Stated Meeting, April 19, 2018

Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA STATED MEETING Room 400, City Hall Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Thursday, April 19, 2018 10:55 a.m. PRESENT: COUNCIL PRESIDENT DARRELL L. CLARKE COUNCILWOMAN CINDY BASS COUNCILWOMAN JANNIE L. BLACKWELL COUNCILMAN ALLAN DOMB COUNCILMAN DEREK S. GREEN COUNCILMAN WILLIAM K. GREENLEE COUNCILWOMAN HELEN GYM COUNCILMAN BOBBY HENON COUNCILMAN KENYATTA JOHNSON COUNCILMAN DAVID OH COUNCILMAN BRIAN J. O'NEILL COUNCILWOMAN CHERELLE L. PARKER COUNCILWOMAN MARIA D. QUINONES-SANCHEZ COUNCILWOMAN BLONDELL REYNOLDS BROWN COUNCILMAN MARK SQUILLA COUNCILMAN AL TAUBENBERGER MICHAEL A. DECKER, CHIEF CLERK Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Good morning. (Good morning.)

We're going to get started. If the visitors will retire behind the rail, we can move on to our invocation. And to give our invocation this morning, the Chair recognizes Pastor Myra Maxwell of the Trinity United Church. She is here today as the guest of Councilman Johnson. I would ask all members, guests, and visitors to please rise. (Councilmembers, guests, and visitors rise.)

Good morning. (Good morning.)

Truly it is an honor today for me to bring this invocation, and I want to especially thank God first and Councilman Johnson, who has been an inspiration and encouragement throughout the City. So we Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 look to the Lord. Almighty, loving, and wise God, as we come before you on this day, we come with a spirit of thanksgiving, thanking you for giving us another opportunity, Lord, for what we may have not done correctly on yesterday that we'll be able to get it right on today. Almighty God, as we come, we humble ourselves before your throne, thanking and praising you, Lord God, for the 17 members of Council that you have handpicked to serve in this city, to touch the lives of the people, to be a voice for those who feel voiceless. Almighty God, we pray that you will just continue to bless each community. Walk through, Lord God, every neighborhood. Touch and heal and deliver, Lord God, as we face issues of substance abuse and violence in our communities. Oh, God, we pray, Lord God, Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 our Councilmembers, Lord God, first with the spirit of love, that they will love the people that they serve and the communities where they serve. Almighty God, we ask that you would empower them with a spirit of wisdom that they may do all that you have tasked for them to do. Almighty God, we pray that you will empower them with a spirit of faith, Lord God, that they will continue to know that you are leading, that you are guiding them, that they may do all that you have for them to do. Almighty God, we pray that you will touch those who will present on today, for, Lord God, there are many that work in our communities and serve, Lord God. We pray that you will touch, Lord God, the grassroots organizations, Lord God, and the larger organizations as well, that we'll work together to do what's necessary to keep this city great. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 God, we give you praise, Lord God, and thanks, Lord God, for just being with us today. So guide and touch all that will be said and done in this Council session today. And, Lord God, we would be remiss if we didn't ask a special prayer over that young man and his child that were shot in the streets of Philadelphia. So, Lord God, bless them, Lord God, that they will be restored to good health. And, Lord God, we thank you for your power, your presence, and your guidance. We ask these things in the name of your son, and our spirit says amen. (Amen.)

Thank you so much, Pastor, for those very inspiring words. Council will be at ease. (Council at ease.)

Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 moment, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Thank you, thank you, thank you, Mr. President. In keeping with our protocol to welcome special guests, it is a thrill for me this morning to present to some and introduce to others several women who have led the way by being sisters in solar, and I want to ask Councilwoman Parker to pay particular attention because she is a sorer of ours. It's a thrill for me to welcome Rose McKinney-James, Esquire, Chair of the Board of Directors for the American Association of Blacks in Energy. She and the entire Board are here, and we want to welcome them to the City of Brotherly Love and Sisterly Effectiveness. (Applause.)

She is joined today to be our keynote speaker for our Sisters in Solar first annual luncheon, which talks about STEM and Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 of color to go into these non-traditional fields. We will also be welcoming George Washington Carver High School students from the School of Engineering and Science, the Science Leadership Academy, and the OIC Smart Energy Solar class. Thank you, Nancy Mifflin, Rose McKinney-James. Please stand up so we can welcome you. (Applause.)

Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Councilwoman. And thank you for being here today. We really appreciate it. Our next order of business is the approval of the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, April 12th, 2018, and the Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee.

Thank Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 you, Mr. President. I move that the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, April 12th, 2018 be approved. (Duly seconded.)

Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, April 12th, 2018 stand approved. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it, and that Journal is approved. The next order of business is requests for leave of absence, and the Chair recognizes Councilman Henon.

Thank you, Mr. President. On behalf of the majority, a leave of absence is requested for Councilmember Jones. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Thank you, Councilman. The record shall reflect leave shall be granted. And the Chair now recognizes Councilman O'Neill.

Thank you, Mr. President. On behalf of the republicans, there are no requests for leave of absence.

The Chair thanks the gentleman. At this time, I would like to dispense with the regular order of business and I would like to thank everyone who has taken time out of their busy day to come down to witness their government in action. We hope your stay here today is a knowledgeable one but, more importantly, a pleasurable one, so much so that you come back again. So, again, thank you so much for being here. At this time, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell, who will present a resolution recognizing and Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 the occasion of her retirement. Would Ms. Brown-Sow and those accompanying her please join the Councilwoman at the podium.

And all the members of Council.

Everybody? All right. And joining the Councilwoman -- everybody?

Everybody.

We have all members of Council. (Councilmembers and guests approached podium.)

Mr. President, this is really a pleasure for us. So many people have known Lynette over the years in so many ways, through so many activities, that everybody is up here to share in certainly our best wishes for her, our thank you's, and our congratulations to her for all that she's Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 done, and especially for her service to Community College of Philadelphia. So we are happy to present this resolution, again, signed by everybody. Resolution recognizing and honoring Lynette Brown-Sow on the occasion of her retirement for her committed service to Community College of Philadelphia and for her many accomplishments that have benefited the City of Philadelphia.

Whereas, Lynette Brown-Sow graduated from West Philadelphia High School in 1968. She received a degree of Bachelor of Science in Administration from Antioch University in 1979 and a Master's of -- M.S.S. in Policy, which is Master's in Social Sciences in Policy, Planning and Development from Bryn Mawr College in 1981; and

We are excited about her next act. Whereas, in 1980, she founded Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Group, a certified minority/female-owned consulting firm that provides professional services to corporations, non-profits, and governmental entities; and

Whereas, Lynette Brown-Sow is also a member of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Philadelphia Alumnae Chapter, Incorporated. And whereas, her expertise in organizational development, board governance, marketing and crisis communications has made her a highly-sought after board member. She currently serves on the board of numerous organizations including, but not limited to, the Philadelphia Tribune Company, Incorporated; Hahnemann University Hospital; NHS Enterprises, Inc.; and The Board of City Trusts of where she serves Girard College via her committee assignment. She's a member also of the Forum of Executive Women and a convener of the Forum for a Better Pennsylvania; Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Whereas, she served as the Chair of the Board of Directors of The Consortium, a behavioral healthcare organization that pioneered the strategy of balancing the input of community leaders and medical experts. In 2007, The Consortium named its newest service center the Lynette M. Brown Center of Hope; and

Whereas, Brown-Sow has served Community College of Philadelphia as a consultant, program director and as Vice President of Marketing and Government Relations for more than 25 years.

As a member of the President's Cabinet at the College, she oversaw advertising, public relations, creative services, publications, special events, and government and community relations for the College; and

Whereas, she Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 nationally and locally, working with the American Association of Community Colleges and the White House to support free-tuition programs at community colleges and to sustain funding for Pell Grants; and

Whereas, Lynette Brown-Sow has also lent her knowledge to those in government. She helped with the transition teams for both Mayor Edward Rendell and Michael Nutter. She was later appointed as Deputy Mayor of Administration for the Rendell Administration; and

She also chaired the Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment during a citywide change. In 2012, she was nominated by Mayor Nutter and was approved by City Council to become the Commissioner and Board Chair of the Philadelphia Housing Authority; and

Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Whereas, Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf appointed Brown-Sow to the Pennsylvania Workforce Investment Board, which works with state educational policies to build a strong workforce development system. She has served as a member since 2015; and

Whereas, Brown-Sow has received numerous honors, awards and recognitions, including the Sammy Award for Outstanding Community Service by the Laborers International Union of North America; the Communications of the Year by the National Council for Marketing and Public Relations; and the Energy for the Community Award from PECO. She was recognized by her peers as one of the 100 Distinguished Alumni at Bryn Mawr College and named, for five consecutive years, as one of the City's most influential Philadelphians by the Philadelphia Tribune; and

Whereas, Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 life-long Philadelphian, and has worked in both the public and private sectors throughout her long and fruitful career. She has dedicated her talents to the service of others and we thank her for the time and energy she has devoted to help our city;

I also want to take a moment to acknowledge my big sister, Lynette Brown-Sow, who when I first got involved in this process of politics, she taught me the art of ward political organizing across the City of Philadelphia. And so now, therefore, be it resolved, that the Council of the City of Philadelphia, hereby recognizes and honors Lynette Brown-Sow on the occasion of her retirement for her commitment to service to Community College of Philadelphia and for her many accomplishments that have benefited the City of Philadelphia.

Further Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 resolved, that an engrossed copy of this resolution be presented to Ms. Brown-Sow as a sincere expression of the Council of the City of Philadelphia's gratitude, admiration and recognition. Congratulations, and all the best. (Applause.)

Good morning. My name is Juvencio Gonzalez and I'm a Special Assistant for the Lieutenant Governor Mike Stack. I have a citation on behalf of the Lieutenant Governor. And today I said to Lynette, Lynnette, I'm going to miss you. She said, I'm not going anywhere. You can continue calling me. So I feel really relieved. From the Lieutenant Governor, in recognition of Lynette Brown-Sow. As Lieutenant Governor of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, I am honored to join with your family, friends, and colleagues to congratulate you on your retirement Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Philadelphia and to celebrate your 22 years of service to the College and many more years to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. During the 22 years that you dedicated to making higher education more accessible, you have been an example of how others should conduct their lives and careers. I thank you for your consistency in meeting many challenges over the years and for your dedication to getting the job done. I hope you can look back on your career with pride and fulfillment, knowing that you made a difference in the lives of many of your colleagues and countless citizens. Your valuable contributions will be greatly missed, but the impact of your work will be felt for years to come. On this occasion, I share with you the words of Winston Churchill, who said, We make a living by what we get. We make a life by what we give. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Pennsylvanians, I would like to commend you and your wonderful career at Community College. Congratulations and best wishes for much health, happiness as you enjoy time with family and friends during your retirement. Mike Stack, Lieutenant Governor, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Thank you. Congratulations. (Applause.)

At this time, the Chair recognizes Lynette Brown-Sow.

Thank you, President Clarke, and thank you, Councilwoman Blackwell, for this resolution. I am honored, I am grateful, and I am thankful. Most of you City Councilpeople I've worked with way before you became City Councilmembers. We worked in the community in making our communities a better place and empowering other people Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 As I said the evening of my retirement, I am very clear that everything that I've done, I haven't done it alone. So thank you to the members of the College family, to those of you who are here from the various boards -- and I know there's a joke, how many boards is she on -- and my friends and my fellow government relations folks who we dawn these walls and in this room on Thursdays together. And I can't forget to thank all the staff people for the Councilpeople, because we know you're the ones that help us get our work done. All of you have touched my life in some way, and you have enriched my life. This resolution is an affirmation that all of the long days, nights, weekends have been worth it, and it affirms that I've been able to demonstrate my passion to make a better place for my people, my community, and our city. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 that I stand on the shoulders of many great women and men, and I understand that I have a responsibility to do what others have done for me, to strengthen the next generation and to pass the baton. And because I have had someone who has done that for me, lots of people, but there's always one that I always have to mention, and that's the Honorable Hardy Williams, a man who gave me as a little girl the ability to think differently, to look at things from a different lens, and to care about people in my community in a way that is sustainable. These lessons helped me understand the common bond between all of us, and I will forever not forget what Hardy Williams has instilled in me. I thank all of you for your support, and I hope that you will continue to support me as I transition back into L.M. Brown Management Group -marketing plea -- and thank you for this Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 what I was here put on this earth to do. And I want to just say that as he said, I'm not going anywhere. I'm going to continue to fight. I'm going to keep on working with all of you to make our community better. I want my legacy to be a list, a list of all the people that I've helped, all the organizations I've helped live their mission, all the legislation and policies that have opened access for people who look like me and there for other people. So I appreciate all of you and I appreciate you appreciating me. Thank you. (Applause.)

Thank you. Council will be at ease. (Council at ease.)

Thank you, and congratulations. At this time, the Chair Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Oh, who will present a resolution recognizing and honoring the 2017 winners of Philly LIVE Center Stage. Would Ms. Dyana Williams and those accompanying her please join the Councilman at the podium. (Councilmembers and guests approached podium.)

Thank you very much, Council President. I would ask the winners of the 2017 PHL LIVE Center Stage to stand in front of the podium. That would be Dell-P, Image, Black Horse Motel, Jonifin Marvin and the Philly Reggae Band, Jason Ager, David Lyve, DJ SoulChild, Aktiveight. All right. Would you step in front of us. And I'd like to just recognize the people who are coming to stand on stage behind me. If you're in music, you know who they are. If you don't, these are really the leaders and heavyweights of the music industry in our Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 sponsors who have allowed this activity, PHL LIVE, to move forward. They are Harold Honickman, Dyana Williams, Dr. Louis Anthony deLise, Ron DiSilvio, Brent Porche, International DJ Casper, David Ivory, Marilyn Rodriguez, Frank Knuckles, Cyndy Drue, E. Daniels, Joseph Conyers, Lovett Hines, Justin Nordell, Simply Monica, Jimmy DaSaint, Stephanie Seiple, Craig White, Bernie Resnick, Randall Jefferson, Rashaan Lucas, Jeff Duperon, and Justin Manetti. All right. So when we begin, let me just say that PHL LIVE Center Stage is an effort to recognize those who are gifted with musical talent and ability and to support them by recognizing them and providing them with a platform. I don't have any money. It is donated to me through corporations like Comcast, national brands, and Coors Light, our primary sponsor, and the Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 venues and these outstanding judges, Grammy Award winners, Grammy-nominated writers, engineers, producers, radio personalities, who donate all their time in this arduous process. And so the winners -- and I'll ask them again, would you stand in front of us so we can all see who you are. That would be -- they're behind me, but step up in front. Yes. Lindsey Tucker-Tso, Dell-P, Image, Black Horse Motel, Jonifin Marvin and the Philly Reggae Band, Jason Ager, David Lyve, DJ SoulChild, Aktiveight. Thank you very much. Let's give them all a hearty round of applause. (Applause.)

Kudos to Councilman Oh for celebrating Philly's own rich, rich cultural and arts talent. Whereas, Philly LIVE Center Stage is a music initiative established by Councilman David Oh as Chairman of the Committee on Global Opportunities and the Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Economy; and Whereas, Philly LIVE Center Stage provides local musicians with exciting opportunities to be discovered and promoted to further achieve success right here in Philadelphia; and Whereas, Philly LIVE Center Stage's performances and Award Show are structured across 10 different genres of music, bringing diverse musicians together. The 10 different genres are Rock, Hip-Hop, Jazz, Classical, Gospel, Country/Folk, World, Pop, R&B, and DJ. In addition, a "People's Choice" Award is selected as an 11th category; and Whereas, this year's finalists performed live in prominent local venues, including World Cafe Live, Milkboy, Hard Rock Cafe, Reformation Lutheran Church, the Clef Club of Jazz, Milkboy South Street, Settlement Music School, Kung Fu Necktie, Voltage Lounge, and William Street Common; and

Whereas, Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 each genre, announced in December at the Trocadero Theatre during the 4th Annual PHL LIVE Center Stage Award Show, were decided by judges who are considered experts in the industry; and Whereas, the "People's Choice" Award is voted on by the audience before and during the Award Show at the Trocadero Theatre; and Whereas, the winning artists from each genre receive top prizes such as $1,000 in cash, studio recording time, music videos, documentaries, and openings at major concerts; and Whereas, the 2017 winner of the Rock category is Siravo; and Whereas, the 2017 winner of the Hip-Hop category is Dell-P; and Whereas, the 2017 winner of the Jazz category is The Jost Project; and

Whereas, the 2017 winner of the Gospel category is Image; Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Whereas, the 2017 winner of the Country/Folk category is Black Horse Motel; The 2017 winner of the World category is Jonifin Marvin and the Philly Reggae Band; and Whereas, the 2017 winner of the Pop category is Jason Ager; and Whereas, the 2017 winner of the Classical category is Bethany Brooks and Samuel Nebyu;

Whereas, the 2017 winner of the R&B category is David Lyve; Whereas, the 2017 winner of the DJ category is DJ SoulChild; and Whereas, the 2017 winner of the "People's Choice" category is Aktiveight; now, therefore, be it Resolved, by the Council of the City of Philadelphia, that it hereby recognizes and honors the 2017 Winners of PHL LIVE Center Stage. (Applause.) Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

And the Chair recognize Ms. Williams for remarks.

