civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - February 28, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Feb 28, 20247h 19m

Are you there?

Similar wording

Ms. McCullough, please.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

Yes, I can hear you.

Similar wording

Are you in a position to be able to put your camera on?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

camera

Similar wording

is it on

Similar wording

it was

Similar wording

it was on mom you've got to hold the phone up

Similar wording

oh

Similar wording

you have to just turn the camera around to yourself now

Similar wording

oh

Similar wording

That's it. You just have to hit the little camera button at the bottom to turn it towards you.

Similar wording

It looks like a small camera.

Similar wording

Hit the what?

Similar wording

It looks like a small camera.

Similar wording

It's up at the top of the screen.

Similar wording

On the left-hand side.

Similar wording

And it's the third.

Similar wording

It looks like a little teeny camera at the very top of the screen.

Similar wording

I think...

Similar wording

I see you

Similar wording

but I don't see

Similar wording

what you're talking about

Similar wording

so Ms. Jeanette are you in position to be able to

Similar wording

move forward with the presentation and share your

Similar wording

presentation with us this morning? I do have a

Similar wording

presentation but I'm just not

Similar wording

I don't know how to

Similar wording

what I did

Similar wording

on the phone.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

Yeah, I see, Mr. Chair, I believe the architect

Similar wording

is on it, may be able to share the presentation.

Similar wording

Obviously, Ms. McCullough

Similar wording

needs to be the one to give

Similar wording

the presentation,

Similar wording

but if the architect has the materials,

Similar wording

he can share them.

Similar wording

I haven't started

Similar wording

speaking.

Similar wording

is coming back in as a

Similar wording

panelist

Similar wording

mom let the architect

Similar wording

speak for now and then they'll come back to you

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

just to be clear

Similar wording

the architect cannot testify

Similar wording

he can only share

Similar wording

his screen and show the

Similar wording

materials miss McClellough has to

Similar wording

testify because she is the property owner

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

So, Ms. McCullough, can you please state your name and spell it for our court reporter,

Similar wording

please?

Similar wording

I'm going to have to probably unmute.

Similar wording

Mom, you've got to unmute the button so you can say your name.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

Yes, please state your name and spell it for the court reporter, please.

Similar wording

Jeanette McCullough.

Similar wording

can you spell it

Similar wording

j-e-a-n-n-e-t-t-e

Similar wording

m-c-c-u-l-l-o-u-g-h

Similar wording

you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes this application is for the

Similar wording

of a one off street parking space accessory

Similar wording

to an existing single-family structure.

Similar wording

You are...

Similar wording

Board member, Mr. Thomas Holloman, has a few questions to ask.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Do you...

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Did you email all the exhibits and documents as required five days in advance to this hearing?

Similar wording

I sent them to the architect?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Please proceed and share your screen.

Similar wording

So, Ms. McCullough, you can continue on with the presentation now with your architect.

Similar wording

Ms. McCullough, can you see what's on the screen? You can see what's being shown?

Similar wording

No, no, that's the problem. I don't know what happened to my screen. I don't have a screen. Oh, maybe that's it.

Similar wording

Can you see, can you see, and Mr. Johnson, if you could put up like a photo or something, I just want to see if Ms. McCullough can see what's being shared on the screen, because if not, we may just need to come back.

Similar wording

I shared the screen. The site plan should be on the screen.

Similar wording

What do you want me to see? I don't, I don't, sorry, excuse me. Mr. Johnson, I don't see the

Similar wording

site plan. I only see a folder that lists documents. Oh, I'm sorry. Let me see something.

Similar wording

That's okay. Stop sharing. Share screen. Share.

Similar wording

That's it. Thank you. Ms. McCullough, can you see plans on the screen?

Similar wording

Yes. Okay. Okay, great. So now, since you can see what your architect is showing,

Similar wording

you can explain about your project, and Mr. Shaheed will ask you a few questions.

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

so ma'am you can continue on this is the uh architecture plans you want to show

Similar wording

let me know what you're trying to do uh with the extra parking space on the side of the property

Similar wording

with the extra parking space on the side of the property?

Similar wording

Well, it's the back of my house, and what I would like to do is put the driveway in

Similar wording

well um

Similar wording

because there has been – I've lived here for 40 years,

Similar wording

and there has been a great increase in the number of people needing parking.

Similar wording

And they just built a, they just built a, they took the church and they built an apartment complex with no parking.

Similar wording

And all of those people are now parking in all, I live on the corner and they park in all my parking spaces and I don't have any place to park.

Similar wording

so i would like to use um use a little bit of my backyard to put a driveway back there so that i

Similar wording

can come and go as i need to do you have any senior citizen now and um i need to be able to park

Similar wording

reasonably close to my house do you have any actual photos of the street okay

Similar wording

what about the street view

Similar wording

I guess Mr. Kenneth

Similar wording

it'll be right in here

Similar wording

is there a street

Similar wording

degress already

Similar wording

yes from the right

Similar wording

of way yes

Similar wording

Mr. Johnson I'm sorry

Similar wording

but you can't testify

Similar wording

Ms. McCullough has to answer questions

Similar wording

so Ms. McCullough

Similar wording

is there a street

Similar wording

degress right there in the middle of the street

Similar wording

looks like I see an X on the floor

Similar wording

on the ground out front

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

because the lady behind me

Similar wording

already has a driveway

Similar wording

she has a driveway

Similar wording

and she uses

Similar wording

part of the street in front

Similar wording

of where I would want to

Similar wording

put my driveway

Similar wording

he uses it to come and go

Similar wording

got it

Similar wording

so right now

Similar wording

the driveway would be right in front of another parking space

Similar wording

off the street so you're taking one parking

Similar wording

space from the street to

Similar wording

utilize behind your property correct

Similar wording

the x

Similar wording

that you see there

Similar wording

it kind of goes over

Similar wording

onto where my

Similar wording

my

Similar wording

yard ends

Similar wording

So when she comes out, if you can see the car there, when she comes out, she comes out partially in front of the area where I want to put my driveway.

Similar wording

So we would actually be not using more space, a complete space, because she's already using part of my space.

Similar wording

okay all right we see that you have met with the uh neighbors of overbrook association

Similar wording

um with about the zoning committee uh can we see the uh appeal letter and

Similar wording

sort of your tax shirts and stuff please

Similar wording

copy of the

Similar wording

Okay, can we see a copy of the D?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

uh any questions from the board no mr any questions from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time uh questions from the virtual audience

Similar wording

there are no hands here planning commission thank you vice chair and good morning david

Similar wording

F-E-C-T-E-A-U, with the City Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Do you switch...

Similar wording

do you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes sir i do proceed

Similar wording

please thank you sir uh vice chair and board members uh good morning david effecto with the

Similar wording

city planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the residential single

Similar wording

family zoning at this location there is no unique physical condition or circumstance of this property

Similar wording

that would prevent it from being used in conformance with the zoning code accessory off street parking

Similar wording

is not a common condition on the 600 block of north 64th street the city planning commission

Similar wording

recommends the board deny the proposed variance for accessory off-street parking

Similar wording

mi-2023-005687 600 to 602 north 64th street my vote is yes

Similar wording

yes. Thomas Holloman, my vote is yes. James Snell, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Congratulations. Moving on number four, MI-2023-003682, 1215 West Tioga Street.

Similar wording

Excuse me, Mr. Chair, I believe we have a couple other pro se cases that we're going

Similar wording

to hear number five to start.

Similar wording

I'm going to go to number five.

Similar wording

MI-2023-001-534-4927 North 8th Street, Aerie Resusio.

Similar wording

Aerie Resusio, Rosario has been promoted to panelist.

Similar wording

I'm sorry I was muted um no problem let me start my video one second I think you should

Similar wording

be able to see me now. Can you see me now? Yes. Good morning. Good morning. Can you state your

Similar wording

name and spell it for the court reporter, please? Yeah, it's Eddie Lara Rosario, E-R-I-L-A-R-A-R-O-S-A-R-I-O.

Similar wording

You swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Yes, I do.

Similar wording

um our board member mr holliman has a few questions to ask you okay good morning did you

Similar wording

did you email all of the exhibits and documents as required five days in advance to this hearing

Similar wording

yes i did thank you please proceed and show your screen okay

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

mr vice chair did you read the refusal into the record

Similar wording

sure uh this application is to legalize the front edition uh porch enclosure on existing

Similar wording

attached structure for use of a single family household living

Similar wording

okay should i proceed yes please

Similar wording

all right so like you say this hearing is uh to request a variant uh for the close of the front

Similar wording

of the porch of my property at 49 27 or as3 um this is the violation notice in order to correct

Similar wording

that i received from lni um as you can see on the letter it was sent to my old address in new york

Similar wording

um i got it because thankfully i was still in contact with my ex-husband and he sent me a

Similar wording

picture of it when he got it that's how i became aware of the requirements uh for in order to do

Similar wording

this uh job uh and according to the letter um the only thing they ask on the letter is that i get

Similar wording

the required permit for it which were the construction permit and the zoning permit

Similar wording

permit. They give me some time to get it done. If not, they say that I will have to pay these

Similar wording

fines on the letter. They did send two letters. I'm sorry. You can see both of them on this

Similar wording

page. They sent a second letter to make sure that we did got the permit. Of course, I was

Similar wording

in the process. It took some time. But after that, I never got any notification from them.

Similar wording

But after that, I never got any notification from them.

Similar wording

This is a copy of the refusal letter, where they say why the permit was refused.

Similar wording

This is the application for appeal.

Similar wording

According to the application, I'm applying for an appeal because this variance will not create any environmental damage, pollution, erosion,

Similar wording

or increase the danger of flooding in the area.

Similar wording

It will not substantially increase traffic or congestion in the public street.

Similar wording