civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 6, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 6, 20255h 46m

is the entrance there what's the purpose of the full kitchen in the basement equal

Similar wording

¿Cuál es el propósito de la cocina entera en el sótano?

Similar wording

No hay cocina en el baño, hay laundry.

Similar wording

So there's not a kitchen in the basement, it's a laundry.

Similar wording

Laundry con el baño y como para meter en cosas.

Similar wording

So laundry with the bathroom and a storage.

Similar wording

The plan shows a full kitchen.

Similar wording

En los planos enseña una cocina entera.

Similar wording

No, porque esos son los planos viejos.

Similar wording

So those were the old plans. Let me show you the new plans.

Similar wording

So this is the basement. That's where the washer and dryer and the bathroom is.

Similar wording

it shows a full kitchen

Similar wording

so i don't know why he added that um but uh right now it just has to wash her in the dryer

Similar wording

and I could take pictures of that if need be.

Similar wording

Well, we should have had pictures today.

Similar wording

Así que debió de haber tenido las fotos hoy.

Similar wording

¿Me pueden dar otra cita?

Similar wording

Would it be possible to have another appointment?

Similar wording

Not my call.

Similar wording

Así que esa era mi decisión.

Similar wording

You know, what we can do is we're going to have one more resumptive hearing.

Similar wording

We have to have photos of the basement to make sure because initially you were asking for three units and now you're down to two.

Similar wording

So we've got to ensure that there is no household living in that basement.

Similar wording

OK, así que lo que podemos hacer es programar otra reunión de resoluciones, este porque inicialmente usted había solicitado para tres unidades y ahora de dos unidades, así que necesitamos imágenes del sótano para asegurarnos que no es vivible en eso, esa parte.

Similar wording

So we will have a resumptive hearing on this, November 18th, 25, at 9.30 a.m.

Similar wording

Así que vamos a tener una reunión de resolución en Noviembre 18, 2025, a las 9.30 de la mañana.

Similar wording

Interpreter, thank you very much.

Similar wording

And sorry, I didn't notice that and I didn't want to waste anyone's time.

Similar wording

All right. Well, we will see you in November. Thank you.

Similar wording

All right. Well, we will see you in November. Thank you.

Similar wording

Así que lo veremos en noviembre.

Similar wording

Okay, gracias.

Similar wording

Thank you, interpreter. As usual, we really appreciate your help.

Similar wording

No problem. Is there any other matter that requires interpretation?

Similar wording

We do have another matter, but I think we have another interpreter.

Similar wording

But if you could just stand by for a moment. Thank you.

Similar wording

We're going to go to number five, right, Hillary?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Number five, MI 2024-006-024-4918 Ellis Street.

Similar wording

Joseph Consul is the attorney.

Similar wording

Mr. Consul, we'll be coming back in as a panel shortly.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Mr. Consul, just for the record, could you state your name as Bellford's stenographer?

Similar wording

Yeah, it's attorney Joseph Consul.

Similar wording

That's C-O-N-S-O-L-E.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Would you identify your client, a relationship to the property?

Similar wording

Yeah, my client is Yublinka Mercado, the owner of the property.

Similar wording

Or board member Tanetta Graham has a few questions.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Have you submitted your documents five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And do you waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

You can share your screen.

Similar wording

I believe I already am.

Similar wording

Is it up?

Similar wording

Yeah, Mr. Chair, we do have another interpreter for this case, Lionel.

Similar wording

Steven, what's the name of our interpreter?

Similar wording

Lionel is the other interpreter that we have.

Similar wording

So, Mr. Albain, thank you.

Similar wording

I think we're all set.

Similar wording

No problem.

Similar wording

Thank you for using the service, interpreter disconnecting.

