civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 16, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 16, 20255h 36m

in Nancy, E-L. Last name Gillen, spelled as in G-U-I-L-L-E-N, as in Nancy. Do you solemnly swear

Similar wording

or affirm that you will interpret accurately, completely, and impartially from English to

Similar wording

Spanish and from Spanish to English to the best of your ability? I swear. Thank you, sir. So

Similar wording

what at this, your case is going to be a vote we're having, so we don't have to call

Similar wording

Hillary we don't have to call the only right okay all right so sir it's MI 2024

Similar wording

001 938 and address is 2091 Bridge Street

Similar wording

could you state that for me first yes your honor it's uh you said case MI 2024 001 938

Similar wording

address is 2091

Similar wording

Bridge Street.

Similar wording

Could you interpret that

Similar wording

in case the person is on the line?

Similar wording

Muy bien, entonces

Similar wording

en cuanto al caso

Similar wording

número MI2024001938

Similar wording

de la dirección

Similar wording

2091 de la calle Bridge.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

And my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Mi voto es sí.

Similar wording

Michael Johns,

Similar wording

my vote is yes.

Similar wording

for johnson my vote is yes

Similar wording

cheryl gaston my vote is yes

Similar wording

tenetta graham my vote is yes

Similar wording

ryan mcadams my vote is yes

Similar wording

ryan mcadams my vote is yes

Similar wording

tayo win my vote is yes

Similar wording

thank you very much sir we appreciate your help

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

See you next time, Your Honor.

Similar wording

Have a beautiful day.

Similar wording

Thank you very much, sir.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

So we're going to go to start with number two, MI 2025-000-480-1513 West Butler Street.

Similar wording

We also have an interpreter for this.

Similar wording

Your board has been promoted to panelists.

Similar wording

They'll be coming back in shortly.

Similar wording

Sure. Thank you.

Similar wording

Interpreter, if you're still in a virtual audience,

Similar wording

please raise your virtual hand away to respond again.

Similar wording

Yes, I have my hand raised.

Similar wording

OK, thank you.

Similar wording

Could you turn on your video, please?

Similar wording

I do have it on.

Similar wording

I'm not sure why you cannot see me.

Similar wording

OK, I had to promote them to panelists.

Similar wording

They'll be coming back in shortly.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair. Sure. Thank you. We're going to bring it back in.

Similar wording

Excuse me.

Similar wording

Okay. Are you able to still hear me?

Similar wording

I hear you, but I think

Similar wording

he's going to bring you back as a panelist.

Similar wording

Here we go. There you are. We see you now.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name

Similar wording

and spell it for the stenographer?

Similar wording

My name is Claudia

Similar wording

Pineda.

Similar wording

The spelling is C-L-A-U-D-I-A

Similar wording

E-I-N-E-D-A.

Similar wording

Do you silently swear or affirm that you will interpret accurately, completely, and impartially from English to Spanish and from Spanish to English to the best of your ability?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Okay, so I'm going to give you the numbers to call the case.

Similar wording

I'm going to give you the numbers to call the case, MI-2025-000-480, and the address is 1513 Butler Street.

Similar wording

MI 2025.

Similar wording

Estamos llamando el caso número MI-2025-000-480. La dirección es 1513 Butler Street.

Similar wording

And the listed applicant is Julia René.

Similar wording

No, I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Listed applicant is Gilberto Álvarez Corona, current owner.

Similar wording

Could you please call him to come on?

Similar wording

Yes, my name is Gilberto Alvarez Corona.

Similar wording

Okay, so what I'm going to do is I'm going to swear him in, but he has to spell his name

Similar wording

for the court stenographer.

Similar wording

but you have to write your name for the court, the stenographer of the court.

Similar wording

Yes, my name is Gilberto Álvarez.

Similar wording

G, I de puntito, L de león, B de burro, de bueno, E de león, D, R de rosa, T de tito, O de oso, A de Antonio, L de

Similar wording

Yes, my name is G as in George, I, L, B as in boy, E, R, T as in Tom, O, A, L, V as in Victor, A, R, E, Z as in zebra.

Similar wording

I'm going to give you the oath.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth,

Similar wording

the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Le voy a tomar juramento.

Similar wording

¿Usted jura o afirma decir la verdad,

Similar wording

solo la verdad y nada más que la verdad?

Similar wording

Sí.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And so this application is for a change of use

Similar wording

to two-family household living

Similar wording

in an existing structure.

Similar wording

Esta solicitud es para el cambio de uso de una vivienda asistida de dos familias a el,

Similar wording

y permíteme un segundo a la intérprete.

Similar wording

Your Honor, this is the interpreter speaking.

Similar wording

Would you repeat the last part of your statement?

Similar wording

Sure, I most certainly will.

Similar wording

This application is for change of use to two-family household living in an existing structure.

Similar wording

Y esta solicitud es para el cambio de uso a dos familias en una vivienda, que es solamente una estructura.

Similar wording

And further, the proposed use to family household living is prohibited in the RSA 5 zoning district.

