civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 13, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 13, 20265h 38m

out how are you are you planning to move the property line or i can speak you can't have

Similar wording

windows on the property line yeah that is that is correct wait a minute wait a minute who's

Similar wording

talking evan is the project architect we can all right evan could you please state your name as

Similar wording

bell for the stenographer sure it's evan litvin e-v-a-n-l-i-t-v-i-n you swear or affirm to tell

Similar wording

truth the whole truth nothing but the truth i do counsel please proceed i think mr johns had a

Similar wording

question go ahead yes um actually andrea if you could go to the rendering i think it might be

Similar wording

helpful to explain yeah that that uh ariel one if you go back there we go perfect so actually

Similar wording

there are not windows on the property line the existing masonry has openings and we're going to

Similar wording

leave them open but the fire separation distance will be maintained as you can see these are

Similar wording

existing openings where the building is actually right up against the property line the openings

Similar wording

are filled in so it's open to a light well and to an exit passageway only

Similar wording

okay okay okay okay okay okay i see it now got it

Similar wording

Yes, I have a question about the rear yard and is it, how is it accessed by the tenants? Because I see there's a courtyard for the sort of rear building with that interior stairwell. So they each, every unit has the two egresses, but how are they accessing the patio?

Similar wording

the patio is only accessible to the ground floor unit that's a private unit so all egress is going

Similar wording

to go out through the front and that's what that's the purpose of the exit passageway on the first

Similar wording

floor to the is the door missing here or is it oh is that a sliding door through the yeah slider

Similar wording

yeah understood okay but everybody does have access to the courtyard and the plaza and then

Similar wording

the roof decks yes okay perfect other questions

Similar wording

questions from our attorney hillary emerson not at this time mr chair

Similar wording

since your comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

planning commission madison matera planning commission staff the comprehensive plan

Similar wording

recommends no change the existing rsa 5 residential single family zoning at this location

Similar wording

two existing buildings sit on this 3500 square foot lot and there is documented history of

Similar wording

previous multi-family use given the size of the lot seven units is in character with the

Similar wording

surrounding neighborhood the building on fairmount ave is currently non-conforming at 38 feet and six

Similar wording

inches the pellet has not demonstrated that the proposed height of 46 and a half feet is the least

Similar wording

minimum the planning commission recommends the board grant the requested variance for seven

Similar wording

and dwelling units and grant the requested variance

Similar wording

for height with proviso max 38 feet, six inches.

Similar wording

If I may, I'll just respond quickly to the height. Because we are adaptively reusing the rear, the additional height allows us to get back the GFA that we're demolishing in the rear of the property, but also level the floor so that they match up with the front of the, of the prop, of the front structure.

Similar wording

If I may, I'll just respond quickly to the height

Similar wording

because we are adoptively re...

Similar wording

all right so mi 2026 000 234 329 to 31 fan round avenue i vote yes with proviso revives plans four

Similar wording

pages stamped by cba on march may 13 2026. michael johns my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes, with Proviso.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes, with Proviso.

Similar wording

Diane Wynn, my vote is yes, with Proviso.

Similar wording

You have, let's see, your number 10.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Who's doing 10?

Similar wording

Oh, I'm doing 10 and 11, yes.

Similar wording

Oh, okay.

Similar wording

All right, I got it.

Similar wording

All right. MI 2026-000-236-56-69 East Armat Street. Council, could you please state your name? You don't have to spell it, just state your name.

Similar wording

Yes, Andrea Solomon, and my client is here, Kyle Leslie, so I'll ask him to step up. I'm also going to switch over, if that's okay, to plug my computer.

Similar wording

whatever you want to do you have the 12th ward with uh serious support and council member bass

Similar wording

has also sent a letter of support

Similar wording

our our board secretary has a few questions uh good afternoon council did you submit your

Similar wording

documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing we did and do you waive the reading

Similar wording

of the review home stipulate to its accuracy i do and you can share your screen and begin your

Similar wording

presentation thank you thank you very much okay this application is for the change of use at the

Similar wording

ground floor of an existing structure to add artist studios the there's no proposed changes

Similar wording

to the height or to the the existing structure the property is located in a commercial auto

Similar wording

commercial zoning district and so the proposed use for artist studios is not allowed

Similar wording

as chairman bergman stated we did receive the support from cindy bass actually and my client

Similar wording

kyle leslie is here and he can speak to this they're working with the councilwoman's office

Similar wording

to find tenants community-based tenants for this space

Similar wording

we also received the support of the coordinating rco the 12th award democratic rco

Similar wording

The property is at the corner of Kenyon Street and East Arment Street. It has 46 parking spaces. It is a large 14,000 unchanged square foot property that formerly housed child care facilities.

Similar wording

and I believe it was also a foster office that they helped adoptive parents and foster parents.

Similar wording

It has then, since they left, has been sitting vacant. My client acquired it about a year ago

Similar wording

and has not been able to find a single tenant that is able to occupy this large space. As you

Similar wording

can see it's set quite set back from the commercial corridor of chelton avenue and it's in front of

Similar wording

this extra space storage facility across kenyon street and on the other side it is facing a

Similar wording

warehouse for verizon wireless so not a lot of foot traffic and a difficult place to find tenants

Similar wording

So, what we're proposing, and here are the images of the street frontage, Kenyon Street, Armit Street.

