civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - March 12, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Mar 12, 20255h 59m

Right. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth? The whole truth is nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed, sir.

Similar wording

I'd like to make a couple of points also followed up with a couple of questions. So I've owned the property in the front 1224 for 16 years. I've lived in it for 14. As far as I'm concerned from witnessing in person over the years, Terrence Dowd, the previous owner, was using that structure as an office.

Similar wording

He was running his painting business out of it with the adjacent garage.

Similar wording

It was not used as a triplex.

Similar wording

My question would be, are there more interior photos of three kitchens?

Similar wording

Are there three leases?

Similar wording

Are there three tenants?

Similar wording

That's a question I have because I don't believe that to be true over my 16 years of ownership.

Similar wording

It has been an issue with that alleyway and that easement on who owns that easement.

Similar wording

It's been a nightmare with the traffic coming in and out of that easement and that alleyway with the previous owners painting clients.

Similar wording

The trash situation was a nightmare, and this is with not having three tenants back there.

Similar wording

Emily Bremer is the tenant of 1224 Columbia, so she signed that form, but she's in no position to vote yes or no, in my opinion.

Similar wording

I'm the owner of the property.

Similar wording

Another question would be, that's an 18 by 29 footprint on that structure.

Similar wording

I don't see how it's even legal to have a triplex on an 18 by 29 foot structure.

Similar wording

And my recommendation moving forward with the group and to the prior or the current owner is, I don't know how far back this goes with zoning, but that garage next door that he purchased with 1224 rear would be a good way for them to access the street.

Similar wording

I think at some point back in the day, that structure, the existing triplex, so to be, would exit and get to the street through the garage because those buildings are attached, but they are separately deeded.

Similar wording

So there's a couple of points I have, and mainly just the trash and the throughfare, people coming and going out of my easement or our easement, I would say.

Similar wording

All right. Thank you for taking the time to call us. We appreciate it. Do you have any questions, Bill?

Similar wording

May I just respond really quickly? Mr. Epperson?

Similar wording

Why don't we do this? Why don't we wait that there's another person with their hand up and then you respond at one time.

Similar wording

Next hand, please.

Similar wording

Yes, the next hand is Robert Everett.

Similar wording

He's from Fishtown. Okay. Hi, Mr. Everett.

Similar wording

Coming in now.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

good morning mr everett i'm here it took a while i know you are just state your name

Similar wording

please and speak for the court stenographer yes first name is robert last name everett

Similar wording

E-V-E-R-E-T-T.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

You are the Fishtown RCL, am I correct?

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

I am one of the co-chairs.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

You have our letter, so I won't go on that.

Similar wording

I can't explain why we had eight abstentions.

Similar wording

Sometimes they hit the wrong button since we do it on Zoom, but that is what it is.

Similar wording

A question earlier from one of the board members there. Did the tenants attend the community meeting? The way we verify, we pull the list of everyone who voted and verify them against our database of verified members where people have given us evidence that they live where they say they live, and none of them are on our list for that meeting as having had attended.

Similar wording

And in addition to the letters that went out from the attorney for the applicant, we follow up and do actual door-to-door flyers for the same meeting the weekend before, so they should have had an opportunity to attend, with the exception if there's someone in the rear, because the gate's locked and we couldn't get back there.

Similar wording

All right. Thank you, Mr. Everett. We appreciate taking the time. Mr. O'Brien, do you want to respond?

Similar wording

Yes, just briefly to Mr. Epperson. Mr. Epperson sent an email prior to the RCO meeting to the Fishtown neighbors saying that he was the owner of the property and disagreed with Mr. Dowd's affidavit that it was continuously used as apartments.

Similar wording

It was that email was discussed at the RCO meeting. As far as I know, Mr. Epperson did not appear or participate in the RCO meeting. So there wasn't any further context.

Similar wording

And regarding the leases, I have two of the three leases here with me. I did not put.

Similar wording

And regarding the leases, I have two of the three leases here with me.

Similar wording

I did not put them part of the package because I thought it contained personal information wasn't necessary.

Similar wording

These are dated in January of 24 between the current residents of the first floor and third floor.

Similar wording

I don't have the second floor lease with me.

Similar wording

The rent is $800 a month and it includes all utilities and it extends until February of 26.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And they were signed by Mr. Dower.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

So we're going to hold this till next Wednesday morning.

Similar wording

We'll vote at 930.

Similar wording

We're going to take it at executive session and go over all the issues.

Similar wording

Chair, do you want my recommendation?

Similar wording

Oh, I'm sorry.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Amy Boyd from the Planning Commission.

Similar wording

oh i don't think i'm on video am i just a second

Similar wording

okay amy board with the planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends no change in zoning

Similar wording

at this location from the existing single family residential rsa5 the limited access by a narrow

Similar wording

easement to the back multiple dwelling units would risk life and safety of those residents in the

Similar wording

space and create congestions for the front property therefore the planning commission

Similar wording

recommends that the board deny the requested variance for multi-family household living

Similar wording

thank you very much we'll vote next wednesday thank you okay thank you

Similar wording

number three mi 2024 004 299 7143 edmond street or hey follow is the tenant applicant

Similar wording

This application is for use as artist studios and artesian industrial in an existing structure. The proposed use to artist studios and artesian industrial is prohibited in the RSA 3 zoning district. There's support from the Taconi Civic Association.

