civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 20, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 20, 20251h 46m

They have proof that the taxes were paid.

Similar wording

And then we have our deed.

Similar wording

let's take a look at the site itself there are significant vacancies in the area

Similar wording

and this will breathe some new life into that particular property which i think as

Similar wording

you can see it's extraordinarily deep the lot

Similar wording

here are the signatures from neighbors

Similar wording

and please note all of these are from venango

Similar wording

and right around the corner

Similar wording

and here's more

Similar wording

we did meet with the 13th ward we'll get into that in a minute do want to take you through

Similar wording

some of the materials that were submitted this company will have a civil rights

Similar wording

compliance compliance requirements from the heart youth haven is the name of the residential

Similar wording

facility that Ms. Minor

Similar wording

would run.

Similar wording

From page 78, 79

Similar wording

onwards, all of this

Similar wording

to 110 was submitted by my client to the state of Pennsylvania.

Similar wording

Organizational chart, board member guidelines, committed to ensuring that all the staff receive

Similar wording

comprehensive training to provide a safe, nurturing, trauma-informed environment for

Similar wording

youth age 16 to 21. The training plan outlines required initial and ongoing training for

Similar wording

all employees, their specific training goals, their specific training hours, not only for

Similar wording

the director, but for the certified trainers and providers.

Similar wording

That's a pretty comprehensive plan.

Similar wording

There'll be exterior lighting and security cameras.

Similar wording

i'm like you're going to hear testimony from my client that she's been doing this for years

Similar wording

not at this particular site oh and that she's done very well and the the children grow up to

Similar wording

be very successful then we have more uh listing of classifications with the functions

Similar wording

Ms. Minor is my client.

Similar wording

They'll also have a director of programming,

Similar wording

childcare supervisor,

Similar wording

recreation workers.

Similar wording

There are a list of client rights and responsibilities

Similar wording

for each child coming into the facility from the system.

Similar wording

there are formal grievance policies

Similar wording

emergency evacuation plan for the property

Similar wording

and as part of our exhibit packet we also have insurances and all other

Similar wording

relevant information.

Similar wording

With that, I'd like to call my client

Similar wording

Sheree Minor to the stand.

Similar wording

You mentioned you were going to talk about the RCO.

Similar wording

Do you want to have her talk about it?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

I want her to start talking about it.

Similar wording

Okay, sure.

Similar wording

Sheree Minor, if you're in a virtual audience,

Similar wording

Please raise your virtual hand.

Similar wording

They have been promoted to panelists.

Similar wording

Please accept the panelists' promotion.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell it for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

My name is Cherie Miner.

Similar wording

is spelled s-h-a-r-e-e last name minor m-i-n-o-r you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth and nothing but the truth i do please proceed counsel thank you first miss minor

Similar wording

good morning miss minor first i'd like to ask you three uh housekeeping questions to get that out

Similar wording

of the way okay did you hear my presentation to the board this morning i did the true and accurate

Similar wording

to the best of your knowledge. Yes. And do you adopt it as your own testimony? I do. Okay. The

Similar wording

chairman had asked for some insight into your relationship and experience with this particular

Similar wording

RCO. So instead of hearing it from me, I think it's probably best if we put it on the record

Similar wording

from you. Do you mind explaining the experience? Yes, I do. Back in, during my first RCO meeting,

Similar wording

I felt like I was treated unfairly. I was cut off while speaking. And the only person that was entertained was my neighbor who lives next door to me, who's been trying to, I believe it's maybe like a five rooming house or apartments in that house.

Similar wording

And she's just been going around the neighborhood trying to obtain signatures, expressing to people that I am trying to do something other than what I'm trying to do.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Did you say she runs a rooming house?

Similar wording

No, she doesn't run a rooming house.

Similar wording

I believe it's five apartments next door to me.

Similar wording

And she rents a room.

Similar wording

She rents a room there.

Similar wording

I see.

Similar wording

So she's a tenant.

Similar wording

She's a tenant.

Similar wording

in and okay and in the apartment building next door okay yes and during

Similar wording

In and OK. And in the apartment building next door. OK.

Similar wording

Yes. And during the first RCO meeting, I was pretty much cut off several times by her stating that I was trying that the neighbors didn't receive the letters that I was trying to backdoor them.

Similar wording

I tried to offer my number to her. I tried to have a conversation with her, but she was just being unruly.

