civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 21, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 21, 20214h 46m

No commercial use on the first floor.

Similar wording

So what is the concern of the RCO?

Similar wording

You can unmute yourself, ma'am, and continue to testify.

Similar wording

Ms. Brutus?

Similar wording

Excuse me, ma'am, you need to unmute me.

Similar wording

Okay, I was muted.

Similar wording

Did you hear what I had to say?

Similar wording

Yes, and I'm just begging your indulgence to allow me to say what I have to say.

Similar wording

The community concern in the letter that you received from the community, and I'm just looking for the date,

Similar wording

in April 2001 made it clear that this variance poses concern about traffic and what the traffic

Similar wording

being proposed by this project will do to the surrounding community. Even though it is

Similar wording

unfortunate that the neighbors at the attached twin did come to some kind of agreement that

Similar wording

they are willing to agree with this, that the overall concern that this project proposes

Similar wording

affects the entire community along the Olney 2 and Olney corridor, impacting residents

Similar wording

trying to access I-95 along the Ogons Avenue corridor, and that the traffic will be grossly

Similar wording

affected for the entire surrounding community. This case for us is not about that house

Similar wording

or that building. It is about what the proposed use is going to do to the entire community and

Similar wording

the traffic flow. If you remember, for a decade or more, the entire impacted community protested

Similar wording

when LaSalle sought to have 20th and Worcester made one way, which created an off jump for

Similar wording

commuter traffic in route to I-76. That closure did occur. So the only off jump for the community

Similar wording

now is Worcester Street and this project along Worcester Street will grossly impair the traffic

Similar wording

flow going to I-76 for the entire community. We are not focused on what is happening on that

Similar wording

property and it was indicated very clearly in the 2019 letter and it is stated repeatedly in the

Similar wording

additional letters um once the only um i have allison weiss on the on the line and i'm sure

Similar wording

And I'm sure this board is aware that I can't fumble with my screen or I'm going to be cut off.

Similar wording

this board is aware that i can't fumble with my screen or i'm going to be cut off she

Similar wording

She has the photo exhibits that will easily, and if I may say, more quickly demonstrate the concern than me reading the letters that were written, which are in quite detail.

Similar wording

So if Allison Weiss can be allowed to share her screen, we can just briefly go over the actual community concern.

Similar wording

And while Allison is, is that okay?

Similar wording

If she wishes to testify, have her raise her hand, please.

Similar wording

Allison, can you raise your hand and then let them instruct you on sharing your screen?

Similar wording

LaSalle University has worked with the community since this project has come about

Similar wording

because they are aware, and when her screen is up, I'll...

Similar wording

Ms. Weiss, would you please identify yourself, spell your full name, and I'll swear you in.

Similar wording

Ms. Weiss?

Similar wording

Ms. Weiss, can you not mute yourself?

Similar wording

Sorry. Sorry.

Similar wording

Please spell your full name.

Similar wording

Allison Weiss, A-double-L-I-S-O-N-W-E-I-S-S.

Similar wording

You swear if I'm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

Can she share the screen for me, which is what I asked her to be?

Similar wording

Yes, just one question.

Similar wording

What is she sharing?

Similar wording

she has a photo exhibit um of uh that outlines the community concerns with regards to this project

Similar wording

okay miss sunken is that okay

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

okay miss allison you can proceed

Similar wording

okay it's not did did that work i

Similar wording

no ma'am um you can just hit the share screen

Similar wording

button at the bottom of your uh right okay yes it's coming up now

Similar wording

and right now we're just looking at an email

Similar wording

did that come up

Similar wording

so what did you you have to do is just unshare

Similar wording

unshare yeah just um put your dot okay here it go is up now okay

Similar wording

Are you able to see it?

Similar wording

Nope.

Similar wording

No, we're still looking at an email.

Similar wording

What would you have to do is unshare, have the document up already, and then share the screen.

Similar wording

unshare stop share okay yep if you have your document up just click the share screen and then

Similar wording

choose the document document is up do you want me to open the document i guess yes open the document

Similar wording

okay and then you can hit your uh share screen

Similar wording

and just click on the documents

Similar wording

that you want to share.

Similar wording

Ms. Weiss, maybe you can just,

Similar wording

let's see if it comes up now.