Similar wording

okay will the other spanish interpreter please raise the virtual hand wait to be sworn in

Similar wording

they should be coming back in right now sir

Similar wording

good morning everybody um yes can you hear me now can you see me now we can could you please

Similar wording

state your name and spell for the stenographer yes my name is leonel spelled as an l-e-o-n-e-l

Similar wording

last name is gillen g-u-i-l-l-e-n you soundly swear affirm that you will interpret accurately

Similar wording

completely and impartially from english to spanish and from spanish to english to the

Similar wording

best of your ability i swear could you please call you belka and the lease and the lease yes

Similar wording

sorry and the lease moving está en audiencia uh belka angelis

Similar wording

esta en audiencia belka angelis this is the interpreter would you like me to state the

Similar wording

address for 918 l street please 4918 l street thank you uh belka angelis de la dirección

Similar wording

I believe my client raised their hand.

Similar wording

Can you raise your hand, please?

Similar wording

Can my client raise your hand, please?

Similar wording

Jason, are we here?

Similar wording

yeah but they could decline the uh the decline to uh become panelists

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

sorry it was a bit uh hard in order to turn on the mic

Similar wording

Could you ask her to state her name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Muy bien, ¿me puede decir su nombre y deletrearlo, por favor, para el estonógrafo?

Similar wording

Yubelka Andeliz, Y-U-B-E-L-K-A, apellido Andeliz, A-N-T-E-L-I-Z.

Similar wording

Yes, it's Yubelka, spelled Y-U-B-E-L-K-A, and Deliz spelled A-N as in Nancy, D as in Denver, E-L-I-Z.

Similar wording

Could you please ask her, do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

¿Cura decir la verdad, toda la verdad y nada más que la verdad?

Similar wording

Sí.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay, counsel, could you proceed?

Similar wording

good morning board my name is joseph console i'm here today

Similar wording

Good morning, board. My name is Joseph Consul. I'm here today representing the property owner of 4918 Ella Street. We're seeking a variance for the proposed use of this existing structure as a two-family household living space.

Similar wording

Muy bien, muy buenos días

Similar wording

todos los miembros de la Junta

Similar wording

mi nombre es, yo soy el abogado

Similar wording

Joseph Consol y represento

Similar wording

a la propietaria

Similar wording

del terreno

Similar wording

a la dueña del terreno y estamos

Similar wording

buscando una varianza

Similar wording

para la

Similar wording

propuesta

Similar wording

una propuesta de varianza

Similar wording

en el uso de

Similar wording

la propiedad 4918

Similar wording

calle L Street

Similar wording

where is it to have a structure for

Similar wording

use of two families?

Similar wording

of support from 14 near neighbors.

Similar wording

los planes arquitectónicos

Similar wording

un documento

Similar wording

donde muestra

Similar wording

que están todos los impuestos

Similar wording

pagados

Similar wording

también una

Similar wording

petición certificada

Similar wording

de aproximadamente

Similar wording

14 vecinos

Similar wording

próximos

Similar wording

the councilwoman in non-opposition oh great uh we all i did not receive it we did we also received

Similar wording

a letter of non-opposition from the city councilwoman okay muy bien y también tenemos una

Similar wording

carta de no oposición de la consejera de la ciudad the property is zoned rsa 5 we are seeking

Similar wording

to convert the lower level into a separate private one-bedroom apartment, which will

Similar wording

encompass an alteration area of 590 square feet. The basement unit will have several above-grade

Similar wording

windows, two above-grade egresses, a dedicated parking space accessible from the rear,

Similar wording

and a separate meter as the photos will show this basement space while it's basement in the front

Similar wording

it's above grade and ground level in the rear not an underground basement muy bien entonces

Similar wording

esto usted va a notar de que esta propiedad actualmente es un rsa rsa 5 y nosotros buscamos

Similar wording

convertir los niveles inferiores

Similar wording

en una propiedad

Similar wording

separada, privada

Similar wording

un apartamento

Similar wording

de una habitación

Similar wording

buscamos hacer esa alteración de una área

Similar wording

total de 595 pies

Similar wording

vamos a agregar

Similar wording

algunas ventanas

Similar wording

vamos a tener también que están

Similar wording

sobre los niveles

Similar wording

y también

Similar wording

unas salidas y un parqueo

Similar wording

exclusivo

Similar wording

que se ingresaría a través

Similar wording

de la parte trasera

Similar wording

y un metro

Similar wording

adicional también así como

Similar wording

se pueden

Similar wording

también vamos a mostrar también fotografías

Similar wording

del sótano

Similar wording

que por enfrente se ve como sótano

Similar wording

pero por atrás es en la

Similar wording

parte de arriba

Similar wording

del nivel del suelo

Similar wording

Thank you. We have engaged extensively with the community regarding this application. A public meeting was held on December 19th of 2024 with the new 42nd Democratic Ward RCO. We received a strong letter of support approving the project.