Similar wording

This is Armit Street, one of the entrances to the lower parking level.

Similar wording

What we're proposing is in this corner of the ground floor space to add artist studios and break up for smaller tenant spaces.

Similar wording

What we're proposing is in this corner of the ground floor.

Similar wording

We're envisioning really community driven asset, and that this becomes an asset for for local artists to be able to come in, set up shop, emerging artists to really have a place where they can create.

Similar wording

This is the interior of the property. It's quite vast. This is the actual space that would be subdivided into the artist studios and more images of the interior of the property. It has a large storage space in the back.

Similar wording

um we did actually get a permit for the second floor of this for an adult

Similar wording

care facility that tenant has since dropped out but the the vision for this is to really be

Similar wording

community spaces and it's been difficult to rent out such such a large structure in this location

Similar wording

the it's just for the one part of it over this is just for the one part of it yes i have the

Similar wording

our application

Similar wording

here we go so this is the ground floor level

Similar wording

again there's 46 or so parking spaces and this corner of the ground floor level

Similar wording

level is what we're proposing for the subdivided artist studios

Similar wording

We've seen this model be successful in other areas in Philly.

Similar wording

This is the former U of Arts building and they're renting, subleasing these spaces for, for studios of smaller footprints so that they can come in and create the posting notices.

Similar wording

so that's that's the proposal um if we can swear callan i'm sure we can talk a little bit about

Similar wording

the green light on the bottom yes all right could you get close that's fine could you please state

Similar wording

your name then smell spell it for the stenographer calfani leslie k-h-a-l-f-a-n-i

Similar wording

leslie l-e-s-l-i-e do you swear referring to tell the truth told truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes counsel uh mr lovely you saw my presentation is it true and accurate to the best of your

Similar wording

knowledge yes and you adopt it as your own testimony yes anything else you would like to add

Similar wording

um yeah actually i think uh i've had other projects that have been solely more residential

Similar wording

mixed-use developments and this was one that honestly i'm struggling with because

Similar wording

the use for it is is not really a network i have which i think would be beneficial for

Similar wording

the community city organizations to use vast amounts of this building in different ways

Similar wording

So this is just one concept that is proposed as an idea, given that this space is available specifically and work needs to be done in this part of the building anyway.

Similar wording

But this is a small portion of the building where other offices, community-based organizations could be involved and pretty much share the space.

Similar wording

the intention is not really to you know build a giant structure at the at this location it's

Similar wording

really to use it for what exists in that neighborhood and i just don't have those

Similar wording

kind of connections within the city or to get this in front of them so artists is and that's

Similar wording

why you've been working closely with the council's office to to find community-based tenants right

Similar wording

correct so that's that's really the goal for this building i think of i'd love for organizations to

Similar wording

take a look at it because then they would understand the scale and how it could actually

Similar wording

be used so this is the first step okay questions from the board yeah what are the other uses that

Similar wording

are happening right now the rest of it is vacant so we're only talking about this portion as artist

Similar wording

studios and then whatever's coming next is still tbd yeah offices businesses again we had the we

Similar wording

had the second floor was going to be an adult care facility but that tenant dropped out hopefully we

Similar wording

can find a similar entity and the artist studios are only happening at the first floor level or

Similar wording

first floor level or like yes

Similar wording

like, yes.

Similar wording

okay other questions nope so i just thought something just as you talk as you talk that

Similar wording

this is a way to get this building activated on the first floor okay all right and that's

Similar wording

been the the input from council and and in the community okay i got it i mean i think

Similar wording

so have you interviewed or talked to any artists in the planning of this i have you have yes okay

Similar wording

because i will just say um your comparison to the via building is it's a wide comparison because

Similar wording

like both locationally but the building the other building also has a lot of other wraparound

Similar wording

support spaces for the artist um i'm one of the tenants that's going to be in that building

Similar wording

or I should be moving, at least starts on Friday.

Similar wording

And like most of the building is not individual artists.

Similar wording

The draw is all of the like other space.

Similar wording

There's a gallery space.

Similar wording

There's like things that artists need.

Similar wording

Whereas this looked very utilitarian, like the matrix.

Similar wording

It was a bunch of cubicles.

Similar wording

I also feel like artists typically need a lot of like water,

Similar wording

right, like most art things either need water.

Similar wording

And like, I didn't see a lot of water hookups

Similar wording

on this building.

Similar wording

So I do question a little bit how this is going to function as a really great studio space. They also need lots of light. These are very tiny windows and fluorescent lights. So like the things that typically artists would want, or that most fine artists would need, the building currently doesn't look like it's supporting. And so I'm a little curious, like without some of those other supportive spaces, how this is going to function as an arts community.

