civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 14, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 14, 20266h 39m

to show the uh support letter sure why don't you why don't you do that sure do we have their letters

Similar wording

i don't know if that's submitted uh by the uh community to the board yeah council we just

Similar wording

received it this morning yeah we while we were in session yeah we we received it while we were in

Similar wording

session so we thank you for the timely uh notification with that thank you again i'm

Similar wording

just showing the board the actual letter itself thank you all right questions or comments from the

Similar wording

board um there's no other sales like tire sales or anything like that that's going to take place

Similar wording

on the premises no tire sales they're not going to do tire work at all to avoid having uh to store

Similar wording

them as part of work relating to tires. Thank you. And from what you're saying, there's only

Similar wording

going to be limited repair work. Correct. That it's going to be more for refurbishing cars for

Similar wording

sale. Is that what? Correct. Mr. Gomez's and his brother's primary business is to be selling. It's

Similar wording

going to be a used car sales lot. All right. Okay. Thank you. Questions or comments from

Similar wording

Artaria? Just a couple of questions. In our paperwork, it looks like the tenants are Roberto

Similar wording

and Miguel Gomez. Is Mr. Giordano Gomez, I know they said brothers, are they part of the same

Similar wording

company or just i want to clarify that there are partners in this uh venture uh all three of them

Similar wording

are going to be part of the the business i don't believe they have a corporation um mr gomez do

Similar wording

you have a corporation formed um yes we do have a corporation that is already active in the states

Similar wording

of pennsylvania and it's the three of us with equal ownership okay and also you indicated um

Similar wording

about the the repairs would be accessory um but in your application you don't have the word

Similar wording

accessory just so you know it's both of the uses it doesn't say one's accessory to the other

Similar wording

yeah the intent was to have it as part of the uh primarily as a sales lot with the

Similar wording

mechanic shopping taking up the smaller portion of the work okay i'm just pointing it out to you

Similar wording

you used accessory not that there's a problem but you have both uses okay understood questions or

Similar wording

comments from the virtual audience i see no hands planning commission thank you chairman and good

Similar wording

afternoon david fecto with the city planning commission chairman and board members the

Similar wording

comprehensive plan recommends a change in zoning at this location from cmx2 commercial mixed use

Similar wording

to icmx industrial commercial mixed use the west side of kensington avenue still carries its

Similar wording

original 1933 zoning the proposed personal vehicle repair and maintenance and personal vehicle sales

Similar wording

and rental are both allowed with a special exception in icmx and this property has a documented

Similar wording

history of auto related uses including a freight terminal and a gasoline service station dating to

Similar wording

at least the 1940s the city planning commission recommends the board grant the proposed use

Similar wording

variances. MI 2026 002 520 36

Similar wording

MI 2026-002-520-3698 Kensington Avenue. I vote yes. Michael Johns, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes. Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Taya Nguyen, my vote is yes. Layla Beebe, my vote is yes. Thank you. Thank you council. Number 14,

Similar wording

MI 2026-002-513-5851 Warrington Avenue.

Similar wording

Lisa Kapla Davis is the owner applicant.

Similar wording

do we see lisa yes chair lisa kepler davis has been promoted okay

Similar wording

lisa kepler you have been promoted and you're allowed to speak please unmute yourself good

Similar wording

morning good good morning good morning hi could you please state and spell your name for the

Similar wording

phonographer? Lisa Davis Caple, L-I-S-A Davis, D-A-V-I-S Caple, C-A-P-L-E. All right. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, sir. I see you have a letter of support from the Third Ward Executive Committee. Is that correct?

Similar wording

That is correct, sir. And our Vice Chair has a few questions for you.

Similar wording

good afternoon um have you submitted your documents and exhibits 14 days in advance for

Similar wording

your hearing yes ma'am okay and this is your understanding that you're here for a referral

Similar wording

for a personal care home that is correct okay all right so um you can share your screen we

Similar wording

have your documents and tell us what you'd like to do so my my daughter actually is going to be

Similar wording

i'm the owner of the property she is going it's going to be her business her baby so she has all

Similar wording

the documents and she should be sharing her screen um i guess she can raise her hand so

Similar wording

she can be born too because she has all the documents and uh able to go through step by

Similar wording

step all that so you'll go through the documents and she'll just put them up for you am i correct

Similar wording

no she's going to go through the documents and put them up listen um hold on our attorney has a

Similar wording

comment here we don't have any information about your daughter all we have is information about

Similar wording

yourself and you indicated you were the owner applicant so we don't have any information

Similar wording

for her to basically have standing in this if i mean okay but you have to be doing the

Similar wording

presentation then we don't have any documentation about her that is fine and i'm so sorry that

Similar wording

didn't go through because through the whole process she has been the contact person but

Similar wording

that is fine she could i guess i'm assuming she still have to share her screen because she has

Similar wording

the document yeah and you'll just tell her when to move the documents okay okay but again you can

Similar wording

call her as a witness but it's your presentation now okay thank you so much and her name is she

Similar wording

should be in the room i guess you raise your hand so you can be brought in what's her name brittany

Similar wording

davis i have promoted britney thank you

Similar wording

britney davis you are now a panelist can you unmute yourself please and then you will be

Similar wording

allowed to speak good morning good morning could you please um just put the documents up

Similar wording

and your mom will do the testimony, okay?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right, Mom, so you could just start,

Similar wording

and then I'll hear the information for, like,

Similar wording

the property overview and all that stuff.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So we are basically proposing to establish a 24-hour residential home

Similar wording

housing six girls between the ages of 12 and 18.