Similar wording

Here we go.

Similar wording

Edit.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And she's already swore in, right, Chair?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay, so you can proceed, ma'am.

Similar wording

I'm just acting to...

Similar wording

Sandra will be speaking

Similar wording

Sandra will be speaking.

Similar wording

Ms. Brodus or Ms. Weiss

Similar wording

someone needs to begin speaking

Similar wording

we have photograph of what looks like

Similar wording

Ogons Avenue and I'm not sure what the intersection

Similar wording

street is that's all we see so could someone

Similar wording

begin speaking about

Similar wording

speaking about this

Similar wording

this application and what

Similar wording

your concerns are

Similar wording

I think

Similar wording

Sandra has her hand raised

Similar wording

she's already unmuted she could

Similar wording

begin talking

Similar wording

am I unmuted yes you are

Similar wording

Ms. Brodus all right thank you very much

Similar wording

okay so

Similar wording

as you can see

Similar wording

The first picture is the Omni Avenue corridor that extends back to Worcester Street, where this property is located.

Similar wording

Partially down the street is 20th Street.

Similar wording

Allison, if you can present, and you can see the traffic backlog, and this is in the afternoon.

Similar wording

It's very-

Similar wording

Ogon's, where is this intersection, the one with the bus?

Similar wording

Where is this intersection in relationship to the 541 East Worcester?

Similar wording

Worcester Street, if you look at the next screen, 20th Street is the next block up, and Worcester Street is half a block up from there.

Similar wording

20th Street used to be a jump-off for this traffic you see in this photograph, the first photograph.

Similar wording

So their cars trying to get to I-76 and major highways could access Belfield Avenue.

Similar wording

20th Street was closed after much protest by the community about this exact traffic log.

Similar wording

So Worcester Street is now the only jump off for this traffic.

Similar wording

And halfway, Worcester Street, Allison, can you move the screen, can you move the screen down some more to the next picture?

Similar wording

Next picture.

Similar wording

So we're leaving 20th Street down to the next picture.

Similar wording

Okay, this is Worcester Street, which is half a block up from where you saw, from 20th Street.

Similar wording

Go back, Allison.

Similar wording

No, you're going the wrong way.

Similar wording

You're going the wrong.

Similar wording

Okay, stop there.

Similar wording

Stop.

Similar wording

Go back.

Similar wording

I need you to go to the third picture, Allison.

Similar wording

One more.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Stop.

Similar wording

Stop.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay, I can't see what you're seeing, so I'm just going by you.

Similar wording

Okay, and you know what?

Similar wording

You all might not be seeing what I'm seeing because my screen is huge because I can't see.

Similar wording

So am I directing her properly?

Similar wording

Are you looking at Worcester Street at this point where the new library for the school is?

Similar wording

all i see is a residential street and it's heading towards a four or five story okay stop

Similar wording

stop stop now can you see it stop can i see what can we see what can you see worcester street the

Similar wording

the new la salle um library uh medical school is is uh on the corner i i assume that's worcester

Similar wording

street it is worcester street okay worcester street is currently a two-way street and halfway

Similar wording

down Worcester Street is where this project is proposed. The buildings that you see next to the

Similar wording

medical school are new projects that have gone up along Worcester Street, some of which are

Similar wording

apartments that Osal was participating in, and what has occurred is that Worcester Street is now

Similar wording

a traffic nightmare. It has relied upon artery for the community, for people coming from as far

Similar wording

as Mount Airy from Germantown who traveled to I-76 using this route. It backs up intensely.

Similar wording

Students coming to LaSalle, students coming to and from Central High School, as you saw on the

Similar wording

first slot picture at Ogun's Denali and parents dropping off children, plus residents driving

Similar wording

from as far up as Sheltonham Avenue, down Broad Street.

Similar wording

down Broad Street, to access I-76 are all piled up at the next corner in the first picture.

