civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - June 30, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jun 30, 20217h 12m

and uh the two witnesses yeah i think we ain't gonna have time to hear them today

Similar wording

in the interest of time we got more cases that we gotta uh uh here so more likely this case will

Similar wording

be continued okay so mr demarco you say you got a few more minutes or yeah i only have a few more

Similar wording

a few more questions for Mr. Jenkins. So the question, want me to continue? I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Go ahead. All right. So Mr. Jenkins, the people who don't, who have that history that you say

Similar wording

that you'll, you'll be checking for that and you're not, you don't plan on serving those

Similar wording

individuals, they will then be rejected from the program into the neighborhood. Isn't that right?

Similar wording

Well, these are people already in the neighborhood. So they're, you know, they're just going to be

Similar wording

rejected from the program they can still come to our evening meals they can still receive services

Similar wording

but as far as housing if they've been at another facility somewhere and just say worst case

Similar wording

scenarios it might staff someone okay we're not going to have them stay here especially if it

Similar wording

OK, we're not going to have them stay here, especially if it happened, you know, if something happened maybe 20 years ago, they haven't had any incidents since then.

Similar wording

happened you know if something happened

Similar wording

We don't know what really happened. That's one thing.

Similar wording

But if someone has been in the facility over the last few years and something has happened that has caused a violent incident to occur at another facility, we're not going to allow them to stay there.

Similar wording

OK, and then they'll just walk out and go into the neighborhood, right?

Similar wording

Well, the reality is we have 120 people that come for a meal during the evenings,

Similar wording

and they go right back into the neighborhood, and they're already in the neighborhood.

Similar wording

So they're just going back to where they already were.

Similar wording

Is that the same with individuals who would test for actively using drugs or alcohol?

Similar wording

That would be the same scenario, would it not?

Similar wording

That is correct.

Similar wording

If anybody is chronically active, but the thing is that it's not just releasing them out into the community.

Similar wording

it's then finding services that fit their need because there are drug treatment centers that

Similar wording

people can go to and we do have folks that we deal with and collaborate with to make sure that they

Similar wording

can be placed in those programs we also work very well with the city outstreet's team um in

Similar wording

philadelphia and uh and get which is through self-help and those folks are also um receive

Similar wording

placement as well so it's not like they we're not just dumping them out in the street you can't we

Similar wording

can't help you at all um no we're going to make sure that people get services if we can get them

Similar wording

there. Mr. Jenkins, I'm almost done. I thank you for your time. I'll put the site plan up on the

Similar wording

screen. You don't show the number of bathrooms or the number of shower stalls in your floor plan

Similar wording

for this use, correct? Sure. So the bathroom, there's a men's room off of the bedroom there

Similar wording

That does have two urinals and one bathroom stall.

Similar wording

And I want to emphasize, too, is that this...

Similar wording

So three total?

Similar wording

Three total?

Similar wording

Excuse me, Counselor.

Similar wording

That's a building code issue.

Similar wording

The number of bathrooms is a building code issue.

Similar wording

But he's asking you for variants.

Similar wording

I think you might want to know how many bathrooms there are going to be for 40 people.

Similar wording

Okay, that's fine.

Similar wording

Ellen, I will make sure of that.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right, that might be it, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

Hold on, let me just.

Similar wording

Oh, is there going to be some security, Mr. Jenkins?

Similar wording

You're going to have cameras?

Similar wording

Yes, there are security cameras actually throughout the entire building.

Similar wording

We'll be adding four additional ones for that particular room.

Similar wording

And if there's a fire, how do these people get out of the basement?

Similar wording

Who's going to help people, make sure people get out safely?

Similar wording

Overnight, there's going to be a minimum two people that are there.

Similar wording

And then upon their entry, they have four staff members.

Similar wording

And also upon their exit, there's four staff members.

Similar wording

When I'm saying entry and exit, the time that they come, there will be four people there.

Similar wording

Time that they leave, there's four people there.

Similar wording

So during their waking hours, there's four staff.

Similar wording

During their sleeping hours, there's two staff.

