civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - December 3, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Dec 3, 20257h 18m

so why don't you start okay so good morning we operate a supported housing home for men of

Similar wording

recovery protected under the ada and fair housing act and we are requesting a reasonable accommodation

Similar wording

for group living uh for up to 10 men to live in a in this house um to live in a structured peer

Similar wording

supported and drug-free home okay um so why don't you um

Similar wording

do you have plans for it drawn drawn up one of your shows your plans first

Similar wording

okay so this is the first floor this is our floor plan so why don't you walk us through what the

Similar wording

first floor looks like so the first floor we have when you first walk in is a vestibule

Similar wording

um and can you speak more into the microphone can can barely hear you pull the mic towards you

Similar wording

when you first walk in it's a small vestibule and then to the left is a living room and um

Similar wording

to the right of that is some stairs and then we have a living area and then straight back

Similar wording

is a kitchen, and then we have an extra room

Similar wording

in the back, and it's three upstairs. We have

Similar wording

three bedrooms. The second floor, we have three

Similar wording

bedrooms and a bathroom, and then the third floor, we have two bedrooms.

Similar wording

Here's some pictures of

Similar wording

how it looks before and after. This is how it looked prior

Similar wording

to me getting some renovations done.

Similar wording

We have two bathrooms, one on the first floor, one on the second floor.

Similar wording

Full shower.

Similar wording

So these are before pictures.

Similar wording

And this is how it looks now.

Similar wording

Is this in operation now?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

We're licensed by the state.

Similar wording

We have one we cover.

Similar wording

This is the kitchen and the living space.

Similar wording

this is the

Similar wording

bedroom upstairs to the back

Similar wording

oh it's a

Similar wording

bathroom on the second floor

Similar wording

it's another room

Similar wording

so six bedrooms total

Similar wording

and this is the basement

Similar wording

so we have our license

Similar wording

we're licensed by the state

Similar wording

and I'm certified to give

Similar wording

medication

Similar wording

and we kindly ask

Similar wording

that we have your support as we request

Similar wording

the proposed use group living

Similar wording

1630 Willington Street

Similar wording

so that we may provide

Similar wording

stability, safety and recovery

Similar wording

support to the community. Finally, we would like to close with the lyrics of Diana Ross

Similar wording

song, reach out and touch someone's hand and make this world a better place

Similar wording

if you can. Thank you. Could you tell us what happened when you went to the RCO?

Similar wording

We went to the RCO and

Similar wording

the church, the guy at the pastor said he had a hard time

Similar wording

voting. There was no instructions on how to vote. So we wasn't

Similar wording

So we wasn't sure if everybody voted on there because it wasn't indicated how to vote.

Similar wording

sure if everybody voted on there because it wasn't indicated

Similar wording

You

Similar wording

And so the people from the board, they didn't.

Similar wording

They said no.

Similar wording

We don't know who else said no, but they said about five people or something.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Questions from the board.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

How long have you been operating this program?

Similar wording

July.

Similar wording

Since July of this year.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And then you currently have 10 individuals already living in the program?

Similar wording

Just one.

Similar wording

Just one.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And then what's the plan for staffing for?

Similar wording

So as we fill up, we have like, so far it's three of us.

Similar wording

I have, you know, us two and then a cousin.

Similar wording

But when it gets filled up, we have people, you know, on board that want to work there.

Similar wording

Right now, you know, it's just one tenant in the air.

Similar wording

Just one tenant.

Similar wording

And then explain a little bit of the setup.

Similar wording

So there's five bedrooms?

Similar wording

it's six bedrooms but one that we're using as an office okay and uh five bedrooms uh for yeah

Similar wording

the tenant and then how long are the tenants typically like what's your expectation for

Similar wording

length of stay so we're taking people coming straight out of treatment after 30 days so they

Similar wording

normally stay about six months to a year okay and then what are the sort of because it just looks

Similar wording

like that we like most of the pictures we saw with the exception of the bedrooms it looks like those

Similar wording

or like cot beds is there furniture in the rest of the house what are like how like what else is

Similar wording

on site to support their living um it's just like the small dressers and in bed is closet space

Similar wording

that's it what about public space like is there the living room and the kitchen and enough seating

Similar wording

for the seats and people okay and then how are you handling food on site like are they doing

Similar wording

there is this are they completely independent yes for now what does that mean oh well yes they are

Similar wording

okay so this is not it's not assisted living no no so you're really like just providing temporary

Similar wording

housing yeah okay and they're coming through a state like a city or state referral program

Similar wording

so far yes but right now we don't have funded or anything so these are people that coming from a

Similar wording

program and come in there and they pay on

Similar wording

their own. The tenants

Similar wording

pay on their own.

Similar wording

Got it.

Similar wording

And so are most of them

Similar wording

like still working or

Similar wording

like employ or

Similar wording

get this a bill. So this isn't with any

Similar wording

like federal subsidy. There's no program.

Similar wording

This is all sort of like a private

Similar wording

agreement between you and the individual

Similar wording

tenants. How are the leases

Similar wording

set up?

Similar wording

It's on here.