Similar wording

Do we see his hand?

Similar wording

Sorry, Chair, I do not.

Similar wording

Oh, yeah, there he is.

Similar wording

Should be coming in shortly.

Similar wording

good morning good morning sir could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

yes how you doing is george falu j-o-r-g-e falu f-a-l-u right do you swear or affirm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes sir our vice chair has a few questions

Similar wording

okay good morning sir have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits as needed

Similar wording

and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Thank you, sir. Please proceed and share your screen.

Similar wording

I'm sorry. I didn't hear you at the end.

Similar wording

You can proceed and share your screen.

Similar wording

Oh, okay.

Similar wording

Your presentation.

Similar wording

Niney, where

Similar wording

I share at?

Similar wording

There should be a green button at the bottom

Similar wording

of your screen in the center.

Similar wording

It says share.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

You have to open your documents up as well

Similar wording

before you share.

Similar wording

I'll open the document there.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Y'all see the documents?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

X this out.

Similar wording

That's good.

Similar wording

You can start your presentation.

Similar wording

Oh, okay.

Similar wording

All right. So, so I'm asking for a variance for the corner property of 7143 Edmond. And this is the blueprint right here. I'm sorry. Blueprint right here where it's the front entrance right here.

Similar wording

and the windows on the side

Similar wording

we're here on the left hand side

Similar wording

I'm trying to move myself but I can't

Similar wording

see my screen

Similar wording

and the office as you said

Similar wording

front office is the front

Similar wording

and right behind is the bathroom

Similar wording

and the main part

Similar wording

of the shop is the back

Similar wording

part of it where it's the dryer

Similar wording

and my

Similar wording

auto print

Similar wording

so it has two three closets

Similar wording

with the

Similar wording

a little sink

Similar wording

in hot or cold water.

Similar wording

And then

Similar wording

I also have

Similar wording

On the right-hand side of 7143 Edmond, on Friendship Street, I also have a garage that I'm renting in front of the property as well.

Similar wording

on the same side of the

Similar wording

on the right hand side of 7143

Similar wording

Edmond.

Similar wording

Why don't you tell us what you're trying to do?

Similar wording

I'm doing this as a screen print. It's a t-shirt shop, a silkscreen t-shirt.

Similar wording

this is the entrance of the shop right here

Similar wording

front door I can show you a better picture than that that's the bathroom

Similar wording

this is the front of the shop

Similar wording

as well as the office I was saying

Similar wording

and they go to the back of the shop

Similar wording

right here this part right here

Similar wording

yeah it's a silk screen

Similar wording

t-shirt

Similar wording

is there a residence above this

Similar wording

yes there's a residence above it

Similar wording

it's two apartments

Similar wording

up top over me

Similar wording

and how many

Similar wording

years have you had this

Similar wording

I say

Similar wording

I rent

Similar wording

2018

Similar wording

I believe

Similar wording

this is uh the back of the shop as well left side is the windows like bow windows

Similar wording

this is the front that's the entrance to the shop where do you get correct

Similar wording

where do you get into the two units above the two units above is up top of the shop

Similar wording

i mean how do you how do you get in there i'm saying oh they have their own entrance

Similar wording

on the left side

Similar wording

they have their own stairway

Similar wording

their own door

Similar wording

and on the right side as well

Similar wording

they have their own entrance as well

Similar wording

So tell me what happened when you went to the RCO

Similar wording

When I went to the RCO

Similar wording

the meeting

Similar wording

I didn't have any objections

Similar wording

not too many people showed up

Similar wording

Right, okay

Similar wording

but

Similar wording

the people that actually

Similar wording

showed up agreed to it.

Similar wording

Let me ask you this.

Similar wording

Before you rented this

Similar wording

property, what was it being used

Similar wording

for then? It was

Similar wording

a non-profit

Similar wording

art school.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you.

Similar wording

They was doing clay

Similar wording

stuff,

Similar wording

oil painting.

Similar wording

You can see it on the

Similar wording

right side of the building.

Similar wording

little pieces of mirror that's on the wall

Similar wording

that's some of the stuff that they were doing

Similar wording

inside of there too as well

Similar wording

questions for the board

Similar wording

yeah I have two questions one

Similar wording

are you using the garages that you

Similar wording

showed in the images

Similar wording

yeah as storage

Similar wording

all three or

Similar wording

no just one I'm sorry

Similar wording

the far right to the

Similar wording

the garage

Similar wording

yes the far right is it's three garages and i'm using the far right so to get into the garage you

Similar wording

have to leave the store walk down the sidewalk there's no through access through the building

Similar wording

correct no at all you have to come outside okay and then how long has your business been in

Similar wording

operation um i've been uh i'm working not there but uh in my grandma's basement since 2016

Similar wording

and then i have we had sold the house and i have rent this place since 2018 and then in the

Similar wording

silkscreen process um i know there's a number of chemicals that are used to treat the like the

Similar wording

of fabrics how are you handling the storage and the disposal of any chemicals related to the

Similar wording

dyeing process okay well um the the type of chemical i do use it's called it's plastic saw

Similar wording

ink and it's similar to like uh like paint but it's for clothes and um when it's time to waste

Similar wording

is that I have a solution product

Similar wording

where it's safe for

Similar wording

the sewage when

Similar wording

it's time to get it off the

Similar wording

screen.

Similar wording