Good morning. Good morning, all. I'm Dyana Williams from 100.3 WRNB Radio One Philadelphia. I'm also the proud Chair of the 20th anniversary of the Marian Anderson Award and I am the former President of the Philadelphia Grammy Chapter and, most importantly, a proud supporter of PHL LIVE. I have worked with Councilman Oh from pretty much day one. So it is an honor to stand before you on behalf of the music industry community in our city, and before you stand, and behind me, talented citizens of one of the greatest cities on planet earth, the City of Brotherly Love and Sisterly Affection. (Applause.)

I thank President Clarke, our Councilpeople for their support of this endeavor. You are affording an opportunity to emerging Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 seen, heard, celebrated, and in some cases rewarded with a cash reward, studio time, and other prizes that will enable them to continue growing their careers into professional careers and preferably full-time musicians in the music industry. FYI, the music industry remains a multi-billion-dollar industry, and our city, considering our status back to early colonial days, we are a music mecca in every single genre of music that you can imagine. Philadelphia excels. We remain that place for commerce, arts, culture in our city. Most of the touring bands that you see from Jay Z to Justin Timberlake, the musicians are from our area. So we are funneling on an international level ambassadors of our great city. So on behalf of the music community in the City of Brotherly Love and Sisterly Affection, we thank you, Councilman Oh. We thank City Council, Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Blondell, who I've had a chance to work with over the years. And I want to take a personal moment to say congratulations to Lynette Brown-Sow, a dedicated daughter of the City of Philadelphia. Thank you all for your support. Continue to encourage music from our great music mecca. (Applause.)

Council will be at ease. (Council at ease.)

Thank you, and congratulations. Our next order of business is communications, and the Chair requests that the Sergeant-of-Arms delivers the messages from the Mayor to the Chief Clerk. Mr. Decker, please read those messages.

To the President and members of the Council of the City of Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Philadelphia, I am pleased to advise you that on April 18, 2018, I signed all of the bills which were passed by Council at its session on April 5, 2018. And I am transmitting herewith for the consideration of your honorable body an ordinance amending Section 2 of an Ordinance (Bill No. 160145) approved April 19, 2016, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 44 by placing on the City Plan 37th Street from Market Street to Filbert Street and from Filbert Street to Warren Street, Cuthbert Street from 37th Street to 38th Street north of Filbert Street, and Warren Street from 37th Street to 38th Street, all under certain terms and conditions," by extending the period for compliance with the terms and conditions stated therein; and An ordinance approving the Fifteenth Amendment of the redevelopment proposal for the Cecil B. Moore Avenue Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Area, being the area generally bounded by 15th Street on the east, Jefferson Street on the south, 19th Street on the west, and Montgomery Avenue on the north, including the Fifteenth Amendment to the urban renewal plan; and An ordinance approving the Forty-Second Amendment of the redevelopment proposal for the Model Cities Urban Renewal Area, being the area beginning on the northwest corner of Front Street and Spring Garden Street, including the Thirty-Fourth Amendment to the urban renewal plan, all under certain terms and conditions.

Thank you, Mr. Decker. Do you have any additional communications?

I have none, Mr. President.

Thank you very much. These messages will be printed in today's Journal. And our next order of business Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 is the introduction of bills and resolutions, and the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Good morning, Mr. President. I'd like to highlight one resolution introduced by -lead introducers are -- forgive me; lead sponsors are Councilman Kenyatta Johnson and Councilwoman Cherelle Parker, who chairs the Labor and Industry, and is co-sponsored by Councilmembers Gym and Councilman Derek Green. And ultimately I'm introducing three resolutions this morning. Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Councilwoman.

A privileged resolution recognizing April 22, 2018 as Earth Day in the City of Philadelphia.

Today's Calendar.

And a privileged resolution authorizing the Committee on Labor and Civil Service to hold hearings Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 on the effectiveness of implicit bias and racial equity trainings for employees of the City of Philadelphia.

Today's Calendar.

And a privileged resolution recognizing April 26, 2018 as 50/50 Day in the City of Philadelphia.

Also on today's Calendar. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell.

Thank you, Mr. President. Today I have no bills or resolutions.

Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee.

Thank you, Mr. President. Today I offer one bill on your behalf.

Thank you, Councilman. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

An ordinance amending Chapter 16-400 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Vacant Surplus Properties," to allow property dispositions by the Philadelphia Land Bank.

Referred to committee. The Chair recognizes Councilman Henon.

Thank you, Mr. President. I have no bills or resolutions today.

Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson. (No response.)

He's not here. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

Thank you, Council President. I have a Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 resolution co-sponsored by Councilman Jones, Green, Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown, Bass, and Blackwell and Councilman Green. Thank you.

Thank you, Councilwoman.

A privileged resolution authorizing the Committee on Appropriations and the Committee on Transportation and Public Utilities to conduct hearings to develop more inclusive, transparent, and efficient processes and methods for the City of Philadelphia's procurement of professional services, capital programs, and commodities.

Today's Calendar. And the Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Council President, no bills or resolutions for today.

Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Thank you, Councilman.

Thank you.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Green.

Thank you, Council President. I have one non-privileged resolution.

Thank you, Councilman.

A non-privileged resolution calling upon the Congress of the United States to pass S. 1689, legislation offered by Senator Cory Booker, to federally decriminalize and otherwise improve public policy with relation to marijuana.

And that will be on next week's Calendar. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.

Thank you, Mr. President. I have one non-privileged resolution and it's co-sponsored by Councilmembers Blondell Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Reynolds Brown, Derek Green, Cindy Bass, and I wish to be heard after the title is read.

Thank you, Councilwoman.

A non-privileged resolution commending the Pennsylvania House of Representatives on the passage of a legislative package aimed at helping grandparents raising grandchildren and encouraging the Senate to pass this legislation into law.

The Chair again recognizes Councilwoman Parker.

Thank you, Mr. President. I just wanted to take this opportunity to lift up two of my former colleagues and, that is, State Representative Eddie Day Pashinski, who is a democrat in Luzerne County, and Representative Kathy Watson, who is a republican from Bucks County. On April the 17th, the Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Pennsylvania House passed and it moved to the Senate a package, a bipartisan package, of bills aimed at supporting grandparents raising grandchildren. It's a legislative package of bills. And for the record, Mr. President, the reason why this issue in particular is of importance to me is, I'm happy that they say it this way, grandparents raising grandchildren, because I was raised by my grandparents. But now the term that is often used, it is referred to as kinship care. And while I don't have any data in front of me showing that there is a statistically significant difference that we can prove that there's a correlation or causation with opioid abuse, lack of unemployment or mental health and the increase in the number of children who are being raised by someone other than their biological parents and their families, for those of us who have a direct connection to the people we represent, we know that we are Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 seeing this phenomena on the rise. So I just want to commend these two legislators in particular and colleagues in the House for moving this package over to the Senate. Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Councilwoman. That will be on next week's Calendar. The Chair recognizes Councilman Domb.

Good morning, Mr. President. No bills or resolutions today.

Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gym.

Good morning, Council President. I have one bill today co-sponsored by Councilmembers Jones and Johnson.

Thank you, Councilwoman. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

An ordinance amending Chapter 9-3500 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Fair Criminal Record Screening Standards," by adding a section providing for prohibition on consideration of or inquiry about an applicant's juvenile records at any stage of the employment or licensing process, and adding definitions.

Referred to committee. The Chair recognizes Councilman Taubenberger.

Thank you, Council President. I have no bills or resolutions this morning.

Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilman O'Neill.

Thank you, Mr. President. I have no bills or resolutions. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.

Thank you, Mr. President. I offer one bill.

Thank you, Councilman.

An ordinance amending Section 9 of an Ordinance (Bill No. 150377) approved June 18, 2015, as amended by Bill No. 160566, approved June 16, 2016 and Bill No. 170566, approved July 11, 2017, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the construction, ownership, and maintenance of various encroachments into the right-of-way of Market Street, Filbert Street, 11th Street, 10th Street, 9th Street and 8th Street, and authorizing the assignment of certain rights with respect to an overhead pedestrian bridge above Filbert Street west of the house line of Ninth Street to be assigned, all under certain terms and Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 conditions, by further authorizing the Streets Department to approve encroachments consistent with plans approved by the Philadelphia City Planning Commission and the City of Philadelphia Art Commission," by extending the time for compliance with the authorization conditions therein.

That will be referred to the appropriate committee. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.

Thank you, Mr. President. I offer no bills or resolutions.

Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Oh.

Thank you, Mr. President. I offer three privileged resolutions co-sponsored by Councilmembers Blackwell, Bass, Domb, Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Green, Henon, Parker, and Gym. Thank you.

Thank you, Councilman.

A privileged resolution Proclaiming the Week of April 27, 2018 to May 5, 2018 as the Eighth Annual Philly Tech Week Presented by Comcast, and Honoring the Broad and Vibrant Philadelphia Technology Community.

This week's Calendar.

And a privileged resolution recognizing May 2018 as Asian American and Pacific Islanders Heritage Month in Philadelphia to celebrate and commemorate the proud heritage of Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders and their important contributions to enhancing the City's culture, economy, and the founding ideals of independence and democracy.

And this week's Calendar. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

And a privileged resolution commemorating the 60th Anniversary of the death of In-Ho Oh and the response by his parents offering forgiveness to the teenage murderers, requesting that the juveniles receive the "most generous treatment possible" allowed by law and establishing a fund to be used for their religious, educational, vocational and social guidance.

And that will also be on this week's Calendar. That concludes our introduction of bills and resolutions, and we will now hear our reports from committee. And the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez for a report from the Committee on Appropriations.

Thank you, Mr. President. The Committee on Appropriations reports one bill with a favorable recommendation. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Thank you. Mr. Decker, please read the report.

To the President and members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia, the Committee on Appropriations, to which was referred Bill No. 180264, entitled "An ordinance authorizing transfers in appropriations for Fiscal Year 2018 from the General Fund, certain or all City offices, departments, boards and commissions, the Grants Revenue Fund, certain or all City offices, departments, boards and commissions to the General Fund, certain or all City offices, departments, boards and commissions," respectfully reports it has considered and amended the same and returns the attached bill to Council with a favorable recommendation.

Thank you, Mr. Decker. And the Chair again recognizes Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill No. 180264. (Duly seconded.)

Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill No. 180264. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it, and this will be placed on our First Reading Calendar today. The next order of business is the consideration of the Calendar. I note that the bill just reported from Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 with suspension of the rules has been deemed to have had a first reading. This bill will be placed on our Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. As there are no additional bills on the First Reading, the Chair recognizes Councilman Henon for the motion concerning the bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the following bills on Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar: Bill Nos. 180003, 180099, 180169, 180172, 180173, 170925, 170926, 171117, 180004, 180079, 180080, 180102, 180179, 180216, 180218, 180262, and 180263. (Duly seconded.)

Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that the rules of Council be Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 2ND READING suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the bills just read by Councilman Henon. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it, the motion carries, and we will consider the Consent Agenda shortly. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Henon for the purpose of calling up bills and resolutions on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar.

Thank you, Mr. President. In addition to the bills being considered on the Consent Agenda, the following resolutions and bills are being called up for the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars today: Bill Nos. 180303, 180322, 180352, 180353, Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 180356, 180121, 180122, 180147. All other bills and resolutions are being held.

Thank you, Councilman. Before considering these bills and resolutions on our Final Passage Calendar today, we will have our public comment session. It will go as follows: If you are interested in testifying on a bill or resolution that is on the Final Passage Calendar today, if you have not already done so, you may sign up at the table to my left. When your name is called, you will go to the middle of the Council Chambers. There's a podium, and on that podium there's a device. When the light turns green on that device, it will be your time to speak. When the light turns yellow, you will have 30 seconds to conclude your remarks. When the light turns red, we'd ask that you please adhere to our guidelines and conclude Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 your remarks. You will be given three minutes to testify. Mr. Decker, please call the first name on the list.

Rob Graff, commenting on 180218. (Witness approached podium.)

Good morning.

Good afternoon, Council President Clarke and members of Philadelphia City Council. My name is Robert Graff. I manage the Office of Energy and Climate Change Initiatives at the Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission. DVRPC serves the City of Philadelphia and its eight surrounding Pennsylvania and New Jersey counties. Councilman Squilla represents the City of Philadelphia on DVRPC's Board. I'm honored to provide testimony in favor of Bill 180218, which discontinues the approval of new reserved electric vehicle parking spaces on the Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 street in front of electric vehicle owners' homes and eliminates the existing spaces by 2033. DVRPC has been involved in electric vehicle work for the past decade. In 2012, DVRPC released Ready to Roll, Southeastern Pennsylvania's regional electric vehicle action plan. We are currently working with the researchers at the Plug-In Hybrid and Electric Vehicle Research Center at University of California - Davis to develop tools to help us understand how electric vehicle ownership and charging in our region is likely to evolve. I also serve as DVRPC's representative on the Drive Electric Pennsylvania Coalition. For the past year, I served on the City's Electric Vehicle Policy Task Force established to develop a long-term sustainable approach to promote electric vehicle use in Philadelphia. The Task Force's policy recommendations released Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 in March include freezing the electric vehicle parking space program. As part of its EV work, DVRPC receives detailed registration data from PennDOT for every vehicle in the five counties of Southeastern Pennsylvania. The most recent data we have from November 2017 shows 733 electric vehicles in Philadelphia. This bill affects only the 68 electric vehicles that are parked and charged on public streets in reserved overnight curbside parking spaces in front of their owners' homes. That is, it affects just 7 percent of the 733 electric vehicles registered in the City. Furthermore, the owners of those 68 electric vehicles will continue to be provided reserved overnight parking on the street in front of their homes until 2033 as long as they own or lease an electric vehicle. This seemed fair to the Task Force members. Note that the City still allows residents to install curbside EV chargers Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 in front of their homes. However, they will not be provided with a reserved spot. EV owners have several charging choices if they do not have dedicated off-street parking. Rent a space to park and charge their electric vehicle, charge at their place of work or other location to which they drive regularly or charge at a public charging station. The Task Force report recommends nine strategies to foster these and other options for EV owners. OTIS has stated it will actively pursue these strategies and report regularly on their implementation status. Thank you for your attention. I would be happy to respond to any questions you might have.

Thank you, sir.

Bill West, commenting on 180218. (Witness approached podium.)

Good Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 morning.

Good morning. My name is Bill West. My colleague Ilene Wilder and I are Co-Chairs of the Parking Committee for the Philadelphia Crosstown Coalition, a group of 32 registered community organizations from across the City. Ilene couldn't be here today, but I am here to urge you to vote in favor of Bill No. 180218, which addresses the closing down of the current curbside charging program for electric vehicles. Ilene and I served as community members of the City's Electric Vehicle Policy Task Force, which conducted a broad inquiry into the potential for bringing large numbers of electric vehicles to the City. The report of the Task Force contains a large number of recommendations and, frankly, is a very encouraging document. Although replacing gasoline and diesel-powered vehicles with electric vehicles on a one-to-one basis would do Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 nothing to alleviate the problems of traffic and parking congestion in the City, it would substantially improve the quality of the air we breathe and also give us a quieter city. One of the jobs of the Task Force was to figure out what to do with the current electric vehicle parking space program, which provides residents with dedicated curbside parking spaces in front of their homes where they may install chargers and recharge their electric vehicles. Although this program is certainly well-intentioned, there is simply not enough space on our streets to accommodate the large number of electric vehicles that the Task Force envisions. To use a piece of jargon, the program is not scalable. In our opinion, Bill 180218 faithfully renders into legislative language the recommendations of the Task Force that relate to the current on-street charging program. I should Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 emphasize that the Task Force reached its conclusions by consensus. The group included three private citizens who are electric vehicle owners. We think the bill represents good policy arrived at through a good procedure. We heartily encourage you to vote for Bill 180218. Thank you.

Thank you for your testimony.

Larry Spector, commenting on 180218. (Witness approached podium.)

Good morning.

Thank you, Council President Clarke, members of City Council and especially our district -- my district Councilman Mark Squilla and Councilman David Oh. My name is Larry Spector. I appear on behalf of the Society Hill Civic Association. This is an association which has 5,000 residents Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 represented who live within boundaries of Delaware River to 8th Street, from Walnut to Lombard Street. We strongly support the phasing out of the current electric vehicle parking program and the recommendations that were made by the Task Force. We think that those recommendations provide an excellent roadmap for parking for public electrical vehicle charging infrastructure. Currently, the curbside charging stations are not scalable and they're not even accessible to many people. So the bill will end the practice of giving an exclusive parking space to homeowners who have these parking permits. Our neighborhood in particular has a disproportionate number of the permits that have been issued under these programs, but the elimination of the program will end the exclusivity that homeowners have for the spaces by Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 codifying two-hour parking for all vehicles between 6:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m. and allowing electric charging to continue from 6:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m. still for the homeowners. And the homeowners will have 15 years during the sunset phase of this bill to be able to continue to charge their cars. The program will stop what we see as sometimes the ad hoc installation of these charging stations that take up valuable places on the public sidewalks and have even been a tripping hazard for some residents of Society Hill. In conclusion, the Society Hill Civic Association strongly supports the work, the excellent work, of the Task Force and its recommendations and the general direction in which this whole venture of electric charging of vehicles is going. Thank you.

