Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA STATED MEETING Room 400, City Hall Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Thursday, June 21, 2018 11:20 a.m. PRESENT: COUNCIL PRESIDENT DARRELL L. CLARKE COUNCILWOMAN CINDY BASS COUNCILWOMAN JANNIE L. BLACKWELL COUNCILMAN ALLAN DOMB COUNCILMAN DEREK S. GREEN COUNCILMAN WILLIAM K. GREENLEE COUNCILWOMAN HELEN GYM COUNCILMAN BOBBY HENON COUNCILMAN KENYATTA JOHNSON COUNCILMAN CURTIS JONES, JR. COUNCILMAN DAVID OH COUNCILMAN BRIAN J. O'NEILL COUNCILWOMAN CHERELLE L. PARKER COUNCILWOMAN MARIA D. QUINONES-SANCHEZ COUNCILWOMAN BLONDELL REYNOLDS BROWN COUNCILMAN MARK SQUILLA COUNCILMAN AL TAUBENBERGER MICHAEL A. DECKER, CHIEF CLERK Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Good morning, everybody. I note that the hour has come and that a quorum is present here in this City Council Chambers, and Council will now come to order. Members, would you please take your seat. Visitors, if you will retire to your seats outside of the rails before the proceedings. I would ask all those who are present, please put your cell phones on silent or vibrant. And I appreciate that. To give our invocation this morning, the Chair recognizes Pastor John Babowitch of Our Lady of Calvary. He is here today as the guest of Councilman O'Neill, and I would ask that all members and guests please rise. (Councilmembers, guests, and visitors rise.)
In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, God is love. There's a desire to make us share in his love. He Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the world to come to our aid and in gentle kindness to help those who are weak, sick or unfortunate. In his love for all of us, Christ said that whatever we do for the least among us, we do for him. He called those who show mercy blessed of his father and promised an eternal life. Let us pray to the Lord's richest blessings. All the members of City Council who are devoted to helping their brothers and sisters, let us pray. Blessed are you, Lord God of Mercy, who through your son gave a marvelous example of charity. Bless all our members of City Council and their families as they work for the wonderful work of the City of Philadelphia. Bless them and strengthen them in every way. Bless all life, born and unborn. Bless all of us here present. Bless all of their aides, all those that serve to make this Council a wonderful working model, and who through the great Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 us a marvelous example of charity and set the commandment of love for one another. Send down your blessings on these, your servants, who generously devote themselves to helping others. When they are called on in times of need, let them faithfully serve you and their neighbor. We ask this through Christ, our Lord. The Lord be with you. May almighty God bless you all, in the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. (Amen.)
Thank you. The Chair thanks the Pastor for his invocation. The Council will be at ease. (Council at ease.)
The next order of business is the approval of the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, June Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 14th, 2018. The Chair now recognizes Councilman Greenlee.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I move that the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, June 14th, 2018 be approved.
It has been moved and properly seconded that the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, June 14th, 2018 stand approved. All in favor will signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and the Journal is approved. The next order of business will be requests of leave of absence. The Chair recognizes Councilman Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. On behalf of the majority, there are no requests for leave of absence today.
The Chair thanks the gentleman. The Chair recognizes Councilman O'Neill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. On behalf of the republicans, there are no requests for leave of absence.
The Chair thanks the gentleman. The Chair will now dispense with its regular order of business and recognize that the guests and visitors that are joining us here today in our great Chambers of the City of Philadelphia. On behalf of all members of City Council, I welcome you all to our Council session. We appreciate you taking your time out to join us and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 in all its affairs for the City of Philadelphia and certainly invite you to come back soon. At this time, the Chair recognizes Councilman Jones, who will present a resolution recognizing Smith Memorial Playground & Playhouse. Would Meg Wise and those accompanying her please join the Councilman at the podium. (Councilmembers and guests approached podium.)
The Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee, Councilman O'Neill, Councilman Oh, Councilman Taubenberger, and Councilman Green.
So for the past 120 years, if you've ever approached that giant wooden sliding board, you couldn't help but find the kid, the inner kid, within you. I remember my first time on that wooden sliding board, and all the sudden, wheeee. That's all you can do. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 years ago, I took my staff back out. We have a thing called Freedom Friday where we explore parts of the district that we need to see so that there is a frame of reference to that particular place. Now, I will admit that the sliding board somehow has gotten smaller in my mind over the years, but when my staff went down it, everybody to a person said, wheeee. So that has not changed. Smith Playground has had over 200,000 visitors a year from every part of Philadelphia, every district, but not just in Philadelphia but outside, and is what I call a regional asset. It's one of those things that doesn't belong to one Councilperson. It belongs to all Councilpeople. And I'd like to say -
It's in the Fourth, though. I was going to get to that. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the individuals up here have decided to make Smith Playground their own, meaning they put their money where their mouth is and contributed to Smith Playground, for which I am truly grateful. And I know on firsthand Councilman Johnson took his children there. And was the wheeee factor in effect?
Sliding board, the whole nine. And if we keep regional assets well maintained, we are better off as Philadelphians, because when people come to visit us, they remember those places that they experienced. And if it was a dump, they remember that. But if it's well kept as a treasure as it should be, that's what they remember. So without further adieu, recognizing and honoring Smith Memorial Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 & Playhouse, for providing Philadelphia children and families with a free, open, safe play space for the past 120 years.
And it's always an honor and a privilege to have the opportunity to have gracing with the Smith Memorial Playground & Playhouse stakeholders, newly elected State Representative Malcolm Kenyatta. Thank you for being here with us today. Whereas, Smith Memorial Playground & Playhouse was built with a bequest from Richard and Sarah Smith, and was dedicated to the memory of their adult son, Stanfield; and
Whereas, Smith's beautiful 16,000 square foot Playhouse was designed solely as a play space for children by one of Philadelphia's most prominent late 19th Century architects, James H. Windrim; and
Whereas, Smith remains a welcoming, safe and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 200,000 Philadelphians annually where differences are valued. Smith facilitates education and interaction among children and families of different backgrounds in order to promote understanding and acceptance of diversity; and
On a personal note, I'd like to thank the leadership of Smith Playground for hosting our Annual Autism Play Date, which will be August 11th of this year, and thank you for hosting autistic families from all over the City of Philadelphia. Whereas, Smith maintains a long tradition of free admission for families and develops relationships with community organizations in an effort to further the development of healthy children, strong families, and safe communities; and
Whereas, Smith provides opportunities for children in the Philadelphia Area, and beyond, to Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 physically, emotionally, and intellectually; and
Whereas, Smith is active in an integrated, collaborative group of East Fairmount Park stakeholders, and works to increase access to the park and draw visitors to the area, including residents and tourists, for a variety of outdoor and play-inspired activities and learning; and
Councilman Jones, now I know who the kids were complaining about. Whereas, Smith provides year-round urban nature play, maximizing the natural resources available to Smith in its unique location, and enabling children and families to enjoy their offerings throughout all four seasons. Smith is a steward of its park and woods, and purposefully shapes programs around its tremendous asset; and
Whereas, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 like "Play-A-Palooza," "Kidchella Music Festival," "Healthy Halloween," and "Winter Wonderland" to provide children and families an opportunity to make new friends and participate in fun activities while learning about the importance of play; and Whereas, Smith's reach is national, but it has a special commitment to and relationship with the families and children in the surrounding neighborhoods. Smith's 200,000 visitors come from 500-plus zip codes to see the Playground every year, but Smith feels a sense of belonging to the local community in particular and serving them is a priority; now, therefore, be it
Resolved, by the Council of the City of Philadelphia, that it hereby recognizes and honors Smith Memorial Playground & Playhouse for providing Philadelphia children and families with free, open and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 past 120 years. (Applause.)
Further resolved, that an engrossed copy of this resolution -- I'm doing my job here -- be presented to the staff -- and that's important -- to the staff and board of Smith Memorial Playground & Playhouse as further evidence of the sincere admiration and appreciation of this legislative body. Congratulations. (Applause.)
Thank you all so much. I also want to thank my board members who are up here with me, Malcolm Kenyatta and Betty Pettine. Thank you. (Applause.)
And my Smith staff members, Kate Zmich, Cheryl Carson, and Shadirah Myrick are also with me. Thank you. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (Applause.)
Everything I would have wanted to tell you about what a treasure and a civic asset Smith is was already summed up in the resolution. We're so proud and we're so grateful to City Council for recognizing how Smith serves children and families. As Councilman Jones said, our visitors to Smith come from every Council district throughout the City and close to 200,000 every year. They come free of charge, and they come to Smith to set a foundation for children to grow up to be happy, healthy, ready to learn, and ready to engage in civic society. Children spending time in play is the most important way that parents can help their children grow up, and I'm really proud and grateful that all of our elected officials up here with us recognize the importance of that time spent for children. So thank you all so much. I Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 that Councilman Jones has been just an absolute champion for Smith. We're very proud to be in the Fourth District, and we're very honored that we are serving all of the families of Philadelphia. I also want to give a special thank you to other people who have been super supportive of Smith, including Council President Clarke, Councilman Squilla, Councilman Johnson, Councilwoman Blackwell, Councilwoman Parker, and Councilman Green and Greenlee and Oh. So thank you all so much, and please come visit Smith. If it's been a while, it's better than ever. So I hope to see you out there on the slide. And wheeee. (Applause.)
Thank you for your remarks. Council will be at ease. (Council at ease.)
At this Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 time, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown, who will present a resolution recognizing the Office of Special Events. I think this should be pretty special today. Would Jazelle Jones and those accompanying her please join the Councilwoman at the podium. (Councilmembers and guests approached podium.)
The Chair also recognizes that Councilman Greenlee, Councilman Jones, Councilman Oh, Councilwoman Maria Quinones-Sanchez, Councilwoman Blackwell, Councilwoman Gym, Councilwoman Parker are also joined and waving hello from Councilman Taubenberger.
I think we're joined by all members of Council, all for Jaz.
Councilman Brian O'Neill and I had the good fortune Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 board of the Philadelphia Visitors and Convention Bureau, and our membership on that board affords us the opportunity to listen, learn, and to be excited on a regular basis about how well Philadelphia is doing in the hospitality and tourism community. In fact, just yesterday the Philadelphia Visitors and Convention Bureau released its new motto called Frankly Philadelphia. And if you consider that, along with the fact that increasingly national professional organizations that work closely or look closely at hospitality and tourism are looking at the second largest city on the East Coast, naturally -- increasingly they're looking at our city, the first planned city in North America, and we all know it to be the first birthplace of America. We're being recognized as a city where you can walk through history, enjoy the local flavor of vibrant restaurants, as well as enjoy the culturally rich arts and culture Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 that, it's my pleasure this morning to honor and recognize the Office of Special Events on the occasion of the City of Philadelphia being recognized as the 2017 World Festival & Event City Award recipient.
Full disclosure, I know her. Second disclosure, she's worked for City government longer than me. Third disclosure, most people in City government like her better than me. (Applause.)
Whereas, the International Festival and Event Association's (IFEA) World Festival & Event City Award is given to those cities who have worked diligently to maintain an environment conducive to successful festivals and events; and Whereas, IFEA World Festival & Event City Award provides a platform from which to recognize the valiant work of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 City of Philadelphia's community in bringing about a successful execution of extraordinary events; and
Whereas, the City of Philadelphia has been honored as the 2017 recipient of the IFEA World Festival & Event City Award; and
Whereas, this is the fourth consecutive year the City of Philadelphia has received this award. Only Sydney, Australia can be said to have matched its accomplishment; and
Whereas, the consistent excellence in the field of events is due in large part to the tireless efforts of the Office of Special Events under the stewardship of The Honorable Jazelle M. Jones; and
Whereas, the Honorable Jazelle Jones has served as Deputy Managing Director and Director of Operations for the City of Philadelphia since 2005. In October 2017, Ms. Jones Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Tom Wolf as Judge of the Court of Judicial Discipline in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as well as a member of the Pennsylvania Emergency Management Council and a member of the Pennsylvania Commission for Women, her volunteer work. Ms. Jones was originally appointed by Mayor Street as Director of Planning for the Mayor's Office of Community Service, the City's Anti-Poverty Agency, in 2001. Prior to joining City government, Ms. Jones held numerous managerial positions in the private sector. She is the recipient of the Governor's Award for Local Government Excellence, the American Red Cross Humanitarian Award, the Mayor's MVP Award, and the NAACP National Voter Fund Award; and
And I would be remiss just to shortly briefly acknowledge that when the Pope came here to the City of Philadelphia, her and her team built that. When the Super Bowl, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 to the City of Philadelphia, her and her team built that. Made in America, Beyonce's Jay Z came here to the City of Philadelphia, her and her team built that. So any great festival that you see taking place here in the City of Philadelphia, her and her team built that. And so I just wanted to acknowledge your hard work and dedication, with Mechelle in the background. Whereas, the Honorable Jones in that capacity has proven herself responsible for the overwhelmingly successful coordination and execution of hundreds of parades, festivals, concerts, and other City events;
Whereas, in recent years, the City of Philadelphia has been the platform for veritable explosions in the magnitude and ambition of staged events, including two National Security Special Events, including the 2015 World Meeting of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Visit and the 2016 Democratic National Convention; and
Whereas, the World Meeting of Families took place over six days in September of 2015 and was highlighted by the visit of Pope Francis to Philadelphia. Preparation and planning for this event was a monumental task, but the Office of Special Events worked with other City and outside agencies to ensure it went off without a hitch. The Philadelphia Convention & Visitors Bureau placed the direct economic impact of the World Meeting of Families Congress at more than 29 million, and this figure does not even account for the Papal Mass on the Benjamin Franklin Parkway, where it drew an estimated one million people to the City of Philadelphia; and
Whereas, the Democratic National Convention brought tens of thousands of delegates and visitors to Philadelphia in July of 2016. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Events served on the front lines of the City's efforts in conceptualizing and carrying out this event, the total regional economic impact of which The U.S. Travel Association estimates at 180 million; and
Whereas, the City of Philadelphia hosted the 2017 NFL Draft Experience from April 27th to April 29th, the largest outdoor festival footprint ever created by the NFL, and way better than Dallas, way better. Widely lauded as a great success, the event was attended by more than 250,000 people and had a total economic impact of $94.9 million according to a study by the PHLCVB; and
Whereas, the Office of Special Events managed a number of operations for the 2017 Philly Free Streets event, a people-powered initiative of the City of Philadelphia, temporarily closing streets to cars, inviting people to walk, bike, and play. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 3.6 mile route from 3rd and Chestnut Streets to 5th and Indiana Avenue, Philly's Free Streets saw a participation of around 40,000 people, a 25 percent increase from 2016; and
Whereas, the Office of Special Events was responsible for the comprehensive operations plan for the 2018 Philadelphia Eagles Super Bowl Championship Parade. Well, we saw this. I saw it -you looked good. I saw you on TV here. An event of this scale usually requires six months of planning; under the leadership of the Office of Special Events, the City finalized plans in a matter of weeks. Total attendance is estimated at more than one million people; and
Whereas, the Office of Special Events further executed a wide variety of other projects in the 2017 calendar year, including: the 2017 Philadelphia Soul Championship Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Rally; Various Major Motion Pictures and Film Projects (GPFA); Citywide Social Media Task Force in the Mayor's Office; Monument Lab Activations and Events; Octavius Catto Statue Unveiling Ceremony; Wawa Welcome America Festival; Philadelphia Veterans Day Parade; Made in America Festival; Philadelphia Marathon Weekend; the 2018 Villanova University Championship Parade; and the 2026 FIFA World Cup Bid; and
Whereas, under the capable leadership of The Honorable Jazelle Jones, Mechelle Sabb, Ilia Ghee, Robert T. Allen, Olivia Gillison, Natalie Faragalli, Zina Van Sciver, and with special thanks to photographer William Foster, the Council sees no reason not to expect that the City of Philadelphia will once more be honored with the IFEA World Festival & Event City Award in 2018; therefore, be it
Resolved, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the City of Philadelphia, that we hereby recognize, honor and celebrate the Office of Special Events on the occasion of the City of Philadelphia being recognized as a 2017 IFEA World Festival & Event City Award recipient. Further resolved, that an engrossed copy of this resolution be presented to Honorable Jazelle Jones and her team, Deputy Managing Director and Director of Operations of the Office of Special Events, as evidence of the sincere sentiments of this legislative body. We thank you for the work that you do in lifting up our city. Congratulations. (Applause.)
It is truly an honor and a pleasure to be here this morning, and I want to say good morning Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 President, the Councilmembers, and guests. It's an honor that I stand before you here today. I am humbled and delighted that this body has formally recognized the Office of Special Events for its achievements over the past four years. On behalf of my staff gathered here with me today and all the members of the Special Events Task Force, I say thank you. The Office of Special Events does manage over 1,600 individual events per year. This impressive figure speaks to the overall health and vibrancy of Philadelphia's event landscape and hospitality industry as a whole. Special Events deliver measurable economic impact to the City and the region. They bring people together, creating lasting images and contribute immensely to the diverse tapestry that is the City of Philadelphia. I would personally like to Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 all the members of the body for your contributions and partnership in building a Philadelphia that has proven time and time again that it possesses the infrastructure, capacity, and proficiency to host large-scale signature events. And full disclosure, I would like to thank Councilman Curtis Jones, who puts up with me being out at events every weekend, and he's very patient about my time, because I really do love what I do and so does my team. Gladiators, yes, please. (Applause.)
There are only seven of us, but we're pretty mighty in what we do. We pledge to continue our tireless work with all of our partners to establish efficiencies across all facets of municipal government to ensure that the City of Philadelphia continues to remain its status as a preferred Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 producers, convention planners, and visitors from around the world. So I thank you. We thank you. We call the names, but I'd like for you to personally know who they are. This is Ilia Ghee, Zina Van Sciver, Natalie Faragalli, Mechelle Sabb, and I'm missing a few Gladiators. Robert is not here today. And I want to give a special shout-out to Bill, who makes sure that he covers everything we do. So thank you, Bill. And thank all of you. (Applause.)
The next order of business is communications. The Chair requests that the Sergeant-of-Arms please deliver to the messages from the Mayor to the Chief Clerk. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Clerk, would you please read the messages from the Mayor.
To the President and members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia, pursuant to Sections 4-604 and 2-307 of the Home Rule Charter, I am today transmitting to the Council the recommendation of the City Planning Commission on the following bills: Bill Nos. 180423, 180424, 180454, 180456, 180459, 180463, 180498, 180501, 180503, 180505, 180507, 180509, 180510, 180511, 180517, 180518, and 180519. And I am pleased to advise you that on June 20, 2018, I signed all of the bills which were passed by Council at its session on June 7, 2018.
Thank you. The messages will be printed in the Journal. Chief Clerk, would you please read any other communications that are in his or your possession.
Thank you. The next order of business will be the introductions of bills and resolutions. The Chair now recognizes Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown.
Thank you very, very much. This morning I offer four resolutions.
A privileged resolution authorizing the Committee on the Environment to Hold Hearings on The State of the Environment in 2018.
And a privileged resolution authorizing the Committee on Law and Government to Hold Hearings on Succession Planning for Appointed Officers in the City of Philadelphia.
Placed on Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 today's Final Passage.
And a privileged resolution recognizing Monique Greenwood, Chief Enjoyment Officer of Akwaaba Bed and Breakfast Inns, and her husband Glenn Pogue on the opening of Akwaaba Philadelphia.
And a privileged resolution commending the Please Touch Museum for its Launch of Pride Family Weekend.
Also be placed on today's Final Passage. The Chair now recognizes Councilman Greenlee -- or Blackwell.
Thank you very much. This morning I introduce one bill.
An ordinance authorizing the construction of a sewer and appurtenant work, required to provide public sewer service, in a portion of the 4800 block of Trinity Street.
That bill will be referred to the appropriate committee. The Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Today I offer three bills, two on behalf of the Council President, and one is co-sponsored by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown, and then on your behalf I offer four bills and two resolutions, one of the resolutions on behalf of the Council President.
An ordinance amending Title 9 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Regulation of Businesses, Trades and Professions," by providing for Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the licensing of persons responsible for the installation, repair, or maintenance of elevators, escalators, and moving walkways.
And an ordinance authorizing Bridgeview Cafe and Catering to install, own and maintain an open-air sidewalk cafe at 4600 Richmond Street.
And an ordinance establishing a no truck parking regulation on the 3400 block of Oakmont Street, both sides.
And an ordinance amending Title 9, "Regulation of Businesses, Trades and Professions," of The Philadelphia Code to add a new Section 9-637, entitled "Opioid Antidote Availability," to require pharmacies to Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 stock opioid antidotes and display signs giving notice of opioid antidote availability to customers.
And an ordinance amending Section 9-610 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Massage Businesses," Section 9-611 entitled "Masseurs and Masseuses," Section 10-1103 entitled "Prohibited Conduct," and Section 14-601 entitled "Use Categories," by deleting some sections and adding new provisions regarding licensing and registration of massage therapists and massage therapy businesses including changes to prohibited conduct, fees, penalties, purpose, definitions, zoning use categories, and other related items.
This bill will be referred to the appropriate committee.
And an ordinance authorizing Shift Capital to install, own Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 and maintain proposed access vault encroachments at 3701 through 07 North Broad Street.
And an ordinance legalizing an existing wood deck and ramp encroachment at 1338 through 1344 Rising Sun Avenue.
And a privileged resolution authorizing the Committee on Fiscal Stability and Intergovernmental Cooperation to hold hearings to examine the financial condition of the City and School District of Philadelphia in light of a recent downgrade of the City's general obligation bond rating, to examine the impact that local control of the School District will have on the City's fiscal condition.
Will be placed on today's Final Passage Calendar. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
And a non-privileged resolution Also Naming the 2900 Block of Holme Avenue in Honor of Police Officer Timothy Simpson.
Will be placed on next Calendar session. The Chair now recognizes Councilman Jones.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have three bills, one privileged and one non-privileged, and I'd like to be recognized after the non-privileged.
An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Parkside Avenue, Belmont Avenue, Girard Avenue, Merion Avenue, and 52nd Street.
Referred to the appropriate committee. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
And an ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Woodbine Avenue, Upland Way, 54th Street, Jefferson Street, 52nd Street, Media Street, and 63rd Street.
And an ordinance amending Title 10 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Regulation of Individual Conduct and Activity," by amending Section 10-615, entitled "Disorderly Conduct and Related Offenses," and Chapter 10-2100, entitled "Marijuana Possession," to provide for certain additional offenses to be enforceable by civil penalties.
And a privileged resolution recognizing and honoring Reverend Quy K. Pham for his outstanding Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 perseverance and for his recent ordination as a Priest by Archbishop Charles J. Chaput at the Cathedral Basilica of Saints Peter and Paul.
And a non-privileged resolution also naming the 5700 block of Race Street as "Reverend Dr. A.F. Campbell Way" in honor of Reverend Dr. Albert F. Campbell.
Will be placed on Final Passage at the next Council session. The Chair recognizes Councilman Jones.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is a minor correction on my previous resolution honoring and changing the street from Dr. Wilson Goode. Mr. Leader, I move that the rules of Council be suspended to permit consideration of this resolution on today's Final Passage Calendar. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (Duly seconded.)
It has been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. It will be placed on today's Final Passage Calendar today. The Chair now recognizes Councilman Johnson.
Council President, I have one non-privileged resolution and would like to be recognized after the title has been read. And I would like to say that this resolution has been sponsored by all members of Council, but more specifically I want to thank Councilwoman Helen Gym and Councilwoman Maria Quinones-Sanchez for their considerable input in helping me craft this resolution, but also for Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the record, let me go through and specifically say those individuals who are supportive, because it's not supported by all members of Council. It's supported by Councilwoman Maria Quinones-Sanchez, Councilman Derek Green, Councilwoman Cindy Bass, Councilwoman Cherelle Parker, Councilman Bobby Henon, Councilwoman Jannie Blackwell, Councilman Mark Squilla, Councilwoman Helen Gym, Councilman Bill Greenlee, Councilwoman Blondell Reynolds Brown, Councilman Curtis Jones, Jr., and someone else who has doctor handwriting.
A non-privileged resolution condemning the Trump Administration's "zero tolerance" immigration policy, which has resulted in thousands of children being separated -(Applause.)
-- which has resulted in thousands of children being Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 separated from their parents after being detained at the United States border, and opposing the use of indefinite family detention as inhumane.
The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson. (Audience members chanting.)
Thank you, Mr. President. A copy of the resolution just read has been circulated to all members of Council, and I move that the rules be suspended so as to permit the consideration of this resolution on today's Final Passage Calendar. (Duly seconded.)
It has properly been moved and seconded. All those in favor signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. The resolution will be placed Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 on today's Final Passage Calendar. (Applause.)
Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Green.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have two privileged resolutions.
A privileged resolution Honoring and Recognizing Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity, Incorporated and Welcoming the 84th Grand Chapter Meeting to the City of Philadelphia in July 2019.
And a privileged resolution authorizing the Committee on the Environment to hold hearings regarding the threat of wasted plastics Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 to health, safety, and wellbeing of the City and residents of Philadelphia.
That resolution will also be placed on today's Final Passage Calendar. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker. (No response.)
On behalf of Councilwoman Parker, she has no bills or resolutions today.
And on behalf of myself, Mr. Chairman, I have one privileged resolution.
A privileged resolution recognizing and honoring Paul R. Levy, recipient of the 2017 Vision for Philadelphia Award, for his hard work and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 dedication to the City of Philadelphia.
That resolution will be placed on today's Final Passage Calendar. The Chair now recognizes Councilwoman Gym.
Thank you very much, Council Leader. Today I offer one privileged and two non-privileged resolutions, and I wish to be recognized after the title of the resolutions are read for a motion on the resolutions.
A privileged resolution honoring the groundbreaking civil rights legacy of the Japanese American Citizens League on the occasion of its national convention in Philadelphia, and recognizing the 30th anniversary of the organization's successful redress campaign that led to the passage of the Civil Liberties Act of 1988, providing a national apology and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 financial reparations for Japanese Americans interned during World War II.
That resolution will be placed on today's Final Passage Calendar.
And a non-privileged resolution authorizing the creation of a Youth Residential Placement Task Force, to make recommendations and provide guidance to safely reduce both the number of Philadelphia youth in residential placements and the use of placements outside of city limits.
Thank you very much, Mr. President. First of all, I want to thank my Council colleagues, Councilman Johnson especially for his help with the establishment of the task force, which has the full support of our City agencies and specifically our Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Commissioner Cynthia Figueroa, and thank Councilwoman Maria Quinones-Sanchez for supporting the other resolution, which also has the support of members of the state delegation and is in line with a letter that they have already sent forward. As a result, I would like to move to suspend the rules of Council so as to permit consideration of each of these resolutions on today's Final Passage Calendar. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded that the rules get suspended. All those in favor? (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that will be on today's Final Passage Calendar. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
And a non-privileged resolution affirming that the imprisonment and prolonged attention of asylum-seeking children and families is in inhumane and counter to international law, and calling on Governor Wolf and -(Applause.)
-- and calling on Governor Wolf and the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services to issue an emergency removal order and immediately close the Berks County Residential Center. (Applause.) (Audience members chanting.)
The Chair recognizes -- did you want to be recognized, Councilwoman?
Yes. Council President, I just wanted to make it clear that I move to suspend the rules of Council so as to permit consideration of all three resolutions on today's Final Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Passage Calendar. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. They will be on today's Final Passage Calendar. (Applause.)
And the Chair recognizes Councilman Taubenberger.
Good afternoon, Council President. I have one privileged resolution and it is co-sponsored by all members of Council, and I thank my colleagues for that.
A privileged Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 resolution recognizing and celebrating the announcement of the inaugural "Sister Cities Friendly" soccer match between the Philadelphia Union and Germany's Eintracht Frankfurt professional soccer team. A portion of the proceeds raised will assist Philadelphia students to travel to our Sister and Partnership Cities.
