civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - February 19, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Feb 19, 20254h 55m

Excuse me, Mr. Chair, on 1201, here and hold, are we bringing that back for resumption on the amended refusal, or are we just opposing the record closed except for the amended refusal?

Similar wording

I think it's closed except for that and comments from the attorney, if he wants, right?

Similar wording

Well, I don't think he'll have comments on the amended refusal, but okay.

Similar wording

It's closed.

Similar wording

Okay, all right, thank you for the clarification.

Similar wording

All right. So we're going to go with number nine, MI 2024-006-839-6101 North Broad Street. Meredith Trego is the attorney. There's a letter of non-opposition from a concerned community association.

Similar wording

counsel could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

uh yes my name is meredith trego with ballard spar my name is spelled m-e-r-e-d-i-t-h

Similar wording

trego is t-r-e-g-o do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but

Similar wording

the truth i do could you identify your client the relationship to the property sure i am here

Similar wording

representing archwell health llc who's the lessee of the property at 6101 north broad street the

Similar wording

property is owned by rtec1 llc and ng 19 lp our vice chair has a few questions good afternoon

Similar wording

counselor do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal or stipulate to its accuracy

Similar wording

we do have emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that's needed to proceed with this

Similar wording

we do have emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that's needed to proceed with this

Similar wording

kids, Bob.

Similar wording

case five days in advance of this hearing yes sir we have thank you counsel please proceed

Similar wording

thank you I will go ahead and share my screen

Similar wording

um thank you chairman and members of the board we're here today for a request for a special

Similar wording

exception for the use of a property as a group medical health practitioner office which will be

Similar wording

located in an existing building in a cmx 2.5 commercial mixed-use zoning district i'm joined

Similar wording

today by my client mr seth dickey who's the associate vp of market development for archwell

Similar wording

health um as well as okay um as well as potentially uh dr moten um who is a senior market medical

Similar wording

director for archwell health she'll be um joining us if she can our exhibits filed with the board

Similar wording

today include everything that's required um included here on this exhibit list um including

Similar wording

our tax clearance certificate for exhibit uh in exhibit two our proof of mailing for our neighbor

Similar wording

notices in exhibit eight our proof of posting in exhibit nine we are also aware that the rco the

Similar wording

acca who's the coordinating rco for this project submitted a letter of non-opposition last night

Similar wording

turning to exhibit three for our referral this is as i said a application for a group

Similar wording

medical practitioner use, which is in the office use category. We note that no zoning plans are

Similar wording

required. This is simply a use application, and this is a special exception in this zoning district.

Similar wording

We do want to note, we met with the community on January 9th, and we'll note up front that their

Similar wording

letter of non-opposition did include three provisos, so we'll just address those. Those

Similar wording

provisos were that the premises not be used as a drug treatment or a drug rehabilitation facility,

Similar wording

that trash will be stored separately in the dumpsters located behind the building in a locked

Similar wording

bin with commercial pickup, and that medical waste will be stored inside the building with

Similar wording

private collection. We have no issues with these provisos. This is our course of business

Similar wording

as a matter of fact anyway, and we're happy to agree to these provisos on any granting of the

Similar wording

special exception. I'm going to go now to exhibit 10, which is our zoning map. As I noted, this is

Similar wording

a CMX 2.5 district. We point out that the property is located on the North Broad Street commercial

Similar wording

corridor with other commercial properties. And looking at some excerpts from the zoning code

Similar wording

in this district, CMX 2.5, this is a special exception. We know that a sole medical health

Similar wording

practitioner is by right, but the group practitioner category puts us into a special

Similar wording

exception. As we will show today, we will meet all the requirements for a special exception

Similar wording

because this will not create any detrimental impact on the health, safety, and welfare to

Similar wording

the community that might exceed or that would exceed what might normally be expected from a

Similar wording

group medical office use. We just want to briefly talk a little bit about Archwell Health.

Similar wording

R2A Health provides primary care services to adults age 60 and over.

Similar wording

They have an average patient age of 72.

Similar wording

R2A Health services include primary care provider visits, lab work, preventative health screenings,

Similar wording

social work visits, nutrition education, care management, cardiology, telehealth visits.

Similar wording

There is a growing need for doctors and other medical professionals in the country, including

Similar wording

in Philadelphia, specifically for the senior population. Approximately 10,000 to 11,000

Similar wording

Americans will age into Medicare each day. R2L was founded in 2020, and it currently has 52

Similar wording

locations throughout the country. It's planning to nearly double that by the end of 2025.

Similar wording

At full capacity at most locations, including this location at 6101 North Broad, we anticipate

Similar wording

roughly 35 full-time staff members. That includes physicians, nurses, nurse practitioners,

Similar wording

medical assistants, as well as other support staff. Archwell also looks to the community first

Similar wording

for hiring and does like to try and fill as many positions of its care team as it can from within

Similar wording

the neighborhood. Facilities, including this one at North Broad, they are purposely located close

Similar wording

to transit and are designed with a focus on accessibility for seniors. The office will be

Similar wording

The office will be open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Similar wording

open from 8 a.m to 5 p.m monday through friday and

Similar wording

And in addition to primary care services, Archwell does provide some ancillary services, such as nutrition education.

Similar wording

Their facilities are also designed to include a modest activities room that can host group activities that promote health and wellness.

Similar wording

Things such as fitness classes like Zumba or chair yoga, as well as other types of health fairs and educational components like that.

Similar wording

It's anticipated that this particular location will schedule roughly 8 to 10 patients per hour,

Similar wording

with an average appointment visit lasting between 40 and 50 minutes per patient.

Similar wording

R2L Health can provide some triage and urgent care services to existing patients,

Similar wording

but that's not their typical model.

Similar wording

It's primarily appointment-based primary care.

Similar wording

R2L Health, we note, does not provide any kind of drug rehabilitation or treatment

Similar wording

at this location or any of its locations.

Similar wording

I'm going to turn to our exhibit 13,

Similar wording

which shows, there we go, an aerial map of the site

Similar wording

with the building and the surrounding parking lot.

Similar wording

This location is located in the Fern Rock neighborhood

Similar wording

of Philadelphia at the intersection of North Broad Street

Similar wording

and Spencer Avenue.

Similar wording

um the existing one-story building is a former ready uh pharmacy and is uh contains roughly 14,000

Similar wording

square feet so we have some images of the site this is a view from north broad street

Similar wording

view from north broad and spencer avenue the view of the south and eastern um facades of the building

Similar wording

from spencer avenue this is the west elevation the north elevation the east elevation which

Similar wording

is essentially the rear of the property and the south elevation we also have included in exhibit

Similar wording

14 some site photos of the interior as i mentioned this is a former rite aid it has been vacant for

Similar wording

a little over a year and then moving to our site plan most of the work that will be done will be

Similar wording

done to the interior of the building we note that while this is an application for the use only we

Similar wording

you know just for informational purposes sort of want to share the site plan and some of the

Similar wording

improvements that will be done so this location has approximately 63 parking spaces those will

Similar wording

remain the same there'll be a little bit of restriping of the ada spaces just to better align

Similar wording

those spaces we're just shifting them essentially from where they are so that the curb onto the

Similar wording

sidewalk sort of meets the ada large space between the spaces a little bit better otherwise the

Similar wording

parking lot will remain the same. The dumpster location is in the rear of the property. That

Similar wording

will be contracted with private commercial pickup. It will be locked between pickups

Similar wording

and for use solely by Archwell. The interior of the building will be fit out with offices

Similar wording

as well as patient rooms, its activity room and a reception area. And on the outside of

Similar wording

the building, most of the work that will be done will really be limited to new signage

Similar wording

on the building as well as new windows and doors so those will be retrofitted just to kind of spruce

Similar wording

up the building give it a fresher look and here is our anticipated again this is not part of this

Similar wording

application but just for your information the the typical signage for archwell and then lastly

Similar wording

we've included some sample interior photos of what offices typically look like

Similar wording

And I think that's it. I think I'll note that the grant of the special exception for the group medical health practitioner use will not create a detrimental impact on the health, safety, and welfare of the neighborhood, exceeding that which we might normally expect from this proposed use.

Similar wording

In fact, the grant of the special exception, we believe, will help improve the health and well-being for the neighbors by bringing accessible health care for seniors to the community.

Similar wording

And I would like to call my client up to adopt my testimony.

Similar wording

Hi, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Seth Dickey, S-E-T-H-D-I-C-K-E-Y.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Mr. Dickey, can you just please tell us about your role with Archwell Health?

Similar wording

Yes, I'm the Associate Vice President with Market Development, so I oversee the end-to-end process from design and construction and the end to go over to our operational leaders.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You have just heard what I said.

Similar wording

Can you affirm that what I've said is true and correct and adopted as your own testimony?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

questions from the board yeah does your use include pickup and drop-off service

Similar wording

Questions from the board.