Thank you for your testimony. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Helen Evelev, commenting on 180322. (Witness approached podium.)

Good morning.

Thank you for giving us this opportunity to speak to you about a critical issue, one that looms over all of us, the universal peril of nuclear weapons and what that means for our children and grandchildren. In our wars, there are -- our wars are fought differently today. Now wars since World War II, the casualties have been 90 percent civilian and 10 percent combatants. Nuclear weapons are designed for one thing, to wipe out whole populations, and they would also dramatically alter the climate in ways so catastrophic that they are, frankly, beyond imagining. This issue is not new to Philadelphia, and I wish to speak to the local precedence. Few of you may recall Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Philadelphia was an active center with its Quaker history of getting a nuclear freeze referendum on the ballot nationally. The referendum called for the United States and Russia, the only nuclear powers at that time, to retain existing nuclear parity, halt the arms race, and open the way for eventual elimination of all nuclear weapons. The nuclear freeze referendum of 1982 was the largest referendum on a single issue in United States history and won by a landslide. It was on the ballot in 38 cities, and I'm proud to say that Philadelphia was one of them and that we voted three to one for the referendum. That was yesterday. Today nine nations have nuclear weapons, with the U.S. and Russia having 90 percent of them. The threat has grown with proliferation and with irresponsible and unpredictable leadership. The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists has a clock that measures how Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 close we are to nuclear war. The hands are now two minutes to midnight. They have only been this close once before, during the confrontation with the Soviet Union drawing the Cuban missile crisis. Today we are here to plead for our grandchildren and children and to our City Council to follow these precedences and make Philadelphia again a leader by exerting pressure on our Congressmen and Senators to co-sponsor companion legislation now languishing in committee that prohibits the President from launching a first strike use of nuclear weapons without a declaration of war by Congress.

Thank you. Thank you for your testimony. (Applause.)

Jean Haskell, commenting on 180322. (Witness approached podium.)

We thank you. The Granny Peace Brigade thanks Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Councilmember Helen Gym and Derek Green for introducing Resolution 180322. We also wish to thank the co-sponsors, Councilmember Parker, Councilmember Reynolds Brown, and Councilmember Greenlee, and we want to give a big shout-out to Jordan Kanell, who seems to be a magician at making things happen. It means a lot to us that City Councilmembers are willing to stand with us as we call on our city to continue its precedent-setting stand to call on Congress and pass the bills that will prevent an unpredictable President from taking unilateral action with a nuclear weapon. We all know the horror to humans and the environment that is caused by the impact of a nuclear strike. We know less about the dollars and cents cost of such a strike. Nuclear weapons have two basic parts, the warhead, or bomb, and the delivery system. One typical nuclear warhead may cost as much Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 as $53 million. Delivery system is more expensive. Depending on whether it goes by land or by submarine, it can cost as much as $200 million. Do the math. If one nuclear weapon were to be launched, the approximate cost could be as much as $253 million. Everyone in this room could come up with a long list of things our city could do with even one-third of $253 million. Thus, while some of you may think that the possible launch of a nuclear first strike is not relevant to our city, the financial implications are clear. The money could be better spent on schools, housing, infrastructure, healthcare, efforts to fight poverty, as well as those other items you all have on your wish list. According to the Union of Concerned Scientists, from where my figures come, the United States will spend some $250 billion on new nuclear warheads and delivery systems in the next Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 few decades. That is roughly equal to 30 years of federal funding for Head Start children. We hope you agree. It is time for our city to call on Congress to act.

Thank you for your testimony. (Applause.)

Hold on one second, Mr. Decker. The Chair recognizes Councilman O'Neill.

Thank you, Mr. President. I ask permission to leave the Chamber. I won't be back for the meeting. I have Council business in my district, and I'd like to be voting aye on all bills and resolutions except for Resolution 180322. Thank you.

Thank you, Councilman. The record shall reflect that.

Margarita Padin, Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 commenting on 180352 and 170678. (Witness approached podium.)

Good morning. I'm here to support Councilmember Reynolds Brown's 180352 urging Pennsylvania House of Representatives to reject House Bills 1659 and 2138, which would create stringent employment requirements for Pennsylvanians using SNAP and Medicaid benefits. Thank you. As a recipient of SNAP and Medicaid benefits and right now it's almost humanely impossible to comply with the present requirements, I don't see how it could be any more stringent. You know, when you receive these benefits, you've got two weeks to go to a CareerLink and apply and receive employment with certain vendors that are contracted with the CareerLink, and if you don't, you've got to do compulsory volunteer work, and when you're doing that, how can you pursue your employment if your eight hours a day are spent doing Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 volunteer work? And also if you're a union member, you can't work for the people that the CareerLink has their contracts with to send you to majority poverty wages because you have to work with contractors that are signatory to your union, and the only way for you to get these jobs is to be out there looking for work. So I don't see how it humanly would be possible to make these requirements any more stringent. So thank you very much. I'm also here in support of Councilmember Maria Quinones-Sanchez's 170678. As a resident of Philadelphia, I appreciate any efforts for affordable housing. The majority of people that work really hard making poverty wages need a place to live. And I live in a neighborhood where we have affordable housing and we also have the highest rising market-rate housing in the area, so it seems to be able to co-exist, but Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 working people need a place to live. Thank you, Maria.

Thank you. (Applause.)

Clerk, could you read the name of our next speaker, please.

Joe Danihel, commenting on 180303, 180353, and 180004. (Witness approached podium.)

This is an official decree of the people in writ of mandamus quo warranto and, as such, requires immediate action and remedy. Every week Council, Mayor, and others transfer private property to the government, probably illegally. Last week Councilman Domb spoke on the responsibility to pay property taxes. He stated that the government cannot pay its bills without people performing their obligation to pay their taxes. What about the government Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 obligation to pay just compensation and expenses for my stolen home? Since all were not paid with the federal HUD monies, how can Mayor, Council preach to Starbucks that officials are committed to equity and fairness? Constitution and laws require compensation that a well-informed owner would accept as well as reimbursed losses and expenses to be paid. Why has no official demanded investigation and prosecution of how my home was stolen without compensation, due process or Seventh Amendment trial by jury in a clear RICO-style conspiracy to deny rights? The constitutions require immediate remedy of this breach of law, breach of close, breach of fiduciary duty. Your oath of office requires you to act or face prison. 42 USC 1982, 1983, 1985, 1986, 1987, 18 USC 241, 242, 2381, 2384, PA Constitution, Article I, Sections 1 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 through 11, 26 PA CSA 703, 705, 708, 709, 712, 713, 716, and other laws listed in SCOTUS 15-8965, 14-1330, 14-4056 appear violated. I call for the federal and Commonwealth governments to perform their constitutional obligations to investigate and prosecute all involved in the theft and illegal deed transfer of my home, 1038 West Wyoming Avenue. The denial of God-given 42 USC 1982 property rights for 24 years is egregious, extraordinary, oath-violating, and requires immediate remedy. A just government must obey the rule of law. This color of law government must have its Charter to govern revoked until a constitutionally compliant government is installed. Public servants cannot refuse their sworn duty to act any more than a fireman can refuse to fight a fire. The sovereign people require oath, Constitution, and laws be enforced. Jail Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 is required for all who violate oath, Constitution or law. I remind Council, it takes a lot of cooperation to create and allow monumental corruption.

Thank you. Clerk, would you please read the name for the next testimony, please.

Liam Dougherty. (Witness approached podium.)

Hello, Councilmembers. Thank you for letting me speak. I'm here to show my support for the unfair rental practices bill introduced by Councilmembers Jones, Parker, and Gym. I have a disability and I work at Liberty Resources. We are a center for independent living, and I want to say on behalf of the disability community, just cause eviction legislation is essential for us. Not only is it sort of unbelievable that this city doesn't have such legislation right now, it takes Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 people with disabilities months, sometimes years, to find housing, and we cannot afford to be on our own and live without. Right now I'm -- in my building I rent, and my wife is eight months pregnant, and our building is being sold to another landlord. And the way things are right now, they could very easily not accept my new lease and I would be trying to look for a new place to live with a four-month-old baby, and that's not something I can do. It took me about a year -- six months to a year to find this current apartment that I'm in. So, again, thank you for hearing me and for introducing this bill, and I appreciate the time. (Applause.)

Thank you for your testimony, sir.

Samantha Petty, commenting on 170854. (Witness approached podium.) Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Hello. Thank you for letting me speak today. I'm here about the same bill as the last speaker, requiring good cause for certain residential evictions and to provide a first option for existing tenants to renew a lease. I'd first like to thank City Council for its current focus on affordable housing and eviction prevention. There's been a lot of action around that in a lot of different ways, and that's very meaningful to the City of Philadelphia. On this bill specifically, I'm here as a mom of a medically complex child. It takes us a very long time to find housing that's on one floor and has an elevator for my child's wheelchair and medical equipment. I do not personally fear eviction. I am quite economically stable. I have a lot of educational access and white privilege that allows me Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 to not let my landlord intimidate me when I ask for reasonable accommodations for my child, but I'd like to represent my child's classmates today and their families who do not have the same access that I do and are often intimidated by their landlords and evicted without any cause given. Eviction in our city affects one out of 14 Philadelphia renters. I believe it's a poverty issue because it causes poverty. It's not just a symptom of not being able to pay your rent. It's a fair housing issue, because it disproportionately affects women of color and children, and those are classes protected under fair housing law. It's also a big public health issue for children like mine and also other children who are moved into substandard housing when their parents have evictions on their record, and reasonable landlords do not want to rent to people with recent evictions on their Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 record. I'm really proud of our efforts in early education. I work in that sector as a peer specialist for other parents of kids with disabilities, and I can't tell you how many kids we lose track of every week because their parents are evicted and we can't give them services because we can't find them again because evictions happen so quickly, the parents don't have time to contact us and set up a new place for us to meet their kids and provide services in their homes. We are facing cuts federally for protections to fair housing. The most recent HUD budget no longer allows us to use federal dollars to affirmatively further fair housing. This is a very important part of our job as a city, and I think we can step up locally, and passing good cause evictions means that we will protect fair housing for our citizens. And, finally, I think good Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 policy supports other existing policy and that this change will support the $500,000 budget recently won by Council for eviction court and our beverage tax that helps with early education in keeping our kids stable and educated. Thank you very much. (Applause.)

Thank you for your testimony.

Ikey Raw, commenting on 170854. (Witness approached podium.)

Good morning.

Good morning. How you doing, Councilman Clarke? Ladies and gentlemen, I'm here to speak on behalf of not only the family of David Jones, also the family of all children murdered in the streets of Philadelphia.

Ikey?

Starbucks is not more Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 dangerous than a racist police officer.

Mr. Raw? (Witness speaking without microphone.)

Mr. Raw, do me a favor. (Witness speaking without microphone.)

You got to start talking -- you signed up for evictions. (Witness speaking without microphone.)

I'm just telling you, if you want to talk about evictions, you can start that process -(Witness speaking without microphone.)

We can talk about that later. (Witness speaking without microphone.) Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

I'll talk to you. (Witness speaking without microphone.)

I'll talk to you. (Witness speaking without microphone.)

Yes, sir. We'll talk right after Council. (Applause.)

There are no other speakers on the public comment list, Mr. President.

Thank you. That concludes our public comment session. We're going to move on to our Calendar. Mr. Decker, please read the title of -- we're going to do the Consent Agenda. We're going to consider the Consent Agenda first. I would ask Mr. Decker to Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 titles of all the bills on the Consent Agenda. After each title is read, any member may object to the inclusion of the bill on the Consent Agenda. Upon such an objection and without debate, the bill will be immediately removed from the Consent Agenda and placed on our regular Final Passage Calendar. Mr. Decker, can you please read the titles of the bills on the Consent Agenda.

Bill No. 180003, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Girard Avenue, 5th Street, Spring Garden Street, 8th Street, Brown Street, and 9th Street"; and Bill No. 180099, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 area bounded by Master Street, 28th Street, Thompson Street, and 27th Street"; and Bill No. 180169, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Zoning and Planning,' by revising Chapter 14-700, entitled 'Development Standards' by creating regulations for Semi-Detached Structures and making related changes"; and Bill No. 180172, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Oakmont Street, Torresdale Avenue, Pennypack Creek, Rhawn Street, and Rowland Avenue"; and Bill No. 180173, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Avenue, Leon Street, Solly Avenue, Frankford Avenue, Stanwood Street, and Erdrick Street"; and Bill No. 180925, entitled "An ordinance terminating a no parking regulation on Ivy Hill Road between Mansfield Avenue and Hazelwood Drive (northeast entrance), south side"; and Bill No. 170926, entitled "An ordinance establishing a one way regulation on Hazelwood Drive at Ivy Hill Road"; and Bill No. 171117, entitled "An ordinance establishing a no truck parking regulation on both sides of 75th Street from Brockton Road to Lansdowne Avenue"; and Bill No. 180004, entitled "An ordinance legalizing an existing retaining wall encroachment at 289 Osborn Street"; and Bill No. 180079, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 9-200 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Commercial Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Streets,' by amending Section 9-204, entitled 'Sidewalk Vendors in Center City' to change certain requirements for vending licenses and the process for obtaining locations for Center City sidewalk vending"; and Bill No. 180080, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the relocation of the lines and the striking and abandonment of certain portions of a right-of-way reserved for drainage purposes and water main purposes extending from Meade Street to Gravers Lane, southwest of Shawnee Street on City Plan No. 165, thereby reducing the width of the said right-of-way"; and Bill No. 180102, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 9-205 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Sidewalk Sales,' by prohibiting vending on both sides of Haverford Avenue between Brookhaven Road and Lansdowne Avenue"; and Bill No. 180179, entitled "An Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 9-205 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Sidewalk Sales,' by exempting sidewalk sales by owners and tenants of properties on both sides of Twenty-Second Street, between Lehigh Avenue and Allegheny Avenue, and by permitting such activity under certain terms and conditions"; and Bill No. 180216, entitled "An ordinance authorizing Timothy McGuriman of St. Joseph's University to construct, own, and maintain a proposed sidewalk cafe and planters encroachment at 2461 through 81 North 54th Street"; and Bill No. 180218, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 12-1131 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Electric Vehicle Parking,' to provide for the discontinued approval of new Electric Vehicle Parking Spaces and the expiration of such existing spaces"; and Bill No.

180262, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 12-701 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Bicycle Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Lanes,' by authorizing the Department of Streets to designate bicycle lanes, in both directions, on Parkside Avenue from North 53rd Street to Bryn Mawr Avenue and authorizing the removal of travel lanes, in the same limits"; and Bill No. "

Thank you, Mr. Decker. These bills have been read on two different days. The question for each bill now is shall the bill pass Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 will call the roll, and upon being called, each Councilmember shall vote aye on each of the bills, nay on each of the bills or indicate those bills for which the member is voting aye and those bills for which the member is voting nay. Mr. Decker, please call the roll.

Councilwoman Bass.

Aye on all bills.

Councilwoman Blackwell.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Domb.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Green.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Aye on all bills.

Councilwoman Gym.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Henon.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Johnson.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Jones is not present. Councilman O'Neill is voting aye on all bills. Councilman Oh.

Aye on all bills.

Councilwoman Parker.

Aye on all bills. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

Aye on all bills.

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Squilla.

Aye on all bills.

Councilman Taubenberger. (No response.)

Council President Clarke.

Aye on all bills. A majority of all members having voted in the affirmative for each of the bills, the bills on the Consent Agenda are passed. We will now consider the bills Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING and resolutions on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar. Mr. Decker, please read the title of 180303.

A resolution authorizing the Philadelphia Land Bank to dispose of 1936 North Marshall Street located in the Fifth Councilmanic District.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Resolution 180303 is Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING adopted. Mr. Decker, 180322.

A resolution urging Congress to pass H.R. 669 and S. 200, the Restricting First Use of Nuclear Weapons Act of 2017, which would prohibit the President of the United States from launching a "nuclear first strike" without a congressional declaration of war.

The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gym.

Thank you very much, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed?

Nay.

Nay. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING

Let the record reflect that Councilman Oh, Councilman Taubenberger, and Councilman O'Neill are voting nay. Resolution 180322 is adopted. (Applause.)

Mr. Decker, 180352.

A resolution urging the Pennsylvania House of Representatives to reject House Bills 1659 and 2138, which would create stringent employment requirements for Pennsylvanians using SNAP and Medicaid benefits.