And that resolution will be on today's Final Passage Calendar. The Chair recognizes Councilman O'Neill.
Thank you, Mr. President. I have no bills or resolutions.
Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.
Thank you, Mr. President. I offer two bills, one co-sponsored by Derek Green, Bobby Henon, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Blondell Reynolds Brown, Helen Gym, and Al Taubenberger.
An ordinance amending Subcode "A" (The Philadelphia Administrative Code) of Title 4 (The Philadelphia Building Construction and Occupancy Code) of The Philadelphia Code, by amending Section A-703, entitled "Special Certificate of Inspection," to provide for lead paint requirements for educational occupancies.
And an ordinance authorizing Building Bok Limited Partnership to construct, own and maintain a proposed loading dock extension encroachment at 1901 South 9th Street.
Referred to committee. And the Chair recognizes Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Councilwoman Bass.
Thank you, Mr. President. I offer two bills, one on your behalf.
An ordinance authorizing the construction of a sewer and appurtenant work, required to provide public sewer service, in a portion of the 5800 block of Knox Street.
And an ordinance amending Chapter 17-1600 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Economic Opportunity Plans," by requiring the Labor Standards Unit to monitor contractors and enforce City contract requirements for Workforce Diversity.
Also referred to committee. The Chair recognizes Councilman Oh. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you very much, Council President. I offer a resolution co-sponsored by Councilmembers Blackwell, Green, Domb, and Reynolds Brown, as well as a bill co-sponsored by Councilwoman Cindy Bass.
An ordinance adding Section 19-101 to The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Adequate and Modern Accounting System," by Providing a Requirement for an Adequate and Modern Accounting System for the City Government and a Requirement that Material Weaknesses and Significant Deficiencies Reported by the City Controller be Addressed; and A privileged resolution authorizing Council's Committee on Global Opportunities and the Creative/Innovative Economy and the Committee on Education to hold hearings on the availability of lab spaces and incubation facilities in the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 are accessible to biotechnology, pharmaceutical, and related start-up companies.
And that will be on today's Final Passage Calendar. That concludes our introduction of bills and resolutions. Councilman, could I borrow you for one second. (Pause.)
So the next order of business is reports from the committee. The Chair now recognizes Councilman Greenlee for a report from the Committee of the Whole.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Committee of the Whole reports out two resolutions with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you. The Chief Clerk, could you please read the report from the Committee Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
To the President and members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia, the Committee of the Whole, to which was referred Resolution No. 180657, entitled a "Resolution approving the appointment of Belinda Mayo as a member of the Board of Commissioners of the Philadelphia Housing Authority"; and Resolution No. 180658, entitled a "Resolution approving the appointment of Samuel Staten Jr. as a member of the Board of Commissioners of the Philadelphia Housing Authority," respectfully reports it has considered the same and returns the attached resolutions to Council with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I move that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit consideration of Resolution Nos. 180657 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 180658 on today's Final Passage Calendar. (Duly seconded.)
It has been moved and seconded that the rules of Council be suspended as to permit the consideration of Resolutions No. 180657, 180658 on today's Final Passage Calendar. All those in favor will signify by saying aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. This motion passes. These resolutions will be placed on today's Final Passage Calendar. The Chair now recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell for a report from the Committee of Finance.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The Committee on Finance reports out two bills with a favorable recommendation. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you, Councilwoman. Clerk, would you please read the report.
The Committee on Finance, to which was referred Bill No. 180600, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 19-3200 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Keystone Opportunity Zone, Economic Development District, and Strategic Development Area,' by providing for further Keystone Opportunity Expansion Zones"; and Bill No. 180603, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 19-2900 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Senior Citizen Low Income Special Tax Provisions,' by providing for regulations relating to eligibility," respectfully reports it has considered the same and returns the attached bills to Council with a favorable recommendation.
The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill Nos. 180600 and 180603. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bills No. 180600 and 180603. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and they will be placed on our First Reading Calendar today. The Chair now recognizes Councilman Johnson for a report from the Committee of Transportation and Public Utilities. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you, Mr. President. The Committee on Transportation and Public Utilities reports one bill with a favorable recommendation.
The Committee on Transportation and Public Utilities, to which was referred Bill No. 180554, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 13 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Water and Sewer,' by amending Section 13-306, entitled 'Water Pipes Laid by Property Owners,' and by amending Section 13-406, entitled 'Sewers Constructed by Property Owners,' by revising certain provisions to allow for private water and sewer services to be constructed to serve units in planned communities and condominiums," Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 considered and amended the same and returns the attached bill to Council with a favorable recommendation.
Thank you. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Johnson.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill No. 180554. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill No. 180554. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
Those opposed? Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (No response.)
The ayes have it, and this bill will be placed on our First Reading Calendar today. That concludes our reports from committee. And our next order of business is the consideration of the Calendar. I note that the bills just reported from committee with a suspension of the rules have been deemed to have had a first reading. These bills will be placed on our Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar at our next session. There are no additional bills on the First Reading Calendar, so the Chair now recognizes Councilman Henon for a motion concerning the resolutions on the Final Passage Calendar.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars today: 180346-A, 180557-A, 180599-A, 180001-A, 180 -excuse me. Excuse me, Mr. President. I want to go over with moving that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the Consent Agenda to consider the following resolutions on the Final Passage Calendars today, and the resolution numbers are 180652, 180653, 180654, 180655, 180656, 180659, 180660, 180662, 180666, 180670, 180671, 180676, 180403, 180470, 180471, 180578, and 180579. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the resolutions just read by Councilman Henon. All in favor please indicate by saying aye. (Aye.) Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
The ayes have it, the motion carries, and we will consider the Resolution Consent Agenda shortly. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Henon for a motion concerning the bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar.
Thank you, Mr. President. I now move that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda on consideration of the following bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars today; that is, Bill Nos. 180346-A, 180557-A, 180599-A, 180001-A, 180015-A, 180286-A, 180261-A, 180163-A, 180428-A, 180512-A, 180514-A, 180234-A, 180162, 180423, 180424, 180426, 180427, 180451, 180454, 180451, 180463, 180496, 180498, 180501, 180503, 180505, 180506, 180507, 180519, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 180367, 180453, 180544, 180456, 180462, 180508, 180236, 180348, 180464, 180521, and 180459. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda -- go ahead, Councilman.
Thank you. Welcome to the last day of Council. My apology on behalf of those who don't understand the process, but I want to thank you, Mr. President, and I move that the rules of Council again be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the following bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars; that is, Bill Nos. 180346-A, 180557-A, 180599-A, 180001-A, 180015-A, 180286-A, 180261-A, 180163-A, 180428-A, 180512-A, 180514-A, 180234-A, 180162, 180423, 180424, 180426, 180427, 180451, 180454, 180463, 180496, 180498, 180501, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 180503, 180505, 180506, 180507, 180509, 180510, 180517, 180518, 180519, 180367, 180453, 180455, 180456, 180462, 180508, 180236, 180348, 180464, 180521, and 180459. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you, Councilman. Folks, can I ask you all just hold your voices down a little bit, please. It's getting a little chatty in here. Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of a Consent Agenda to consider the bills just read by Councilman Henon. All in favor please indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)
The Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 2ND READING ayes have it, the motion carries, and we will consider the Consent Agenda shortly. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Henon for the purpose of calling up bills and resolutions on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar today.
Thank you, Mr. President. In addition to the resolutions and bills that are being considered on the Consent Agenda, the following resolutions and bills are being called up for the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars today. They are Bill Nos. 180661, 180663, 180668, 170678-A, 180164-A, 180295, 180347-A, 180351-A, 160007, 180430, 180100, 180511, and 170673. All other bills and resolutions are being held.
Councilman, just one correction. Bill No. 180100 will be held at the request of the sponsor, which is myself. (Applause.) Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you. So there's like a little too much going on in here today. So I'm going to ask people please hold your voices down, or if you need to talk, go outside, and if you have any cell phones or any other electronic devices that make noise, would you please turn them off. Thank you. We will now move to our public comment session. Before considering any bills or resolutions on the Calendar, I'll give you the guidelines for the public comment session. If you are interested in testifying on a bill or resolution on today's Final Passage Calendar, if you have not already done so, you can sign up at the table to my left. When your name is called, you will go to the middle of the Council Chambers. There's a podium, and on that podium there's a device. When the light Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 turns green on that device, it will be your time to speak. When the light turns yellow, you will have 30 seconds to conclude your remarks. When the light turns red, we'd ask that you please adhere to our guidelines and conclude your remarks. I would appreciate your adherence to our guidelines, and thank you very much for your cooperation. There is one note. There's a significant number of witnesses today, some testifying on a particular bill. The rules associated with public comment do authorize me, the Chair, to cut off public comment if it's redundant on a particular bill or resolution. I want to thank you very much for your cooperation and I appreciate you. Mr. Decker, please call the first name on the list.
Gladys Lackey, commenting on 180430. (Witness approached podium.)
Good morning, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Council. Thank you for inviting me. I would like to thank Councilperson Oh, Domb, Blackwell, and a few others for coming out to my house. My name is Gladys Lackey. I've lived in the Germantown area since 1956.
Ma'am, hold on a second. Folks, can you all please stop talking so we can hear the witness. Thank you. Ma'am, go ahead. Please proceed, ma'am. I'm sorry.
I've lived in the Germantown section since 1956 when my parents first bought their first home. I am a senior citizen of 70 years of age. After purchasing and building -- after purchasing building materials I needed to renovate my house, I went to check on the house, and to my amazement, a fence had been erected, and the fencing was part of the materials that I had purchased and put inside. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 After further investigation, I found out that squatters had taken over my property and the materials inside. Once I found out squatters was in my property, I immediately called the police district, and that's when my nightmare began. I was bombarded with court fees. Nothing seemed to come close to closure. In order to get assistance with the procedure, I visited and made phone calls to various elected officials so they could advocate and place calls and letters on my behalf. One squatter happened to be a school teacher of ten years, still working the system. The other claimed to be a contractor of 20 years. The school teacher owns a property valued at $178,000. During the six months, I have called upon Police and Sheriff Department several times during this ordeal. When all was final, I was left with a shell, ten windows gone, doors gone, radiators Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 gone, plumbing and electric gone inside and out, house destroyed and trashed. At that time, I was handed a letter from the Sheriff Department signed by the Mayor. Up until now, no one has been held accountable for my loss. No one. I am appalled. I'm outraged. This is a travesty. My purpose for being here today is to help approve a bill in order that no one should ever have to go through what I've experienced and what I've gone through and with the expenses that I have incurred. I thank you so much. (Applause.)
Camille Yamrich, commenting on 180430. (Witness approached podium.)
Hello. Thank you for having me here today. I appreciate it. My story resonates with many others. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 My father died in May of 2017, and within two weeks, the trespasser had broken into his home. The police would do nothing, and I was unable to engage legal counsel for several weeks, as I was waiting to be appointed administratrix for my father's estate. So the original complaint for ejectment was not filed until mid June, with the initial hearing occurring in July. The trespasser did not respond to the complaint, was not represented by counsel, and did not attend the hearing. So I was awarded a default judgment. You think it would have ended there, but it didn't. Despite this, I was not granted legal possession until this past February, seven months later. By the time I was able to enter the property, all of my father's valuables were gone. All that was left was her trash, rotten food and maggots in the refrigerator, fecal matter, and a cockroach infestation. Nothing was Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 salvageable. Aside from the obvious financial implications, the legal fees, the clean-out costs and repairs, and the brazenly run-up utilities, her presence precluded my ability to perform my administrative estate duties. There was nothing of value left to inventory, and I was unable to prepare the inheritance tax return in a timely manner. All the while I exhausted every avenue I could think of to have her removed as expeditiously, to no avail. In my case, the entire process took nine months from the filing of the complaint to being awarded possession. In reality, any amount of time, whether it's one year or one day, is too long for a trespasser to be in a home. It's not just a house but a family's entire world that's impacted. They have complete control of a family's sacred space, their personal files and information, all valuables and mementos. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 The cost to the family goes way beyond just financial. It's far more emotional. You're left to feel frustrated, angry, hopeless and, most of all, abandoned by the very entities you believe are in a position to help protect and serve. In closing, I'll say that legislation that serves to address the criminal trespasser issue and save a family such grief should be supported. In my opinion, opposing such legislation is irresponsible. You need to be able to put yourselves in the victim's place. What if it happened in your family? Just try to imagine the feeling and then multiply that feeling exponentially. Victimizing the victims has got to stop. Thank you for hearing me out. (Applause.)
Rodney Little, commenting on 180430. (Witness approached podium.)
I'm here on behalf of my mother-in-law, Anashel Ingram, who owns a property in West Philadelphia. As a retired police officer and Fraternal Order of Police Union President, I urge Council who is sitting on this bill to pass this bill on behalf of tenants who own property in the City of Philadelphia where you call the Police Department. She's 89 years old. She just left the emergency room. She's trying to go back to her dwelling, but we have individuals who are occupying that dwelling, who do not have a lease. When we notified the Police Department, the Police Department came to try to do their job. They asked Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the individual if he resides there. He says, yes, he was paroled there 15 years ago. Unfortunately, it's a relative, which is not true. So what I'm saying is that individuals who have no lease, they have no mail, and when police ran him through NCIC, PCIC, the individual had no identification whatsoever, and they said that we could not evict these individuals. And I'm saying this lady is 89 years old. She wants to go back to her house where she can reside and, God forbid, God calls her home, she can live in peace. So I urge you here in Council to please vote yes and pass this bill. Thank you. (Applause.)
Good morning, sir. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
-- for hearing me out on Bill 180430. I'm a real estate attorney and I represent many homeowners who have -- or homebuyers who have faced squatters in their properties and wanted to bring your attention to CP 1960. For two years, it took two years after the property was purchased in order to have the person removed from the property, even after the order was entered by the Court. He filed a motion pro se, meaning without an attorney, to have the ejectment stayed, and after 60 days, the Court asked him, why haven't you moved, and he asked for additional time. This is after two years of being in the property. This person had a full-time job, works for the City of Philadelphia, and had alternative places to move to in two years. This property was cited by License and Inspection with a collapsed roof as well as a collapsed wall, yet the police could do nothing to have the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 squatter removed, and my client was receiving notices from the City, threatening to sue him because of the collapsed roof, and there was no way that he could enter the property. This is the kind of jeopardy that buyers have been put in, and it was a legitimate sale from the estate of the owner who couldn't afford to make the repairs to the property in order for it to be up to code. So I ask that you pass 180430 and reduce the amount of time that homebuyers are required or contractors are required to spend before they can actually access the property, which is their right under the titles that are given to them. Thank you. (Applause.)
Martin Ward, commenting on 180430. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (Witness approached podium.)
Good afternoon. Thank you for this opportunity. My name is Martin Ward. I grew up in the Mayfair section of Philadelphia in my parents' home. After my parents passed away, as their only child, I became the executor of their estate and caretaker for their now vacant home. I was preparing the home for sale and showing it to an interested buyer on the evening of August 22nd, 2017 when I realized the house was occupied and I was not able to gain access to the property. So here's my story. It's one of many you as Councilmembers have likely been hearing with increasing frequency. On that date last year in 2017, unable to gain access to the property, I contacted the police. The police arrived. I provided them with evidence of ownership. With my permission, the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 police breached the rear door and entered the property. On entering the property, the police found three occupants that included two adults and one minor child. The police questioned the adult occupants, who produced a two-page lease agreement and asserted that they were renting the property. The lease was not signed by me, nor anyone I knew. For the record, even to an uninformed layperson, the lease agreement looked fairly deficient. For the more educated in rental matters, the lease agreement did not even remotely contain all the necessary clauses to lease property in the City of Philadelphia. Moreover, the occupants could not even provide the full name and a contact address and phone number for the landlord, the alleged landlord. The police instructed me and one of the occupants to basically travel to the local police district and file a report, which we did. Despite my Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 mother's deed and my proof of ownership, the police felt there was nothing more they could do about the illegal trespass into my parents' house and said to pursue it as a civil matter through the court system. Because the couple broke in unexpectedly, I was not able to turn off the utilities. Moreover, the utilities would not be willing to shut off for any reason at that point. By the time the couple left, over seven months later and only after receiving formal court notice from the Sheriff's Department in March of 2018, I incurred or the estate incurred in excess of $4,400 in expenses. In addition, the couple left the house a mess, and they certainly didn't leave me with a forwarding address. I have no way to contact them, nor do I have any way to file a claim in the courts or seek any restitution against them. So there currently is nothing Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 in place to effectively address this issue timely and comprehensively, thereby allowing harm to continue unchecked. As an analogy, the problem is akin to a cancer and it's plaguing the occupants, the homeowners, and the citizens of this city. Similar to spreading cancer, the condition is rampant and epidemic, needs to be taken -- there's an action that needs to be taken, and basically the remedy is this ordinance or this bill that you're being considered. In closing, I appreciate the collective efforts of the Council at this point. I urge you not to let the ordinance stall because of its perceived flaws, but rather to give this ordinance an opportunity to work as it was intended. This ordinance will allow the legal and rightful owners, your constituents, to expeditiously take possession of their properties fairly and without unnecessary delays and to seek Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 restitution for the harm that has already occurred and will continue to occur. Thank you. (Applause.)
Maria Vicente, commenting on 180430. (Witness approached podium.)
Good afternoon, Council. Maria Vicente for Bill 180430. Councilman Oh, thank you again for inviting me back. I am a property manager in the City of Philadelphia for the last 18 years. Over the last seven months, I have had five squatters go into vacant properties. I've been knocked down a flight of steps by a squatter, and even at that point when the police came and I explained that the person knocked me down the steps and was still in the house, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 they most certainly adamantly assured me that there was nothing they can do, and that if I have been doing this for 18 years, I should know that I should exercise the eviction process. First of all, it is not an eviction. It is an ejectment, because they are not legally my tenant. However, when you do go to Municipal Court and you try to use the eviction process, if you've offered the person a lease, if you're unable to give them a rental suitability or a partner for good housing, you cannot even remove them from the property using an eviction process. When you call the police, they tell you that it's not considered breaking and entering because they change the locks to get in. Well, if I didn't give you a key, that's breaking and entering. If I go to anyone's home and I go in and I'm not supposed to be there, I guarantee that I'm probably going to be arrested on the spot. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 So we have now started the process of every vacant property of screwing the door shut. Screwing the door shut, because if they break the door to get in, at that point it is considered breaking and entering, which means that I can no longer spontaneously go out to show a property when I have interested prospective tenants without having a maintenance man, someone that I must pay, to go and unscrew a door to let me into the property, because I am unable physically to do so myself. Please, I urge you for the greatness of our city that we live in, please pass Bill 180430. Let's get this on the record. They are illegally committing a crime. They are in a property that no one has authorized them to be in. That is breaking the law. If I take your car without your permission, I have now committed robbery. If I come into your store and I take things without paying for them, I have now committed Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 robbery. It is no different if someone takes over someone's property without their permission. It is at the point now where my family fears for my safety when I go out to show a property, because they don't know if I'm going to encounter a dangerous situation, like when I got knocked down a flight of steps because I didn't know somebody was in the property. I had walked through the entire downstairs, and upstairs he was hiding in the closet. Thank you again for hearing me out. Please help us make it so that our city can be safe and I can do my job without threat to my safety. Thank you again. (Applause.)
Patrick Russell, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 commenting on 180430. (Witness approached podium.)
Good afternoon, Council President and Councilmembers. I want to thank you for this opportunity and privilege to testify before this body in support of criminal and defiant trespassers bill. My name is Patrick Russell, age 65. Although I have been a resident renter in Philadelphia for the greater part of my life, in 2012 I decided to make a commitment to Philadelphia as a resident. But what good is a commitment -- but what good is it for me to make such a commitment to the City when I stand in jeopardy every day to become homeless for six months or longer because a City failure to procure my safety by allowing a situation to persist that allows my rights as a homeowner to be given to a trespasser who claims that he or she is renting my property. I have a friend whose mother, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Mrs. Fleming, which was selling her property when trespassers broke in. Rather than being able to have them arrested for trespassing, she had to go through the process of ejection. After six months, the trespassers finally were removed, but the property was trashed and the value of the property decreased. About a year later, trespassers again broke into the house, and Mrs. Fleming found herself in the same situation. The frustration and anxiety that this senior citizen experienced was not because she didn't know the procedures, but that real justice was not served. My second friend, Jacqueline Wilson, whose mother passed away in 2017, was in the process of selling her mother's house. Shortly after the mother's death, a trespasser got into the property. When Jackie called the police, the police came out to the property. The trespasser said she wasn't leaving, that Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 she was claiming squatters' rights. Not realizing that there was no such right, the officer was a bit confused, gave Jackie the information to get an ejection notice. After six months and five unanswered summons were served to the trespasser, the house was trashed. Her mother's identification was now known to the trespassers. To add salt to the wound, eventually this property was sold at Sheriff Sale. There are some who would like to see this bill fail, but I urge City Council to resist any pressure that they may incur to say no to this bill. Therefore, I urge this Council to protect people like Ms. Lackey, Ms. Fleming, Jackie Wilson, and myself and passing the criminal and defiant trespassers bill. Thank you.
Thank you for your testimony, sir. (Applause.) Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
George Gould, commenting on 180430. (Witness approached podium.)
Thank you. My name is George Gould. I'm a Senior Attorney at Community Legal Services in Philadelphia and I've worked in housing for many, many years. There clearly is a serious problem with criminal trespass in this city. However, we and others believe that this bill is not the appropriate way to go. First off, City Council cannot mandate what the courts can do and what the police can do, and I think the passage of this bill in fact would give a false impression that something is getting done when in fact it's not. There are also problems within the bill. It doesn't deal with people Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 who have dealt with owners who are fraudulent and enter into leases with tenants who have no idea that's the case. These tenants could be defined as criminal trespassers. Tenants with oral leases may not be able to prove they actually have a right to live in the property. Homeowners who have lost their home to a tax foreclosure sale or Sheriff Sale have a right to live in the property during the period of redemption. The purchaser of that property could go to court immediately, file an affidavit, and that person would be liable as a criminal trespasser. The federal legislation has recently been enacted -- reenacted which protects tenants after there has been a mortgage foreclosure sale on a property, and if a tenant is in that property, they have a right after the Sheriff Sale and after the property has been purchased by a new owner to remain in the property and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 continue until their lease ends. There's nothing in this bill which protects those tenants. There is also enacted actually yesterday change in the adverse possession law. Where it used to be 21 years, now it's ten years. Also, as many of you are aware, there are heirs that live in property throughout this city who don't have title to the property. These folks could clearly be labeled defiant criminal trespassers. Again, we urge this Council -by the way, there has also been through Councilwoman Cherelle Parker a task force created and it met a couple days ago, and it was a very effective meeting. The police were there, the District Attorney was there and representatives from realtors, owners, advocates, City Council, the purpose of which is to come up with a solution to this problem, which we urge people to vote no on this and let Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the task force act. Thank you.
Chuck Bode, commenting on 180430. (Witness approached podium.)
Thank you. My name is Chuck Bode from the West Powelton/Saunders Park RCO. We thank all the Councilmembers who have worked to introduce Bill 180430, without taking the time to enumerate them all. The bill is important to all Philadelphia property owners. We have had two instances in our territory where this has happened, but I will skip the details of reading them all. None of these instances should have occurred. No homeowner in Philadelphia should have to live in fear Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 of returning home to find their home occupied or, even worse, to find that they have lost use of their home to an illegal occupant. It is significant, and everyone in this room could discover when they go home that they are homeless. There were several specific issues that need to be considered. First, how long will mortgages be available to purchase homes in Philadelphia while trespassers have more rights than homeowners? Second, how long will homeowners insurance be available in Philadelphia while trespassers have more rights than homeowners? And, third, a home that cannot be used by the owner has no value to the owner. What happens to the tax revenue when property values go down because trespassers have more rights than homeowners? We urge City Council to quickly pass Bill 180430 to give Philadelphians Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 peace of mind and the security of their homes. Thank you. (Applause.)
Jackie Martinez, commenting on 180676. (Witness approached podium.)
Hi. My name is Jackie Martinez. I am the face that this country hates. I am a Native American, and everybody here is an immigrant. This country was founded on murder, greed, and hate. We don't get a voice here in this country, and what I want people here to know today and people, if you even call them a person, No. 45, he stands for everything that is evil. Okay? What I want people to understand is that these people that you Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 call immigrants, they forget that we were all one nation, many tribes. The people in Mexico -- Mexico is named after a Native American word. It's called Mexica. They were a tribe. Now, the thing that people don't understand about Mexico is is that it is not a race. It's a nationality. There are more Native American Indian people in Mexico than there is anywhere else in the world, in this continent of the Americas. Right now there's 68 indigenous languages still spoken in Mexico and beyond north of Mexico. There are Indian people still there trying to hang on to their ways. But with this agenda that we're under, it's impossible. It's impossible. We will never have our rights. We will never, never, no one will hear our voices. I didn't grow up with history books. It was before the Internet. You know how I know my history? Not by Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 reading books that talked about George Washington and Lincoln, who everybody says freed the slaves. He killed Indians. He killed African Americans, okay, under his regime. They're not great people. They're rapists, they're murderers. Now, the thing is, you know, these immigrants that 45 calls rapists, murderers, thieves, he's describing the white agenda, this white supremacy. We're not murderers. We're not thieves. This was our land, and I'm just tired of this. I speak two languages, English and Spanish, and neither is the language I'm supposed to speak. Neither of them. I'm now one person who doesn't know my own language. Now, I'm here to try and speak up, because I am the lesser heard voice. Even in the native communities, people don't talk about this. This country and colonialism has stripped native people of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 their identity. These terms like Latin, Latin America, Hispanic, Hispanic is a made-up word to lump over people. I have to cut this short.
But my point is is that it should be called South America, not Latin America, because we're native first. We've been relabeled Spanish and have Spanish names and Spanish languages now. It's not our language. Anyway, I'm here for Carmela. Let's get her a Green Card. Let her family be safe. We're native people. Thank you.
The biggest problem facing the City is the lack of housing resources. If I don't have a home, I don't keep my job, I don't send my kids to school. And if I live in a nursing home and can't get out because the lack of housing, I don't pay taxes. The disabled community, most of which make less than 20,000 a year, have been working for decades to get housing resources, especially for new housing units, so people don't need to remain in institutions like nursing homes or live in inaccessible homes or live in cars or shelters or street corners. Why does our City Council do next to nothing? I know that listening to what the constituents want is not your priority, but listening to what the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 funders want and what the powers in Council want is more important. We have worked on campaigns to increase housing resources for the last 20 years. Sometimes we win, sort of, but most times our efforts are highjacked. I believe the democratic process, and I participate in it, but City Council does not. No matter what we say or do, they've already made up their minds before the hearing begins. It's simply a formality. You actually seem proud to be the city with the highest poverty rate of the top ten cities. This is not something to be proud of, but something you should want to change immediately, but that is not happening. I know you're not going to do the right thing, but I hope you take a long look at what decisions you're making and for whom and why and amend the bill so that you can receive services for people that make 30 percent or below of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 AMI. (Applause.)
Good afternoon. Thank you, Council and everyone. My name is German Parodi. I'm the President of Disabled in Action. I'm here to testify on Bill 180347-A and 180351-A. You heard Nancy Salandra. You've been hearing us for years now. We ask you to do the right thing. We say the right thing is to fund all people, all Philadelphians. Right now you're looking at bringing in $20 million new to the Housing Trust Fund, and that money you plan to only use for people earning under $4,000 plus a year, family of four. That is not Philadelphia. That is not who votes any of you in. That may be who Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 fills your coffers. That is not who elects you. We ask of you today that either you vote no if there are no amendments to the Housing Trust Fund bill and if you're not giving any of this new construction impact money to people earning less than 30 percent of AMI. We're talking about people earning at least $34,000 or less. People with disabilities, those on fixed incomes earn less than $1,500 a month. That is not who you want to house? I understand that you're looking at Temple graduates. I understand that is who you're looking at to keep in Philadelphia. So are you looking to put the rest of us out on the streets? Are you looking at putting people in nursing homes more inside? (Applause.)
