civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 8, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 8, 20258h 7m

We're going to number...

Similar wording

Number seven first.

Similar wording

MI 2024-006-946-5773 Kemble Avenue.

Similar wording

Craig Smith is the owner-applicant.

Similar wording

I'll be coming back in as a panel shortly, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Good morning, Mr. Smith.

Similar wording

Mr. Smith, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Craig Smith, C-R-A-I-G, S-M-I-T-H, Craig Smith.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

This applicant is for use as a personal care home with an existing structure, whereas the proposed use personal care home requires special exception approval

Similar wording

in the RSA-5 zoning district.

Similar wording

There's unanimous opposition

Similar wording

from Oak West Community Coalition.

Similar wording

And there's also a letter of support

Similar wording

from the state representative,

Similar wording

Andrea Carroll,

Similar wording

Xavier-

Similar wording

Andrea.

Similar wording

The principal, yep, Carroll.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

And somebody named LK.

Similar wording

So, Mr. Smith,

Similar wording

we're up in the air

Similar wording

about what this is. Am I correct, Hillary?

Similar wording

Yes. No, Mr. Smith, I understand

Similar wording

at the time that the permit application

Similar wording

At the time that the permit application was filed, there was communication with the examiner about the use, and at the time it was determined to be personal care home, but I understand that since that time, there was a realization that it may not be the correct use.

Similar wording

was filed, there was

Similar wording

communication with the exam.

Similar wording

So maybe group living could be single room residents.

Similar wording

So what we're going to do today is we will hear the case and get that information.

Similar wording

And then I will go back to L&I and we will likely need to amend the refusal if it doesn't

Similar wording

appear that personal care home is the correct category.

Similar wording

So but we will hear that we will hear the case today and just hold if we for an amended

Similar wording

refusal and just voted a later date.

Similar wording

So you have to come back.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

So there's two things. I actually emailed just for clarification and never heard anything back from anyone, just kind of clarifying that it's not a personal care home. It's actually a group home for foster care youth. But we never received any contact back from anyone in that office.

Similar wording

And then the second thing, I never received an updated summary of the RCO meeting from my RCO.

Similar wording

What she sent me was grossly inaccurate. It did not reflect the numbers, nor did it reflect the accurate vote.

Similar wording

I did ask of her to share with me what she was going to share with the board prior to doing so, and she has not.

Similar wording

So I did hear board member Bergman state that there was gross opposition.

Similar wording

That's not what was the outcome of the call that we had.

Similar wording

I said there was opposition from them, but we do have a letter from her that said this was the second of two meetings.

Similar wording

The first meeting was held on March 13th with six attendees, but due to technical difficulties, no vote was taken.

Similar wording

During discussion, the sentiment was to oppose the proposal.

Similar wording

So that's inaccurate.

Similar wording

And the vote wasn't taken because she scheduled the meeting for 3 o'clock p.m.

Similar wording

And she should have scheduled it, what I later learned, for 6 o'clock p.m.

Similar wording

So why don't we do this?

Similar wording

Why don't you start your presentation?

Similar wording

Absolutely.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So I am going to share my screen with you guys.

Similar wording

Give me one sec.

Similar wording

Let me pull everything up.

Similar wording

I'm in a meeting James, you see the green go ahead you're coming up now, I'm in a meeting.

Similar wording

Are you guys able to see my screen?

Similar wording

We see it now.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So, good morning, everyone.

Similar wording

My name is Dr. Craig Smith.

Similar wording

I'm the CEO and founder of Foster and Success Boys to Men.

Similar wording

We are a nonprofit organization founded back in 2016.

Similar wording

Our Foster and Success Residential Care Program was implemented back in May of 2025.

Similar wording

So this is the most recent arm to the civic engagement work that we are implementing here in the city.

Similar wording

The location for our Alpha House location is 5773 Kimball Avenue, Philadelphia PA, 10141.

Similar wording

And this is a house. This is a picture of the front of the property.

Similar wording

Our mission is to close the opportunity divide by improving, excuse me, the positive life outcomes of youth at promise.

Similar wording

We don't believe that any youth are at risk, especially with the help that we're looking to provide them through early awareness, educational mentorship, resource alignment and leadership development, all of which will be in a residential setting.

Similar wording

One of the things that we strive to put forth for these young people is creating a sense of normalcy for these youth who have been in foster care, some as early as age seven, seven years of age, and having a sense of normalcy being in and out of different treatment facilities and different group homes and some foster care homes is a rarity to them.

Similar wording

So our program model, I do have a video of the house with the walkthrough.

Similar wording

You'll see it is a home like setting. We keep it small.

Similar wording

We keep it intimate with two to three young people in our care and in our program.

Similar wording

I'm asking the board today for us to expand this particular location to four or five young men because we have the capacity to serve more at this location.

