We are actually now, just now, starting to be able to look at recidivism program by program. Up to now, we haven't had that ability, so I can't answer that information. But the work release program over the years has been growing. Those 593 inmates paid in $325,000 in room and board that went back to the City. When they are admitted, some of them have work that they had prior to being arrested, but a large number of them were not working. 00183 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole And the prison has job developers who help them to find work, go out, speak to the employers, make certain that they are where they are supposed to be, try to resolve any work-related problems that might arise. So we're really trying to help them hang on to that work. And the goal is that when they're released, they would stay with that job. But we don't know right now whether or not that's actually happening, Councilman.
And that's something we'll be able to track in the future?
Let me just speak to something that the Commissioner mentioned. With these work release facilities, believe me, this is a political football. And this one -- it's between Erie Avenue, Luzerne, G, and Whittaker. It's a special program. I mean, it's a special area because there's no houses there. And we put a new police station that I picked the location, I'm not ashamed to say, on Whitaker Avenue. Kintock is down the street on 00184 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Whitaker Avenue. The Coleman Center is behind it, and Luzerne is down the street. Now, the feds came around and were looking for something, and we didn't hear anything about them. This is an industrial area where industry is not doing well any more. I mean, the guy in the box factory there hates me, because he blames it all on me, and that's understandable. He was afraid of the prisoners leering at his female employees. And if you ever been to the center, nobody's leering at nobody. There's no time for leering. But what I'm getting at is, you're absolutely right. If we're going to do this, it has to be in the neighborhoods but not in the neighborhoods. Because in Philadelphia right now, there's the housing problems, and everybody's got a reason to be afraid. And people are fleeing and coming back, and, you know, neighborhoods are changing, for the better at most part, but they get worse before they get better. But if we can find locations like this -- I mean, it's up to you, it's what you do. 00185 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole But if there's a causal effect for anyone being incarcerated, and there definitely is, be it drugs, environment, abuse, we have to -- the people that are willing, to accept treatment. I mean, I feel like I'm preaching to the Vatican here. I know you guys know. But if we have to do this to make sure they don't repeat. Now, some people are going to repeat anyhow. But I think by the time you get to a work release facility, it's obvious who the repeaters are going to be, because if you have a choice between being in a work release facility and not, you're not going to want to be in there if you're a scammer. I mean, it's going to be. Easy. But if you're somebody that made a mistake and realizes it, and you see that. So I don't know all the numbers. I'm sure the Controller or someone else, maybe Councilman Nutter, he can do the numbers work. It's probably cheaper in the long run to do these. But it has to be done very gingerly with the help of the District Council people, because I know in this neighborhood, 00186 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole because it's my District and I grew up there, it's really tricky. Now, I can't tell you what Council President Verna or Councilman Blackwell or Nutter have in their District. They may not have areas like that. I'm just fortunate to have old industrial areas that aren't as, you know, successful as they were at one time. I thank you. Thank you for that information.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Commissioner, I did want to ask as a follow-up to the earlier questions, I am trying to understand why or what caused such a significant increase in the prison health services contract from 2002 to 2004 with a more than 50 percent increase. What was the reason?
I'm going to address that question to Miss Steiker from the Managing 00187 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Director's Office.
Just before she begins, you just have to remember, too, that medical services for everybody in the entire country is a cost that always goes up, and it remains that way in the prison. So that's part of the reason.
This is Ellen Steiker, Deputy Managing Director. The actual costs for the year -- for FY '02 was $32.6 million. The amount that we paid P.H.S. for that year was $28 million. They suffered a loss of $4.6 million. So I think it's important for us to distinguish between what it costs the City to provide the services and what it provides -- and what it costs to provide those services in total. The difference between $26 million and --
Well, let's stay on that point. I mean, let's go back. FY '02, you're saying that prison health services costs were $32 million. Is that what you said?
The invoiced cost was 00188 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole $32.6 million.
28 million. The difference between 26, which shows up in the budget documents in the prison's general fund, and 28 million is 2 million of grants funds that's provided through the Health Department.