Because if you vote for this, that is what you're doing. Clarke, you are part of one of the sponsors. I expect you to lead your Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Council to vote no today on these bills. Thank you. (Applause.)
Good afternoon. As a member of Philly ADAPT, as a board member of Liberty Resources, we demand that at least half of any of the monies from the Housing Trust Fund go to homeowners earning 30 percent of AMI or less, to amend the construction impact tax to include at least half of all the collected fees to allow people earning also 30 percent of AMI or less, and if no amendments are made, all Councilmembers vote no. I'd like to remind everyone Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 here that last time we brought this up, there were two particular agencies that were to me very surprising that were supporting this effort, both the -- I'm going to say the agencies' full name wrong, but basically the realtors and the people who deal with construction, which I find quite hypocritical knowing the history of redlining in this city and redlining in our country. And this is actually an amendment to fix what has happened in our history to keep people out of neighborhoods, and we should all come together and vote yes on the amendments or vote no on these bills until we do the right thing. And as a member -- or as Councilman Squilla is my person who is -- I'm living in his district, I would hope that he would hear that there are many houses in our district that are in need of this funding so we can have a more inclusive neighborhood and not a neighborhood that is outsiders and not true Philadelphians. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Thank you.
Joe Danihel, commenting on 180653, 180660, 180671, 180661, 180662, 180676, 180445, 180456, 180462, and 180508. (Witness approached podium.)
Okay. I too am a stolen home victim, except my perpetrator is the government. This is an official decree of the people in writ of mandamus quo warranto and, as such, requires immediate action and remedy. Every week, Council, Mayor, and others transfer private property to government, probably illegally. Is Council, Mayor, and others selling tangled title deeds in Cindy Bass' Bill 180676? In 1776, in this very city, sovereign people stated clearly, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 obstructing the administration of justice and depriving us of the benefits of trial by jury are not allowed. Furthermore, it is the people's God-given right and their duty to throw off any government that attempts these acts. Franklin stated, we need a revolution every 200 years because government becomes corrupt. If rights are truly inalienable and inviolable and Dr. King stated, he who passively accepts evil is as much involved in it as he who perpetrates it, why has no prosecution of oath, Constitution, and law violations occurred? Why has the Attorney General not acted on the numerous complaints filed by me? Do Council, Mayor, Governor, and others oppose several trials by jury? Was my home and my just compensation stolen? The constitutions require immediate remedy of this breach of law, breach of close, breach of fiduciary Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 duty. Your oath of office requires you to act or face prison. 42 USC 1982, 1983, 1985, 1986, 1987, 18 USC 241, 242, 2381, 2384, PA Constitution, Article I, Sections 1 through 11, 26 PA CSA 701, 703, 705, 708, 709, 712, 713, 716, and other laws listed in SCOTUS 15-8965, 14-1330, 14-4056, 14-6880 appear violated. I call for the federal and Commonwealth governments to perform their constitutional obligations to investigate and prosecute all involved in the theft and illegal deed transfer of my home, 1038 West Wyoming Avenue. The denial of God-given 42 USC 1982 property rights for 24 years is egregious, extraordinary, oath-violating, and requires immediate remedy. A just government must obey the rule of law. This color of law government must have its Charter to govern revoked until a constitutionally compliant government is installed. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Public servants cannot refuse their sworn duty to act any more than a fireman can refuse to fight a fire. The sovereign people require oath, Constitution, and laws be enforced, and jail is required for all who violate oath, Constitution, and laws.
-- it takes a lot of cooperation to create and allow monumental corruption.
Commenting on Councilwoman Gym's resolution calling on the Governor to close the Berks County Residential Center. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (Witness approached podium.)
Thank you, Councilmembers and Council President, for having us here today. Thank Councilwoman Gym for calling the resolution on Governor Wolf to shut down the Berks County ICE Detention Center. (Applause.)
This is our country. This is our America. Ask yourself, what makes our country beautiful besides the beautiful landscape all across the nation. It's the people that make our country beautiful, the makeup of the different ethnicities from all around the world. There is a reason why people seek to come here from all around the globe. But right now here in our time, in our time, we're watching one of the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 most atrocious violations of human rights that we've ever seen. We're actually seeing images of children and families kept in cages like animals, and we have to answer to our children why this is happening. I had to have an hour conversation last night with my teens as to why this is happening and what can be done to stop it. Around the nation we have three ICE detention centers, two in Texas and one right here in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. We have a moral obligation. We have a responsibility. We can call on Governor Wolf to issue an emergency removal and shut down this facility that houses young children, their moms and dads. The Department of Health and Human Services, they have a moral obligation to protect people against abuse. Right now abuse is an understatement. We're watching neglect in education, neglect in medical Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 services. We're watching children being ripped from their parents' arms right before our very eyes. Not only is this horrific, but this is the continued criminalization that this country has always displayed of black and brown bodies. (Applause.)
Generations and generations down the road when all of you are silver and gray, your grandchildren and your great-grandchildren will ask you, what did you do. So today ask yourself, what can you do to shut down this facility in the Commonwealth. Thank you. (Applause.) (Audience members chanting.)
Commenting on Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Councilwoman Gym's resolution calling on the Governor to close the Berks County Residential Center. (Witness approached podium.)
Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Brenda Hernandez. I come from Philadelphia. I'm a DACA recipient. I'm just here to talk about shutting down Berks facilities. Berks Resident Center is the prison for immigrant families. It is a shame that I have to be standing here before y'all and talk about something that we've been talking for years about shutting down. It is a shame that it has to be an English speaker, also a Mexican native to talk to you about incarcerating kids and families. It is really a shame to have babies in the facility in cages, guys. Seriously? Imagine having your children around that and having families being detained for years without having good resources of like healthcare or anything like that. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 I'm here on behalf of my own family. It's really sad to hear my own five-year-old niece and nephew talking about having their moms being taken away. I want to make sure that Philadelphia keeps a really good sanctuary city, not only for immigrants but all black and brown folks. (Applause.)
And make sure that everyone is being respected the way that this America has to be, which is the freedom of living in their own thoughts and dreams. (Applause.)
Karla Rojas, commenting on Councilwoman Gym's resolution introduced today calling on the Governor to close the Berks County Residential Center.
My name is Karla Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Rojas and I am undocumented. I am here today -(Applause.)
I am here today to be the voice of the families inside Berks Detention Center. At the age of seven, coming to this country left me traumatized for many years. I know what these children feel. They feel scared. They feel overwhelmed, overwhelmed from coming to a country and getting rejected, getting treated like they are criminals for wanting safety and a better life. (Applause.)
On top of that, these children have been separated from their parents, only comfortable what they come into a new environment. I can only imagine the emotional being down in their life. That is not going to last just today or tomorrow; it's going to last a lifetime. It's inhumane that the State of Pennsylvania is locking up families and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 their kids. How can you go to sleep knowing you're taking away the children's childhood? It's time to put yourself in their shoes. If your child was being attacked, would you run away too? We need to end family separation and (unintelligible) to those who are seeking refugee in our country. This call of abusing families, abusing their legal rights, the physical abuse, the mental abuse, this is inhumane. This is illegal. This is absolutely un-American. I see how my own community has been attacked for many years and been separated from their families. I see my community shed tears from not knowing when they will see their family again. We are not taking any more excuses, because we have been waiting for a long time. The time is now. We need to order an evacuation of Berks County and let the families live a stable life without fear. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (Applause.)
I will continue to fight for no family separation, no family detention, and not one more deportation. Thank you. (Applause.)
Thank you. Mr. Decker, our next one. (Audience members chanting.)
Gretchen Dahlkemper, commenting on 180668. (Witness approached podium.)
Good morning. Thank you for allowing me to speak. Good Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 morning to my Councilman, Mr. Johnson. I am standing here today as a member of Nebinger Elementary School's Advisory Council in support of Resolution 180668 introduced by Councilman Green, Taubenberger, and Councilwoman Parker. As a children's environmental health advocate but, most importantly, as a parent of two and soon to be three children attending Philadelphia public schools, I support this resolution to provide new capital funding for the School District of Philadelphia, and perhaps for the first time in the eight years I've lived here, I applaud the PPA for helping fund or taking the fees that they take from all of us to fund our public schools. I can do a lot as a parent to make sure that my children are protected. I send my daughter to school with her asthma inhaler. I send my son to school with an Epipen, but what I cannot control is what my children are encountering with Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 environmental hazards once they are in school. For far too long, our schools have been left crumbling. We mandate by law that our children attend 180 days a year, but we do not mandate like we do with housing that our children have a safe and healthy environment in which to learn. Since January, I have been working with the School District and the Philadelphia Healthy Schools Initiative to develop a comprehensive lead stabilization plan that protects the health and safety of our students, our teachers, and the staff that learn and work in our public schools all year long. For far too long, they have fallen victim to the cuts in public education, and our children have been exposed on a daily basis to serious health and safety concerns. The city, state, and federal governments must come together to find Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 funding to fully -- to find a solution to fully fund these capital improvements for the District. Only with full and adequate funding can all parents feel confident that the school buildings they send their children to is healthy and safe and that improvements are determined by risk and need and not by zip code or those who yell the loudest. Resolution 180668 is a creative approach to start funding the District's outstanding capital improvements and needs. It is a good first step, but we need full and adequate funding to fix these huge problems. I urge both City Council and Governor Wolf to support this resolution to protect the health and safety of our state's most precious resource, our children. Thank you very much.
Beth McConnell, commenting on 170678, 180347, and 180361. (Witness approached podium.) MS. McCONNELL: Good afternoon. My name is Beth McConnell. I'm the Policy Director at the Philadelphia Association of CDCs here to testify in support of Bills 170678, 180347, and 180351 that create a construction impact tax, a new Housing Trust Fund sub-fund, and a voluntary mixed-income housing program. Over the last four years, PACDC and dozens of our members have begged this Council to do more to address our large and growing housing affordability crisis. We've worked closely with Councilmembers and their staff exploring a range of policies and revenue-generating ideas. We've testified at more than half a dozen committee hearings. The package of bills that we're seeing today is the result of years of work and together will more than Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 double dedicated revenue to the Housing Trust Fund. Since 2006, the Trust Fund has invested in the housing security of more than 40,000 households. The need is so much greater. The bills will allow Philadelphia to create more mixed-income communities where low- and moderate-income families can live in neighborhoods that offer great quality of life. It will make the dream of homeownership possible for working-class households that deserve a shot at building family wealth from the City's strengthening housing market. It will preserve and repair existing affordable homes so that owners and renters don't get displaced, and it will create new rental homes for our neighbors that struggle with homelessness, housing instability, lack of accessible homes, and overwhelming housing cost burdens. And it will support households at anywhere from zero percent AMI up to 120 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 percent AMI. If the bill doesn't pass, we have zero new dollars available for households who need the most support. We hope that Council will commit to working with PACDC to ensure that affordable housing developers that have to pay the tax will get adequate subsidies from the Trust Fund to offset the cost serving low-income renters. PACDC is grateful for the support and leadership of Council President Clarke, Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez, and Councilman Squilla in championing these bills, and Councilmembers Parker and Blackwell, Reynolds Brown, Greenlee, and Bass for your votes in committee. We hope that we can count on all of your yes votes today for final passage to show folks that City Council is committed to creating a more equitable Philadelphia. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Gabriella Nolan, commenting on 180261. (Witness approached podium.)
Firstly, I demand Council get some heat up in here. It is too cold. (Applause.)
But seriously, good afternoon. My name is Gabriella Nolan and I'm with the North 5th Street Revitalization Project in the Olney section of Philadelphia. I'm testifying in support of Bill 180261 on behalf of my organization, PACDC, South Street Headhouse District, Germantown United, Passyunk Avenue Revitalization Project, and the African Cultural Alliance of North America. This bill will create five new Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 slots in the CDC tax credit program unless the Administration certifies each year that half a million dollars in new grant funds are made available to CDCs that engage in economic development. Eighty-four percent of the businesses in Philadelphia have 20 or fewer employees. They invest in our neighborhoods, provide jobs to our residents, and offer needed goods and services. This bill represents a modest but very impactful investment in the capacity of non-profit CDCs that are doing vital work in our neighborhoods supporting these businesses, making streetscape and storefront improvements, filling vacant storefronts, running job training programs and more. We are grateful to the support of Councilmen Henon and Green in shaping the legislation and for the support of the Finance Committee members, especially Councilwoman Cherelle Parker, that recommended the bill for your final Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 approval today. We hope you will vote yes. Thank you for the opportunity.
Renee McKenzie, commenting on 180671. (Witness approached podium.) REVEREND McKENZIE: Good morning. Good afternoon. I stand before you today to encourage the passage of Bill 180671, which was introduced by Councilwoman Gym and co-sponsored by Councilmembers Green, Reynolds Brown, Quinones-Sanchez, Domb, Greenlee, Jones, and Council President Clarke. My name is Reverend Renee McKenzie and I am the Pastor of the Episcopal Church of the Advocate located in North Philadelphia, which is the home of the Stadium Stompers. (Applause.) REVEREND McKENZIE: Our Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 community is honored to be able to provide sanctuary to Carmela Hernandez and her four children. It's an honor because loving the neighbor and seeking justice are part of our sacred responsibility spelled out in our baptismal covenant. We found encouragement for our response to seeing the City of Philadelphia standing tall as a sanctuary city. Your strength in owning this sanctuary city status shows to those supporting the actions of providing sanctuary that we have a shared value in the sanctity of human life and human -- I forget the word. In this time as we witness the tragic and trauma-filled separation of children from asylum-seeking parents, the choice that Carmela made in seeking sanctuary was the only viable option available to her that offers a strong probability that her children will mature into adult life relatively free from Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 violence and will learn to contribute to the greater good of society. If nothing else, this experience has taught these children that they must advocate for themselves and that Philadelphia is full of people who see their humanity, who will affirm their dignity, and who will work with them on their behalf. In this way, Philadelphia lives into its moniker of the City of Brotherly Love and the City of Sisterly Affection. The resolution you have before you this morning resolves that the Council of the City of Philadelphia urges the United States House of Representatives to pass H.R. 5623, providing for the relief of Carmela Hernandez and her four children, Fidel, Keyri, Yoselin, and Edwin, due to the extraordinary services of persecution, and urging the exercise of prosecutorial discretion to stay the family's removal and join a motion to reopen the Hernandez family's case for asylum. These Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 children, all children, deserve a safe home. We urge you to approve this bill to send a clear message of support for the Apolonio Hernandez family at this crucial moment. We would also ask that you, with whatever measure of personal influence you have, encourage Senator Bob Casey to introduce a companion bill for the United States Senate so that the family can reside safely in this country and continue to advocate for themselves and for others. Thank you. (Applause.)
Claire Yoo and Keyri Artillero. (Witnesses approached podium.)
Good afternoon. I'm Claire Yoo, member of Sanctuary Advocate Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Coalition and Stadium Stompers housed at Church of the Advocate. (Applause.)
I will read the testimony of Carmela Apolonio Hernandez. Good morning. My name is Carmela Apolonio Hernandez. I would have liked to share these words in person, but it's impossible, as I am living in sanctuary at the Church of the Advocate with my four children. We are resisting a deportation order that will put my family in immediate danger. I ask that you please vote in favor of the resolution introduced by City Councilmember Gym and co-sponsored by Councilmembers Green, Reynolds Brown, Quinones-Sanchez, Domb, Greenlee, Jones, and Council President Clarke. I ask that you commit to supporting private bills on behalf of my family, both in the House of Representatives and in Congress, as they are our main hope for obtaining a stay of deportation and reopening our asylum Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 case. Deportation to Mexico is not an option for us. It is not an option for most immigrant families who come to the United States after our countries have been made nearly unlivable by high levels of violence and poverty, which are a direct result of U.S. foreign policy. (Applause.)
If you approve this resolution, you'll be joining cities like Austin, Texas and Columbus, Ohio that have also come out in support of sanctuary leaders and the millions of undocumented people we represent. It is important to take action now and to put an end to the suffering of asylum seekers at the border. I lived through firsthand what many of these people are experiencing when my family arrived to the U.S. almost three years ago seeking asylum. My 12-year-old son, Fidel, was taken from my side and put in a room with adult men Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 because the agents claim that he looked like a grown man. He later told me that they had him and others sleep without blankets in freezing temperatures. They were not allowed to take showers. Guards would beat men for the smallest mistakes. The desperation in the center was so high that adult men would fight each other over food and pick on the younger men or the children who were placed in that room. This is what happens when you put people in cages and treat them as less than human beings. It is a shame that the men were put through this abuse, and it is also unjust for children to bear witness to it and to receive similar treatment. It leaves everyone traumatized. That is why I also support the effort to close down the Berks concentration camp and to stop the construction of cages for immigrants. Detention centers inflict trauma in our community, but the trauma continues even when we are not locked up. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 The threat of deportation weighs heavy on our souls. In a sense, it's as if I had never left the detention center, because I still have to wear the ankle monitor they placed on me at the border. It tracks my every move and is a form of torture. I know that the purpose of this device is to keep us caged psychologically and to live in constant fear. I do not want to live in fear anymore, and that is why I am being public about my case. I do it to claim the right of human beings for all immigrants. We thank you for your support, and we ask that you keep fighting with my family and many other families. We ask that you use your influence with other elected officials to put an end to the criminalization of immigrant people and people of color. We ask that you encourage Senator Bob Casey to take a similar stance in support of immigrant people by introducing a companion bill in Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the Senate for me and my family. Thank you for your support.
Thank you for your testimony. (Applause.) MISS ARTILLERO APOLONIO (through interpreter): Hello. My name is Keyri Artillero Apolonio and this is my brother. I am a person who at my short age has gone through the experience of living in sanctuary as well as having gone through a detention center when my family came seeking asylum in this country. It's not easy to live under a sanctuary because you can't easily go out and you can't even breathe fresh air or leave without the fear of deportation. I live the same experience that many children are experiencing right in this moment in centers of detention. As my mom told you, my brother was taken away from us, which had never been -which had never happened. We had always Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 been together. And so the first day that they took him away from us, the rest of us were very scared, and we asked our mom, where they have taken him to, and she tried to reassure us. She told us that he was okay, that he would be back with us. And the next day we saw him through a window walking through one of the hallways with his hands raised over his head, and it gave us such sadness to see him like that. Even though me and my brothers -- my other siblings were with my mother, we also suffered because we also slept on the floor and suffered a lot of cold. The toilet was in the same room where the rest of us were, and we could smell everything that was happening in the bathroom. And then there were a lot of people gathered in the same room together. My mom hardly slept because agents would call roll every two or three hours. I got to meet a girl who was Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 ten years old, who was the same age as I was at that time. She had two siblings, a little brother and a little sister. And she hardly slept because the agents would call roll and she had to stay awake to be able to give the names of her brother and sibling so that they could sleep. Her mom and her father had been killed in her country, and she cried whenever she talked about her father who had passed away. She only slept one night with us and the next day she was gone. After watching the news and seeing what's happening with other families on the border, I feel so sad because we went through the same thing ourselves. If you can find a way to support them, please do it. Please fight to prohibit the encaging of children and immigrant families. And you can also by helping us put a private bill in the Senate. Bob Casey has already done his Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 part by putting something in Congress. We ask that Senator Bob Casey also supports us with a private bill this time in the Senate. Thank you so much for your time, and I hope that you help us.
Thank you so much for your testimony. (Applause.)
Greetings, Council President Clarke and members of City Council.
I am here to speak on or provide some comments on Bill 170673, the Cobbs Creek Restoration and Community Foundation. I come before you today to provide a voice to many golfers who use the golf courses owned by the City of Philadelphia. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 I'm kind of upset. This is like nothing compared to what we just heard. Recently we learned that in an article in the June 13th, 2018 Philadelphia Inquirer about the plans for Cobbs Creek Restoration and Community Foundation to enter into an agreement to improve and manage the Cobbs Creek and Karakung Golf Courses and the City Line Sports Center. On Tuesday, June 19th, 2018, I was able to get a copy of the relevant document called Community Benefits Statement, which I shared with a number of golfers who play on several of the City-owned golf courses, as I do. I'm fortunate enough to be retired from the City and I play golf every day, all year. A meeting was called with several golfers from the City to discuss the plans that we had read about in the Inquirer. We recognize we are extremely late getting into the process involving Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 this proposal. However, we appreciate the opportunity you're providing today to give consideration to a suggestion from these golfers. It is related to Section 2, Paragraph B in the Community Benefits Statement. Specifically we ask that an Advisory Committee on Golf be created, made up of the golfers in the City, who play on the City golf courses. Further, we ask that the Recreation Department consult with the Advisory Committee on Golf on matters related to fee schedules and access to playing time for golfers. This is a key concern for the golfers who play daily on the City golf courses, a large number of whom are retirees, unable to afford the rates charged on privately owned public courses. In closing, we regret we did not have more of an opportunity to participate in the development of the proposal. Many of the components have our wholehearted support. It is our hope Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 that the creation of the Advisory Committee on Golf will provide an opportunity for more communications with the golfers and lead to an increase in rounds played on the City courses and in particular provides some protection for the young people who come along behind us old folks. And in closing, I'd like to add another point. I was able to discuss with the members of the Foundation today and share with them a document, printed version of what I just mentioned, and John Burnes, the Executive Secretary, has indicated that he supports this request from the golfers of the City of Philadelphia. I thank you for your time.
Emmanuel Bussie, commenting on 180351. (Witness approached podium.)
Good afternoon, Councilman Clarke, members of City Council. I'm commenting on 180351. I just want to start by saying that I hope that the closed circuit cameras get a chance to take a look at Council while we're up here testifying. And I know that you guys control what angles and what you see, but me sitting here and watching a 70-year-old, what remind me of my mom, testifying, shaking, trying to hold back tears, and you pushing the button three and four different times to give it a red signal that she got to get off, I think as a suggestion -- I don't want to criticize you guys, but a suggestion, you might want to moderate that behavior, because we waited two hours for you to even come Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 into the Chambers, two extra hours for you to come into the Chambers to get started. And I think that when you have -- and I appreciate you when the young people were testifying, you didn't do that to them, and I really appreciated that. But I also noticed that while that young person was testifying, shaking, tears, crying, some Councilmembers were on their phone, they were chatting, texting, Facebooking. If you want us to regard you and respect you and you told us a number of times can you keep it down, can you keep it down, but a lot of the chatter come from our Councilmembers. So Albert Einstein said that you can't solve a problem in the same mindset that you were in when you created it. Stephen Covey said most significant break-throughs came with a break with. And I say that to say this to Council: What we're looking from you -and I come up here every time because I Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 try my best not to be critical. I come up here time after time to be encouraging of Council, and what we want from you guys, the most sophisticated and knowledgeable, highly technical Council to ever exist in the second largest city on the East Coast, is for you to give us more, because we expect more. We don't expect you when we come up here for our three minutes after some of us make almost $70 an hour, we pay our parking, we come downtown, leave our jobs to give you our three minutes and you on the phone Tweeting and texting and Facebooking. And if you want us to have the kind of regard and respect for you and our city, then you should lead by example. I came up here to testify about 180351, because you guys know that it is critical that we address the affordable housing problem. With Amazon wanting to come into our city, Apple, and Google, you know that it is actually critical Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 that you address the affordable housing issue. And I actually applaud you guys for having eight sponsors on a bill, because that's what we need you guys to do. We need you guys to work together. That's all we ask. All we ask is that you come together and work together to solve the systemic institutional issues in our city. You know you can't do that by yourself. No matter how great Kenyatta is, no matter how wonderful Cindy is, no matter how intelligent Maria Quinones is, no matter now bright Derek Green is, he can't do it by himself. The only way that you're going to solve these systemic problems that have existed for decades in our city is that you come together. Anything other than that, you're actually wasting time and playing games. We need you to do exactly what you did on Bill No. 180351, though not perfect, because it's supposed to be an affordable housing bill. Somehow it Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 turned into an affordable housing/home improvement bill. We can't let the perfection be the enemy of the good. And I'm going to say to my friend, David Oh, you say that 180351 doesn't provide enough resources to address the real problem. Neither does your $50 million bill.
So don't be hypocritical, because your $50 million you know is not enough to solve the affordable housing bill. So if you want to vote no on that bill, you should vote no on your own bill. So let's be serious and let's stop playing games and let's get some real stuff done, because we got real issues in our city. I thank you. I encourage you guys. I appreciate you guys trying to make bold, aggressive moves to transform our city. Thank you.
Thank you for your testimony. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (Applause.)
Rochelle Bilal, commenting on 180351. (Witness approached podium.)
Good afternoon. I had to check to see was it morning or afternoon. Good afternoon to Council President Clarke, to the Councilmembers here, and everybody here today. I have a list of a lot of bills, because I'm constantly researching every bill that you put up there and pass and list. But I'm going to go to mine that I've been harping on, that 160248 first. Vote no. You keep trying to give away the kitchen sink. Because you want other people to come in here and do business, you're going to give them a break on the occupancy tax and you don't give those that constantly have businesses in the City a break on their Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 occupancy tax. Vote no. Until you give us one, they don't get none. That's 160248. And it ain't got nothing to do with the person that initiated it. 180347 -- I'm staying in my three minutes. You ain't going to have to buzz me off, but I'm going to get them in -- and 180351. Nothing is perfect. Nobody gets everything they want, whether it's a bill, whether it's in life, whether it's the car you want to get. You don't get everything you want in that car, because if I could, I'd get some wings on there and fly around the City instead of in the traffic. No stadium, no deal. That's what that was for. We are saying you don't get everything that you want, but we applaud you that you are trying. Housing in the City is at an all-time high. People can't find any place to live here. And for those who are stuck, there are retirees -- and I'm retired -- that if we pay all these taxes that y'all keep Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 increasing and still talking about more, then we don't have money to fix up our housing. So I see both sides of this, but it is something. If you've been on Council more than 5, 10, 15, 20 years and poverty has increased under your watch, you are not doing your job. (Applause.)
At some point you've got to address the issue, because you can't keep going on and not. I say vote yes. We support you, and we'll do anything that we can to help you and even donate to your campaign. I got a couple dollars. 180430, defiant trespass -- I'm finishing up with my 11 seconds. Yes. I have a friend that is living next to a person who is squatting in the house. She's a homeowner. She lives up in Bass's district, and her name is Mariama Bahador, and she is going through hell because the person next door is tormenting her. She's the homeowner Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 next door to a squatter. Vote yes for 180430. And that lawyer that came up in here talking about what it don't address, well, it is going to address those who go in properties, take people homes because they get sick, especially the elderly and the weak, and take over their property and give them hell, and the police and nobody does anything to support them. Vote yes. Please vote yes. At least they will have something, something to help them fight off people that's just taking over people houses. And watch those that are sending you letters talking about they want to buy your house, because if you don't respond, then they'll go after getting in your house and squatting and you'll have to go through the same thing.
Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Thank you for your testimony. (Applause.)
Tiffany Green, commenting on 180511 and 170678. (Witness approached podium.)
Good afternoon. First, I want to say I'm asking City Council to please set up an area for disabled people who are not in wheelchairs, who have canes, on this side, if you can, because I didn't appreciate seeing a blind man escorted upstairs on the second floor when he should have been able to come in and sit right here in this area. So we're asking for those that's not in a wheelchair to have a disabled part. Thank you. (Applause.)
