civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 15, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 15, 20205h 54m

and you'll see the unit size. Other than 510-12 North Street, each of the properties in this

Similar wording

grid that I created shows that all of them are RSA 5. And you'll see the lot size. And if you

Similar wording

look compared to the unit size, our lot, which is 980 square feet dimensionally, is much larger

Similar wording

than what has been previously granted in the past by the Doney Board of Adjustment.

Similar wording

okay have you met with the Civic Association yes and there and that's

Similar wording

exhibit number eight and they're actually in support of this project if

Similar wording

you look at it exhibit a we met with the Norris Square Community Alliance and of

Similar wording

the board ten ten board members support ten board members supported it and three

Similar wording

opposed and then 28 all 28 attendees supported our project so any any

Similar wording

communication with the council person uh no we i i did reach out i haven't heard back

Similar wording

madam chair vice chair we do have sloan folks available for testifying from the council's

Similar wording

office okay great is sloan unmuted long you are not available to speak good afternoon

Similar wording

Good afternoon. Do you agree? I need to swear you in first. Do you agree to swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth and nothing but the truth? I agree. Thank you. Thank you. You may proceed.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, GBA members and vice chair. My name is Sloan Folks, S-L-O-A-N-E-F-S-A-F-I-R-O-L-K-S

Similar wording

from the Office of Councilwoman Maria Keyona Sanchez, Room 508 City Hall. The applicant has

Similar wording

met with the RCO and has guarded a letter of support. Therefore, the Councilwoman is submitting

Similar wording

or submitting non-opposition to this project. Thank you very much. Does the board have any

Similar wording

questions? Ron, Planning Commission? Yes, this is Ron Bednar, City Planning Commission. The property

Similar wording

Yes, this is Ron Bednar, City Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The property is indicated for residential use on the city plan.

Similar wording

is indicated for residential use on the city plan. Given the new development pattern in that

Similar wording

Given the new development pattern in that neighborhood, we have no objection to the granting the variance.

Similar wording

neighborhood we have no objection to the granting the variance thank you calendar number three nine

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

calendar number 39647409 West Houston. My vote is yes. My vote is yes. My vote is yes.

Similar wording

six four seven four oh nine west use and my vote is yes my vote is yes my vote is yes

Similar wording

thank you very much good luck oh and you're still here calendar number

Similar wording

Thank you very much. Good luck. Oh, and you're still here. Calendar number 39647409 West Houston.

Similar wording

Natalie Klesjorni is going to be handling that one madam chair I'm sorry madam chair it appears

Similar wording

He's going to be handling that one, Madam Chair. I'm sorry, Madam Chair. It appears that someone

Similar wording

that someone just popped up um anthony patrick were you trying to speak for this case

Similar wording

just popped up. Anthony Patrick, were you trying to speak for this case?

Similar wording

yeah i want to uh i have some questions um regarding this um keep it down uh i have some

Similar wording

yeah i want to uh i have some questions um regarding this um keep it down uh i have some

Similar wording

questions regarding this i'm sorry i have kids in the background um okay uh i apologize good

Similar wording

questions regarding this i'm sorry i have kids in the background um okay uh i apologize good

Similar wording

afternoon to everyone here i'd like to say first uh but question good afternoon i would like to

Similar wording

afternoon to everyone here i'd like to say first uh but question good afternoon i would like to

Similar wording

swear you in do you swear or affirm to tell the truth and nothing but the truth yes thank you

Similar wording

swear you in do you swear or affirm to tell the truth and nothing but the truth yes thank you

Similar wording

all right also can you put your name and address for the record my name is anthony patrick my

Similar wording

also can you put your name and address for the record my name is anthony patrick my address is

Similar wording

address is 2045 north lawrence street um just for a little info i live up the block from 409 west

Similar wording

houston street because uh houston is the small street um lawrence street and lithgow are the

Similar wording

streets that straddle it so um where this property is going i'm a community member i am

Similar wording

mackenzie mackenzie mackenzie can you keep it down please i'm um i am a community member i'm part of

Similar wording

the community garden that's down there on lawrence and north streets um my question is um i don't

Similar wording

Um, my question is, um, I don't know if this could be answered, but, um, like what is going

Similar wording

know if this could be answered.

Similar wording

on with the development property, uh, when it's developed, how much will it be sold for?

Similar wording

And like, I have questions regarding, uh, what this will do to people's, uh, taxes.

Similar wording

Um, and, and what, what, what will it, will this drive?

Similar wording

Sorry to cut you off, but unfortunately that's not.

Similar wording

matter, uh, issue. Uh, you would like, you know, meet with the attorney, uh, you know,

Similar wording

and discuss all that, you know, stuff, but unfortunately that's not a zoning, uh, issue.