Right. Now, I mean, we didn't force prison health services to take this contract, right?
They took the contract with their eyes open, and said, we can provide this service. What was the bid amount?
There was a bid for FY '02. I would have to get back to you. It was a lower amount than 28 million. 00189 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole We did add some money for certain things that were unexpected. We negotiated some small increases to get to the 28 million. But I'll get back to you with that amount. It's somewhere between million and million, I believe, that we added.
All right. So their costs in '02 were 32 million. What do you estimate their actual costs will be in '03?
We're estimating that their actual costs will be somewhere between 36 and 37 million. The trends are very positive right now because of the lower population. There's a component of medical costs, such as pharmaceutical costs and the number of hospital days that are related to the population. And with the population being down, we've been seeing a very positive trend. But again, you know, that could turn around in the next few months as the weather gets warmer. So, right now we're predicting somewhere between 36 million and 37 million.
So they had about a 10 percent... a little more than 10 00190 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole percent cost increase to them from '02 to '03. And is that about a percent -- close -- 18 or 4 so percent increase from '03 to '04? Is that 5 fair? 6
From '03 to '04 the 7 major component of the increase is the opening of 8 the women's detention facility. The amount in the 9 budget for that opening is about 3.8 million. 10 Again, we're looking at that very 11 carefully. When that amount was developed, it was 12 at a time when the population was increasing. And 13 the thought was that anybody who had to add would 14 be an increase to the total. 15 At this point, given that the 16 population is lower and we're looking at how, you 17 know, people are being placed in the various 18 units, there's a possibility that there will be 19 some savings against that 3.8 million increase. 20 But that is the major reason for the big increase from '03 to '04.
Well, if you could lay out all of these items in a memo to the President or to the Chair here of the Committee of the Whole, we will all get a copy. We'd all like 00191 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to understand why these costs have been rising at the amounts that they are. Now, let me understand this: What is the situation with regard to the bidding of this particular contract? Councilman Ortiz went over this, and I thought we read some news accounts that seemed to indicate that the contract most recently was not bid, it was just extended. Which is it?
We did solicit bids for the year beginning for FY '03, and we did get bids from two vendors. The amounts of the --
Right. What they did was, they -- given their losses, they opted to not renew the contract. They asked to be released from the contract. And the Managing Director at the time, Estelle Richmond, released them from the 00192 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole contract so that they didn't have to continue to provide the services, and negotiated an arrangement where they would extend their contract for three months till the end of September to give the City time to find another vendor. We did go through a bid process last summer. We got two bids. Both of them were at a higher cost and with less favorable terms and conditions than the contract we ultimately signed with prison health services. It was not a very good situation at that point in time.
What's your evaluation of the quality of service that was to be provided for whatever the dollar amount was by the other companies?
I have an opinion on it. I haven't studied it in detail; but, you know, it may not be what people want to hear. But out of those three companies that sort of had anything to do with -- the three companies that had anything 00193 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to do with inmate health care, P.H.S. would be the one I would choose. I was never -- I have never been necessarily impressed with the two other companies. We went --
Wexford and Correctional Medical Services. In 1998 we went through the bid process. They came in. We interviewed, you know, all those folks, asked them all sorts of pointed questions, and I at that time sort of formed my opinion of those two companies.
What companies across the country in your estimation provide superior services in this area?
If you're talking large companies, those are the three. And I think Wexford just went out of business. So it's P.H.S. and this C.M.S. There are a lot of other smaller entities that provide health care. For example, last week General Counsel and I had a conversation with the non-profit -- people from the nonprofit entity 00194 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole that contract for health services in Washington, D.C. So there are a lot of entities like that that have one or two accounts. And in Washington, D.C. they only have 2500 inmates. So, would they be capable of providing services in a system that have 7100, when they don't have that experience? They have a lot of smaller companies that might bid. But do they have the experience? You know, we're the fourth largest jail system in the country.
Do we have performance criteria or benchmarks or standards as a part of our contract?
I don't think we have them specifically. But we are working on that. That's a whole new -- We do?