Similar wording

Like I stated, we are a 501c3 nonprofit organization that specializes in coaching, mentorship, and educational programming.

Similar wording

Like I say, we are a 501c3 nonprofit organization that specializes in coaching, mentorship.

Similar wording

This particular residential care program is a 24-hour trauma-informed community-based residential program for youth involved in welfare services between the ages of 13 and 18.

Similar wording

These are not adjudicated youth.

Similar wording

These are not bad kids, as someone had mentioned before.

Similar wording

These are young people who need a home, who need some structure, who need some consistency, and who ultimately need some love and help from individuals who are well-trained in this particular work and have an extensive background to really help them manifest their dreams to become a part of reality.

Similar wording

We are licensed through the Office of Children and Youth Services. We bear an L38 license, so we are not operating out of compliance. We are in compliance with the state.

Similar wording

In terms of a program overview, and we'll move this over, shared rooms, home-cooked meals, varying levels of assistance with daily living.

Similar wording

We have a pre-supervised independent living curriculum where we are teaching these young men life skills, skills that's going to help them navigate life once they're aged out at 18.

Similar wording

They can actually stay with us until they're 21 years of age, but the plan is for the young people who have the academic potential and promise to age out of 18 and go on to some type of post-secondary program, preferably a residential program.

Similar wording

We provide the custodial care.

Similar wording

We're teaching on laundry and housekeeping.

Similar wording

We are certified to manage medication, transportation to and from outside activities such as college and professional sporting events.

Similar wording

We have unique skill building programs.

Similar wording

We have our Emergent Leaders of Tomorrow Rites of Passage program, our entrepreneurship program, our financial literacy program, and a few other programs that we offer in-house in addition to the community-based initiatives that we also offer as well.

Similar wording

Some of our program highlights, you can see right to our left, that picture is two of our youth currently in our care who participate in the Junior Barbara Academy with P. Michael.

Similar wording

He received a lot of grant money from the city of Philadelphia, so his work is recognized throughout the city.

Similar wording

They actually have a program this evening from six to eight on Wednesdays, and they also have programming on Sundays.

Similar wording

but we have post-secondary prep. My background is in higher education. I have a master's in

Similar wording

clinical psychology, a doctorate in ed leadership and management from Drexel. I served as a guidance

Similar wording

counselor, college admissions counselor. So pretty much all of the work that we're tying into how

Similar wording

we're helping to shape the lives of these young men at Promise, I have over 20 years of experience

Similar wording

working in this arena. Just found that housing insecurity was always a challenge for persistence

Similar wording

and retention, oftentimes with our young people. So we just added this group home model. If they're

Similar wording

with us 24-7 and they're under our care, the likelihood that they will fall through the cracks

Similar wording

or slip through the cracks diminishes. We have a work readiness program. We provide trauma-informed

Similar wording

services, our rights of passage program, that 15 by 18. So there's 15 core things that we believe

Similar wording

that the young people should know before they hit age of 18. So we're constantly teaching them and

Similar wording

coaching them on those particular things, how to change a tire, how to change oil, how to manage a

Similar wording

bank account, how to write a check, how to fill out an envelope, right? We have our health and

Similar wording

wellness regimen. A lot of these young men have come to us with high A1Cs, pre-diabetic. So our

Similar wording

health and wellness regimen has got our one kid who's 16, 275 pounds. We got him down to 260

Similar wording

and his A1C went from a 6.3 to a 5.9.

Similar wording

So we're getting him in the right direction

Similar wording

through diet and exercise

Similar wording

in our partnership with the YMCA.

Similar wording

Service learning activities.

Similar wording

We do weekly community service

Similar wording

with the shared food program

Similar wording

where they're packing boxes three hours a week,

Similar wording

helping out in the community that way.

Similar wording

And also cleaning the block.

Similar wording

We have a lot of elderly folk in the neighborhood

Similar wording

who don't have the ability to sweep up the leaves and to get the trash out front of the

Similar wording

houses.

Similar wording

So my young people are seen doing that, found doing that as well.

Similar wording

There's a lot of partners in the work that we work closely with.

Similar wording

SARE Health Center, also the Strawberry Mansion Health Center number 12, has been a huge help

Similar wording

to us, helping us to navigate and stay compliant with ensuring that the kids are receiving

Similar wording

within the first 30 days of being placed with us, their physicals, their shots are being updated,

Similar wording

any forms that they need. Also with management, I mentioned the Junior Barber Academy. We have

Similar wording

Black Men Hill. We have therapy sessions through them. Each of the young men come with their own

Similar wording

Each of the young men come with their own respective therapists based off of where they're

Similar wording

respective therapists based off of where they're placed.

Similar wording

placed.

Similar wording

And then we also have group therapy by a licensed counselor that comes in on Sundays.

Similar wording

And then we have yoga, in-house yoga on Mondays as well.

Similar wording

We have the YMCA team leadership program.