The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Resolution 180352 is adopted. Mr. Decker, 180353.

A resolution approving the redevelopment contract of the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority for the redevelopment and urban renewal of a portion of the Model Cities Urban Renewal Area, identified by house numbers and street addresses as 1029 through 1031 Mount Vernon Street and 1028 Lemon Street.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Resolution 180353 is adopted. Councilman Taubenberger, did you need to be recognized?

Yes. In my quick absence, the Consent Agenda was voted upon, and I would like to be recorded voting aye on all bills.

Thank you, Councilman. The record shall reflect that. Mr. Decker, 180356.

A resolution urging the U.S. Department of Treasury to help protect access to banking services in lower-income communities by declining to adopt harmful proposed changes to Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Community Reinvestment Act regulations.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Council President, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Resolution 180356 is adopted. Mr. Decker, 180121.

A resolution appointing Adam Teterus to the Board of Directors for the Old City Special Services District.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Resolution 180121 is adopted. Mr. Decker, 180122.

A resolution appointing Donal McCoy to the Board of Directors for the Old City Special Services District.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.) Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Resolution 180122 is adopted. Mr. Decker, 180147.

A resolution confirming the appointment of Marcel S. Pratt, Esquire, as City Solicitor.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Henon.

I move for the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Resolution 180147 is adopted. Mr. Decker, do you have any additional resolutions?

A resolution recognizing April 22, 2018 as Earth Day in the City of Philadelphia, introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.) Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING

The ayes have it. That resolution is adopted.

And a resolution authorizing the Committee on Labor and Civil Service to hold hearings on the effectiveness of implicit bias and racial equity trainings for employees of the City of Philadelphia, introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

The Chair again recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING ayes have it. That resolution is adopted.

And a resolution recognizing April 26, 2018 as 50/50 Day in the City of Philadelphia, introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

The Chair one more time recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.

A resolution authorizing the Committee on Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Appropriations and the Committee on Transportation and Public Utilities to conduct hearings to develop more inclusive, transparent, and efficient processes and methods for the City of Philadelphia's procurement of professional services, capital programs, and commodities, introduced by Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for its adoption. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING ayes have it. That resolution is adopted.

And a resolution Proclaiming the Week of April 27, 2018 to May 5, 2018 as the Eighth Annual Philly Tech Week Presented by Comcast, and Honoring the Broad and Vibrant Philadelphia Technology Community, introduced by Councilman Oh.

The Chair recognizes Councilman Oh.

Thank you. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. That resolution is adopted. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING

And a resolution recognizing May 2018 as Asian American and Pacific Islanders Heritage Month in Philadelphia to celebrate and commemorate the proud heritage of Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders and their important contributions to enhancing the City's culture, economy, and the founding ideals of independence and democracy, introduced by Councilman Oh.

The Chair again recognizes Councilman Oh.

Thank you very much. On my behalf, on behalf of Councilwoman Helen Gym, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.) Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 4/19/18 - STATED - 2ND READING

The ayes have it. That resolution is adopted.

And a resolution commemorating the 60th Anniversary of the death of In-Ho Oh and the response by his parents of offering forgiveness to the teenage murderers, requesting that the juveniles receive the "most generous treatment possible" allowed by law and establishing a fund to be used for their religious, educational, vocational and social guidance, introduced by Councilman Oh.

The Chair again recognizes Councilman Oh.

Thank you. With appreciation to Councilwoman Jannie Blackwell, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. That resolution is adopted.

There are no other resolutions on the Final Passage Calendar, Mr. President.

Thank you very much. Are there any speeches on the behalf of the minority? The Chair recognizes Councilman Oh.

Thank you very much, Council President. There have been a lot of issues that have faced the City, and fortunately the media has reported on it, and I appreciate all the Councilmembers who have been very actively engaged. I would like to talk about Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 something, however, that I came across last week. While I was away, a woman came and left me a booklet, and it was about her son. His name is Eric Mann. And I agreed to meet her, but she wanted me to read the booklet, and I did read the booklet, and it reminded me of something that I had experienced many years ago as an attorney and, that is, when I came across Pennsylvania's Post Conviction Relief Act. I'd like to talk a little bit about it because I will introduce a resolution next week calling upon the State Legislature to amend and reform this Act. I have asked my staff to contact Harrisburg. I will go visit them. The first page of the book that she left me, which is evidence of proof of incidence, is an opinion written by Justice James Fitzgerald, who was specially assigned to Superior Court, and he wrote in concurrence or agreement with the decision that the law was being Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 followed, but this is what he said. He said, I write separately only to express my utmost displeasure with the Post Conviction Relief Act's failure to facilitate justice in this case, where it is clear to all that it is likely that an innocent man sits behind bars for no better reason than a poorly conceived statute. No system of criminal justice is perfect. However, a system of criminal justice that prevents the correction of obvious errors is easily improved, if only the Legislature could see fit to do it. This case, in summary, is about a man who was accused of shooting from a terrace another man. A witness, a single witness, said he saw him from a terrace shoot downward and kill the man. At the hearing, there were three alibi witnesses sitting in court, but the attorney never called them to testify. And later, many years later after the conviction, it was found that likely the defense attorney Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 the prosecution that they had an alibi witness and, therefore, could not present the alibi witness. Since that time, the single eyewitness recanted, saying that he did not tell the truth. 32 caliber weapon, firing horizontally and from down to up. It would be scientifically impossible for the person on the terrace to have shot the bullets that killed this person. He has spent 26 years in jail. Here is the problem with Pennsylvania's Post Conviction Relief Act, and I did run into this decades ago, and fortunately for the person I represented in a very long process through a writ of habeas corpus in the Federal Court, the evidence against him was found to be unreliable and he was set free. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 once a person is found guilty in Pennsylvania and the appeals are exhausted, a defendant may file post-conviction relief, and there are limited grounds. Ineffective assistance of counsel is one. Newly discovered evidence is the other. However, you have to file within a year, and if you have newly discovered evidence, you have to file within 60 days of the knowledge of that evidence. That may sound simple enough, but in Pennsylvania, the standards are too strict. They're too hard. It's hard to overcome these standards, because for ineffective assistance of counsel, it is different than medical malpractice.

The standard is that no competent attorney would have done what the attorney did in either -- particularly excluding or not including evidence of innocence, and that evidence has to be of a certain category and, therefore, if an attorney committed malpractice, what I would say is Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 malpractice, that will not provide the defendant an opportunity to have his case heard or the evidence heard. The other issue is that in Pennsylvania, newly discovered evidence is not evidence that you just find. It's evidence that you should have found, could have found, but didn't find. And in Pennsylvania, no matter how poorly represented you are, how illogically you are represented, how terribly you're represented, as long as your lawyer told you what he was going to do -- and most people rely on their lawyers -- you don't have an appealable basis. I think that the Pennsylvania Post Conviction Relief Act needs to be amended so that people who have evidence, newly discovered evidence, scientific evidence, recanting of evidence, evidence of attorney malpractice, can appeal and present their evidence, because the way it is right now, it is just nearly impossible in our state. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Thank you, Councilman. Speeches on behalf of the majority? The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Thank you, Mr. President. I have one announcement and remarks I wish to make. First, my favorite writer, Maya Angelou, once remarked, quote, Success is loving life and daring to live it. I rise this morning to inform my colleagues and staff that Haniyyah Sharpe-Brown for the last two years has loved her work in our office, but has dared to live life and move on. She's been offered -- made an offer she cannot refuse, a career opportunity she cannot refuse, and has chosen to move on and make another corner of the world distinctively hers. So I want all to join me in Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Haniyyah Sharpe-Brown. (Applause.)

Secondly, Mr. President, on a personal but also a very professional note, Councilman Goode has always been my leader, my teacher, my hero when it comes to any and all issues that remotely touch the song known as diversity and inclusion. This morning I, along with Councilman Kenyatta Johnson and Chair of the Committee on Labor and Civil Service, Councilwoman Cherelle Parker, coupled with co-sponsorship by members Gym and Green, have offered a resolution, because given the song we've been singing for the last 20-plus years, diversity and inclusion is still not well in the City of Philadelphia. The expulsion, arrest, and detainment of two African American men at Starbucks in Philadelphia last week never should have happened. We know that Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 brown people, women happens all the time. It happens because this country suffers from a history of inequality and racism, from slavery to Jim Crow. It happens because the biases and stereotypes created in our history, like the movie Birth of a Nation, still live with us today profoundly. It is because of this history that we end up with a neighborhood where African Americans are 3 percent of the residents. Let me repeat that. African Americans are 3 percent of the residents, yet 67 percent of the police stop and frisk, according to the ACLU. So I join many across the City and, quite frankly, around the country, but locally a number of institutions, including our own City of Philadelphia and Starbucks and other companies, who take full responsibility to not only acknowledge the power of these biases and stereotypes but, more importantly, to Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 hiring and advancement practices to modernize policies and procedures. We need to look at how well we're not doing in this area. So clearly it is now time for City Council and the City of Philadelphia to again lead by example by doing two things. Let's first evaluate best practices that work, look to see how effective they are with regards to training in the area of implicit bias and racial equity, and then look to see what we can adopt as a city so that we can lead by example from this day going forward. Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Thank you, Council President. And I want to also thank my colleague Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown for staying on the case Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 the plate with my other fellow Councilmembers with me last week in the Second Councilmanic District as we address the issue of racial profiling in the Starbucks cafe at 18th and Spruce Streets. By this point, I think we're all aware of the racial profiling incident that took place last week where two African American young men at the Starbucks located at 18th and Spruce Streets were arrested. If you had told me a week ago I'd meet the founder of Starbucks this week as a result of racial profiling in the Second Councilmanic District, I probably wouldn't have believed you. Nevertheless, here we are. Privately I met with members of the local Starbucks team, including the founder of the company, Howard Schultz, to address the issues and concerns regarding to my constituents. I have to personally commend their executives for showing up in person and listening to Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 say and taking steps pretty immediately to address racial profiling in their stores. My fellow Councilmembers and myself and advocates stood outside on the corner of 18th and Spruce Streets and demanded an apology and also expected -and also addressed the issue of, beyond just an apology, for Starbucks to take seriously by addressing the issue of sensitivity training in their stores, because we have come to learn that this is not an isolated incident only in the City of Philadelphia. In the last few days, the company has announced it will close 8,000 stores on the afternoon of May the 29th for what they call unconscious bias training. This is a step in the right direction in Philadelphia and across the country, but to me I must personally say it's not enough. The company has work to do here in the City of Philadelphia to regain the trust of customers and restore Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 portrays as a welcoming environment for people to meet up and hang inside their establishment. The two young men affected, Rashon Nelson and Donte Robinson, have spoken out publicly for the first time this morning offering their perspective on the event and also asking to be a part of clear policy changes. Those two young men have experienced a deep level of trauma as a result of being arrested for doing nothing. We will continue to have conversations with local residents and the company leadership to see what more can be done moving forward to ensure all of our citizens feel welcome in the Starbucks cafe. We need to be sure that there are clear policies uniformly applied across the board for everyone to adhere to and that employees are not set up to use their discretion for failure. However, even more, we need to engage with the Philadelphia Police Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 improve community and police relations. Most of you know that police have a tremendous amount of discretion and have the opportunity to make decisions on the drop of a dime whether they would like to arrest someone or not. You can look on social media on any given day at any given time and see officers engaged in their level of discretion when it comes to if they would like to arrest someone or not regarding to the circumstances of the issue at hand. I will be meeting with Commissioner Ross to address the Philadelphia Police Department's policies regarding rules of engagement as well as when is discretion used and how is that discretion used, and also looking at the issue of racial profiling, particularly in the Second Councilmanic District, as the figures that were released by ACLU were just mentioned by my colleague Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown.

Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 the customers and advocates who documented this incident and brought national media attention to this issue. As a city, we're in a unique position now that we weren't in last week to have a real conversation and open up a dialogue about racial profiling in our city and what it looks like in 2018. There's an international spotlight on Philadelphia right now documenting how we handle this, whether we like it or not, and on our Police Department and the Starbucks corporation telling the story of race relations in America. Hopefully we can use it as a platform where we want to continue to advocate for a better way of handling situations in public and private spaces and show the world how Philadelphia will go about implementing real change and making progress as it relates to race relations. I am encouraged by the positive steps we're taking right now, and they Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 significant, but as I mentioned before, it's not enough. Again, I want to thank my colleagues for over the last few weeks and over this last week just being supportive and having the dialogue and conversing with me about the various ways in approaching this issue, and Council President, thank you for your time.

Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell.

Thank you, Mr. President. Let me say that I am proud of and I certainly agree with Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown and Councilman Kenyatta Johnson. Let me also say that I want to thank and agree with Councilman Oh about what he's saying, and we're proud to support anything we can do to support him in what he says about making the law fairer for people who have been Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Finally, I wanted to say to all those who listen, please make sure that April -- the end of April is coming soon on our parking amnesty program. Please make sure you take advantage of it. We have already brought in $1,430,295 with cash payments and payment plans. We brought that into the City with this amnesty plan. So please, John and Jane Q. Public, please come forward, take advantage of this, because the end of April is coming soon. We said they should extend it another 30 days, but of course we can't get that. We did try. So do what you can to let your people know time is running short. And we're so happy. People didn't agree with this, but bringing in $1 and a half million already certainly makes a big difference. Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Stated Meeting April 19, 2018

Thank you. I want to remind folks that we have an L&I hearing scheduled for 1:00. We will delay that to 1:15 given where we are right now. It's important to note the intersectionality of some of the issues that we talk about, and I definitely want to join Councilwoman Reynolds Brown in speaking of the work that Wilson Goode did here in Council around inclusion and how all these things come together. I personally want to thank you, Council President, for the RFP on the OPA assessments. As we're in the middle of this budget discussion, it's very important definitely as Chair of Appropriations that we really demonstrate to folks that we're being good stewards of their money. Last year I introduced a bill to review the state code and the matrix by which assessments are conducted in the Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Philadelphia, and the law clearly stipulates that we cannot use unrealized value of abatements so that we don't overvalue, overassess, and overburden longtime residents. Last week Councilman Johnson introduced a resolution, and we'll work jointly on that public discussion that's so very important, and clearly your RFP is complementary to that work. Today, along with Councilman Johnson and Councilman Green, Councilwoman Blackwell, Councilman Jones, Councilwoman Bass, and Reynolds Brown, we are calling for another public discussion that we believe is extremely timely about our capital and professional contracting for the City of Philadelphia, not only in the General Fund but also in our enterprise funds. In our public discussions over the last couple of weeks, it's alarming that we don't have articulated standards and that departments have a lot of Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 RFPs, how they award contracts, whether it's the lowest responsible bidder, best value as it gets incorporated, but the level of discretion is concerning. It's further alarming that our numbers are decreasing given the Mayor's public commitment to inclusion and Council's work around this issue. That's why I think it's necessary for us to have a very public discussion and develop standards that hold contractors and vendors responsible to meet their participation goals. Ultimately if we don't debar and fire people, they're not going to take us serious. But, more importantly, that we hold the departments responsible to reach the goals, because we are talking about a five-year $10.8 billion capital fund, and when you look at our enterprise funds such as the Water Department at $4.8 billion, we got to show people, not just tell people, that we're being responsible, and I look Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 discussion as we've always had in Council to bring added value and added discussion within the Administration and Council on these important issues. Thank you, Council President.

Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.

Thank you, Mr. President. I just want to take a moment to invite everyone over to the Caucus Room. I know we have a lot happening today after session, but I wanted to invite everyone over to the Caucus Room immediately after session for a lunch briefing on Community HealthChoices. This is Pennsylvania's new mandatory managed care program for individuals who are eligible for both medical assistance and Medicare, older adults and individuals with physical disabilities. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 rolling out across the state since the beginning of this year and will go into effect in Philadelphia next January, and it's going to have a significant impact. It's going to impact thousands of our residents, many of whom may either be unaware of the change or have concerns about these changes and what it can mean for their healthcare. So we certainly hope folks can come over after the session and get some valuable information that can be shared with all of our constituents. Thank you, Mr. President.

Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Domb.

Thank you, Council President. This week we remembered the six million Jews killed in concentration camps during World War II. My grandfather came here in 1915. He was Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 eight aunts and uncles were all killed in concentration camps, so were my great-grandparents, so were their children, including a two-year-old. Everyone perished except my grandfather. No one spoke for them. The world was silent. No one spoke. I see what happened this past week in Philadelphia, and I'm glad that we do speak for people who need our voice. That's a good thing. Thank you.

Thank you, Councilman. There are no additional speeches on behalf of the minority and majority. And with that, the Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee for a motion to adjourn.

Thank you, Mr. President. I move that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, April 26th, 2018 at 10:00 a.m. Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 (Duly seconded.)

Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, April 26th, 2018 at 10:00 a.m. All in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Those opposed? (No response.)