Susan says that we do, Miss Kretzky. Maybe Susan, do you want to come and explain that? But we are working on that issue, performance measures and things like that, for the next contract because the prisons was -- 00195 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole You know, we weren't involved in the process before about what the quality measurement should be, and we weren't responsible to sort of follow them. Now that we are --
Well, because we weren't in charge of providing -- We weren't in charge of monitoring the contract.
The Managing Director's Office, and before that, the Health Department. And now that it's back into the prison system, we're sort of jumping into and saying: Okay, this is what we need. This is what we need to measure performance, et cetera. So that's all undergoing change.
Susan Kretzky, Deputy Managing Director. What I was referencing when I was shaking my head yes over there is, the contract does include performance standards, things about what has to happen, how quickly it has to happen, 00196 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole issues around when service must be provided, things like that. It also requires that the vendor have a quality improvement program, and has a lot of protocols and requirements around that. In addition, I know that the prison is actively involved with them in their quality improvement program. I think some of what the Commissioner is talking about, the direction that they're moving in, is some of the work that, you've probably heard reference in a lot of the Social Service Commissioner's testimony. And that is that all of the departments are very much involved in defining a range of performance measures that include outcomes for the people being served. And we're working very actively right now with the prison system to make sure that the prison health services component is involved in the prison's performance measurement system. With that data we will work with them, as well as taking a look at what it says, what the trends are. Using that, really, I think, 00197 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole is the basis for more questions about what is working well and for whom, and what isn't working. And we are doing some trainings with them, and are involved with their staff on an ongoing basis on this.
And I think I can speak for everyone at the prison. And I think I've been sort of reminding P.H.S. this. We understand how much money this is. It's taxpayer dollars. I remind people that we all work at the prison. This is our money. So, we expect -- You know, you signed the contract for however much it is. We expect you to perform.
And how often are these benchmarks reviewed, and at what point is an evaluation made?
Well, I can't answer that question because that would require us bringing someone else here, I guess, who was sort of in charge of that. But again, right now we've assembled a whole new monitoring team, and we're reviewing this. We have an action plan with P.H.S. that we are updating on a weekly basis, based on, you now, 00198 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Dr. Greifinger and Dr. Patterson's complaints. And we're expecting them to move and jump. And I've told them that that's what we expect to do. And they're doing it, even though their contract term is just, you know, about to end. So we're doing it on a weekly basis.
Well, I guess that was my question. Commissioner, how often do you meet with the people who are performing the analysis on the benchmarks and whether the contractor is living up to the requirements of the contract?
I meet at least weekly with Deputy Commissioner Grooms, and I get updates on a weekly basis.
Well, are they in compliance with the performance standards?
I need a more specific answer. Are they in compliance with the performance standards? That's a yes or no 24 question.
They're providing care in 00199 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole the sense that I am satisfied that they're providing good care in a generalized sense. But in specifics I'm not at this point satisfied that things are where they need to be. I'm not satisfied. That's why we're working with them to move things to where --
Well, is that a personal satisfaction issue or is that a contract issue? Are they in compliance with the terms and conditions of the contract, is what I'm asking?
I don't think they're in substantial breach of the contract. But, you know, I think everyone that works with me at the prison would share my view. The care is good, generally speaking, but we're not satisfied with some of the specifics. And we're satisfied with their response to our, you know, request to them, but it's not where we want it to be, and I wouldn't suggest --
Could you provide to the Chair a comparative analysis between the performance standards in the contract versus where you think the contractor should be on 00200 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole those standards? It would possibly help us to better understand the distinction between the two.
You're welcome. The Chair recognizes Councilman Cohen.
Thank you, Madam President. I think the questions that are being asked are very important. But I'd like to touch on some other areas. Of the 7100 approximate persons who are under the prison system currently, where are they located?