Number two, I want to talk about this mixed housing bill and also the construction tax bill. My concern at this point is that I feel as Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 though these bills are peanuts. We have been coming down here asking you to help us. Now, you're talking about one percent. One percent is not a lot of money at all. I mean, you mean to tell me that you're so concerned with your association that you cannot increase it to and percent? You talk about the mixed housing. You're only talking about 10 percent. I have developers that come with -- they're doing like ten. What you going to get? One unit. Or you're doing 20, you're only going to get two units. You keep the low-income, minority community at a disadvantage there. We need to have balanced reinvestment. You cannot keep ramming down our throats about mixed-income housing, but yet you don't want to put forth the bill for mixed-income housing. Yet you have a get out the neighborhood in this particular bill. You allowed a developer to pay money so he don't have Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 to include affordable housing in his unit. Well, that's keeping it elite and wealthy, and that's not right and that's not fair, because at this particular point, he'll give you $300,000 so he can keep it upscale. He don't have a problem with that. One-time fee? These people are being told that it's up and coming. They feel as though at this point when they buy into this particular complex, that you all or we all going to be out of here in five to eight years. Up and coming means that you're going to be out of here in five to eight years. We have -- over at the ZBA, we have developers coming down here who are doing five units, three units, ten units, and don't want to give you not one affordable housing. You need to have it from the get-go. If you're putting in three, give us one. If you're giving five, give us two. That's the only way you're going to maintain it. Because at Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 this particular point -- and then you have over at the ZBA yesterday I have a developer who already done numerous market rate. He come with three more condos, didn't want to give us one, and kept -- and DiCicco is going to approve him for the project. I have a developer last week who came through with 27 -- last month, 27. Didn't want to give us not one. We asked him for nine affordable. He didn't want to give up not one affordable unit. And then we go down to the ZBA and then DiCicco goes and passes it through. How do you have the person who introduced the ten-year tax abatement bill down there making decisions about affordable housing and about the units? You cannot. You're not going to go against your own policy, and that is where I'm saying you're not doing right by this. We need at this particular point, we need affordable housing. We cannot be going back to blocks -- and I'm Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 saying since I've been doing this -- and I've been coming down a long time -- we have a lot of units coming here, and you have 98 percent no black or brown people going into these houses. We are not here for -- we here for new development. Okay? This has turned into racist development. This is racist development that we are experiencing, and it's not fair to us longtime Philadelphians who have been here for a long time. And I'm saying that these bills need to be amended and you need to talk with the people who are at ground zero.
There are no other speakers on the public comment list, Mr. President.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Decker. We will now consider today's Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Consent Agenda. I would ask Mr. Decker to read the titles of all resolutions on the Consent Agenda. After each title is read -- before I do that, hold on one second. I almost forgot. I just want to announce I have a special guest here today. I just want to call him out. Micah Gold-Markel. So he is actually the winner of the Friends of Adaire Silent Auction, and I want to -(Applause.)
And the winning prize was you got to come down here and be with us today. So I don't know how much you paid, but thank you for your commitment to Adaire School. We appreciate what you've done. Thank you. Let me start over again. Before we do, let me recognize Councilman Squilla. I think he wants a suspension of the rules.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move the rules of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 be suspended to permit the introduction of an additional bill at this time. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
An ordinance legalizing an existing garage extension encroachment at 1815 South 8th Street, Philadelphia, PA 19148.
Thank you, Mr. Decker. That will be referred to the appropriate committee. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 time, I will ask Mr. Decker to read the titles of all the resolutions on the Consent Agenda. After each title is read, any member may object to the inclusion of the resolution on the Resolution Consent Agenda. Upon such an objection and without debate, the resolution will be immediately removed from the Resolution Consent Agenda and placed on today's regular Final Passage Calendar. Mr. Decker, will you please read the titles of the resolutions on the Resolution Consent Agenda.
Resolution No. 180652, entitled a "Resolution urging the Pennsylvania Legislature to support House Bill 2132 and Senate Bill 1140, which would commit the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to 100 percent renewable energy by 2050"; and Resolution No. 180653, entitled a "Resolution approving the redevelopment contract of the Philadelphia Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 for the redevelopment and urban renewal of a portion of the Mantua Urban Renewal Area, identified by house number and street address as 3721 through 3729 Brandywine Street"; and Resolution No. 180654, entitled a "Resolution also naming West Mantua Avenue between Brown and 36th Streets Herman C. Wrice Way in recognition of his role in creating the Young Great Society in Mantua and his remarkable community activism in mentoring young people and fighting tirelessly against drug violence"; and Resolution No. 180655, entitled a "Resolution also naming North 34th Street between Mantua and Fairmount Avenues 'Tim Spencer Boulevard' in recognition of his role in creating the Mural Arts Program in Philadelphia"; and Resolution No. 180656, entitled a "Resolution also naming the 6000 block of Springfield Avenue 'Marcus J. Yates Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Way', in honor of the legacy of Marcus Yates, whose tragic death has helped bring awareness to gun violence all over Philadelphia"; and Resolution No. 180659, entitled a "Resolution approving the agreements of sale of the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority for the redevelopment and urban renewal of a portion of the Model Cities Urban Renewal Area, to convey certain portions of property identified by house number and street address as 1600 through 1636 North Broad Street"; and Resolution No. 180660, entitled a "Resolution approving the redevelopment contract of the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority for the redevelopment and urban renewal of a portion of the Model Cities Urban Renewal Area, identified by house number and street address as 3101 Cecil B. Moore Avenue"; and Resolution No. 180662, entitled a "Resolution authorizing the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Bank to dispose of 1106 North Street located in the 5th Councilmanic District"; and Resolution No. 180666, entitled a "Resolution authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property to execute and deliver to the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority, without consideration, deeds conveying conditional fee simple title to certain City-owned lots or pieces of ground with the buildings and improvements thereon, situate in the Seventh Ward of the City of Philadelphia"; and Resolution No. 180670, entitled a "Resolution commending the Pennsylvania General Assembly for working in a bipartisan manner to address victims' rights and declaring support for the enactment of Marsy's Law in Pennsylvania, which seeks to better promote and protect the rights of crime victims and their families through an amendment to the Pennsylvania Constitution"; and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 R. 5623, providing for the relief of Carmela Apolonio Hernandez, and her four children, Fidel Artillero Apolonio, Keyri Artillero Apolonio, Yoselin Artillero Apolonio, and Edwin Artillero Apolonio due to extraordinary circumstances of persecution, and calling on the United States Department of Homeland Security to exercise prosecutorial discretion to stay the family's removal and join a motion to reopen the Hernandez family's case for asylum"; and Resolution No.
180676, entitled a "Resolution approving the redevelopment contract of the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority for the redevelopment and urban renewal of a portion of the Logan Redevelopment Area, identified by house numbers and street addresses as 4715 through 4755 North Marshall Street, 701 through 741 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (including 700 through 716 Wyoming Avenue), 901 through 939 Roosevelt Boulevard (including 922 through 940 Courtland Street and 4523 through 4545 North Tenth Street), 4710 through 4750 North Marshall Street (including 4723 through 4767 North Seventh Street), 4714 through 4766 North Seventh Street (including 4715 through 4769 North Franklin Street and 701 through 715 Wyoming Avenue), 4715 through 4765 North Eighth Street (including 4714 through 4768 North Franklin Street and 717 through 731 West Wyoming Avenue), 4700 through 4762 North Eighth Street (including 4701 through 4763 North Ninth Street), 4712 through 4764 North Ninth Street (including 901 through 919 West Wyoming Avenue and 4715 through 4769 North Hutchinson Street), 4715 through 4765 North Tenth Street (including 921 through 939 West Wyoming Avenue and 4714 through 4760 North Hutchinson Street), 4608 through 4626 North Eighth Street Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (including 800 through 824 West Wyoming Avenue and 4621 through 4647 North Ninth Street), 4600 through 4650 North Ninth Street (including 900 through 918 West Wyoming Avenue and 4601 through 4655 North Hutchinson Street), 4601 through 4655 North Tenth Street (including 920 through 938 West Wyoming Avenue and 4600 through 4650 North Hutchinson Street), 4511 through 4549 North Eleventh Street, 4508 through 4546 North Tenth Street, 4601 through 4655 North Eleventh Street, 4600 through 4654 North Tenth Street, 4711 through 4761 North Eleventh Street and 4712 through 4764 North Tenth Street"; and Resolution No. 180403, entitled a "Resolution approving the appointment of Abby Pozefsky to the Philadelphia Water, Sewer and Storm Water Rate Board"; and Resolution No. 180470, entitled a "Resolution confirming the appointment of Barbara Moore as a member of the Board Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Philadelphia Energy Authority, to serve in the term ending January 1, 2019"; and Resolution No. 180471, entitled a "Resolution confirming the reappointment of Christopher Lewis as a member of the Board of the Philadelphia Energy Authority, to serve in the term ending January 1, 2023"; and Resolution No. 180578, entitled a "Resolution confirming the appointment of Michael Kopistansky, as a member of the Board of the Philadelphia Energy Authority, to serve in the term ending January 1, 2023"; and Resolution No. "
Thank you, Mr. Decker. The Chair recognizes Councilman Henon for a motion to adopt each of the resolutions on the Resolution Consent Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of each of the resolutions on the Consent Agenda. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It has been moved and seconded that each of the resolutions on the Resolution Consent Agenda be adopted. All in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and each of the resolutions on the Resolution Consent Agenda has been adopted. We will now consider today's Bill Consent Agenda. I will ask Mr. Decker to read the titles of all the bills on the Consent Agenda. After each title is read, any member may object to Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 of the bill on the Consent Agenda. Upon such an objection and without debate, the bill will be immediately removed from the Consent Agenda and placed on our regular and Final Passage Calendar. Mr. Decker, will you please now read the titles of the bills on the Consent Agenda.
Bill No. 180346-A, entitled "An ordinance to amend Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Zoning and Planning,' by revising and clarifying certain provisions"; and Bill No. 180557-A, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 22 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Public Employees Retirement Code,' to expand 'Plan 16' to include certain employees, to change contribution rates for certain employees and the City, to amend various provisions relating to the Deferred Retirement Option Plan, and to make Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 amendments"; and Bill No. 180599-A, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 22 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Public Employees Retirement Code,' to provide for additional members of Plan 16, to change contribution rates and to specify the Stacked Hybrid Cap for certain employees"; and Bill No. 180001-A, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 6 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Health Code,' by adding a new Chapter 6-310, entitled 'Sodium Safety Warning Labeling for Chain Restaurants,'"; and Bill No. 180015-A, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the City of Philadelphia to organize an authority to be known as the Callowhill Business Improvement District"; and Bill No. 180286-A, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 an area bounded by Girard Avenue, Broad Street, Fairmount Avenue, and Corinthian Street"; and Bill No. 180261-A, entitled "An ordinance amending Subsection 19-2604(6) of The Philadelphia Code, under which businesses may enter into agreements to make contributions to community development corporations and certain other organizations to receive credits against business income and receipts taxes, by increasing the number of businesses for which the credit shall be made available to"; and Bill No. 180163-A, entitled "An ordinance to adopt a Fiscal 2019 Capital Budget"; and Bill No. 180428-A, entitled "An ordinance establishing no truck parking and tow away regulations on Black Lake Place from McNulty Road to its terminus further southwardly therefrom"; and Bill No. 180512-A, entitled "An ordinance revising parking regulations on Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 between South Broad Street and South Front Street"; and Bill No. 180514-A, entitled "An ordinance revising parking regulations on Spruce Street between South Broad Street and South 2nd Street"; and Bill No. 180234-A, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 21 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Miscellaneous,' by creating a new Chapter 21-2600, entitled 'Environmental Impact Statements,' to provide for the preparation of such statements in connection with Council legislation"; and Bill No. 180162, entitled "An ordinance to adopt a Capital Program for the six Fiscal Years 2019 through 2024 inclusive"; and Bill No. 180423, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by the Delaware River, Pennypack Street Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 (extended), State Road, Rhawn Street, Frankford Avenue, Academy Road, and Linden Avenue (extended)"; and Bill No. 180424, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 14-603 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Use Specific Standards,' by amending the number of curb cuts permitted for certain zoning districts"; and Bill No. 180426, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Packer Avenue, 10th Street, Citizens Bank Way, Pattison Avenue, and Broad Street"; and Bill No.
180427, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Dunks Ferry Road, the Poquessing Creek, Knights Road, Mechanicsville Road, Medford Road, and Lester Road"; and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 180451, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Master Plan for the University of Pennsylvania, and to approve the proposed addition to 3900 Walnut Street"; and Bill No. 180454, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Grant Avenue, Academy Road, Convent Avenue, Willits Road, and Ashton Road"; and Bill No. 180463, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 14-604 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Accessory Uses and Structures' by making technical changes to the size and siting of Roof Deck Access Structures"; and Bill No. 180496, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code to revise certain provisions of Chapter 14-600, entitled 'Use Regulations,' by amending exceptions to use tables for green roofs"; and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 180498, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Zoning and Planning,' to provide for the procedures for the Administrative Review process"; and Bill No. 180501, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 14-500 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Overlay Zoning Districts,' by creating a new overlay entitled /FAO, Frankford Academy Overlay District"; and Bill No. 180503, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Blue Grass Road, Grant Avenue, Ashton Road, Willits Road, Welsh Road, Dewees Street, Revere Street, Tremont Street, Leonard Street, and Welsh Road"; and Bill No. 180505, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Frankford Avenue, Felton Street, Arch Street, and Gross Street"; and Bill No. 180506, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Master Plan for the River Road Residential Mixed-Use Area, bounded by the Montgomery County Line, a Railroad Right-of-Way, Shawmont Avenue, and the Schuylkill River, to approve a subdivision and the construction of a utility project"; and Bill No. 180507, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Conrad Street, Indian Queen Lane, Scotts Lane, and Crawford Street"; and Bill No. 180509, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Zoning and Planning,' by creating a new Wissahickon /NCO, Neighborhood Conservation Overlay Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the area generally bounded by Henry Avenue, Hermit Street, Ridge Avenue, and the Wissahickon Creek"; and Bill No. 180510, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 14-500 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Overlay Zoning Districts,' by amending the subsection entitled '/NCA, Ridge Avenue Neighborhood Commercial Area Overlay'"; and Bill No. 180517, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Leiper Street, Oxford Avenue, Harrison Street, Oakland Street and Foulkrod Street"; and Bill No.
180518, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Roosevelt Boulevard, Godfrey Avenue, Castor Avenue, and Fillmore Street"; and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 180519, entitled "An ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Allegheny Avenue, Kensington Avenue, Lehigh Avenue, and 2nd Street"; and Bill No. 180367, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 16-400 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Vacant and Surplus Properties,' to allow property dispositions by the Philadelphia Land Bank"; and Bill No. 180453, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the Procurement Commissioner and the Free Library of Philadelphia to enter into a sublease agreement to lease from the Philadelphia Municipal Authority personal computers and associated equipment, and receive related maintenance and other services, for the use of the Free Library of Philadelphia"; and Bill No. 180455, entitled "An Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the Commissioner of Public Property to enter into a lease agreement with Why Partners for use by the City of a portion of the premises located at 1425 Arch Street"; and Bill No. 180456, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property to acquire fee simple title or a lesser real estate interest to all or a portion of parcels of land, together with the improvements thereon, located in and about the area bounded by West Huntingdon Street, North 31st Street, West York Street and North Napa Street"; and Bill No. 180462, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property to enter into an amendment to sublease agreement with the Philadelphia Authority for Industrial Development for the use by the City of premises located at 1101 Market Street"; and Bill No. 180508, entitled "An Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 the Commissioner of Public Property to acquire fee simple title or a lesser real estate interest to all or a portion of a parcel or parcels of land, together with the improvements thereon, located in and about the area bounded by the Schuylkill River, The Schuylkill River Trail, Hagys Mill Road and Port Royal Avenue"; and Bill No. 180236, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 307 by placing on the City Plan an irregularly-shaped area extending along the northerly side of John F. Kennedy Boulevard, from Twenty-Second Street to Twenty-Third Street, in order to conform with the lines established by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania"; and Bill No. 180348, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 4 of The Philadelphia Code (The Philadelphia Building Construction and Occupancy Code), Subcode PM (The Philadelphia Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Code), by adding requirements regarding the use of dumpsters on private property"; and Bill No. 180464, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 4 of The Philadelphia Code, 'The Philadelphia Building Construction and Occupancy Code,' by amending Subcode 'F' (The Philadelphia Fire Code) and Subcode 'PM' (The Philadelphia Property Maintenance Code), to add sections requiring hard-wired interconnected smoke alarms in boarding homes"; and Bill No. 180521, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 4 of The Philadelphia Code by amending Sections A-503 (entitled 'Prosecution') and A-601 (entitled 'Fines') of The Philadelphia Administrative Code, to provide for assessment of an additional penalty in connection with repeated abatements of unlawful conditions on vacant and exterior properties"; and Bill No. "
Thank you, Mr. Decker. These bills having been read on two different days, the question for each bill now is shall the bill pass finally. The Clerk shall call the roll, and upon being called, each Councilmember shall vote aye on each of the bills, nay on each of the bills or indicate those bills for which the member is voting aye and those bills for which the member is voting nay. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Decker, can you please call the roll.
Aye on all bills. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye on all bills. The majority of all members having voted in the affirmative for each of the bills, the bills on the Consent Agenda are passed. We will now consider the bills and resolutions on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar. Mr. Decker, please read the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING title of 180661.
A resolution authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property to execute and deliver to the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority, without consideration, deeds conveying conditional fee simple title to certain City-owned lots or pieces of ground with the buildings and improvements thereon, situate in the Thirty-Second Ward of the City of Philadelphia.
Thank you, Mr. President. I would like to offer an amendment on your behalf to Resolution No. 180661. A copy of that amendment has been circulated to all members, and I move for the adoption of the amendment. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor? Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING (Aye.)
The ayes have it. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Greenlee on Resolution 180661.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move the adoption of the resolution, as amended. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. Resolution 180661 is adopted. Mr. Decker, 180663.
A resolution also Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING naming the 2400 block of North 59th Street as "W. Wilson Goode, Sr. Way" in honor of former Mayor Dr. W. Wilson Goode, Sr., and in commemoration of his life-long and dedicated service to the citizens of Philadelphia.
Thank you, Mr. President. I would like to offer an amendment to Resolution No. 180663. A copy of that amendment has been circulated to all members of Council, and I move for the adoption of the amendment. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING ayes have it, and the amendment is approved. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Jones.
Thank you again, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution, as amended. (Duly seconded.)
Moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. Resolution 180663 is adopted. Mr. Decker, 180668.
A resolution calling upon Governor Tom Wolf and the General Assembly to enact the proposal of the Philadelphia Parking Authority in order to provide new capital funding for Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING the School District of Philadelphia.
Thank you, Council President. Many people in this body know that my mother taught in the School District about 31 years, 25 of those years at Olney High School, and that my son is a 10th grade high school student at Hill-Freedman World Academy in Councilwoman Parker's Ninth Council District. In fact, one of the first things I did when I came into this body, one of my first legislative actions was having hearings regarding the environment of our schools following the unfortunate situation where SEIU 32BJ member Chris Trakimas lost his life at the Edmonds School, and we had hearings regarding that issue. From there, myself and other members of this body joined the Philadelphia Healthy School Initiative to really address and raise awareness Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING regarding some of the concerns we had about hazards in our school, hazards like lead paint, lead in our water, mold, and asbestos. And, in fact, the legislation introduced today by Councilman Mark Squilla is a continuation of the work that a number of Councilmembers have taken regarding the concerns we have regarding our schools. Councilmembers Brown and Gym and others have really been leaders in that regard of addressing these issues in our schools. Last week we had a press conference here in the Council Chambers calling on Governor Wolf and the General Assembly to support an initiative that's being proposed by the Philadelphia Parking Authority and others to provide some additional dollars to our School District. We were joined in this press conference by our democratic Chair of Appropriations, Senator Vincent Hughes, as well as State Representative Jim Roebuck, who is the democratic Chair of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING the Education Committee, as well as State Senator Art Haywood and representatives from the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, SEIU 32BJ, as well as Principal Natalie Catin St. Louis from Nebinger Elementary School, as well as Gretchen Dahlkemper, who testified earlier during the public comment. The reason we came together to support this press conference is that it would add an opportunity of adding 50 cents per share to ride shares in the City of Philadelphia, which could provide another $8 million that can be used for dedicated funding for our School District. We've been talking with the School District. Dr. Hite also supports this proposal. And that $8 million could be dedicated funding that could be leveraged for another $100 million in capital dollars for our schools. As you know from all the issues we've been discussing not only in this body and also in the Toxic City stories Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING that we read about, we need additional money for our schools and especially for capital improvements to improve the physical conditions of our schools. Considering that information and considering this opportunity, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. Resolution No. 180668 is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of 170678-A.
An ordinance amending Title 7 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Housing Code,' by adding Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING a new Chapter 7-200, entitled 'Mixed Income Housing Program,' to provide for affordable housing standards; amending Section 14-702 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Mixed Income Housing,' to make related changes; amending Chapters 14-600 and 14-700 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled, respectively, 'Use Regulations' and 'Development Standards,' to amend certain zoning standards relating to residential development.
This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, call the roll.
Aye. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. The ayes are 17; the nays are zero. A majority of members present voting in the affirmative, the bill passes. Mr. Decker, 180164-A.
An ordinance adopting the Operating Budget for Fiscal Year 2019.
This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is shall the bill pass Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING finally. Mr. Decker, call the roll.
Aye. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. The ayes are 16; the nays are Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING one. A majority of members present voting in the affirmative, the bill passes. Mr. Decker, 180347-A.
An ordinance amending Chapter 21-1600 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Housing Trust Fund," to authorize the establishment of separate sub-funds to receive, respectively, revenues attributable to recording fees and revenue attributable to certain payments required upon construction of certain real estate.
This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, call the roll.
Councilwoman Blackwell. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Councilwoman Parker. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. CHIEF Clerk: The ayes are 13; the nays are four.
Thank you, Mr. Decker. A majority of members present voting in the affirmative, the bill passes. Mr. Decker, please read the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING title of 180351-A.
An ordinance providing for a payment to the City upon the construction of certain real estate, and directing Council to appropriate revenues from such payments to the Department of Planning and Development Division of Housing and Community Development, in order to support equitable neighborhood development by constructing affordable housing, including units for sale or rent, and by providing assistance to Philadelphians who desire to become homeowners.
This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, call the roll.
Councilwoman Blackwell. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Councilwoman Parker. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. The ayes are nine; the nays are eight. A majority of members present voting in the affirmative, the bill passes. (Audience members booing.)
Okay. Mr. Decker, please read the title of 160007. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
An ordinance repealing an Ordinance (Bill No. 150894) entitled "An ordinance authorizing the striking from City Plan No. 119 and abandoning of a certain pedestrian walkway reserved within the bed of former Thompson Street, from Watts Street to Thirteenth Street, and the modifying of a certain right-of-way for drainage purposes, water main purposes, gas main purposes, and public utility purposes, also reserved within the bed of said former Thompson Street."
Thank you, Mr. President. On your behalf, I move that Bill No. 160007 be withdrawn. (Duly seconded.)
It's been motioned and properly seconded. All those in favor? (Aye.)
Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Those opposed? (No response.)
The ayes have it. Bill 160007 is withdrawn. Mr. Decker, 180430.
An ordinance amending Title 10 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Regulation of Individual Conduct and Activity," Chapter 10-800, "Safety," by adding a new Section 10-840, "Criminal and Defiant Trespassers," by establishing and clarifying procedures to remove criminal and defiant trespassers from real property.
Thank you, Mr. President, for I wish to be heard on this bill prior to voting. For the record, I just want to start by thanking all of the residents in the City of Philadelphia who have, in essence, stood up via through letter writing, through calls to our offices, by Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING coming during our public comment period to share their experiences and/or testify in the November and/or the most recent hearing to share their stories. In essence, Mr. President, what these residents attempted to do was to ensure that this issue that is called illegal squatting or criminal squatting, that there is a prevention of delayed justice so that those who are suffering and negatively impacted by this have some recourse and that the irreparable harm that is being caused to homeowners who are living near it -- and I heard someone testify about this earlier. In essence, the residents of the City of Philadelphia have said, City Council of Philadelphia, we want you and this city to come up with a very sound legislative remedy, a practical remedy/policy to ensure that this issue is addressed in the City. It is with this in mind, Mr. President, that I want to state for the record that I will be voting no on Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Bill No. 180430, and I will share why, but just for the record, I want to say a special thank you to my colleagues who have attempted to find a solution to address this problem, Councilman Oh, Councilman Taubenberger. And I would be remiss for the record if I did not thank Councilman Allan Domb along with Councilwoman Helen Gym for their efforts at diplomacy before I got actively engaged on this issue in trying to find some common ground. In addition to that, Mr. President, I also want to thank the housing advocates at Community Legal Services, the Tenant Union Representative Network, TURN, the SeniorLAW Center, and the Public Interest Law Center of Philadelphia, who I also want to state for the record despite what we have heard on a number of occasions presented and strongly recommended in both versions challenges they had with the legislative solution that was proffered. They Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING produced -- and I just want to note this for the record. m. that notes, amendments to the bill as introduced in the fall and that these issues, these same issues, were not addressed when the new version of the bill was drafted. In addition to that, there was a fact sheet that was sent to us by Community Legal Services and the Public Interest Law Center that noted very early on, Mr. President, that this definition was too broad. And, two, because they gave us this summary or this fact sheet, someone might attempt to argue that we expected them to do the work of our technical staff, our personal staff or either our Law Department and draft the amendment language for us when as advocates what they do is they present to us the challenges they find in the laws that we propose, and that's exactly what this fact sheet did. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Now, let me just talk about the facts from my perspective. One, Mr. President, the first reason why I would be voting no on this legislation today is that State Representative John Taylor has introduced and has passed out of the House legislation moving forward on the state level. As a matter of fact, it was just yesterday, Mr. President, that the bill was passed out of the House, and it now moves to the Senate. And just for the record, while it is unclear on what parts of Rep Taylor's bill will, in essence, be preempted -- or will preempt the bill that is before us, we're having our Law Department cross-reference it.
I want you to know that the bill to address this issue at the state level was supported by Rep Taylor, Morgan Cephas, William Keller, Maria Donatucci, who is the Chair of the Philadelphia Delegation in the Pennsylvania House, Driscoll, Jared Solomon, along with Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Representative Cruz. Second -- that's one. So, one, we have a bill that has been passed out of the House and is over in the Senate to address this issue. And so we have issues of preemption because we did not, Mr. President, work in advance with our colleagues in the State House. In addition to that, I also want to be clear about this. Now, for those of you who represent people who live in the community where the transference of property occurs naturally because they have access to a lawyer and/or an attorney and that a will when someone passes away is a standard operating procedure, then this doesn't matter to you, but I want us to be clear that this bill that is in front of us notes that a criminal and defiant trespasser -- this is the definition. A person who occupies residential property without title, including 21 years of adverse possession. Now, for those who Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING are like me who are not lawyers, you say what does 21 years of adverse possession mean. Adverse possession is what we know of particularly in the African American community, I've experienced this, grand-mom passes away, there was no deed left around or transferred to me during her illness. I live in the property and I've been taking care of the property, but this will be called a no deed or either a tangled title issue, but I live there and I take care of the property. I would be considered a criminal and defiant trespasser even if 21 years of adverse possession is what is noted. Now, Mr. President, for you and the members of this body who took the lead to work on cleaning up the code, Mr. President, that's what the business community told us to do. They said, Philadelphia, you have laws on the books that are antiquated and outdated. It is preventing business from being done decently and in order, so you need to Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING comb through this code and you need to clean it up. Well, Mr. President, this body is being asked to vote on a bill today that is in direct conflict with Governor Wolf and a bill that he just signed into law. The bill is House Bill 352, and the law allows an individual to obtain a clear title to a property under adverse possession. Guess what, Mr. President? I was about to call you Mr. Speaker again. Adverse possession, Mr. President, but, listen, not the 21 years that is noted and that we are about to pass into law, but ten years that the Governor has just signed into law. So you mean this legislative body is literally being asked to take legislative action on a bill, not like Rep Taylor's that has just been passed out of House and is going to the Senate, but now you're asking me to vote in the affirmative on a bill that is in direct Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING conflict with a law, an act that Governor Wolf just signed into order. That's not something I'm willing to do. The final and last thing I just want to note for the record, because this is important, Mr. President, because when they get it wrong, we call them out all of the time. But this was something that -- and it got to me today when I heard people testifying about the experiences. It got to me during the hearings. When people talked about they had nowhere to go and it was delayed, and even when they've reported the problem, they could get no recourse. Well, now as a result of a meeting that was referenced by Mr. Gould during his testimony, we had a task force hearing on May the 29th, 2018. Without passage of this bill, residents of the City of Philadelphia, our Police Department has already implemented a procedure.
