civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - November 10, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Nov 10, 20216h 2m

Thank you.

Similar wording

.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Welcome back everyone, it is now 4.05 p.m., Carol, are you available?

Similar wording

Yes, I am.

Similar wording

Okay, Jim, Tom, and confessor, let's see, I didn't see you, Tom, are you signed on yet?

Similar wording

try it again i don't see confessor is uh is jim snell available uh no chair i'll reach out to

Similar wording

him remember confessor had to leave all right yeah i'm sorry you didn't thank you

Similar wording

yes jim jim's there we got it yes okay jim thank you

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

And Tom.

Similar wording

Tom Holloman.

Similar wording

I think everybody got confused with last week.

Similar wording

Chair, I couldn't reach him at the moment, but I believe we now have a quorum.

Similar wording

Yes, we do.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Pauline, we're ready to go live.

Similar wording

okay sir you're set to go thank you and uh staff will let us know when you're ready

Similar wording

we're ready chair thank you good afternoon everyone my name is frank de chico i'm the

Similar wording

chair of the zoning board of adjustment i'll be participating in today's hearing along with our

Similar wording

vice chair ms carol tenere and board member mr james snell i anticipate board member mr

Similar wording

holliman will be joining us shortly present mr holliman mr james no present i'm present

Similar wording

all right i got ahead of everybody uh also our board administrator ms lakeisha dandy and our

Similar wording

board attorney ms melissa freeman are also in attendance as is our zoning board administrator

Similar wording

ms tanya sunkett for those of you who haven't yet participated in one of our virtual hearings

Similar wording

i'll go through some of the basics of what you can expect first we will be administering oaths

Similar wording

to individual participants prior to their testimony second we'd like to advise everyone

Similar wording

that this proceeding is being recorded and that by participating you acknowledge your agreement

Similar wording

to be recorded and also that the recording will be made available to the public by contacting

Similar wording

Ms. Tanya Sunket at tanya.sunket at phila.gov. For anyone participating by phone, if you

Similar wording

wish to testify, you must raise your hand by hitting star 9 and then star 6 to unmute

Similar wording

yourself pardon me i'll repeat for anyone participating

Similar wording

pardon me i'll repeat for anyone participating by phone if you wish to testify you must raise

Similar wording

your hand by hitting star nine and then star six to unmute yourself finally to enter an appearance

Similar wording

statement call google 267-270-5548 and leave your email address and the address of the property at

Similar wording

issue. I will repeat that. For anyone participating, excuse me, for anyone who would like to make an

Similar wording

appearance statement, call Google number 267-270-5548 and leave your email address and

Similar wording

the address of the property at issue. I would also like to remind everyone, please do not attempt

Similar wording

to testify in the chat. Comments, questions, or concerns should be directed to our board

Similar wording

Administrator, Ms. Dandy. Having said that, there are no requests on the 330 list for continuance

Similar wording

or withdrawals at this time for me, but I will ask that question. Would anyone like to request

Similar wording

a continuance or withdrawal on the 330 list? Please raise your hand. If you're requesting

Similar wording

a continuance or withdrawal please raise your hand chair we have natasha bass miss bass you

Similar wording

can unmute yourself and wait for the chair good afternoon ma'am please spell your full name and i'll

Similar wording

where are you in? Ms. Bass? Ms. Bass, are you out there?

Similar wording

She's unmuted. I don't know why. There's no. Yeah, I see that. I see her hand up, not muted.

Similar wording

all right let's move on and she if she has anything she'll come back anyone requesting a

Similar wording

continuance or withdrawal no more hands at this time chair miss bass i see your hand up again

Similar wording

are you miss bass

Similar wording

well miss bass hello yes please miss bass spell your first and last name please

Similar wording

yes n-a-t-a-s-h-a last name b-a-s-s you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and

Similar wording

nothing but the truth yes i do and you're calling regarding uh my property at 630 north 55th street

Similar wording

philadelphia pennsylvania 19131 i wanted to request a continuous because as i'm listening

Similar wording

you guys are asking about um there was supposed to be a package submitted five days prior

Similar wording

and I submitted documents

Similar wording

during the beginning

Similar wording

of the process, but I

Similar wording

didn't email you guys anything

Similar wording

recently.

Similar wording

Okay, we'll continue their case.

Similar wording

All right?

Similar wording

Right now or

Similar wording

in the future? We're going to continue it.

Similar wording

You'll get a date.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you, Emma.

Similar wording

Pardon me?

Similar wording

In an email?

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you so much.

Similar wording

thank you MI 2021-002463 630 north 55th street is continued must be heard

Similar wording

any other requests for continuances or withdrawals on the 330 list

Similar wording

and no more handshare thank you we're going to go to case number five

Similar wording

to the board because we have an interpreter

Similar wording

pardon me case number five is mi 2021 that's zero zero two five three five three six two east

Similar wording

wyoming avenue i'm not going to attempt to to uh pronounce the last the name of the individual

Similar wording

um councilwoman sanchez sent a letter of non-opposition

Similar wording

she refers to the rco letter of support so amparo i don't know how to pronounce your last name if

Similar wording

you're out there please raise your hand or whomever is testifying in this case

Similar wording

and they're coming in now as a panelist thank you

Similar wording

Hi, Chair, this is Tanya, the ZBA administrator. If I could state that Ilana Ponce is the

Similar wording

interpreter now available as a panelist, if she could be sworn in as well. Thank you.

Similar wording

Yes, I had that on my list. Okay. Ms. Ponce, we just spell your full name and I'll swear you in.

Similar wording

Yes, I had that on my list. Okay. Ms. Ponce, we just

Similar wording

Sure. I-L-A-N-A. Last name P-O-N-C-E.

Similar wording

You swear for him to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you. Just stand by and you are the interpreter, correct?

Similar wording

I am.

Similar wording

Thank you. Is the applicant available?

Similar wording

Si. Estoy aquí.

Similar wording

Amparo, so Ms. Ponce, I'm going to ask him to spell his full name so you can help us

Similar wording

with that.

Similar wording

Que si, por favor, puede letrar su nombre completo?

Similar wording

Es Rafael Cabrera Delgado.

Similar wording

Amparo Echavarría era la antigua dueña.

Similar wording

Ya va, señor.

Similar wording

So my name is Rafael Cabrera Amparo, and Amparo was the last owner.

Similar wording

R-A-F-A-E-L

Similar wording

C-A-B-R-E-R-A

Similar wording

He's where and affirmed to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

Señor, ¿usted jura decir la verdad y nada más la verdad hoy?

Similar wording

Sí.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Ms. Ponce, the vice chair will have some questions for Mr. Ponce, not Mr. Ponce, for Rafael.

Similar wording

Señor Rafael, tiene unas preguntas para usted.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay, good afternoon.

Similar wording

I'm sorry. I apologize. I keep interrupting. I feel so bad.

Similar wording

But can I just ask, Chair, where were the exhibits sit?

Similar wording

Ms. Potts, if you can ask that question.

Similar wording

Señor, si puede mostrar los exhibits que va a presentar hoy.

Similar wording

Okay, ustedes pueden agregar a la señora Melissa Cadillo para compartir la pantalla.

Similar wording

Could you add

Similar wording

Ms. Melissa Cadillo

Similar wording

so she can share her screen?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Meditza Cadillo?

Similar wording

Meditza Cadillo.

Similar wording

Who was she?

Similar wording

No, she's an

Similar wording

expeditor.

Similar wording

It has to be

Similar wording

Mr. Cabrera or an attorney.

Similar wording

No, Sr. Cabrera.

Similar wording

Tiene que ser usted o un abogado.

Similar wording

No, yo lo voy a

Similar wording

presentar. Yo lo que quiero que

Similar wording

le permitan entrar

Similar wording

para que ella me comparta la pantalla.

Similar wording

O sea, es la pantalla nada más.

Similar wording

I'm going to be the one presenting.

Similar wording

She has the screen that I need you to

Similar wording

have her be able to share.

Similar wording

First, we need to know

Similar wording

where were the exhibits

Similar wording

that are required

Similar wording

were emailed because we do not

Similar wording

have a record.

Similar wording

Necesitan saber

Similar wording

a dónde mandaron el correo electrónico

Similar wording

de los exhibits.

Similar wording

They sent it to RCO and Zuleta.

Similar wording

So, this is Tanya again. We have no record, neither I or Salada or RCO. If we could request the forwarded email sent to us again to review and share, if it's okay with you, we'd like to move on to another case.

Similar wording

que nadie tiene eso

Similar wording

si por favor se lo puede mandar otra vez

Similar wording

que le pueda hacer

Similar wording

un favor

Similar wording

we're going to have to continue

Similar wording

this case Ms. Ponce

Similar wording

van a tener que

Similar wording

seguir este caso en otro momento

Similar wording

yo tengo ya

Similar wording

si me dan dos minutos

Similar wording

ya yo tengo como

Similar wording

seis meses esperando por este

Similar wording

por este meeting

Similar wording

Could I have two minutes, because I've been waiting for this for six months?

Similar wording

Two minutes for what purpose?

Similar wording

To talk to his expediter?

Similar wording

Para hablar con la señora?

Similar wording

No, lo que pasa es que tuve que tener un meeting con la comunidad y todo eso, por eso duró tanto tiempo.

Similar wording

No, it took a long time because I had to wait to meet with the community and all.

Similar wording

We understand that, but either he or he relied on his expediter did not follow through on providing us with the exhibits that are necessary for us to conduct a hearing.

Similar wording

So we must continue this case.

Similar wording

Entonces necesitan seguir este caso en otro momento.

Similar wording

Okay, what date could that be?

Similar wording

Okay, what date could that be?

Similar wording

Well, that'll come forward later, Mr. Sunkit.

Similar wording

Well, that'll come forward later.

Similar wording

Mr. Sunkit will advise him of a date.

Similar wording

So for the purpose of the record, MI 2021, that is 002-535-362 East Wyoming Avenue is continued.

Similar wording

Must be heard.

Similar wording

El señor Sunkit le va a dar la fecha en otro momento después de esto.

Similar wording

Okay, también. Muchísimas gracias.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

um i'm sure i would just like to say thank you for miss potts for your interpretation we appreciate

Similar wording

you yeah thank you thank you thank you thank you okay uh we'll go back to case number one

Similar wording

mi 2021-001318 1805 east pass yonk avenue and then in parentheses at 18th and pass yonk

Similar wording

Is that a typo?

Similar wording

Councilman Squilla sent a letter of non-opposition.

Similar wording

Mr. Aaron Matzkin, if you're out there, I think this is a typo.

Similar wording

This probably should be 1805 West Pass Yonk, I believe.

Similar wording

Correct me if I'm wrong.

Similar wording

East Pass Yonk Crossing sent a letter of support.

Similar wording

those councilman Squilla and East Pass Yunk Crossing represent the west the east side of

Similar wording

Broad Street is Mr. Matzkin available

Similar wording

and there's no hand up at this time chair

Similar wording

okay thank you MI 2021-001318 1805 West Pass Yunk Avenue

Similar wording

this case is continued must be heard it's number two I just want to put on a record inside of the

Similar wording

eclipse database and on the refusal is 1805 East Passion no but the interest

Similar wording

if yeah but you see on the list it says 18th and Passion that would make it the west side

Similar wording

make it the west side right i understood that's the okay i just want to make sure the record is

Similar wording

correct yeah correct all right thank you thank you for clearing that up so it'll be 1805 east

Similar wording

past young cabinet this case is continued must be heard uh case number two mi 2021-001973

Similar wording

2020 North

Similar wording

18th Street

Similar wording

Rachel Pritzker is the Attorney of

Similar wording