The ayes have it. Thank you all very much. ) Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 CERTIFICATE I HEREBY CERTIFY that the proceedings, evidence and objections are contained fully and accurately in the stenographic notes taken by me upon the foregoing matter, and that this is a true and correct transcript of same. MICHELE L. m 1:7 60:3 53:9 64:16 97:6 98:4 80:13 81:1 105:15 109:22 47:11 100:2 45:19 102:3 60:5 126:25 69:15 74:12 99:3,23 82:1 83:1 amended appealable 121:20 102:6 127:7 active 62:2 101:3,25 84:1 85:1 43:13 47:20 109:16 approval 7:1 asked 105:16 abandonme... actively 55:14 103:4 104:8 86:1 87:1 109:19 appeals 108:4 7:21 52:24 asking 116:9 83:11 104:24 adoption 88:1,24 amending appear 58:23 84:20 assessments abatements 113:2 89:14 90:16 93:14 32:8 36:3 71:4 approve 44:3 121:17,25 122:4 activities 91:21 92:22 Ager 23:17 42:3 43:11 applause 6:21 approved 8:4 assigned ability 21:13 10:22 83:2 94:6 95:3 25:14 28:9 81:6 82:24 7:13 17:9 8:10,18 43:25 24:19 activity 24:3 95:23 97:17 ago 105:10 83:2,19 19:12 22:18 14:21 32:9 105:23 able 3:10 84:8 98:16 99:12 107:19 84:2,17,24 25:17,18 43:12,13,14 assignment 20:22 60:8 ad 60:11 100:16 114:14 85:9 28:25 29:21 44:5 12:23 43:21 68:25 75:14 Adam 94:21 101:14 agree 66:5 Amendment 31:11 63:20 approving assistance absence 8:20 added 124:4 102:17 119:17,21 32:24 33:7 66:9 69:5 32:23 33:8 108:7,17 8:24 9:10 124:4 103:20 120:19 33:9,14 73:20 77:9 92:11 124:23 93:14 adding 42:6 adults 124:24 agreed 105:6 70:15 79:12 91:7 approximate Assistant abuse 3:23 42:10 advancement agreement America 111:4 65:7 17:12 40:19 addition 113:3 105:24 15:14 applicant's April 1:7 7:22 association Academy 7:8 26:15 50:20 advantage aimed 39:10 118:16 42:8 8:3,9 32:3,5 6:17 14:4 accept 70:9 additional 120:7,13 40:4 American applied 32:10 34:19 58:24,25 73:11 33:19 49:7 advertising air 57:5 6:16 14:4 116:21 35:8 39:25 60:17 access 22:12 97:8 126:16 13:20 Aktiveight 45:17 102:3 apply 67:19 45:7 97:10 Atomic 62:24 74:25 75:6 address 114:5 advise 32:2 23:18 25:15 111:23 128:21 99:5 101:5 attached 93:23 114:22 advocate 28:19 114:11 appointed 120:5,5,14 47:21 accessible 115:3 118:18 AL 1:17 Americans 14:14 15:3 126:24 attention 18:8 59:15 117:16 advocates alarming 45:20 102:6 appointing 127:6 6:12 55:17 accommoda... addressed 115:6 118:3 122:23 112:12,14 94:21 95:17 arduous 25:6 118:5 57:17 115:9 Affection 123:7 amnesty appointment area 30:19 attorney accommoda... addresses 29:20 30:24 alibi 106:21 120:6,11 96:14 33:2,2,11 105:10 75:3 56:11 92:16 affirmation 107:3,4 amount 117:4 appreciate 33:11 68:24 106:22,25 accompany... addressing 20:19 22:2 ALLAN 1:11 and/or 7:19 22:15 80:18 81:2 108:19,20 10:4 23:6 115:11 affirmative Allegheny 128:23 22:16 68:18 81:17,25 108:24 accomplish... adhere 51:25 88:22 84:7 Anderson 73:19 92:15 113:5 109:22 11:11 16:23 116:22 affirmatively alleviate 57:2 29:9 104:22 113:12 audience 27:9 accurately adjourn 76:19 allow 36:5 Angelou appreciating areas 80:17 aunts 126:2 128:5 126:21 affirms 20:22 72:5 110:13 22:16 80:25 81:16 Authority accused adjourned afford 73:4 allowed 24:3 anniversary appreciation 81:24 14:23 92:12 106:17 126:24 affordable 46:9 103:11 29:9 46:4 103:19 arms 62:8 authorization achieve 26:6 127:6,16 68:18,22 allowing 60:4 103:6 approach arrest 111:22 44:9 acknowledge ADJOURN... 74:11 allows 54:24 announced 53:23 117:7,12 authorizing 16:10 126:1 127:1 affording 74:25 76:17 27:3 115:16 approached arrested 32:11 34:24 112:24 Adjustment 29:25 Almighty 3:4 announcem... 10:17 23:9 114:13 37:9 43:16 ACLU 14:19 African 3:11,18 4:7 110:10 52:8 55:24 116:12 43:21 44:2 112:17 Administra...

11:16 28:11 40:6 41:1 13:4 14:18 7:14 12:2,7 34:22 35:6 Casper 24:7 128:2 back 9:21 better 12:25 41:14 42:1 14:22 15:4 13:10 21:24 35:11 37:19 casualties certification 18:14 21:24 38:19 41:10 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 128:20 chance 31:2 88:14,17 35:4,9 38:4,9,18 119:11 70:20 9:17,21 certified 12:2 change 14:19 89:6 90:4 37:14 44:5 39:5,14 120:23 115:17 18:21 65:10 CERTIFY 52:15 77:3 91:10 92:10 44:6 47:7 41:8,16,24 124:8 closing 56:12 65:23 128:3 83:4 118:22 93:21 94:20 47:13,15,18 42:12,19 125:17 Club 26:21 115:13 certifying 125:9 95:16 96:13 52:13,17,20 43:2,8 126:14 Co-Chairs 120:12 128:24 changes 97:9 98:5 54:16,24 44:10,18 127:3,10,13 56:5 121:14 Chair 2:10 81:11 93:25 99:4,24 56:9,19 45:4,13,24 class 7:9 co-exist 68:25 125:13 6:2,15 7:23 116:10 101:4 102:2 57:4,6 46:12 47:2 classes 75:17 co-sponsor comes 111:9 8:21 9:5,12 125:10 103:5 104:9 58:19 63:9 47:23 48:9 Classical 63:12 117:11 9:23 13:4 changing child 5:9 64:10,12 48:17,20 26:13 28:11 co-sponsored coming 23:21 14:22 19:14 80:16,24 74:18 75:4 65:11,15 49:23 50:8 classmates 34:12 37:2 120:5,14 22:25 29:3 81:15,23 child's 74:20 66:6 72:24 50:11 51:5 75:5 38:25 41:22 commemor... 29:8 31:18 Chapter 75:5 74:9,14 52:9,12 clear 20:4 44:24 45:19 102:5 34:3 35:12 12:10 29:11 children 75:10 76:21 55:20,25 21:2 65:16 co-sponsors commemor... 35:19 36:10 36:3 42:3 40:21 61:12 83:7,15 58:11,16,19 70:16 106:7 64:4 46:3 103:6 36:17,22 81:8 82:24 63:8 66:4 94:22 95:18 60:24 61:5 116:10,20 co-sponsors... commend 37:20 38:5 charge 55:7,7 75:17,20,21 96:15 97:11 63:18 66:7 clearly 113:6 111:16 19:3 41:3 38:20 39:15 55:9 60:9 77:21 126:5 98:10 99:6 66:10,22 122:2,10 Coalition 114:24 41:11,18 charged Choice 26:15 100:6 73:21 77:10 Clef 26:21 53:19 56:7 commending 42:14,21 54:12 27:8 28:19 104:20 77:15,18,23 Clerk 1:19 code 36:4 39:8 43:4 44:13 chargers choices 55:5 111:20 78:3,7,11 31:21,24 42:4 81:7 comment 44:20 46:18 54:25 57:13 chosen 112:18,21 78:16,22 33:20 34:18 82:25 83:20 51:1,10 47:25 49:8 charging 110:22 113:7,7,14 79:2,6,10 34:23 35:7 84:3,18,25 52:1 53:1 50:14 66:12 53:15 55:4 Church 2:11 115:15,24 79:16 85:21 36:2 37:8 85:10 54:1 55:1 89:12 90:13 55:10 56:13 26:20 118:5,9 88:18,19 38:11 39:7 121:24 56:1 57:1 91:18 92:20 57:25 59:11 Churchill 120:10 89:11,17,21 42:2 43:10 codifying 58:1 59:1 94:4,25 59:14 60:4 18:23 122:2,19 89:24 90:12 45:6,15 60:2 60:1 61:1 95:21 96:17 60:12,21 Cindy 1:10 City' 83:4 90:18,22 46:2 47:6 colleague 62:1 63:1 97:14 98:13 Charter 39:2 City's 15:22 91:2,8,17 52:6 55:22 56:4 113:24 64:1 65:1 99:9 100:12 71:18 circumstan...

45:22 53:21 91:23 92:3 58:13 61:2 117:24 66:1 67:1 101:12 Cherelle 1:15 117:13 56:15 102:8 92:6,19,25 63:21 66:25 colleagues 68:1 69:1 102:13 34:10 citation 17:13 citywide 93:5,8,17 69:6,9 72:8 17:24 18:17 70:1 71:1 103:17 111:15 cities 29:19 14:19 94:3,9,13 72:10 73:23 39:20 41:5 72:1 73:1 104:16 Chief 1:19 33:11 62:15 Civic 58:24 94:16,24 77:12 79:13 110:16 74:1 75:1 110:7 31:20,24 92:14 60:17 95:5,9,12 80:14 86:11 119:5 76:1 77:1 111:13 33:20 34:18 citizens 18:18 Civil 34:25 95:20 96:2 86:15,19,22 College 11:3 78:1 79:1 113:20 34:23 35:7 29:18 58:4 98:7 111:14 96:6,9,16 86:25 87:5 11:9,21 79:14,19 119:13 36:2 37:8 76:24 civilian 61:16 96:21,25 87:8,11,15 12:22 13:13 commenting 120:25 38:11 39:7 116:18 Clarke 1:10 97:4,13,19 87:22 88:2 13:20,24 52:7 55:23 121:19 42:2 43:10 city 1:2,6 2:2,5 5:20 97:23 98:2 88:6,10,14 15:20 16:21 58:14 61:3 124:10 45:6,15 2:25 3:15 5:25 7:16 98:12,18,22 88:17 89:6 18:2,4 19:5 63:22 67:2 125:19 46:2 47:6 4:25 6:19 8:6,13,16 98:25 99:8 90:4 91:10 20:7 69:10 73:24 126:19 52:6 55:22 11:12 12:21 9:2,11 10:9 99:14,18,21 92:10 93:21 colleges 14:5 77:13 chaired 14:18 58:13 61:2 14:21 16:8 10:14 19:13 100:11,18 94:20 95:16 14:7 commerce Chairman 63:21 66:25 16:14,17,24 19:17 22:19 100:22,25 96:13 97:9 colonial 30:12 30:15 25:24 69:9 72:10 17:5 19:21 22:23 29:2 101:11,16 98:5 99:4 color 7:2 Commercial chairs 34:11 73:23 77:12 19:23 20:25 29:23 31:12 101:20,23 99:24 101:4 71:17 75:16 82:25 challenges 79:13 80:14 28:22 29:16 31:15 33:17 102:12,19 102:2 103:5 combatants Commission 18:11 86:11,15,19 29:19 30:11 33:22 34:16 102:23 104:9 61:17 44:6,7 Chamber 86:22,25 30:16,21,23 34:21 35:5 103:2,16,23 climate 52:15 Comcast 52:17 66:16 87:5,8,11 30:25 31:6 35:10,17,24 104:3,6,12 61:20 24:24 45:10 Commissio... Chambers 87:15,22 31:25 32:12 36:8,15,20 110:3 clock 62:25 101:7 14:22 51:18 88:2,6,10 32:13 34:20 37:6,18,25 113:18 close 63:2,4 come 3:5,6,11 117:16 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 commissions 114:21 121:25 consistent control 30:25 31:12 95:20 96:2 42:14,16,20 47:14,17,19 115:16,23 confirming 44:4 128:23 31:13,14,15 96:6,9,16 42:21,23 commitment 116:16 96:14 Consortium convener 31:25 32:4 96:21,25 43:3,4,6,9 16:20 123:9 compensati... confrontation 13:5,9 12:24 33:17,22 97:4,13,19 44:20,22 committed 70:2,8,14 63:5 conspiracy conversation 34:16,21 97:23 98:2 45:5 49:9 11:9 70:6 competent congestion 70:16 118:8 35:5,10,17 98:12,18,22 49:12 50:4 108:24 108:19 57:3 constituents conversations 35:24 36:8 98:25 99:8 50:15,19 committee complemen... congratulate 114:23 116:15 36:15,20,25 99:14,18,21 51:6 52:20 12:22 25:25 122:10 17:25 125:15 conversing 37:6,18,22 100:11,18 58:21,22 34:24 36:9 complex congratulat... Constitution 119:8 37:25 38:4 100:22,25 66:12,14,23 37:9,10 74:17 10:25 17:7 70:7,25 conviction 38:7,9,18 101:11,16 69:4,6,19 42:13 44:12 compliance 19:5,11 71:25 72:3 105:12 39:5,14 101:20,23 72:7 77:18 46:17,20,23 32:21 44:8 22:24 31:5 constitutional 106:5,24 41:8,16,21 102:12,19 86:19,20,22 47:8 49:2 compliant 31:16 71:8 107:18 41:24 42:12 102:23 86:23,25 56:6 63:13 71:20 Congress constitution... 109:18 42:17,19 103:2,16,23 87:3,8,9,11 98:6 99:25 comply 67:14 38:12 63:17 71:19 Conyers 24:9 43:2,8 104:3,6,12 87:13,15,17 100:2 compulsory 64:14 66:6 constitutions cooperation 44:10,18 104:19 87:19,20 111:14 67:22 90:5 70:18 72:5 45:4,13,24 110:3 113:7 88:10,12,14 commodities conceived congressional construct Coors 24:24 46:12 47:2 113:18,23 89:12,13 37:17 100:9 106:9 90:10 84:12 copy 17:2 47:7,21,23 119:9,11 90:24,25 common concentrati... Congressmen construction corner 33:12 48:5,9,12 120:23 91:3,4,4 21:18 26:24 125:24 63:11 43:16 110:23 48:17,20 121:13,16 92:20,21 Commonwe... 126:3 connection consultant 115:7 49:6,14,23 124:3,5,7,8 93:11,13,18 17:22 18:5 Concerned 40:24 13:14 corporation 49:25 50:8 125:17,22 94:4,5,25 19:10 71:7 65:22 consecutive consulting 118:15 50:11 51:5 126:14,23 95:2,21,22 communica...