Similar wording

after the RCO she was allowed to keep cutting me off and anybody that spoke for me

Similar wording

was just kept being was in my favor just kept being placed on mute I mean the neighbors yes

Similar wording

also after the meeting I decided to be proactive and go door to door to obtain to introduce myself

Similar wording

to the neighborhood, explain to them what it is that I was trying to do. And everybody that I met

Similar wording

was for it. Everybody that answered the door was for it. The next day, I got word that she's been

Similar wording

going around the neighborhood getting signatures from different people, especially in the building

Similar wording

across the street in which I obtained signatures for them, for that building. When I tried to go

Similar wording

in and get more signatures. I was just, you have to be buzzed in. And I was just met with so much

Similar wording

resistance from one of her friends. So I decided not to go in that building again. And that's the

Similar wording

address at 2104 West Venango. And you believe the information to obtain those signatures was

Similar wording

based on misinformation about your mission. Is that right? Yeah. Or just her being, she has a

Similar wording

friend that live in that building. And I believe that, you know, she helped her, you know, walk

Similar wording

around well not believe um one someone who's going to speak

Similar wording

um a lot of the you know a lot of the residents feel bad for me she has been nothing but a nuisance

Similar wording

to the neighbor i don't really want to speak about her but this is expected of her and what

Similar wording

about the rco what about and then talk about the rco itself the second time you went uh the the rco

Similar wording

so during the meeting yeah charles corn during the meeting with you i want to say that he was

Similar wording

he wasn't it wasn't like when i was on a meeting with him the first time like i said the first time

Similar wording

he was you know he kind of like scolded me um he kept cutting me off while i was speaking

Similar wording

and he allowed uh the neighbor to do so as well and anybody that was for me you know he kept

Similar wording

cutting them off and putting them putting them on mute did you get a do you think you after two

Similar wording

meetings you got a fair hearing and presentation to the community without any interruption or issues

Similar wording

no thank you now let's talk about your mission because it's important now again the use that

Similar wording

you're proposing is already assumed to be compatible with this property uh the board

Similar wording

just needs to hear that you are professionally going to operate this home and your history

Similar wording

in doing so and your mission. So speak a little bit about that, please. Okay. I've been a foster

Similar wording

parent, a therapeutic foster parent since April 12, 2012, fostering nothing but teenage females

Similar wording

who are currently in DHS care. And that's what I plan to do so in this property as well. I have

Similar wording

I've also been a case manager for over a decade for at-risk youth in the city of Philadelphia.

Similar wording

I also have a letter of support from the director of that agency as well.

Similar wording

The name of my business is From the Heart Youth Haven.

Similar wording

And I actually have a letter that I don't know if you'll mind me reading.

Similar wording

Do you want me to share my screen or?

Similar wording

You could read it into the record. That's fine.

Similar wording

Okay. Okay. So I had, you know, when I was introducing myself, my name is Cherie. I am a passionate advocate for at-risk youth in our community. I have an identical twin sister, Marie Minor, and we are extremely close. For over a decade, my sister and I have been fostering therapeutic teenage girls together.

Similar wording

Growing up within walking distance of 2135 West Venango Street, I witnessed firsthand the challenges faced by our neighborhood's most vulnerable teenagers.

Similar wording

Since April 12th, since April of 2012, I have opened my home and my heart to teenage girls.

Similar wording

My decade-long career as a case manager for juvenile and adult probation has equipped me with the skills and passion to serve youth at risk of violence or drug abuse.

Similar wording

Our city faces a high demand for finding suitable placements for these teens.

Similar wording

Unfortunately, many are left sleeping on cots and floors in the Department of Human Services building,

Similar wording

hoping to find a foster parent like us to take them in.

Similar wording

With no more space left in our home, my sister and I decided to take action to better...

Similar wording

With no more space left in our home, my sister and I decided to take action to better support

Similar wording

teenagers in need. My sister opened a shelter and I opened a group home. This way we can provide a

Similar wording

more suitable living environment for these teenagers until they can find a permanent

Similar wording

placement. Today, I stand before you with a vision to transform these challenges into

Similar wording

opportunities for our youth. Currently, there's over 10,000 youth in the city of Philadelphia

Similar wording

that are homeless and that that's that's facts that's on the city website and i'm looking to

Similar wording

only house nine and it's up to nine in this property thank you thank you miss minor mr

Similar wording

chair at the rco meeting that i attended there was no uh absolutely zero uh testimony or discussion

Similar wording

about this particular operation, about this particular home, and about the care and programming

Similar wording

for these particular girls. It was, it was all about how the, there were complaints about how

Similar wording

the neighbors have had enough of too many people, too many children, and too much crime in the

Similar wording

community. Uh, it, it was, it was a quick de-evalation, uh, uh, into, uh, more of a, uh,

Similar wording

Ad Hahnemann attack on my client. And it ended with a final question from, uh, one of the members

Similar wording

of the committee where they asked, uh, why don't she open up across the street from my own personal

