NominationApproved
Property profile
1001-13 CHESTNUT ST
OPA 88811056826 linked recordsCouncil district 1
Actor profiles are grouped by kind and normalized name. Two people with the same name may appear together in this first version.
Zoned CMX-5Commercial/Commercial Mixed-Use
- Owner
- KULKARNI RADHIKA
- ZIP code
- 19107
- Year built
- 1900
- Market value
- $248,000
Historic
Designation status and decisions from the historic property record.
- Historic address
- VICTORY BUILDING 1021 CHESTNUT STREET, 1011-13 CHESTNUT STREET, 1001-13 CHESTNUT STREET VICTORY BUILDING, 1001 CHESTNUT STREET VICTORY BUILDING, VICTORY BUILDING 10TH AND CHESTNUT STREETS, 1001-13 CHESTNUT STREET, 1011-13 CHESTNUT STREET (VICTORY BUILDING ANNEX), 1001-1013 CHESTNUT STREET, 1007-13 CHESTNUT STREET, VICTORY BUILDING 1001 CHESTNUT STREET, 1001-1013 CHESTNUT STREET (VICTORY BUILDING), VICTORY BUILDING, VICTORY BUILDING 1001-1013 CHESTNUT STREET, 1007-13 CHESTNUT STREET VICTORY BUILDING ANNEX
- Year built
- 1900
- Building description
- RES CONDO 5+ STY MASONRY
- Owner
- KULKARNI RADHIKA
- NominationNo decision
- InformationalNo decision
- Criteria cited
- Historical
- Alteration reviewDeferred
- Criteria cited
- Detailed elevationExisting condition documentation
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- B. Bluesteinneutral, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Eliott Rothschildneutral, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Criteria cited
- Original characterOriginal cornice rhythm
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Criteria cited
- Second Empire design
- Demolition reviewDeferred
- Criteria cited
- Financial hardshipDemolition by neglectPublic safetyStructural integrityFederal income tax credit feasibility
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Gray Smithoppose, person
- Morris Hersmansupport, person
- Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
- Robert Solvibileneutral, person
- Samuel Rappaportsupport, person
- Demolition reviewDeferred
- Criteria cited
- Demolition by neglectPublic safetyFinancial hardshipRehabilitation feasibility
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Donald Kligermanneutral, person
- Harold H. Hairstonneutral, person
- Morris P. Hershmansupport, person
- Philadelphia Historic Preservation Corporationoppose, organization
- Richard Tyleroppose, person
- Samuel Rappaportsupport, person
- Demolition reviewNo decision
- Vote tally
- no vote taken
- Criteria cited
- Court of Common Pleas hearing pending
- Demolition reviewDeferred
- Vote tally
- Approved unanimously; Hollenberg abstained
- Criteria cited
- Financial hardshipNo economically viable reuse demonstratedSignificant landmark status warrants comprehensive independent reviewPublic safety concerns — loose roof elements, fires, vandalismDemolition by neglectBuilding designated as landmark in October 1972
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Barbara Kaplanyes
- David Brownleeyes
- David Hollenbergabstain
- Jason Nathanyes
- Scott Wildsyes
Testimony
- Howard Kittelloppose, person
- Morris Hershmansupport, person
- Nathaniel Carrneutral, person
- Paul Uyeharaneutral, person
- Philadelphia Historic Preservation Corporationoppose, organization
- Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
- Richard Tyleroppose, person
- Samuel Rappaportsupport, person
- Alteration reviewDeferred
- Criteria cited
- Financial hardship claim requires independent consultant assessmentBuilding tour scheduled to evaluate condition
Votes and testimony
Votes
- David Hollenbergabstain
- NominationNo decision
- Demolition reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Unanimous
- Criteria cited
- Financial hardshipEconomic viability of rehabilitationCurrent and foreseeable market conditionsSelf-imposed hardship considerationCompleteness and accuracy of applicant's submissionIndependence and adequacy of appraiser's report
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Barbara Kaplanyes
- Edward A. Montgomery, Jr.yes
- Jason Nathanyes
Testimony
- Gray Smithoppose, person
- Howard Kittelloppose, person
- Morris Hershansupport, person
- Philadelphia Historic Preservation Corporationneutral, organization
- Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
- Samuel Rappaportsupport, person
- William Bladesneutral, person
- Demolition reviewDeferred
- Vote tally
- Unanimous
- Criteria cited
- Financial hardshipSection 14-2007 of the Philadelphia CodePhiladelphia preservation ordinance
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Barbara Kaplanyes
- David Brownleeyes
- David Hollenbergabstain
- David Wismeryes
- Edward A. Montgomery, Jr.yes
- James Cuoratoyes
- Jason Nathanyes
- Louis Einhornyes
- Reverend William D. Thompsonyes
- Scott Wildsyes
- Stephanie Wolfyes
- William Brownyes
Testimony
- Donna Harrisoppose, person
- Foundation for Architectureoppose, organization
- Gray Smithoppose, person
- Howard Kittelloppose, person
- John Higginsoppose, person
- Morris Hershmansupport, person
- Philadelphia Historic Preservation Corporationoppose, organization
- Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
- William Bladesoppose, person
- Demolition reviewDenied
- Vote tally
- unanimous, with Hollenberg abstaining
- Criteria cited
- Financial hardship three-part test: reasonable reuse not precludedFinancial hardship three-part test: reasonable rate of return not demonstrated as unachievableFinancial hardship three-part test: sale of property not shown to be impracticableHistorical significance of Second Empire architectureNational Register listing 1980Center City East Commercial Historic District listing 1984Philadelphia Historical Commission designation 1972Public safety concernsOwner's record of neglect/demolition by neglectNew expressions of interest from Thomas Jefferson University and Kevin DonahoePurpose of preservation ordinance
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Barbara Kaplanyes
- David Brownleeyes
- David Hollenbergabstain
- David Wismerno
- Edward A. Montgomery, Jr.yes
- James Cuoratoyes
- Jason Nathanyes
- Louis Einhornyes
- Reverend William D. Thompsonyes
- Scott Wildsyes
- Stephanie G. Wolfyes
Testimony
- Barbara Kaplanoppose, person
- Captain Nathaniel Carrneutral, person
- Don McNeilneutral, person
- Donna Harrisoppose, person
- Foundation for Architectureoppose, organization
- Gray Smithoppose, person
- Howard Kittelloppose, person
- Kevin F. Donohoeoppose, person
- Morris Hershmansupport, person
- Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
- Richard Tyleroppose, person
- Samuel Rappaportsupport, person
- Sandra Garzoppose, person
- William Bladesoppose, person
- Demolition reviewNo decision
- Criteria cited
- Commission's prior denial of demolition permit
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Richard Tylerneutral, person
- Demolition reviewNo decision
- Demolition reviewNo decision
- Criteria cited
- Reuse practicalityEconomic feasibility
- InformationalNo decision
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Wayne S. Spilovesupport, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Architectural Committee voted to recommend approval
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Jonathan Brohsupport, person
- Randal Baronneutral, person
- NominationApproved
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Jonathan Brohsupport, person
- NominationApproved
- NominationApproved
Linked public records
Records are sorted by date and cite the basis for each property link.
- DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia L&I Business LicensesView on Atlas
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondenied
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved