Again, we ask that you honor the two-minute limit please. Thank you.
Good morning, Special Committee. My name is Sabrina Tate. I'm the Executive Director of Everybody Builds. I've been in my position for all of seven weeks, and these are my observations. At Everybody Builds, we believe that people who live in Philadelphia should have the fair chance to help Philadelphia and benefit from its growth. Philadelphia has made a commitment, a commitment to creating opportunities for minority, women and disabled-owned businesses. But having a goal is only the first step. We also have to look at what happens after the goal is set. Can a small contractor get the money needed to take on large projects? Can they get the bonding and insurance? Do they know about opportunities early enough to compete? Can they build relationships with larger contractors? And when they do good work, are they given the chance to grow from a small subcontractor into a large contractor that can compete for bigger projects? These are real issues for small businesses. A business may have the skill and expertise to do the work, but still not have the cash needed to carry payroll while waiting to be paid. Another business may be ready to grow but need help with estimating, building, insurance bonding or back-office support. When we remove those barriers, the impact becomes greater. Large organizations, you know, building relationships with smaller organizations can help them increase their capacity. Businesses can hire one worker and grow from five employees to ten. A small subcontractor can become a prime contractor. More money can stay in our neighborhoods and help families build generational wealth. This is also about workforce. As Philadelphia continues to build, we have an opportunity to connect more residents to apprenticeships, training, good-paying construction careers, and we must make sure that people from our communities often have the opportunity that they need in order to obtain this goal. At Everybody Builds, we see diversity and inclusion as more than just numbers on a report. The real question is who's getting the opportunity, who's growing, who's getting the jobs and contracts and are we helping businesses become strong enough to compete without needing special assistance forever. That is the impact I hope this committee will continue to examine. We support looking closely at what is working, where the barriers still exist and how the city and private sector can work together to create real and lasting opportunities. Everybody Builds is ready to partner with you all in this work and because we like to help small businesses grow, not just in building businesses, but building jobs, families, these neighborhoods and a stronger Philadelphia. Thank you for the opportunity to share my perspective.
Thank you. Please state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.
Michael Brown, CEO and founder of The 360 Group. Honorable members of City Council and committee members, thank you for the opportunity to address you today. I'm here representing minority businesses in the construction industry, specifically in the union trades, specialty trades such as mechanical, HVAC, plumbing and electrical. Today, minority businesses across Philadelphia are witnessing a catastrophic erosion of market share, pushing foundational enterprises to the brink of collapse. This crisis has amplified nationally by the dismantling of the federal diversity programs, such as the ADA program and locally by institutional indifference across agencies such as the School District of Philadelphia. Firms face a hostile procurement maze. Change orders are stalled, task orders are inadequate and equitably distributed, and agencies turn a blind eye to predatory business and discriminatory practices. More destructive is the manipulation of the usage of the term DEI. It is now being used to erode the core competencies of Black and Hispanic businesses. Ms. Flamer spoke of data. The Commonwealth Disparity Study done by Secretary Kerry Kirkland exposed a grim reality: Baseline state contracting utilization for African American and Hispanic firms languishes at razor thin percentages 1% Black, 2% with Hispanic. Philadelphia's slowly sleepwalking down the same exact destructive path if we do not change our practices with diversity. We know that distribution of resources is central to governance. Our 6 Council Districts each represent 7 roughly equal communities of 8 160,000 constituents. If 9 Philadelphia is entering another 10 era of major infrastructure investment, we must build durable architecture of shared prosperity, moving beyond the check-the-box metrics towards a strict economic distribution framework backed by heat maps showing precisely where the capital flows. Union Black and Hispanic businesses create Black and Hispanic Union jobs. We don't have pre-apprenticeship programs. We have apprenticeship programs that take you to journeyman positions. You are in danger of losing all of your minority union self-performing contracting firms. I make up one of the largest ones in the city and we will probably close that business down by the end of next year. So thank you all and I appreciate your time.
