civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 5, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 5, 20267h 25m

reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy yes i do all right thank you you can

Similar wording

your screen to proceed with your case so joe why don't we do this why don't uh why don't you call

Similar wording

your client a one for us and i'm going to um um have the interpreter you know give her the oath

Similar wording

okay okay fair enough um an interpreter quiere darte el auguramento okay okay please state her

Similar wording

name and spelled for the stenographer okay si no puede dar su nombre y deletriado para el reporter

Similar wording

jennifer garcia jennifer garcia g-e-n-n-i-f-e-r garcia g-e-n-n-i-f-e-r-c-i-a

Similar wording

jure y afirma decir la verdad toda la verdad nada más que la verdad

Similar wording

yes all right mr vicario could you start your presentation

Similar wording

and then i could go slow but then during my pauses if the interpreter could please

Similar wording

for what i said for absolutely okay so jennifer is the principal of jg cosmetics the listed owner

Similar wording

of this property and this is an application to permit two units on the property así que jennifer

Similar wording

She is the principal of JG Cosmetics and she is the owner of the property and in the

Similar wording

solicitude, she is asking permission for two units in the property.

Similar wording

When the property was purchased on December 12th of 2023, it already had the two units.

Similar wording

When the property was purchased on December 12th of 2023, it already had the two units.

Similar wording

And if I could start sharing my screen, we could go to the corrected plans.

Similar wording

In the initial set of plans, it was misidentified as C Street, and then I supplemented it and corrected it with the corrected plans.

Similar wording

It said D Street.

Similar wording

So the basement is not being used strictly for storage.

Similar wording

on the first floor the the applicant is seeking to legalize a smaller unit in the rear which is

Similar wording

highlighted in pink or red and then the larger unit is on the first floor the front half of the

Similar wording

first floor and the full second floor así que aquí están los planos corregidos este fueron

Similar wording

mal identificado como C-street y yo suplementé para que lo corrigieran en los planos como D-street.

Similar wording

Así que aquí está el sótano, no está siendo utilizado, es solamente para almacén.

Similar wording

El primer piso, la aplicante está buscando legalizar una unidad más pequeña en la parte de atrás.

Similar wording

This is in red or red here, and then the biggest unit that is in the first floor is in the bottom.

Similar wording

The entrance to the larger unit would be on the front, where D Street is, and that's where my cursor is hovering over that staircase and that entrance.

Similar wording

Así que la entrada de la unidad más grande sería aquí en la parte del frente, donde está ubicada la Death Street, y a donde estoy apuntando ahora mismo, que es las escaleras.

Similar wording

Y esa unidad es aproximadamente 910 pies cuadrados.

Similar wording

unit that entrance would be in the rear alley

Similar wording

y ahora estoy señalando la entrada de la unidad más pequeña y eso estaría en la

Similar wording

parte de atrás de entrada y esa unidad aproximadamente 366 pies cuadrados

Similar wording

The approximate rent of the larger unit is 1200 feet and the approximate rent for the smaller unit is 700 square feet.

Similar wording

So the approximate rent of the larger unit is 1200 feet and the approximate rent of the smaller unit is 700 feet.

Similar wording

If I could show you some photographs.

Similar wording

Yeah, thank you, Joe.

Similar wording

Okay, so.

Similar wording

Something's off there.

Similar wording

We got to, we got to re-center something.

Similar wording

We will fix that shortly.

Similar wording

Do you see a letter?

Similar wording

we see a letter but it's kind of we we needed to be enlarged okay i i was going to show you

Similar wording

the photos first so sure that's good smaller i could show you the photos first and then we'll

Similar wording

and then we'll get to the letters okay uh so here's a photo of the front of the building

Similar wording

with its posting with its poster

Similar wording

Here is a photo of the rear of the building, with the entrance, to the basement, my cursor is over the entrance to the basement,

Similar wording

And here is the entrance to the smaller unit in the back.

Similar wording

And here is where the trash is being stored.

Similar wording

And again, that entrance would be from the rear alley.

Similar wording

Y esa entrada es del callejón de atrás.

Similar wording

Así que aquí está la vista, una de las direcciones del callejón.

Similar wording

Muchos de los residentes se estacionan en la parte de atrás de este callejón.

Similar wording

one of the neighbors, the rear entry to their property, here's another view of another

Similar wording

Another image from the back of the house of the neighbors.

Similar wording

interpreter, interpret, and then I have another set of properties.

Similar wording

At 4952 D Street, that was approved for multifamily, although I'm not sure how many units.

Similar wording

At 512 East Roosevelt that was approved for two units.

Similar wording

At 512 East Roosevelt, that was approved for two units.

Similar wording

La 512 East Roosevelt fue aprobada para dos unidades.

Similar wording

And at 514 East Roosevelt that was for six units.

Similar wording

Y la 514 East Roosevelt fue aprobada para seis unidades.

Similar wording

And I have those listings which I'm showing you.

Similar wording

You do?

Similar wording

Go ahead.

Similar wording

Y tengo eso listado que le estoy enseñando.