Well, what did you just say? That means before this Council passes Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING anything, it is already policy and procedure within the Police Department. Now, they can wrangle over who is going to take credit about who did what, and I know the sponsor of this bill, along with Councilman Domb, Councilman Taubenberger and lots of folks would have encouraged that action, but if you are a victim of squatting in any way, shape or form now, the City of Philadelphia via our Police Department is now doing the following things: They are immediately referring the case to a detective to investigate. We did not have that policy or procedure prior to Commissioner Ross, along with Inspector Fran Healy communicating this to us. Second, the detective will investigate any claim by a person who has an ownership interest in the property and who is claiming that someone is living there illegally. Well, before, Mr. President, you can say somebody was Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING living next door to you or they came and took your property, but there was no one who was specifically responsible for investigating it. We now have a detective in the Police Department who will make sure -- and that is a unit, not one -- that will be responsible for researching this information. And next, a detective will investigate if the person living there has proof of residence using several criteria to determine the proof. Now, based on the detective's investigation, the detective, guess what, the detective, Mr. President, not someone that is just making a decision about whether or not they believe it or not, this is going to be researched now. So instead of -- I want you to hear me. Instead of Ms. 49 and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING bought a package of leases and they completed this document and she's given them money and she thinks she's rented a property and she doesn't know that she has an illegal document and she's just been scammed, under this bill she would be a criminal trespasser, that she would have no recourse, because when her deed is researched, it would be found that it was an illegal document. That's one. Next, the detective will determine if there is probable cause to obtain an arrest warrant to remove an individual from a property. For all of you good government folks out there who are concerned about liability associated with the City of Philadelphia and it having an impact fiscally on the City of Philadelphia, I want you to think about what it is like if we are removing someone, our Police Department, through an affidavit or anything, they're going to remove someone from a property without just cause. This Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING due process is established without this legislation that we are being asked to vote on today. Next, the detective unit has the resources to determine if it's a case of just theft or if it's a case of theft and fraud; for example, if a person knowingly rented to someone and they're scamming them. And sometimes if the people residing in the property are victims themselves, the victim assistance officer for that police district will become involved to assist them with finding another place to live. Cherelle, why did you just walk through these remedies, this policy, these regulations that have been instituted before this becomes law? Because the Police Department is already doing this work, and no longer will residents in the City of Philadelphia be able to say we have no recourse, because now they do and they didn't before. Finally, I want to say this to Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING you, Mr. President, and this is extremely important. You can blame this on Harrisburg when you've had to work in a place when you're definitely always in the minority.
You have to start with bringing everybody to the table, even people who you think disagree with what your stance is. So we had this bright idea working with many of the agencies I referenced to put together a task force meeting, and which I want to thank most of the members of this Council, for if they didn't come themselves, they sent staff, and these are the people who were represented: Brian Kisielewski -- and I just chopped you up, Brian, but charge it to my head and not my heart; Kate Dugan. They were from the First Judicial District. From the District Attorney's Office, District Attorney Larry Krasner. Thank you so very much for your presence, but to Mike Lee and Lauren Townsend who were there, thank you for your input. Inspector Francis Healy from the Police Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Department; the Sheriff's Office, Staff Inspector Marquet Parsons; L&I, Basil Merenda; Department of Behavioral Health, Commissioner David Jones, Yolanda Hughes; DHS, Sam Harrison; Office of Homeless Services, MaryBeth Gonzalez; Water Department, Commissioner Debra McCarty; PGW, Joe Greenberg; Records Commissioner, James Leonard; City Solicitor, Law Department, Joe Altman; CLS; SeniorLAW; Public Interest; and Tenants. In addition to that, the private sector was there, GPAR, Matthew Braden, along with Harvey Spear from HAPCO. And we heard you loud and clear that this is having a negative impact on the rental industry and homeownership, and we want to address it. I want you to know for the record that all of the people and entities that I just mentioned, they all have a stake in this. Guess what? They were never once, they were never once asked to come to a meeting where all of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING them who have a role in this issue were asked to put their minds together. Let me give you an example. Several people who came and testified, guess what they said? The water was turned off. Why would the City of Philadelphia's Water Department go and turn back on the water? PGW, why are you legally giving them access to gas? PECO, why do they have access to electric? Do you know that in the City of Philadelphia there is no one-stop shop or clearinghouse for them to even know, so they deal with people who are renting properties all day long. But they don't have a place where they can affirm or check on whether or not this home is considered to be occupied by squatters. The only thing they know is that somebody brought a lease to them and said, hey, I'm renting, and they turned it on. But until now, there is no place. In addition to that, I also want to note this, and this is very Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING important, Mr. President, because I'm not going to have anyone -- and I really do mean exactly what I'm saying. All of my colleagues, the ten District Council colleagues, along with all of those at-large, we have all been faced with residents in the City of Philadelphia who have been impacted, and there is no one person who has done more, who cares more than the other. We have all been working hard to come up with a solution to address this issue. And I just want us to note for the record that this definition is so broad, for all of you who support our senior citizens, who support victims of domestic violence, who support victims' rights, that they could be deemed criminals and potentially penalized with a $300 fine or a 90-day imprisonment. As a matter of fact, on June the 4th, she couldn't be here today, so you didn't hear her voice today, but a woman testified named Margaret Green and, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Mr. President, she lives near my grandmother in North Philadelphia where my great-grandmother's house was, and she testified about how she rented her apartment from a man named Mr. Brown who claimed to be the heir of the prior owner. It turns out that the man was lying. He had forged the deed.
Now, after Ms. Green testified -- and you go back and check the notes of testimony -- the sponsor was asked whether or not this bill would affect her, and he was quoted as noting, this bill would not affect you. Well, because we wanted to do our due diligence, we immediately contacted the Law Department as to whether or not this bill as written would impact Ms. Green, and here is the response, and I quote, "If Mr. Brown was not the owner of the property, Ms. " My hope is that this bill will not be enforced in a way that penalizes Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING the victims. In addition to that, I want to note that this bill wouldn't even -- and I've got to say this for the record, because you all know that we've been dealing with this in Lawncrest, Lawndale, Burholme, and Oxford Circle. To the residents who live near Weymouth Street in Lawncrest, this bill could not and will not help you. You want me to tell you why? Because you don't have standing. If you are a resident on a block and you don't own that property like the one on Weymouth Street that's been abandoned because it's going to Sheriff Sale next month, you cannot -you do not have just cause in anything relative to that property. So those homeowners who no longer care about a house and walk away because it's going to foreclose or Sheriff Sale, it is the neighbors, not the negligent homeowner, who have to deal with the squatters or their illegal Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING activity. But under this bill, my constituents would not have standing, because they are neither the owner of the house or what in this bill is identified authorized agent. I want to note that we put our task force together. We're working, but I'm not going to be saying to residents of the City of Philadelphia that when we pass this law, this is a solution. It's not a solution. You won't help my residents on Weymouth Street. I'm not giving them a pseudo solution, a piece of paper that said we passed a law. In effect, that we can't force -- we can't dictate policy to the Police Department. The Law Department has given us an opinion that tells us we don't have the legal authority, this City Council of Philadelphia, to dictate policy to the Police Department. In addition to that, this bill actually also says that within five days, our courts have to hear the case. And, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING in fact, that's just not true. The language of the bill says five business days or such other time as is necessitated by the circumstances presented or applicable court procedure. " There is absolutely no guarantee that the courts will hear these cases in five days. And anyway, Council can't dictate their procedure. So, in effect, if Council passes this bill today, you are passing a piece of paper that you are proffering as a solution that doesn't give our residents the tool to address this issue. In addition to that, let's just note this, and I want to just say it for the record. There are three buckets. There are victims of fraud such as senior citizens who may be taken advantage of. That's a senior who wants to rent the house, not knowing that the person they're renting from doesn't own the home. They're being scammed. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING The second is people who are truly desperate. This is the bucket of people who are homeless. These are homeless individuals who need a roof over their head. They usually find abandoned buildings. And in my opinion, the best way to help these individuals is not by incarcerating them, but providing them with the necessary social services. That's why human services and social services were at our task force meeting. And, finally, it is the criminals. Let's keep it real. Criminals who know exactly what they are doing, they know it's illegal, and they have it down to a science. They scope out the homes.
They know when the homeowners are going on vacation or when a rental home has been vacant for a month or two. They take over the home. They immediately change the locks. And because we don't have one standard point of contact relative to this issue, they put some bills in their name. So they Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING even get PGW, PECO, and our Water Department to help them. What I'm saying to you today is, in our task force, the courts, the Police, L&I, anyone who -- the District Attorney's Office, the Sheriff's Office, they all noted that we need a solution, but we need one that is coherent. We need one where there is what one of my colleagues would often call a standard operating procedure, so that no matter where you live or which bucket your category of squatting falls under, there is a one-stop shop that is recording the data, we know what sections of the City this is happening in, we know whether or not we need social or human services involved, we know whether or not this is immediately just for law enforcement and we have the courts. But we should start with giving them the opportunity to respond to this issue, and we haven't done it, because we didn't even, Mr. President, start with giving every Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING agency in the City of Philadelphia who has a role in addressing this issue, we didn't even start with bringing them to the table to ask them what they thought or what their internal policies or procedures were. And so I thank you all so very much for your patience. I know based on the press, the task force isn't a headline-grabbing activity, Mr. President, because calling people together at a table to talk about what they're doing already and then figuring out how do we move together, where's our clearinghouse, where's the one-stop shop, that's not sexy, because that's gritty and dirty work, but to my surprise -- and I really mean this, and I'm not being sarcastic -- I think there have been journalists so far that have read the bill and they heard also the powers and the procedures that the Police Department have already enacted, and they have said this bill will not, will not be the Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING silver single bullet solution that many have proffered it to be to address squatting in the City of Philadelphia. So residents of the Ninth Councilmanic District, those who I'm immediate responsible to, I want you to know this vote no, this no vote that you're going to hear from me today, it's not because I don't hear you or I'm not acknowledging that it's a problem. I know it is, but I want to do it the right way with all of the parties at the table, and I think that's just where we should start. I thank my colleagues for your patience. I want you to think about how I feel when all of these recommendations were given in the fall and then in the spring and we didn't see any of it sort of incorporated into the process. So I thank you all so very much.
Thank you, Councilwoman. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Okay. This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, please call the roll.
Councilman Johnson. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
A majority of members present voting in the affirmative, the bill passes. We're going to take a quick break. (Short recess for the stenographer.)
We're back. Mr. Decker, I think we're going to call 180295.
An ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Zoning and Planning," by amending the One Year Rule; modifying certain public notice requirements and making related changes.
Thank you, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Mr. President. I'd like to offer an amendment to Bill No. 180295. A copy has been circulated to all members, and I move for the adoption of the amendment. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor? (Aye.)
The ayes have it. Bill No. 180295 is amended. It will be placed on our Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. That will not be next week. I think we have 180511.
An ordinance amending Section 14-503 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "/NCA, Neighborhood Commercial Area Overlay," by adding a new subsection entitled "South Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Broad Street Gateway."
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that Bill No. 180511 be withdrawn. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor? (Aye.)
The ayes have it. Bill No. 180511 is withdrawn at the request of the sponsor. Mr. Decker, 170673. Please read the title.
An ordinance authorizing the Parks and Recreation Commissioner, on behalf of the City of Philadelphia, to enter into an agreement for the use of Cobbs Creek Golf Club, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Karakung Golf Club, and the City Line Sports Center, under which the operator will restore...
This bill has been heard on -- I'm sorry. Councilman Jones.
Yes. Thank you, Mr. President. I'd like to go public on the record and thank the Chair of Parks and Rec for her due diligence in looking at this agreement with a fine-tooth comb and thank her for taking that responsibility for all Philadelphians, and I appreciate it. And, therefore, I've agreed to do three basic things upon passing this legislation. One, to amend with an agreement a quarterly review of the revenues and revenue projections and uses of those funds on a quarterly basis to maximize benefit to the City of Philadelphia. The second thing that I've agreed to push is -- which is already in Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING the legislation, is an advisory board. What we have not done is talked about the composition of that advisory board, representing City Council, representing the Rec Department, and representing, most importantly, the community. And the third thing that we've agreed on is to look at when if indeed we do get a national event and we finally get Tiger Woods, that we look at possible revenues in addition that can come to the City of Philadelphia from that national golf outing. I wanted to also say that I represent three golf courses in my district. One is private. It's Bala. But the other one is Cobbs Creek and Karakung. What we don't often know is the asset that we have. This is a golf course that helped break down the color barrier in the City of Philadelphia, that the first African American to win a national actually golfed and got his start here in Philadelphia in that golf Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING course. And so we want to restore it back to its original position and historic position within the City of Philadelphia. So with those provisos, I would seek my colleagues' support on this bill.
Thank you. Thank you, Councilman. Mr. Decker, call the roll. I'm sorry. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.
Thank you so much, Mr. President. I just really wanted to thank my colleague Councilman Jones for his work on this. It was really a team effort. And we just really want to make sure that whenever we are working with another entity, when we're talking about City assets, that we're really doing the right thing by our citizens, especially at times like this when we're asking them to dig deeper. So I just really wanted to say thank you so much to the Councilman. We Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING look forward to working with you and trusting that this is a process that is going to work and, most importantly, that it's going to work for the citizens of the City of Philadelphia and for the near neighbors who are most affected. So thank you, Councilman, so much.
Thank you, Councilwoman. This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, please call the roll.
Councilman Green. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Aye. The ayes are 17; the nays are zero. A majority of members present voting in the affirmative, the bill passes. Mr. Decker, do you have any additional resolutions?
A resolution authorizing the Committee on the Environment to Hold Hearings on The State of the Environment in 2018, introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
The Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution authorizing the Committee on Law and Government to Hold Hearings on Succession Planning for Appointed Officers in the City of Philadelphia, introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
The Chair one more recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
Thank you, Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution recognizing Monique Greenwood, Chief Enjoyment Officer of Akwaaba Bed and Breakfast Inns, and her husband Glenn Pogue on the opening of Akwaaba Philadelphia, introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
The Chair again recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution commending the Please Touch Museum for its Launch of Pride Family Weekend, introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
The Chair again recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING (Aye.)
And a resolution authorizing the Committee on Fiscal Stability and Intergovernmental Cooperation to hold public hearings to examine the financial condition of the City and School District of Philadelphia in light of a recent downgrade of the City's general obligation bond rating, to examine the impact that local control of the School District will have on the City's fiscal condition, introduced by Councilman Henon on behalf of Council President Clarke.
It's been moved and properly seconded. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution recognizing and honoring Reverend Quy K. Pham for his outstanding perseverance and for his recent ordination as a Priest by Archbishop Charles J. Chaput at the Cathedral Basilica of Saints Peter and Paul, introduced by Councilman Jones.
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Those opposed? (No response.)
And a resolution also naming the 5700 block of Race Street as "Reverend Dr. A.F. Campbell Way" in honor of Reverend Dr. Albert F. Campbell, to commemorate his forty-seven and a half years of preaching at Mount Carmel Baptist Church, introduced by Councilman Jones.
Thank you again, Mr. President. I move for its adoption. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
Those opposed? Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING (No response.)
And a resolution condemning the Trump Administration's "zero tolerance" immigration policy, which has resulted in thousands of children being separated from their parents after being detained at the United States border, and opposing the use of indefinite family detention as inhumane, introduced by Councilman Johnson.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor? (Aye.)
Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Those opposed? (No response.)
The ayes have it. The resolution is adopted. The Chair recognizes Councilman O'Neill.
Mr. Council President, I'd like to be recorded as voting no on that resolution.
And the record shall also reflect Councilman Taubenberger.
Resolution condemning the Trump Administration's "zero tolerance" immigration policy which has resulted in thousands of children Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING being separated from their parents after being detained at the United States border, and opposing the use of indefinite family detention as inhumane.
And a resolution Honoring and Recognizing Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity, Incorporated and Welcoming the 84th Grand Chapter Meeting to the City of Philadelphia in July 2019, introduced by Councilman Green.
In the spirit of 1911, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.) Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution authorizing the Committee on the Environment to hold hearings regarding the threat of wasted plastics to the health, safety, and wellbeing of the City and residents of Philadelphia, introduced by Councilman Green.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution recognizing and honoring Paul R. Levy, recipient of the 2017 Vision for Philadelphia Award, for his hard work and dedication to the City of Philadelphia, introduced by Councilman Domb.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Those opposed? (No response.)
And a resolution honoring the groundbreaking civil rights legacy of the Japanese American Citizens League on the occasion of its national convention in Philadelphia, and recognizing the 30th anniversary of the organization's successful redress campaign that led to the passage of the Civil Liberties Act of 1988, providing a national apology and financial reparations for Japanese Americans interned during World War II, introduced by Councilwoman Gym.
Thank you very much, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution authorizing the creation of a Youth Residential Placement Task Force, to make recommendations and provide guidance to safely reduce both the number of Philadelphia youth in residential placements and the use of placements outside of city limits, introduced by Councilwoman Gym.
The Chair one more time recognizes Councilwoman Gym.
Thank you very much, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.) Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And a resolution affirming that the imprisonment and prolonged detention of asylum-seeking children and families is in inhumane and counter to international law, and calling on Governor Wolf and the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services to issue an emergency removal order and immediately close the Berks County Residential Center, introduced by Councilwoman Gym.
The Chair one more time recognizes Councilwoman Gym.
Thank you very much, Council President. I think Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING this body has spoken up very significantly and I think the folks who have spoken earlier testifying to the issue of family separation and detention, the fact that the new law talks about -the new executive order, I'm sorry, by the President identifies family detention as preferable to family separation does not make the issue of detention any better. It is a big concern that Pennsylvania will be one of three family detention centers. If we're upset about little children as young as one year old being kept on the television cameras, that's what's happening at Berks right now. Many of those children have been there for months. Some of them have been there for almost a year. It's unhealthy. It's inhumane. We can do better. We need a sensible immigration and refugee policy, and I'm hoping that Pennsylvania doesn't become another symbol and place where we're going to see these kinds of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING things happening within our own Commonwealth. With that, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.
Sorry. Okay. Let the record reflect that Councilman O'Neill and Councilman Taubenberger are voting nay.
And a resolution recognizing and celebrating the announcement of the inaugural "Sister Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING Cities Friendly" soccer match between the Philadelphia Union and Germany's Eintracht Frankfurt professional soccer team. A portion of the proceeds raised will assist Philadelphia students to travel to our Sister and Partnership Cities, introduced by Councilman Taubenberger.
Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING
Hold on, Mike. The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.
Thank you, Council President. Council President, I would like to be dismissed, but I would like to be recorded as voting aye on all bills and resolutions. Thank you, Council President.
Thank you, Councilman. The record shall reflect that. Thank you. Mr. Decker, go ahead.
A resolution authorizing Council's Committee on Global Opportunities and the Creative/Innovative Economy and the Committee on Education to hold hearings on the availability of lab spaces and incubation facilities in the City of Philadelphia that are accessible to biotechnology, pharmaceutical, and Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING related start-up companies, introduced by Councilman Oh.
Thank you very much, Council President. On behalf of Councilwoman Blackwell and myself, I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And Resolution No. 180657, entitled a "Resolution approving the appointment of Belinda Mayo as a member of the Board of Commissioners of the Philadelphia Housing Authority," Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING introduced by Councilwoman Blackwell.
The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell for a motion.
All right. So moved, Mr. -- I don't remember what it is, but I'll assume we did. Maybe the day is just too long.
It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
And Resolution Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 6/21/18 - STATED - 2ND READING No. 180658, entitled a "Resolution approving the appointment of Samuel Staten Jr. as a member of the Board of Commissioners of the Philadelphia Housing Authority," introduced by Councilwoman Blackwell.
The Chair again recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell.
Thank you. I move for the adoption, Mr. President. (Duly seconded.)
Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The ayes have it. That resolution is adopted. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Mr. President, there are no other resolutions on the Final Passage Calendar.
So we will ask for speeches on behalf of the minority. (No response.)
And speeches on behalf of the majority. The Chair recognizes Councilman Jones.
Thank you, Mr. President. We talked about the Cobbs Creek piece, but I want to give a little more history. This was not done just by us. Councilman, I want you to know that Congressman Robert Brady worked on this long before I did and has been a champion of the Cobbs Creek Golf Course. I have it under authority he needs to get his game up by way of his swing, but irrespective of his golf game, his game up in Harrisburg and in Washington was tight. He had the Army Corps of Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 were underground and -- talk about environmentally friendly -- had them daylighted to create streams within our community which are adjacent to that golf course. He's been fighting for that golf course for a long time. I have it under good authority there is at least 20 golfer friends that have already begun donating golf clubs and bags to the two teams that will be sponsored by the golf course. So I wanted to give him a public thank you and say that whether he's in Washington, I'm going to have to get him on that golf course and teach him a thing or two, because I'm a novice as well. So it will be blind leading the blind. Thank you, Mr. President.
Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown. Stated Meeting June 21, 2018
Thank you, Mr. President. Speaking in my former role as a teacher and higher ed professional, I think it's important to recognize young people who really serve at the heart of the work we do in City Council. This year -- I'm speaking about our interns. This year our office was privileged to receive support from young people from Prep Charter School, Penn Charter, Cheyney University, Temple University, American University, and the University of Pennsylvania. In my office we choose to treat our interns as full members of the team. So I want to say thank you to all of them for their service. I also want to seize the moment to express my relief that President Trump has come to his senses and reversed his inhumane decision to rip apart families at our country's southern border. Thank you to Councilman Kenyatta Johnson, who punctuated this action through his Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 afternoon, for it is my view that the direction of President Trump was unprecedented, immoral and, quite frankly, downright cruel for those of us who care about kids. As we look towards the celebration of the birth date of our country and think about these trying times that we're living in, it is my hope that we leave for our children a better country than the one we inherited. Thank you, Mr. President.
Thank you, Councilwoman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Green.
Thank you, Council President. I just want to remind colleagues and staff that we do have a briefing and lunch provided by Gateway Healthcare that's in the Caucus Room. So for those, please attend in the Caucus Room right after Council.
I guess there's a motion on the floor that will carry over to the Caucus Room. Thank you, Council President.
Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.
Thank you, Mr. President. I just really wanted to acknowledge, in thinking about our young people, Mr. Kyle Nelson who is here today, who is a student at East Stroudsburg University and a Nicetown resident, who is shadowing me for the day. I'm sure he had -(Applause.)
I'm sure he had quite an experience today. And he was inspired to become a political science major somehow by Mark Squilla. I don't know what happened, but he met Mark a few years ago and he is following his Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 and his inspiration. So I just wanted to acknowledge him. Thank you.
Thank you, Councilwoman. There being no additional speeches, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown for a motion to adjourn.
Thank you, Mr. President. I move that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, September 13th, 2018 at 10:00 a.m. (Duly seconded.)
It's been moved and seconded that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, September 13th, 2018, 10:00 a.m. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)
The Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 you all very much. ) Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 CERTIFICATE I HEREBY CERTIFY that the proceedings, evidence and objections are contained fully and accurately in the stenographic notes taken by me upon the foregoing matter, and that this is a true and correct transcript of same. MICHELE L. m 1:7 Accessory Adaire 207:20 184:23 209:3,4,16 199:12 165:24 265:14,19 171:16 155:11,17 208:6 186:19 210:10,14 affords 18:4 166:1,3,6 abandoned accompany... adamantly 217:18 190:20 advise 31:15 African 98:5 166:10 75:6 221:16 7:9 17:7 85:2 219:13 239:15 advisory 124:23 167:1 168:1 224:6 accomplish... ADAPT 223:16 240:13 118:5 139:8 209:5 169:1 170:1 abandoning 20:13 104:14 227:3 241:11 139:13 234:23 171:1 172:1 202:6 account add 35:23 addressed 242:7 243:8 140:2 234:2 afternoon 173:1 174:1 abatement 23:18 90:11 54:19 244:5 245:4 234:4 50:19 80:4 175:1 176:1 153:17 accountable 140:10 204:22 246:5 advocate 80:5 84:12 177:1 178:1 abatements 72:7 178:12 206:8 248:10 71:13 118:9 84:13 88:4 179:1 180:1 178:22 Accounting 189:12 addresses 249:8 250:5 126:21 94:11 96:12 181:1 Abby 163:20 54:13,15 adding 36:14 161:24 251:9 128:5 100:6 102:9 182:21 ability 74:7 accurately 54:11 addressing 252:10 129:13,25 102:10 agent 222:6 able 73:20 267:5 167:14 188:12 254:16 130:3,11 104:12,14 agents 132:2 75:14 80:16 achievements 178:2 226:3 255:25 advocates 110:3,6 135:23 82:9 89:4 28:7 189:12 adequate 257:20 93:22 113:6 121:5 136:5 92:8 127:2 acknowledge 190:25 54:12,14 258:24 205:16 124:15 aggressive 136:7 21:23 22:10 203:11 120:5,15 259:25 206:22 126:12 145:21 138:13 264:13 231:25 123:9 adopting affairs 7:3 129:23,24 ago 8:2 77:4 140:11 265:3 addition adhere 69:7 193:21 affect 220:14 137:17 93:18 150:17 acknowledg... 67:10 82:18 adherence adoption 220:15 141:6,7 131:23 215:23 227:11 171:5 69:9 165:4 Affection 146:7,8,10 264:25 absence 5:24 acquire 176:9 205:14 adieu 9:24 183:20 128:12 146:11 agreed 6:6,14 177:3 206:10 adjacent 184:11 affidavit 150:8,9 233:16,25 absolute 16:3 act 46:24 208:10 261:6 185:15 92:15 263:2 234:9 absolutely 94:2 108:3 217:13 adjourn 186:8 190:8 214:23 age 70:18 agreement 116:13 109:3 211:2 218:24 265:10 231:5 239:5 affirm 128:8 88:10 115:7 81:8,12,15 223:8 250:14 221:3 adjourned 240:2,25 218:17 134:11 138:9 abuse 111:23 acted 107:18 222:23 265:13,18 241:21 affirmative 136:2 175:19 111:23 action 83:11 223:17 266:4 242:22 182:19 agencies 176:4,20 116:11,12 102:13 234:12 ADJOURN... 243:19 193:17 23:12 47:25 232:24 132:16 106:17 additional 265:1 266:1 244:18 196:3 105:3 233:12,19 abusing 131:17 39:19 62:17 administrat... 245:19 198:23 216:10 agreements 116:10,10 210:21 78:16 155:1 107:2 125:3 247:23 201:20 agencies' 159:7 168:8 Academy 212:9 156:1,3 Administra... 248:22 210:25 105:6 ahead 65:10 170:3 262:25 167:7 42:20 245:6 249:19 230:9 agency 21:12 70:13 171:12 actions 178:21 246:23 250:23 238:16 226:2 247:13 172:12 127:14 188:20 administrat... 251:24 affirming agenda 62:25 256:17 187:11 187:15 190:2 52:8 74:8 254:5 49:3 252:12 63:1,8,21 aid 3:3 acceptance Activations 238:19 172:6 255:14 afford 79:10 64:1,8,16 aides 3:23 11:8 26:5 265:7 178:20 257:9 139:18 65:1,10,18 Aiko 104:7,9 accepts active 12:5 address 75:10 administrat...