Yes. My name is Dean Robateau. I'm the Chief Development Officer for McKissack & McKissack. I reserve my statements only because I really wanted to participate and hear what was being discussed and I took down some notes. There were four bullet points that really jumped out at me. We talked about capacity building, workforce development, timely payments and contracts or capital. And I'll begin with the last. What would you prefer, a contract or a capital infusion? I think they go hand-in-hand at this point, because quite frankly, if you're in the room, and I think Donna Allie said it best where she noted that she doesn't play golf or live in those communities, but if we can have continued outreach with respect to some of the larger companies and partner them, mentor protege relationships, that would go a long way because access to capital is only through those relationships when you're on a golf course, living next door, at the shore or wherever it may be, just by observation. The second one is capacity building. We have mega projects and we don't have that capacity with respect to M, W or local business enterprises. And that's something we should continue pushing because there are very talented firms out here. And you've heard from several of them, but there are a lot more than that. So I think a continued push on this committee as far as DE&I to let those smaller companies, emerging companies, have access to us, and vice versa, would go a long way. Thirdly, workforce development. This is very near and dear to my heart. I've been in Philadelphia years. I 18 originally came from New York. My 19 first project was The School of The 20 Future, which was a carve-out of approximately 7 or 8 acres in Fairmount Park. And what I saw was a very successful relationship with regard to that workforce development to assure that those percentages were met. Not just the minimum, but exceeding the minimum. We really need to get back to that. Because as a prime example, we had a 36% share at the Terminal D and E connection- building over to years ago. 9 That's eroded. That's eroded now 10 to the point where a lot of these 11 larger companies, because there's 12 not a push from the federal 13 agencies or the federal government, 14 they don't see the need for it. 15 Several of them, to their credit, 16 have said, we will continue because 17 we're private companies. 18 And finally, timely 19 payments. This is the lifeblood of 20 any company, large or small. And I don't have to tell the business owners here, but anything over 90 days, you turn into a pumpkin because that goes against your borrowing base. But there's also a ripple effect. Because as prime contractors on a lot of the projects we have, if we don't get timely payment, we're often between a rock and a hard place. Do we try to advance payment to these smaller companies or just let them know it's a contractual obligation. We try to go with the first and try to see how we can pay them and take the hit ourselves, but it's a bottom-line business that we're in. So I appreciate your time. I welcome further meetings with this committee, but this is an excellent first, second and third start. Thank you.
Did we hear from Billy McCann? (Witnesses approached witness table.) MR. McCANN: Good morning.
Good afternoon. Please state your name. MR. McCANN: My name is Billy McCann. I am currently a committee person with the 45th Ward, 5th Division serving there. I'm currently running for City Council At-Large. I wanted to share a little bit of my story about my own disability and how a lot of times we find it hard to come out of the shadows. About ten years ago, I was serving at Universal Charter School as principal and I came down with bipolar disorder, a federally- recognized disability covered under the American Disabilities Act. Before that, I served as assistant principal at Universal Audenried in Grays Ferry. For me, coming down with a disability like that meant I needed to step out of the classroom and step out of a school because I needed to take care of myself before I can take care of kids, other people's kids. So I stepped into the construction world. I stepped into real estate. And I found myself having a hard time getting ahead, getting information, access to capital and really being discriminated against. To be honest with you, we are often a historically marginalized voice. That's not part of the conversation. I find it interesting. This morning I was watching Channel 6 News, and there was a segment on about the National Alliance on Mental Illness and streaming at The Marquee. At the bottom of the segment was information about this hearing today. So I came here with a wondering how often are our voices included in the conversation. Thank you.
Are there any other witnesses to come before this body? (No response.)
Going once. Well, the esteemed Chairperson and President of City Council just arrived. So, Councilman Johnson, you can't come into the room 14 without having something to say. Please take the mic.
I see my good friend Nadir back there, who I have supreme confidence who will make sure that we continue to address the issue of inclusion when it comes to small and local businesses as it relates to providing an opportunity for all businesses to have an opportunity to have a seat at the table. I just want to personally just thank my Co-Chairs of this task force, Mr. Harold Epps and Regina Hairston and all of the members who took time out of their schedule to address a very critically important issue. We're the second poorest, largest city in America. In order for us to address the issue of poverty, we have to make sure that we're making opportunities available for everyone here in the city of Philadelphia, regardless of their demographics, regardless of their zip code, regardless of their background. And so, I just want to thank all the members for your hard work. It's definitely a step in the right direction. Michelle, thank you for your legal expertise that you brought to the table. And like you reassured me early on, we've been here before. We know that there have been significant attacks from Washington, D.C. on Black and Brown people, to be quite frank with you, and also women and other individuals who have been marginalized in our society. And so, I remain committed to make sure we're leveling the playing field for everyone here in this great City of Philadelphia when it comes to making sure everybody has a seat at the table. And we have to be intentional about the changes that we want to see and this is why we are here. I'm a firm believer that power concedes nothing without a demand. It never has and it never will. And that's why we remain committed here. And to all the stakeholders who have participated in this process, I see the Economy League over there. Thank you, Jeff Hornstein, for stepping up to the plate, you and Kenyatta early on and saying we want to be a part of this conversation, but most importantly, not just a conversation and not just policy that sits on the shelf, but actually the action behind it to make sure we're addressing the issue. And so, with that being said, to everyone who took time out of your schedule on a very, very complex and I call it not-sexy issue, thank you for your dedication and making sure this is a priority. Thank you very much.