concerning 15:21 12:3 corporations 51:17 52:9 127:3,5,10 96:17,18 12:14 15:15 49:10 123:6 consensus contact 76:12 12:5 24:23 52:12,13 127:13 101:10,12 31:1,18 concerns 58:3 105:17 corpus 55:20,25 Council's 101:13 32:1 33:1 114:22 Consent 49:1 contained 107:22 58:11,16,19 123:10 102:11,13 33:19 125:9 49:15 50:2 128:5 correct 128:8 58:20 60:24 Councilman 102:14 communities concerts 50:13,21 contains correction 61:5 63:9 1:11,12,12 103:14,17 3:24 4:5,20 27:16 79:22,24 56:20 106:13 63:18 66:7 1:13,14,14 103:18 19:24 93:24 conclude 80:1,3,5,8 continue 3:19 correctly 3:9 66:10,17,22 1:15,17,17 104:16,18 community 51:23,25 80:12 81:1 4:13 17:18 correlation 69:16 70:5 2:13,23 110:4 111:7 3:20 11:3,9 concludes 82:1 83:1 21:23 22:5 40:18 72:4 73:21 7:23,25 111:13 13:8,13,23 46:15 79:18 84:1 85:1 30:5 31:9 corruption 74:10 77:4 8:21,22 9:3 113:20,22 14:4,6 conclusion 86:1 87:1 54:18 60:5 72:6 77:10,15,23 9:6,7 11:13 119:12,19 15:12,18 60:16 88:1,23 60:9 64:12 Cory 38:14 78:3,7,11 13:12,18,25 119:21 16:21 18:2 conclusions 93:14 116:14 cost 64:22,25 78:16,22 14:17,25 122:6,12,13 19:5,24 58:3 consider 118:18 65:4,7 79:2,6,10 15:9 16:9 122:14 20:24 21:15 Concourse 49:15 50:3 contract Council 1:2 79:11,16 16:25 23:2 125:19,21 22:7 29:16 85:14,18 50:13 79:23 92:11 1:10 2:2,5 85:21 88:17 23:7,10 126:15,20 30:23 45:12 concurrence 88:25 contracted 3:14 5:6,20 88:19 89:11 25:20,24 126:22 56:8,14 105:24 consideration 67:21 5:23,24,25 89:17,21,24 28:13 29:13 Councilma... 72:21 94:2 conditions 32:7 42:7 contracting 7:16 8:6,13 90:12,15,18 30:25 34:9 89:9 114:4 101:9 117:2 32:20,21 48:24 122:18 8:16 9:2,11 90:22 91:2 34:13 35:19 114:16 124:19 33:16 44:2 considered contractors 10:8,9,14 91:8,17,23 35:21,25 117:22 companies 44:9 84:9 27:6 47:20 68:7 123:13 10:15 14:21 92:3,6,19 36:10,12,16 Councilme... 112:22 85:20 50:21 contracts 15:16 16:17 92:25 93:5 36:17 37:2 8:25 64:2,5 companion conduct 18:9 considering 68:5 123:3 17:4 19:13 93:8,17 37:5,21,22 64:5,6 67:5 63:12 37:12 100:4 30:11 51:7 contributions 22:19,21,22 94:3,5,9,13 38:2,3,5,6 68:16 86:3 company conducted consistency 18:19 45:21 22:23 23:11 94:16,24 38:10 41:11 Councilme... 12:18 56:16 18:11 102:8 28:21 29:2 95:5,9,12 41:13,17 2:16 4:2 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 10:16 19:23 121:2,3,11 56:12 57:11 death 46:4 52:16 59:3 53:14,22 discretion 116:13 23:8 34:12 122:14,15 59:13 103:7 delay 121:6 100:4 123:2 116:23 dollars 64:21 38:25 41:22 124:9,11,12 current 56:12 debar 123:16 deLise 24:5 123:12 117:5,11,19 76:18 44:25 64:11 125:18 57:9,24 debate 80:7 deliver 3:22 developed 117:20 Domb 1:11 72:13,16 counsel 108:7 59:6 73:16 decade 53:7 delivers 14:2 123:2,6 14:17 41:12 104:23 108:17 74:10 decades 66:2 31:19 development discriminat... 41:13 44:25 114:3 115:5 counties currently 107:19 delivery 11:21 12:12 112:2 69:19 86:19 Councilpeo... 52:19 54:7 12:16 53:10 December 64:24 65:2 15:6 81:9 discussion 86:20 19:21 20:15 countless 59:13 27:3 65:25 device 51:19 121:18 125:20,21 29:23 18:18 customers decided 27:5 Dell-P 23:15 51:20 122:9,16 Donal 95:17 Councilwo... country 115:25 decision 25:12 27:20 devoted 16:8 123:12 donate 25:6 1:10,11,13 112:4,19 118:2 105:25 Delta 12:9 dialogue 124:2,4 donated 1:15,16,16 115:22 Cuthbert decisions demanded 118:8 119:7 discussions 24:23 6:3,4,11,22 Country/Folk 32:16 117:6 70:12 115:8 diesel-powe... 122:22 donation 25:2 7:14,17 26:14 28:3 cuts 76:15 Decker 1:19 democracy 56:24 DiSilvio 24:6 Donte 116:6 9:24 10:5,7 County 39:22 Cyndy 24:8 31:22 33:18 45:23 difference dispense 9:14 Dougherty 10:11,12,18 39:24 47:4,24 102:10 18:16 20:2 displeasure 72:10,12 11:23 12:7 couple 122:23 D 52:4 66:11 democrat 40:17 106:4 downward 13:3 14:9 coupled D 1:16 79:21,25 39:22 120:21 dispose 89:8 106:20 15:25 19:18 111:15 dangerous 80:11 85:22 demonstrate different dispositions Dr 24:5 25:19 26:25 course 120:16 78:2 86:2,9 89:4 20:23 21:14 26:10 36:6 drainage 27:23 34:4 court 77:5 Daniels 24:9 90:3 91:9 121:20 26:12 74:13 disproporti...

83:12 34:5,10,17 105:23 Danihel 69:9 92:9 93:20 denial 71:11 85:24 59:21 dramatically 35:13,14,18 106:22 69:12 94:19 95:15 deny 70:17 107:10 disproporti... 61:20 36:23,24 107:23 dared 110:19 96:12 97:7 Department 108:18 75:16 drawing 63:6 37:3,7 Craig 24:11 daring declaration 44:3 85:2 differently distinctively drive 53:18 38:21,22 create 67:8 110:14 63:16 90:11 85:11 93:22 21:13 61:14 110:24 55:9 82:8 39:6,15,17 72:5 91:13 DARRELL declining 117:2 dime 117:6 Distinguish... 82:12 85:13 41:9,19,20 created 112:7 1:10 93:24 118:14 direct 40:24 15:20 85:14,15,15 41:25 44:14 creating DaSaint decreasing 123:23 128:23 district 58:20 85:18,19 44:15,19 81:10 24:11 123:8 Departmen... direction 58:21 66:18 drop 117:6 46:19,22 creative data 40:15 decree 69:13 117:17 60:20 89:10 94:23 Drue 24:8 48:2,3 13:21 54:5,8 decriminalize departments 115:21 95:19 114:4 due 70:14 86:11,13,15 Creative/In... daughter 38:15 47:14,16,18 directions 114:17 Duly 8:5 48:8 86:17 87:5 26:2 31:6 dedicated 122:25 85:4,13 117:22 49:22 89:16 87:6,22,24 Creek 81:19 David 1:14 16:6 18:7 123:18 director diverse 26:11 90:17 91:22 88:2,4,6,8 criminal 42:5 23:17 24:7 31:6 55:5 Depending 13:15 diversity 92:24 94:8 90:13,14 106:10,12 25:14,24 57:11 65:3 Directors 111:11,19 95:4,25 91:18,20 crisis 12:13 28:14 58:22 dedication Deputy 14:14 6:16 13:5 DJ 23:17 24:7 96:20 97:18 97:12,14,16 63:6 77:20 18:12 Derek 1:12 94:22 95:18 25:14 26:14 98:17 99:13 98:11,13,15 critical 61:9 Davis 53:13 deed 71:10 34:13 39:2 disabilities 28:17,17 100:17 99:7,10,11 107:8 dawn 20:11 deemed 49:3 64:2 73:2 76:6 document 101:15 100:10,12 Crosstown day 3:5 9:17 deep 116:11 designate 124:25 56:22 102:18 100:14 56:6 29:14 34:20 defendant 85:3,12 disability documenta... 103:22 102:16 Crow 112:6 35:9 39:21 108:5 109:3 designations 72:18,21 27:15 127:2 103:19 CSA 71:2 48:6,13 defense 80:17,25 discontinued documented Duperon 110:8,9 Cuban 63:6 67:25 97:10 106:25 81:16,24 84:20 118:3 24:13 111:5,15 cultural 99:5 113:15 definitely designed discontinues documenting duty 70:21 113:19,24 25:21 117:9 121:10,19 61:18 52:24 118:12 71:22 117:25 culture 30:16 days 20:20 definitions detailed 54:5 discovered doing 22:2 DVRPC 119:14,15 45:22 102:9 30:12 85:24 42:11 detainment 26:5 108:8 67:23,25 52:17 53:5 119:18 curbside 108:11 degree 11:16 111:23 108:10 77:18 113:5 53:7 54:4 120:24 54:13,25 115:16 Delaware develop 37:12 109:6,20 113:8 DVRPC's 120:15 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 52:21 53:17 53:2,6,9,12 7:8 15:17 113:2 128:4 83:14 76:18 74:7,9 Dyana 23:5 53:15,18,21 16:8 52:15 equity 35:3 evolve 53:16 extraordina... 107:23 79:24 90:6 24:5 29:6 53:23 54:2 enforced 70:7 98:9 example 18:8 71:13 federally 90:9 105:19 54:9,11,16 71:25 113:13 113:8,15 extremely 38:15 76:15 110:12 E 54:18,22 engage Erdrick 82:4 excellent 122:17 feel 3:17 113:9 116:7 E 24:8 55:7 56:13 116:25 Eric 105:5 59:10 60:18 eyewitness 17:19 Fiscal 47:12 early 30:12 56:15,18,24 engaged errors 106:13 excels 30:14 107:6 116:18 fit 106:15 76:4 77:6 57:9,14,17 104:24 especially excited 11:24 fellow 20:10 Fitzgerald earth 22:3 58:5 59:6 117:10 2:22 11:2 exciting 26:5 F 114:3 115:5 105:22 29:19 34:20 60:4,21 engagement 58:20 excluding face 3:22 felt 18:20 five 15:21 97:10 84:18,20 117:18 Esquire 6:15 108:21 70:22 fiduciary 54:6 ease 5:23,24 electrical Engineering 96:15 exclusive faced 104:20 70:20 five-year 22:21,22 59:11 7:6 essential 59:17 facilitate fields 7:3 123:20 31:13,14 elevator engineers 72:23 exclusivity 106:6 Fifteenth floor 74:19 easily 73:10 74:20 25:4 established 59:24 facing 76:15 32:24 33:6 focus 74:10 106:13 eligible engrossed 25:23 53:22 Executive failure 106:5 Fifth 89:9 folks 20:11 east 33:4 124:22 17:2 establishing 12:24 116:23 fight 22:6 121:4,21 economically eliminates enhancing 46:9 82:11 executives fair 42:4 65:18 71:23 125:12 74:23 53:3 45:21 102:8 82:15 114:24 54:22 75:15 figure 57:8 follow 63:9 economy 26:2 elimination enjoy 19:7 103:12 exempting 75:18 76:16 figures 65:23 followed 45:22 102:9 59:23 62:10 enriched establishme...

84:4 76:19,23 117:23 106:2 Eddie 39:21 emerging 20:18 116:4 exerting fairer 119:25 Filbert 32:14 following educated 29:25 ensure EV 54:4,25 63:11 Fairmount 32:15,17 49:16 50:22 77:7 emphasize 116:17 55:4,13 exhausted 85:15 43:19,23 follows 51:10 education 58:2 enterprise evaluate 108:4 fairness 70:7 file 108:5,9 Force 53:22 18:7 76:4 employees 122:21 113:9 existing 53:3 faith 4:12 108:11 54:23 55:11 77:6 35:3 98:9 123:22 Evelev 61:2,7 62:8 74:7 faithfully filed 107:2 56:16,20 educational 116:22 Enterprises evening 20:3 77:2 82:20 57:22 final 27:2 57:8,18,24 15:5 46:10 employment 12:20 event 116:9 84:22 families 40:23 49:5,11,17 58:2 59:8 74:24 42:9 67:9 entire 6:18 events 13:22 expected 75:6 50:17,24 60:19 103:13 67:20,24 entities 12:6 eventual 62:9 115:8 family 17:24 51:8,13 Force's 53:25 Edward 91:14 entitled 32:10 everybody expenses 70:3 19:7 20:7 80:9 89:3 foregoing 14:13 empower 4:2 36:4 42:4 10:10,11,13 70:10 77:20,21 104:10 128:7,20 effect 125:4 4:8,12 43:15 47:10 10:22 11:5 expensive favor 8:11 finalists forever 21:19 effective empowering 80:15,22 evicted 75:8 65:3 48:15 50:5 26:17 forget 20:13 113:11 19:25 81:5,7,9,13 76:9 experienced 52:23 56:10 finally 76:25 21:19 effectiveness enable 30:5 81:21 82:5 eviction 105:9 78:8 89:19 86:2 120:3 forgive 34:8 6:20 35:2 encourage 82:10,14,19 72:22 74:11 116:11 90:20 91:25 financial forgiveness 98:8 31:9 58:8 82:23,25 74:23 75:10 expertise 93:3 94:11 65:15 46:6 103:8 efficient encouraged 83:3,8,18 77:5 12:11 95:7 96:4 find 73:3,15 former 29:10 37:13 100:5 118:24 83:20,25 evictions 74:6 experts 13:8 96:23 97:21 74:19 76:10 39:20 effort 24:17 encourage... 84:3,10,16 75:23,25 27:6 98:20 99:16 109:7,9 fortunately efforts 65:18 2:25 84:18,23,25 76:11,22 expiration 100:20 fire 71:23 104:21 68:18 76:3 encouraging 85:8,10 78:13,18 84:21 101:18 123:16 107:20 egregious 7:2 39:12 entrance 82:9 evidence express 106:3 102:21 fireman Forty-Second 71:13 56:22 environment 105:20 expression 103:25 71:23 33:9 eight 52:18 encroachm... 64:19 116:3 107:9,23 17:4 127:8 firing 107:12 Forum 12:24 67:25 73:7 82:21 84:14 envisions 108:8,11,12 expulsion favorable firm 12:3 12:25 126:2 encroachm... 57:18 108:22,23 111:22 46:25 47:22 first 2:23 4:3 forward 24:4 Eighth 45:8 43:17 44:4 equal 66:2 109:4,6,7,8 extend favorite 6:24 16:12 113:16 101:6 endeavor equipment 109:19,20 120:15 110:12 48:6,13,22 116:17 either 108:21 29:24 74:21 109:21,21 extending fear 74:22 49:3,8 52:5 120:12 125:8 energy 6:17 equitable 109:21,23 32:20 44:8 federal 66:3 63:15 65:14 124:2 electric 52:25 70:4 71:6 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 foster 55:12 26:6 44:2 God 2:23 3:4 71:7 122:13 hands 63:2 hearings hoc 60:11 fought 61:14 76:19 123:7 3:11,13,18 Governor Greenlee 1:12 hang 116:4 34:25 37:12 hold 34:25 found 106:25 Furthermore 3:20,22,25 15:2 17:13 7:24,25 Haniyyah 98:7 100:4 66:10 98:7 107:24 54:17 3:25 4:3,7 17:14,20,22 16:25 35:20 110:16 heartily 58:8 123:13,18 108:3 109:8 FYI 30:9 4:11,13,17 19:10 35:21 64:7 111:2 hearty 25:17 home 70:3,14 109:9 4:19,21,22 grades 32:12 87:2,3 happen 64:9 heavyweights 71:10 founded G 4:23 5:2,3,3 graduated 89:12,13 76:11 23:25 homeowners 11:25 Garden 33:13 5:7,11,12 11:14 92:20,21 happened held 51:4 59:18,25 founder 80:19 5:14 Graff 52:6,11 126:20,22 111:25 Helen 1:13 60:6,7 114:14,21 gasoline God-given 52:14 grounds 126:9 61:2 64:2 homes 53:3 founding 56:23 71:12 Grammy 108:6 happening 102:16 54:14,20 45:22 102:9 general 47:12 goes 65:3 25:3 29:11 group 12:2 124:16 Hello 72:12 55:2 57:12 four-month... 47:17 60:20 going 2:6 Grammy-n... 21:24 56:7 happens 74:2 76:14 73:13 122:20 17:16,17 25:4 58:3 112:3,4,6 help 16:8 Honickman Frank 24:8 generally 22:5,5,6 grandchild... R 90:5 19:6 40:20 highlight Hospital fully 128:5 75:9 111:18 27:24 great-gran... habeas 75:19 34:7 12:20 fund 46:9 117:9,9 govern 71:19 126:4 107:22 healthcare highly-soug...

