civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 22, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 22, 20266h 32m

I guess does the interpreter want to interpret the question first?

Similar wording

So, the criteria is that they're a member of this Jeep club or the softball team.

Similar wording

It's mostly adults over the age of 40, men and women.

Similar wording

In terms of dues, I would ask the interpreter to ask my client to see collect dues from the members of the clubs.

Similar wording

Así que la criteria para los miembros del club de Jeep y el equipo de softball, la mayoría son adultos sobre la edad de 40 años, hombres y mujeres.

Similar wording

Acerca de cuotas, se lo voy a preguntar a usted, señor Mota, ¿hay alguna cuota para los miembros?

Similar wording

no no no dudes so can you ask my client if he maintains the property with all his own

Similar wording

money así que señor usted mantiene la propiedad con su propio dinero entonces

Similar wording

So we do raffles.

Similar wording

There you go.

Similar wording

No, I mean, I'm just, I'm just trying to figure out. Yeah. I mean,

Similar wording

there must be some kind of upkeep. Bills. Yeah. Bills, you know,

Similar wording

that come up as part of this. So I'm just trying to figure out, okay.

Similar wording

So is this just a group that kind of chips in a little bit whenever the bills

Similar wording

come due or how they manage to, you know, keep things going?

Similar wording

exactly and it's a pretty lean operation so you know so then the thing with the jeeps i mean

Similar wording

does anybody keep them there already he keeps a jeep there but when like the jeep club is this

Similar wording

is i'm not in this sort of i'm not in the jeep sort of social circles but my understanding from

Similar wording

talking to him is that you know they'll meet up you know the group will meet up there and then

Similar wording

they'll sort of do a drive about in their jeeps but they don't no one's keeping their jeeps

Similar wording

there overnight except he has one car that he keeps there along with the motorcycle

Similar wording

así que este lo que estaban preguntando es que para el club de los jeeps que si este otras

Similar wording

personas mantenían los jeeps en la propiedad este su representante contestó que usted solamente que

Similar wording

tiene su jeep y su motora en la propiedad pero todos los demás personas solamente se encuentran

Similar wording

ahí y después hacen sus giras en este al salir

Similar wording

y así que el espacio no se renta a otras organizaciones

Similar wording

questions for questions from our attorney yes i just i just have one question you indicated that

Similar wording

uh your client parks his jeep there so i assume that the existing non-accessory parking use is

Similar wording

to remain with the uh yes please request okay then we need to make that a proviso

Similar wording

remain with the uh yes please request okay then we need to make that a proviso then

Similar wording

all right proviso that would be um one second existing non-accessory parking use to remain

Similar wording

existing uh non-accessory parking use to remain if you are going to grant the variance request

Similar wording

either temporary permanent whatever it is that needs to be another

Similar wording

question from the virtual audience did you get that to him

Similar wording

I will right now. Así que van a este añadir un proviso que es que el estacionamiento existente

Similar wording

no asesorio.

Similar wording

Okay. Questions or comments from the virtual audience.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, I do not see any hands raised.

Similar wording

planning commission

Similar wording

sorry amy board with the planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends no change

Similar wording

to the current rsa 5 residential single family zoning at this location the property is remapped

Similar wording

from i2 medium industrial in 2024 in a community supported map change however the property has a

Similar wording

history of non-residential uses including auto repair and a special exception for assembly and

Similar wording

entertainment in 2023 the planning commission recommends that the board grant their request

Similar wording

advance for private clubs and my 2026 001 136 10 1052 to 54 roy street i vote yes with proviso

Similar wording

existing non-accessory parking to remain and this is interesting would you like me to interpret the

Similar wording

planning commission statement así que éste en mi porte la comisión de planificación el plan

Similar wording

integral recomienda no modificar la actual sonificación residencial unifamiliar rs a 5

Similar wording

en esta ubicación la propiedad fue reclasificada de categoría industrial de mediana intensidad en

Similar wording

el 2024 como parte de un cambio de sonificación respaldo por la comunidad no esté obstante el

Similar wording

Este mueble cuenta con antecedentes de usos no residenciales, entre ellos un taller de reparación de automóviles y una autorización especial concedida en el 2023 para actividades de reunión de entretenimiento.

Similar wording

La Comisión de Planeo recomienda que la Junta le dé los avances pedidos de un club privado, así que MI 2026 00113610 en la dirección 1052 a 54 Royce Street. Yo voto que sí con provisos y existente el estacionamiento existente no asesorio.