Similar wording

but um well on your plan where where would these people be in this on their on your floor plan

Similar wording

i'm sorry to interrupt here but um if i could call time on this one we still have a couple cases to

Similar wording

hear all right and we're going beyond the time okay gosh thank you chair sorry to interrupt

Similar wording

thank you yes that was my last question mr chairman would be where the staff would be to

Similar wording

help people get out in the event of an emergency in a basement like this. Okay. So I don't see it

Similar wording

on the floor plan. You want me to answer that real quickly? Please. Okay, there's an open area there.

Similar wording

That is where the staff would be. All right, I'm finished. Thank you for it. Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you. So, guys, calendar number, for this case here, calendar number MI2020-002583, 3959 Lancaster Avenue. We'll do a resumption hearing on August 3rd at 9.30 a.m. Okay? August 3rd at 9.30 a.m. Good luck.

Similar wording

9.30, thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You're welcome.

Similar wording

Calendar number MI 2020-00012, 7158 Charisdell Avenue.

Similar wording

mr young has been promoted to panelists thank you

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Mr. Young, please identify yourself for the record.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, members of the board.

Similar wording

My name is Jeffrey Young.

Similar wording

Here on behalf of the applicant, Pastor Jay Monbram, my address is 3900 Ford Road, Suite

Similar wording

B Philadelphia PA 19131. Can you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth for nothing but

Similar wording

the truth? Yes I do. And Q do you agree to waive the reading of its refusal and stipulate to its

Similar wording

accuracy? I agree to waive the reading however I cannot stipulate to its accuracy which I will

Similar wording

get into in the presentation. Okay have you emailed an exhibit packet with the required documents

Similar wording

Proof of ownership, proof of tax compliance, copy of the refusal or referral, photos and

Similar wording

plans five days prior to this hearing?

Similar wording

It has been emailed, but I don't believe it was five days.

Similar wording

I believe it was three days before.

Similar wording

Sharon, you...

Similar wording

Is he able to...

Similar wording

That is your call, Sharon.

Similar wording

Was you able to, Shannon was, is everything in the, in the FOB?

Similar wording

Yes, we have everything at this point.

Similar wording

Council

Similar wording

I believe

Similar wording

last time you was in front of us

Similar wording

I guess

Similar wording

you didn't submit the right timing

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

I'm going to let

Similar wording

we're going to proceed this time

Similar wording

but next time please try to have them

Similar wording

five days in advance okay

Similar wording

please proceed

Similar wording

mr chairman i believe he froze

Similar wording

i'm sorry can you guys hear me go ahead okay um i'm sorry i my uh it blacked out so i didn't hear

Similar wording

um anything okay so i was saying that the last time you came in front of this board

Similar wording

you have submitted your uh your documents late as well okay

Similar wording

so we're going to let you slide this time but next time try to have them on

Similar wording

just so we could have time to review them okay thank you

Similar wording

uh mr jeffrey young this is tanya sunkett if i could request that you stop your video

Similar wording

and maybe that might um have a bearing on your um sound because we keep losing you

Similar wording

um so you can stop your video and the chair has allowed you to proceed so you can share

Similar wording

your screen now thank you my um zoom webinar says not responding at the moment okay here

Similar wording

we go now i'm back um i will stop the video and i'll share my screen all righty

Similar wording

i apologize for the technical issues but my zoom webinar says not responding yeah i'm not getting

Similar wording

i'm trying to stop your video on my end as well and it's not working um so we're gonna push this

Similar wording

back one let's move into the next case if that's all right okay sounds good with me chair okay

Similar wording

calendar number mi2020-001-196-7424 reverie street how are you working this entire time

Similar wording

Um, wow, this is crazy.

Similar wording

Mr. Jeffrey Young, we still hear you.

Similar wording

So I'm suggesting that you disconnect and reconnect.

Similar wording

Raise your hand.

Similar wording

We'll promote you again and try again.

Similar wording

But when we promote you, if you could leave your video off, only use your audio.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you, because it's stuck on our end as well.

Similar wording

I'm sorry chair you can continue. Okay calendar number MI 2020-001-196-7424

Similar wording

Reverie Street.

Similar wording

anyone else anyone here for this case mr jen's been a promoter to panelists

Similar wording

i'm sorry um i i actually raised my hand because i thought i was next for i'm sorry i'm sorry my

Similar wording

apologies i'm sorry jason the gentleman who should be going forward hand is raised

Similar wording

Mr. Zeng is the last case.