Similar wording

If you want, go halfway through it, I'll come back for you.

Similar wording

so the proposed use

Similar wording

to family household living

Similar wording

el uso que se está proponiendo

Similar wording

es la vivienda

Similar wording

o que viven hay dos familias

Similar wording

right

Similar wording

is prohibited

Similar wording

in the RSA 5 zoning district

Similar wording

y ese uso está prohibido

Similar wording

dentro del distrito

Similar wording

de zonas de RSA 5

Similar wording

and

Similar wording

one more thing before he starts

Similar wording

There's a letter of unanimous opposition from the 13th Ward Democratic RCO.

Similar wording

Though there's unanimous opposition from the 13th Ward Democratic RCO.

Similar wording

Could you please ask him to start his presentation and share his computer?

Similar wording

Okay, we have that.

Similar wording

We have that. Please move on.

Similar wording

Please move on.

Similar wording

Ya lo tenemos. Por favor, continúe.

Similar wording

We have all those documents.

Similar wording

We have it.

Similar wording

Tenemos todos esos documentos.

Similar wording

Lo tenemos.

Similar wording

Now, Holden, we need right there. Stop there, if you would.

Similar wording

Ahí. Deténgase.

Similar wording

If you make that a little larger, we want to see the drawings.

Similar wording

Lo puede hacer un poquito más grande. Queremos ver los dibujos.

Similar wording

So the question is, there's nothing in the basement, ask them that.

Similar wording

La pregunta es, no hay nada en el sótano.

Similar wording

Oh, show us the first floor.

Similar wording

Muéstonos el primer piso.

Similar wording

Is that the first floor?

Similar wording

Is that el primer piso?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Is there a full bathroom in the first floor

Similar wording

or is that a half bath?

Similar wording

¿En el primer piso hay un baño completo

Similar wording

o es un medio baño?

Similar wording

Baño completo.

Similar wording

Baño completo.

Similar wording

Full bathroom.

Similar wording

Let us see the other drawing, please.

Similar wording

Muéstrenos el otro dibujo, por favor.

Similar wording

The piso.

Similar wording

Okay, so on the first floor

Similar wording

we do not see a full bathroom in the plans do you have photos please

Similar wording

completo. Yeah, there's not a full bathroom downstairs, but I want to build a full bathroom.

Similar wording

What is existing right now? What do you have there on the first floor?

Similar wording

¿Qué es lo que hay ahora, actualmente en ese primer piso?

Similar wording

La casa esta residencial es solamente una casa que hasta ahora.

Similar wording

it's a residential home

Similar wording

it's just one home so far

Similar wording

do you show us photos

Similar wording

nos puede mostrar fotos

Similar wording

si

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

ok

Similar wording

keep going

Similar wording

continue

Similar wording

oh boy

Similar wording

is that the entrance to the where's the entrance to the second floor

Similar wording

your honor this is at jeffrey speaking i couldn't hear what he said

Similar wording

We're trying to see where the entrance is to the second floor.

Similar wording

Is that the entrance to the whole property there?

Similar wording

That's the entrance, and the stairs are the stairs that go to the second floor.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

la propiedad está una sola residencia residencial no está dividida the property is just one

Similar wording

it's like a residential home just one home

Similar wording

would you ask them what happened when he went to the rco meeting

Similar wording

¿Qué pasó cuando fue a la reunión del RCO?

Similar wording

Yo expliqué cómo iba a hacer todo.

Similar wording

Well, I explained how I was going to build everything.

Similar wording

Questions for the board.

Similar wording

Preguntas de la mesa.

Similar wording

Yeah, could you walk us through your plans for each floor of the new construction?

Similar wording

Si, nos puede explicar paso por paso los planos que tiene para cada piso para la construcción?

Similar wording

Si.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

so why don't you show the first floor and let him say everything that's on the first floor

Similar wording

Muestre el primer piso y díganos todo lo que está en el primer piso.

Similar wording

muestra el primer piso y díganos todo

Similar wording

Let him know that the plan doesn't make sense.

Similar wording

There's not a full bathroom.

Similar wording

There's no air.

Similar wording

Que el plano no tiene sentido.

Similar wording

No hay un baño completo ahí.

Similar wording

Sí, porque todavía no está.

Similar wording

Eso es lo que estoy proponiendo.

Similar wording

Yeah, it's still not there.

Similar wording

That's what I'm proposing.

Similar wording

No, we know, but what is being proposed does not make sense.

Similar wording

There's no full bathrooms.

Similar wording

There's no way for a person to shower or bathe themselves.

Similar wording

And there's a notation that says bedroom number two,

Similar wording

but there's no bedroom number one.

Similar wording

So we want a full idea of what is the plan for the two apartments?

Similar wording

How many bedrooms?

Similar wording

How does he think it's going to be laid out?

Similar wording

Etc.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

We do not have a bathroom, or there are no way to get a bathroom, so that a person can

Similar wording

have a bathroom that says in the bathroom.

Similar wording