Similar wording

A little background history,

Similar wording

the reason why we decided to do this is because I am a medical provider and

Similar wording

Brittany is a social worker who's been working in this capacity for 10 plus years now.

Similar wording

We came up with this idea of me being a foster parent in my past,

Similar wording

coming up with this idea to continue our help with children in our community in the same

Similar wording

community in which I raised her in. So the goal for the housing for the group home is to provide

Similar wording

like a safe, structured, family-oriented environment where youth who have been

Similar wording

family-oriented environment where where youth who have been um unfortunately were able to

Similar wording

experience some stability guidance and a sense of belonging um we are just uh asking for the

Similar wording

board's approval to the to for this property to be um rezoned as we are now and um it's

Similar wording

is listed as a single-family home and we're asking for residential, I mean, because we're

Similar wording

in a residential zoning district, we're asking for the zoning to be changed to, I guess, you know.

Similar wording

Why don't you, why don't you have the documents you need to present put up?

Similar wording

Okay. Brittany?

Similar wording

Yep. Am I able to, am I able to share my screen?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

You should be.

Similar wording

Can you see my screen?

Similar wording

Yeah, I see it now, yeah.

Similar wording

Why don't you just put it up?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

It's got a...

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

okay so that's the location I see that yes and this is the um schematics of the apartment

Similar wording

so why don't you explain what's up now so what's up now is the the house as it stands now um um

Similar wording

which was presented by um an architect so if you look there's it's got to make it bigger I'm on my

Similar wording

phone i'm sorry so you if you look from the first screen it's showing the lower level which is the

Similar wording

basement which has an attached garage in the in the basement there's an exit to the outside from

Similar wording

the basement and there's an exit for to the outside from the garage as well and then there's

Similar wording

an opening from the garage into the basement inside on the first picture on the second picture

Similar wording

is showing the first floor where in the entry there's an enclosed porch then you

Similar wording

come into the common area which is the living room and then there's a dining

Similar wording

room and then there's a kitchen off to the back if you see where the lines are

Similar wording

there's an exterior deck from the dining room there's a door that leads off to a

Similar wording

small deck where you can store a trash can, a grill, you know. And then on the

Similar wording

third picture is showing the upper floor, which is the first bedroom, which the

Similar wording

plan is to house three young ladies. The second bedroom, which is the smallest of

Similar wording

the three, we said that we can put one in the back room which housed two females.

Similar wording

and there's a bathroom on the second floor which is a full bathroom with the

Similar wording

shower tub combo to go back to the first floor I'm sorry there is a half bathroom

Similar wording

on the first floor was just a sink and a toilet off of the dining room like sits

Similar wording

between the living room in the dining room area you know we have photos we

Similar wording

should

Similar wording

All right. These are some of the photos that we have.

Similar wording

Explain what that is, please.

Similar wording

Yes. So this is the property as it stands. If you see when you come in,

Similar wording

there's a step up from the enclosed porch that's open to the living room and then the dining room

Similar wording

and then the kitchen towards the back. That fireplace is just decorative. There's no

Similar wording

venting or anything or fire use to it. Then you have the the bathroom that's on

Similar wording

the side which is just a toilet sink a powder room you know as you would say.

Similar wording

This is the exterior of the property. Small front yard this has been cemented.

Similar wording

It was grass like the neighbors on each side of me but during my occupancy I

Similar wording

had it uh uh concreted over um go to the next picture

Similar wording

or more pictures of the powder room this is just going up the steps

Similar wording

okay kitchen

Similar wording

so this is the back bedroom that we plan on housing two

Similar wording

occupants in this back bedroom if you can see from the other end there's a

Similar wording

closet and this alcove there's a closet on each side so it'll be two closets to have them um

Similar wording

have their um clothing and you know storage of their personal properties in each of those closets

Similar wording

this is the middle bedroom which is will be a single bedroom located

Similar wording

This is the middle bedroom, which will be a single bedroom located where you see the doorknob to your left, there's a closet there.

Similar wording

I'm not sure we have a picture of the inside of it. This is facing from the top of the steps from the back bedroom.

Similar wording

This is the full bathroom that's on the second floor, like I said, the tub shower combo.

Similar wording

I don't know if we have a picture of the other angle, there is a storage closet in there

Similar wording

to provide for towels and washcloths and all.