Similar wording

Yeah, sorry about that.

Similar wording

No worry.

Similar wording

Mr. Zeng, if you could sit tight, we're going to leave you there,

Similar wording

but please keep your video off and your audio off.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Mr. Zeng has been promoted to a panelist.

Similar wording

Please forgive the error.

Similar wording

Hello, sir.

Similar wording

Please identify yourself for the record for your first and last name.

Similar wording

hello yes please identify yourself for the record uh good afternoon i'm zong zang z-o-n-g

Similar wording

z-h-e-n-g uh 74 24 revere street philadelphia pennsylvania 19152 okay uh you swear a firm

Similar wording

to tell the truth the whole truth for nothing but the truth i do are you the owner yes uh

Similar wording

have you met with the RCO? I have. Okay. So, all right. So, have you emailed an exhibit packet

Similar wording

with the required documents, proof of ownership, proof of tax compliance, copy of the refusal or

Similar wording

referral, photos and plans five days prior to this hearing? I have, but might be some missing

Similar wording

documents. I could not get a copy of the tax complaints. Okay. What else?

Similar wording

and and and the letter from the rco i i tried to request that several times but didn't get the

Similar wording

answer sharon was you able did we receive any rco letter i did not receive one but the applicant

Similar wording

really has no control over that i will um look up the tax records for the property okay but if he

Similar wording

did, if you can confirm that he met with the RCO. Sir, who was the community group you met with?

Similar wording

Mayfair Civic Association. Okay. This was back in, I believe, August. Okay, Chair, if you will allow,

Similar wording

I can have the ZBA staff please search our email box for any documents from Mayfair Civic

Similar wording

association or that address but share as you wish we can always move forward um once we get the

Similar wording

information from ms saleta yep okay sir please proceed okay um uh you want me to screen share

Similar wording

sir yes please you got any plans okay i'm sorry here i'm very new to this uh not sure what am i

Similar wording

doing here um no problem sir i'll walk you through if you look at the bottom of your screen are you

Similar wording

on the computer yes if you look at the green button that says share okay you're going to click

Similar wording

on that with your documents already open and thereafter click on the documents you wish to

Similar wording

share. Is it showing? Nope.

Similar wording

there you go okay okay before you go on chair i can um confirm that the property is tax compliant

Similar wording

thank you sir please proceed okay so uh i'm here to get a um approval to uh build this carport um

Similar wording

uh behind um uh 7424 revere street uh i have a refusal letter um if i pull it up here

Similar wording

sorry

Similar wording

okay so the reason of refusal because of the size of um where it meets my neighbors

Similar wording

where it meets my neighbors for the carport.

Similar wording

for the carport.

Similar wording

It's required to be eight feet in width.

Similar wording

But I only have 0.5 feet for where it meets my neighbor's property line.

Similar wording

Let's see if I can pull up the...

Similar wording

Excuse me, this is Sharon again.

Similar wording

And the RCO did not send the letter to me, but they did send it to the RCO ZBA mailbox, and the position was they opposed.

Similar wording

They opposed, okay. Thank you.

Similar wording

Can you show us the picture, sir?

Similar wording

The picture for the carport?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Is it Sonja?

Similar wording

Is that it?

Similar wording

Is it billed already or that's it?

Similar wording

It's as it is right now.

Similar wording

is it a carport or a garage it's a carport uh carports only have roof

Similar wording

no sides no sides okay roof is all a carport has okay yeah i was not uh aware of that

Similar wording

so this can i show you like the picture of uh what the dimension

Similar wording

of um

Similar wording

so if i if i if i um don't

Similar wording

put a solid

Similar wording

sidewalls

Similar wording

is that

Similar wording

would that meet the requirement of

Similar wording

carport as like this

Similar wording

I don't know if you can see that

Similar wording

whose carport is that

Similar wording

oh I just googled it

Similar wording

this is what I was

Similar wording

my goal was

Similar wording

well you see the wall down to the ground

Similar wording

but you need more opening in the side walls okay

Similar wording

but i doesn't believe you are the five the eight foot distance from the property line

Similar wording

Yes, I don't see how I'm going to do an 8-foot from the properly line when I have only, let me see here, if I meet 8-foot from each of my neighbors from left and right, I'm only left with maybe a 5-foot carport.

Similar wording