There are 6600, roughly speaking, who are in our physical custody, meaning either on State Road, at the Center I talked about on Cambria Avenue, at 600 University Avenue, and then we have a facility next to Holmesburg Prison. We have 410 approximately housed in Delaware County. Let me see. We have 88 that are 00201 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole housed in the Department of Corrections. We have 56 folks today, I believe, that are in other jurisdictions for various reasons. So 6600 people are really what we have in the physical facilities that are connected to the prison system in the City of Philadelphia.
When they go on work release, are they considered part of your population?
And so the 7100 would include the persons on work release?
They spend the evening. You know, they have to sleep at the prisons.
So they're counted in the number. 00202 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole
When did the private medical services come into being in the prison system? Wasn't there a time when the prison had its own doctors, its own nurses, its own whatever you could get by the way of nurses, its own psychologists, its own therapists?
1979 or so. That's when 00203 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole the Health Department came in, became responsible for health services in the prison. And then in 1988 it went to a private contractor. And I just want to add about that. 1979 was a different time. We had different people there. We had a different outlook. We hadn't gone through, you know, the court cases, and sort of the lessons that we've learned about all these things. And we have a more educated, more professional staff than we had back in 1979. So, that's sort of the point I'm trying to make. If we didn't have -- we haven't had responsibility for medical services since 1979. It's sort of unfair to criticize us for everything that happened, because we haven't been the ones that have been there saying do this, do that. So now that we have it back, we're trying to make the point that we've learned, we've got a lot of professional people up at the prison system who are dedicated to this issue, and we're moving forward, not backwards.
Well, when you say you have a lot of professional people that are 00204 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole dedicated --
-- are they prison employees or are they outside vendors?
Well, as far as managing the contract goes, they're prison employees. And we also have a lot of people in the Managing Director's Office, the Health Department that are helping us oversee the contract. And we do have, you know, to people's credit at the prison, there are people who work for P.H.S. who are dedicated as well. The problem has been, from our point of view, is more not one of so much of having staff who are dedicated, but having a management team that's a little better evolved.
I have a feeling that people who perform for profit have much less sense of dedication than the people who become prison employees. I have that not only in connection with the prisons, but generally. I don't see privatization as any improvement ever. I will concede that here or there 00205 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole maybe for a day or two there might be some improvement, if you substitute a profit motive for the normal motives of wanting to help people, because people that become government employees generally accept as part of their pay the satisfaction from helping because they surely don't get it in dollars. So that I felt that the step toward a private prison system -- to private management of the medical system, all it did was to provide a new source of income for people who -- you know, I'm not saying they're mean people or bad people, but people whose major interest is, how does it operate, you know, from a profit point of view. And whenever they find that it doesn't operate successfully from a profit point of view, they can quit, and just say, no, we've had enough losses, or we haven't made enough money. I find all of the testimony pretty troubling for this reason: I think -- I'll speak for myself. I think I try to hide from feeling responsible for the conditions in the prison. It's not very encouraging to find 00206 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole expenses for the prisons increasing or finding that people suffer in Philadelphia prisons because they're poor, because that's the only reason they're in is they can't come up with enough money but the families can't come up with the money. And Council does have a major responsibility to it. It's Council and the Mayor that have the responsibility for the policy decisions that have to be made and for the conditions in the prison. And I think we have sometimes tried to handle our responsibility by closing our eyes. So I'm very concerned about the conditions in the prison, because I don't think we do our job for the most vulnerable people in Philadelphia. Because it is true in Philadelphia, as it seems to be everywhere else, that the poor suffer disproportionately. They stay in prison longer simply because they don't have money. And I think that's not an acceptable thing, to turn prisons into sort of being poorhouses. You know, the homes of those whose family cannot afford, if they have a family. And if it's a loner person, male or female, they need 00207 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole other kinds of help. Now, we don't have enough care for them, obviously, from the testimony the panel has given, with respect to the drug needs. I can't believe that there are only a couple of hundred prisoners who need drug treatment in addition to those that are already sentenced by the courts to the drug treatment program. When they're sentenced, do they have to do it? When the judge says -- Does the judge actually sentence them to participating in drug treatments?
Then they're violating the terms of their release or their parole, and they go back to prison.