hours 67:25 47:13,15,17 121:6 123:8 governance greatest Hahnemann 13:6 65:18 12:15 house 14:5 103:12 giving 3:7 12:13 29:18 12:19 125:11 Hill 58:24 39:9 40:2 122:20 59:17 61:8 government greatly 18:19 half 120:20 HealthChoi... 60:15,16 41:5 43:24 123:21 glad 126:10 9:18 13:16 green 1:12 Hall 1:6 124:20 82:7,12 67:6,7 funding 14:7 Global 25:25 13:23 14:11 13:12 34:13 halt 62:8 hear 46:17 Hines 24:9 91:11,12 66:3 go 7:2 51:10 20:11 69:18 37:3,5 38:5 hand 117:14 heard 30:2 Hip-Hop 92:15 funds 122:21 51:17 67:18 69:21,25 38:6 39:2 handle 39:3 109:4 26:13 27:20 housing 123:22 105:17 71:16,18,20 45:2 51:20 118:12 109:4 hiring 113:2 14:23 65:17 funneling 118:21 governmen... 64:2 86:22 handling hearing 73:18 history 62:3 68:19,23,24 30:20 125:4 12:6 86:23 118:19 106:21 62:13 112:5 73:3 74:11 further 16:25 goals 123:15 governments 111:17 handpicked 121:5 112:8,11 74:19 75:15 123:19 3:15 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 75:18,22 importance 102:10 51:11 Islanders Johnson 1:14 Kathy 39:23 65:4 80:18 76:16,19,23 40:9 independent international 45:17,20 2:13,23 keep 4:25 80:25 81:16 Howard important 72:20 15:13 24:6 102:4,7 16:9 34:9 22:6 81:24 89:7 114:21 45:21 76:20 indicate 50:5 30:20 isolated 36:18 37:21 keeping 6:6 landlord 73:9 HUD 70:4 102:7 121:8 86:5 118:11 115:14 37:22 38:3 77:7 75:2 76:17 121:19 individually intersection... issue 40:8 41:23 87:12 Kenyatta landlords humanely 122:9 124:6 123:2 121:9 61:9,23 87:13 94:4 1:14 34:9 75:8,24 67:14 importantly individuals intimidate 62:12 75:12 94:5 111:13 111:13 landslide humanly 9:20 29:12 124:22,24 75:2 75:15,20 113:21,22 119:19 62:14 68:11 112:25 industry intimidated 109:5 114:5 119:19 keynote 6:23 Lane 83:15 humans 123:18 23:25 27:7 75:7 115:9,11 122:7,13 kids 76:6,7,14 lanes 85:3,6 64:19 impossible 29:16 30:8 INTRO 34:1 117:13,21 join 10:5 77:7 85:12 humble 3:12 67:14 30:9,10 35:1 36:1 118:5 119:9 17:23 23:6 kill 106:20 Lanes,' 85:2 Hybrid 53:11 107:13 34:11 37:1 38:1 123:10 110:25 killed 107:15 85:11 109:25 ineffective 39:1 40:1 issued 59:22 112:18 125:23 language I improve 108:7,17 41:1 42:1 issues 3:22 121:11 126:3 57:23 ideals 45:23 38:16 57:4 inequality 43:1 44:1 104:20 joined 6:23 kinship 40:14 languishing 102:9 117:2 112:5 45:1 111:9 joining 10:10 know 4:13 63:13 identified improved influential introduce 6:9 114:22 jointly 122:8 20:9,15 Lansdowne 92:15 106:14 15:22 105:14 121:9 124:6 joke 20:9 23:23 40:25 82:17 83:23 II 61:15 In-Ho 46:4 inform introduced items 65:19 Jones 8:25 64:18,21 85:13,18 125:24 103:7 110:15 34:7 72:16 Ivory 24:7 37:3 41:23 67:17 large 56:18 Ikey 77:12,24 incarcerated information 97:11 98:10 Ivy 82:7,12 72:16 77:20 111:25 56:20 57:17 Ilene 56:4,9 120:2 125:14 99:6 100:9 87:15 117:3 larger 4:23 56:14 incidence infrastruct... 101:10 J 122:14 120:18 largest 62:12 illegal 71:10 105:21 59:12 65:17 102:10 J 1:15 Jonifin 23:15 124:15 Larry 58:13 illegally incident initiative 103:14 jail 71:25 25:13 28:6 knowing 58:22 69:18 114:10 25:23 121:23 107:16 Jordan 64:8 18:16 launch 65:13 illogically 115:14 Initiatives 122:7 James 105:22 Joseph 24:9 knowledge launched 109:11 118:4 52:15 introducers Jane 120:11 Joseph's 14:11 65:6 image 23:15 include 54:2 innocence 34:8 Jannie 1:11 84:12 108:12 launching 25:12 27:25 included 58:4 108:22 introducing 103:19 Jost 27:22 knowledgea... M 12:2 lawyers 125:7 37:13 100:5 60:11 2:1,8,9,22 Jews 125:23 Juvencio 21:24 109:15 implementa... incorporated installed 3:1 4:1 5:1 Jim 112:6 17:11 Labor 34:11 lead 34:8,8 55:16 12:10,19 71:20 6:1 Jimmy 24:10 juvenile 42:8 34:25 98:6 113:8,15 implementi...

S 11:18 58:21 medical 13:8 78:6,10,15 29:6 34:6 legalizing 65:20 79:15 looking 68:9 magician Market 32:14 74:21 78:21,25 34:15 41:13 82:20 listed 71:3 117:20 64:9 43:18 108:18 79:5,9 41:21 42:18 legislation listen 120:4 looks 118:10 main 83:13 market-rate 124:23 middle 51:17 52:10 56:2 22:11 38:14 listening looms 61:10 maintain 68:24 medically 121:17 56:3 58:17 39:13 63:13 114:25 Lord 3:3,8,13 84:13 marketing 74:17 midnight 61:6 67:4 72:22,25 little 21:12 3:20,22,25 maintenance 12:13 13:16 Medicare 63:3 77:16,17 legislative 105:13 4:3,13,19 43:17 15:16 21:25 124:23 Mifflin 7:10 110:15 39:10 40:6 live 22:11 4:20,21,22 major 27:16 Marshall meet 76:13 Mike 17:13 111:12 57:22 23:4,13 5:3,3,7,11 majority 8:24 89:8 105:6 19:9 116:8 legislators 24:3,16 5:12,14 68:5,19 Marvin 23:16 114:14 Milkboy Motel 23:15 41:4 25:22 26:3 lose 76:7 88:21 110:6 25:13 28:6 116:3 26:19,21 25:13 28:4 Legislature 26:8,18,19 losses 70:10 126:18 Master 81:2 123:14 million 65:2,5 motion 49:10 105:15 27:4 28:24 lot 64:10 72:5 making 18:7 Master's meeting 1:3 65:8,12 50:12 106:14 29:13 59:2 74:12,13,24 19:24 64:9 11:18,19 7:22 8:3,9 120:20 126:21 Lehigh 84:7 68:21,21 104:20 68:20 81:11 math 65:5 18:11 66:17 125:23 Mount 92:17 Lemon 92:17 69:2 73:4 122:25 118:22 matrix 117:15 mine 75:20 move 2:8 8:2 lens 21:14 73:12 124:15 119:24 121:24 127:16 minority 24:3 48:4 lent 14:10 110:14,19 lots 21:9 malpractice matter member 12:8 104:15 49:13 79:19 Leon 82:2 112:9 Louis 24:5 108:18,25 109:10 12:15,23 126:17 89:14 90:15 lessons 21:17 lives 3:16 Lounge 26:23 109:2,22 128:7 13:19 15:7 minority/fe... 91:21 92:22 Let's 25:16 18:9,17 love 4:3,4 man 5:9 Mawr 11:21 68:3 80:4 12:3 94:6 95:3 113:9 living 18:24 6:20 29:20 21:12 106:8 15:20 85:5 86:6,7 minutes 52:3 95:23 96:18 letting 72:13 72:20 30:23 106:17,18 Maxwell 2:11 members 63:3 97:17 98:16 74:3 local 26:4,18 loved 110:18 106:20 2:18,20 2:14 3:14 missed 18:19 99:12 level 30:20 61:25 Lovett 24:9 manage Maya 110:12 10:8,15 missile 63:6 100:15 116:11 114:20 loving 3:4 52:14 Mayor 14:13 20:6 31:25 mission 22:11 101:14 117:10 116:15 110:14 managed 14:14,20 47:7 52:12 Model 33:10 102:16 123:5 locally 14:3 lower-income 124:21 31:20 69:16 54:23 56:15 92:14 103:20 Liam 72:10 76:21 93:24 Management 70:5 58:19 88:21 modernize 110:19,22 Liberty 72:19 112:20 lowest 123:4 12:2 21:24 Mayor's 111:16 113:3 126:23 licenses 83:5 located 80:18 Lucas 24:13 mandamus 123:8 114:19 mom 74:17 moved 8:7 licensing 81:2,17,25 lunch 124:19 69:14 McCoy 95:17 men 21:4 moment 6:2 40:2 48:10 42:10 89:9 114:12 luncheon mandatory McGuriman 111:23 16:10 31:4 49:24 75:21 Lieutenant location 55:8 6:25 124:21 84:11 114:11 124:14 89:18 90:19 17:12,14,20 locations 83:6 Lutheran Manetti McKinney-... 116:5,11 money 24:22 91:24 93:2 17:22 19:9 Lombard 26:20 24:14 6:15 7:11 mental 40:20 65:16 94:10 95:6 life 18:25 59:4 Luzerne Mann 105:5 Meade 83:14 mention 121:22 96:3,22 20:17,19 long 16:5 39:22 Mansfield mean 125:10 21:10 Monica 24:10 97:20 98:19 82:8 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 99:15 4:25 123:11 54:24 111:7 11:8 16:19 56:25 organizatio... 103:8 passing 76:22 100:19 Necktie 26:23 121:8 18:22 ones 20:16 12:12 parity 62:8 passion 20:23 101:17 need 68:21 notes 128:6 off-street OPA 121:16 organizations park 55:6 Pastor 2:10 102:20 69:2 93:12 notice 107:2 55:6 open 62:9 4:22,23 85:16 2:18,20 103:24 113:4 November offer 35:22 118:8 12:17 22:10 parked 54:11 5:21 127:4 116:19,24 54:9 43:7 44:16 opened 22:12 56:8 Parker 1:15 pay 6:12 movie 112:8 126:11 nuclear 61:11 44:23 openings organizing 6:12 13:3 69:20,22,23 moving 41:5 needs 109:18 61:17 62:3 110:20 27:15 16:14 34:10 38:21 70:2 75:14 116:17 neighborho... 62:7,8,10 offered 38:14 opinion 57:21 Osborn 82:21 38:22 39:16 payment multi-billio...

3:21 59:20 62:11,19 110:20 105:21 OTIS 55:14 39:17 45:2 120:9 30:10 68:22 63:2,15 111:17 opioid 40:19 outside 115:6 64:5 72:17 payments murdered 112:12 64:16,20,22 offering 46:5 opportunities outstanding 87:23,24 120:9 77:21 Nelson 116:6 64:25 65:6 103:8 116:8 25:25 26:5 15:12 25:3 111:15 Peace 63:25 murderers never 106:22 65:14,24 office 52:14 opportunity overassess parking PECO 15:18 46:6 103:9 107:2 90:7,9 70:21 3:8 29:25 122:5 52:25 54:3 pedestrian MURPHY 111:24 number 110:18 39:19 61:8 overburden 54:13,19 43:23 128:14 Nevertheless 40:21 56:20 officer 78:2 109:3 122:5 55:6 56:5 peer 76:5 music 23:23 114:18 57:17 59:21 officers 110:21 overcome 57:3,9,11 peers 15:19 23:25 25:2 new 52:19,24 112:20 117:10 117:5 108:16 59:7,10,17 Pell 14:7 25:23 26:11 61:23 65:24 numbers offices 47:13 opposed 8:14 overhead 59:19 60:2 PennDOT 26:22 27:15 73:11,12 56:18 92:15 47:16,18 48:18 50:9 43:22 82:6,15 54:6 29:16 30:8 76:13 84:20 123:8 official 69:13 89:22 90:23 overnight 84:21 85:17 Pennsylvania 30:9,12,13 124:21 numerous 70:12 92:4 93:6 54:13,19 120:6 1:6 12:25 30:22 31:9 newest 13:9 12:16 15:10 officials 70:6 94:14 95:10 oversaw Parking,' 15:2,3 31:10 newly 108:8 Nutter 14:13 Oh 1:14 3:25 96:7 97:2 13:20 84:19 17:23 18:5 musical 24:18 108:10 14:20 13:25 23:2 97:24 98:23 overvalue Parkside 85:4 19:10 39:8 musicians 109:6,20 23:10 25:20 99:19 122:5 part 54:4 40:2 52:19 26:4,11 NHS 12:20 O 25:24 28:13 100:23 owner 70:9 76:20 116:9 53:18 54:7 30:7,19 nights 20:20 O'Neill 1:15 29:13 30:25 101:21 owners 54:17 participation 67:6 91:11 Myra 2:10 nine 55:12 9:6,7 13:18 44:21,22 102:24 55:4,13 123:15 108:3,14 62:18 126:2 42:22,23 46:4 58:22 104:4 58:5 84:5 particular 109:6,10,17 N Ninth 43:24 66:13,14 87:19,20 127:11 owners' 53:3 6:12 40:9 Pennsylvan... name 5:17 nominated 87:17 91:5 90:24 91:3 option 74:7 54:14 41:4 59:20 53:8 105:11 17:11 51:16 14:20 Oakmont 101:10,12 options 55:13 ownership particularly 107:18 52:5,13 non-privile... 81:17 101:13 order 7:20 43:16 53:15 108:21 124:20 56:4 58:22 38:8,11,24 oath 70:21 102:11,13 8:19 9:14 117:21 Pennsylvan... 69:7 72:9 39:7 71:24 72:2 102:14 31:17 33:25 P partnerships 19:3 67:10 105:5 non-profits oath-violati... m 60:3,5 14:2 91:15 named 13:9 12:5 71:14 103:18 ordinance 127:17 parts 64:23 Pennypack 15:21 non-traditi... obey 71:16 104:17,18 32:8,9,10 PA 70:24 Pashinski 81:18 Nancy 7:10 7:3 object 80:4 119:21 32:23 33:8 71:2 39:21 people 3:16 Nation 112:9 Nordell 24:10 objection OIC 7:8 36:2 42:2 Pacific 45:17 pass 21:7 4:4 10:20 national north 15:14 80:6 Old 94:22 43:10,11,15 45:20 102:4 38:13 39:12 19:25 20:14 15:16 24:24 32:17 33:6 objections 95:18 47:10 80:15 102:7 64:14 85:25 20:24 21:9 118:4 84:15 85:5 128:4 older 124:23 80:23 81:6 package 90:5 21:15 22:9 nationally 89:8 obligation on-street 81:14,22 39:10 40:3 passage 39:9 22:13,14 14:3 62:5 northeast 69:23 70:2 57:25 82:6,11,15 40:4,6 41:6 49:5,11,17 23:21 40:25 nations 62:19 82:9 obligations once 63:4 82:20,24 Padin 66:25 50:17,24 59:16 68:4 nay 86:4,8 northwest 71:8 108:2 83:9,19 67:4 51:8,13 68:19 69:2 90:24,25 33:12 obtaining 110:13 84:2,11,17 :19 80:10 89:3 69:13,22 91:5 Nos 49:17 83:6 one-third 84:24 85:9 paid 70:4,11 104:10 71:24 73:2 nearly 109:24 50:25 obvious 65:11 organization parents 40:23 passed 32:4 75:25 Nebyu 28:12 note 48:25 106:13 one-to-one 13:6 46:5 75:22 40:2 88:24 109:15,19 necessary occasion 10:3 76:6,8,12 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 112:3 115:2 Petty 73:23 16:3 79:21 80:2 positive 18:1 19:1 60:24 61:5 125:22 116:3 74:2 Philadelphi...

