civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - March 12, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Mar 12, 20255h 59m

So you're just

Similar wording

putting it down a regular drain inside the

Similar wording

property? No, there's a solution with

Similar wording

it that

Similar wording

when it goes down the drain,

Similar wording

it goes through this

Similar wording

solution and it goes through

Similar wording

the pipes before it hits the

Similar wording

drain. Like it flushes

Similar wording

and then what do you need to do any updates to the property or have you done any updates to the

Similar wording

property as it relates to ventilation uh they already have ventilation in there all i did was

Similar wording

it already had ventilation in there all i did was uh add um i made it a little bit uh bigger

Similar wording

uh add um i made it

Similar wording

with a ventilation it was like a i think it was a 18 inch fan exhaust fan and i made it to a 22 inch

Similar wording

okay but no major systems no no major systems at all uh the only other difference was the electric

Similar wording

I had to put a brand-new panel on the electric.

Similar wording

And did you pull permits with L&I?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Did that work?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

I have a question.

Similar wording

So when customers, they come into your building to place orders, is there any kind of – there was a concern that maybe parking on the sidewalk.

Similar wording

is there adequate parking you think around your area so that if customers had to come in

Similar wording

to place orders that they wouldn't have to park on the sidewalk yeah yeah there's this parking

Similar wording

there's plenty of parking it says uh sometimes i have uh customers come and they'll like pick up

Similar wording

and there'll be a like a bunch of boxes so they have reversing to put it in the back of the van

Similar wording

and stuff like that but besides that it's not like a constant where they always park on the sidewalk

Similar wording

other questions yes sir what is your plan for removing um motor oil and transmission fluids

Similar wording

from the site excuse me i'm sorry i didn't get that plans to change my motor oil yes the waste

Similar wording

as far as uh the only thing that takes the oil is it's a compressor like and it's something small

Similar wording

I could put it in a little

Similar wording

like a gallon bucket

Similar wording

it's not

Similar wording

like I don't work on the cars or anything

Similar wording

in the garage

Similar wording

so I guess

Similar wording

I guess I got

Similar wording

a couple of questions

Similar wording

so

Similar wording

you okay

Similar wording

I'm

Similar wording

going to

Similar wording

go through how I think this works

Similar wording

and you can tell me if i'm correct okay sure sure so how do you get the t-shirts that you're going

Similar wording

to imprint um to this premises are they delivered in trucks vans how how does that how does that

Similar wording

okay yes so when when when um it's trying to do it when i take an order sometimes i purchase the

Similar wording

shirts for them or they bring the shirts themselves and I print on them or I give them my

Similar wording

idea and you know whether they like it or not you know I print it or not okay so you have

Similar wording

deliveries of through UPS like yes through I'm sorry this is like more bulk delivery correct

Similar wording

of the t-shirts? Yes. For most part, yes. I say about 80%. About 80%. Sometimes I do retail.

Similar wording

I get a little bit of both, but more of a contracting. Okay. And then if you're doing

Similar wording

these kind of bulk things this is uh you do the imprinting and what have you you then box this all

Similar wording

up and then this has to be delivered to somebody or do they come to pick it up or how does this

Similar wording

work yes the once this once the product is finished there i'll call they'll come some

Similar wording

customers that come pick up or they're uh or i send it through ups okay mostly it'll be customers

Similar wording

coming to pick up all right and so then most of the the t-shirts are inside your building um until

Similar wording

such time as the the work is done and you're shipping it out to wherever correct yes yes yes

Similar wording

Once I finish the work, it'll give them about 24 to 48 hours.

Similar wording

They'll be there. I'm very local.

Similar wording

Most of your orders, they're online? They're in person?

Similar wording

How do we do this? I don't see that there's a sign of any sort.

Similar wording

No, there's no signages yet.

Similar wording

People just

Similar wording

go on my social media, word of mouth.

Similar wording

so i'm working on that part as well okay all right and about how how large is this

Similar wording

it's it's um it's not very big it's just like i'm gonna say about almost 800 square footage

Similar wording

and the actual um

Similar wording

and the actual

Similar wording

you have one of these machines to do the

Similar wording

screening or do you have multiple? Yes, it's only one machine

Similar wording

one machine. How many people do you have working with you?

Similar wording

It's just me, like I said, it's very small, it's not a huge

Similar wording

Okay, so how many of these would you say you produce

Similar wording

in a week, shall we say? Far as printing t-shirts

Similar wording

um i'd say about five to eight hundred

Similar wording

depending on the the you know depending on the client

Similar wording

what type of work for schools or events and you say you've been doing this since 2018

Similar wording

on my own yes 28 2016 on my own i've been working for other companies

Similar wording

right but i thought you said that you moved into this property yes to 2018 i moved in this property

Similar wording

all right okay thank you okay uh sorry mr felu i have a couple follow-up questions

Similar wording

so you moved in in 2018 and it's looking like this has been a use issue since and i'm just

Similar wording

what when was were you made aware that the business was now in violation

Similar wording

and what has taken so long to address it okay so yeah there was uh i didn't know any better when i

Similar wording

actually moved into this building and um the landlord had i asked him about the um there was

Similar wording

a piece of paper that said a non-profit art school and i told him that uh i asked him is this is good

Similar wording

for my for my business as well as i do artwork as well and um he told me that i was fine with it

Similar wording

until i think it was like two years a year and a half ago and i it i was i guess i didn't know

Similar wording

any better on that part and that's when i had a license inspection guy come out and say no you

Similar wording

have to actually read

Similar wording

to have it under

Similar wording

my name and different

Similar wording

title.

