civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 22, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 22, 20266h 32m

little drawings. Let's see what's on the second and third floor. Hold on one moment. Here are the

Similar wording

pictures of the second and third floor in their existing condition. The first row are pictures of

Similar wording

the second floor. Is that right, Bruno? The first row is the third floor. First row is the third

Similar wording

floor. I'm sorry. And the second row is the second floor. So this will have to be basically a lot,

Similar wording

a gut job and exactly do it right no Eric there'll be a lot of work done up

Similar wording

there I'm I'm sorry mr. chair can you repeat that well there have to be a lot

Similar wording

of work done here so if I may introduce into a firm and adopt my testimonies

Similar wording

his own um bruno the owner is seated beside me all right uh good afternoon uh good afternoon sir

Similar wording

could you please state your name and spell before the stenographer yes my name is bruno vogrig uh

Similar wording

v like victor ogrig and i am the owner of the property you swear or affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

the whole truth nothing but the truth yes sir arick yes um so certainly um uh you know

Similar wording

So, certainly, you know, beyond this permit, renovation will be needed to be done to update the units to provide for residential household living.

Similar wording

Be honest.

Similar wording

Bruno, Mr. Boberg, is there anything you'd like to add about the renovation process that you foresee?

Similar wording

um we do anticipate to do some minor renovation but the extent of the work will not be very large

Similar wording

the previous owners were using both spaces uh the third floor uh for residents and the second floor

Similar wording

for commercial to be making art as an artist studio so it was uh updated in the 2014 with

Similar wording

new electric and plumbing and they had permits for that as well okay i got it okay thank you

Similar wording

questions from the Board. Questions from our attorney? No questions. Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, I do not see any hands raised. Planning Commission. Amy Boyd with the Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends no change in zoning to the current RMX

Similar wording

IRMX, Industrial Residential Mixed Use. The proposed two-family is in the spirit of the zoning code. The Planning Commission recommends that the board grant their impressive variance for two-family household living.

Similar wording

MI 2026-001-283-733-37 North 4th Street, I vote yes.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Layla Beebe, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel. Thank you all for your time this afternoon. Sure. Number 12, MI 2026, 001354, 1813 North Howard Street. Andrea Solomon is the attorney.

Similar wording

I guess she was sitting in the back. She went back there a long time. Hi, good afternoon.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

My name is Andrea Solomon, A-N-D-R-E-A-S-A-L-O-M-O-N.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Could you identify your client in relationship to this property?

Similar wording

Yes, my client is Howard N-D-L-L-C.

Similar wording

The owner of this property with me today on behalf of the ownership is Mr. David Hadari

Similar wording

and the project architect, Mr. Sergio Koscia.

Similar wording

our vice chair has a few questions good afternoon have you submitted your

Similar wording

documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing we have with

Similar wording

exception of the tax clearance certificate which was submitted on

Similar wording

Monday okay and thank you for that and do you waive the reading of the refusal

Similar wording

and stipulate to its accuracy I do all right thank you can show your screen and

Similar wording

proceed with your case. Thank you. There we go. Again, good afternoon. Andrea Solomon on behalf

Similar wording

of the owner, Howard ND LLC, respectfully request that these exhibits 1 through 10 be incorporated

Similar wording

and made part of the record okay 1813 north howard is a new construction mixed-use building housing

Similar wording

multi-family dwelling units industrial spaces and accessory parking the building was an investment

Similar wording

in this former industrial neighborhood to bring high quality modern residential units to meet the

Similar wording

changing needs of the neighborhood this block has seen a big redevelopment to add multi-family

Similar wording

dwelling units. The current application is for the change of use of three of the existing

Similar wording

industrial artist studios for uses three residential dwelling units for a total of

Similar wording

28 multifamily units in this existing structure. You have the letter of support from the coordinating

Similar wording

RCO, North Square Community Action Network. It was a well-attended meeting and we had a very

Similar wording

productive discussion about the changing needs of the community um the underlying zoning is irmx

Similar wording

which requires the 50 of the ground floor school area to be industrial uses that's the that's why

Similar wording

we have the artist studios um and these three tenant spaces were designed as artist studios

Similar wording

originally the location of this property is not conducive

Similar wording

The location of this property is not conducive to industrial or commercial spaces.

Similar wording

It's a very residential block.

Similar wording

This is the area with a lot of multifamily dwelling on the block and some single-family

Similar wording

residential further south on the block.

