civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - November 6, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Nov 6, 20244h 58m

de atrás del apartamento

Similar wording

si era de acuerdo a

Similar wording

o la medida de la propiedad

Similar wording

la línea de propiedad como tal

Similar wording

pero eso en sí no importa porque lo que

Similar wording

a mí más me preocupa es que

Similar wording

cuando ellos salgan del apartamento

Similar wording

en el sótano

Similar wording

No, que ellos entren directamente a la entrada como tal y que estén expuestos a los otros vehículos.

Similar wording

No es como los demás edificios que ellos tienen un lugar para estacionamiento,

Similar wording

pero que cuando salen de la habitación como tal o de la vivienda como tal van directamente a la entrada y pueden ser expuestos a vehículos.

Similar wording

No, pero la parte de atrás, la parte de atrás que tiene va a ser privada porque solo va a tener su carro parqueado allí.

Similar wording

So that wouldn't be a problem because in the back, that would be a private driveway for their vehicle only.

Similar wording

And then on the side, there is an emergency exit. And that would be it.

Similar wording

I think that's

Similar wording

Mr. John's point

Similar wording

Is there other questions from the board?

Similar wording

I have a question

Similar wording

Where is the trash stored now

Similar wording

and where is

Similar wording

I guess in terms of

Similar wording

access to

Similar wording

the utilities

Similar wording

the mechanicals

Similar wording

how is that achieved

Similar wording

in your drawing?

Similar wording

Así que ahora tengo otra pregunta.

Similar wording

¿Cómo es que tienen acceso a basura y para también las utilidades en este esquema de planos?

Similar wording

Esa basura está puesta enfrente porque el basurero siempre pasa enfrente allí de la casa.

Similar wording

So the trash is in the front of the house because the garbage truck comes from the front of the house.

Similar wording

other questions

Similar wording

and who has access to the basement like how much access is given to the basement in terms of like

Similar wording

and who has access to the basement like how much

Similar wording

the second and the third units on the uh of the building would they have access to the basement

Similar wording

y la unidad es of the basement y la este el segunda y tercera planta de la unidad van a

Similar wording

tener acceso a el sótano no no no eso es aparte los apartamentos están aparte arriba eso yo este

Similar wording

so um they don't have accents to um the basement the only two entrances and exits

Similar wording

are the emergency exit on the side and then the back entrance

Similar wording

so the back entrance is considered this his main entrance to that uh lower unit

Similar wording

You can't do that. You cannot enter through a bedroom. You can't enter a unit through a bedroom and a room that's subject to locking. You can't do that. That can't be your main entrance.

Similar wording

So that can be your main entrance, because they can't enter for a fourth unit.

Similar wording

Yes, that can change. That can be different.

Similar wording

I'm trying to do what you ask me.

Similar wording

I'm trying to do it with permission, because many people have induced me to do it without permission,

Similar wording

but I don't want to do something illegal.

Similar wording

So that could be changed and that's why I came here so that I can get your permission so that I could do it the correct way because there's been many people that told me, oh, that you don't need to get any sort of permits and don't don't do it that way.

Similar wording

but I wanted it to do it the legal way.

Similar wording

So I'm here to listen to what you have to say

Similar wording

so that I can make those changes

Similar wording

like you're telling me.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Other questions from the board?

Similar wording

Questions or comments from our attorney,

Similar wording

Hillary Emerson.

Similar wording

Just briefly, Mr. Chair,

Similar wording

um the we do not have an RCO letter um in this case the coordinating RCO was take back your

Similar wording

neighborhood but we we received it can you please show it because we we did not receive a copy

Similar wording

Give me one second, please.

Similar wording

They just sent an email.

Similar wording

I have to save it.

Similar wording

While you're doing that,

Similar wording

can you just verify that this is the meeting

Similar wording

that occurred

Similar wording

on July 25th?

Similar wording

Y mientras hace eso,

Similar wording

esta reunión,

Similar wording

si me puede verificar,

Similar wording

fue la que ocurrió

Similar wording

en Julio 25.

Similar wording

¿A dónde?

Similar wording

Where?

Similar wording

Are we just,

Similar wording

I'm just basing it off

Similar wording

of the letter

Similar wording

that was in the exhibit packet

Similar wording

that said a meeting

Similar wording

was occurring

Similar wording

on July 25th.

Similar wording

Yes, and they were there and they checked the basement and everything.

Similar wording

Okay, so it was a site visit?

Similar wording

Yes, so it was a site visit or maybe?

Similar wording

Could you make that a little larger?

Similar wording

I'm not having a...

Similar wording

We can't...

Similar wording

We can't...

Similar wording

It's better than make the letter larger.

Similar wording

Puede hacer la carta más grande

Similar wording

o ponerlo más grande

Similar wording

en la pantalla.

Similar wording

I'm trying, but it doesn't allow me.

Similar wording

It appears that the letter

Similar wording

is in opposition.

Similar wording

La carta está en opuesto.

Similar wording

All right. Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

All right, questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Preguntó comentarios de la audiencia virtual.

Similar wording

And, Mr. Chair, I just ask if the applicant could submit this letter to us for our records along with a copy of the floor plans.