Similar wording

That was the reason why

Similar wording

it took that long.

Similar wording

It looks like there's a number, and I don't

Similar wording

know if it's for your space specifically or the whole

Similar wording

building, but it looks like there's been a number

Similar wording

of fire code violations that

Similar wording

go back a few years.

Similar wording

I was wondering, have you

Similar wording

had to take steps, or is the landlord

Similar wording

taking steps to address it?

Similar wording

Yes, the land that that was the building that that on the basement. So when the license inspections came out downstairs in the basement, they had like old panels. I guess that was there before the new breakers they had put up and they didn't secure it right.

Similar wording

that was just like wires almost everywhere in the basement.

Similar wording

And since then, they had dressed up the coat with fire alarms and stuff like that.

Similar wording

And can you explain, like, who did the electrical work for you?

Similar wording

It was, his name was Lee, his business is Lime Electrician, but his name is Lee Lawarski.

Similar wording

and you and you're under the belief that he pulled a permit to do that work for for for my

Similar wording

for my unit but he i think pro managed that's the people that i rent from they uh handled

Similar wording

what they had to handle for their their building got it so i just want to let you know that there's

Similar wording

no electrical permit on record with the city that shows that this work was permitted and

Similar wording

done by a licensed electrician and i just want to make you aware like the the thing that we're

Similar wording

looking at today is both the approval for you to be able to use the space in the way that you've

Similar wording

been using it we understand that since 2018 but it would would require you to get a certificate

Similar wording

of occupancy for you to be able to continue to operate which means you have a certificate of

Similar wording

occupancy yes you can't you can't yeah that's you have you need approval from us to get the

Similar wording

certificate of occupancy oh i'm sorry i guess i'm talking about the wrong thing then yeah um but i

Similar wording

just want to let you know because that means that anything like as a as a business anything that in

Similar wording

the building that was not up to code would have to be brought up to code and done under a license

Similar wording

and permitted would have to be done under a licensed professional and permitted so i just

Similar wording

wanted to make you aware just uh there's been no plan have you been working with any

Similar wording

like licensed professional to kind of put together your layout plans for the shop yeah there was um

Similar wording

the electrician he he um he was like he is licensed electrician that's the guy

Similar wording

the electrician he um he was like he is licensed electrician that's the guy they uh recommended uh

Similar wording

get and he just didn't pull a permit so i just wanted to make you aware because you showed us a

Similar wording

hand-drawn plan that i'm assuming you sketched and you've given us sort of estimates for the square

Similar wording

footage that anything moving forward would require you to get a ceo and you'd have to hire a

Similar wording

professional and it could uncover some other things that you'd have to update in that space

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from our attorney?

Similar wording

Sir, you are leasing unit 1F.

Similar wording

Is that correct in this building?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

I have a question real quick.

Similar wording

So could you clarify for me, are you using the basement or does your business use the

Similar wording

basement as well?

Similar wording

No, I'm no use in the basement.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the audience or the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Daniel Trubman will be promoted

Similar wording

questions or comments

Similar wording

could you identify yourself please

Similar wording

can we see him

Similar wording

he's disappeared not there uh no he was there but i don't okay planning commission

Similar wording

amy board with the planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends a change in

Similar wording

zoning at this location from rsa3 residential single family to cmx1 commercial mixed use the

Similar wording

proposed use is consistent with documented prior use. The Planning Commission recommends a board

Similar wording

grant their proposed use for artist studios and artisan industrial. MI 2024-004-299-7143

Similar wording

Edmund Street. I vote yes with proviso. Certificate of occupancy has to be issued.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Oh, and also, I'm sorry, proviso, one F only. So a certificate of proclamation must be issued and one F only.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Tywin, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shahid, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you, sir.

Similar wording

Number four, MI 2024-006-065-6156 Mulberry Street.

Similar wording

Corn Wise is the attorney.

Similar wording

Inanimous non-opposition from the Wissahickon Civic Association.

Similar wording

Corn Wise is coming in as a panelist.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You're welcome.

Similar wording

I was shuffling my screens.

Similar wording

Hi, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Corin Wise, C-O-R-E-N-W-I-S-E, Attorney for Applicant Patricia Ludwig, 6156 Mulberry Street.

Similar wording

Okay, do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Our vice chair has a few questions.

Similar wording

Good morning, sir. Have you emailed?

Similar wording

Excuse me.

Similar wording

Do you swear to, do you agree to the...

Similar wording

Do you agree to waive to read another refusal or stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that's needed and required?

Similar wording

In this case, five days in advance of this hearing.

Similar wording

I have.

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I'm going to share my screen.

Similar wording

So this is 6156 Mulberry Street.

Similar wording

this is actually a photo of the back where you see two garages and um

Similar wording

why don't you say what you're trying to do sir yes sir uh i represent patricia ludwig

Similar wording

I represent Patricia Ludwig. She's the owner of this property since 1987. It's been a duplex. It was purchased as a duplex. She's had a rental license as a duplex since that time, but only recently found out that zoning was required.

Similar wording

she's the owner of this property since 1987

Similar wording

so we are seeking a variance to legalize this existing duplex at 6156 mulberry it's on a block

Similar wording

front of four uh these four or you see two in this photo uh they're all duplexes um okay so uh

Similar wording

let me when he shows the photos and

Similar wording

trying to go through the photos

Similar wording

Nothing's not working.

Similar wording

You see the garage doors?

Similar wording

We see garage doors, but I understand.

Similar wording

Why don't you get to the front?

Similar wording

Why don't we go to the front?

Similar wording

That's what I'm trying to do.

Similar wording

So let me try and reshare.

Similar wording