Similar wording

This artery of Worcester Street cannot be compromised by additional traffic, which is

Similar wording

what this new project is proposing. The bigger issue is that LaSalle has indicated to us and

Similar wording

we have walked through and we have looked that the pre-existing and new apartment buildings

Similar wording

that have been put along this corridor have vacancies. There is absolutely no need for this

Similar wording

new project to go up. There was certainly... That's a decision that the developer has to make,

Similar wording

whether it makes sense economically to build or not, whether vacancies... We're saying there was

Similar wording

no need economic there was no need for the neighbor to have to um compromise their home

Similar wording

and and live with a detached project there was no urgency because the project is not even needed

Similar wording

um to go there um allison can you go down a little bit further i'd just like to i'm sorry

Similar wording

chair this is for you guys we need for i'm sorry tanya yeah no sir i'm just i apologize for the

Similar wording

interruption i just wanted to make everyone aware that um we do have others waiting some who have to

Similar wording

go to lerp as well and we do have four other hands up to testify for this particular case

Similar wording

just to make you aware to you tanya can you hear me ma'am with all due respect you have said

Similar wording

repeatedly you talk about the traffic about you know i haven't even begun to talk about the oh

Similar wording

I think you have. With all due respect, you've talked about the traffic, about I-76. This is a thoroughfare to I-76 and other points. Would you please summarize so we can get to the other witnesses? Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay. Mr. Chair, we have been on this line since 9.30. This is the fourth time that we've had to do this.

Similar wording

And we moved.

Similar wording

We should make our case.

Similar wording

I need one at a time. I need one at a time, please, for the accuracy of the record. Thank you.

Similar wording

And we have moved other cases that are ahead of you to get to your case first.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And I just please ask that we now be allowed to present our case because we've been very

Similar wording

indulgent listening to other people test to present for hours.

Similar wording

Our case is not about that house.

Similar wording

It is about what the proposed project is going to, how it is going to impact the overall

Similar wording

community.

Similar wording

And next to Worcester Street, and as you can see where the yellow building is on the first

Similar wording

and the above picture is a residential block of Elkins Avenue.

Similar wording

They too can only exit their block by entering onto Worcester Street.

Similar wording

And they are literally entrapped in their block as they're trying to get out.

Similar wording

There's no right of way. And Worcester Street, as you can see from the photos, backs up and there's no right of way.

Similar wording

This corridor cannot handle any further traffic, any further traffic in this area.

Similar wording

It is posing a hardship and endangerment to not just the immediate neighbors, but it is endangering the rest of the community that has to navigate around this.

Similar wording

The Penn area neighbors have agreed to this.

Similar wording

The Bellfield area neighbors have agreed to this.

Similar wording

LaSalle University is strongly concerned about this.

Similar wording

And I'd like to just show you some of the things that are going on that you asked me,

Similar wording

what were the concerns with the other concerns about this project?

Similar wording

So let's just move off of traffic and go down to the next picture, please.

Similar wording

Can you go down to the next picture, Allison?

Similar wording

I'm going.

Similar wording

Okay, I'm sorry.

Similar wording

All right. You're somewhere in between. Go back. Okay. Okay. How many? You're going kind of fast. Okay. Go back. Go back. Okay. Stop. Stop there.

Similar wording

Okay, so this is the intersection of Worcester and Armstrong Street, the corner, the exact property that is being proposed for this use.

Similar wording

As you can see, the cars park all along the corridor, this parking all along the side of the property.

Similar wording

This is essential parking.

Similar wording

There is hardly any parking on that block already.

Similar wording

There are apartments to the point of hazardous saturation, and they park everywhere, anywhere, because there is no place else to.

Similar wording

and they park everywhere, anywhere, because there is no place else to put another car or another

Similar wording

human being. The picture to the right is, in fact, cars trying to jump off of Armstrong Street

Similar wording

into the Worcester Street traffic, and at the bottom of the hill is Belfield Avenue. These

Similar wording

pictures were taken at around 11 o'clock in the afternoon, I mean in the morning, and the traffic

Similar wording

was that bad at that time of day.

Similar wording

So you can only imagine that multiplied

Similar wording

by rush hour traffic and cars coming in

Similar wording

and out of that corridor.

Similar wording

It is simply not,

Similar wording

it is going to present a hazard to the community.

Similar wording

Go down one more picture, please.

Similar wording

Again, here are the oncoming cars.

Similar wording

And as you can see in the rear, the trees,

Similar wording

that that is the proposed location for this new condo development and next to it is the residential

Similar wording