar wording

layout okay okay understood thank you sorry about that miss ramirez i do have another question so

Similar wording

it looks like you purchased the property this year and i know you said you guys have done no

Similar wording

work did you purchase this uh cash or did you uh do a bank process to get this and did you run a

Similar wording

title search before you when you purchased so yeah we did like uh i'm sorry you said it was cash or

Similar wording

through a bank yes yeah so we did it through a bank um there was a title search um like to the

Similar wording

title company but no one like told us that it wasn't zoned correctly um yeah so if that didn't

Similar wording

come up and i mean if we knew it wasn't like zoned correctly we would probably have purchased it but

Similar wording

it didn't come up during the title did anything come up during your bank process when you did

Similar wording

the inspections no no okay so they like they said they thought everything was fine yeah

Similar wording

the only reason i'm bringing it up is because there were a lot of lni violations from the

Similar wording

previous owner that you purchased the building from and it does look like some of the work

Similar wording

that's depicted currently was corrected during the lni violation process without permits so

Similar wording

so the only thing that we were aware of like in terms of violation was the like the rear yard

Similar wording

of the um like it was a lot of grass and trees in which we cut down but that was the only thing

Similar wording

that we were aware of and then we fixed we corrected that yeah well they they had they

Similar wording

had way more than the real wall they had like some structural things that they had to adjust so i just

Similar wording

wanted to make sure if you had a if you went through a bank process though you should have

Similar wording

been covered yeah nicole do you do you do you attend to get um your certificate of occupancy to

Similar wording

properly operate if the board grants your variance today yes yeah that's the plan

Similar wording

and could you just let me know about the trash uh for both units yeah so um as i mentioned we

Similar wording

have a rear yard and we do have like a trash and recycling management plan because that was uh

Similar wording

the our for the rco so um the trash and recycling containers are going to be stored in the rear in

Similar wording

the rear yard and which is accessible for both units um both units will be assigned um two 32

Similar wording

gallon trash containers and another 32 gallon um recycling bin and if you know extra containers

Similar wording

are needed then we'll definitely provide them also we'll be providing with the like both units

Similar wording

like indoor containers so they'll have a place to store their indoor trash and um recycling um you

Similar wording

know for daily use and then it's up to you know they have to go down and um you know throw their

Similar wording

trash in the in the rear yard and then another um thing that uh we're gonna do is through uh we're

Similar wording

gonna hire a property management and their maintenance company they'll be responsible for

Similar wording

you know bringing the containers um on trash date um to return it back and bring them out and then

Similar wording

And also, so they'll be responsible for that just to make sure that, you know, I know, sorry, that the tenants, they don't leave like the trash bins out on the curb.

Similar wording

All right. Questions from our attorney?

Similar wording

All right. Questions from our attorney?

Similar wording

Not at this time, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

I do not see any of your hands, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Chair, members of the board.

Similar wording

Michael Gall with the Philadelphia City Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends no change to the RSA-5 residential single-family attached zoning at this location.

Similar wording

the city rezoned this neighborhood in uh this section of tioga in 2006 in a community requested

Similar wording

map change this property does have a documented history of two-family residential use therefore

Similar wording

the city planning commission recommends that the board grant the proposed variance for two-family

Similar wording

residential use so mi2024-006-814-3630 north buvier street i vote yes with proviso certificate

Similar wording

of occupancy to would be obtained. Michael Johnson, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes with proviso. Ryan McAdams, my vote

Similar wording

is yes with proviso. Io Nguyen, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel. Thank you, everyone.

Similar wording

Move that range from that window.

Similar wording

Write that down, Nicole. He's serious. Hillary,

Similar wording

We just mentioned there's three cases remaining.

Similar wording

We will add them to them.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And Mr.

Similar wording

I can just put those on the record.

Similar wording

Give me one second.

Similar wording

Sorry.

Similar wording

So those cases will be 2954 North Fairhill Street, 3301 North 22nd Street and 1019 Wallace

Similar wording

Street.

Similar wording

Those cases will be heard at 2 p.m. after a recess.

Similar wording

OK, thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you very much, everyone.

Similar wording

See every one of two.

Similar wording

He knows we have to.

Similar wording

We're going to we have three cases from this morning's list.

Similar wording

We're going to hear those first.

Similar wording

But before I start, I should mention that this morning we announced that.

Similar wording

Tinetto Graham is the new vice chairman.

Similar wording

And Cheryl Gaston is the secretary of the board.

Similar wording

So I just want everybody to know.

Similar wording

Okay, so number seven from the earlier list, number eight from the earlier list, MI 2024-006-880-2954 North Fairhill Street.

Similar wording

Richard Rivera, Roman is the appellant.

Similar wording

What's the name?

Similar wording

Do we see him?

Similar wording

Here, this is Jason Handel.

Similar wording

I'll be stepping in briefly.

Similar wording

Sure. Jason, do we see him?

Similar wording

He's in the virtual audience,

Similar wording

but he's not raising his hand.

Similar wording

Mr. Rivera, if you are still

Similar wording

in the virtual audience, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

Okay. He just raised his hand and he'll be coming back in as a panelist for him, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Sure, thank you.

Similar wording

Hello, everybody.

Similar wording

Hi, sir. I believe I swore you in earlier today. Am I correct?

Similar wording

Yes, that is correct.

Similar wording

All right. So why don't you bring up your video and start your presentation?

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Well, as far as I know, everyone can see.

Similar wording

Yeah, so we have all your paperwork.

Similar wording

So why don't you start with your plans for the building, right?

Similar wording

We have that.

Similar wording

Why don't you start with your plans for the building and your photos?

Similar wording

All righty.

Similar wording

So my proposed plans are demonstrated in this blueprint here.

Similar wording

So this would be the first floor plans indicating.

Similar wording

Can you blow that up a little bit?

Similar wording

It's a little hard to see, just a little bit.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

it doesn't seem to be quite working at the moment okay all right so

Similar wording

so that's your first floor where's your second floor my second floor

Similar wording

so that's your first floor where's your second floor my second floor

Similar wording

is right here so i have two bedrooms on top each room has their own closet as well as

Similar wording

a washer and dryer there's w and d there next to the bathroom then after you go up the stairs

Similar wording

There's a little bit more of a staircase, maybe two stairs.

Similar wording

There's a kitchen area, and then you have space for your dining room

Similar wording

and your living room as well here.

Similar wording

And show us the first floor again.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

The second computer is a bit slow.

Similar wording

That's the second floor, right?

Similar wording

There we go.

Similar wording

It just loaded in.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So each floor will have its own separate entrance.

Similar wording

As you see, this is the main entrance, but the entry point for the first housing unit will be here, and this will be the second unit's entry.

Similar wording