Similar wording

um hope street and howard street are two narrow streets again very residential in nature

Similar wording

this is the view of hope street uh from facing on the block facing north this was it facing south

Similar wording

and on howard street uh we have the same conditions but there's a transition to

Similar wording

single-family residential and across the street is also the uh toey playground which neither of

Similar wording

the streets have as much foot traffic or other commercial industrial uses as opposed to berk

Similar wording

street and front street just a couple blocks over that are more of a commercial corridor

Similar wording

and uh this is a montgomery avon howard which has also been redeveloped for multi-family residential

Similar wording

this is the entrance of the building on hope street and what the what the building looks

Similar wording

like from hope street with the various residential units the artist studios are located on the ground

Similar wording

in the first the second floor and this is what some of the residential units that have already

Similar wording

been existing and have started to be leased up uh are look like

Similar wording

the property owner has marketed these three units since the even before the ceo was received but

Similar wording

there's really been no bites for artist studios in the area but they have seen a big demand for

Similar wording

residential and these are the prior approved plans that show the three artist studios

Similar wording

there are five parking accessory spaces commercial trash pickup and a trash room

Similar wording

on the ground floor with pickup from howard street each unit has its own mailbox and at

Similar wording

the entrance vestibule and all all the units including the artist studio units share a com

Similar wording

the the now artist studios which we're proposing be converted to residential share a common

Similar wording

entrance um with that i'd ask that um mr larger than yes the artist studio the this the ground

Similar wording

floor studio is 400 square feet and the uh ones on the second floor are for a one bedroom which

Similar wording

is 558 square feet and a studio which is 472 square feet bring your person on um yes david

Similar wording

And Hedari, if you can raise your hand so that you can be promoted as panelists.

Similar wording

They will be back in as a panelist shortly.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Hello, good afternoon.

Similar wording

Hi, good afternoon.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name as spelled for the stenographer?

Similar wording

yes my name is david hidary h-i-d-a-r-y do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

and nothing but the truth i do counsel hi david uh can you just state for the record your

Similar wording

relationship to howard and dlc yes i'm the property manager for the building and you saw the entirety

Similar wording

of my presentation i did and is it true and accurate to the best of your knowledge

Similar wording

yes it is and do you adopt it as your own testimony i do and we also have mr kosha here

Similar wording

the project architect to answer any questions the board may have on the layout and of the

Similar wording

of the spaces all right questions from the board so these uh artist units are is a total of how

Similar wording

many three three units grace so you'll be converting them and there are two

Similar wording

efficiencies in one one bedroom that's that what I heard yes okay all the

Similar wording

questions and so the rest of the building is being leased with no problem

Similar wording

that's correct David I know you can speak to the numbers but they've seen

Similar wording

great success with the lease up okay and what you're basically saying is there's no real

Similar wording

demand for artists yeah it's not it's not an area that's really conducive to the industrial use

Similar wording

demand for artists yeah it's not it's not an area that's really conducive

Similar wording

in fact the whole area has really been redeveloped from this and from the former industrial nature

Similar wording

all right other questions and so the trash uh disposal for and storage for these three units

Similar wording

is that connected with the rest of the circulation of the building that's correct it'll be a

Similar wording

commercial trash pickup and it's it's service from howard street okay so they would have to

Similar wording

where would they bring their trash they would bring their trash into that um the other residential

Similar wording

system like like is there a trash room yeah each floor has a each floor has a trash chute um and

Similar wording

then on the ground floor there is a trash room which is um really only accessed by um our trash

Similar wording

company philly wide um except for recycling so people leave their recycling in the bins in the

Similar wording

trash room and then each floor has a shoot for um you know like for your garbage bags so these units

Similar wording

are on the ground floor though so they're not able to use the shoot or they're able to they're on the

Similar wording

set two of them are on the second floor and one is on the ground floor so the one on the ground

Similar wording

floor would just bring it down the hall to the trash room correct yeah gotcha thank you other

Similar wording

questions questions more attorney no questions questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

yes chair i have a hand up from a sergio cassia i've allowed them to speak

Similar wording

sure hi hi i'm just the architect i was um just making myself available to answer any questions

Similar wording

sure we appreciate that thank you anyone else yes i have a hand up oh the hand was up but

Similar wording

they put it down okay now to put it up it's um from a number ending in nine four seven zero

Similar wording

i have allowed them to speak okay yes good afternoon hi hi good afternoon could you please

Similar wording

state your name and spell for the stenographer yes milda pimentel n-i-l-d-a-p-i-m-e-n-p-e-l

Similar wording

and i'm the uh president of the coordinating art field sure do you swear or affirm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes i do please proceed yes uh before we

Similar wording

Also for comments on the application, I want to go on record by apologizing to the affected

Similar wording

RCO, the South Kensington Community Partners for our failure, I mean unintentionally I

Similar wording

would say, to copy them on the materials that we submitted to the SBA in mid-June.

Similar wording

This is the first time this happened, so again, we apologize for that and we also made that

Similar wording

known to them personally via email. Our board, our group also wants to add that prior to the

Similar wording

zoning committee meeting that we held on May 12th to consider this application, I personally contacted

Similar wording

at the coordinating RCO, and they were informed about our SONI meeting.

Similar wording

So, internal application, as we indicated in our explanation letter, our SONI committee

Similar wording

endorsed the application and including the attendees.