Similar wording

i guess yeah i got it yeah so i voted yep just you i voted okay michael johns my vote is yes

Similar wording

with provisos michael johns me what does he come provisos

Similar wording

cheryl gaston my food is yes with proviso cheryl gaston me about this

Similar wording

comprovisos tenetta graham my vote is yes with proviso internet grammy vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

thank you thank you number three mi 2026 001 027

Similar wording

i'll say interpreter thank you so much as usual all right thank you for using this

Similar wording

service interconnecting mi 2026 001 027 3941 mount vernon street henry clinton is the attorney

Similar wording

thank you sir

Similar wording

good afternoon mr chairman members of the board council could you please state your name and

Similar wording

spell for the stenographer sure henry clinton h-e-n-r-y clinton c-l-i-n-t-o-n right um do you

Similar wording

swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do council could you

Similar wording

identify your client a relationship to the property sure my client is lefter lefter demon d-h-i-m-a

Similar wording

and he is on the call all right and you also have support from the mantua civic association

Similar wording

our vice chair has a few questions good afternoon have you submitted your documents and exhibits

Similar wording

five days in advance of this hearing i submitted the bulk of them we just had a community meeting

Similar wording

on july 20th monday night so some of the documents came in late okay all right thank you for standing

Similar wording

on the set and do you wave the reading of the refusal stipulate to its accuracy i do all right

Similar wording

and do you waive the reading of the refusal to stipulate to its accuracy

Similar wording

i do all right thank you you can share your screen and proceed with your case

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

thank you mr graham

Similar wording

is that visible mr chairman it is okay uh again good afternoon mr chairman members of the board

Similar wording

i'm here on behalf of ahm properties llc but my client is on the call leftler dima

Similar wording

This is a request for a two-family dwelling on a block that has other multifamily units on the block, including the right next door at 3943 was three units.

Similar wording

And the back story on this is, and the reason we had such a late community meeting is, we had an initial community meeting where we suggested exactly what was next door, three units.

Similar wording

The community group did not like that.

Similar wording

Now, grant you $39.43 is a corner property.

Similar wording

The board granted three dwelling units there.

Similar wording

We asked for the same thing.

Similar wording

Didn't go over very well, so we came back with a revised set of plans asking for two units rather than three.

Similar wording

The refusal, this is an RSA 5 zoning district.

Similar wording

Household living, you can see the application requested three dwelling units.

Similar wording

And as I say, we have downsized that to two dwelling units.

Similar wording

RCO letter of support, just coming two days ago.

Similar wording

Photographs, 3900 block of Mount Vernon. We're right here, one vacant lot in off the corner.

Similar wording

That vacant lot is now, the structure is up and I have photographs of the existing building triplex that's there now.

Similar wording

Again, here's the corner property, which I'll show you. Ours is one in.

Similar wording

so this is the corner property 3943 and we are 3941 and then there's one or two lots in between us

Similar wording

and the next two-story homes

Similar wording

these are the revised plans uh that were submitted and then approved by the rco the other day uh

Similar wording

Three stories, bays at the second and third floor with a rooftop deck, all brick, and some hardy board siding on the second and third floor.

Similar wording

What we've done to accommodate some living space in the basement, and we've done this on other projects, actually on one on this particular block.

Similar wording

We have spiral steps in the egress well, which permit one to walk up and out if there is an issue of any type in the basement.

Similar wording

floor plans

Similar wording

I can walk through them

Similar wording

enter the front door

Similar wording

I walk down into the basement

Similar wording

in the basement there are two bedrooms

Similar wording

front and rear

Similar wording

there's an egress well

Similar wording

a large one in the front

Similar wording

as well as sliding doors that come out

Similar wording

the spiral stairs and up into the rear yard

Similar wording

there's also two baths in the basement

Similar wording

come back upstairs

Similar wording

have the living area, dining area

Similar wording

and then a bedroom in the rear, access to the rear yard.

Similar wording

And as I say, there's a spiral stairs.

Similar wording

If you come in the front door, you want to get to the second unit,

Similar wording

go up the same set of stairs, bedroom in the front, bathroom, kitchen area,

Similar wording

living in the back, and there's a small Juliet balcony in the back

Similar wording

for recycling and trash.

Similar wording

And then up to the third floor, repeat was basically in the lower level in the basement.

Similar wording

Two bedrooms, then access to a rooftop deck on the top of the building.