Similar wording

My young men participate two Saturdays out of the month in the Philadelphia Police Explorers

Similar wording

program with the 35th District.

Similar wording

I mentioned the food chair program.

Similar wording

And then we have our sister partner catered to you, Youth Haven, where they house females, where that's where they're receiving some of the financial literacy, the tutoring and some of the grooming stuff.

Similar wording

So these are just some of the partners that we partner with to keep these young men busy.

Similar wording

The key to our program is just just for a point of information, what we're here for today is the use of the property.

Similar wording

So I think you need to start showing the property, what it's like inside and things like that and how you intend.

Similar wording

Sure. Absolutely. So that's just the overall program. So all of this is what's happening inside of the house.

Similar wording

Yep. I have a video, so I'll I'll retrieve the video. Let me stop sharing this and then I will share the video of the home.

Similar wording

Can you guys see this? What we did and it just went off. It's black right now.

Similar wording

You might want to talk like as it goes through how many bedrooms do you have? Where are the rooms where they would all join together?

Similar wording

things like that. Yeah. So this video is a full walkthrough of the property. So it'll actually

Similar wording

show the rooms as well. There's three bedrooms in this property. Actually, I'm going to mute this.

Similar wording

I don't know how to mute the video, but we have the capacity. That's the office space downstairs.

Similar wording

There's three bedrooms upstairs. One could be used as a single room, and then the other two

Similar wording

can be used as double beds. So right now in this stage, as this is now bedroom number one. So this

Similar wording

is a one-bed room because we moved the office down to the basement that we saw.

Similar wording

Compliance requires that each single room

Similar wording

needs to be 70 square feet, so that passes that. This is the second bed room.

Similar wording

That's about 175, 190 square feet where two young

Similar wording

men can be housed in that particular room.

Similar wording

this is the bathroom

Similar wording

how many bathrooms it's two full bathrooms in the house but this is the bathroom that's used

Similar wording

specifically for the young men that door is permanently locked so it's not a entrance or

Similar wording

exit and then this is the front bedroom here that houses two young men each have their own closets

Similar wording

somebody with them 24 hours a day

Similar wording

mr smith somebody's there 24 hours a day yes we have 24 hours staffing the young men are never in

Similar wording

the community without us. Otherwise, they're at a structured event and activity. They don't get

Similar wording

free reign to walk to the stores or none of that. They're literally under supervision 24-7.

Similar wording

You move the staff office down to the basement? Is that what you're saying?

Similar wording

Yes. Yeah.

Similar wording

All right. Anything else you want to add?

Similar wording

That's pretty much where we are. We currently have the capacity for

Similar wording

three. We're currently licensed for three. We have the capacity to serve up to five young men

Similar wording

in the home. So what we're asking of the board is for the board to allow us

Similar wording

the permission to expand our reach and expand the work that we're doing.

Similar wording

One of the last things in terms of the impact of the work that we're having on the young men,

Similar wording

I have a young man who actually just tried to bring me something now. We're a huge advocate

Similar wording

for these young men. They've been overlooked. I have a young man in my care who's 16 years of age

Similar wording

who came to me not being able to read at all. At all. He's currently reading on a third grade

Similar wording

reading level, and he's been with me since June 1st. So we do an intensive work with these young

Similar wording

men because we're able to literally change their lives by fostering their success. And that's what

Similar wording

the whole heart is behind the work that we're doing uh as i stated on our co call they can

Similar wording

As I stated on RCO call, they can contact the police. The police have never been called to the home. There was a question during that first meeting about if it would tear down the property value. The home, in question, has appraised two years ago for over $300,000. So, if anything, my beautiful home that I've trusted and lent to the group home to do this meaningful work.

Similar wording

contact the police the police have

Similar wording

Are you supported by the neighbors on either side?

Similar wording

Absolutely, I am.

Similar wording

All right. Questions from the board.

Similar wording

You said you currently have three of kids there now.

Similar wording

Yeah, we call them scholars. Yes.

Similar wording

OK, three. OK. And the goal is to have five.

Similar wording

Yes, sir. You said that's what the state will allow.

Similar wording

That's the. In that space, the house only have capacity for five.

Similar wording

Okay, for five.

Similar wording

The state allows us to operate with three without change in zone, and more than three, we have to come and go through this process.

Similar wording

But because we have the capacity for five, I'm looking for five.

Similar wording

We probably will only do four in that space, but things are subject to change.

Similar wording

You never know.

Similar wording

So I would much rather be in a position to offer this service and resource to more young people than less.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Right. So, but the state said that the building as it stands right now and as configured can only have five.

Similar wording

Well, can only have three. Otherwise, I go through this rezoning process.

Similar wording

No, no, no. Regardless of the zoning process.

Similar wording

Oh, yes.

Similar wording

State requirements, the max is five.

Similar wording