Similar wording

Uh, Anthony, you can reach me at a L a N dot knockamson N O C H U M S O N at N O C H U M S

Similar wording

And Mr. Knockupson, could you put that information in the chat for him as well or anyone else who wishes?

Similar wording

I will.

Similar wording

So the next question is, this meeting is for just the zoning notice?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

And everybody so far is in the grants?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

yes the community of the the civic association and the councilwoman

Similar wording

okay all right then i have no no more questions

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

thank you for um for speaking up though

Similar wording

we ready for the next one yes calendar number three nine two zero seven

Similar wording

7600 State Road. Alan, you are not the attorney? Not for this one, Madam Chair. Natalie Klischdorni

Similar wording

from my office will be handling this one. I'll stay. Okay, where is Natalie?

Similar wording

Hello? Hi, Natalie. Hi. Can you please, can you put your name and address on the record, please?

Similar wording

I did that. Oh, okay. Natalie Kleshtorni, Knockups on PC, 123 South Broad Street,

Similar wording

Suite 1600, Philadelphia PA 19109. Okay. And do you swear or affirm to tell the truth and nothing

Similar wording

but the truth? I do. Do you also agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its

Similar wording

accuracy? I do. Okay. You may present your case. Thank you. I'm here on behalf of the

Similar wording

tenant ecm group pertaining to the property 7600 state road my client has been a tenant for two

Similar wording

years in the packet that i submitted we have the lease attached as have one exhibit one we had

Similar wording

applied for a use permit to legalize the existing use of wood pallet recycling and refurbishing

Similar wording

this property is zoned i2 in response to our application for a use permit we received a

Similar wording

notice of referral and the reason for the referral was that the proposed use equipment and material

Similar wording

storage building requires a special exception approval in the industrial and manufacturing area

Similar wording

storage building requires a special exception approval in the industrial and manufacturing area

Similar wording

in all honesty i believe that a notice of referral was issued an error because if you look

Similar wording

in all honesty i believe that a notice of referral was issued an error because if you look

Similar wording

at the the list of classifications um equipment and material storage in yards and buildings is

Similar wording

at the the list of classifications um equipment and material storage in yards and buildings is

Similar wording

in fact allowed under i2 so i'm not sure why we were given notice of referral in any event

Similar wording

in fact allowed under i2 so i'm not sure why we were given notice of referral in any event um

Similar wording

is the use of the property as for wood pallet recycling and refurbishing is certainly in

Similar wording

is the use of the property as for wood pallet recycling and refurbishing is certainly in

Similar wording

compliance with um with the classification which allows um the storage of building supplies and

Similar wording

equipment, equipment and material storage, warehousing,

Similar wording

movage and storage facilities, and limited and general industrial.

Similar wording

We did meet with the community and we received a letter of non-opposition.

Similar wording

We also have a letter of non-opposition from Councilman Bobby Heenan.

Similar wording

Is there anyone else who will be testifying in this case?

Similar wording

um i have my client uh um on standby if you wish to ask any questions his name is

Similar wording

does the board have any questions

Similar wording

planning commission

Similar wording

ron oh oh unmute yourself ron

Similar wording

oh unmute yourself Ron thank you okay we support the granting of the special

Similar wording

exception calendar number three nine two zero seven seventy six hundred State

Similar wording

Road my vote is yes my vote is yes my vote is yes thanks thank you so much

Similar wording

Sure. Good luck. Calendar number 39715, 2942 Belgrade Street. The attorney is Neil Sklaroff.

Similar wording

Mr. Sklaroff, you have been promoted to panelists, and you can now put your camera on and speak

Similar wording

as you wish mr skaroff can you hear me can you hear me oh i sure can loud and clear do you swear

Similar wording

or affirm to tell the truth and nothing but the truth i do and you also agree to waive the reading

Similar wording

of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy i will stipulate that uh it's what the examiner has

Similar wording

put on the refusal and referral. Okay. Do you have anyone who's going to be testifying?

Similar wording

With me today is Gamil Hall of the school district and Carlos Tovar, who is the project

Similar wording

architect. Whether you will be asking them questions or not, I don't know.