Council President Johnson, let me say this as the chronological senior person in the room, it's my experience that no system, no system is no 3 stronger than how it treats and deals with the least of us. And there is no demographic out there that will not suggest that the least of us in America are its disabled and Black and Brown citizens. Okay. That's just the facts. And so, the question is where does Philadelphia want to be going forward? What we just witnessed this summer shows what we can do when we work together. Philadelphia elevated its platform and got a positive reputation around the world. I can guarantee you that I was out of the country and people raved about their experiences and interactions with Philadelphia. But this issue right here is critical to the current and future determination, will we continue to evolve. Council President Johnson talked about the second lowest, poorest, what used to be the first. All right. So we've gotten ourselves one step above the bottom. Let's keep going. But if we don't deal with this, we won't get there. So we want to thank all of the witnesses for their participation today. Your testimony will help shape the committee's findings and the record supporting its final report. And absolutely know that we value your time and your insight. So, Councilman Johnson, I see you sitting down again. Is there anything else you want to say before we begin to wrap up?
I also just wanted to take a moment to acknowledge my staffer who has this particular issue in his portfolio. And he has stayed on this issue from day one. He has steadied the ship regarding this particular issue. And I work on a lot of issues in City Hall, right. And this is only near and dear to me because it's an opportunity for us to change people's lives. And the City of Philadelphia has always been a tale of two cities, where some folks are doing great and some folks aren't doing so great. And if we're not focusing on building generational wealth as a way to address the issue of poverty, institutional poverty that we have seen time and time again, then what's the purpose of us being here. So I just want to acknowledge Mr. Kareem Groomes for just taking time -- (Applause.)
-- staying on top of this issue. As my mentor Hardy Williams used to say, he stayed on the case consistently. And I just want to thank you, Kareem. It wasn't easy. This is not one of these issues where when you start working on it, people start coming out and just clapping and giving you kudos. Because we recognize part of it is us just addressing systemic and institutional racism and economic barriers for people of color and other marginalized people to have a seat at the table. But you stepped up to the plate and continuously stayed focused on making sure we got not only the report done, but also some legislation passed as well. And this is just the beginning. So thank you, Kareem. Continue to keep up the good work. And that's all I have. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
Well, you always give your boss, in this case Councilman Johnson, the last word. And so, with that this concludes the public hearing portion of today's proceedings. We will now go into the public meeting of the Special Committee to consider adoption of the committee's final report. So, Mr. Groomes, will you please call the roll to take attendance for the public meeting.
Della Clark -- excuse me. We have Victoria Hosendorf for Della Clark.
Mr. Chair, thank you for recognizing the presence of the -- no, I'm the Chair. Sorry about that. I want to thank you for recognizing the presence of a quorum. The Chair now recognizes Co-Chair Hairston for a portion of the final report of the Special Committee.
I move that the Special Committee adopt its final report on the City's private sector diversity, equity and inclusion policies, that the Co-Chairs and Committee staff be authorized to make technical and editorial corrections to the report, including corrections to citations, figures and formatting, without further action of the committee and that the report, as corrected, be transmitted to Council President Johnson and the members of Council.
We have a first and a second. Ready for the question? So it has been moved and properly seconded that the Special Committee adopt its final report to authorize the Co-Chairs and staff to make technical and editorial corrections and to transmit the report as corrected to Council President Johnson and the members of Council. All those in favor of this motion will signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
Hearing none, the ayes have it. The final report is adopted. Technical corrections are authorized and the report will be transferred to Council President Johnson and the members of Council. Ms. Hairston, you have the final word.
This concludes the business before the Special Committee for today. On behalf of both Co-Chairs, thank you. And thank you to our witnesses, to the members of the Committee and to the public for your attendance. This hearing and public meeting are adjourned to reconvene at the call of the Chairs.
May you have a great Monday and not need your umbrellas. - - - (Special Committee on City and Private Sector Diversity Equity and Inclusion Policies adjourned at 12:15 p.m.) - - - C E R T I F I C A T I O N I, hereby certify that the proceedings and evidence noted are contained fully and accurately in the stenographic notes taken by me in the foregoing matter, and that this is a correct transcript of the same. ________________________________ TANEHA CARROLL