Similar wording

home? Uh, my answer is to her, to that RCO and to this board. If there were a property, uh,

Similar wording

available, I would welcome it. Ms. Minor is nothing but professional. Her vision and materials

Similar wording

speak nothing but professionalism, and her mission is she wants to open her house and her home to

Similar wording

these young girls who just need a chance. This board can give her that opportunity, and I ask

Similar wording

for that today. Thank you. Questions from the board? Yes, I have a question. So the photos that

Similar wording

you showed us were the interior of the property correct yes okay and so what are the plans for

Similar wording

the exterior that's the first question a lot of work go ahead miss minor i have got um i have

Similar wording

gotten siding done on the outside of the property and i plan to maintain uh trash removal and

Similar wording

landscaping and snow okay so my question is what um my other question is so what outdoor space

Similar wording

will be available for the youth,

Similar wording

whether it's in the front or the rear?

Similar wording

There's a large yard in the rear of the property.

Similar wording

The actual lot goes from street to street.

Similar wording

So it's extremely deep, over 100 feet deep.

Similar wording

So it's plenty of yard space.

Similar wording

Ms. Minor even mentioned to me

Similar wording

during one of our conferences

Similar wording

about starting some gardening for the girls as well.

Similar wording

Just show them how to take care of the earth

Similar wording

and take care and grow their own food.

Similar wording

So there's a lot of space back there for them.

Similar wording

And we're going to assume that it's going to be fenced in in the rear.

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

Okay. So in terms of, and this,

Similar wording

I'm asking this question because it's going to have some,

Similar wording

especially the front footage would be something that the neighbors will get

Similar wording

to see. So what's the intent for the front yard of the property?

Similar wording

Just landscaping, you know, investment. It'll, you know,

Similar wording

an investment in the landscaping in the front so that it's a vast

Similar wording

improvement over what it is there now.

Similar wording

Am I still on mute?

Similar wording

Other questions for the board.

Similar wording

Yes, question.

Similar wording

So what age young women are we talking about?

Similar wording

Ms. Minor?

Similar wording

I'm going to do ages 14 to 20.

Similar wording

And the reason being is one girl that I currently have in my care is 19 and she'll be graduating 12th grade this year.

Similar wording

sometimes they'll let um sometimes their parents decide to hold them back or due to their

Similar wording

circumstances they might be held back a grade or two okay so and then how many how many bedrooms

Similar wording

are there or how many how many bedrooms are there in the house let's go back to the plan if you'd

Similar wording

like but go ahead miss minor you can speak while i scroll there's five uh bedrooms okay and you

Similar wording

said that there'll be eight to nine uh young women is that correct what we're talking about

Similar wording

so and then is there how many how many kitchens how many bedrooms one large kitchen is that right

Similar wording

miss minor yes it's one large kitchen i have a picture of that as well if you want me to share

Similar wording

my screen along with a nook set that has a uh in between a dining room in the kitchen

Similar wording

I have built a nook set that has a pull-out microwave, along with a beverage center and a sink.

Similar wording

i have uh built a nook set that has a pull-out microwave along with the bed

Similar wording

Scroll back to the first floor.

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Go ahead, Cheryl.

Similar wording

I just wanted to.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Yeah. So we're going to have basically a communal sort of kitchen experience where we're going to be eating together and that kind of thing.

Similar wording

this is a family okay and then the uh uh are all these uh uh young women going to be in

Similar wording

high school is 14 high school already or how do we will they be going to school yes the answer is

Similar wording

yes they'll be going to school okay and and when they come home they you know there's

Similar wording

the education continues there's help at home this for the first time in their lives they'll have

Similar wording

help at home with with reading writing and arithmetic gotcha okay and then uh where will

Similar wording

these uh young women be coming from i think you said that they were dhs from the okay this is the

Similar wording

Department of, what is it, Human Services? Human Services. These are not kids coming out of

Similar wording

drug and alcohol facilities. These are not kids coming out of the criminal justice system.

Similar wording

These are kids who have no one and they end up in DHS. Okay. And now they'll have Ms. Minor

Similar wording

and her team. And how long, you said you've been doing this since 2012? Is that what I heard?

Similar wording

Yes. Okay. And then what is foster therapeutic care? Can you tell me what that is?

Similar wording

Just children who've been through a lot of challenges in life and are in need of therapy.

Similar wording

So we also have mobile therapists available. We partner with mobile therapists available to be on call to provide them with the therapy that they need.

Similar wording

So they will be having weekly therapy with a therapist because a lot of times when children are placed in the system, it's a high waiting list for it.

Similar wording

Sometimes it's a three to six month waiting list to even be seen by a therapist.

Similar wording