80:11 86:9 118:24 20:1 21:1 63:14,18 126:14,23 119:25 phase 60:8 15:23 89:4 120:4 possible 46:8 22:1 23:1 64:15 66:7 127:3,10,13 120:17,19 phasing 59:5 Philly 23:4,16 120:6,11,12 65:13 68:12 24:1 25:1 66:10,15,22 President's 123:16,24 phenomena 25:13,22 pleased 32:2 103:11 26:1 27:1 73:21 77:10 13:19 123:24 41:2 26:3,8 28:6 pleasurable Post 105:11 28:1 29:1 77:15,23 pressure 126:11 Philadelphia 45:9 101:6 9:20 106:4 30:1 78:3,7,11 63:11 People's 1:2,6 5:11 Philly's 25:20 pleasure 107:18 presented 78:16,22 pretty 29:14 26:15 27:8 11:3,10,12 PHL 23:13 10:19 109:18 17:3 45:9 79:2,6,10 115:3 28:19 11:15 12:9 24:3,16 Plug-In 53:11 post-convic... 101:7 79:15,16 prevent 64:15 percent 54:15 12:18 13:14 27:4 28:24 podium 10:6 108:5 President 85:21 88:17 prevention 61:16,17 14:18,23 29:12 10:17 23:7 potential 1:10 2:2,5 88:19 89:11 74:12 62:20 15:23 16:15 physical 23:9,14 56:17 5:20,25 6:5 89:14,17,21 prevents 112:13,15 16:18,22,24 124:24 51:18,19 poverty 65:18 7:15,16 8:2 89:24 90:8 106:12 112:15 18:2 26:7 piece 57:19 52:8 55:24 68:6,20 8:6,13,16 90:12,15,18 pride 18:15 perfect 28:22 29:7 pioneered 58:15 61:4 75:12,13 8:23 9:2,8 90:22 91:2 primary 106:11 29:11 30:14 13:6 63:23 67:3 power 5:15 9:11 10:9 91:8,17,21 24:25 perform 71:7 31:7 32:2 place 19:25 69:11 72:11 112:24 10:14,19 91:23 92:3 printed 33:24 performanc... 34:20 35:4 20:24 30:15 73:25 77:14 powers 62:7 13:15 19:13 92:6,19,22 prison 70:22 26:9 35:9 36:4,6 55:8 68:21 point 114:8 practice 19:17 22:19 92:25 93:5 private 16:4 performed 42:4 44:5,7 69:2 73:12 police 78:2 59:17 22:23 23:11 93:8,17 58:4 69:17 26:18 45:11,18 76:13 112:16 practices 29:2,10,23 94:3,6,9,13 118:19 performing 47:8 52:13 114:10 116:25 72:15 113:3 31:12,15,24 94:16,24 Privately 69:23 52:18,21 placed 48:21 117:3,4,17 113:10 33:17,21,22 95:3,5,9,12 114:19 peril 61:10 53:24 54:10 49:4 80:9 118:14 praise 5:3 34:6,15,16 95:20,23 privilege period 32:20 56:6 61:24 places 60:13 policies 15:5 praising 3:13 34:21 35:5 96:2,6,9,16 74:25 perished 62:2,16 placing 32:13 22:12 113:4 Pratt 96:15 35:10,15,17 96:21,25 privileged 126:6 63:10 68:17 plan 32:12,13 116:20 pray 3:18,25 35:22,24 97:4,13,17 34:18,23 permission 74:15 75:11 33:7,15 117:17 4:11,17,21 36:8,13,15 97:19,23 35:7 37:8 66:15 77:22 80:16 53:9 83:16 policy 11:19 prayer 5:9 36:20,25 98:2,12,16 44:23 45:6 permit 48:6 80:23 81:7 120:11 11:20 38:16 preach 70:5 37:6,18,23 98:18,22,25 45:15 46:2 48:12 49:14 81:14,22 planet 29:19 53:21,25 precedence 37:25 38:4 99:8,12,14 prizes 27:13 50:2 82:25 83:20 Planning 56:16 58:7 61:25 38:7,9,18 99:18,21 30:4 permits 59:19 84:3,18,25 11:20 44:6 77:2,2 precedences 38:23 39:5 100:11,15 probably 59:22 85:10 89:7 52:16 116:10 63:9 39:14,18 100:18,22 69:18 permitting 92:12 97:11 Planning,' political precedent-s... 40:8 41:7,8 100:25 114:17 84:8 98:10 99:6 81:8 16:14 64:13 41:14,16,21 101:11,16 problem person 101:9 102:5 plans 44:4 politics 16:13 preferably 41:24 42:12 101:20,23 107:17 107:14,15 111:21,24 120:9 poorly 106:9 30:7 42:17,19,24 102:12,19 108:2 107:20 112:21 planters 109:10 pregnant 43:2,7,8 102:23 problems 108:3 113:7 84:14 Pop 26:14 73:8 44:10,16,18 103:2,16,23 57:2 114:25 115:15,21 plate 114:2 28:9 presence 5:15 44:23 45:4 104:3,6,11 procedure personal 31:4 115:24 platform populations present 1:9 45:13,24 104:12,19 58:8 111:6 116:25 24:21 61:19 4:18 6:8 46:12,23 110:3,10 procedures personalities 117:17 118:17 Porche 24:6 9:25 11:4 47:2,6,23 111:6 113:4 25:5 118:11,21 plea 21:25 portion 32:12 23:3 67:15 48:4,9,17 113:17,18 proceedings personally 122:2,19 plead 63:7 92:14 87:16 107:4 48:20 49:13 113:23 128:4 74:22 125:5 please 2:15 portions 109:23 49:23 50:8 119:10,11 process 16:12 114:24 126:10 7:11 10:5 83:11 PRESENT... 50:11,20 119:16 25:7 42:10 115:22 Philadelphi... 23:6 31:22 portrays 10:1 11:1 51:5 52:9 120:22,23 70:15 78:19 121:15 17:5 37:15 47:4 51:24 116:2 12:1 13:1 52:12 55:20 121:16 83:6 107:21 perspective 100:7 52:4 69:8 position 14:1 15:1 55:25 58:11 124:7,8,13 processes 116:8 Philadelphi...

72:8,9 118:6 16:1 17:1 58:16,19 125:16,17 37:14 100:6 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 Proclaiming 96:22 97:20 61:1 62:1 R 10:19 17:19 97:14 98:13 105:16 relief 105:12 45:7 101:5 98:19 99:15 63:1 64:1 R&B 26:14 23:24 68:20 99:9 100:12 Reformation 106:5 procurement 100:19 65:1 66:1 28:14 76:3 121:20 101:12 26:20 107:18 37:15 100:7 101:17 67:1 68:1 race 62:9 reason 40:8 102:13 refuse 71:21 108:6 producers 102:20 69:1 70:1 118:15,23 106:9 103:17 71:23 109:18 25:5 103:24 71:1,21 racial 35:3 reasonable 104:16 110:21,22 relieved professional 127:5 72:1 73:1 98:8 113:13 75:3,24 110:7 regain 115:25 17:19 12:4 30:6 properties 74:1 75:1 114:5,9,15 recall 61:25 113:20 regarding religious 37:16 100:8 36:5 84:5 75:19 76:1 115:3 recanted 119:13 114:23 46:10 111:7 property 36:5 77:1 78:1 117:21 107:6 120:25 117:12,18 103:13 122:18 69:17,20 79:1,14,18 118:9 recanting 124:10 regards relocation profiling 71:12 100:3 racism 112:5 109:21 125:19 113:11 83:9 114:6,9,16 proposal 118:19 racist 78:2 receive 27:13 126:20 Reggae 23:16 rely 109:15 115:4 32:25 33:10 120:12 radio 25:5 46:7 67:17 recognizing 25:14 28:7 remain 30:15 117:21 proposed 122:8,16,22 29:7 67:19 9:25 11:6 region 24:2 remains 30:9 118:9 84:13 93:25 123:9,12 rail 2:7 103:10 23:3 24:20 53:16 remarked profoundly prosecute 124:2 raised 40:12 received 34:19 35:8 regional 110:13 112:10 71:9 128:15 40:21 11:16 15:10 45:16 97:10 52:16 53:9 remarks 29:4 program prosecution publications raising 39:11 receives 54:5 99:5 102:3 registered 51:23 52:2 13:14 54:3 70:13 107:2 13:22 40:5,11 recharge recommend... 54:16 56:7 110:11 56:13 57:10 protect 76:23 publicly Randall 57:13 46:25 47:22 registration remedy 69:15 57:14,19,25 93:23 116:7 24:12 recipient recommend... 54:5 70:19 71:15 59:7,24 protected purpose Rashaan 67:12 53:25 56:21 regular 9:14 remembered 60:10 120:6 75:18 50:15 24:13 recognition 57:23 59:7 50:17 80:9 125:23 124:21 protections purposes Rashon 116:6 17:6,21 59:9 60:19 89:2 remind 72:4 125:2 76:16 83:13,13 Raw 77:12,17 recognitions recommends regularly 121:4 programs protocol 6:6 pursuant 77:25 78:4 15:11 55:12 55:9,15 reminded 14:6 37:16 proud 29:8 85:17 78:8 recognize record 9:3 regulation 105:8 59:23 100:8 29:12 45:19 pursue 55:14 reach 123:19 23:21 24:17 40:7 42:5 82:7,12,16 remiss 5:8 progress 62:15 76:3 67:24 reached 58:2 29:3 66:23 75:23 regulations remotely 118:22 102:6 put 22:3 read 31:22 recognized 76:2 91:3 81:10 94:2 111:10 prohibit 90:8 119:17,22 39:4 47:4 15:19 93:12 93:18 reimbursed removal 85:6 prohibiting prove 40:17 Q 50:3 69:7 recognizes recorded 70:10 85:16 83:21 provide 52:22 Quaker 62:3 72:8 79:21 2:10 6:3 93:16 Reinvestme... removed 80:8 prohibition 59:9 74:6 quality 57:5 80:2,4,11 7:23 8:21 recording 94:2 Rendell 14:13 42:7 76:14 84:19 question 85:23 89:4 9:5,24 27:14 reject 67:7 14:15 prohibits 109:2 85:24 105:7,7 16:18 19:14 records 42:9 91:12 renders 57:22 63:14 provided questions reading 48:6 23:2 28:23 red 51:24 relate 57:24 renew 74:8 Project 27:22 54:19 55:3 55:19 48:13,22 34:3 35:12 redevelopm... related 81:11 renewal 33:2 proliferation provides 12:4 quick 93:14 49:4,5,8,11 35:19 36:10 32:24 33:10 relates 33:7,11,15 62:22 26:4 57:10 quickly 76:11 49:16 50:1 36:17,22 92:11,12,13 118:23 92:13,15 prominent providing quieter 57:6 50:17,23 37:20 38:5 reducing relation rent 55:6 26:18 24:20 42:6 Quinones-S... 89:1,3 90:1 38:20 39:15 83:16 38:17 73:7 75:14 promote public 13:20 1:16 36:23 91:1 92:1 41:11,18 referendum relations 75:24 53:23 15:16 16:4 46:19 48:2 93:1 94:1 42:14,21 62:4,5,11 13:16,21,23 rental 72:15 promoted 37:11 38:16 88:3 100:10 95:1 96:1 43:4 44:13 62:12,17 15:17 20:11 renters 75:11 26:6 51:1,9 52:1 100:13 97:1 98:1 44:20 46:18 referred 36:9 117:3 repeat 112:14 proof 105:20 53:1 54:1 121:2 99:1 100:1 47:25 49:9 40:14 42:13 118:16,23 replacing properly 8:8 54:12 55:1 Quinones-S...

101:1 102:1 50:14 66:12 44:11 47:9 released 53:7 56:23 48:11 89:18 55:10 56:1 68:16 103:1 89:12 90:13 reflect 9:4 53:25 report 46:20 90:19 91:24 57:1 58:1 quite 74:23 Ready 53:7 91:18 92:20 66:24 91:3 117:23 47:5 55:11 93:2 94:10 59:1,11 112:19 real 118:7,22 94:4,25 93:19 relevant 55:15 56:19 95:6 96:3 60:1,13 quo 69:14 really 7:19 95:21 96:17 reform 65:14 reported quote 110:13 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 48:25 83:12 104:10 revoked Rock 26:13 scheduled 85:9,17 76:10,14 104:21 resident resolved 71:19 26:20 27:18 121:5 Sections 93:23 94:23 reporter 68:17 16:17 17:2 reward 30:4 Rodriguez School 7:5,6 70:25 95:19 100:8 128:24 residential 28:21 rewarded 24:8 11:15 26:22 sector 76:5 session 5:7 reports 46:1 74:6 Resources 30:3 roll 53:8 86:2 schools 65:17 sectors 16:4 32:5 49:6 46:17,24 residents 72:19 Reynolds 86:10 Schultz see 25:9 51:10 79:19 47:1,19 54:25 57:10 respect 43:22 1:16 6:3 rolling 125:2 114:21 30:18 60:11 124:16,18 48:1 58:25 60:15 respectfully 34:4 37:4 Ron 24:6 Science 7:7,7 67:15 68:11 125:13 represent 112:13,15 47:19 39:2 64:6 room 1:6 11:16 106:15 set 76:13 40:25 75:4 116:15 respond 67:5 88:7 20:12 65:9 Sciences 113:10,13 107:24 representat... 122:6 125:7 55:18 91:18 97:12 124:15,18 11:20 116:16 116:22 39:21,23 Resnick response 8:15 97:14 98:11 Rose 6:15 scientific 117:9 126:8 Settlement 53:17 24:12 36:19 46:5 98:14 99:7 7:10 107:9 seeing 41:2 26:22 Representa... resolution 48:19 50:10 99:10 110:8 Ross 117:16 109:20 seen 30:2 Seventh 39:9 67:7 9:25 11:5,6 88:16 89:23 113:25 roughly 66:2 scientifically Seiple 24:11 70:15 91:12 17:3 19:19 92:5 93:7 117:25 round 25:17 107:13 selected share 10:23 represented 20:19 23:3 94:15 95:11 119:18 Rowland Scientists 26:16 18:22 59:2 107:21 34:7,19,24 96:8 97:3 121:11 81:19 62:25 65:22 Semi-Detac... shared 109:11,12 35:8 37:2,9 97:25 98:24 122:15 RPR-Notary SCOTUS 81:10 125:14 109:13 38:8,12,24 99:20 RFP 121:16 128:15 71:4 Senate 39:12 Sharpe-Bro... represents 39:8 45:7 100:24 122:10 rule 71:17 Screening 40:3 41:6 110:17 52:20 58:6 45:16 46:3 101:22 RFPs 123:2 rules 48:5,11 42:5 Senator 111:3 reproduction 51:12 64:3 102:25 Rhawn 81:19 49:2,13,25 second 49:5 38:14 Shawnee 128:21 66:20 89:6 103:7 104:5 rich 25:21,21 117:18 49:10,16 Senators 83:15 republican 89:15,25 127:12 RICO-style run 107:19 50:17,23 63:12 Sheffield 82:2 39:24 90:4,16 responsibility 70:16 running 66:11 89:2 send 68:5 shoot 106:20 republicans 91:5,10 21:5 69:20 right 3:10 120:18 114:4,16 sensitivity shooting 9:9 92:7,10,23 112:23 10:10 23:19 Russia 62:6 117:22 115:12 106:17 requested 93:9,21 responsible 24:15 26:7 62:20 seconded 8:5 separately short 120:18 8:24 94:7,17,20 123:4,14,19 67:13 72:25 8:8 48:8,11 106:3 shortly 50:13 requesting 95:13,16,24 123:25 73:6,10 S 49:22,25 Sergeant-of...

123:4 124:4 105:12 testifying 74:9 77:8 109:17 50:24 51:9 trial 70:15 40:19 various 20:8 121:10 51:12 77:11 79:17 114:8 51:13 56:9 Tribune unfair 72:15 43:17 119:8 talking 78:12 testimony 85:22 89:13 123:11 61:14 62:18 12:18 15:24 uniformly vehicle 52:25 123:20 52:23 58:12 90:14 91:20 Thirty-Fou... 63:7 74:3 Trinity 2:11 116:20 53:2,6,9,12 talks 6:25 60:25 63:19 92:21 93:18 33:14 75:5 112:9 tripping unilateral 53:15,21,24 Task 53:21 66:8 72:9 95:2,22 Thompson 122:12 60:14 64:16 54:3,6,22 53:24 54:23 73:22 77:11 97:16 98:15 81:3 124:16 Trocadero union 15:14 55:7 56:15 55:11 56:16 Teterus 94:21 99:11 thousands today's 33:24 27:3,11 63:6 65:21 57:9 58:5 56:20 57:7 thank 2:23 100:14 125:7 34:22 35:6 truck 82:15 68:3,8 59:6,11 57:18,23 5:14,21 6:2 101:13 threat 62:21 35:11 37:19 true 128:7 unique 118:6 84:19,21 58:2 59:8 6:4,5,5 7:10 102:14 three 34:14 told 109:13 Truly 2:20 United 2:11 vehicles 54:9 60:18 7:14,17,18 103:18 44:23 52:2 114:13 trust 115:25 38:13 62:6 54:11,16,18 tasked 4:10 7:25 8:7,22 104:13,18 58:4 62:17 Tom 15:2 Trusts 12:21 62:13 65:23 56:13,19,24 Taubenber... 9:3,7,15,22 110:2,4,9 106:21 tools 53:14 truth 107:7 90:8 56:25 57:14 1:17 14:25 10:24 16:7 111:2 thrill 6:7,14 top 27:13 try 120:16 universal 57:18 60:3 42:15,16 18:10 19:11 113:17,19 throne 3:12 Torresdale trying 73:11 61:10 60:21 88:15 90:25 19:16,17 113:22,24 Thursday 1:7 81:18 Tucker-Tso University vending 83:5 91:4 93:11 20:6,13 118:2 119:4 7:22 8:3,9 touch 3:16,21 25:12 11:17 12:19 83:7,21 93:13 21:21,25 119:10,12 126:24 4:18,21 5:5 turns 51:20 53:13 84:12 vendors taught 16:13 22:17,20,24 119:15,21 127:6 111:10 51:21,24 unpredicta... 67:20 83:3 tax 77:5 23:10 25:16 120:22,24 Thursdays touched Twenty-Sec... S 62:20 116:23 voice 3:17 term 40:13 48:10 49:12 theft 71:9 Timothy 32:6 93:22 118:17 126:11 terminating 49:24 50:19 Theta 12:9 84:11 transparent ultimately 122:3 voiceless 3:17 82:6 51:6 55:17 thing 61:18 title 39:3 37:13 100:5 34:13 Utilities Voltage 26:23 terms 32:19 55:21 58:10 107:8 79:22 80:3 Transporta... 123:15 37:11 100:3 volunteer unaware 67:23 68:2 Stated Meeting April 19, 2018 vote 56:10 21:15 40:10 7:4 116:3 78:5,9,14 writ 69:13 1,000 27:14 82:10 67:2,6 91:9 58:9 86:4 62:9 68:8 well-inform... 78:20,24 107:22 1,430,295 171117 49:19 92:7 voted 27:9 73:9 82:11 70:9 79:4,8 write 106:3 120:8 82:14 180353 50:25 62:17 88:22 109:23 well-intenti... 8 123:23 109:1 110:1 81 84:15 4/19/18 2:1 111:1 112:1 8th 43:20 3:1 4:1 5:1 113:1 114:1 59:3 80:20 6:1 7:1 8:1 115:1 116:1 9:1 10:1 117:1 118:1 9 11:1 12:1 9 43:11