civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 16, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 16, 20255h 36m

that you would like to see here's the trailer that is going to serve as the office here's

Similar wording

why don't you do this why don't you why don't you go back and show the garage that's going

Similar wording

up then you have a little drawing of the garage that's going to go up yes i did i'll go to the

Similar wording

drawing right away and were you at the rco meeting council yes sir i was mr chair

Similar wording

yes sir i was mr chair when you give us a report of that yeah it's the well they approved that it

Similar wording

why don't you give us a report of that yeah it's

Similar wording

is go there first i guess here we have the letter but i mean just give me tell us what happened

Similar wording

oh basically they had several i would say maybe a half dozen community members um the the questions

Similar wording

varied as they actually there wasn't that many questions to be quite frank with it there was a

Similar wording

some discussion as to whether

Similar wording

or not the structure could be moved to the other adjacent

Similar wording

masonry wall

Similar wording

I had already sent a letter out

Similar wording

or an email out to the RCO

Similar wording

indicating that that would just start the whole

Similar wording

process again and I had explained how

Similar wording

everything at least

Similar wording

there was a septic right away that had to be

Similar wording

executed by the client but

Similar wording

that that would just be onerous

Similar wording

with respect to the owner

Similar wording

and contemporaneously with

Similar wording

the

Similar wording

that letter that's when we received a little delayed but we received a copy of the letter

Similar wording

from the RCO where they gave their approval right you explain again what's going to be done in the

Similar wording

garage there that you're building basically in this what would be the extension of the use in

Similar wording

this area here whether it's the proposed location and I and here is the more detailed drawing

Similar wording

it's just going to be for purposes of bringing in vehicles for what I would consider light

Similar wording

maintenance, everything from brake work to oil changes

Similar wording

to tire changes, in addition to the vehicle sales and rentals

Similar wording

from that lot. That is it. There's not going to be any change within the location

Similar wording

itself. It's not going to be extended in any shape or form.

Similar wording

Okay. Why don't you bring your client on?

Similar wording

Yes. Ms. Peralta, are you on, please?

Similar wording

We will be joining as a panel shortly.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Hi, can you guys see me?

Similar wording

Yes, I can.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name as spelled for the stenographer?

Similar wording

her. My name is Elba Peralta, E-L-B-A-P-E-R-A-L-T-A. Do you swear or affirm to tell the

Similar wording

truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? I swear. Counsel, proceed. Ms. Peralta, you just

Similar wording

heard my, you did hear my presentation to the board this morning? Yes. And do you agree with

Similar wording

everything that I've said to the board with respect to the variance that is being sought

Similar wording

at this location? Yes, I agree. And in the words that I, the explanation I provided to the board,

Similar wording

would you have explained it in the same way in terms of the variance that you're seeking to get

Similar wording

on this property? Sure. So the business is going to be like a tire shop. We're going to build the

Similar wording

garage to put uh feed two cars and do the maintenance like a tire change uh brake change

Similar wording

just simple maintenance uh the community will need just in case of an emergency

Similar wording

um so that's basically what we are going to be doing and Mr. Chair to the extent that there's

Similar wording

any questions there's not going to be any excavation or with or the digging of footers

Similar wording

with respect to the proposed

Similar wording

I'll call it metal

Similar wording

shed where the vehicles will go in for

Similar wording

repair. Okay, questions

Similar wording

from the board. You said there's

Similar wording

not going to be any foundations?

Similar wording

What is this, a prefab sort of

Similar wording

bring in?

Similar wording

Yes, sir. That's basically it.

Similar wording

It's obviously going to have to be

Similar wording

bolted in, but in terms of having

Similar wording

a site

Similar wording

excavator come in and dig footers

Similar wording

so there could be a pouring, it's not going to happen.

Similar wording

It'll be on the existing slab.

Similar wording

That is correct.

Similar wording

And is there going to be any painting?

Similar wording

No painting.

Similar wording

As I said before, the repair and maintenance that is going to be done at this location is minor.

Similar wording

Painting would require, as you well know, certainly a completely different, I would say, guidelines and prerequisites in order to allow for it.

Similar wording

That's not going to take place at this location.

Similar wording

Do you have a grading plan of the site?

Similar wording

I think my concern would be if this is slab-on-grade, most parking lots are on a slope to drain water.

Similar wording

And how is this metal structure going to sit flush to the ground in that location?

Similar wording

The framing and foundation plan shows, again, if you look at number seven, that's the manner and how they're going to bolt it.

Similar wording

Let me see if I can get the detail up here.

Similar wording

Yeah, but that's a plan. I'm looking for an elevation.

Similar wording

yeah but that's a plan i'm i'm looking for either and i'm looking for an elevation

Similar wording

I don't believe there's been any issues with respect to addressing the elevation.

Similar wording

I'll say this, that whatever water that is filtering out due to rainwater or otherwise, it hasn't changed.

Similar wording

There's not going to be that change to it.

Similar wording

I don't expect really any water to emanate from this location because it's really just going to be a cool shed with parking spots to do the repairs and maintenance.

Similar wording

Obviously, if there's an oil change, they do have to gather the oil and have to dispose about it.

Similar wording

I've never seen a garage that had no runoff.

Similar wording

So I guess my question is really how are we handling any runoff that comes from any work being done with the repairs?

Similar wording

Do none of these repairs need any type of water hookup?

Similar wording

because right now this is a simple shed

Similar wording

with no water

Similar wording

access or even

Similar wording

electricity. Where's the electricity?