Similar wording

Basically similar to the house next door.

Similar wording

Side view, closer front view, elevations.

Similar wording

These were the plans we presented to the community May 28th, which were not well received because, again,

Similar wording

it was a i'll show you the presentation was for three three family and client

Similar wording

rethought his plans and we came back again for a recent meeting

Similar wording

the remaining documents from one that you typically see in a presentation like this

Similar wording

the PIP form, the proof that there's no taxes owed with regard to the property, 3941 Mount Vernon,

Similar wording

the zoning map indicating, again, one lot off the corner in an RSA 5 zoning district,

Similar wording

the deed indicating ownership of the property.

Similar wording

This is our notice letter that we sent out for both meetings, one earlier,

Similar wording

and then another on July

Similar wording

20th. Here's a second

Similar wording

Here's a second letter we sent out Monday, July 20th at 5.30 with the ZBA hearing today at 2 p.m.

Similar wording

letter we sent out Monday, July 20th

Similar wording

at 530.

Similar wording

Proof of mailing, 143 pieces went out.

Similar wording

Mount Vernon Street, Mellon Street, Haverford Avenue, Union Street.

Similar wording

And then these are the zoning records of the other properties on the block, including the one on the corner.

Similar wording

As I say, three units.

Similar wording

39.23 is two units.

Similar wording

39.32 to 36, it's 14 units.

Similar wording

39.04 to 10, two units.

Similar wording

And then on the corner of 39th Street,

Similar wording

there's two properties that have two units each.

Similar wording

And I have the backup for all this summation

Similar wording

to show the board.

Similar wording

39.43, approved 10.24, excuse me.

Similar wording

Maximum three units.

Similar wording

39-23

Similar wording

issue 2026

Similar wording

two family dwelling

Similar wording

39-32 to 36

Similar wording

this is from November of 2021

Similar wording

multi-family

Similar wording

14 dwelling units

Similar wording

39-04 to 0-10

Similar wording

this is where there's two

Similar wording

two family dwellings, two units, and then 620 around the corner, at the corner actually

Similar wording

of 39th street, two rental units.

Similar wording

So that is a presentation.

Similar wording

We have a vacant lot that the community was interested in multifamily, but not what they

Similar wording

considered a bit of an overreach at three.

Similar wording

we've scaled that back to two and it was well received at community meeting on monday night

Similar wording

i do have my client participating if he could unmute himself and maybe adopt

Similar wording

my testimony and then i can feel the questions i'll go back to the floor plans

Similar wording

leffler can you unmute yourself

Similar wording

then we're coming back in as a panel shortly at council thank you

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Han.

Similar wording

Lefter, are you there?

Similar wording

Yeah, I'm here.

Similar wording

Hi, my name is Lefter.

Similar wording

Hold on.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

My first name is Lefter, L-E-F-T-E-R, and last name is Vima, D-H-I-M-A.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Counsel?

Similar wording

Mr. Dima, you were on the call when I presented your project for 3941 Mount Vernon.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And were you also at the community meeting Monday night, which took place via Zoom?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And are all the characterizations that I just made concerning the project true and accurate?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And would you adopt them as your own?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Dima.

Similar wording

questions from the board yeah question what's the depth of this uh unit compared to the new

Similar wording

unit on the corner do they have the same size rear yard uh i'm going to go back to the site plan

Similar wording

it doesn't she's not showing that i don't want to i don't know or or is it i can't tell i don't

Similar wording

want to represent that that dash line is actually the end of the building because i don't know that

Similar wording

for a fact, although let me blow it up.

Similar wording

Leifler, do you know the answer to that question?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Our 70 is 56.6.

Similar wording

The building in the corner is more longer.

Similar wording

They have probably like, we have around 10 foot 0.6 backyard.

Similar wording

The building in the corner, probably they have around four foot back

Similar wording

or maybe between uh four or three foot backyard building in the corner we have a larger backyard

Similar wording

just need a slightly larger so that does the uh building on the corner also have roof decks and

Similar wording

other locations around have roof decks yes and also the building at 3923 has a roof deck also

Similar wording

leffler yeah and what's the depth of the the basement slab below grade

Similar wording

uh i think so i were like uh five foot below the sidewalk can you pull it this that elevation up

Similar wording

so you're

Similar wording

so you're you're 5 foot 2 below grade 2 foot 10 it would be good if you can raise that up some more

Similar wording