259:12 affordability 66:1,17 ain't 147:4,7 107:13 actively 81:20 82:21 73:7 adult 10:17 121:17 67:3,12 air 134:18 access 12:8 205:11 83:2 121:16 admiration 81:6 127:25 affordable 97:18 98:12 akin 83:6 37:2 79:17 activism 143:22 14:11 131:25 122:17 155:2,4 Akwaaba 80:17,22 158:14 144:2 145:8 admission 132:9 123:8 157:1,4,7 33:5,7 139:14 activities 148:11 11:18 adults 81:5 143:22 157:10,15 240:16,18 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Al 1:18 52:3 170:12,19 167:2 206:6 35:24 36:3 124:4,13 121:4 124:9 161:22 218:3 alarms 171:3,8 America antidotes 126:7,24 126:10 168:2 220:13 178:13 172:15,24 18:19,21 36:2 129:16 129:21 169:24 asking Albert 40:12 173:7,15 22:4 26:7,9 antiquated 130:4 137:12 170:15,22 150:10,18 142:18 174:13,20 99:3,10,10 209:23 131:10 141:4 146:5 171:11 151:3 244:9 175:3 110:15 anxiety 89:13 134:6 150:6 172:18 210:24 all-time 191:10 114:13 anymore 137:10 appropriate 173:3,9,18 235:23 147:21 233:19 124:24 133:12 146:2 148:9 34:8 35:7 174:2,10,16 Assembly Allan 1:11 amended American anyone's 150:3,21 35:13,19 174:23 160:18 205:9 61:3 154:14 21:17 46:19 85:22 154:19 36:6,22 175:6 186:23 alleged 81:21 184:12 96:15 97:5 anyway 99:15 155:12 37:6,12 176:13 188:17 Allegheny 186:8 97:10 209:5 223:10 264:19 38:25 39:10 177:7,15 asserted 81:8 175:7 231:16 234:23 apart 262:22 Apple 143:24 39:22 91:17 231:24 assessment Allen 26:16 amending 250:8 apartment applicable 156:25 Area,' 58:12 178:21 Alliance 34:23 35:21 262:13 220:6 223:6 199:6 areas 38:20 asset 8:17 124:23 36:8 39:12 Americans apology apply 267:21 Appropriat... 39:5 167:25 12:24 15:5 allow 60:23 39:14 52:7 47:3 98:5 46:25 65:13 appointed 188:23 169:23 234:20 83:21 52:11 53:16 250:16 250:15 21:2,9 approval 4:1 170:14,21 assets 9:16 104:21 58:8,16 Americas Apolonio 32:23 73:7 4:24 5:1 171:10 235:20 109:16 60:16,18,20 97:13 129:6 130:6 239:19 126:2 172:17 assist 51:8 122:7 166:18 AMI 102:2 130:8 134:7 appointment approve 173:2,17 215:14 175:12 167:4,12 103:9 134:9 161:6 56:8,12 72:11 129:4 174:15,22 255:6 allowed 107:4 168:6 169:9 104:18,22 161:7,8,9,9 163:19,24 131:11 175:5 assistance 132:6 170:6,8 122:25 appalled 72:8 164:12 153:7 171:5 argue 206:17 71:10 151:24 171:15,21 123:2 appear 257:23 173:12 arms 112:3 199:14 allowing 83:4 171:24 amount 74:18 108:10 259:3 approved 5:8 Army 260:25 215:12 88:21 172:3,9 79:14 applaud appreciate 5:15,22 arrest 214:14 associated 117:25 173:22 analogy 83:5 118:16 2:12 6:24 186:3 arrested 69:14 allows 88:22 174:6,8 Anashel 144:3 69:8,19 approving 85:25 89:5 175:21 210:8 175:10 76:11 147:19 72:24 83:15 56:7,12 arrived 80:24 214:18 almighty 4:14 177:22 and/or 204:3 Applause 139:2 142:5 157:24 131:22 association Alpha 44:17 178:6,9,16 204:4 14:3,14,21 145:20 159:7,16 Art 189:3 24:6 121:8 247:15 178:17 208:16 15:2 16:20 150:15 161:18 article 108:6 151:8 Alston 75:23 190:24 267:23 19:15 27:20 155:18 163:19 138:6 Association's 75:25 191:4,7 angles 141:15 29:16 30:17 233:15 164:18 Artillero 19:18 alternative 196:7 203:8 angry 75:5 42:23 44:3 appreciated 257:23 129:20 assume 258:8 78:20 230:18,20 animals 49:9,16 142:7 259:3 134:7,9 assured 85:2 Altman 231:22 111:5 50:14 67:25 appreciation appurtenant 161:7,8,8,9 asthma 217:11 amendment ankle 133:5 72:17 75:22 14:11 34:4 53:10 arts 18:25 118:23 amazement 105:12 anniversary 77:20 79:21 approach April 24:10 158:22 asylum 70:23 160:24 46:22 84:5 87:20 120:12 24:11 asbestos 128:25 Amazon 176:20 250:11 90:25 94:6 approached Arch 173:4 188:5 130:25 143:23 183:17,19 announce 96:5 99:21 7:12,19 176:6 Ashton 131:18,23 ambition 183:21 155:7 99:25 102:3 17:10 69:24 Archbishop 171:13 134:14 22:23 185:12,13 announcem... 103:21 72:22 76:5 40:3 243:13 172:19 161:16 Amen 4:16 185:15 51:3 254:25 104:4 106:5 77:22 80:2 architects Aside 74:3 asylum-see...
95:24 100:8 239:20 66:8,22,25 201:16,17 263:14 200:3,5,7 15:20,24 161:10 100:22 242:13 67:21 68:2 201:23 264:7 265:5 200:10,12 42:22,25 223:5 101:10,15 247:18 70:8 72:18 202:15,21 265:16,22 200:14,17 49:5 111:4 cited 78:22 105:10 248:15 76:8 77:24 202:25 265:25 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 clauses 81:16 121:2 124:7 200:19,22 closet 87:14 230:19 137:22 94:1 95:1 21:7 31:10 clean 210:3 126:8 200:24 closing 24:24 231:23 140:8 96:1 97:1 Commissio... clean-out 129:19 201:3,6,9 75:9 83:15 Code,' 166:20 141:25 98:1 99:1 48:2 160:7 74:5 137:11 201:12,15 139:21 167:6,14 142:3,17,25 100:1 101:1 175:17 cleaning 140:22,24 202:2 203:7 140:10 178:9 143:2,10,13 102:1 103:1 176:2,8,18 209:19 141:2 146:3 228:7,10,13 closure 71:10 190:25 143:24 104:1 105:1 177:2 179:2 clear 49:23 150:4 228:15,17 CLS 217:11 codes 13:15 144:8,18 106:1 107:1 179:3 183:4 129:5 154:20 228:20,22 Club 232:25 coffers 103:2 146:21 108:1 109:1 212:17 208:11,19 156:19 228:24 233:2 coherent 150:17 110:1 111:1 217:5,8,9 210:9 157:16 229:3,5,8 clubs 261:11 225:9 151:12 112:1 113:1 232:23 217:16 166:11 229:10,14 co-sponsored cold 124:12 153:5 114:1 115:1 Commissio... clearinghou... 179:19 229:17,20 34:15 50:21 135:17 155:14 116:1 117:1 56:9,14 218:14 180:4,8,12 229:23 51:25 54:4 collaborative 204:19 118:1 119:1 257:24 226:16 180:15,18 230:2,5,17 54:6 126:15 12:6 216:14 120:1 121:1 259:5 clearly 91:14 180:22,25 231:21 130:17 collapsed 217:25 122:1 123:1 commit 123:7 93:13 181:4,8,11 232:21 Coalition 78:23,24 219:12 124:1 125:1 130:21 106:25 181:15,18 236:17,20 130:2 79:5 234:12 126:1 127:1 157:20 Clerk 1:20 181:22 236:23,25 Coast 18:17 colleague 247:11,12 128:1 129:1 commitment 30:25 31:2 182:2,6,10 237:3,6,8 143:8 235:15 262:21 130:1 131:1 13:11 88:14 31:4,22,25 182:14 237:10,13 Cobbs 137:20 colleagues comfortable 132:1 133:1 88:16,17 32:14,20 183:3 237:15,18 138:8,10 47:21 50:22 115:18 134:1 135:1 155:17 33:3,11 184:25 237:20,23 232:25 205:4 208:9 coming 70:5 136:1 137:1 committed 34:2,22 186:21 238:2,5,8 234:18 219:5,6 115:8,12 138:1 139:1 86:23,25 35:8,14,20 190:23 238:11,20 260:14,20 225:11 151:3 140:1 141:1 123:22 36:7,24 191:18,21 239:16 cockroach 227:16 152:10,14 142:1 143:1 committee 37:7,13 191:24 240:14 73:25 263:20 152:18 144:1 145:1 32:15,21 38:2,17 192:2,4,7,9 241:12 code 34:24 colleagues' 154:3,4 146:1 147:1 34:9 35:7 39:2,11,23 192:11,14 242:8 243:9 35:23 36:9 235:7 204:2 148:1 149:1 35:13,19 40:8 42:18 192:16,19 244:6 245:5 39:13 52:8 collected commandm... 150:1 151:1 36:6,23 42:24 44:15 192:21,24 246:22 52:10,10 104:21 4:3 152:1 153:1 37:6,12,14 44:22 45:22 193:3,6,9 247:14 53:17 54:12 collective commemor... 154:1,21 38:25 39:10 46:16 47:7 193:12,20 248:11 58:9,17 83:16 244:10 189:9 204:2 39:22 44:23 49:2,10 194:4,7,10 249:9 250:6 60:17 79:12 colonialism commemor...
commenting 52:16,24 50:25 52:6 194:12,14 251:10 120:9 98:25 185:5 69:23 72:21 53:14,23 52:17 53:8 194:17,19 252:11 166:13,19 color 108:22 commending 76:4 79:25 54:21,23 53:15 54:10 194:21,24 254:23 167:5,13 133:22 33:12 84:9 88:2 55:15,18,20 55:24 56:3 195:2,5,7 256:2,18 168:7 234:21 160:17 91:7 94:8 55:25 56:5 58:4,6 195:10,13 257:21 169:10 Columbus 241:13 96:9 100:2 57:21,23 60:13 69:22 195:16,19 258:25 170:7 131:13 comment 106:7 58:6 59:24 72:20 75:23 195:22 260:2 171:16,22 comb 210:2 68:1,13,16 109:22 60:3,13 75:25 76:3 196:6,21,24 client 79:2 172:4,10 233:13 69:1,14,16 112:25 62:8,12 77:21 79:24 197:3,5,7 close 15:12 173:23 come 2:4,6 70:1 71:1 114:21 121:23 84:8 87:23 197:10,12 49:14 71:9 174:7 3:2 7:4 9:18 72:1 73:1 117:22 123:19 87:25 91:2 197:14,17 107:25 175:11 13:15 15:11 74:1 75:1 121:3 124:8 125:23 91:4,6 94:7 197:19,22 109:24 177:23,25 15:13,14 76:1 77:1 126:9 141:3 139:8,13 96:8 99:24 197:24 113:3 178:2,7,10 16:16 71:9 78:1 79:1 141:9 146:4 140:3 100:2 102:6 198:3,6,9 114:23 178:12,17 86:23 93:23 80:1 81:1 150:5 156:25 104:7 106:6 198:12,15 132:20 178:20 105:15 82:1 83:1 comments 189:2 109:20,22 198:18 252:19 190:25 110:22 84:1 85:1 137:19 238:21 112:23,25 199:3,21,24 closed 141:11 191:5,8 113:8 86:1 87:1 Commercial 239:17 114:20 200:3,5,7 closely 18:14 196:8 203:9 115:19 88:1 89:1 174:10 242:9 117:15,18 200:10,12 18:15 209:19 119:25 90:1 91:1 231:24 248:12 117:21 200:14,17 121:18 210:2 131:5,14 92:1 93:1 Commission 256:19,21 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 committing complaints 178:23 160:1 161:1 146:15,24 117:3 22:16 54:3,8 55:5 86:19 107:18 179:13 162:1 163:1 constituents 129:13 copy 14:5 56:4,18,24 common complete 190:5 164:1,25 83:23 continued 27:10 43:10 57:7 58:22 205:13 74:22 condominiu... 165:1,5,11 100:24 112:5 138:13 58:24 59:4 Commonwe... completed 60:25 165:19,22 222:3 continues 183:18 59:8,11,16 21:4 108:12 214:3 condos 153:6 165:24 Constitution 29:24 185:13 59:19 60:7 111:13 complex conducive 166:1,2,5 107:16 132:25 231:3 60:11 61:4 112:16 152:12 19:21 166:10 108:6 109:6 contract Corinthian 61:6,12,16 157:20 compliant conduct 167:1 168:1 109:8 53:20 168:4 61:19,24 177:20 108:25 36:12,18 169:1 170:1 160:25 157:25 corners 62:3,24 254:3 components 39:14,16 171:1 172:1 constitutional 159:17 100:21 63:7,17,19 communica... 139:24 203:10 173:1 174:1 108:13 161:19 corporations 64:2,5,15 212:18 composition conference 175:1 176:1 constitution... contractor 168:10 65:6,8,12 communica... 234:4 188:15,22 177:1 178:1 108:24 71:18 Corps 260:25 65:16 66:8 30:1,22 comprehen... 189:11 179:1 180:1 constitutions contractors correct 267:8 66:15,22,25 31:1,23 25:9 119:14 confident 181:1 107:23 53:20 79:15 correction 67:21 68:2 140:4 comprehen... 120:6 182:20 construct contribute 40:19 67:22 68:23 70:2 communities 83:3 confirming Conservation 52:19 28:22 128:2 corrupt 70:8 72:18 11:22 60:25 computers 163:24 173:25 constructed contributed 107:10 76:7,8,15 98:23 122:9 175:20 164:6,12 consider 60:21,24 9:6 corruption 77:17,23,24 community concentrati... conflict 210:5 18:12 62:25 constructing contribution 109:17 79:22 80:3 11:19 13:17 132:21 211:2 63:8,21 199:12 166:22 cost 75:2 83:16 84:6 18:8 20:3 conceptuali... conform 64:7 65:18 construction 167:8 122:23 84:11,14 21:11 91:11 24:4 177:19 66:17 67:3 34:3 52:9 contributions 123:11 87:21 88:5 100:14 concern confused 90:4 154:25 53:9 103:7 29:4 168:9 costs 74:5 90:16,18,23 116:15,18 139:16 congratulate 165:21 104:19 control 37:21 Council 1:2 91:18 93:15 127:2 150:25 29:2 182:22 105:8 74:23 1:10 2:5,6 93:23 94:4 132:24 253:12 Congratula... considerable 121:10 118:24 3:12,17,24 94:10 95:24 137:21 concerned 14:13 27:19 41:24 132:22 141:14 4:21,22 96:6,11 138:8,14 151:7 Congress consideration 150:24 242:16 6:23,24 99:6,19 139:6 214:17 23:2,16 40:24 43:14 173:13 267:23 13:21 15:8 100:5,22 151:17 concerning 130:23 48:11 49:24 177:24 Controller 15:11 16:11 101:3,10 158:13 62:20 64:10 137:2 56:25 57:8 178:8 54:18 16:23,24 102:4,8,11 168:9 199:9 concerns Congressm...
62:9 64:16 196:14 Convent 17:22 21:6 104:2,5,11 205:16 119:23 260:18 139:4 199:5 171:12 26:19 27:2 106:3,18,21 206:12 188:2,9 connection 160:10 consult convention 28:2 30:18 107:19 208:13 concerts 169:15 183:7 139:12 18:3,10 30:20 31:5 109:12 209:6,21 22:17 178:22 considered contact 81:19 23:3,13,23 31:8,17 110:8 118:5 234:7 261:6 conclude 69:5 Conrad 56:16 58:21 82:22 30:3 46:20 34:14,19 120:17 companies 69:7 99:7 173:18 61:2 67:12 224:24 250:10 40:15,23 121:16 55:4 257:2 concludes consecutive 83:14 85:18 contacted conversation 41:15,21 123:6,13,22 companion 55:8 62:7 20:10 86:6 95:9 80:23 111:8 42:5 43:12 124:11 129:10 condemning Consent 209:14 220:17 convey 46:9 47:16 126:18 133:25 42:19 245:6 62:25 63:1 218:19 contain 81:15 159:11 47:17,21 128:15 compared 246:23 63:8,20 220:22 contained conveying 48:10,15,20 129:17,22 138:3 condition 64:1,7,16 considering 267:5 160:10 48:23 49:18 130:20 compensati... 37:17,23 65:1,9,17 68:13 190:6 continent 183:7 49:22,24 134:4 137:8 107:22 83:9 242:12 66:1,16 190:7 97:12 cooperation 50:4,8,11 137:13,15 complaining 242:18 67:3,12 consistent continuation 37:16 69:10 50:15,19,21 137:16 12:15 conditional 155:2,4 20:16 188:7 69:18 50:23 51:11 140:20 complaint 160:11 157:1,4,7 constant continue 109:16 51:19 52:4 141:5,9,13 73:8,13 183:8 157:10,15 133:10 29:20 83:4 242:11 52:15,23 142:24 74:17 conditions 158:1 159:1 constantly 84:3 93:2 coordination 53:6,13,22 143:4,6 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 145:24 235:8 265:17,22 42:9,10,12 182:12 229:20,22 123:17 191:21,23 146:6,11 236:10 265:25 42:13,16,16 183:14,15 229:23,25 126:16 192:7,8,21 148:6 238:11,13 Council's 43:6,7,9,17 184:9,10 232:4,5 130:18 192:23,24 149:21,25 238:25 54:21 43:22,24 185:9,10 233:7,8 142:10,17 193:2,3,5 150:7,11 239:7,11,14 256:19 44:4,8,10 186:5,6 235:9,15,25 146:12 194:4,6,7,9 154:17,23 239:22 Councilman 44:12,20 187:4,5 236:8,23,24 188:8,10 194:17,18 155:13 240:4,8,11 1:11,12,12 45:4,10,11 188:6 236:25 Councilmen 195:7,9,10 156:2,6,10 240:21 1:13,14,14 45:12,15,16 191:24,25 237:2,3,5,8 125:21 195:12,13 156:13,17 241:3,7,10 1:15,15,17 45:17,20,21 192:2,3,4,6 237:9,10,12 Councilpeo... 195:15 156:23 241:17,23 1:18 2:2,17 46:3,14 192:9,10,11 237:13,14 8:20 196:21,23 164:21 242:3,6,19 4:18,23 5:4 47:4,15,22 192:13,14 237:15,17 Councilper... 196:24 165:8,14,17 242:24 5:5,9,12,19 50:16,18,24 192:15,16 237:18,19 8:19 70:3 197:2,10,11 169:15 243:4,7,16 5:21,25 6:3 51:14,16,20 192:18,19 238:5,7,8 Councilwo...
197:24 179:14 243:21,25 6:7,9,11,15 51:21,23 192:20 238:10 1:10,11,13 198:2,3,5,6 182:14,16 244:4,14,20 7:6,10,13 52:5 53:24 193:6,8,9 242:19,21 1:16,16,17 198:8 183:13,23 244:24 7:14,15,15 54:2,9 193:11 243:15,17 10:18 16:12 199:21,23 184:3,6,14 245:3,15,18 7:16,16,18 55:10,13,17 194:10,11 243:18 16:13 17:2 199:24 184:18,21 245:21,25 8:21,23 9:8 55:19,23 194:12,13 244:12,15 17:8,14,15 200:2,10,11 185:8,14,17 246:4,9,11 9:12,14 56:20,21,22 194:14,16 244:16 17:15,16,19 200:24 185:22,25 246:15,20 10:6,24 57:5,13,15 194:19,20 245:13,16 17:24 20:5 201:2,3,5,6 186:10,14 247:7,11,20 11:9,23 58:2 59:23 194:21,23 245:17 20:9,21 201:8 186:17 248:2,6,9 12:4,13,13 60:2,8,9 194:24,25 246:6,8,13 22:19 26:25 203:17,18 187:3,6,12 248:18,21 12:25 13:20 61:9,10 195:2,4,5,6 246:16 32:8,9,13 205:10 188:15 248:24 14:4,15 62:19,22 195:16,18 247:19,21 33:19,23,24 227:25 190:10,15 249:4,7,15 15:10 16:2 63:22 64:10 195:19,21 247:22 34:16 41:22 228:7,9,10 190:18 249:18,21 16:11,12,14 64:13 65:10 197:3,4,5,6 248:17,19 41:23 42:6 228:12,20 191:13 249:25 16:21,25 65:11 66:9 197:7,9,12 248:20 42:8,8,10 228:21 193:12,14 250:4,19,22 17:11,12,13 66:18 67:5 197:13,14 249:14,16 42:11,12 229:10,12 193:23 250:25 17:13,17,21 67:9,22 197:16,17 249:17 44:5,6,9 229:14,16 195:22,24 251:5,8,19 17:24 19:9 84:15 197:18,19 254:17,21 45:8,13 229:17,19 196:16 251:23 19:16 20:15 105:18 197:21,22 254:21 46:7,8,15 230:24,25 198:15,17 252:2,6,9 21:21 23:4 109:9,13,18 197:23 255:8,11,12 47:18,19 235:12,13 198:20 252:21,25 23:22 24:8 110:5 198:9,11,12 256:6,8,15 48:3 49:20 236:11,17 199:6,16 254:7,11,14 24:19 25:7 112:20 198:14 257:3,5,6 49:21 53:2 236:19,20 201:15,17 254:19 25:21 26:13 114:17 200:3,4,5,6 260:11,13 53:3,7 54:7 236:22 201:23 255:10,13 27:21 29:10 117:8,12 200:7,9,12 260:17 57:20,22 237:6,7,20 202:15,21 255:16,20 30:18,21 118:2,6 200:13,14 261:23 58:3,25 237:22,23 202:25 255:23 31:19 32:3 120:23 200:16,17 262:24 59:2 93:17 237:25 203:4,16 256:4,9,9 32:12,18,25 123:15 200:18,19 263:16,18 109:23 238:2,4,24 204:18 256:13,14 33:9,15,18 124:2,5 200:21,22 264:3,8 110:9 113:2 239:2,4,21 211:25 257:4,7,11 33:22 34:7 126:5 141:8 200:23 Councilma... 114:21 239:23,25 216:13 257:15,18 34:10,12,20 155:21,24 201:9,11,12 160:4 227:6 118:7 240:19,22 219:5 258:3,10,15 34:21 35:6 156:15,18 201:14 Councilme... 123:14 240:24 222:20 258:19,22 35:12,18 164:23 202:16,17 130:17 125:24 241:15,18 223:10,12 259:8,15,20 36:5,21 165:3 205:6,7,9 179:20 126:15 241:20 227:24 259:23 37:5,11,24 180:12,13 212:7,7 Councilme...
180:4,6,8 250:18,20 230:2,4,7 260:5,9 38:6,9,10 180:15,16 228:13,14 2:20 7:11 180:10,22 250:21 230:14,23 261:22 38:15,16,24 180:18,20 228:15,16 17:9 28:2 180:23 251:18,21 231:7,11,14 262:8 39:9,21 180:25 228:17,19 54:4 80:19 181:18,20 251:22 231:18 263:14,19 40:6,13,16 181:2,4,6,8 228:22,23 88:5 94:15 181:22,24 252:20,23 232:3,9,13 263:24 40:18 41:3 181:9,11,13 228:24 104:23 182:2,4 252:24 232:16 264:6,7 41:8,10,14 181:15,16 229:2,3,4,5 110:8 187:12 257:8 258:2 233:5 234:5 265:5,12,16 41:15 42:7 182:6,8,10 229:7,8,9 121:19 191:18,20 258:4,6,12 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 259:6,9,11 court 21:3 232:25 36:4 199:17 193:19 definitely 222:17,18 261:25 71:8 78:12 234:18 cut 69:15 222:24 194:3 196:5 216:5 222:22 262:2 78:15 82:6 260:15,20 99:5 223:4,10 196:20 definition 225:3 263:15,25 82:15 85:10 cried 136:11 cuts 119:20 228:3 198:21,25 206:14 226:23 264:10,11 92:15 223:6 crime 86:19 170:9 236:13 199:20 208:22 234:6 264:20 Courtland 160:23 Cynthia 48:2 deal 91:25 201:24 219:15 252:17 265:6,9,11 162:5 criminal 105:8 203:6 228:5 definitions deportation counsel 73:5 courts 82:23 75:11 88:8 D 147:17 230:15 36:19 117:5 73:14 91:19 90:21 91:15 D 1:16 218:15 232:19 Delaware 130:13,25 count 123:20 222:25 92:6,16 DACA 113:8 221:24 235:10 169:25 131:3 133:2 counter 49:6 223:9 225:5 93:13 dads 111:19 dealing 221:7 236:15 delayed 134:19 252:15 225:21 203:12,14 Dahlkemper dealt 92:2 238:18 204:10 depriving countries covenant 204:9 117:22,24 death 89:22 246:21 211:14 107:3 131:6 127:8 208:21 189:8 159:3 247:13 delays 83:25 Deputy 20:23 country covers 30:14 209:14 daily 119:22 debate 157:8 256:17 delegates 27:12 96:15,17,19 Covey 142:21 214:8 139:16 166:4 declaring 23:24 Derek 1:12 98:24 CP 78:7 220:23 Dallas 24:13 Debra 217:8 160:20 delegation 42:7 51:25 105:11 craft 41:25 criminaliza... danger decades decreased 48:6 207:24 144:14 110:15,16 Crawford 112:6 130:14 100:16 89:9 deleting describing 110:19 173:20 133:21 dangerous 144:18 decree 106:14 36:14 98:11 112:6 115:8 create 109:16 criminals 87:9 decently dedicated delighted deserve 115:12 121:10 115:13 Danihel 209:25 10:16 122:2 28:5 122:14 116:9 122:8,19 219:19 106:6,11 decided 9:3 185:6 deliver 28:18 129:2 129:12 124:25 224:14,15 109:11,15 88:13 189:16,20 30:24 160:8 designations 134:15 261:5 crisis 121:18 DARRELL decision dedication 183:5 38:19 39:4 136:11 created 24:12 criteria 1:10 213:17 22:11 46:2 demand 167:25 263:9,12 93:18 139:8 213:13 data 225:16 262:22 249:13 104:16 169:23 country's 142:20 critical 143:2 date 11:12 decisions deed 82:2 124:10 170:14,21 262:23 creating 143:22,25 80:21 263:8 101:22 108:15 democratic 171:10 County 49:14 28:21 criticize dated 206:4 153:18 209:7,11 23:3,23 172:17 109:24 123:22 141:22 daughter deck 37:8 214:9 220:9 101:8 173:2,17 110:12 158:12,21 Cross 21:17 118:22 171:19 deeds 106:22 188:22,25 174:15,22 113:3 169:11 cross-refere... 213:21 Decker 1:20 160:10 denial 108:17 175:5 114:23 172:11 207:18 David 1:15 60:12 69:20 183:7 Department designed 116:23 173:24 crucial 129:7 145:6 217:5 109:19 deemed 62:13 49:12 71:22 10:20 173:9 creation 47:9 cruel 263:5 day 26:8 59:5 112:22 219:19 72:5 76:18 desire 2:25 252:19 140:2 crumbling 59:12 61:13 114:19 deeper 76:24,24 199:15 couple 8:2 251:11 119:5 61:20 65:12 117:10,14 235:23 82:16 desperate 82:8,13,19 creative Cruz 208:2 74:19 88:18 124:6 default 73:15 111:20 224:3 93:18 120:11 crying 142:10 135:2,8 154:24 Deferred 139:12 desperation 148:15 Creative/In...
faithfully 4:9 87:8 175:18 176:7,17,25 207:15 everybody 122:17 20:4 108:19 fall 206:7 encountering 176:3,19 177:11,21 establish 2:3 8:10 156:20 128:21 227:19 118:25 232:24 178:5,15,18 29:22 96:16 98:3 expand 161:10 fallen 119:20 encourage entered 78:11 178:19,25 established 146:13 166:20 extremely falls 225:14 126:13 81:2 190:25 177:19 216:7 Expansion 138:24 false 91:22 129:9 entering 81:3 191:2,6,9 215:2 evict 77:11 58:14 216:2 families 3:18 133:23 85:19,22 196:8 202:4 establishing eviction 85:6 expect 26:20 eyes 112:4 10:3 11:6 145:19 86:7 203:9 35:15 85:8,11,16 103:25 11:15,18,22 encouraged entire 74:15 230:19 168:20 evidence 143:9,10 F 12:20 13:6 212:8 74:21 87:12 231:23,25 203:13 14:10 27:14 expected F 40:12 13:12,25 encourage... entities 75:6 257:22 establishme... 80:24 267:4 206:18 177:16 15:9 16:6 127:9 217:22 259:2 47:23 evil 96:23 expeditiously 244:9 23:2,5,16 encouraging entitled 34:24 entity 235:19 196:10 107:13 74:13 83:23 F' 178:9 49:5 111:4 143:3 35:24 36:9 enumerate estate 73:8 exactly expenses face 96:14 113:12,19 encroachm... 36:10,12,13 94:17 74:8 78:3 144:22 72:14 82:18 108:3 113:22 37:9 52:21 39:13,15,17 environment 79:9 80:11 206:24 experience Facebooking 115:6,25 156:21 52:11 53:17 19:21 32:16 82:17 219:4 24:10 128:4 142:12 116:10,17 encroachm... 54:12 56:7 32:17 44:24 176:10 224:15 134:11,20 143:16 116:24 37:3 56:11 58:8 115:19 177:4 examine 264:21 faced 78:5 122:10 ended 73:16 58:10,15,17 119:9 196:15 37:16,21 experienced 219:7 131:5 ends 93:2 60:16,17,19 187:16 199:5 242:12,16 9:20 72:13 facet 20:2 133:18 enemy 145:4 60:21 238:22,23 estimated example 3:16 89:14 209:6 facets 29:22 136:18,23 energy 157:17,23 248:13 23:20 25:19 4:2 143:19 experiences facilitates 160:24 157:22 158:8,17,23 environmen... estimates 215:8 218:4 19:2 204:3 11:4 252:14 164:2,9,14 159:6,15,24 118:8 119:2 24:7 excellence 211:12 facilities 262:22 enforce 53:20 160:5,16 169:12 eternal 3:9 20:16 21:17 experiencing 54:25 family 33:13 enforceable 161:2,17 environmen...