Similar wording

This picture we're looking at here is the main bedroom, which we, based on the square

Similar wording

footage, we assume we can get three children in that room.

Similar wording

This is a wide closet, okay, this is another angle of the bathroom.

Similar wording

This is back to the hallway.

Similar wording

middle room going backwards but it's just not in order sorry

Similar wording

all right back to the front bedroom this is the footage of the square of the bedroom

Similar wording

babe we're talking about the the main bedroom which um could occupy um up to three uh girls

Similar wording

back to the front of the house from the living room looking outside

Similar wording

it's at the end of the pictures yes that's all the photos okay and then this is the rco how let

Similar wording

me at least let me ask you this how is your next door neighbors on either side so the the the

Similar wording

neighbors on the left of me um their that that property is owned by um a private owner just

Similar wording

boarded from an LLC and he does a rooming house so those neighbors aren't

Similar wording

concerned about us having a group home and my neighbor to the right of me is

Similar wording

actually an elderly neighbor who is one of my good friends who was theirs when I

Similar wording

moved there for the house in my in my 20s when my children were old younger

Similar wording

with that used to watch my children who is has my back in this project all right questions from the

Similar wording

board okay so you said um you're gonna have um six girls you said from 12 to 18 yes ma'am is that okay

Similar wording

Okay. And where will these young ladies come from?

Similar wording

So they will come from DHS. So we plan to obtain a relationship with DHS and the services like Kua.

Similar wording

My daughter, because like I said in the beginning, she's a social worker. She has a lot of relationships already with those companies and her daily workings.

Similar wording

So that's why I wanted her to get on here and I can call her as a witness to testify

Similar wording

to that part of the question because that would be her part of working on that.

Similar wording

And have you done this before?

Similar wording

Have I ran a group home before?

Similar wording

No, I have not, but I have raised five children, four of my own.

Similar wording

I've raised my godson since he was two months old and I was a foster parent for about six

Similar wording

years back in the 2000s so i am well versed in raising children i am a nurse practitioner so i

Similar wording

have the medical background and you know about you know health and healing and raising and you know

Similar wording

what i mean the things of that nature that because we wanted to be not like a group home in a sense

Similar wording

of a institution we wanted to be more home home based so you feel more like home like a family

Similar wording

You know what I mean? And now I've never done a group home, but I've been a mother for many years and, you know, some things just come, you know, naturally and tending to children and making them feel loved and at home is something I've done most of my life. Like I said, I even was a foster parent at a point in my life.

Similar wording

Okay. And how many employees?

Similar wording

I'm going to divert that question to Brittany.

Similar wording

You can.

Similar wording

We have to call her.

Similar wording

with this we'd have to call her as a witness so so i can call britney as a witness i'm sorry please

Similar wording

state and spell your name britney um britney davis b-r-i-t-t-a-n-y last name d as in dog a-d-i-s

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm the total truth told truth nothing but the truth yes we should please proceed

Similar wording

oh i'm sorry so britney so the question was proposed of um the first question was what we

Similar wording

would get the children from who will be housed at that location and the second question was um um

Similar wording

oh i just had a brain fog i'm sorry how many employees how many employees

Similar wording

how many employees how many employees do we have i'm sorry thank you so much

Similar wording

what we have. I'm sorry. Thank you so much.

Similar wording

thank you um so yes we plan to uh get a contract have a contract with um the department of human

Similar wording

services once we go through licensing and inspection through l and i and everything

Similar wording

um we will be getting our children from um dhs we plan to have as far as staffing um

Similar wording

during our first we plan to have three shifts those during the first shift it would be a one

Similar wording

a six ratio with the children during the second shift it will be a one to three ratio where it

Similar wording

will be two staff and six girls and then overnight would be um one to six ratio

Similar wording

and can you do that one more time that kind of went that you kind of went fast do that one more

Similar wording

time i'm sorry during the first shift which is going to be from seven to three thirty we're

Similar wording

going to have one step um the expectation is that the children will be um in school during those

Similar wording

hours but we still would have somebody on site um just in case a child gets sick or they not

Similar wording

enrolled in school yet um things of that sort um during the second shift which will be from 3

Similar wording

to 11 30 we will have two staff um on site with six children so the ratio will be one to three

Similar wording

um during that time they will be getting assistance with homework doing chores meal prep

Similar wording

um things of that sort um and then for third shift which would be 11 to 7 30 um it would be

Similar wording

one staff doing rounds every hour checking on the girls making sure you know linens don't need to

Similar wording

be washed and then it's just like a 30 minute overlaps for each shift to give the staff time

Similar wording

to debrief and communicate with each other um you know what was going on the previous shift

Similar wording

okay and how many bedrooms and how many this is so this is a three bedroom um home is one

Similar wording

one full bedroom and a half bedroom

Similar wording

okay thank you and what area will the staff be designated for staff i'm sorry say that again

Similar wording

what area in the other home will be designated for staff like to do paperwork

Similar wording