Similar wording

And I think there were some additional photos that were not previously submitted as well.

Similar wording

Whatever you have, please send now to our office, OK?

Similar wording

Así que todos esos documentos, la carta, los planeos y otras fotos que uno había incluido previamente, si no los puede enviar.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Planning Commission.

Similar wording

No hands, Mr. Chair, please excuse the interruption.

Similar wording

Thank you very much. Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Amy, what the Planning Commission?

Similar wording

This property is indicated for residential use on the city plan.

Similar wording

Así que esta es la Comisión de Planeo. Esta propiedad está para uso de residencial en los planos.

Similar wording

El distrito recomienda que no haya cambio en la zona como estaba previamente en esta ubicación.

Similar wording

the applicant has not demonstrated that the property cannot be used in conformance with

Similar wording

the zoning code due to unique physical circumstances or conditions

Similar wording

y el aplicante no ha podido demostrar que esta residencia puede ser utilizada como está

Similar wording

adecuadamente en la zona y en las condiciones necesarias therefore we recommend that the

Similar wording

requested variance not be granted.

Similar wording

Por eso es que nosotros recomendamos que las variencias pedidas no sean dadas.

Similar wording

Hillary, could you please read the number and the address in the record?

Similar wording

Yes, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

This is MI-2024-000056-1329 Levick Street.

Similar wording

I vote no.

Similar wording

Oh, Mr. Chair, let the interpreter put that on the record.

Similar wording

Oh, I'm sure.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Este es el caso MI, línea 2024, línea 000056, 1329 Levick Street.

Similar wording

I vote no.

Similar wording

Voto no.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Michael John, voto no.

Similar wording

Oh, Gaston, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, mi voto es no.

Similar wording

Tanada Graham, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Tanada Graham, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shahid, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shahid, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

And count interpreter, thank you very much for your help.

Similar wording

We appreciate it.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you, everyone.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

We're going to move on to number four.

Similar wording

MI 2024

Similar wording

000819

Similar wording

4444

Similar wording

Oakmont Street. Robert and Amanda

Similar wording

Klein are the owners.

Similar wording

Good morning, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

This is Jason Hand. I'm serving as temporary

Similar wording

co-host. The person

Similar wording

has been promoted to

Similar wording

panelist.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay. Could you please state your name and spell it for the court sonographer?

Similar wording

My name is Robert Klein, R-O-B-E-R-T-K-L-E-I-N.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Okay. Our vice chair has a few questions.

Similar wording

good morning sir have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that's needed

Similar wording

to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing yes sir thank you please proceed

Similar wording

and share the screen

Similar wording

So it's not allow me because someone else is sharing still.

Similar wording

Yeah, could we, could we, could we have that take it off the screen that what's up there now?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Now try.

Similar wording

Attendee.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Welcome.

Similar wording

Hey, so my name is Robert Klein.

Similar wording

We've owned 444 Oakmont Street since 2003.

Similar wording

44-44 Oakmont Street since 2003.

Similar wording

It was the very first apartment me and my girlfriend at the time moved into, now my wife.

Similar wording

It was, you know, very

Similar wording

We started our family in this home, quickly outgrew it when our daughter was born.

Similar wording

The home means a lot to us, and we're hoping we can get this visitor accommodation license so that we can continue to own it.

Similar wording

The city introduced new licensing requirements, or I'm sorry, sorry.

Similar wording

After losing both of our tenants around Christmas in 2022, we decided to make improvements to the apartment and try it out as an STR.

Similar wording

We spent roughly six months improving the home so that it would be a good STR rental.

Similar wording

We'd work on nights and weekends when we didn't have any other commitments.

Similar wording

It was the perfect storm for us.

Similar wording

Right after we finished everything and went live, the city introduced new licenses, requirements, and we're fine getting whatever license we have to get.

Similar wording

But right now, we cannot get the license because of the zoning.

Similar wording

So that's what we're here for today, to seek a variance to the zoning that will allow us to get the visitor accommodation license.

Similar wording

We have a landscaper that we've had probably for 15 years.

Similar wording

Trash is put out weekly.

Similar wording

We have two dedicated parts.

Similar wording

Why don't you start showing your documents besides just the one, okay?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So this is just showing that we post at the meeting.

Similar wording

This is the bedroom.

Similar wording

This is the back driveway.

Similar wording

This is the, it is a corner property.

Similar wording

This is the front corner.

Similar wording

Trash is inside the yard and right outside, you know, right along the side of the house.

Similar wording

This is the kitchen, living room, kitchen, picture, living room again.

Similar wording

so that's pretty much all of our our pictures let me let me ask you this let me ask this is it

Similar wording

two apartments it is two apartments yes so shows again should you show the second

Similar wording

floor apartment shows the kitchen on the second floor

Similar wording

that's the kitchen on the second floor yes all right then what's the first floor

Similar wording

so i don't have any pictures of the first floor right now um i thought it was just because so we

Similar wording

we're not doing anything in the first floor. We, we had a tenant get out and then we did.

Similar wording

But my question is, are you going to put a tenant in the first floor? You're saying you want to

Similar wording

make that an Airbnb too? We want to make that an Airbnb as well, but we haven't,

Similar wording