Similar wording

We didn't see any like major serious issues

Similar wording

about the application.

Similar wording

We don't believe that converting those three small units

Similar wording

in the context of over 200 units of residential housing

Similar wording

in the area, in particular the surrounding blocks

Similar wording

is going to alter fundamentally the context of the block.

Similar wording

We also want to let the board members know

Similar wording

that as it's our practice,

Similar wording

we organize a pre-soning conference

Similar wording

and we attended a pre-soning conference

Similar wording

with the Mr. David Hedery and the attorneys

Similar wording

and invited some nearby residents.

Similar wording

We usually do that.

Similar wording

And we also had an opportunity to tour the units

Similar wording

under consideration.

Similar wording

We also reached out to a council member

Similar wording

and as of this morning, we were told

Similar wording

as of this morning we were told that they were issuing an opposition letter

Similar wording

that they were issuing an opposition letter.

Similar wording

okay um council do you have any questions no thank you i i'll affirm you know um miss

Similar wording

nilda was able to tour the units and it was a well-attended community meeting and

Similar wording

we we did reach out to many community members to come tour the units and see see it for themselves

Similar wording

All right. Thank you. Thank you for taking the time to call us. We appreciate it. Thank you very much. Anyone else in the audience?

Similar wording

No further hands, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Amy Boyd with the Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends no change in zoning at this location to the current IRMX industrial residential mixed use.

Similar wording

The appellant has not demonstrated that there are unique physical conditions or circumstances of the property that would prevent it from being used in conformance with the zoning code.

Similar wording

the planning commission recommends the report to neither requested variants for ground floor use

Similar wording

just i'll note again that it's a difficult area to have the industrial uses and i'll know also

Similar wording

for the record that the refusal is not for the density the number of units would be allowed by

Similar wording

right it's just the removal of the industrial space that results in the refusal all right thank

Similar wording

you mi 2026 001 354 1813 north howard street i vote yes michael johns my vote is yes

Similar wording

cheryl guest my vote is yes tenetta graham my vote is yes leila beebe my vote is yes

Similar wording

thank you very much thank you have a great afternoon

Similar wording

you um number 15 mi 2026 002 612 921 north 29th street um tobe tobe jia anderson

Similar wording

don't be coming back in as a panel

Similar wording

hello good afternoon hi could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

the bodger henderson t-o-b-i-j-a-h anderson a-n-d-e-r-s-o-n okay and you have a letter

Similar wording

of support from francisville i understand is that correct i do i have a letter of support um

Similar wording

and i'm newer to this and when you did you say franceville it's francisville right that's the

Similar wording

location am i wrong it's 921 north 29th street fairmount yeah okay fairmount okay yes fairmount

Similar wording

center room which is next to francisville i'm sorry um our vice chair has a few questions for

Similar wording

you okay good afternoon um have you submitted your uh documents and exhibits uh five days in

Similar wording

advance of this hearing yes okay and so is your understanding that this application is for visitor

Similar wording

accommodations yeah okay and uh you understand that in this zoning district cmx1 that the visitor

Similar wording

accommodations is prohibited that's the reason for your refusal is that understandable yes okay all

Similar wording

right thank you you can uh share your screen show us what you're trying to do all right thank you

Similar wording

guys can you see my screen now we can all right um want to try to make this short and sweet um i do

Similar wording

have a refusal here is for a visitor accommodation it was uh approved previously and it expired on

Similar wording

4-13-26. So this was my appeal. And it uses the current layout. There's no, nothing that's going

Similar wording

to be changed on the property inside or outside. The use is low intensity, so it does not create

Similar wording

any conditions that um warn a public safety this is the

Similar wording

application information here i forget the term the um of this form but with the form that i was

Similar wording

supposed to fill out in addition to the appeal this is the lease agreement here this is the

Similar wording

tax clearance here this is just a layout of the two apartments over top of the

Similar wording

commercial daycare downstairs this is the second and third floor again

Similar wording

nothing's changed this was the ZBA meeting notice this was the petition

Similar wording

from the people physically on the block on that particular block there are other

Similar wording

On that particular block, there are other commercial facilities. There's a Chinese store across the street. And then on the corner of 29th and Gerard, there's four different commercial properties there.

Similar wording

their commercial facility is a Chinese store across the street.

Similar wording

This is the, these are the letters that went out to all of the neighbors and this is the letter from the zoning meeting.

Similar wording

so we have we have the letters sir we have we have we have everything

Similar wording

and that's really all i have to provide okay and you've had no problems with before right

Similar wording

how long have you been doing this no problems i've actually been doing this prior to um the

Similar wording

city of philadelphia asking for the zoning permit so i was doing it since 2017 and then when the

Similar wording

tony permit was requested um we started that process our vice chair our board has a few

Similar wording

questions anyone the question oh okay all right questions from our attorney

Similar wording

yes um i just want to make sure is the uh use that you're asking for limited to

Similar wording