228:15,16 Gross 173:5 124:7,15 83:19 85:13 218:8 139:17 Google 112:12 236:25 ground gain 80:16,22 85:21 91:21 220:11 140:3 143:24 grandmother 237:2 154:16 game 260:22 95:25 136:7 233:9 232:25 gotten 8:8 220:3 247:19,21 160:12 260:23,23 139:4 247:13 233:2 Gould 91:6,9 grant 125:5 247:22 183:9 games 144:21 141:20 256:17 234:14,16 91:10 171:11 248:17,19 205:13 145:16 143:8,13 God 2:24 234:20,25 211:18 172:19 248:20 groundbrea... garage 146:19,22 3:14 4:14 260:20,23 govern 179:8 263:17,18 46:17 250:7 156:20 146:24 77:14,15 261:6,7,11 108:24 granted 264:3 group 12:6 gas 202:11 147:2 149:9 149:23 261:13,17 government 73:17 Greenberg grow 12:2 218:10 152:6,20,23 God-given golfed 234:24 19:12,14 Grass 172:19 217:9 15:15,20 Gateway 152:24 107:6 golfer 261:10 21:13,16 grateful 9:7 Greenlee 1:12 97:23 232:2 153:6,11,13 108:17 golfers 29:23 32:22 15:7,21 5:4,5 6:2,3 growing 263:21 218:4 Godfrey 137:23 54:15 123:12 7:14 10:24 121:17 gathered 28:8 223:15 174:24 138:16,22 106:13,20 125:20 11:23 16:14 grown 132:3 135:21 260:15 goes 75:2 139:5,9,15 107:7,10 gray 112:12 17:12 20:15 guarantee general 37:20 261:14 153:15 139:16 108:21,23 great 3:25 24:8 33:18 85:24 223:9 107:17 given 19:3,19 going 8:24 140:5,17 108:25 6:21 22:7 34:11,12 Guards 132:6 160:18 79:19 88:23 68:5,6 Gonzalez 214:16 24:14 98:7 42:12 55:17 guess 210:10 186:23 214:3 85:24 87:8 217:7 239:18 122:11 55:19 56:21 213:15 188:16 222:18 101:20 good 2:2 governments 144:11 56:22 109:9 217:23 242:15 227:19 105:6 17:25 25:13 108:12 158:12 109:13,18 218:6 264:3 generally giving 36:3 115:21,22 27:25 50:18 119:25 great-gran... 110:5 guest 2:17 174:2 103:7 144:16 69:25 76:6 Governor 112:13 112:20 155:8 generations 152:23 145:5 76:7,8 21:2 49:8 great-gran... 114:17 guests 2:19 112:10,11 218:10 146:17,22 77:24 80:3 49:11 220:4 117:8,12 2:20 6:19 generously 222:14 147:7,8 80:5 84:11 107:20 greater 88:12 120:23 7:11 17:9 4:6 225:22,25 148:12,23 84:13 85:14 109:24 122:7 128:3 123:18 28:3 gentle 3:3 Gladiators 149:5 88:4,15,16 110:11 greatness 124:2,5 guidance gentleman 29:15 30:10 151:14,15 94:10 96:11 111:16 86:16 126:5,17 47:11 6:8,16 Gladys 69:22 152:13,15 100:5 102:8 113:3 greed 96:18 130:19 251:13 George 91:6 70:6 152:25 102:10 114:23 green 1:12 180:19,20 guidelines 91:10 98:2 Glenn 33:6 153:7,20,25 104:11,13 120:18 7:17 11:9 183:14,15 68:15 69:7 German 240:17 154:6 110:3,5 186:22 16:14 23:4 184:9,10 69:9 102:6,12 Global 54:21 210:23 113:6,24 188:16 42:7 44:11 192:5,6 gun 159:4 Germantown 256:19 212:4 114:7 210:6,18 44:12 51:25 194:15,16 guys 113:21 70:7,16 globe 110:23 213:18 117:24,25 211:2 54:5 69:2 197:8,9 141:14,23 124:21 go 42:2 63:6 214:24 120:14 252:16 99:16 118:6 200:8,9 143:5,21 Germany's 65:10 68:7 219:3 121:5 Governor's 125:21 202:16,17 144:3,5,6 51:5 255:3 68:23 70:13 221:16,22 124:14 21:16 126:16 228:18,19 145:20,20 get-go 152:22 72:12 76:20 222:9 126:11,12 GPAR 130:18 237:4,5 Gym 1:13 getting 66:12 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 17:15 20:9 264:24 248:15 248:13 41:3,8,10 101:7 homelessness 126:2 41:22 42:11 happening healthcare 256:22 42:9,16 highlighted 122:21 130:24 46:7,8 101:19 113:24 heart 216:18 43:6,17,22 23:7 homeowner 137:7 47:19 49:21 111:7,9 263:22 262:7 43:24 44:4 highly 143:6 88:22 94:24 139:25 52:2 110:10 135:19 healthy 11:21 heat 124:11 44:8,20 Hill-Freed...
148:21,25 141:11 126:15 136:17 13:4 15:16 heavy 133:2 45:4,10,15 187:11 221:24 220:24 130:17 225:17 119:9,13 heir 220:7 45:20 46:3 Hispanic 99:3 homeowners 263:10 180:22,23 253:17 120:7 heirs 93:10 46:14 47:4 99:3 78:4 83:7 hopeless 75:5 188:11 254:2 187:24 held 21:13 47:15 51:25 historic 235:4 92:10 95:13 hoping 192:7,8 happens Healy 212:18 67:20,23 55:13,23 history 18:22 95:15,17,23 253:23 194:17,18 95:20 216:25 72:7 56:20 57:5 97:23,25 104:18 horrific 112:5 197:10,11 132:13 hear 70:11 Helen 1:13 57:13,15 105:10,13 199:15 hospitality 200:10,11 happy 15:16 97:22 41:22 42:11 58:2 62:19 260:16 204:14 18:7,15 205:10 hard 22:10 105:20 52:2 205:10 62:22 63:22 hitch 23:13 221:20 28:17 228:20,21 45:25 114:3 hell 148:23 64:10,13 Hite 189:18 224:19 host 29:8 237:6,7 219:12 213:20 149:10 65:11 66:18 hold 32:16,22 homeowner... R 128:17 217:6 204:15 helped 159:3 242:19,21 4:15 19:4 27:4 82:19 84:25 161:4 Harvey 205:21 234:21 Henry 174:3 home 31:7 27:24 28:3 89:11,21 Hagys 177:9 217:15 211:11 helping 3:12 Herman 70:17 73:4 38:4 40:11 90:9 103:13 half 104:16 hate 96:18 217:15 4:7 41:24 158:11 74:20 77:15 127:4 159:2 128:16 104:20 hates 96:15 226:22 118:17 Hermit 174:3 80:9,12,13 185:4 244:9 130:22 121:22 Haywood 228:2 233:6 136:24 Hernandez 85:22 92:11 Honorable 148:20 125:4 189:3 236:12 Henon 1:13 112:23 95:2,2,4,7 20:20,22 149:17,19 244:10 hazards hearing 73:10 2:2 4:18,23 113:6,7 95:18 22:13 26:15 157:18 Hall 1:6 119:2 188:3 73:14 75:21 5:9,12,19 114:11 100:10,12 27:11 158:5 Halloween 188:3 78:2 80:20 5:21 6:7,15 127:3 106:12 honored 16:5 159:12,21 13:4 he'll 152:6 87:15 7:13 14:15 128:19,24 107:21 20:6 26:22 161:4,23 hallways head 135:11 101:12 16:21,25 129:6 130:6 108:15 127:2 207:8,12,24 135:10 216:18 102:16 17:11,21 130:8 161:6 126:22 honoring 208:5,9 hand 206:3 224:6 204:5 27:21 30:18 161:15 129:3 9:25 39:24 210:7,22 handed 72:4 Headhouse 211:19 30:21 31:19 hey 218:21 218:18 40:20 44:16 213:23 hands 135:10 124:21 hearings 32:3,12,18 Hi 96:13 223:25 45:23 46:17 220:4 handwriting headline-gr... 32:16,22 32:25 33:9 hiding 87:13 224:20,21 243:10 221:21 42:15 226:11 37:16 44:24 33:15,22 high 131:7 homebuyers 247:15 222:5 hang 97:17 health 28:15 54:24 34:7,20 132:9 78:5 79:15 249:10 223:23 HAPCO 45:2 111:20 121:23 35:6,12,18 147:21 Homeland 250:7 housed 130:2 217:15 118:9 187:16,20 36:5,21 187:9,10 161:12 honors 13:23 households happened 119:16,23 211:13 37:5,11,24 higher 262:4 homeless hope 16:17 122:6,14,24 71:15 75:16 120:19 238:22 38:6,15,24 highest 88:19 95:7 101:21 123:5 94:21 167:13 239:18 39:9,21 101:15 217:6 224:4 105:20 houses 105:13 217:4 242:11 40:6,13 highjacked 224:5 123:6,19 105:21 134:25 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 111:18 humanity imagine 219:9 152:2 indicate initiative 83:21 149:15 128:7 75:17 impactful 166:21 63:23 66:19 24:23 interaction 154:6 humbled 28:4 113:21 125:13 included 81:5 179:22 119:13 11:5 housing hundreds 115:20 implemented including indicated 187:24 interconnec... 56:10,15 22:17 immediate 211:23 12:9 16:10 140:16 188:17 178:13 85:15 91:12 Huntingdon 106:16 implications 22:23,25 indigenous inner 7:21 interest 100:9,13,16 176:14 107:24 74:4 25:24 36:17 97:14 Inns 33:6 176:10 100:17 husband 33:6 108:20 importance 162:2,4,8 individual 240:17 177:4 101:5 240:17 130:14 13:8 15:23 162:10,13 28:13 39:13 input 41:24 205:19 102:21 Hutchinson 227:7 important 162:17,19 77:2,9 216:24 206:13 103:6 162:21,24 immediately 14:8 15:19 162:22 203:9 210:8 Inquirer 212:22 104:17 163:7,10 49:13 71:6 94:18 101:3 163:2,5,8 214:15 138:7,24 217:12 119:8 Hybrid 167:9 92:15 131:17 199:13 individuals inside 70:25 interested 121:11,12 hypocritical 101:18 211:7 216:3 208:24 9:2 42:3 71:4 72:2 68:17 80:14 121:17 105:9 157:9 166:5 219:2 262:5 inclusion 76:21 77:7 103:20 86:9 122:2,5,16 145:10 212:14 importantly 157:6 166:2 77:12 224:5 115:6 Intergover...
122:21,23 220:17 118:9 234:7 inclusive 11:2 224:8 Inspection 37:15 123:8 I 224:22 236:4 105:23 Industrial 52:12 78:23 242:10 143:23 ICE 110:12 225:20 impossible 169:19 176:21 Inspector internal 144:2,25 111:12 252:18 97:19,20 income 58:18 179:6 212:18 226:6 145:12 idea 92:4 immensely 130:10 168:12 industry 216:25 international 147:20 216:10 28:22 impression 191:3,6 28:17 217:3 19:17 49:7 148:4 ideas 121:21 immigrant 91:22 incomes 217:17 inspiration 252:15 150:23 identification 96:16 impressive 103:12 infestation 265:2 interned 47:3 151:11,21 77:10 90:10 113:12 28:14 incorporated 73:25 inspired 250:17 151:22 identified 131:5 imprisonme... 44:17 inflict 132:23 264:22 Internet 152:2,21 158:5 133:21,24 49:4 219:21 227:21 influence instability 97:24 153:18,24 159:12,21 136:23 252:12 247:16 129:9 122:22 interns 262:9 190:25 161:23 immigrants improve increase 12:7 133:19 install 35:10 262:15 191:3,4 222:5 97:2 98:10 138:10 25:6 101:5 information 36:25 interpreter 196:8 199:9 identifies 114:8 190:4 140:5 151:8 74:24 90:5 installation 134:8 199:12 253:8 132:22 improvement increased 190:6 213:9 35:3 INTRO 32:1 205:16 identity 99:2 133:15 145:3 148:7 infrastruct... installed 33:1 34:1 257:25 IFEA 19:18 immigration 167:21 increasing 29:7 108:25 35:1 36:1 259:5 19:23 20:7 42:21 245:7 improveme... 80:20 148:2 Ingram 76:11 instances 37:1 38:1 Housing,' 26:22 27:7 246:24 120:3,8,13 168:13 inhaler 94:20,23 39:1 40:1 191:6 II 47:3 253:22 125:17 increasingly 118:23 instituted 41:1 42:1 housing/ho... 250:17 immoral 160:13 18:13,17 inheritance 215:19 43:1 44:1 145:2 Ilia 26:16 263:4 176:12 incubation 74:10 institutional 45:1 46:1 huge 120:16 30:8 impact 23:15 177:6 54:25 inherited 144:9 47:1 48:1 Hughes illegal 82:4 24:5,16 183:10 256:23 263:12 institutions 49:1 50:1 188:23 95:5 108:15 28:19 37:21 190:4 incur 90:17 inhumane 100:19 51:1 52:1 217:5 116:13 103:8 inaccessible incurred 43:5 49:6 instructed 53:1 54:1 human 49:12 204:9 214:6 104:19 100:20 72:15 82:17 115:24 81:22 155:1 156:1 111:2,21 214:11 121:10 inalienable 82:17 116:12 insurance introduce 127:16,16 221:25 169:13 107:11 indefinite 245:13 95:15 33:20 94:16 132:14 224:16 214:19 inaugural 43:4 245:12 247:5 integrated 129:10 133:14 illegally 217:17 51:3 254:25 247:5 252:14 12:5 introduced 224:11 86:18 220:19 incarcerating Indian 97:10 253:21 intellectually 114:22 225:18 106:20 242:16 113:18 97:16 262:22 12:3 118:6 252:17 212:24 impacted 224:9 173:19 initial 73:10 intelligent 126:14 Humanitari... illness 209:9 74:22 include Indiana 25:4 initiated 144:13 130:16 21:18 images 28:21 204:12 104:20 Indians 98:5 147:5 intended 153:16 111:4 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 188:6 206:6 involving 164:3,10,16 262:24 judgment 144:12 187:7 Laid 60:19 207:7 138:25 Japanese join 6:25 7:10 73:15 262:24 189:23 Lake 168:21 238:23 irregularly-...
111:21 165:4 153:5 233:22 4:25 5:7,14 187:23 MICHELE 122:10 Morgan 183:20 176:23 maximizing 22:25 23:5 193:16 267:14 Modern 207:21 184:11 Marquet 12:17 23:15 44:18 196:2 mid 73:9 54:12,14 morning 2:3 185:15 217:3 Mayfair 80:7 93:19 198:22 middle 68:23 modest 2:15 19:4 186:7 190:7 Marshall Mayo 56:8 138:21 201:19,22 mighty 29:18 125:12 27:25,25 202:19 161:25 257:23 211:17 209:18 Mike 216:23 modifying 32:10 33:20 226:15 162:7 Mayor 21:9 216:12 216:13 256:5 202:9 69:25 76:6 231:5 232:6 Marsy's 30:25 31:3 217:25 230:8 231:4 mile 25:2 230:20 76:7,9 239:5 240:2 160:21 72:6 106:18 224:12 238:15 Mill 177:9 mold 188:4 77:25 240:25 Martin 79:24 106:21 247:17 258:11 million 23:17 mom 134:23 117:24 241:21 80:7 107:19 266:4 262:16 23:20 24:7 135:5,22 118:2 242:21 Martinez 185:4 Meetingho... membership 24:17 25:19 136:10 126:12 243:19 96:8,13,14 Mayor's 179:8,10 18:4 102:20 141:17 128:14 244:17 99:8,22 21:10,18 Meg 7:9 mementos 125:4 145:9 moment 130:7 146:9 245:18 marvelous 26:4 Mei 140:22 74:25 145:10 129:7 mortgage 247:23 3:16 4:2 McCarty 140:24 Memorial 7:8 189:15,19 134:22 92:21 248:21 MaryBeth 217:8 Melissa 9:25 10:9 189:21 262:19 mortgages 249:18 217:7 McConnell 109:20 10:13 13:23 millions moms 111:19 95:10 250:22 Mass 23:18 121:2,5,6 member 21:5 14:9 131:15 114:5 mother 88:25 251:23 massage 36:9 McKenzie 21:6 56:9 memory mind 8:9 96:2 money 9:5 89:19 254:4 36:16,17 126:8,11,20 56:13 10:16 204:23 102:21 135:15 255:13 Masseurs 126:25 104:14,15 men 131:25 minds 101:12 103:8 148:3 187:7 257:8 36:11 McNulty 105:18 132:7,9,11 218:3 151:6,25 mother's 82:2 259:12 Masseuses 168:22 118:4 132:15 mindset 190:3 214:4 89:21,22 265:12 36:11 mean 151:6,6 129:25 mental 142:20 monies 90:10 moved 5:13 Master 171:3 209:4 157:5 116:12 mine 146:17 104:17 mother-in-l... 41:4 43:18 173:7 210:19 163:25 mentioned minor 40:19 moniker 76:11 48:16 50:5 match 51:4 219:4 164:8,13 140:14 81:5 128:10 motion 26:2 57:6 59:9 255:2 226:19 165:25 217:22 minority Monique 46:13 57:16 61:17 63:18 matched 229:13 179:23,24 mentoring 151:17 33:4 240:15 62:20 64:6 65:7 66:14 20:13 meaning 9:4 187:18 158:14 216:6 260:7 monitor 64:10 67:2 78:15 156:7 Material 78:12 257:24 mercy 3:8,15 minutes 53:19 133:5 78:12 165:9 54:16 means 86:7 259:4 Merenda 143:11,14 Montgomery 128:24 183:24 materials 152:15 members 2:6 217:4 147:7 173:9 161:14 184:15 70:21,24 211:25 2:18 3:11 Merion 38:22 Miscellaneo... month 103:12 164:24 185:18 71:4 267:22 3:17 6:22 mess 82:19 169:11 153:10 258:5 264:4 186:11 matter 25:18 measurable 14:19,23 message missing 30:9 221:17 265:9 190:11 73:24 82:6 28:19 17:22 28:9 129:5 mistakes 224:20 motioned 231:8 101:10 measure 29:3 31:5 messages 132:7 months 25:15 202:22 232:10 144:11,12 129:8 41:21 42:5 30:24 31:3 mixed 150:23 71:21 73:19 motto 18:10 239:8 240:5 144:13,14 Mechanicsv... 43:8,12 31:20 151:10 74:16 82:14 Mount 241:4,24 207:9 170:24 48:5 49:17 met 93:18 191:2,6 84:19 88:19 244:11 242:25 208:19 Mechelle 50:21 56:4 264:24 mixed-inco... 89:7 90:7 mouth 9:5 243:22 219:22 22:11 26:15 112:19 Mexica 97:6 121:12 253:19 move 5:6 244:21 225:12 30:9 117:11 Mexican 122:8 Monument 40:22 43:12 245:22 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 248:3,25 naming 38:3 necessary 122:20 201:18 209:16 237:16,17 occupies 249:22 40:9 158:9 81:16 221:23 Ninth 162:17 210:16 246:7,8 208:23 251:2 252:3 158:18,24 224:10 236:7 162:18 225:8 254:17,21 occupying 254:8 185:2 244:7 necessitated neither 98:17 163:3,4 notes 206:5 Oakland 76:22 255:17 Nancy 99:24 223:5 98:18 145:8 187:12 208:21 174:18 occur 84:3 257:12 102:15 need 4:8 8:5 222:4 227:5 220:12 Oakmont occurred 84:3 258:7,13,16 Napa 176:15 68:7 75:14 Nelson noise 68:10 267:6 35:16 94:24 259:16 Natalie 26:17 95:9 100:18 264:14 Nolan 124:7 notice 36:3 oath 107:15 107:17 265:17 30:8 189:6 105:22 nephew 114:4 124:10,14 82:15 90:6 108:2 109:5 occurring moves 145:21 nation 97:3 107:8 116:7 Network 124:15 230:21 109:8 73:10 207:12 110:18 116:22 205:18 non-privile... noticed 142:8 oath-violati...
occurs 208:14 moving 35:4 111:11 120:9,15 never 97:20 38:3,12,14 notices 79:3 108:19 Octavius 26:6 63:6 207:8 national 122:6 123:5 97:21,21 40:9 41:16 notified 76:23 obey 108:21 October multiply 13:11 18:13 144:5,6,22 133:4 42:18 46:10 noting 220:14 object 157:5 20:25 75:18 21:19 22:24 151:18 134:24,25 47:8 49:3 November 165:25 offenses municipal 23:3,23 152:21 217:24,24 non-profit 204:4 objection 39:16,19 29:23 85:10 46:20,25 153:23,24 new 13:6 125:14 novice 261:18 157:8 166:3 offer 32:10 175:20 234:10,13 154:14,15 18:10 35:23 north 18:19 number objections 34:13,17 Mural 158:22 234:24 190:2 36:14 92:25 37:3 97:16 24:20 47:12 267:4 46:9 51:24 murder 96:18 250:9,15 209:25 100:17 124:16,24 69:12 81:20 obligation 53:4 54:3 murderers nationality 210:2 224:5 102:20 126:22 138:16 37:20 122:11 98:8,11,13 97:9 225:8,9,10 103:7 158:18 139:17 111:15,22 125:11 MURPHY native 96:15 225:18 115:19 159:14 142:14 242:15 156:16 267:14 97:5,10 253:22 118:13 160:3 150:22 obligations 183:17 Museum 98:23,25 needed 70:21 121:11 161:24 158:5 108:13 185:11 33:13 99:11,17 125:11 122:19 162:6,7,8,9 159:13,21 obstructing 231:2 241:13 113:18 needs 83:10 123:4 162:11,13 168:13 107:2 offered 85:12 Music 13:3 natural 12:18 83:11 124:25 162:14,16 170:8 188:8 obtain 210:9 offerings MVP 21:18 naturally 120:14 125:4 154:8 162:17,18 205:22 214:14 12:21 Myrick 14:24 18:17 260:21 167:14 162:21,22 251:14 obtaining offers 13:2 208:14 negative 169:11 162:24,25 numbers 130:24 127:23 N nature 12:17 217:17 172:11 163:3,4,7,8 63:11 obvious 74:3 office 17:4 NAACP nay 179:21 negatively 173:24 163:10,11 161:23 occasion 19:5 19:5 20:18 21:19 179:25 204:12 186:25 163:12,13 numerous 27:5 46:19 21:11 23:10 name 2:22 197:6,13 neglect 191:2 163:14,15 21:14 250:9 24:2,20 68:22 69:21 200:6 111:24,25 203:11 163:16 107:18 occasions 25:8,16,22 70:5 80:6 254:22 negligent 206:9 176:14,15 153:4 205:22 26:4 27:4 81:19 88:9 nays 193:15 221:24 231:25 185:2 220:3 nursing occupancies 27:13 28:6 91:9 94:12 195:25 neighbor 253:6,7 northerly 100:12,19 52:14 28:12 108:2 96:13 198:19 4:10 127:5 newly 10:10 177:16 103:19 occupancy 216:21 102:11 201:18 neighborho... news 136:16 Nos 31:11 52:10 217:2,6 105:6 113:7 230:6 105:24,24 NFL 22:2 56:25 59:6 O 146:23 225:7,7 114:25 238:14 151:23 24:10,12 64:19 65:20 O'Neill 1:15 147:2 262:9,14 121:6 NCA 174:9 173:25 Nicetown 67:16 2:18 6:10 177:24 officer 33:5 124:15 231:23 174:10 264:16 note 2:3 6:11 7:15 178:8 38:5 76:13 126:19 NCIC 77:9 199:11 niece 114:4 11:10 62:11 12:25 17:25 occupant 90:4 215:13 130:7 134:8 NCO 173:25 231:24 night 111:8 69:11 206:2 26:13 51:15 95:5 240:16 148:22 near 204:15 neighborho... 136:14 211:6 51:16 occupants Officers 224:25 220:2 221:9 13:14 nightmare 218:25 181:12,13 81:4,7,18 32:24 named 97:4 236:6 105:14 71:7 219:14 192:17,18 81:23 83:7 239:19 219:25 nearly 131:7 122:11 nine 9:13,15 221:4 222:7 195:3,4 occupied offices 203:25 220:6 Nebinger 125:10,15 74:16 223:18 197:20,21 80:16 95:3 official names 30:6 118:4 189:6 neighbors 153:12 noted 206:13 200:20,21 218:19 106:14 99:12 136:7 229:6,7 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 officials 15:22 20:24 24:21 258:20 172:3,9,15 172:13 Papal 23:2,18 188:19 193:25 71:12 25:10 27:13 259:21 172:24 173:25 paper 222:15 Parks 179:4 196:18 133:20 operative 265:23 173:7,15,22 174:7 223:14 232:22 199:18 offset 123:10 223:7 opposing 174:6,13,20 231:24 Parade 25:11 233:11 210:17 Oh 1:15 7:15 operator 43:4 75:13 175:3,10,16 Overlay' 26:8,11 Parkside 222:11 12:13 16:14 233:3 245:11 176:2,8,18 174:10 parades 38:21 228:4 17:13 24:19 opinion 75:13 247:4 177:2,12,22 overwhelmed 22:17 Parkway 236:14 53:25 54:2 222:19 option 127:22 178:6,16 115:11,11 Paragraph 23:19 passage 70:3 84:15 224:7 131:4,4 179:2 overwhelmi... 139:6 Parodi 102:6 32:19 33:2 145:6 opioid 35:24 166:25 190:23 122:23 parcel 177:5 102:10,12 33:10,16 181:15,16 36:2,3 oral 92:7 193:20 overwhelmi...