Similar wording

further up my client has been able to obtain some individual letters of support from some specific

Similar wording

near neighbors especially the immediate neighbors I could show you those y ahora estoy demostrando

Similar wording

cartas de apoyo de los vecinos alrededor, vecinos específicos.

Similar wording

From T. Anderson at 5015, D Street, en calle D, then we have Edwin Budalife, B-O-L-U,

Similar wording

W-A-T-I-F-E

Similar wording

At 5011 D Street

Similar wording

501 D Street

Similar wording

Emily Yelena at 5009 D Street

Similar wording

Emily Yelena, 5009-Destrick.

Similar wording

Joe, ¿cuántas letras tienes?

Similar wording

Eso fue tres.

Similar wording

Un.

Similar wording

Un total de cuatro letras en addition

Similar wording

a la letra del RCO.

Similar wording

Muchas gracias.

Similar wording

Sí, que son cuatro cartas y esta es también la carta del RCO.

Similar wording

Ok, puedo parar de compartir eso

Similar wording

y luego puedo simplemente scrollar a través de los otros

Similar wording

exhibits, oh sorry, and again I'm showing the uh, I'm going to focus on some interior photos of the

Similar wording

property in addition to the deed the tax clearance certificate the letter of

Similar wording

support from the RCO proof of mailing and we have here we go some interior

Similar wording

photos of the property so we have a bedroom 4

Similar wording

así que ahora me voy a enfocar en las diferentes evidencias para esta

Similar wording

propiedad vamos a enfocarnos en las fotos interiores este de la propiedad en la

Similar wording

escritura de la propiedad los certificados de impuestos las cartas de

Similar wording

apoyo del rco y la evidencia de correo postal aquí están las fotos interiores

Similar wording

empezando con el cuarto número 4

Similar wording

tenemos la segunda cocina

Similar wording

Y tenemos la sala, tenemos el baño, aquí está el otro cuarto, aquí está el cuarto primordial,

Similar wording

Here's another bedroom, here's the other kitchen, and to the right right is the staircase.

Similar wording

I'll show you that photo shortly.

Similar wording

Y le voy a enseñar esa foto. Aquí está otro cuarto. Y ahí está en la escalera. Y yendo para el segundo piso.

Similar wording

I've shown I've shown the board are our exhibits are there any questions of the board si que le

Similar wording

he enseñado a la junta la evidencia si hay alguna pregunta de la junta

Similar wording

why don't we have the interpreter have your testimony adopted okay my clients

Similar wording

coming to the computer one book but I beg the boards indulgence up here she is okay

Similar wording

who's there and would you like

Similar wording

Would you like me to ask her if she accepts the testimony from the attorney?

Similar wording

Okay, I'm going to ask that in English, so we have a clear record.

Similar wording

Ms. Garcia, have you heard my presentation?

Similar wording

Señora Garcia, usted ha escuchado la presentación.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And you saw it and you agree with it?

Similar wording

Y usted lo vio, usted está de acuerdo con la presentación.

Similar wording

yes and you have any corrections or other additions to my testimony tiene alguna

Similar wording

corrección o alguna adicción para este testimonio everything's fine and would you

Similar wording

adopt it as your own if you were testifying y usted adoptaría este testimonio como el

Similar wording

propio su propio este si estuviera testificando yes any questions of the board questions from the

Similar wording

Yes, I have one question about access to the basement. In the plans that you showed, it looked like the access to the basement was in the smaller unit, but the stairwell cuts into the new unit you've created on the first and the second floor. What is happening with the stairwell that was coming from inside to the basement?

Similar wording

The only access to the basement is from the back alley.

Similar wording

and i could show you that those photos again you showed the you showed the back alley entrance to

Similar wording

the basement but there's still the stairwell on the plan and so what is what is happening with

Similar wording

that stairwell are you closing it off was it removed can you go back to the play go back to

Similar wording

the plans for the plans gladly

Similar wording

and are there any photos of the basement at all no we the basement's not being used we took no

Similar wording

photos of the of the basement um find the plans

Similar wording

here we go so um can you see uh the basement can you see the plans

Similar wording

yes okay so there's no staircase in the basement

Similar wording

okay and that's correct right miss garcia there's no is there is there a staircase in the basement

Similar wording

going from the basement to any of the units or no y señora garcia hay escaleras desde el sótano

Similar wording

No, she said no. She said no. The only staircase is from the front of the first floor leading up to that second floor.

Similar wording

Así que la única escalera es desde el primer piso y yendo hacia el segundo piso.

Similar wording

Y claro, está la escalera de atrás que van de el callejón a la unidad de atrás.

Similar wording

and floor respectively for each unit.

Similar wording

Así que la otra pregunta acerca de las utilidades.

Similar wording

¿Fueron movidas las utilidades del sótano al primero o segundo

Similar wording

piso para cada unidad?

Similar wording

Usted lo sabe, señora, donde está la electricidad, gas.

Similar wording

De eso no hay gas ahí.

