civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 8, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 8, 20258h 7m

So, yes.

Similar wording

you're i guess you started off by saying it's just you so you don't need like so the reason is you

Similar wording

need this this this rental unit but then you're you're keeping the four bedroom really a four

Similar wording

bedroom house and you're renting out the basement as a one bedroom essentially so i'm trying to

Similar wording

understand the hardship if you're keeping it's almost like if if you had said i'm a one person

Similar wording

i'm going to keep the basement i'm going to rent out the rest of the house because i don't need

Similar wording

all this space but you're one person that has four bedrooms so i'm just trying to understand

Similar wording

one i mean right now i'm by myself maybe one day i'll have a husband and kids but i still do pay

Similar wording

the mortgage and bills all by myself so as of right now i mean it's a completely habitable space

Similar wording

minus the kitchenette that's not there and you know obviously obviously renovations that will

Similar wording

happen but it's a 1100 square foot proposed apartment that i could live in but i mean i

Similar wording

own the house so i would rather the basement be you know running out i got as of this you know

Similar wording

appointment and this for this hearing i gotcha so and then so we go back to the basement plan i've

Similar wording

got a concern about that, what you're calling

Similar wording

a flat or

Similar wording

a, what is it called, an efficiency, especially efficiency. It's really a one-bedroom.

Similar wording

And there's no means of egress windows

Similar wording

out of that bedroom space. You're calling it a studio,

Similar wording

but it's really a one-bedroom. So, you know,

Similar wording

if it is approved, you really need to provide

Similar wording

uh egress windows out of that out of that out of that what you're calling a studio space

Similar wording

okay so just to um i'm just going to talk about when i got the plans resolved so if you see here

Similar wording

i have the basement plans back up um where so it would be would have been i believe one of these

Similar wording

windows we i originally proposed to have a second mode of egress and my original thought was to make

Similar wording

this a one-bedroom however the out pouching that are created to make a window well would

Similar wording

kind of pouch into the walkway leading into the backyard so when I got my plans created by code

Similar wording

correct me if I'm wrong if there's no technical doorway to separate the studio space to the

Similar wording

living area it could be advertised as a studio instead of a one-bedroom and as far as the

Similar wording

distance I think I can keep this as is as far as entrance and egress yeah I think it's still

Similar wording

problematic I don't know exactly whether that's true what you say exactly but in terms of a

Similar wording

functional from a functional standpoint it's essentially a bedroom and you can add an egress

Similar wording

well in that walkway with the grate and provide that access still okay I'm willing to have that

Similar wording

there's a so i think so so those those are my sort of big concerns about that that and you

Similar wording

got to make sure if you do we if we do approve you got to have legitimate size doorways um that

Similar wording

are into this space um so that's about it okay other questions from the board no i guess i'm just

Similar wording

following up with

Similar wording

Board Member Johns that

Similar wording

you're going to have a

Similar wording

kind of very spacious

Similar wording

kind of

Similar wording

unit and then you're

Similar wording

going to be

Similar wording

your rental unit is not going to be

Similar wording

I don't know

Similar wording

how attractive it's going to be

Similar wording

to

Similar wording

anybody.

Similar wording

That's just my

Similar wording

and that's not a zoning issue

Similar wording

that's just

Similar wording

the you know as far as like renovations or just the space or i'm just trying to understand it's

Similar wording

the space i mean okay it's it's it's not like it's teeny tiny you said it's 1100 square feet

Similar wording

yes 1100 11 to be it's and you're going to put a little kitchenette you said in there

Similar wording

okay okay um questions okay i guess sure and i'm hearing um board member gas and i guess your

Similar wording

other concern is you're kind of forcing the renter to go to the back of the house to to enter

Similar wording

the basement unit which is kind of not not the greatest sort of experience I guess so yeah

Similar wording

yeah I got you yeah structurally I thought that this would be the least modifiable because if I

Similar wording

were to completely restructure the house I would have to make new stairs you know what I mean like

Similar wording

have a new walkway um i would have to completely restructure the house to make it

Similar wording

i guess more favorable in that way um but it does have its

Similar wording

I guess, more favorable in that way, but it does have its own private entrance, shared

Similar wording

backyard space, full privacy of its own, but I understand the concerns.

Similar wording

Did any of those come up at the RCO meeting?

Similar wording

Not that the RCO meeting, oh, I did have, sorry, that was the last of my presentation.

Similar wording

The RCO meeting was relatively small.

Similar wording

there were only about four attendees um the main concern was uh just like having doing everything

Similar wording

in a legal way there are the most of the my block is uh single family but there are numerous

Similar wording

multi-family houses uh units on that block okay um questions from my attorney

Similar wording

not at this time out of my chair

Similar wording

um questions from our virtual audience you're not seeing the hands madam chair okay um planning

Similar wording

commission good evening liz fuselay from the planning commission the comprehensive plan

Similar wording

recommends no change whoops sorry let's do that again

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing neighborhood commercial

Similar wording

oh i'm in the wrong spot i am so sorry

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends no change in zoning at this location from the existing rsa3

Similar wording

residential zoning. There is no unique physical condition or circumstance of this property

Similar wording

that would prevent it from being used in strict conformity with the zoning code.

Similar wording

The City Planning Commission recommends that the board deny the requested variances for two-unit

Similar wording

living. Okay, so we want to hold this and talk about it in executive session. So what date do

Similar wording

I give her like for so we so we're going to hold for discussion we will vote on this matter next

Similar wording

Wednesday the 15th at 2 p.m. okay thank you all right thank you are there any other cases on the

Similar wording

330 hearing lists see no further hands miss chair oh thank you all right thank you everybody good

Similar wording

night have a good safe evening you as well great job everyone

Similar wording

Thank you, Emily.

Similar wording