Similar wording

Yeah, does your use include

Similar wording

I didn't I'm pretty sure if I heard that for residents I mean for your clients

Similar wording

patients sure I'll let mr. Dickey take that question sure most I should say

Similar wording

most if not all Medicare plans do include some type of transportation for

Similar wording

members so we do ride-share partnerships for sure so you'll have vans parked out

Similar wording

in the parking lot when you're not using yeah but it would be more you know like a minivan type of

Similar wording

situation and do you know how many you anticipate having so i'm not sure does archwell health have

Similar wording

its own van or i believe you just i believe they contract with other um private providers of that

Similar wording

service um like health there's a septa has its own service care transit no i know some some of

Similar wording

these services have their own fleet of vans and sometimes they take up all the parking

Similar wording

Apologies for the confusion, but yeah, we don't have our own bus.

Similar wording

Thank you for the question.

Similar wording

And what's the breakdown in terms of services between dental providers and regular medical

Similar wording

practitioners that you're going to have on site?

Similar wording

Did you say dental?

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Oh, I don't believe.

Similar wording

Yeah, so it's just medical service.

Similar wording

It's just primary care, medical.

Similar wording

So no, we wouldn't refer that out.

Similar wording

And then what are the hours of operation?

Similar wording

From Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 5.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Any other questions?

Similar wording

Questions from our attorney.

Similar wording

I'm sorry. Do you have, I guess, like some kind of patient rooms where they can gather or they can have meetings or they can have, do you have like different services on site for these patients, which you said the average age is like 72?

Similar wording

sort of like activity room or something sure yeah so we have a very well done uh reception

Similar wording

area with a cafe and then um like meredith said kind of a modest activity room where we would do

Similar wording

cooking classes nutrition classes chair yoga okay that type of stuff yes all right thank you

Similar wording

questions from our attorney hillary emerson not at this time questions from the audience

Similar wording

questions. Sorry, we have a person with the iPhone. Charlene will be promoted.

Similar wording

Hi. Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Can you hear me? I can. Could you state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Hi, my name is Dr. Charlene Moten, M-O-T-E-N, Charlene, S-H-I-R-L-E-N-E.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Hi, Dr. Moten, thank you for joining us.

Similar wording

We actually thought that you were in mid-flight.

Similar wording

We weren't sure that you were available.

Similar wording

So thank you for logging on.

Similar wording

If you would like, can Dr. Moten adopt my testimony as well?

Similar wording

most certainly. Dr. Moten, have you heard what I said today and can you affirm that what I've

Similar wording

said is true and accurate and adopted as your own testimony? I can. Great. Thank you. Is there

Similar wording

anything else you'd like to add? No, I agree with everything that you've said so far. I do want to

Similar wording

share that, yes, we do contract with Ride Health utilizing SEPTA and ensuring that for those

Similar wording

patients with mobility issues, they do have transportation to the site.

Similar wording

Anyone else in the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Planning commission. The next will be

Similar wording

Tracy Williams.

Similar wording

We had somebody in the audience?

Similar wording

Yes, Tracy Williams. Hi, could you please state your name as spelled

Similar wording

for the stenographer?

Similar wording

hello hi could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

okay tracy williams t-r-a-c-e-y williams w-i-l-l-i-a-m-s right do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth okay could you put your video on please

Similar wording

I'm trying to turn in.

Similar wording

It's not coming on.

Similar wording

You all have it.

Similar wording

We see.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Are you a neighbor?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I live in the 6,000 block of North 13th Street.

Similar wording

We were not aware of this facility.

Similar wording

Archwell helped coming in.

Similar wording

We just were made aware on Thursday.

Similar wording

We oppose it.

Similar wording

We oppose it. The RCO, I don't know who they met with. No one has met with us. I've spoke with residents on 12th Street. I've spoke with residents on Park Avenue. I've spoke with residents on Camac Street. We were not aware of Archwell Health. It's not necessary because Oak Street Health is less than 500 feet away.

Similar wording

The RCO.

Similar wording

I don't know who they met with.

Similar wording

No one has met with us.

Similar wording

that does the same exact thing and does have vans they're connected to the eye institute

Similar wording

and they do the same exact thing for seniors we have a lot of medical facilities we would like

Similar wording

another uh pharmacy in the area thank you counsel you have any questions um sure we would just like

Similar wording

to note that the um uh coordinating rco was assigned by the council person um which is a

Similar wording

the ACCA which is a concerned community association we mailed our notice letters on

Similar wording

November 25th a second letter on January 21st and January 21st in accordance with the address

Similar wording

list provided by the city we held our RCO meeting on January 29th 2025 and posted the property the

Similar wording

same day okay could you tell me who attended your meeting now can't continue yes we we met it was

Similar wording