Similar wording

OK, well, the electricity.

Similar wording

Where's the electricity?

Similar wording

Where are they?

Similar wording

Is it outside in the back alley, though?

Similar wording

Tiene su electricidad en la de antes y el de atrás.

Similar wording

Y a dónde está ubicada la electricidad?

Similar wording

En cada apartamento.

Similar wording

En la parte de atrás, afuera, adentro?

Similar wording

Lo mire tan afuera.

Similar wording

La caja tiene una caja principal para cada apartamento.

Similar wording

so there is an electrical box for every apartment the meters are outside but

Similar wording

every apartment has its own electrical boxer for each unit okay and just to

Similar wording

confirm this is an all-electric building y para confirmar este un edificio que

Similar wording

es completamente electricidad correct and then where the water where's the

Similar wording

where's the water heater y el calentador de agua

Similar wording

water heater y el calentador de agua

Similar wording

it's electric as well understand that but where is the water tank

Similar wording

y a donde está y el tanque de agua a donde está ubicado porque no lo vemos en el plano

Similar wording

cada uno hay un uno de esos de los galones de agua en el de adelante está

Similar wording

al entrar hay una parte que está sellada y todo donde está el calentador de agua cada uno tiene

Similar wording

su parte de calentador de agua pero cerrado so each unit has their gallon of the water heater

Similar wording

and it's closed off but each unit has it the first one has it as you go in but it's also closed off

Similar wording

What do you mean it's closed off?

Similar wording

So it's like a small door with a closet that has the water heater.

Similar wording

Okay, so each unit has their electrical panel and their water heater in the unit respectively.

Similar wording

and the owner is going to be the only person with access to this basement door

Similar wording

correct okay thank you

Similar wording

yeah i just i just have one i guess one question comment

Similar wording

The three-bedroom unit has just a very small living kitchen area for that size unit.

Similar wording

And because we don't have any images of the basement, I'm still trying to understand we've got a basement that's a full height that's essentially above grade in the back.

Similar wording

And you're not using it for anything.

Similar wording

um that seems odd when this space for the living room dining room kitchen is all in the space of

Similar wording

about 100 square feet for a three bedroom unit so i think the i think the the density of the

Similar wording

the building is just too tight um or too much for this building and the fact that the folks

Similar wording

that live in this other you know i'm saying a lot has to walk through a driveway to get to a public

Similar wording

So, I have a question, a comment.

Similar wording

The unit of three rooms has a very small kitchen room for that size.

Similar wording

And as we don't have images of the sótano, I'm still trying to understand.

Similar wording

We have a whole sótano that is above the level of the floor in the back, and they don't use it for anything.

Similar wording

Eso parece extraño cuando el espacio para la sala de estar, el comedor y la cocina está a unos 100 pies cuadrados para una unidad de tres habitaciones.

Similar wording

Así que la densidad del edificio es como que está muy estrecha.

Similar wording

Hay como que mucho en ese espacio.

Similar wording

Y también que tienen que caminar por la entrada donde se estaciona, que es un sitio público.

Similar wording

any other questions you otra pregunta

Similar wording

questions from our attorney Hillary not at this time mr. chair questions or comments from the

Similar wording

virtual audience in no age chair planning commission Amy Boyd with the planning commission

Similar wording

a y b o y d do you swear referring to tell the truth whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends no change in zoning at this location from the current RSA-5 residential single family.

Similar wording

The applicant has not demonstrated that there are unique physical conditions or circumstances of the property that would prevent it from being used in conformance with the zoning code.

Similar wording

física única o circunstancia de esta propiedad que previene que se utilice conforme al código

Similar wording

de zonificación. No hay evidencia que el convertir a dos unidades fue hecho con beneficio

Similar wording

The planning commission recommends that the board deny the requested variance for two family household living.

Similar wording

for two family household living el comité de planeo recomienda que la junta denegue

Similar wording

el pedido de la variancia de dos una unidad o una vivienda de dos familias

Similar wording

Thank you. Joe, we're going to hold this till Monday next Wednesday at 9 30 AM.

Similar wording

We're going to take you to executive session where we'll discuss the comments made by the planning commission and also some of the members.

Similar wording

Asi que nosotros vamos a aguantar la decisión para el miércoles que viene a las 9 y media.

Similar wording

Nosotros vamos a tener una sesión ejecutiva donde vamos a hablar y discutir los comentarios

Similar wording

que fueron hechos por el comité de planos y vamos a hablar acerca de esto con los miembros de la junta.

Similar wording

was this discussion of the basement and how that may be addressed so all right so all of this will

Similar wording

be closed except for your presentation of photos of the basement okay okay much appreciated thank

Similar wording

you okay thank you uh andy what's that joe you froze you froze okay um do you require further

Similar wording

interpretation oh and thank you very much by the way we do appreciate your help

Similar wording

thank you for using the service have a great afternoon

Similar wording

we're going to go to number 10 uh we have a um malam ma la lay malaylam interpreter

Similar wording

Could our interpreter please come on?

Similar wording