Well, tell me, of the 800 and odd number that you take care of, how many of them are not physically confined in any 00208 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole part of the prison system?
The 800 I think you're referring to, those are the options inmates. They are in the prison.
Right. What I was referring to are the F.I.R. inmates, or the F.I.R. folks. They're not in the prison. That's part of their sentence, and they're not in the prison.
No. Well, I'm not -- At the moment they would not be a major concern because they're not part of the prison population.
Right? They would become it possibly if they didn't live up to the terms of their parole or whatever -- probation r whatever it was the judge ordered. But I am very concerned with whether -- How many -- So, all 800 odd number, 879 or whatever the number was, are in the prison system. Now, how many of them are in the 00209 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole prison system taking drugs because part of the sentencing involved while confined they had to be part of a drug treatment?
Is that the number, a bit over 500 that was testified to before?
Which would leave just under 300, who during their confinement volunteered for a drug program?
How does that happen? How do you find that out? Do they make a written request or an oral request?
It can be either in their meetings with their social workers. That's one of the areas that is brought up. They can ask. The social worker can recommend. There are a number of ways that we find out what the 00210 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole treatment needs are of the inmates that we serve.
If the need were to be met, what would that 300 figure be? That is, what would be the number in your best judgment, the number of inmates that would want to be part of this program beyond those that are already in it? How many would it have to be to have to increase the availability?
Well, I can tell you that as of February there were 450 inmates that were on a waiting list to enroll in the drug treatment program. So, at a minimum, we could easily add close to 500.
At what levels would they be hired? What would be the job 00211 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole titles, for example?
And what is the -- Are social workers difficult to find today or are they...
Could you put together the amount of money that would be necessary to cover the costs of these 15 additional employees, plus the other expenses that would be involved with affording them drug treatment?
Also, from your experience -- and I'm glad the Councilman picked up on this -- is there an alternative to give care, other than hiring full-time people? Is there some other alternative that you could present that would give this care, because hopefully going forward this academic might start to reduce. Is there a plan that you could suggest to give the additional care without increasing the number of employees?
Well, the other option would be to bring outside agencies in to provide that. That would probably create some labor problems that we would have to look at closely.
I'm interested in helping people. And I'm sure our labor relations organization would be able to work with the organized labor, the labor union to address that issue. But could you explain in -- If we didn't hire additional employees, what other alternative -- what -- explain these other 00213 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole agencies or whatever other alternative there could be.
If you could prepare that, including the alternative suggested by Councilman Rizzo, though I must say I don't find any of them very appetizing, but they could be. Gaudenzia House. I don't know whether it still exists or not.
Which, when I worked with them, had a tremendously fine record of performance. I'm very much interested in and I'm going to ask you questions about Judge Presenza's program which has won national acclaim.
But that does not involve inmates; is that right? That involves people to whom the judge affords sort of a last opportunity to stay out of jail. But you might inform me. I may be wrong as to that. But that program seems to have a success rate of about 90 percent, the only 00214 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole success rate anywhere near those numbers of any program that I've ever heard of. And I would like to know what you do about that. But let's do one thing at a time. Let's get from you what the cost would be if in-house you covered the 500 people or added services available for them, and any other alternatives or suggestions that you think along the line that Councilman Rizzo stated that you thought might be used. But I would like you -- Let me put it in my terms. I would like you to indicate which you felt were more successful. You might agree with me. You might disagree with me. But we'd like to know, because I think we've got to come face to face finally with our local problem. And I think maybe this responsibility which we have in all of us, try to stay away from, because it's so difficult and so unpleasant in many ways to think of our responsibility for the conditions of folks in the prison system. But I would like to see how we could save the City lots of money. And my feeling is 00215 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole that it wouldn't cost the City anything, really. In the long run it would probably save the City many millions of dollars if we could deal with two problems, giving people -- three problems, as I see it: Giving people the drug assistance they need; getting rid of those prisoners who are in prison only because they're poor, and find some way of dealing with that situation. And that would reduce, I think, the number of prisoners overwhelmingly and would cut the cost. I hate to see money so difficult to achieve for the schools, and yet it rises in a compelling fashion in the prison system, the figures that Councilman Nutter referred to, the 50 percent or more increase in costs. And I think that's going to probably continue, unless we solve the problem of numbers. And it seems to me we can do so much better in the United States than just incarcerate people because they're too poor or because we're not offering rehabilitation. What do we do about rehabilitation? Does every prisoner get a chance to work? And 00216 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole earn -- I know they earn mighty small sums of money. But do they get a chance to do that? Or are there numbers of prisoners who have nothing to do but sit around all day?