parcels 103:22 37:25 40:7 192:19,20 opportunities ordeal 71:23 196:6 199:3 22:15 176:11 paroled 77:3 40:14,25 195:5,6 11:24 54:22 order 2:6 202:2,3,4 owned 137:24 177:5 Parsons 41:12 43:15 197:22,23 256:20 4:24 5:23 203:7 139:19 parent 217:3 44:2,21 200:22,23 opportunity 6:18 11:7 230:17 owner 79:9 118:10,20 part 8:14 45:6 46:5 205:6 229:8 10:8 13:6 30:22 32:4 231:21 92:25 95:19 parents 15:19 20:17 70:24 46:24 47:6 229:9 18:5 53:18 49:13 55:14 232:21 95:20 220:8 43:2 70:17 88:13 47:16 48:13 237:18,19 58:10,13 62:8 71:10 ordination 220:21 80:9 115:18 103:24 48:25 50:2 257:3,5,6 80:6 83:20 72:11 76:14 40:3 243:12 222:4 120:5 127:6 137:2 50:13 51:13 Ohio 131:13 88:6 123:24 78:9,11 organization owners 83:22 127:20 150:20 55:6 57:2,9 okay 96:23 126:4 139:3 79:11 124:20 92:2 93:22 245:10 participate 57:18 62:16 98:6 106:11 139:22 116:23 organizatio... m 206:5 197:25 29:21 176:4 182:21 226:16 190:16 58:16 60:16 72:8 266:5 198:2 partnership 207:7,11 One-time 203:2 83:13,18,19 outside 2:9 PA 108:5,7 200:25 29:4 51:9 208:4 152:9 231:12 83:21 8:16 23:11 156:22 201:2 52:19 255:7 210:22 open 10:4 232:14 156:19 47:14 68:8 PACDC 203:17,18 parts 8:5 222:15 13:25 239:12 166:12,18 251:17 121:14 229:11,12 207:14 passes 57:16 open-air 240:9 241:8 167:4,12,18 outsiders 123:7,12 237:21,22 pass 76:16 153:15 35:10 242:4 243:5 167:23 105:25 124:20 Parker's 77:18 79:13 193:18 opening 33:7 244:2,25 168:6,17,20 outstanding package 187:12 86:17 95:25 196:4 240:18 246:2 248:7 168:25 39:25 121:23 parking 123:3 198:24 operating 249:5 250:2 169:5,9,17 120:13 214:2 35:15 128:17 201:21 193:21 251:6 252:7 169:21 243:11 Packer 143:12 146:16 208:17 208:18 254:12 170:6,12,19 overall 28:15 170:15 168:20,25 161:4 209:7 225:12 255:21 171:3,8,15 overlay paid 155:16 169:5 179:18 211:25 operations 257:16 171:21 172:10,12 paint 52:13 186:24 191:15 223:13 188:4 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 230:9 178:21 154:15 perpetrates 10:3 11:16 158:22 232:24 Pine 169:2 238:17 Penn 262:11 158:14 107:14 11:25 13:22 159:5,8,17 233:23 Pipes 60:19 passing 90:20 Pennsylvania 187:6 perpetrator 13:24 16:7 160:2,8,15 234:13,22 place 8:7 22:7 223:13 1:6 21:4,5,7 208:12 106:12 18:2,7,9,11 161:19 234:25 23:5 25:2 233:17 49:11 211:11,13 persecution 19:6 20:6 163:20 235:5 236:6 71:13 75:15 passively 111:14 215:11 128:21 20:11,24 164:2,8,14 239:20 83:2 147:22 107:13 115:25 216:8,15 161:11 21:24 22:3 164:19 240:19 168:22 Passyunk 157:18,21 217:21 perseverance 22:5,8,21 166:13,19 242:13 215:15 124:22 160:17,21 218:5,15 40:2 243:11 23:8,13,21 167:5,13,19 247:18 216:5 Pastor 2:15 160:25 224:2,4 persist 88:21 23:25 24:9 167:23 248:16 218:17,23 2:22 4:19 171:4 226:12 person 8:11 24:23 25:10 168:7 249:12,13 253:24 126:20 177:20 262:6,11 78:10,18 25:25 26:8 169:10,21 250:10 placed 23:14 patience 207:24 264:14 84:24 85:12 26:9,21 170:7,12,19 251:15 32:19,25 226:9 252:16 people's 92:16 96:21 27:3,6 171:8,16,22 255:3,6 33:10,16 227:17 253:13,23 107:5 98:19 28:24 29:5 172:4,10,15 256:24 37:25 38:7 patient 29:12 262:14 people-pow... 105:19 29:24 31:6 172:24 257:25 40:7,14 Patrick 87:23 Pennypack 24:22 130:9 32:24 33:8 173:15,23 259:5 41:11 43:25 87:25 88:9 169:25 perceived 134:10 34:23 35:23 174:7,13,20 Philadelphi... 44:21 45:5 Pattison people 9:18 83:18 142:9 147:5 36:9 37:18 175:3,11,13 10:22 20:2 46:4 47:5 170:17 16:9 19:13 percent 25:6 148:20,24 38:18 39:3 175:18,19 28:16 218:8 57:17 59:20 Paul 40:5 23:20 24:16 101:25 153:16 39:12 44:19 175:24 Philadelphi...
62:5,15 45:23 24:25 25:5 103:9 208:23 45:3,25 176:21 9:18 11:3 132:12 243:15 25:20 28:20 104:18,22 212:21 46:2,21 177:23,23 95:25 133:6 249:10 68:6 90:19 122:25 213:11 47:12 51:5 177:25 102:19 157:11 Pause 55:12 91:25 93:25 123:2 125:7 215:8 51:8 52:7,9 178:7,7,10 105:25 166:6 pay 86:11 96:20,21,24 151:5,5,9 219:10 52:10 53:17 178:11,17 154:12 231:16 100:13 96:25 97:3 151:12 223:23 54:11 55:2 178:19 199:14 Placement 123:9 97:7,11,17 154:5 personal 56:5,10,15 179:6 183:6 233:15 47:9 251:12 143:12 98:7,23,25 157:21 11:10 74:24 58:9,17 183:12 Philly 24:21 placements 147:25 99:4,17 perfect 129:8 60:17 76:12 185:7 104:14 47:13,14 151:25 100:18 144:24 175:20 76:17 78:19 186:24 Philly's 25:4 251:16,16 paying 86:25 101:25 147:9 206:19 80:8 81:17 187:2,24 PHLCVB places 9:19 payment 102:18,22 perfection personally 84:18 88:12 188:18 24:18 78:20 199:4 103:8,10,11 145:4 28:25 30:7 88:14 91:12 189:4,14 phone 71:11 placing payments 103:19 perform 74:7 persons 35:2 94:18,25 190:24 81:20 177:14 196:13 104:21 108:12 perspective 95:12,16 191:5,8 142:11 plaguing 83:6 199:7 105:8,13 period 92:13 207:3 102:24 196:8 203:8 143:15 plan 25:10 PCIC 77:9 106:15,25 204:2 Peter 40:5 103:17 203:23 phones 2:11 102:22 peace 77:16 109:5 permission 243:14 113:8 114:6 204:17,18 68:8 119:15 96:2 110:18,22 80:25 86:22 Pettine 14:20 118:11,14 205:20 photograph... 166:21,25 peanuts 111:22 87:4 PGW 217:9 119:13 207:23 26:19 167:7 171:3 151:2 128:7 permit 40:23 218:9 225:2 121:7 122:8 209:22 physical 173:7 PECO 218:10 131:16,21 43:13 48:11 PHA 258:11 123:23 211:21 116:11 177:14,14 225:2 132:13 49:24 56:24 Pham 39:25 124:18 212:11 190:5 202:5 pedestrian 133:21,22 57:7 59:5 243:11 125:8 214:19,20 physically planned 202:6 133:25 59:11 61:12 pharmaceu... 126:22 215:22 12:2 86:14 18:19 60:25 penalized 135:21 61:19 62:24 55:3 256:25 127:11 218:12 pick 132:10 planners 30:3 219:20 140:8 142:6 63:7,20 pharmacies 128:6,10,15 219:8 220:3 Pictures 26:2 planning penalizes 146:21 64:15 65:9 35:25 137:25 222:10,21 piece 222:14 21:10 23:9 220:25 147:21 65:17 66:16 Philadelphia 138:7 223:7 226:2 223:14 25:15 31:9 penalties 149:7,14,14 156:2 1:2,6 3:19 140:18 227:4 260:15 32:23 199:8 36:19 39:20 150:12 permitted 6:22 7:3 156:22 230:18 pieces 160:12 230:19 penalty 152:9 154:5 170:9 8:15,16 157:25 231:23 183:9 239:19 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 Planning,' 149:12 71:6,22 159:12 prepare 60:7,11 186:17 243:4,7,16 166:14 150:11 73:4 76:13 position 75:7 74:10 61:6,11,16 187:3,6 243:21,25 172:5 157:13 76:14,18,24 235:3,4 preparing 61:24 62:3 190:10,15 244:4,14,17 173:24 166:8 180:2 76:24 77:8 positions 80:12 62:23 63:5 190:18 244:20,24 plans 25:17 182:25 78:25 80:23 21:14 presence 74:6 63:17 64:2 191:13 245:3,15,18 53:18 138:7 190:21 80:23 81:2 possesses 216:22 64:5,14 193:12,14 245:21,25 138:23 198:25 81:4,6,22 29:6 present 1:9 65:6,15 193:23 246:4,9,11 plastics 44:25 201:24 81:24 82:3 possession 2:4,11 3:22 66:8,22,25 195:22,24 246:15,20 248:14 228:5 84:23 85:17 31:24 39:18 7:7 17:3 67:10,21 196:16 247:7,11,20 platform 232:19 89:23,24 73:18 74:17 193:16 68:2 70:8 198:15,17 248:2,6,9 19:24 22:21 236:15 91:20 93:20 83:24 93:7 196:2 72:18 76:8 198:20 248:18,21 play 10:4,20 241:13 149:10 208:25 198:22 76:14 77:24 199:16 248:24 11:12 12:17 263:23 211:22 209:3,4,16 201:19 79:22 80:3 201:15,17 249:4,7,15 13:9 14:2 pleased 31:15 212:3,11 210:10,14 206:22 84:6,11 201:23 249:18,21 15:18 24:25 pleasure 19:3 213:6 possible 230:8 87:21 88:5 202:15,18 249:25 138:16,19 27:24 214:22 122:13 238:15 90:23 94:4 202:21,25 250:4,19,22 139:10,16 pledge 29:20 215:13,20 234:11 PRESENT... 94:10 96:6 203:4,16,19 250:25 Play-A-Pal...
154:1,21 136:24 50:20,25 Procurement 66:14 156:7 149:9 15:21 16:4 133:10 160:7 146:16 54:20 175:16 183:24 159:12 101:14,17 public 34:5 166:19 151:21 262:10 produced 184:15 160:7 prove 92:8 53:11 59:24 167:5 176:3 216:11 prize 155:14 81:7 206:2 185:18 175:12 proven 22:14 60:4,14 176:9,19 218:3 222:7 pro 78:12 producers 186:11 176:3,9,19 29:5 68:1,12,16 177:3 179:3 224:25 probability 30:2 190:11 177:3 178:2 provide 13:5 69:1,14,16 183:4 189:9 puts 29:11 127:24 professional 202:22 178:4,11 34:4 39:18 70:1 71:1 202:12 putting probable 18:13 51:6 231:8 179:3,9 47:11 52:13 72:1 73:1 204:2 103:19 214:14 255:4 262:5 232:10 183:5 53:10 81:19 74:1 75:1 205:19 137:2 probably Professions 239:8 240:5 203:15 118:13 76:1 77:1 206:12 152:22 85:24 34:25 35:22 241:4,24 208:14,23 125:10 78:1 79:1 217:12 Q Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 122:11 raise 187:25 182:1,24 80:15 6:19 15:23 258:4 259:9 217:9 256:16 quarterly raised 51:7 183:1 184:1 realizing 90:3 19:4,25 260:11 recourse refrigerator 233:20,22 135:10 185:1 186:1 really 15:21 27:3 138:24 261:24 204:13 73:24 Queen 255:5 187:1 188:1 29:13 155:21 263:16 211:16 refugee 116:9 173:19 Rally 26:2 189:1 190:1 113:19 262:6 264:9 265:8 214:9 253:22 question ramming 191:1 192:1 114:3,7 recognized recognizing 215:23 refuse 109:2 179:17 151:19 193:1 194:1 142:7 18:21 19:7 7:7 9:25 Recreation 109:4 191:15 ramp 37:8 195:1 196:1 187:25 27:6 28:6 15:8 17:4 139:12 regard 193:25 rampant 197:1 198:1 188:11 38:13 41:18 33:4 39:24 179:4 142:13 196:18 83:10 199:1 200:1 219:3 46:11 49:20 44:16 45:23 232:22 143:17 199:18 ran 77:8 201:1 202:1 226:19 recognizes 46:21 51:2 red 21:17 188:12 228:3 range 121:20 203:1 204:1 235:14,17 2:15 5:3,25 240:15 69:6 141:20 regarding 236:13 rapists 98:7 205:1 206:1 235:17,21 6:9 7:6,14 243:10 redemption 36:15 44:25 questioned 98:10 207:1 208:1 235:24 13:22 14:16 247:15 92:13 178:3 81:6 rate 101:15 209:1 210:1 262:6 17:2,12 249:10 redevelopm... 187:16,20 quick 230:10 153:5 211:1 212:1 264:12 27:22 32:7 250:11 157:24 188:2,9,10 quickly 95:24 163:21 213:1 214:1 realtors 33:17 34:10 254:24 158:2,3 248:13 Quinones 164:20 215:1 216:1 93:22 105:7 38:8 40:16 recommend... 159:8,9,16 regime 98:6 144:14 rates 139:19 217:1 218:1 reappointm... 41:13 43:7 31:9 55:22 159:18,19 region 28:20 Quinones-S... 166:22 219:1 220:1 164:7,18 44:5,10 56:19 57:25 160:9 regional 8:17 1:16 17:14 167:8 221:1 222:1 rear 81:2 45:7,11 58:23 60:6 161:18,20 9:16 24:5 41:23 42:7 rating 37:20 223:1 224:1 reason 26:20 46:6 47:18 61:5 161:21,22 registration 48:3 123:15 242:15 225:1 226:1 82:12 49:19 50:16 recommend... 183:6 36:16 126:17 RCO 94:14 227:1 228:1 110:21 51:14,21 47:10 redlining regret 139:21 130:19 reach 13:10 229:1 230:1 189:10 52:25 53:24 227:18 105:10,11 regular 6:18 181:23 read 31:3,23 231:1,17 207:4 55:16 56:21 251:13 redress 46:23 18:6 67:7 192:25 41:18 43:11 232:1 233:1 reassure 57:19 58:25 recommend...
reserved 46:4,17 244:5,6 101:5 259:22 remedies 217:17 10:11 202:7,13 47:5,8 48:4 245:4,5,19 104:15 260:8 215:17 224:20 188:24 reside 77:14 49:3 50:20 246:5,10,18 113:24 265:24 remedy 83:12 rented 214:4 205:17 129:12 51:2,12 246:19,22 145:7 215:6 responsibility 106:17 215:9 220:5 207:6 208:2 residence 54:4,20 247:14,24 respect 111:15 107:24 renter 88:12 representat... 213:12 56:6,7,11 248:10,11 142:14 127:7 108:20 renters 93:21 resident 56:12,25 248:22 143:17 233:14 204:20 122:18 128:17 88:11,15 63:11 64:7 249:8,9,19 respected responsible remedy/poli... 123:11 130:23 113:11 68:18 69:17 250:5,6,23 114:12 22:15 25:9 204:21 renting 81:9 161:4 189:3 221:13 109:23 251:9,10,24 respectfully 35:2 213:4 remember 88:24 represented 264:17 110:10 252:10,11 56:16 58:20 213:8 227:7 7:22 9:19 213:22 73:13 residential 113:2 254:5,15,23 61:2 rest 103:18 9:21,23 218:15,22 216:16 47:9,13 114:22 255:14,24 respectively 135:3,18 258:7 223:24 representing 49:14 118:5,12 256:3,18 191:9 restaurants remind reopen 234:5,5,6 109:25 120:11,18 257:9,19,21 196:11 18:24 104:25 128:24 represents 113:4 128:13 257:22 respond Restaurants,' 109:11 161:15 125:12 114:24 130:16 258:23,25 73:12 167:16 141:17 reopening reproduction 173:8 131:12 259:2,24 149:18 restitution 263:19 130:25 267:21 191:12 155:2 157:1 263:2 225:23 82:24 84:2 remiss 21:22 Rep 207:14 republicans 208:23 157:6,7,9 resolutions response 5:20 Restoration 205:8 207:21 6:12 251:12,15 157:10,15 32:6,11 41:9 43:23 137:20 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 138:8 166:15 153:22 Rodney 76:3 61:11,18 salvageable 139:14 155:6 restore 233:4 168:25 227:12 Roebuck 62:13,23 74:2 school 37:18 182:23 235:2 169:5 235:21 188:25 63:7,19 Sam 217:6 37:22 71:16 208:3 result 48:9 revision 247:9 Rojas 114:20 64:14 65:8 Samuel 56:13 71:18 212:20 121:24 177:12 253:17 114:25 65:16 66:15 259:3 100:11 224:2 131:9 Revitalizati... 258:7 115:2,5,16 69:14 Sanchez 118:14,22 231:16 211:17 124:17,22 263:24 117:3 155:23,25 20:21 44:5 118:23 233:24 resulted revoked right-of-way role 158:12 run 116:6 44:6 181:24 119:3,12 seconded 42:21,25 108:24 173:10 158:21 run-up 74:6 193:2 120:6 5:11,13 245:8 revolution 202:10 218:2 226:3 running 195:12 155:17 41:2,4 246:25 107:9 rightful 83:22 262:4 125:18 198:5 201:5 187:2,8,9 43:16,18 retire 2:8 Reynolds rights 46:18 roll 135:23 Russell 87:23 229:16 187:10,20 48:14,16 retired 76:13 1:17 17:3 88:22 90:2 136:6 87:25 88:4 237:25 187:24 50:3,5 57:4 138:18 32:8 34:16 95:13,17,22 179:19 88:10 sanctity 188:3,20 57:6 59:7 147:24 42:13 52:2 97:21 180:3 127:16 189:7,16,18 59:10 61:15 retirees 54:5 123:18 107:11 191:17 S sanctuary 242:13,17 61:18 63:16 139:18 126:16 108:18 194:3 S 1:12 114:7 127:3 262:11 63:19 65:5 147:24 130:18 111:2 196:20 Sabb 26:15 127:11,13 School's 65:8 66:7 Retirement 182:3 193:4 116:11 199:20 30:9 127:15,22 118:4 66:15 156:5 166:20,25 195:14 160:20,23 228:6 sacred 74:23 129:25 schools 156:7 165:7 167:6 198:7 201:7 219:18 235:10 127:6 130:11 118:12,19 165:10 return 74:11 229:18 250:7 236:16 sad 114:3 131:15 119:4,13,18 183:22,24 returning 238:3,24 rip 262:22 Ronald 136:18 134:12,17 187:17 184:13,15 95:2 239:2,21,24 ripped 112:3 137:11 sadness Sarah 10:15 188:10,13 185:16,19 returns 56:17 240:20,23 rise 2:19,21 roof 78:24 135:11 sarcastic 189:22 186:9,11 58:22 61:3 241:15,19 Rising 37:9 79:5 171:18 safe 10:4,25 226:20 190:3,5 190:9,12 revenue 261:25 risk 120:9 224:5 11:22 14:2 save 75:11 Schuylkill 202:20,22 95:20 122:2 265:9 River 169:25 roofs 171:25 87:17 99:17 saw 25:4,12 173:11 231:6,8 196:13 Rhawn 170:2 173:8,11 room 1:6 119:9 120:8 25:12,13 177:8,9 232:8,10 233:21 rich 18:25 177:8,9 76:20 95:6 129:2 135:8 science 239:6,8 revenue-ge...
87:15,19,22 230:25 102:17,18 threat 44:25 251:20 10:12 17:6 152:10 59:24 60:4 88:6 90:22 232:5 233:8 105:17 87:18 133:2 252:22 28:4,9 209:21 60:14 90:24 91:9 233:10,13 136:19 248:14 261:8 30:11 31:8 tolerance trash 73:23 94:3,5,12 235:9,9,13 149:20 threatening timely 74:11 34:13 41:12 42:20 245:7 trashed 72:3 94:14 96:4 235:15,25 211:5 79:4 83:3 45:14 46:9 246:24 89:8 90:9 96:7 99:18 236:8,11 218:20 three 34:13 times 4:8 59:21 62:6 Tom 21:2 trauma 99:20 102:5 239:4,25 233:24 38:11 49:25 71:23 101:7 63:3,10 186:22 132:24,24 102:11 240:24 234:8 81:4 111:11 141:20 64:18 67:8 tomorrow trauma-filled 104:3,6 241:20 235:21 118:10 142:15 67:15 68:5 115:22 127:19 106:2,4 243:18 261:18 131:23 235:22 69:12 72:10 tool 223:16 traumatized 109:9,10,13 244:16 things 8:18 135:23 263:10 72:24 96:20 top 101:16 115:9 109:14,14 245:17 86:24 141:19 Timothy 38:5 103:4 104:2 115:16 132:19 110:7,9 248:20 187:14 143:11,14 tired 98:14 110:9 tormenting travel 24:6 112:17,20 249:17 212:13 147:7 tireless 20:18 112:14 148:25 51:9 81:23 114:17 250:21 233:17 152:19,23 29:21 114:22 torture 133:8 255:7 117:6,8,12 251:22 254:2 153:5 tirelessly 115:3,5,22 total 24:5,16 travesty 72:9 117:13,25 252:24 think 17:5,21 223:19 158:15 118:3 25:18 treasure 9:22 120:22,23 255:12 73:16 74:12 233:16 title 34:23 121:24 Touch 33:12 15:5 123:24 256:8,13,15 91:20 234:16 35:21 39:12 123:20 241:13 treat 132:14 124:2 126:4 256:16 141:21 253:13 41:18 46:12 126:2,13 tourism 18:8 262:15 126:5 257:6 142:4 throats 52:8 60:16 137:22 18:15 treated 129:15,18 259:11,16 155:22 151:20 93:11 139:3 tourists 12:10 115:13 133:16 260:13 214:21 throw 107:6 106:22 140:12 tow 168:21 treatment 134:3,5 261:15,21 216:8 Thursday 1:7 155:5 157:5 146:13 Townsend 132:18 137:6,9 261:23 226:20 4:25 5:7,14 160:11 155:8,15 216:23 tremendous 140:19,21 262:2,17,23 227:14,17 265:13,18 165:25 188:6 207:6 Toxic 189:25 12:24 145:19,23 263:13,15 230:15 Tiffany 150:4 166:13,18 210:5 tracks 133:7 Tremont 145:25 263:18 231:20 Tiger 234:11 167:4,12 211:10 Trades 34:25 172:21 149:22,23 264:6,8,11 252:25 tight 260:25 169:9 215:4 35:22 trespass 82:4 150:2,20 265:4,6,11 253:3 262:5 Tim 158:20 171:21 219:23,24 tradition 91:15 154:18,24 266:3 263:9 time 6:25 7:5 172:3 223:13 11:18 148:17 154:24 thanking thinking 7:23 15:18 173:22 225:4 227:9 traffic 147:16 trespasser 155:16,18 203:22 264:13 15:23 17:2 176:10 264:15,21 tragic 127:19 73:3,12 155:24 thanks 4:19 thinks 214:4 29:5,6,13 177:4,22 today's 32:19 159:3 74:20 75:11 156:15,18 6:8,16 third 19:12 69:3 72:4 178:6,16 33:2,10,16 Trail 177:9 88:23 89:22 156:24 26:18 265:2 95:18 234:8 73:20 74:18 183:2,8 37:25 40:7 training 89:25 90:9 164:22 theft 108:14 Thirteenth 78:16 79:14 190:22,24 40:25 41:11 125:19 92:17 165:3,9 215:7,7 202:9 82:13 94:17 199:2 43:15 44:2 Trakimas 208:22 179:15 therapists Thirty-Seco... 105:2 201:24 44:21 45:5 187:19 209:15 183:15 36:16 183:11 110:24,25 203:8 46:4 47:5 transcript 214:8 Stated Meeting June 21, 2018 220:23 turn 68:10 85:13 86:13 100:18 62:24 63:20 vault 37:2 16:16 23:2 254:22 trespassers 82:9 205:18 139:18 151:15 64:15 65:9 veritable 23:7 256:11 88:9 89:3,7 218:9 unanswered 152:19,19 65:17 66:16 22:22 visited 71:11 89:10 90:11 turned 145:2 90:8 152:19 85:11 95:4 version visitors 2:8 W 90:21 92:6 154:9 218:7 unborn 3:22 153:19 102:22 140:14 2:21 6:19 W 185:3,4 93:14 95:12 218:22 unchecked 154:4 133:19 206:9 8:14 12:8 waited 95:16,22 turns 69:2,3,6 83:4 199:13 137:23 versions 13:14 15:10 141:25 203:12,14 220:8 unclear University 170:7 205:23 18:3,9 waiting 73:6 trespassing TV 25:13 207:14 26:10 171:4 171:24,25 Veterans 23:14,25 116:21 89:5 Tweeting underground 262:12,13 175:23 26:8 30:3 walk 18:22 trial 107:3 143:15 261:3 262:13,14 176:4,22 viable 127:22 vital 125:15 24:25 trials 107:21 Twenty-Sec... understand 264:16 178:3 179:7 vibrancy voice 96:19 215:16 tribe 97:6 177:17 65:14 96:25 unjust 132:16 191:9 28:15 98:22 115:6 221:21 tribes 97:3 Twenty-Thi...
97:8 103:14 unlawful 232:25 vibrant 2:12 137:23 walked 87:12 tried 135:6 177:18 103:15 178:23 245:12 18:23 219:24 walking Trinity 34:6 two 22:23 understand... unlivable 247:4 Vicente 84:8 voices 66:11 135:9 truck 35:15 34:14,17 11:7 131:7 251:16 84:13,14 68:7 97:22 walkway 168:20 44:13 46:10 understate... unnecessary uses 171:17 victim 106:12 voluntary 202:7 true 77:5 51:24 53:4 111:24 83:25 233:21 119:20 121:12 walkways 105:25 55:21 57:24 undocumen... unpreceden... usually 25:14 212:9 volunteer 35:5 223:2 267:7 73:3 78:8,8 115:2 263:4 224:6 215:12 21:8 wall 78:24 truly 9:7 78:17,21 131:16 unscrew utilities 59:25 victim's vote 77:18 Walnut 171:6 27:23 81:5 94:20 unexpectedly 86:12 60:4,14 75:15 93:25 103:5 want 14:18 107:11 98:16 105:3 82:9 Unveiling 74:6 82:10 Victimizing 103:23 16:2,8 224:3 111:12 unfortunate 26:6 82:10 75:19 104:2,24 27:25 30:12 Trump 42:19 118:10 3:4 187:17 Upland 39:6 utility 173:13 victims 75:19 105:15,16 41:22 47:21 245:6 135:23 Unfortunat...