Similar wording

okay so you may present your case all right I don't I'd like to share my

Similar wording

screen I don't seem to be able to do that in any event I represent the school

Similar wording

district of Philadelphia which proposes an addition to the Richland Richmond

Similar wording

in elementary school at

Similar wording

or sound went off

Similar wording

unmute yourself sir

Similar wording

Mr. Skleroff you can now share your screen if you wish

Similar wording

and unmute yourself

Similar wording

I'm unmuted now I think

Similar wording

but I don't the share screen is not coming up

Similar wording

it's in shadow

Similar wording

i don't i don't need to be seen even though i had a powerpoint

Similar wording

this project on behalf of the school district is to construct a 16 000 square foot addition

Similar wording

to the existing elementary school the school sits on an assemblage of properties

Similar wording

which was acquired by the school district in the late 1920s and the

Similar wording

school has been operated therefore for many many decades. We've come to the school to the

Similar wording

zoning board with the support of the Southport Richmond Civic Association and the project has

Similar wording

also been approved by the Art Commission. The addition to the building will allow a multi-purpose

Similar wording

room in the existing building which has been used for both the gym and the cafeteria to be

Similar wording

single purpose for a gym and the new cafeteria will be in the new addition. I have submitted in

Similar wording

advance a rather lengthy set of exhibits, and in those exhibits we not only have

Similar wording

the tax certification, the deeds, photographs of the existing Richmond

Similar wording

school, as well as renderings of the proposed edition. We've been asked to get

Similar wording

a special exception that's the basis of the referral. However, this building has

Similar wording

been used as a as a and the property as a school building since before the

Similar wording

enactment of the zoning code plus it's been used continuously as the school

Similar wording

and I'm not sure it warrants however there is no additional burden on the

Similar wording

community because of the addition there will not be additional students because

Similar wording

of the addition by itself and there won't be additional teachers. This is merely giving

Similar wording

the students and children the proper space in order to promote the educational program. As for

Similar wording

As for the variants, the examiner has identified a need for parking, 17 additional spaces based on the 16,530 square feet in the addition.

Similar wording

the variants

Similar wording

they have

Similar wording

There has never been parking for this school.

Similar wording

There will be no additional burden on the surrounding parking on account of this addition.

Similar wording

And therefore, the property could not be improved to provide those parking spaces.

Similar wording

And therefore, we ask for a variance.

Similar wording

Be pleased to answer any questions.

Similar wording

Does the board have any questions?

Similar wording

Can everybody unmute themselves, confessor?

Similar wording

No, I'm good.

Similar wording

No?

Similar wording

No, I'm good.

Similar wording

No questions.

Similar wording

Planning commission?

Similar wording

We support the granting of the special exception.

Similar wording

Hold on, Carol.

Similar wording

Tanya, is there anybody else that want to speak?

Similar wording

Nobody's hand is up.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Calendar number 39715, 2942 Belgrade Street.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

Good luck.

Similar wording

And good luck.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Have a great summer.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You as well.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

that concludes the two o'clock hearing and I guess I'll see y'all at 3 30.

Similar wording

thank you sounds like a plan I hope Frank safe on that roof this is right

Similar wording

okay so I unmute myself

Similar wording

all right yeah second court reporter yeah i'm here okay we're all ready chair all right

Similar wording

here we go good afternoon everyone my name is frank de chico i'm the chair of the zoning board

Similar wording

of adjustment we have a quorum i'm officially calling this session to order also in attendance

Similar wording

is our vice chair ms carol tenere our board member mr thomas holloman and our board secretary

Similar wording

confessor plaza along with our city solicitor sharon saletta as you probably are aware today

Similar wording

is our second day of holding virtual hearings while we may have we may have to make adjustments

Similar wording

along the way. Our plan is to call each case and basically proceed as we would have in a live

Similar wording

hearing. We ask that attorneys for the applicants or other interested parties identify themselves

Similar wording

for the record when the case you'll be participating is called. We will then hear the

Similar wording

appellant's presentation, followed by any presentation by attorneys representing other

Similar wording

parties. Interested parties and members of the public not represented by counsel will then be

Similar wording

given an opportunity to testify. We will finally hear the recommendation of the

Similar wording

Planning Commission. At the hearing's conclusion, the Board will either vote

Similar wording

the matter immediately or hold it for discussion in executive session. Any case

Similar wording

any case held for discussion will be voted on the record at the scheduled

Similar wording

July 21st morning session. A couple of changes related to the virtual format.

Similar wording

First, we will be administering oaths to individual participants prior to their testimony, rather than to the room as a whole, obviously, since we don't have a room.

Similar wording

Second, for the benefit of anyone participating by phone, we ask that attorneys and witnesses identify themselves prior to speaking or testifying.

Similar wording

Third, we'd like to advise everyone that this proceeding is being recorded and that by

Similar wording

participating you acknowledge your agreement to be recorded. I'd also like to remember recognize that

Similar wording

our staff is being represented by Tanya, Ms. Tanya Sunkit. With that, Carol, call the first case.

Similar wording

please okay um we do have three continuances do you want to do those first or the case if you

Similar wording