Similar wording

uh furthermore we have collected 14 petitions of support from the the neighbors um including

Similar wording

the adjacent neighbors and many others who reside on ellis street itself or immediately adjacent

Similar wording

streets um and actually i'll stop there muy bien y también

Similar wording

Actually, I'll stop there.

Similar wording

También tenemos una carta de apoyo de 14 vecinos que viven aledaños a la propiedad en L Street.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

The apartment is specifically being renovated to create a caretaker space for the owner's mother,

Similar wording

ensuring that the property can best meet the needs of its occupants.

Similar wording

Eubelka has owned the property since October 28, 2005, demonstrating a longstanding commitment to this neighborhood.

Similar wording

We acknowledge that there are open violations from last July, which arose from work initiated by a contractor hired by the owner.

Similar wording

However, once the owner was notified that the contractor was proceeding without obtaining the necessary approvals,

Similar wording

As you'll see in the photos, all construction was immediately halted. I was hired and we've been moving forward since that date to legalize this property by getting architecturals, submitting them and coming through the zoning process.

Similar wording

And, well, the apartment has the idea of making renovations to be able to create an area to take care of the mother of the owner, to be able to fulfill the needs that she has.

Similar wording

Uvelka has been owner of this property since October 28th of 2005, demonstrating a high commitment to this vecindario.

Similar wording

Si estamos de acuerdo de que tenemos violaciones abiertas desde el desde el desde el julio pasado, ya que huelca contra contrató a un contratista y una vez que se le notificó que el contratista estaba trabajando sin los permisos necesarios, toda construcción se detuvo, como lo lo van a poder ver en las fotografías.

Similar wording

y en ese caso se me contrató

Similar wording

y desde entonces hemos estado avanzando

Similar wording

para poder legalizar

Similar wording

los planes arquitectónicos

Similar wording

y para poder proceder

Similar wording

en este procedimiento

Similar wording

Is there any way you can show

Similar wording

the drawings while you're talking?

Similar wording

Oh yes, yeah absolutely, I was just about to comment

Similar wording

that it's a little difficult for me to

Similar wording

go back and forth with the translator

Similar wording

and flip through like I normally do

Similar wording

so I was gonna see if you wanted

Similar wording

me to pause and show anything

Similar wording

okay i'm gonna hit a few more points and please bear with me okay the existing structure particularly

Similar wording

the ground level basement with its independent access and sufficient light and air presents

Similar wording

unique physical circumstances that make it suitable for a separate dwelling unit without external

Similar wording

The proposed alteration, one more sentence, is a thoughtful adaptation representing the minimum variance necessary to afford relief and permit a reasonable use as a caretaker space for the owner's mother.

Similar wording

Muy bien, la estructura actual existente que es un sótano pero está a nivel de piso provee suficiente luz y es un espacio y una entrada aparte y puede es es útil es adecuado para proveer un espacio de vivienda para ser adaptado para cumplir las necesidades de la madre para para que se pueda

Similar wording

actuar como cuidador de la madre there are uh precedent for um duplex adaptations on this block

Similar wording

three have been approved since the 1960s uh it appears that 4924 ella is the only one that is

Similar wording

still active as such furthermore as the aerial photos in our packet will demonstrate the rear

Similar wording

of the properties on this block about a non-residential lot used for what appears to be

Similar wording

vehicle storage, which indicates a mixed-use context directly adjacent to these properties.

Similar wording

Since 1960, there have been three approbations.

Similar wording