Similar wording

I don't know

Similar wording

if the rendering

Similar wording

here indicates it

Similar wording

but

Similar wording

Alba, do you now

Similar wording

I didn't anticipate this question but Alba, do you

Similar wording

know with respect to the utility

Similar wording

services to that shed?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

A few months ago I reached out

Similar wording

to PICO

Similar wording

is like a brand new

Similar wording

they will have to go and make all the

Similar wording

installments for the to build

Similar wording

a line because there's no line

Similar wording

attached to that lot

Similar wording

but they're going to have to dig up the asphalt

Similar wording

anyway

Similar wording

look they do for the line

Similar wording

more than probably yes but in terms

Similar wording

of digging up put footers in for

Similar wording

a garage space that's not going to take place

Similar wording

okay and then

Similar wording

are customers able

Similar wording

to access the bathroom because I see

Similar wording

there's only the one port-a-potty?

Similar wording

There's

Similar wording

going to be. I know there's one port-a-potty.

Similar wording

There may be another one. The only

Similar wording

other bathroom that's going to be

Similar wording

at least enclosed would be the one

Similar wording

in the trailer. They're going to have

Similar wording

to refit that if, in fact,

Similar wording

that's what they're going to do. But I don't

Similar wording

believe a bathroom consideration is taking

Similar wording

place. Am I correct with that, Ms. Peralta?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

You're correct.

Similar wording

I have a question. Is there a separation

Similar wording

between the vehicles that are for sale

Similar wording

and the vehicles that are being worked on

Similar wording

and the customer parking.

Similar wording

Ms. Peralta, could you respond to that, please?

Similar wording

We are going to more focus right now on the garage.

Similar wording

If there's going to be any vehicles for sales,

Similar wording

it's going to be there's plenty of parking space

Similar wording

that we're going to have them,

Similar wording

if you can see right next to the garage.

Similar wording

Yeah, there's tens of parking spaces.

Similar wording

So I have a question.

Similar wording

So in your garage, is there any kind of lifts or anything that the cars would sit on to lift the cars to, like, do the oil changes or anything like that?

Similar wording

Well, sir, if we're talking about pneumatic lifts, they're not going to place pneumatic lifts.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I forget the name of the – it's like a portable lift.

Similar wording

you know Ms. Peralta can you explain that

Similar wording

I think that's what you're going to do

Similar wording

yeah just you know

Similar wording

the ones that you just put under the

Similar wording

car and you just left it it's not going

Similar wording

to be any other like

Similar wording

digging to

Similar wording

bring the cars up

Similar wording

Ms. Peralta do you already have a business

Similar wording

that conducts these activities

Similar wording

no

Similar wording

do you have experience

Similar wording

running tire shops

Similar wording

no I don't

Similar wording

um actually uh it's me and my dad that we build in um this business uh he's the one that um

Similar wording

is gonna be more like in charge of it um but i'm i'm not very aware of like i don't have

Similar wording

experience with tire shops and how many employees do you anticipate that you have on site so far

Similar wording

is going to be my dad and my uncle so and then how many customers are you projecting a day

Similar wording

uh well you know it's a new business so we have to build uh the customers so hopefully i wish

Similar wording

since day one will be full of customers but we're gonna plan into uh we are planning to open like

Similar wording

uh the earliest as possible like around 6 a.m uh till 7 p.m so hopefully we can get

Similar wording

from our expectation expectation from day one like at least 20 30 customers

Similar wording

and did you already talk with the rco about the business hours

Similar wording

question never came up never came up okay and then my last question

Similar wording

question never came up never came up okay and then my last question is about the tire rack

Similar wording

so it looks like everything on this site outside of that very the two-car garage is exposed where

Similar wording

are you storing like metal tools tires in the winter like what's your seasonal plan for the site

Similar wording

if i could just plan on on the on the rendering and the drawing you could see that there's a tool

Similar wording

shed box that is detailed uh they have the tire the dry tire changing and they have the workshop

Similar wording

stock against material light bulbs whatever it is that they're going to store up

Similar wording

okay questions other questions yeah okay so what are you doing there now you you i'm not seeing

Similar wording

any pictures of what you're doing there now so what are you doing at this location at this point

Similar wording

it says here that you the proposed uses uh right now we ran that a lot two years ago in this past

Similar wording

june was two years ago so for um it's been just sitting there we've been paying rent uh for this

Similar wording

past two years waiting for everything to get approved so right now it's not in use

Similar wording

the quick answer to that is that uh is that there hasn't been any

Similar wording

commercial activity at this location pending this variance that they're seeking

Similar wording

okay and uh you um okay so part of this you're gonna need to have some kind of hazardous waste

Similar wording

disposal? I mean, if you're going to be changing oil and other

Similar wording

fluids in the car, have you made arrangements for that?

Similar wording

And what are you planning to do about that?

Similar wording

Well, my understanding is that as soon as the variance is approved, they would obviously

Similar wording

have to make those arrangements for waste disposal, primarily

Similar wording

of oil, but also of tires, to the extent new tires put on

Similar wording

and the old ones are discarded. Okay. And then the other thing

Similar wording

about tires of course is you know there's the risk of fire and what have you so where if you

Similar wording

don't have any like hookup for like water or I mean you're going to need other kinds of fire

Similar wording

suppression types of equipment what are you doing about that I don't think there is going to be an

Similar wording

overall large accumulation of tires and in the form of it's not a retail shop it's more of a

Similar wording

repair shop um am i correct with that miss peralta yes and of course if there is a is there is a i'm

Similar wording

sorry if there is a fire code um issue that has to be met you know obviously it will be done and

Similar wording

corrected or not corrected but it will be done and implemented so where are the tires going to

Similar wording

be stored right well they have it if you see here on the rendering it is at this location

Similar wording

which is but again we're not talking about a retail shop selling tires just talking about

Similar wording

tire repair just to confirm what you just pointed to is not tire storage and what is shown is on the

Similar wording

there's tire racks which is usually where tires are stored and they're shown on the site plan

Similar wording