Similar wording

and are these are these uh tenants uh in in a recovery program are they in recovery or

Similar wording

they be in recovery programs and what are what a wrapper are there any wraparound services that

Similar wording

you provide or that are provided by any other organization yeah they all we all they all

Similar wording

referred out so they all go to like um you know meetings and get their mental health um services

Similar wording

outside and then how how are you able to confirm that if it's a private agreement

Similar wording

well the guy that we have now um he go north board street so um well i understand that for

Similar wording

your single tenant but like once you have 10 people i think i'm i'm more so concerned that

Similar wording

like one at fully fully occupied how is this like mint how are you going to manage the 10 tenants

Similar wording

where they all might be what programs they might be in and then what other provisions in place

Similar wording

should something go wrong right like because things don't always go as you intend the more

Similar wording

people you have the more instances you have for that to happen and you've got a private lease

Similar wording

agreement what is like you know would you have to wait if a person for whatever reason you know

Similar wording

relapsed and they're in your house would that one it's potentially a trigger for your other

Similar wording

residents but would you have to then go through a traditional uh eviction process to try to get

Similar wording

them out so I'm just I'm trying to understand like kind of operationally what this in the lease

Similar wording

agreement that they find in the packet that we have and you're operating this under an LLC

Similar wording

because then this is a private property a non-profit what's your what's your background

Similar wording

in this in this field or is do you have are you a social worker or a substance abuse

Similar wording

abuse counselor, or what's your background in this type of facility or treatment?

Similar wording

counselor or what's your background in this type of

Similar wording

Basically, I'm in a coalition. I have a mentor, and we're in a coalition where we

Similar wording

meet once or twice a week. But I have a passion for this work. My mother was on drugs. My family

Similar wording

grew up on drugs. So this is a way I can get back and help. So that's my mission. That's why I'm

Similar wording

doing this but uh i work in a hospital uh in a pharmacy uh full-time and and then i do this too

Similar wording

but um i just have a question for clarity so do you just want to have a rooming house or do you

Similar wording

want to run a program i do want to run a program okay but but with each person getting the individual

Similar wording

a lease?

Similar wording

Well, after we, once we get approved

Similar wording

through this and be able to get funding and all that kind of stuff, you know,

Similar wording

then it'll be, basically it won't be a room

Similar wording

thing anymore once we get, you know, funding. But right now they have to pay because we don't have

Similar wording

you know, any funding or anything for them for now.

Similar wording

So, I guess, okay.

Similar wording

okay so you're saying that you work full-time correct and then so who will be

Similar wording

there yeah i have a cousin and then my daughter and me and i work overnight we have a house you

Similar wording

know the house manager be the overnight and my cousin he works and then he's he helped us too

Similar wording

he worked there but i work overnight so i'm there a lot in the day okay so you have two you you're

Similar wording

there, and there'll be two

Similar wording

other assistants who

Similar wording

will be. My daughter and my cousin.

Similar wording

And this is a, this is

Similar wording

24 hours a day, seven days

Similar wording

a week kind of thing.

Similar wording

Correct?

Similar wording

You gotta be sworn in.

Similar wording

Could you please

Similar wording

could you please state your

Similar wording

name and spell for the stenographer? My first name is

Similar wording

Alicia, A-L-L-I-C-A, and my last name

Similar wording

is Harold, H-A-R-O-L-D.

Similar wording

You swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth,

Similar wording

nothing but the truth. I do. Please proceed.

Similar wording

Let me tell you what my concerns are.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay, so then you can, all right.

Similar wording

So what we have here is a, you're not fish, you're not thou, shall we say, all right?

Similar wording

A lot of group homes, they have some kind of organization that they are attached to.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

They have a funding source because they are this nonprofit that gets funding, say, from organizations that may place residents with a facility like a group home or what have you.

Similar wording

so you're not you don't have any of those kind of things and it also means that it's a little

Similar wording

hard to get a sense of where you're getting your where you're going to get your clientele from

Similar wording

how they are going to be uh supervised during the time that they are with you and that kind

Similar wording

of things so that's where we're kind of having our problem and so and can you just indicate on

Similar wording

the record what your relationship is to this property or the project so i'm her daughter and

Similar wording

partner in the business okay all right thank you all right um so can you state your first question

Similar wording

i'm sorry i just want to make sure it's it's more about how is how is this all gonna um work

Similar wording

Right. Yeah. So because, you know, we don't we're we're we're a little unsure about where you're getting your clientele from.

Similar wording

The. Yeah. The the how they're going to be supervised while they're there. Right.

Similar wording

OK. How you're going to support the activities of the house, you know, like right now you say you have no funding.

Similar wording

So, again, you are depending on whoever these residents are to pay whatever the rent is so that you can at least provide the housing for them.

Similar wording

But they are also, you know, presumably you're going to provide some sort of support services of some sort.

Similar wording

so you have to be able to afford to do that right so you know because you're not attached to any

Similar wording

other like group or whatever the question is how is that all going to be worked out or managed or

Similar wording

have you come up with do you have a business plan do you have some way that you are going to

Similar wording

operate this facility yes so basically we've we got two properties we've had this property for

Similar wording

old for a year and it just become an occupier. We've been maintaining a property. We both work

Similar wording

and it's just becoming occupied.

Similar wording

We've been maintaining the property.

Similar wording

We both work full-time.

Similar wording

full-time. I work with a mental.

Similar wording

I work with a mental health program, and she works at a hospital,

Similar wording

so we've been funding the property on our own.

Similar wording

We've been able to afford it.

Similar wording

The people that come in, they're on Social Security

Similar wording

or they're required to work because no one can stay in the house all day

Similar wording

for 24 hours.

Similar wording

We do have video surveillance because this is a level 2 home,

Similar wording

so they're not required to be babysat.

Similar wording

We just have to check in every day, which we do.

Similar wording

It's required every other day.

Similar wording

We go there every day between me, my mother, and my cousin.

Similar wording

And then we also have video surveillance.

Similar wording

We know when they're entering.

Similar wording

We know when they're leaving.

Similar wording

And then we also want to add a police log to check in every day also.

Similar wording

But we've been maintaining this property without rent assistance or anything like that because I'm a realtor and I have a job.

Similar wording

And we get clients.

Similar wording