And have learned how next time to maybe avoid arrest, if they did something wrong. Maybe they learned a new technique for doing something. But I don't think people basically want to commit crime. I think society makes it difficult for many people to survive honestly because of disadvantaged circumstances. Some people rise above it; some don't. But I think if they don't, we ought to help them get the strength to rise above it. So I would like to see this proposal, you know, because then I think we're beginning to manage it. And I would like to have any ideas how -- I'm going to be introducing a resolution, hopefully tomorrow; but if not tomorrow, if my staff can't get it together in time, then it will be probably the following week. 00217 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole I want to investigate, with your cooperation. So investigate is probably not the proper word, but to make inquiry into a lot of things about the prison system. I'd like to know how we find out how many folks are there just because of money. And what is there by the way of money. Maybe the City ought to help sponsor, in addition to Kimbell Centers, other kinds of centers that would make fund raising -- would raise enough money to support some kind of staffs that would make funds available for prisoners who are in jail solely because they can't make bail, and that would have a staff sufficient to work with the people, to try to avoid as much recidivism as possible among that group. I'd like to see your budget, your technical budget moved down, and I would like to see the numbers you talk about move down. Commissioner Timoney had been blamed in large part for making many arrests that didn't stand up in Court. I don't know whether that was sound or not. 00218 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole I don't know whether Safe Streets, you know, or the war, or the cold whether, or whatever has caused the drop. But I think the fact of a drop in the number of prisoners is excellent. So, Madam President, I'm going to stop my questioning now, because I think there's so much work that's got to be done in the prisons. And the Home Rule Charter puts that responsibility in our hands. And I think it's time that City Council meet it. And so I'm suggesting that the first two roads to meet would be to get out of the prisons, and we've got to find a way to do it. Those people are there simply because they're poor. It would be a great mark of distinction for Philadelphia to be able to brag: No one is in prison just because he or she doesn't have enough money to get out. And secondly, I would like to see a situation in which all prisoners are getting the proper services they need with the proper amount of rehabilitation. Tell me, offhand... One question I 00219 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole did raise with you that I haven't yet got an answer to. How many folks don't have anything to do and why is that? Is it their choice when they're prisoners? Are they people that are not working at all or is everybody given an assignment?
We only have so much room 9 and so much work for folks to do. We can't force them to work.
What would be the number that you could -- What number would you have to get down to so that you feel you could be able to say, we have work for everybody that comes in?
All right. Well, that will be the kind of question when our resolution, if it's adopted by Council -- I'm hopeful it will be -- is then carried out, and we 00220 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole hold hearings on it. Thank you very much.
You're welcome, Councilman. Gentlemen, thank you very much.
Thank you so much. And to our stenographer, thank you. You've been very patient. Thank you. And The Committee will recess until Monday, April 7th, at 10:00 a.m. And the record should also note that the Department of Records will come in again to testify on April the 8th, at 1:00 p.m. Thank you all very much. (Hearing concluded at 1:23 p.m.) 00221 CERTIFICATE I HEREBY CERTIFY that the proceedings and evidence are contained fully and accurately in the stenographic notes taken by me upon the City Council Hearing taken on April 2, 2003, and that this is a true and correct transcript of same. _____________________________ DAVID A. DEIK, RPR and Commissioner of Deeds (The foregoing certification of this transcript does not apply to any reproduction of the same by any means, unless under the direct control and/or supervision of the certifying reporter.)