Similar wording

yeah it's so it's it's been vacant and i i think you're right the hope is that we have all these

Similar wording

other bigger tenants that are drawn it becomes a really community-based space that makes sense

Similar wording

most of that has little to do with the use and more with the layout of the space but i do think

Similar wording

like as you're developing it that's something i would i mean think about their options here i mean

Similar wording

if they we have multiple units designed to make it you know affordable attractive but they can be

Similar wording

larger occupy more of the window spaces when we construct it we do have water hookups at two

Similar wording

locations within that area but they weren't shown on that plan that we plan to incorporate

Similar wording

overall this idea essentially came from uh interested tenant who wanted to do a print shop

Similar wording

That would make more sense, because those operate very well on things that look like

Similar wording

basements.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Well, we didn't even show you that portion of the building, but it's like a warehouse

Similar wording

space.

Similar wording

And that was where the print shop would have been, and you could have walked from the print

Similar wording

shop to these artist studios, and those were students that would come into the building.

Similar wording

So then it would start becoming this kind of environment that supports all of these

Similar wording

arts.

Similar wording

So after school programs, things like that.

Similar wording

And that print shop is the business support, which is by right, but is part of this application.

Similar wording

Got it.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Questions from our attorney, Hillary Emerson.

Similar wording

It doesn't sound like the buildings come divided into, like, units or suites,

Similar wording

so it probably wouldn't make sense if the board granted to put a proviso for a specific area,

Similar wording

the way it's set up now, anyway.

Similar wording

Right. It's not subdivided yet. I think we had applied for it on the ground floor.

Similar wording

Okay. Yeah, it doesn't specify that on the refusal, but that that's fine.

Similar wording

So, okay. Thank you. Just ground floor only when we do it.

Similar wording

If the board wishes, yes, we can specify the ground floor. Yep.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

I do not see any hands, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

planning commission thank you Madison Matera planning commission staff the comprehensive plan

Similar wording

recommends a change in zoning at this location from the existing CA1 auto-oriented commercial

Similar wording

to CMX3 commercial mixed use under the recommended CMX3 zoning artist studios are allowed by right

Similar wording

planning commission recommends the board grant the requested variance for artist studios

Similar wording

and my 2026 000236 53 to 69 east armat street i vote yes with proviso ground floor only

Similar wording

michael johnson my vote is yes with proviso cheryl gaston my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

i am mcadams my vote is yes with proviso i win my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

thank you for coming in sir good luck with your project thank you appreciate it um

Similar wording

So, MI 2026-000267, 1935 Huntington Street.

Similar wording

Andrea, just state your name. Andrea Solomon. And could you identify your client, a relationship to this property? Yes, my client is LOD LLC, and here on behalf of LOD LLC is Evan Lipman, who was already sworn in.

Similar wording

Andrea, just state your name.

Similar wording

Andrea Solomon.

Similar wording

and i see a letter from council member squilla and also there's uh east kendington neighbors

Similar wording

association am i correct great our our um board secretary has a few questions

Similar wording

good afternoon council did you submit your documents and exhibits five days in advance of

Similar wording

this hearing we did and do you waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy

Similar wording

I do. Then you can share your screen and begin your presentation. Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you very much. This application is for the demolition of the existing structures and a lot line adjustment of two parcels, 1935 East Huntington Street and 1944 Herald Street, combining the two parcels and then readjusting to subsequently create three parcels.

Similar wording

uh we received the support from ecna

Similar wording

this uh parcel is located on hunt it fronts two streets huntington and herald street as you can

Similar wording

see it is an oversized and irregular lot that is zoned for RM1. Sorry, so many today.

Similar wording

It's zoned for RM1. We're proposing to more regularly subdivide the lot and

Similar wording

follow the context of the neighborhood to create more regularly sized parcels. The refusal is due

Similar wording

to the fact that even though the parcels will be similar in size to the others existing on

Similar wording

the block and in the neighborhood, they will be below the required lot size. This is East Huntington

Similar wording

and Harold Street streets where the proposed lots are, the existing structures that are proposed to be demolished, and again, it's a primarily RM1 block.

Similar wording

There is various zoning, but you can see the parcel sizes are really similar along Huntington Ave.

Similar wording

Here, there's other very similarly sized RM1 lots.

Similar wording

We're proposing this lot area diagram breaks it down further and the more immediate blocks, including, in addition to the lots that I just showed,

Similar wording

are very similar in size. The three resulting lots that we're proposing,

Similar wording

K, L, and J, will be in conformity with the other existing parcels, also zoned RM1.

Similar wording

The zoning site plans gear the lot lines as existing and as proposed,

Similar wording

and elevations of the eventual proposed development which would be by right

Similar wording

here they are again a little bit more closely and i'm happy to

Similar wording

turn the mic over to evan for more questions but it's the again the the refusal is just for the

Similar wording

resulting lot sizes nothing to do with the what's going to go on yeah okay bring evan on

Similar wording

evan yes evan just for the record could you please state your name you've already been sworn

Similar wording

sure it's evan litman okay council evan you saw um my presentation

Similar wording

And is it true and accurate to the best of your knowledge?

Similar wording

Yes, it is. You adopted as your own testimony.

Similar wording

I do anything else that you are you would like to add or

Similar wording

i think we can we can take questions for from the board any questions that you have

Similar wording

so once these are subs once the slot is subdivided will the rear yards comply yes

Similar wording